Monozygotic twins discordant for submicroscopic chromosomal anomalies in 2p25.3 region detected by array CGH

Although discordant phenotypes in monozygotic twins with developmental disorder are not an exception, underlying genetic discordance is rarely reported. Here, we report on the clinical and cytogenetic details of 4-year-old female monozygotic twins with discordant phenotypes. Twin 1 exhibited global developmental delay, overweight and hyperactivity. Twin 2 had an autistic spectrum disorder. Molecular karyotyping in twin 1 identified a 2p25.3 deletion, further confirmed by Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis on leukocytes. Interestingly, array comparative genomic hybridization was normal in twin 2 but FISH analysis using the same probe as twin 1 showed mosaicism with one-third of cells with a 2p25.3 deletion, one-third of cells with a 2p25.3 duplication, and one-third of normal cells. Genotyping with microsatellite markers confirmed the monozygosity of the twins. We propose that the chromosome imbalance may be due to a mitotic non-allelic recombination occurring during blastomeric divisions of a normal zygote. Such event will result in three distinct cell populations, whose proportion in each embryo formed after separation from the zygote may differ, leading to discordant chromosomal anomalies between twins. We also discuss that the MYTL1L and the SNTG2 genes within the reported region could probably relate to the phenotypic discordance of the monozygotic twins.

Phenotypic spectrum of CHARGE syndrome in fetuses with CHD7 truncating mutations correlates with expression during human development

BACKGROUND

The acronym CHARGE refers to a non-random cluster of malformations including coloboma, heart malformation, choanal atresia, retardation of growth and/or development, genital anomalies, and ear anomalies. This set of multiple congenital anomalies is frequent, despite rare patients with normal intelligence, and prognosis remains poor. Recently, CHD7 gene mutations have been identified in CHARGE patients; however, the function of CHD7 during development remains unknown.

METHODS

We studied a series of 10 antenatal cases in whom the diagnosis of CHARGE syndrome was suspected, considering that a careful pathological description would shed light on the CHD7 function during development. CHD7 sequence analysis and in situ hybridisation were employed.

RESULTS

The diagnosis of CHARGE syndrome was confirmed in all 10 fetuses by the identification of a CHD7 heterozygous truncating mutation. Interestingly, arhinencephaly and semi-circular canal agenesis were two constant features which are not included in formal diagnostic criteria so far. In situ hybridisation analysis of the CHD7 gene during early human development emphasised the role of CHD7 in the development of the central nervous system, internal ear, and neural crest of pharyngeal arches, and more generally showed a good correlation between specific CHD7 expression pattern and the developmental anomalies observed in CHARGE syndrome.

CONCLUSIONS

These results allowed us to further refine the phenotypic spectrum of developmental anomalies resulting from CHD7 dysfunction.

[A preliminary study to assess the value of the DNA chips SpectralChip to detect subtle constitutional chromosome imbalances]

Comparative genomic hybridization on a microarray (microarray-CGH) allows to detect genomic chromosome imbalances. In order to assess its value to detect small chromosome imbalances observed in a clinical setting, using a DNA chip available commercially (Spectral Genomics, Houston, Texas, USA), we studied the DNA of 9 patients carrying a well characterized chromosome imbalance and the DNA of 11 patients where cytogenetic techniques such as high resolution banding karyotype, FISH using subtelomeric probes and comparative genomic hybridization on metaphase chromosomes conclude to a normal and/or balanced karyotype. A result was obtained for 19/20 patients. Failure of hybridization was observed for one patient. For all the other cases the sex of patients was correctly identified. Microarray-CGH was able to correctly diagnose the chromosome imbalance in 6/8 patients carrying such a defect i.e 9/11 imbalances (deletion or duplication) were detected. No chromosome imbalance was observed in 11 patients considered normal and/or balanced using cytogenetic techniques. Several clones were found to be polymorphic and required FISH studies to eliminate duplication or deletion. In conclusion, we think that this commercially available DNA chip might be useful to screen for chromosome imbalances. However, technical improvements are still necessary before using it in a clinical setting. Also, further studies are necessary to assess its sensitivity and specificity.

Molecular characterization of partial trisomy 16q24.1-qter: clinical report and review of the literature

We describe a 3(1/2)-year-old girl with psychomotor and mental retardation; dysmorphic features, including a high forehead with bitemporal narrowing; a broad nasal bridge and a broadened nose; downslanting palpebral fissures; abnormal ears; vertebral abnormalities; cardiac defect; genital hypoplasia; and anal abnormalities. The karyotype of our patient (550 bands) was normal. Molecular cytogenetic techniques, including comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), revealed that this girl was a carrier of a de novo derivative chromosome 7 arising from a cryptic t(7;16)(p22.3;q24.1) translocation generating a trisomy 16q24.1-qter and a 7p22.3-pter deletion. FISH with a series of specific chromosome 7p and 16q probes allowed us to delineate the chromosome 7 breakpoint between YAC660G6 (WD7S517) and YAC848A12 (D7S521, D7S31, and WI-4829) and the chromosome 16 breakpoint between BAC457K7 (D42053) and BAC44201 (SGC30711). The comparison of the clinical features of our patient with those of 2 cases of pure terminal 7p deletion and 28 cases of trisomy 16q reported in the literature allowed us to establish the following phenotype-genotype correlation for trisomy of the long arm of chromosome 16: distinctive facies (high/prominent forehead, bitemporal narrowing, periorbital edema in the neonatal period); severe mental retardation; vertebral, genital, and anal abnormalities to 16q24; distal joint contractures and camptodactyly to 16q23; cleft palate and renal anomalies to 16q22; beaked nose and gall bladder agenesis to 16q21; gut malrotation; lung and liver anomalies to 16q13; and behavior abnormalities to band 16q11-q13.

Automated fluorescent genotyping detects 10% of cryptic subtelomeric rearrangements in idiopathic syndromic mental retardation

Recent studies have shown that cryptic unbalanced subtelomeric rearrangements contribute to a significant proportion of idiopathic syndromic mental retardation cases. Using a fluorescent genotyping based strategy, we found a 10% rate of cryptic subtelomeric rearrangements in a large series of 150 probands with severe idiopathic syndromic mental retardation and normal RHG-GTG banded karyotype. Fourteen children were found to carry deletions or duplications of one or more chromosome telomeres and two children had uniparental disomy. This study clearly shows that fluorescent genotyping is a sensitive and cost effective method that not only detects cryptic subtelomeric rearrangements but also provides a unique opportunity to detect uniparental disomies. We suggest giving consideration to systematic examination of subtelomeric regions in the diagnostic work up of patients with unexplained syndromic mental retardation.

A CGH study of 27 patients with CHARGE association

CHARGE association is a non-random occurrence of congenital malformations including coloboma, heart disease, choanal atresia, retarded growth and/or retarded development, genital hypoplasia, ear anomalies and/or deafness. The cause of this association remains unknown. Various genetic mechanisms have been proposed, including a contiguous gene syndrome but, so far, no recurrent locus has been identified. To address this question, we decided to perform a comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) study on a cohort of 27 patients with CHARGE association and a normal standard karyotype. We found two chromosomal anomalies: a der(9)t(9;13) derived from a paternal translocation and a der(6)t(4;6) of unknown origin. This suggests that chromosome imbalances may well mimic CHARGE association. Therefore patients with CHARGE association must be carefully tested with classical and molecular cytogenetic techniques to detect a potential chromosome imbalance. It is expected that more stringent diagnostic criteria of CHARGE association could define a more homogeneous group of patients where a single genetic cause might be identified.

Comparative genomic hybridisation in mentally retarded patients with dysmorphic features and a normal karyotype

Segmental aneusomy for small chromosomal regions has been shown to be a common cause of mental retardation and multiple congenital anomalies. A screening method for such chromosome aberrations that are not detected using standard cytogenetic techniques is needed. Recent studies have focused on detection of subtle terminal chromosome aberrations using subtelomeric probes. This approach however excludes significant regions of the genome where submicroscopic rearrangements are also liable to occur. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the efficiency of comparative genomic hybridisation (CGH) for screening of submicroscopic chromosomal rearrangements. CGH was performed in a cohort of 17 patients (14 families) with mental retardation, dysmorphic features and a normal karyotype. Five subtle unbalanced rearrangements were identified in 7 patients. Subsequent FISH studies confirmed these results. Although no interstitial submicroscopic rearrangement was detected in this small series, the study emphasises the value of CGH as a screening approach to detect subtle chromosome rearrangements in mentally retarded patients with dysmorphic features and a normal karyotype.

Partial maternal heterodisomy of chromosome 17q25 in a case of severe mental retardation

We report a segmental maternal uniparental heterodisomy of chromosome 17 (mat UPD17) in a 3-year-old boy presenting with hyperactivity, major instability, mental retardation and facial dysmorphism. Since conventional and high resolution karyotypes were normal, this patient was tested for cryptic telomeric rearrangements by using the recently developed fluorescent genotyping-based technology. The mat UPD17 segment extended for a small 11-cM region of the distal chromosome 17q. Trisomy 17 in circulating lymphocytes and skin fibroblasts was excluded. Our finding emphasizes the potential use of fluorescent genotyping to detect uniparental disomies and suggests that chromosome 17q25 should contain one or several imprinted genes of particular importance for brain development.

A novel automated strategy for screening cryptic telomeric rearrangements in children with idiopathic mental retardation

Cryptic unbalanced subtelomeric rearrangements are known to cause a significant proportion of idiopathic mental retardation in childhood. Because of the limited sensitivity of routine analyses, the cytogenetic detection of such rearrangements requires molecular techniques, namely FISH and comparative genomic hybridisation (CGH). An alternative approach consists in using genetic markers to detect segmental aneusomy. Here, we describe a new strategy based upon automated fluorescent genotyping to search for non mendelian segregation of telomeric microsatellites. A total of 29 individuals belonging to 24 unrelated families were screened and three abnormal patterns of segregation were detected (two rearrangements and one parental disomy). This study gives strong support to the view that cryptic telomeric rearrangements significantly contribute to idiopathic mental retardation and demonstrates that fluorescent genotyping is a very sensitive and cost-effective method to detect deletions, duplications and uniparental disomies.

Subtle familial unbalanced translocation t(8;11)(p23.2;p15.5) in two fetuses with Beckwith-Wiedemann features

We describe a subtle translocation t(8;11)(p23.2;p15.5) ascertained after two induced abortions in the same sibship because of the discovery of fetal hydrops on ultrasound examination. Initial cytogenetic studies performed on cultured amniotic fluid cells were considered as normal in both fetuses. High resolution banding analysis and FISH studies performed on the parents' chromosomes revealed a paternal translocation t(8;11)(p23.2;p15.5). Retrospective FISH analysis of both fetuses showed that they carried the same chromosomal imbalance including a distal monosomy 8pter and a distal trisomy 11pter. The phenotypes of the fetuses were re-examined and found to be compatible with Beckwith-Wiedemann syndromes (BWS). FISH analysis using an IGF2 probe demonstrated the presence of three copies of the IGF2 gene. This study highlights the value of searching for subtle chromosome rearrangements in families with recurrent unexplained multiple malformation syndromes discovered prenatally. Also, it contributes to a better delineation of the prenatal phenotype of BWS. Finally, it sheds new light on the aetiology of non-immune hydrops fetalis.