1
|
Willadsen E, Lohmander A, Persson C, Lundeborg I, Alaluusua S, Aukner R, Bau A, Boers M, Bowden M, Davies J, Emborg B, Havstam C, Hayden C, Henningsson G, Holmefjord A, Hölttä E, Kisling-Møller M, Kjøll L, Lundberg M, McAleer E, Nyberg J, Paaso M, Pedersen NH, Rasmussen T, Reisæter S, Andersen HS, Schöps A, Tørdal IB, Semb G. Scandcleft randomised trials of primary surgery for unilateral cleft lip and palate: 5. Speech outcomes in 5-year-olds - consonant proficiency and errors. J Plast Surg Hand Surg 2017; 51:38-51. [PMID: 28218556 DOI: 10.1080/2000656x.2016.1254647] [Citation(s) in RCA: 64] [Impact Index Per Article: 9.1] [Reference Citation Analysis] [What about the content of this article? (0)] [Affiliation(s)] [Abstract] [Key Words] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Submit a Manuscript] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Indexed: 10/20/2022]
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND AIM Normal articulation before school start is a main objective in cleft palate treatment. The aim was to investigate if differences exist in consonant proficiency at age 5 years between children with unilateral cleft lip and palate (UCLP) randomised to different surgical protocols for primary palatal repair. A secondary aim was to estimate burden of care in terms of received additional secondary surgeries and speech therapy. DESIGN Three parallel group, randomised clinical trials were undertaken as an international multicentre study by 10 cleft teams in five countries: Denmark, Finland, Norway, Sweden, and the UK. METHODS Three different surgical protocols for primary palatal repair were tested against a common procedure in the total cohort of 448 children born with non-syndromic UCLP. Speech audio- and video-recordings of 391 children (136 girls and 255 boys) were available and transcribed phonetically. The main outcome measure was Percent Consonants Correct (PCC) from blinded assessments. RESULTS In Trial 1, arm A showed statistically significant higher PCC scores (82%) than arm B (78%) (p = .045). No significant differences were found between prevalences in Trial 2, A: 79%, C: 82%; or Trial 3, A: 80%, D: 85%. Across all trials, girls achieved better PCC scores, excluding s-errors, than boys (91.0% and 87.5%, respectively) (p = .01). CONCLUSIONS PCC scores were higher in arm A than B in Trial 1, whereas no differences were found between arms in Trials 2 or 3. The burden of care in terms of secondary pharyngeal surgeries, number of fistulae, and speech therapy visits differed. TRIAL REGISTRATION ISRCTN29932826.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Elisabeth Willadsen
- a Department of Nordic Studies and Linguistics , University of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Anette Lohmander
- b Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Karolinska Institutet, Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Christina Persson
- c Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Sahlgrenska University Hospital , Gothenburg , Sweden.,d Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology, Speech and Language Pathology Unit , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Inger Lundeborg
- e Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Linköping University , Linköping , Sweden
| | - Suvi Alaluusua
- f Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center , Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Ragnhild Aukner
- g Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Anja Bau
- h Copenhagen Cleft Palate Centre , University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Maria Boers
- h Copenhagen Cleft Palate Centre , University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Melanie Bowden
- i Greater Manchester Cleft Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Julie Davies
- i Greater Manchester Cleft Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | | | - Christina Havstam
- k Cleft Palate Team , Sahlgrenska University Hospital , Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Christine Hayden
- l The Royal Hospital for Sick Children , Belfast , Northern Ireland
| | - Gunilla Henningsson
- m Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | | | - Elina Hölttä
- e Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Linköping University , Linköping , Sweden
| | | | - Lillian Kjøll
- g Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Maria Lundberg
- m Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Eilish McAleer
- l The Royal Hospital for Sick Children , Belfast , Northern Ireland
| | - Jill Nyberg
- m Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Marjukka Paaso
- f Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center , Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | | | | | | | | | - Antje Schöps
- h Copenhagen Cleft Palate Centre , University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Inger-Beate Tørdal
- g Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Gunvor Semb
- g Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway.,o Dental School , University of Manchester , Manchester , UK.,p Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| |
Collapse
|
2
|
Semb G, Enemark H, Friede H, Paulin G, Lilja J, Rautio J, Andersen M, Åbyholm F, Lohmander A, Shaw W, Mølsted K, Heliövaara A, Bolund S, Hukki J, Vindenes H, Davenport P, Arctander K, Larson O, Berggren A, Whitby D, Leonard A, Neovius E, Elander A, Willadsen E, Bannister RP, Bradbury E, Henningsson G, Persson C, Eyres P, Emborg B, Kisling-Møller M, Küseler A, Granhof Black B, Schöps A, Bau A, Boers M, Andersen HS, Jeppesen K, Marxen D, Paaso M, Hölttä E, Alaluusua S, Turunen L, Humerinta K, Elfving-Little U, Tørdal IB, Kjøll L, Aukner R, Hide Ø, Feragen KB, Rønning E, Skaare P, Brinck E, Semmingsen AM, Lindberg N, Bowden M, Davies J, Mooney J, Bellardie H, Schofield N, Nyberg J, Lundberg M, Karsten ALA, Larson M, Holmefjord A, Reisæter S, Pedersen NH, Rasmussen T, Tindlund R, Sæle P, Blomhoff R, Jacobsen G, Havstam C, Rizell S, Enocson L, Hagberg C, Najar Chalien M, Paganini A, Lundeborg I, Marcusson A, Mjönes AB, Gustavsson A, Hayden C, McAleer E, Slevan E, Gregg T, Worthington H. A Scandcleft randomised trials of primary surgery for unilateral cleft lip and palate: 1. Planning and management. J Plast Surg Hand Surg 2017; 51:2-13. [PMID: 28218559 DOI: 10.1080/2000656x.2016.1263202] [Citation(s) in RCA: 55] [Impact Index Per Article: 7.9] [Reference Citation Analysis] [What about the content of this article? (0)] [Affiliation(s)] [Abstract] [Key Words] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Submit a Manuscript] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Indexed: 10/20/2022]
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND AIMS Longstanding uncertainty surrounds the selection of surgical protocols for the closure of unilateral cleft lip and palate, and randomised trials have only rarely been performed. This paper is an introduction to three randomised trials of primary surgery for children born with complete unilateral cleft lip and palate (UCLP). It presents the protocol developed for the trials in CONSORT format, and describes the management structure that was developed to achieve the long-term engagement and commitment required to complete the project. METHOD Ten established national or regional cleft centres participated. Lip and soft palate closure at 3-4 months, and hard palate closure at 12 months served as a common method in each trial. Trial 1 compared this with hard palate closure at 36 months. Trial 2 compared it with lip closure at 3-4 months and hard and soft palate closure at 12 months. Trial 3 compared it with lip and hard palate closure at 3-4 months and soft palate closure at 12 months. The primary outcomes were speech and dentofacial development, with a series of perioperative and longer-term secondary outcomes. RESULTS Recruitment of 448 infants took place over a 9-year period, with 99.8% subsequent retention at 5 years. CONCLUSION The series of reports that follow this introductory paper include comparisons at age 5 of surgical outcomes, speech outcomes, measures of dentofacial development and appearance, and parental satisfaction. The outcomes recorded and the numbers analysed for each outcome and time point are described in the series. TRIAL REGISTRATION ISRCTN29932826.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Gunvor Semb
- a Division of Dentistry, University of Manchester , Manchester , UK.,b Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway.,c Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | | | - Hans Friede
- e Department of Orthodontics , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Gunnar Paulin
- f Department of Dentofacial Orthopedics , University Hospital , Linköping , Sweden
| | - Jan Lilja
- g Department of Plastic Surgery , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Jorma Rautio
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Mikael Andersen
- i Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center, University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Frank Åbyholm
- b Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| | - Anette Lohmander
- j Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Karolinska Institute, and Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - William Shaw
- a Division of Dentistry, University of Manchester , Manchester , UK
| | - Kirsten Mølsted
- i Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center, University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Arja Heliövaara
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Stig Bolund
- i Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center, University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Jyri Hukki
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Hallvard Vindenes
- k Centre for Cleft Lip and Palate, Bergen University Hospital Haukeland , Bergen , Norway
| | - Peter Davenport
- l Greater Manchester Cleft Lip and Palate Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Kjartan Arctander
- b Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| | - Ola Larson
- m Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Anders Berggren
- n Department of Plastic Surgery , University Hospital , Linköping , Sweden
| | - David Whitby
- l Greater Manchester Cleft Lip and Palate Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Alan Leonard
- o The Royal Hospital for Sick Children , Belfast , N. Ireland
| | - Erik Neovius
- m Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Anna Elander
- g Department of Plastic Surgery , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Elisabeth Willadsen
- p Department of Nordic Studies and Linguistics , University of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - R Patricia Bannister
- l Greater Manchester Cleft Lip and Palate Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | | | - Gunilla Henningsson
- m Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Christina Persson
- r Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology, Speech and Language Pathology Unit , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden.,s Division for Speech and Language Pathology , Sahlgrenska University Hospital , Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Philip Eyres
- a Division of Dentistry, University of Manchester , Manchester , UK
| | | | | | - Annelise Küseler
- a Division of Dentistry, University of Manchester , Manchester , UK
| | | | - Antje Schöps
- i Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center, University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Anja Bau
- i Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center, University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Maria Boers
- i Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center, University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | | | - Karin Jeppesen
- i Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center, University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Dorte Marxen
- i Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center, University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Marjukka Paaso
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Elina Hölttä
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Suvi Alaluusua
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Leena Turunen
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Kirsti Humerinta
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Ulla Elfving-Little
- h Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center, Helsinki University Central Hospital , Helsinki , Finland
| | - Inger Beate Tørdal
- c Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Lillian Kjøll
- c Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Ragnhild Aukner
- c Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Øydis Hide
- c Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | | | - Elisabeth Rønning
- b Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| | - Pål Skaare
- b Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| | - Eli Brinck
- b Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| | - Ann-Magritt Semmingsen
- b Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| | - Nina Lindberg
- b Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| | - Melanie Bowden
- l Greater Manchester Cleft Lip and Palate Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Julie Davies
- l Greater Manchester Cleft Lip and Palate Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Jeanette Mooney
- l Greater Manchester Cleft Lip and Palate Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Haydn Bellardie
- l Greater Manchester Cleft Lip and Palate Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Nina Schofield
- l Greater Manchester Cleft Lip and Palate Unit , Royal Manchester Childrens' Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Jill Nyberg
- m Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Maria Lundberg
- m Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | | | - Margareta Larson
- u Eastman Institute, Stockholms Läns Landsting , Stockholm , Sweden
| | | | | | | | | | - Rolf Tindlund
- w Dental School, University of Bergen , Bergen , Norway
| | - Paul Sæle
- x Oral Health Center of Expertise/Western Norway , Bergen , Norway
| | - Reidunn Blomhoff
- k Centre for Cleft Lip and Palate, Bergen University Hospital Haukeland , Bergen , Norway
| | - Gry Jacobsen
- k Centre for Cleft Lip and Palate, Bergen University Hospital Haukeland , Bergen , Norway
| | - Christina Havstam
- s Division for Speech and Language Pathology , Sahlgrenska University Hospital , Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Sara Rizell
- e Department of Orthodontics , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Lars Enocson
- e Department of Orthodontics , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Catharina Hagberg
- e Department of Orthodontics , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Midia Najar Chalien
- e Department of Orthodontics , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Anna Paganini
- g Department of Plastic Surgery , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Inger Lundeborg
- y Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Linköping University , Linköping , Sweden
| | - Agneta Marcusson
- f Department of Dentofacial Orthopedics , University Hospital , Linköping , Sweden
| | - Anna-Britta Mjönes
- n Department of Plastic Surgery , University Hospital , Linköping , Sweden
| | - Annica Gustavsson
- f Department of Dentofacial Orthopedics , University Hospital , Linköping , Sweden
| | | | - Eilish McAleer
- o The Royal Hospital for Sick Children , Belfast , N. Ireland
| | - Emma Slevan
- o The Royal Hospital for Sick Children , Belfast , N. Ireland
| | - Terry Gregg
- o The Royal Hospital for Sick Children , Belfast , N. Ireland
| | | |
Collapse
|
3
|
Lohmander A, Persson C, Willadsen E, Lundeborg I, Alaluusua S, Aukner R, Bau A, Boers M, Bowden M, Davies J, Emborg B, Havstam C, Hayden C, Henningsson G, Holmefjord A, Hölttä E, Kisling-Møller M, Kjøll L, Lundberg M, McAleer E, Nyberg J, Paaso M, Pedersen NH, Rasmussen T, Reisæter S, Søgaard Andersen H, Schöps A, Tørdal IB, Semb G. Scandcleft randomised trials of primary surgery for unilateral cleft lip and palate: 4. Speech outcomes in 5-year-olds - velopharyngeal competency and hypernasality. J Plast Surg Hand Surg 2017; 51:27-37. [PMID: 28218551 DOI: 10.1080/2000656x.2016.1254645] [Citation(s) in RCA: 50] [Impact Index Per Article: 7.1] [Reference Citation Analysis] [What about the content of this article? (0)] [Affiliation(s)] [Abstract] [Key Words] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Submit a Manuscript] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Indexed: 10/20/2022]
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND AIM Adequate velopharyngeal function and speech are main goals in the treatment of cleft palate. The objective was to investigate if there were differences in velopharyngeal competency (VPC) and hypernasality at age 5 years in children with unilateral cleft lip and palate (UCLP) operated on with different surgical methods for primary palatal repair. A secondary aim was to estimate burden of care in terms of received additional secondary surgeries and speech therapy. DESIGN Three parallel group, randomised clinical trials were undertaken as an international multicentre study by 10 cleft teams in five countries: Denmark, Finland, Sweden, Norway, and the UK. METHODS Three different surgical protocols for primary palatal repair were tested against a common procedure in the total cohort of 448 children born with a non-syndromic UCLP. Speech audio and video recordings of 391 children (136 girls, 255 boys) were available and perceptually analysed. The main outcome measures were VPC and hypernasality from blinded assessments. RESULTS There were no statistically significant differences between the prevalences in the arms in any of the trials. VPC: Trial 1, A: 58%, B: 61%; Trial 2, A: 57%, C: 54%; Trial 3, A: 35%, D: 51%. No hypernasality: Trial 1, A: 54%, B: 44%; Trial 2, A: 47%, C: 51%; Trial 3, A: 34%, D: 49%. CONCLUSIONS No differences were found regarding VPC and hypernasality at age 5 years after different methods for primary palatal repair. The burden of care in terms of secondary pharyngeal surgeries, number of fistulae, and speech therapy visits differed. TRIAL REGISTRATION ISRCTN29932826.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Anette Lohmander
- a Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Karolinska Institutet, and Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Christina Persson
- b Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology, Speech and Language Pathology Unit, Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg, Sahlgrenska University Hospital , Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Elisabeth Willadsen
- c Department of Nordic Studies and Linguistics , University of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Inger Lundeborg
- d Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Linköping University , Linköping , Sweden
| | - Suvi Alaluusua
- e Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center , Helsinki University Central Hospital , Finland
| | - Ragnhild Aukner
- f Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Anja Bau
- g Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center , University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Maria Boers
- g Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center , University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Melanie Bowden
- h Department of Plastic Surgery, Greater Manchester Cleft Unit , Royal Manchester Children's Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | - Julie Davies
- h Department of Plastic Surgery, Greater Manchester Cleft Unit , Royal Manchester Children's Hospital , Manchester , UK
| | | | - Christina Havstam
- j Division of Speech and Language Pathology , Sahlgrenska University Hospital , Gothenburg , Sweden
| | - Christine Hayden
- k The Royal Hospital for Sick Children , Belfast , Northern Ireland
| | - Gunilla Henningsson
- l Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | | | - Elina Hölttä
- e Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center , Helsinki University Central Hospital , Finland
| | | | - Lillian Kjøll
- f Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Maria Lundberg
- l Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Eilish McAleer
- k The Royal Hospital for Sick Children , Belfast , Northern Ireland
| | - Jill Nyberg
- l Stockholm Craniofacial Team , Karolinska University Hospital , Stockholm , Sweden
| | - Marjukka Paaso
- e Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Center , Helsinki University Central Hospital , Finland
| | | | | | | | | | - Antje Schöps
- g Copenhagen Cleft Palate Center , University Hospital of Copenhagen , Denmark
| | - Inger-Beate Tørdal
- f Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway
| | - Gunvor Semb
- f Department of Speech and Language Disorders , Statped sørøst , Oslo , Norway.,n School of Dentistry , University of Manchester , Manchester , UK.,o Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery , Oslo University Hospital Rikshospitalet , Oslo , Norway
| |
Collapse
|