Real World Experience of Denosumab Treatment in the Belfast Osteoporosis Service

Osteoporosis is a significant global health and economic burden associated with bone fracture, morbidity and mortality. Denosumab, a novel human monoclonal antibody second-line treatment, inhibits osteoclast-mediated bone resorption and increases bone mineral density (BMD). Treatment achieves reductions in vertebral, non-vertebral and hip fracture risk. We undertook a service evaluation to review clinical outcomes of patients treated with denosumab in an osteoporosis department that provides regional services. We identified 529 patients (95% female; mean age 72.8 years; 35-98 years), who had at least one dose of denosumab administered for the treatment of osteoporosis. The mean number of denosumab doses administered was 4.9 (range: 1 to 12). 330/529 patients had completed a baseline and post-treatment bone densitometry scan (DXA). The mean observed BMD change at around 18 months at the lumbar spine was +8.4% and at the hip was +3.5%. While the majority have transitioned to shared care administration of treatment within primary care (53%), 20% continue to attend hospital clinics to receive treatment. During follow-up, there were 66 deaths (12%). 15% switched to an alternative treatment or were discharged. This retrospective cohort study demonstrates the clinical effectiveness of denosumab in improving bone mineral density in a real life setting in an ageing, co-morbid population. There has been recent progress with adoption of shared care administration in primary care. As part of a quality improvement programme we have recently developed a dedicated denosumab database and day-case treatment clinic for those receiving treatment in secondary care.

SIRT7 expression and epigenetic status determine variability in telomere length in breast cancer

Abstract #4052

Background: As cancer is a disease of ageing, factors involved in biological ageing may be informative in investigating the underlying mechanisms of cancer pathogenesis. How biological age is affected by epigenetic changes remains to be fully determined. This is pertinent to cancer pathogenesis, as epigenetic changes can increase the risk of neoplasia. We have investigated the biological age of breast tumours, using telomere length and the expression of sirtuin 7, a gene involved in the regulation of ribosome biosynthesis and previously demonstrated as potentially prognostic in breast cancer. We have evaluated these for association with epigenetic status.
 Materials and Methods: Telomere lengths and Sirtuin 7 (SIRT7) expression were determined using Q-PCR. Epigenetic status was determined using a Methylamp Global DNA methylation kit. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS v15.
 Results: Chronological age was negatively associated with telomere length (p=0.013) and positively associated with methylation levels (p=0.007). Furthermore, telomere length showed a negative association with global methylation levels (p=0.002). Individuals with shorter telomeres were older and demonstrated higher levels of global DNA methylation. SIRT7 expression was positively associated with telomere length (p=0.01), but showed no association with methylation levels. Linear regression analysis indicated that SIRT7 expression accounted for 52.2% of the observed variability in telomere length (p=0.001) and methlyation for 33.4% (p<0.001). Multiple linear regression analysis indicated that methylation status and SIRT7 expression combined accounted for 69.4% of the observed variability in telomere length. Chronological age was not a significant contributor in either analysis.
 Discussion: Cells with critically short telomeres present a high risk of becoming neoplastic, as they are biologically aged. This study has demonstrated that both SIRT7 expression and global methylation levels significantly influence telomere attrition in breast cancer. This is consistent with a scenario whereby the rate of biological ageing in breast tumours is influenced by telomere mediated epigenetic changes and mechanistically by cellular proliferation requirements. The latter is manifest through SIRT7 regulated ribosome biogenesis. These findings support the use of SIRT7 as a potential prognostic tool and therapeutic target in breast cancer.

Citation Information: Cancer Res 2009;69(2 Suppl):Abstract nr 4052.

A secondary RNA polymerase sigma factor from Streptococcus pyogenes

The important human pathogen Streptococcus pyogenes (the group A streptococcus or GAS) causes diseases ranging from mild, self-limiting pharyngitis to severe invasive infections. Regulation of the expression of GAS genes in response to specific environmental differences within the host is probably key in determining the course of the infectious process, however, little is known of global regulators of gene expression in GAS. Although secondary RNA polymerase sigma factors act as global regulators of gene expression in many other bacteria, none has yet been isolated from the GAS. The newly available GAS genome sequence indicates that the only candidate secondary sigma factor is encoded by two identical open reading frames (ORFS). These ORFS encode a protein that is 40% identical to the transcription factor ComX, believed to act as an RNA polymerase sigma factor in Streptococcus pneumoniae. To test whether the GAS ComX homologue functions as a sigma factor, we cloned and purified it from Escherichia coli. We found that in vitro, this GAS protein, which we call sigmaX, directed core RNA polymerase from Bacillus subtilis to transcribe from two GAS promoters that contain the cin-box region, required for transcription by S. pneumoniae ComX in vivo. On the other hand, GAS sigmaX did not promote transcription of a GAS promoter (hasA) expected to be dependent on sigmaA, the housekeeping or primary RNA polymerase sigma factor. Addition of monoclonal antibody that inhibited sigmaA-directed transcription had no effect on sigmaX-directed transcription, showing that the latter was not the result of contaminating sigmaA. Transcription of both cin-box-containing promoters initiated downstream of the cin-box and two different single basepair substitutions in the cin-box of the cinA promoter each caused a severe reduction of sigmaX-directed transcription in vitro. Thus, the cin-box is required for sigmaX-directed transcription.

Identification of a DNA binding region in GerE from Bacillus subtilis

Proteins that have a structure similar to those of LuxR and FixJ comprise a large subfamily of transcriptional activator proteins. Most members of the LuxR-FixJ family contain a similar amino-terminal receiver domain linked by a small region to a carboxy-terminal domain that contains an amino acid sequence similar to the helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif found in other DNA-binding proteins. GerE from Bacillus subtilis is the smallest member of the LuxR-FixJ family. Its 74-amino-acid sequence is similar over its entire length to the DNA binding region of this protein family, including the HTH motif. Therefore, GerE provides a simple model for studies of the role of this HTH domain in DNA binding. Toward this aim, we sought to identify the amino acids within this motif that are important for the specificity of binding to DNA. We examined the effects of single base pair substitutions in the high-affinity GerE binding site on the sigK promoter and found that nucleotides at positions +2, +3, and +4 relative to the transcription start site on the sigK promoter are important for a high-affinity interaction with GerE. We next examined the effects of single alanine substitutions at two positions in the HTH region of GerE on binding to wild-type or mutant target sites. We found that the substitution of an alanine for the threonine at position 42 of GerE produced a protein that binds with equal affinity to two sites that differ by 1 bp, whereas wild-type GerE binds with different affinities to these two sites. These results provide evidence that the amino acyl residues in or near the putative HTH region of GerE and potentially other members of the LuxR-FixJ family determine the specificity of DNA binding.

SpoVID guides SafA to the spore coat in Bacillus subtilis

Bacteria assemble complex structures by targeting proteins to specific subcellular locations. The protein coat that encases Bacillus subtilis spores is an example of a structure that requires coordinated targeting and assembly of more than 24 polypeptides. The earliest stages of coat assembly require the action of three morphogenetic proteins: SpoIVA, CotE, and SpoVID. In the first steps, a basement layer of SpoIVA forms around the surface of the forespore, guiding the subsequent positioning of a ring of CotE protein about 75 nm from the forespore surface. SpoVID localizes near the forespore membrane where it functions to maintain the integrity of the CotE ring and to anchor the nascent coat to the underlying spore structures. However, it is not known which spore coat proteins interact directly with SpoVID. In this study we examined the interaction between SpoVID and another spore coat protein, SafA, in vivo using the yeast two-hybrid system and in vitro. We found evidence that SpoVID and SafA directly interact and that SafA interacts with itself. Immunofluorescence microscopy showed that SafA localized around the forespore early during coat assembly and that this localization of SafA was dependent on SpoVID. Moreover, targeting of SafA to the forespore was also dependent on SpoIVA, as was targeting of SpoVID to the forespore. We suggest that the localization of SafA to the spore coat requires direct interaction with SpoVID.

Forespore-specific transcription of the lonB gene during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

The Bacillus subtilis genome encodes two members of the Lon family of prokaryotic ATP-dependent proteases. One, LonA, is produced in response to temperature, osmotic, and oxidative stress and has also been implicated in preventing sigma(G) activity under nonsporulation conditions. The second is encoded by the lonB gene, which resides immediately upstream from lonA. Here we report that transcription of lonB occurs during sporulation under sigma(F) control and thus is restricted to the prespore compartment of sporulating cells. First, expression of a lonB-lacZ transcriptional fusion was abolished in strains unable to produce sigma(F) but remained unaffected upon disruption of the genes encoding the early and late mother cell regulators sigma(E) and sigma(K) or the late forespore regulator sigma(G). Second, the fluorescence of strains harboring a lonB-gfp fusion was confined to the prespore compartment and depended on sigma(F) production. Last, primer extension analysis of the lonB transcript revealed -10 and -35 sequences resembling the consensus sequence recognized by sigma(F)-containing RNA polymerase. We further show that the lonB message accumulated as a single monocistronic transcript during sporulation, synthesis of which required sigma(F) activity. Disruption of the lonB gene did not confer any discernible sporulation phenotype to otherwise wild-type cells, nor did expression of lonB from a multicopy plasmid. In contrast, expression of a fusion of the lonB promoter to the lonA gene severely reduced expression of the sigma(G)-dependent sspE gene and the frequency of sporulation. In confirmation of earlier observations, we found elevated levels of sigma(F)-dependent activity in a spoIIIE47 mutant, in which the lonB region of the chromosome is not translocated into the prespore. Expression of either lonB or the P(lonB)-lonA fusion from a plasmid in the spoIIIE47 mutant reduced sigma(F) -dependent activity to wild-type levels. The results suggest that both LonA and LonB can prevent abnormally high sigma(F) activity but that only LonA can negatively regulate sigma(G).

Alternative translation initiation produces a short form of a spore coat protein in Bacillus subtilis

During endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis, over two dozen polypeptides are localized to the developing spore and coordinately assembled into a thick multilayered structure called the spore coat. Assembly of the coat is initiated by the expression of morphogenetic proteins SpoIVA, CotE, and SpoVID. These morphogenetic proteins appear to guide the assembly of other proteins into the spore coat. For example, SpoVID forms a complex with the SafA protein, which is incorporated into the coat during the early stages of development. At least two forms of SafA are found in the mature spore coat: a full-length form and a shorter form (SafA-C(30)) that begins with a methionine encoded by codon 164 of safA. In this study, we present evidence that the expression of SafA-C(30) arises from translation initiation at codon 164. We found only a single transcript driving expression of SafA. A stop codon engineered just upstream of a predicted ribosome-binding site near codon M164 abolished formation of full-length SafA, but not SafA-C(30). The same effect was observed with an alanine substitution at codon 1 of SafA. Accumulation of SafA-C(30) was blocked by substitution of an alanine codon at codon 164, but not by a substitution at a nearby methionine at codon 161. We found that overproduction of SafA-C(30) interfered with the activation of late mother cell-specific transcription and caused a strong sporulation block.

Morphogenetic proteins SpoVID and SafA form a complex during assembly of the Bacillus subtilis spore coat

During endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis, over two dozen polypeptides are assembled into a multilayered structure known as the spore coat, which protects the cortex peptidoglycan (PG) and permits efficient germination. In the initial stages of coat assembly a protein known as CotE forms a ring around the forespore. A second morphogenetic protein, SpoVID, is required for maintenance of the CotE ring during the later stages, when most of proteins are assembled into the coat. Here, we report on a protein that appears to associate with SpoVID during the early stage of coat assembly. This protein, which we call SafA for SpoVID-associated factor A, is encoded by a locus previously known as yrbA. We confirmed the results of a previous study that showed safA mutant spores have defective coats which are missing several proteins. We have extended these studies with the finding that SafA and SpoVID were coimmunoprecipitated by anti-SafA or anti-SpoVID antiserum from whole-cell extracts 3 and 4 h after the onset of sporulation. Therefore, SafA may associate with SpoVID during the early stage of coat assembly. We used immunogold electron microscopy to localize SafA and found it in the cortex, near the interface with the coat in mature spores. SafA appears to have a modular design. The C-terminal region of SafA is similar to those of several inner spore coat proteins. The N-terminal region contains a sequence that is conserved among proteins that associate with the cell wall. This motif in the N-terminal region may target SafA to the PG-containing regions of the developing spore.

Structure and assembly of the bacterial endospore coat

Many biological processes are mediated through the action of multiprotein complexes, often assembled at specific cellular locations. Bacterial endospores for example, are encased in a proteinaceous coat, which confers resistance to lysozyme and harsh chemicals and influences the spore response to germinants. In Bacillus subtilis, the coat is composed of more than 20 polypeptides, organized into three main layers: an amorphous undercoat; a lamellar, lightly staining inner structure; and closely apposed to it, a striated electron-dense outer coat. Synthesis of the coat proteins is temporally and spatially governed by a cascade of four mother cell-specific transcription factors. However, the order of assembly and final destination of the coat structural components may rely mainly on specific protein-protein interactions, as well as on the action of accessory morphogenetic proteins. Proteolytic events, protein-protein crosslinking, and protein glycosylation also play a role in the assembly process. These modifications are carried out by enzymes that may themselves be targeted to the coat layers. Coat genes have been identified by reverse genetics or, more recently, by screens for mother cell-specific promoters or for peptide sequences able to interact with certain bait proteins. A role for a given locus in coat assembly is established by a combination of regulatory, functional, morphological, and topological criteria. Because of the amenability of B. subtilis to genetic analysis (now facilitated by the knowledge of its genome sequence), coat formation has become an attractive model for the assembly of complex macromolecular structures during development.

A region of sigmaK involved in promoter activation by GerE in Bacillus subtilis

During endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis, the DNA binding protein GerE stimulates transcription from several promoters that are used by RNA polymerase containing sigmaK. GerE binds to a site on one of these promoters, cotX, that overlaps its -35 region. We tested the model that GerE interacts with sigmaK at the cotX promoter by seeking amino acid substitutions in sigmaK that interfered with GerE-dependent activation of the cotX promoter but which did not affect utilization of the sigmaK-dependent, GerE-independent promoter gerE. We identified two amino acid substitutions in sigmaK, E216K and H225Y, that decrease cotX promoter utilization but do not affect gerE promoter activity. Alanine substitutions at these positions had similar effects. We also examined the effects of the E216A and H225Y substitutions in sigmaK on transcription in vitro. We found that these substitutions specifically reduced utilization of the cotX promoter. These and other results suggest that the amino acid residues at positions 216 and 225 are required for GerE-dependent cotX promoter activity, that the histidine at position 225 of sigmaK may interact with GerE at the cotX promoter, and that this interaction may facilitate the initial binding of sigmaK RNA polymerase to the cotX promoter. We also found that the alanine substitutions at positions 216 and 225 of sigmaK had no effect on utilization of the GerE-dependent promoter cotD, which contains GerE binding sites that do not overlap with its -35 region.

A Bacillus subtilis secreted protein with a role in endospore coat assembly and function

Bacterial endospores are encased in a complex protein coat, which confers protection against noxious chemicals and influences the germination response. In Bacillus subtilis, over 20 polypeptides are organized into an amorphous undercoat, a lamellar lightly staining inner structure, and an electron-dense outer coat. Here we report on the identification of a polypeptide of about 30 kDa required for proper coat assembly, which was extracted from spores of a gerE mutant. The N-terminal sequence of this polypeptide matched the deduced product of the tasA gene, after removal of a putative 27-residue signal peptide, and TasA was immunologically detected in material extracted from purified spores. Remarkably, deletion of tasA results in the production of asymmetric spores that accumulate misassembled material in one pole and have a greatly expanded undercoat and an altered outer coat structure. Moreover, we found that tasA and gerE mutations act synergistically to decrease the efficiency of spore germination. We show that tasA is the most distal member of a three-gene operon, which also encodes the type I signal peptidase SipW. Expression of the tasA operon is enhanced 2 h after the onset of sporulation, under the control of sigmaH. When tasA transcription is uncoupled from sipW expression, a presumptive TasA precursor accumulates, suggesting that its maturation depends on SipW. Mature TasA is found in supernatants of sporulating cultures and intracellularly from 2 h of sporulation onward. We suggest that, at an early stage of sporulation, TasA is secreted to the septal compartment. Later, after engulfment of the prespore by the mother cell, TasA acts from the septal-proximal pole of the spore membranes to nucleate the organization of the undercoat region. TasA is the first example of a polypeptide involved in coat assembly whose production is not mother cell specific but rather precedes its formation. Our results implicate secretion as a mechanism to target individual proteins to specific cellular locations during the assembly of the bacterial endospore coat.

Assembly requirements and role of CotH during spore coat formation in Bacillus subtilis

We report Western blot data showing that the 42.8-kDa product of the previously characterized cotH locus (8) is a structural component of the Bacillus subtilis spore coat. We show that the assembly of CotH requires both CotE and GerE. In agreement with these observations, the ultrastructural analysis of purified spores suggests that CotH is needed for proper formation of both inner and outer layers of the coat.

Regulation of hexuronate utilization in Bacillus subtilis

We have identified a locus essential for galacturonate utilization in Bacillus subtilis. Genes homologous to Escherichia coli and Erwinia chrysanthemi glucuronate and galacturonate metabolic genes were found in a cluster consisting of 10 open reading frames (ORFs) in the B. subtilis chromosome. A mutant of B. subtilis containing a replacement of the second and third ORFs was unable to grow with galacturonate as its primary carbon source. Galacturonate induced expression from a sigmaA-dependent promoter, exuP1, located upstream from the first ORF. The eighth ORF in this cluster (the exu locus) encodes a LacI and GalR homolog that negatively regulated expression from exuP1. A 26-bp inverted repeat sequence centered 15 bp downstream from the exuP1 start point of transcription acted in cis to negatively regulate expression from exuP1 under noninducing conditions. Expression from the exuP1 promoter was repressed by high levels of glucose, which is probably mediated by CcpA (catabolite control protein A). A sigmaE-dependent promoter, exuP2, was localized between the second and third ORFs and was active during sporulation.

A region in Bacillus subtilis sigmaH required for Spo0A-dependent promoter activity

Spo0A activates transcription in Bacillus subtilis from promoters that are used by two types of RNA polymerase, RNA polymerase containing the primary sigma factor, sigmaA, and RNA polymerase containing a secondary sigma factor, known as sigmaH. The region of sigmaA near positions 356 to 359 is required for Spo0A-dependent promoter activation, possibly because Spo0A interacts with this region of sigmaA at these promoters. To determine if the amino acids in the corresponding region of sigmaH are also important in Spo0A-dependent promoter activation, we examined the effects of single alanine substitutions at 10 positions in sigmaH (201 to 210). Two alanine substitutions in sigmaH, at glutamine 201 (Q201A) and at arginine 205 (R205A), significantly decreased activity from the Spo0A-dependent, sigmaH-dependent promoter spoIIA but did not affect expression from the sigmaH-dependent, Spo0A-independent promoters citGp2 and spoVG. Therefore, promoter activation by Spo0A requires homologous regions in sigmaA and sigmaH. A mutant form of Spo0A, S231F, that suppresses the sporulation defect caused by several amino acid substitutions in sigmaA did not suppress the sporulation defects caused by the Q201A and R205A substitutions in sigmaH. This result and others indicate that different surfaces of Spo0A probably interact with sigmaA and sigmaH RNA polymerases.

A region in the Bacillus subtilis transcription factor Spo0A that is important for spoIIG promoter activation

Spo0A is a DNA binding protein in Bacillus subtilis required for the activation of spoIIG and other promoters at the onset of endospore formation. Activation of some of these promoters may involve interaction of Spo0A and the sigmaA subunit of RNA polymerase. Previous studies identified two single-amino-acid substitutions in sigmaA, K356E and H359R, that specifically impaired Spo0A-dependent transcription in vivo. Here we report the identification of an amino acid substitution in Spo0A (S231F) that suppressed the sporulation deficiency due to the H359R substitution in sigmaA. We also found that the S231F substitution partially restored use of the spoIIG promoter by the sigmaA H359R RNA polymerase in vitro. Alanine substitutions in the 231 region of Spo0A revealed an additional amino acid residue important for spoIIG promoter activation, I229. This amino acid substitution in Spo0A did not affect repression of abrB transcription, indicating that the alanine-substituted Spo0A was not defective in DNA binding. Moreover, the alanine-substituted Spo0A protein activated the spoIIA promoter; therefore, this region of Spo0A is probably not required for Spo0A-dependent, sigmaH-directed transcription. These and other results suggest that the region of Spo0A near position 229 is involved in sigmaA-dependent promoter activation.

Involvement of superoxide dismutase in spore coat assembly in Bacillus subtilis

Endospores of Bacillus subtilis are enclosed in a proteinaceous coat which can be differentiated into a thick, striated outer layer and a thinner, lamellar inner layer. We found that the N-terminal sequence of a 25-kDa protein present in a preparation of spore coat proteins matched that of the Mn-dependent superoxide dismutase (SOD) encoded by the sod4 locus. sod4 is transcribed throughout the growth and sporulation of a wild-type strain and is responsible for the SOD activity detected in total cell extracts prepared from B. subtilis. Disruption of the sod4 locus produced a mutant that lacked any detectable SOD activity during vegetative growth and sporulation. The sodA mutant was not impaired in the ability to form heat- or lysozyme-resistant spores. However, examination of the coat layers of sodA mutant spores revealed increased extractability of the tyrosine-rich outer coat protein CotG. We showed that this condition was not accompanied by augmented transcription of the cotG gene in sporulating cells of the sodA mutant. We conclude that SodA is required for the assembly of CotG into the insoluble matrix of the spore and suggest that CotG is covalently cross-linked into the insoluble matrix by an oxidative reaction dependent on SodA. Ultrastructural analysis revealed that the inner coat formed by a sodA mutant was incomplete. Moreover, the outer coat lacked the characteristic striated appearance of wild-type spores, a pattern that was accentuated in a cotG mutant. These observations suggest that the SodA-dependent formation of the insoluble matrix containing CotG is largely responsible for the striated appearance of this coat layer.

Control of cell shape and elongation by the rodA gene in Bacillus subtilis

The Escherichia coli rodA and ftsW genes and the spoVE gene of Bacillus subtilis encode membrane proteins that control peptidoglycan synthesis during cellular elongation, division and sporulation respectively. While rodA and ftsW are essential genes in E. coli, the B. subtilis spoVE gene is dispensable for growth and is only required for the synthesis of the spore cortex peptidoglycan. In this work, we report on the characterization of a B. subtilis gene, designated rodA, encoding a homologue of E. coli RodA. We found that the growth of a B. subtilis strain carrying a fusion of rodA to the IPTG-inducible Pspac promoter is inducer dependent. Limiting concentrations of inducer caused the formation of spherical cells, which eventually lysed. An increase in the level of IPTG induced a sphere-to-short rod transition that re-established viability. Higher levels of inducer restored normal cell length. Staining of the septal or polar cap peptidoglycan by a fluorescent lectin was unaffected during growth of the mutant under restrictive conditions. Our results suggest that rodA functions in maintaining the rod shape of the cell and that this function is essential for viability. In addition, RodA has an irreplaceable role in the extension of the lateral walls of the cell. Electron microscopy observations support these conclusions. The ultrastructural analysis further suggests that the growth arrest that accompanies loss of the rod shape is caused by the cell's inability to construct a division septum capable of spanning the enlarged cell. RodA is similar over its entire length to members of a large protein family (SEDS, for shape, elongation, division and sporulation). Members of the SEDS family are probably present in all eubacteria that synthesize peptidoglycan as part of their cell envelope.

Assembly and interactions of cotJ-encoded proteins, constituents of the inner layers of the Bacillus subtilis spore coat

During Bacillus subtilis endospore formation, a complex protein coat is assembled around the maturing spore. The coat is made up of more than two dozen proteins that form an outer layer, which provides chemical resistance, and an inner layer, which may play a role in the activation of germination. A third, amorphous layer of the coat occupies the space between the inner coat and the cortex, and is referred to as the undercoat. Although several coat proteins have been characterized, little is known about their interactions during assembly of the coat. We show here that at least two open reading frames of the cotJ operon (cotJA and cotJC) encode spore coat proteins. We suggest that CotJC is a component of the undercoat, since we found that its assembly onto the forespore is not prevented by mutations that block both inner and outer coat assembly, and because CotJC is more accessible to antibody staining in spores lacking both of these coat layers. Assembly of CotJC into the coat is dependent upon expression of cotJA. Conversely, CotJA is not detected in the coats of a cotJC insertional mutant. Co-immunoprecipitation was used to demonstrate the formation of complexes containing CotJA and CotJC 6 h after the onset of sporulation. Experiments with the yeast two-hybrid system indicate that CotJC may interact with itself and with CotJA. We suggest that interaction of CotJA with CotJC is required for the assembly of both CotJA and CotJC into the spore coat.

Activation of the Bacillus subtilis spoIIG promoter requires interaction of Spo0A and the sigma subunit of RNA polymerase

Bacillus subtilis Spo0A activates transcription from both sigmaA- and sigmaH-dependent promoters. Baldus et al. (2) identified two amino acid substitutions in the carboxyl terminus of sigmaA, K356E and H359R, that specifically impaired Spo0A-activated transcription in vivo. To test the model in which the K356E and H359R substitutions in sigmaA interfere with the interaction of Spo0A and sigmaA, we examined the effects of alanine substitutions at these positions in sigmaA on sigmaA's ability to direct transcription in vivo and in vitro. We found that alanine substitutions at these positions specifically reduced expression from the sigmaA-dependent, Spo0A-dependent promoters, spoIIG and spoIIE, in vivo. Furthermore, we found that stimulation of spoIIG promoter activity by Spo0A in vitro was reduced by the single substitutions H359A and H359R in sigmaA.

CotM of Bacillus subtilis, a member of the alpha-crystallin family of stress proteins, is induced during development and participates in spore outer coat formation

We cloned and characterized a gene, cotM, that resides in the 173 degrees region of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome and is involved in spore outer coat assembly. We found that expression of the cotM gene is induced during development under sigma K control and is negatively regulated by the GerE transcription factor. Disruption of the cotM gene resulted in spores with an abnormal pattern of coat proteins. Electron microscopy revealed that the outer coat in cotM mutant spores had lost its multilayered type of organization, presenting a diffuse appearance. In particular, significant amounts of material were absent from the outer coat layers, which in some areas had a lamellar structure more typical of the inner coat. Occasionally, a pattern of closely spaced ridges protruding from its surface was observed. No deficiency associated with the inner coat or any other spore structure was found. CotM is related to the alpha-crystallin family of low-molecular-weight heat shock proteins, members of which can be substrates for transglutaminase-mediated protein cross-linking. CotM was not detected among the extractable spore coat proteins. These observations are consistent with a model according to which CotM is part of a cross-linked insoluble skeleton that surrounds the spore, serves as a matrix for the assembly of additional outer coat material, and confers structural stability to the final structure.

cse15, cse60, and csk22 are new members of mother-cell-specific sporulation regulons in Bacillus subtilis

We report on the characterization of three new transcription units expressed during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis. Two of the units, cse15 and cse60, were mapped at about 123 degrees and 62 degrees on the genetic map, respectively. Their transcription commenced around h 2 of sporulation and showed an absolute requirement for sigmaE. Maximal expression of both cse15 and cse60 further depended on the DNA-binding protein SpoIIID. Primer extension results revealed -10 and -35 sequences upstream of the cse15 and cse60 coding sequences very similar to those utilized by sigmaE-containing RNA polymerase. Alignment of these and other regulatory regions led to a revised consensus sequence for sigmaE-dependent promoters. A third transcriptional unit, designated csk22, was localized at approximately 173 degrees on the chromosome. Transcription of csk22 was activated at h 4 of sporulation, required the late mother-cell regulator sigmaK, and was repressed by the GerE protein. Sequences in the csk22 promoter region were similar to those of other sigmaK-dependent promoters. The cse60 locus was deduced to encode an acidic product of only 60 residues. A 37.6-kDa protein apparently encoded by cse15 was weakly related to the heavy chain of myosins, as well as to other myosin-like proteins, and is predicted to contain a central, 100 residue-long coiled-coil domain. Finally, csk22 is inferred to encode a 18.2-kDa hydrophobic product with five possible membrane-spanning helices, which could function as a transporter.

Potassium permanganate susceptibility of sigma E-RNA polymerase-promoter complexes

We used potassium permanganate (KMnO4) to identify unpaired thymidine (T) residues in promoter complexes formed by RNA polymerase (RNAP) associated with sigma E (sigma E-RNAP) from Bacillus subtilis. We found that a region of the spoIIID promoter from at least -10 to +1 becomes melted in the presence of this polymerase. In promoter complexes formed by RNAP associated with a mutant sigma E that melts promoter DNA inefficiently, we noted additional KMnO4 sensitivity at the -11 position of the spoIIID promoter. We suggest that the base pair at -11 is unpaired in both mutant and wild type (wt) complexes; however, close proximity of wt sigma E-RNAP with the T at -11 may protect it from KMnO4 attack. The absence of a close contact between the mutant sigma E-RNAP and the base at -11 may explain why this polymerase uses promoters less efficiently than wt sigma E-RNAP.

Two-stage regulation of an anti-sigma factor determines developmental fate during bacterial endospore formation

During endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis an asymmetric division produces two cells, forespore and mother cell, which follow different developmental paths. Commitment to the forespore-specific developmental path is controlled in part by the activation of the forespore-specific RNA polymerase sigma factor, sigma F. Activity of sigma F is inhibited in the mother cell by the anti-sigma factor SpoIIAB. In the forespore, sigma F directs transcription of the structural gene for sigma G. However, sigma G does not become active until after engulfment of the forespore is complete. This sigma G activity is dependent upon the products of the spoIIIA operon. We showed that sigma G is present but mostly inactive in a spoIIIA mutant. We also demonstrated that the anti-sigma factor SpoIIAB can bind to sigma G in vitro. Moreover, a mutant form of sigma G that binds SpoIIAB inefficiently in vitro was shown to function independently of SpoIIIA during sporulation. These and previously reported results support a model in which SpoIIAB functions as an inhibitor of sigma G activity during sporulation. Therefore, we propose that the anti-sigma factor SpoIIAB antagonizes both sigma F and sigma G activities, and that this antagonism is relieved in the forespore in two stages. In the first stage, which follows septation, a SpoIIAA-dependent mechanism partially relieves SpoIIAB inhibition of sigma F activity in the forespore. In the second stage, which follows forespore engulfment, a SpoIIIA-dependent process inactivates SpoIIAB in the forespore, resulting in the activation of sigma G.

A sigma E dependent operon subject to catabolite repression during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

To identify genes expressed at intermediate stages of Bacillus subtilis sporulation, we screened for sigma E-dependent promoters. One promoter that we found drives expression of an operon consisting of at least five open reading frames (ORFs). The predicted products of the first three ORFs are very homologous to enzymes involved in fatty acid metabolism, including acetyl coenzyme A (acetyl-CoA) acetyltransferase (thiolase), 3-hydroxybutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase, and acyl-CoA dehydrogenase, respectively. We showed that the fourth ORF encoded a third isozyme of citrate synthase in B. subtilis. Genetic evidence and primer extension results showed that transcription of this operon is directed by the mother cell compartment-specific sigma factor, sigma E, and so the operon was named mmg (for mother cell metabolic genes). Furthermore, we found that a sequence (mmgO) with homology to a catabolite-responsive element mediates glucose repression of mmg promoter activity during sporulation and that this repression was lost in a ccpA mutant.

Passage to nonselective media transiently alters growth of mycophenolic acid-resistant mammalian cells expressing the escherichia coli xanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase gene: implications for sequential selection strategies

The Escherichia coli xanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase gene (Ecogpt) rescues mammalian cells from inhibition of purine nucleotide biosynthesis by mycophenolic acid (MPA). We used Ecogpt and other selectable markers to obtain subclones of NIH 3T3 derivatives (EN/NIH) stably expressing transfected genes of interest. In their respective selective mediums, growth of MPA-resistant (MPA(R)) isolates was indistinguishable from that of aminoglycoside-resistant counterparts expressing selectable marker genes conferring resistance to protein synthesis inhibitors hygromycin B, puromycin, and G418. Growth of aminoglycoside-resistant isolates remained unaltered on passage to nonselective media. In contrast, MPA(R) cells transferred from MPA complete media to nonselective media displayed morphologic changes with static growth. These findings resolved completely by third passage in nonselective media and were independent of the gene of interest cis-linked to the selectable marker. Sequential selection strategies involving cell culture conditions resulting in these altered growth characteristics significantly impaired detection (by selection in G418) of genomic events associated with reactivation of enhancerless, transcriptionally silent neointegrants present in MPA(R) EN/NIH isolates. We explored the cause of these cell culture findings and defined transfection and sequential selection strategies for MPA(R) derivatives that successfully circumvented these effects.

sigma E changed to sigma B specificity by amino acid substitutions in its -10 binding region

The association of a sigma factor (sigma) with RNA polymerase in bacteria determines its specificity of promoter utilization. To identify amino acid residues in sigma E from Bacillus subtilis that determine the specificity of its interaction with the nucleotides at the -10 region of its cognate promoters, we tested whether base pair substitutions in the -10 region of a sigma B-dependent promoter could signal its utilization by sigma E-RNA polymerase. We found that a combination of base pair substitutions at positions -15 and -14 of the sigma B-dependent ctc promoter resulted in its utilization by sigma E-RNA polymerase in vivo. We also found that the combination of two amino acid substitutions at positions 119 and 120 in sigma E changed its specificity for promoter utilization, resulting in a sigma factor that directed transcription from the sigma B-dependent ctc promoter, but not from sigma E-dependent promoters. These results suggest that amino acid residues at positions 119 and 120 determine, at least in part, the specificity of interactions between sigma E and the nucleotides in the -10 region of its cognate promoters.

Sequence-specific interactions between promoter DNA and the RNA polymerase sigma factor E

In order to determine which amino acyl residues in a secondary sigma factor govern its specificity of recognition at the -35 region of promoters, we examined the effects of amino acid substitutions in sigma E in Bacillus subtilis that made the sequence of its putative -35 recognition region more similar to another sigma factor in B. subtilis, sigma K. We found that a single amino acid substitution at position 217 of sigma E resulted in a sigma factor that could direct transcription from sigma K-dependent promoters. Furthermore, we tested whether this amino acid substitution in sigma E had changed the specificity of interactions of the sigma with -35 region sequences by examining the activity of the mutant sigma E on derivatives of sigma E-dependent promoters that contained single base-pair substitutions. We found that this substitution in sigma E specifically suppressed the effect of a single base-pair substitution at position -31 in a sigma E-dependent promoter spoIIID. The amino acyl residue at another position (219) on sigma E affected the specificity of interaction with position -33 in spoIIID promoter. The amino acyl residues at the two positions in sigma E, 217 and 219, that determine the specificity of interactions between the sigma and base-pairs in the -35 region of its cognate promoters (positions -33 and -31, respectively, in the spoIIID promoter) probably closely contact these base-pairs.

Evidence that the transcriptional activator Spo0A interacts with two sigma factors in Bacillus subtilis

The transcriptional regulator Spo0A activates transcription from two types of promoters. One type of promoter is used by RNA polymerase containing sigma A, whereas the other type is used by RNA polymerase containing sigma H. There are Spo0A-binding sites near the -35 region of both types of promoters. It has been reported that some transcriptional regulators that bind near the -35 regions of promoters directly interact with the sigma subunit of RNA polymerase. Therefore, we looked for evidence that Spo0A interacts with both sigma factors by searching for single amino acid substitutions in these factors that specifically prevent expression from Spo0A-dependent promoters, but that do not decrease activity of Spo0A-independent promoters. Two such amino acid substitutions were isolated in sigma A and one was isolated in sigma H. The amino acid substitutions in sigma A prevented expression from the Spo0A-activated promoters, spoIIG and spoIIE, but expression was not impaired from the Spo0A-independent, sigma A-dependent promoter tms or from the Spo0A-activated, sigma H-dependent promoter, spoIIA. The amino acid substitution in sigma H prevented expression from the spoIIA promoter but not from the Spo0A-independent promoter, citGp2, which is used by sigma H-RNA polymerase. All of these amino acid substitutions occur in the carboxyl terminus of the sigma factors. These amino acid substitutions may define the sites of contact between the sigma factors and Spo0A. The ability of response regulators such as Spo0A to interact with multiple sigma factors may increase the variety of responses made by bacteria using a limited number of transcription factors.

A single amino acid substitution in sigma E affects its ability to bind core RNA polymerase

We have examined the role of the most highly conserved region of bacterial RNA polymerase sigma factors by analyzing the effect of amino acid substitutions and small deletions in sigma E from Bacillus subtilis. sigma E is required for the production of endospores in B. subtilis but not for vegetative growth. Strains expressing each of several mutant forms of sigE were found to be deficient in their ability to form endospores. Single amino acid substitutions at positions 68 and 94 resulted in sigma factors that bind with less affinity to the core subunits of RNA polymerase. The substitution at position 68 did not affect the stability of the protein in B. subtilis; therefore, this substitution probably did not have large effects on the overall structure of the sigma factor. The substitution at position 68 probably defines a position in sigma E that closely contacts a subunit of RNA polymerase, while the substitution at position 94 may define a position that is important for protein stability or for binding to core RNA polymerase.

Characterization of cotJ, a sigma E-controlled operon affecting the polypeptide composition of the coat of Bacillus subtilis spores

The outermost protective structure found in endospores of Bacillus subtilis is a thick protein shell known as the coat, which makes a key contribution to the resistance properties of the mature spore and also plays a role in its interaction with compounds able to trigger germination. The coat is organized as a lamellar inner layer and an electron-dense outer layer and has a complex polypeptide composition. Here we report the cloning and characterization of an operon, cotJ, located at about 62 degrees on the B. subtilis genetic map, whose inactivation results in the production of spores with an altered pattern of coat polypeptides. The cotJ operon was identified by screening a random library of lacZ transcriptional fusions for a conditional (inducer-dependent) Lac+ phenotype in cells of a strain in which the structural gene (spoIIGB) for the early-acting, mother-cell-specific transcriptional factor sigma E was placed under the control of the IPTG (isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside)-inducible Pspac promoter. Sequence analysis of cloned DNA from the cotJ region complemented by genetic experiments revealed a tricistronic operon preceded by a strong sigma E-like promoter. Expression of an SP beta-borne cotJ-lacZ fusion commences at around h 2 of sporulation, as does expression of other sigma E-dependent genes, and shows an absolute requirement for sigma E. Studies with double-reporter strains bearing a cotJ-gusA fusion and lacZ fusions to other cot genes confirmed that expression of cotJ is initiated during sporulation prior to activation of genes known to encode coat structural proteins (with the sole exception of cotE). An in vitro-constructed insertion-deletion mutation in cotJ resulted in the formation of spores with no detectable morphological or resistance deficiency. However, examination of the profile of electrophoretically separated spore coat proteins from the null mutant revealed a pattern that was essentially identical to that of a wild-type strain in the range of 12 to 65 kDa, except for polypeptides of 17 and 24 kDa, the putative products of the second (cotJB) and third (cotJC) cistrons of the operon, that were missing or reduced in amount in the coat of the mutant. Polypeptides of the same apparent sizes are detected in spores of a cotE null mutant, on which basis we infer that the products of the cotJ operon are required for the normal formation of the inner layers of the coat or are themselves structural components of the coat. Because the onset of cotJ transcription is temporally coincident with the appearance of active sigma E, we speculate that the cotJ-encoded products may be involved in an early state of coat assembly.

Bacillus subtilis lon protease prevents inappropriate transcription of genes under the control of the sporulation transcription factor sigma G

The Bacillus subtilis RNA polymerase sigma factor sigma G is a cell-type-specific regulatory protein that governs the transcription of genes that are expressed at an intermediate to late stage of sporulation in the forespore compartment of the sporangium. Here we report the identification of a mutation (lon-1) that causes inappropriate transcription of genes under the control of sigma G under nutritional and genetic conditions in which sporulation is prevented. The mutation is located at 245 degrees on the genetic map and lies within a newly identified open reading frame that is predicted to encode a homolog to Lon protease. Inappropriate transcription of sigma G-controlled genes in the lon-1 mutant is not prevented by mutations in genes that are normally required for the appearance of sigma G during sporulation but is prevented by a mutation in the structural gene (spoIIIG) for sigma G itself. In light of previous work showing that spoIIIG is subject to positive autoregulation, we propose that Lon protease is responsible (possibly by causing degradation of sigma G) for preventing sigma G-directed transcription of spoIIIG and hence the accumulation of sigma G in cells that are not undergoing sporulation. An integrated physical and genetic map is presented that encompasses 36 kb of uninterrupted DNA sequence from the lon pheA region of the chromosome, corresponding to 245 degrees to 239 degrees on the genetic map.

Cloning and characterization of spoVR, a gene from Bacillus subtilis involved in spore cortex formation

Screening for sigma E-dependent promoters led to the isolation of a gene from Bacillus subtilis, designated spoVR, which appears to be involved in spore cortex formation. Cultures of strains carrying mutations in spoVR had an increased proportion of phase-dark spores, which correlated with an increased proportion of cortexless spores seen by electron microscopy. The numbers of heat- and chloroform-resistant phase-bright spores produced by these mutants were decreased by about 3- to 10-fold, and accumulation of dipicolinate was decreased by more than 3-fold. The spoVR gene was located on the B. subtilis chromosome immediately upstream from, and in the opposite orientation of, the phoAIV gene. Expression of spoVR was initiated at the second hour of sporulation from a sigma E-dependent promoter, and this expression did not require any of the other known mother-cell-specific transcriptional regulators. The spoVR gene was predicted to encode a product of 468 residues.

Subcellular localization of proteins involved in the assembly of the spore coat of Bacillus subtilis

Spores of the bacterium Bacillus subtilis are encased in a two-layered protein shell, which consists of an electron-translucent, lamellar inner coat, and an electron-dense outer coat. The coat protein CotE is both a structural component of the coat and a morphogenetic protein that is required for the assembly of the outer coat. We now show that CotE is located in the outer coat of the mature spore and that at an intermediate stage of sporulation, when the developing spore (the forespore) is present as a free protoplast within the sporangium, CotE is localized in a ring that surrounds the forespore but is separated from it by a small gap. We propose that the ring is the site of assembly of the outer coat and that the gap is the site of formation of the inner coat. Assembly of the ring depends on the sporulation protein SpoIVA, which sits close to or on the surface of the outer membrane that encircles the forespore. We propose that SpoIVA creates a basement layer around the forespore on which coat assembly takes place. The subcellular localization and assembly of CotE and other coat proteins are therefore determined by the capacity of SpoIVA to recognize and adhere to a specific surface within the sporangium, the outer membrane of the forespore.

Phosphorylation of Bacillus subtilis transcription factor Spo0A stimulates transcription from the spoIIG promoter by enhancing binding to weak 0A boxes

Activation of the spoIIG promoter at the onset of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis requires the regulatory protein, Spo0A, which binds to two sites in the promoter, sites 1 and 2. Phosphorylation of Spo0A is essential for the initiation of sporulation. Therefore, we examined the role of Spo0A phosphorylation in spoIIG promoter activation. Phosphorylation of Spo0A stimulated transcription from the spoIIG promoter in vitro. In DNAse I footprinting experiments with the spoIIG promoter, we found that phosphorylation of Spo0A increased its affinity for site 2 more than for site 1, which is the site to which nonphosphorylated Spo0A binds most avidly. This result could not be explained by increased cooperativity between Spo0A bound at sites 1 and 2 because the increased affinity for site 2 by phosphorylated Spo0A was also observed with a deletion derivative of the spoIIG promoter containing only site 2. We have located Spo0A-binding sequences in the spoIIG promoter by DMS protection assays and mutational analysis, and found that site 1 contains one higher-affinity binding sequence whereas site 2 contains two weaker-binding sites. Two substitutions in site 2 of the spoIIG promoter that change the sequence to be more like an optimal Spo0A-binding site were found to increase promoter activity. Moreover, phosphorylation of Spo0A was not required in vivo for activation of the spoIIG promoter containing these strong binding sites. The results suggest that the primary role for phosphorylation of Spo0A is to increase its affinity for specific sites rather than to activate an activity of Spo0A that acts on RNA polymerase at promoters.

Forespore-specific disappearance of the sigma-factor antagonist spoIIAB: implications for its role in determination of cell fate in Bacillus subtilis

Endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis is a morphologically complex process in which the bacterium divides into two compartments (forespore and mother cell) that follow different developmental paths. Compartment-specific transcription in the forespore is initiated by RNA polymerase containing sigma F, and results in the forespore-specific production of sigma G, which directs most of the subsequent forespore-specific transcription. The activity of sigma F is thought to be restricted to the forespore by the sigma factor antagonist SpoIIAB. We used antibodies against SpoIIAB to monitor its accumulation during sporulation. We found that SpoIIAB accumulates early after the initiation of sporulation, and that it was present in the mother-cell compartment 2h after sigma F became active in the forespore. SpoIIAB disappeared preferentially from the forespore during development, and its disappearance from the forespore compartment correlated with the activation of sigma G in that compartment, raising the possibility that SpoIIAB may be involved regulating sigma G activity. We tested whether SpoIIAB could antagonize sigma G activity by replacing the sigma F-dependent promoter that drives expression of spoIIIG, the structural gene for sigma G, with a sigma H-dependent promoter. This resulted in a lytic phenotype that was suppressed by the simultaneous expression of a plasmid-borne copy of spoIIAB. This suggests that SpoIIAB can suppress this effect of sigma G expression. Moreover, these cells formed spores efficiently.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cloning and characterization of a gene required for assembly of the Bacillus subtilis spore coat

During endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis, approximately a dozen proteins are synthesized and assembled around the prespore to form a protective coat. Little is known about the assembly process, but several of the genes encoding these coat proteins are expressed in the mother cell compartment, where the proteins accumulate on the outer side of the developing endospore. Transcription of these genes is directed by the mother cell-specific sigma factor, sigma K, during the later stages of endospore development. sigma E may direct expression of the genes that encode proteins that function in the earliest stages of coat assembly. By screening for sigma E-dependent promoters, we cloned a gene, designated spoVID, required for assembly of a normal spore coat. Expression of spoVID was initiated at about the second hour of sporulation and continued throughout development from a sigma E-dependent promoter. The spoVID gene was located on the B. subtilis chromosome just downstream of the previously characterized hemAXCDBL operon and is predicted to encode an extremely acidic protein with 575 residues. Insertion mutants of spoVID produced refractile spores that were resistant to heat and to chloroform but were sensitive to lysozyme. Electron microscopic examination of sporulating spoVID mutant cells revealed normal morphological development up to about the third hour of sporulation. However, during the later stages of development the coat proteins assembled into aberrant structures that occurred freely in the mother cell cytoplasm and that consisted of reiterations of the single inner and outer layers that normally make up the spore coat.

Genetic suppression analysis of sigma E interaction with three promoters in sporulating Bacillus subtilis

Genetic evidence suggests that the sigma (sigma) subunit of RNA polymerase determines the specificity of promoter utilization, by making sequence-specific contacts with DNA. We examined the effects of two single amino acid(aa) substitutions in sigma E on the utilization of mutated derivatives of three different promoters in sporulating Bacillus subtilis. We found allele-specific suppression of mutations in all three promoters by each aa substitution in sigma E. These results provide strong evidence that sigma E interacts with each of these promoters in vivo. Moreover, the specificity of suppression of the mutations by the aa substitutions in sigma E lead us to speculate that the Met124 of sigma E closely contacts two adjacent bp in the -10 region of the promoters.

Effects of amino acid substitutions in the -10 binding region of sigma E from Bacillus subtilis

The sigma subunit of bacterial RNA polymerase is required for specific binding to promoters. One region in most sigma factors makes sequence-specific contacts at the -10 region of its cognate promoters. To test the role of the amino acids in this -10 binding region, we examined the effects of 49 single-amino-acid substitutions in sigma E from Bacillus subtilis. We assayed the effect of each amino acid substitution on spore formation because sigma E is essential for endospore formation in B. subtilis. Our results showed that substitutions at several positions, including the highly conserved aromatic amino acid at position 102, had little or no detectable effect. Substitutions at another position, position 117, produced dominant negative mutations; we suggest that these mutations allow RNA polymerase containing the mutant sigma factor to bind specifically to promoters but prevent transcription initiation. Of the recessive defective alleles, those that produced substitutions at positions 113, 115, and 120 produced the most defective sigma factors. These results suggest that the residues at or near these positions in wild-type sigma E play important roles in sigma E function.

Spo0A controls the sigma A-dependent activation of Bacillus subtilis sporulation-specific transcription unit spoIIE

The spoIIE operon is a developmentally regulated transcription unit activated in the second hour of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis. Its promoter has an unusual structure, containing sequences which conform perfectly to the consensus for vegetative promoters recognized by sigma A-associated RNA polymerase (E sigma A), but with a spacing of 21 bp between the apparent -10 and -35 elements instead of the 17- or 18-bp spacing typical of promoters utilized by E sigma A. Mutations introduced into the apparent -10 element affected transcription in a manner consistent with its functioning as a polymerase recognition sequence. The deleterious effect of one -10 mutation was also suppressed in an allele-specific manner by a mutation in sigA known to suppress analogous -10 mutations in conventional vegetative promoters recognized by E sigma A. Similar suppression experiments failed to provide evidence for a direct interaction between E sigma A and the "-35-like" element, however, and DNase I protection experiments suggested instead that the Spo0A protein binds to a site overlapping this -35-like hexamer. Moreover, the effects of mutations within the -35-like hexamer on the binding of Spo0A in vitro paralleled their effects on transcription in vivo. We suggest that spoIIE belongs to a class of early-intermediate sporulation genes whose transcription by E sigma A is activated by the Spo0A protein.

Mutant sigma factor blocks transition between promoter binding and initiation of transcription

The sigma subunit of bacterial RNA polymerase is required for specific binding of the enzyme to promoters. This specificity is probably directed by two regions of most sigma factors that make sequence-specific contacts at two regions of promoters, the -10 and -35 regions. We found that a single amino acid substitution in the -10 recognition region of sigma E from Bacillus subtilis trapped RNA polymerase in a stable complex with promoter DNA in which it was unable to initiate transcription. Our results are consistent with the view that promoter utilization by RNA polymerase proceeds through several intermediate steps and suggest that the -10 recognition region of sigma factors may participate in a step that follows initial promoter binding.

Binding of Spo0A stimulates spoIIG promoter activity in Bacillus subtilis

The spoIIG promoter is used by RNA polymerase containing sigma A (E sigma A), the primary form of RNA polymerase found in vegetative cells in Bacillus subtilis. However, the spoIIG promoter is active only after the onset of sporulation. Activation of the spoIIG promoter requires the product of the spo0A gene (Spo0A). Spo0A is a sequence-specific DNA-binding protein which binds to two sites in the spoIIG promoter that are essential for promoter activity. We found that single-base-pair substitutions in these two regions that reduced promoter activity in vivo caused reduced binding of Spo0A in vitro, and one substitution that increased promoter activity in vivo increased the affinity of Spo0A for this DNA in vitro. Furthermore, Spo0A stimulated transcription from the spoIIG promoter by E sigma A in vitro. These results support the model that binding of Spo0A activates E sigma A-dependent transcription from the spoIIG promoter after the onset of sporulation.

Genetic evidence for interaction of sigma E with the spoIIID promoter in Bacillus subtilis

During sporulation in Bacillus subtilis, new RNA polymerase sigma factors are produced. These sigma factors direct the transcription of genes that are required for this cellular differentiation. In order to determine the role of each sigma factor in this process, it is necessary to know which promoters are recognized by each sigma factor. The spoIIID gene product plays an important role in the establishment of mother cell-specific gene expression during sporulation. We found that substitution of an alanine at position 124 of the sporulation-specific sigma factor sigma E suppressed the effect of a single-base-pair transition at position -13 of the spoIIID promoter. This alanine substitution in sigma E did not suppress the effect of a transversion at position -12 of the spoIIID promoter. The allele specificity of the interaction between sigma E and the spoIIID promoter is strong evidence that sigma E directs transcription from the spoIIID promoter during sporulation. Position 124 in sigma E is located within a region that is highly conserved among the regions in other sigma factors that probably interact with the -10 regions of their cognate promoters.

Deletion of spoIIAB blocks endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis at an early stage

During an early stage of endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis, the cell divides asymmetrically into two compartments that follow different developmental paths. The differential expression of genes in these two compartments is controlled in part by the production of compartment-specific transcription factors, sigma G and sigma K. It is not known how sigma G accumulation is restricted to one of the two compartments, the forespore. However, the observations that sigma F directs transcription of the structural gene for sigma G and that sigma F activity can be modified by the product of a gene, spoIIAB, has led us to investigate the role of spoIIAB during sporulation. We have isolated mutants that carry deletion alleles of spoIIAB. Electron microscopic examination of these mutants revealed that these mutations blocked endospore formation at an early stage before septation and caused extensive cell lysis. The spoIIAB deletion alleles caused hyperexpression of genes that are normally expressed exclusively in the forespore compartments of sporulating wild-type cells, whereas these alleles reduced expression of other genes, including spoIIE, which is expressed before septation in wild-type cells. These observations confirm that spoIIAB is essential for sporulation and are consistent with models in which the product of spoIIAB plays a role in regulating the timing and/or compartment specificity of sigma F- and sigma G-directed transcription.

Expression of stage II genes during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Two RNA polymerase sigma factors, sigma F and sigma E, are produced during the first two hours of endospore formation in Bacillus subtilis. Transcription of the structural genes for these factors is activated about one hour after the start of endospore formation. The operon encoding sigma F is transcribed by RNA polymerase containing sigma H, another secondary sigma factor, whereas the operon encoding sigma E is transcribed by RNA polymerase containing sigma A, the primary sigma factor in growing cells. Evidently, the coordinate temporal control of these transcriptional units is mediated by a factor other than the sigma factors, possibly by the DNA-binding protein encoded by spo0A. Both sigma F and sigma E activities are also regulated by mechanisms operating after transcription.

Genetic evidence for interaction of sigma A with two promoters in Bacillus subtilis

The specificity of promoter binding by RNA polymerase is governed by the sigma subunit. Recent studies, in which single-amino-acid substitutions in sigma factors have been found to suppress the effects of specific base pair substitutions in promoters, support the model that these sigma factors make sequence-specific contacts with nucleotides at the -10 and -35 regions of promoters. We found that single-amino-acid substitutions in the putative -35 region and -10 region recognition domains of sigma A specifically suppressed the effects of mutations in the -35 and -10 regions, respectively, of two promoters that are expressed in exponentially growing Bacillus subtilis. These mutations change the specificity of sigma A, the primary sigma factor in growing B. subtilis, and demonstrate that this sigma factor interacts with promoters in a manner similar to that of its homolog in Escherichia coli, sigma 70. These mutant derivatives of sigma A also provide a tool that may be useful for determining whether sigma A uses specific promoters in vivo.

Spo0A binds to a promoter used by sigma A RNA polymerase during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Examination of the effects of 56 single-base-pair substitutions in the spoIIG promoter and studies of the interaction of the spo0A product (Spo0A) with this promoter in vitro demonstrated that Spo0A acts directly to enable this promoter to be used by sigma A-associated RNA polymerase (EC 2.7.7.6). The spoIIG operon from Bacillus subtilis is transcribed during sporulation by a form o RNA polymerase containing sigma A, the primary sigma factor in vegetative cells. The spoIIG promoter is unusual in that it contains sequences that are similar to those found at the -10 and -35 regions of promoters that are used by sigma A-associated RNA polymerase, but these sigma A-like recognition sequences are separated by 22 base pairs rather than the typical 17 or 18 base pairs. We found that single-base-pair substitutions in the around the -35-like sequence, and substitutions in a region upstream from this position, around position -87, reduced promoter activity. DNase I protection and electrophoretic gel mobility shift assays were used to demonstrate that Spo0A binds specifically to these regions in vitro. Evidently, the -35-like sequence is part of a Spo0A binding site and therefore is possibly not a sigma A-recognition sequence. These results support a model in which Spo0A activates the spoIIG promoter after the onset of endospore formation.

Transcription of the Bacillus subtilis spoIIA locus

The spoIIA operon encodes three genes, including the structural gene for a sporulation-induced sigma factor sigma F. We used deletion analysis of spoIIA-lacZ fusions to define the location of the spoIIA promoter. We found that sigma H-RNA polymerase transcribes spoIIA accurately in vitro and propose that sigma H directs transcription of spoIIA during sporulation.

Control of developmental transcription factor sigma F by sporulation regulatory proteins SpoIIAA and SpoIIAB in Bacillus subtilis

The sporulation operon spoIIA of Bacillus subtilis consists of three cistrons called spoIIAA, spoIIAB, and spoIIAC. Little is known about the function of spoIIAA and spoIIAB, but spoIIAC encodes a sigma factor called sigma F, which is capable of directing the transcription in vitro of genes that are expressed in the forespore chamber of the developing sporangium. We now report that the products of the spoIIA operon constitute a regulatory system in which SpoIIAA is an antagonist of SpoIIAB (or otherwise counteracts the effect of SpoIIAB) and SpoIIAB is, in turn, an antagonist of SpoIIAC (sigma F). This conclusion is based on the observations that (i) overexpression of spoIIAB inhibits sigma F-directed gene expression, (ii) a mutation in spoIIAB stimulates sigma F-directed gene expression, (iii) a mutation in spoIIAA blocks sigma F-directed gene expression, and (iv) a mutation in spoIIAB relieves the block in sigma F-directed gene expression caused by a mutation in spoIIAA. The SpoIIAA/SpoIIAB/SpoIIAC regulatory system could play a role in controlling the timing of sigma F-directed gene expression and/or could be responsible for restricting sigma F-directed gene expression to the forespore chamber of the sporangium.