Distribution of Salmonella spp. serotypes in poultry flocks in Abruzzo and Molise, Italy (2015-2020)

Issue/problem

The Italian National Health System has implemented a National Control Program for Salmonella in poultry populations in order to reduce the prevalence of infection. Starting from 2019, the control program has introduced health measures against Salmonella breeding flocks of Gallus gallus, positive to Salmonella Infantis, an emerging serotype at European level, and widespread along the entire poultry primary production chain.

Description of the problem

Recent data from the European Union One Health 2019 Zoonoses Report published by EFSA, highlighted that most of the Salmonella isolates (70%) originated from broilers. Interestingly, Salmonella Infantis accounted for 29.7% of the total.

Results

In the framework of the Italian Salmonella National Control Program the isolation of Salmonella spp. is carried out according to ISO 6579-1: 2017 from faeces, dust and boot socks. During the 2015-2020 period, testing in the Italian Regions Abruzzo and Molise was performed on 2,791 samples and 5,039 sample units. The percentage of samples positive to Salmonella spp. in Abruzzo and Molise was 16,9% and 10,1%, respectively. Out of 395 Salmonella spp. strains isolated, Salmonella Infantis was the most prevalent, representing the 54,9% and 61,9% for Abruzzo and Molise, respectively, followed by Salmonella Livingstone (18,4%) for Abruzzo and (14,4%) for Molise.

Lessons

The record of Salmonella Infantis in the areas under study reflects the European trend highlighted by the EFSA 2019 Report and justifies the decision to increase the biosecurity measures in farms where this serotype is isolated and to proceed with destruction of positive animals according to the Regulation 1069/2009/EC.

Key messages

Salmonella Infantis represents a risk for human health due to the presence of antimicrobial resistance genes that confer resistance to relevant antibiotics used in the treatment of human infections. Biosafety guidelines and disinfection practices on poultry farms should be improved in order to reduce the spread of this serotype, also considering its capability to form biofilm.

Application of a welfare assessment tool (Shelter Quality Protocol) in 64 Italian long-term dogs' shelters: welfare hazard analysis

The confined environment of the dog shelter, particularly over extensive time-periods can impact severely on welfare. Surveillance and assessment are therefore essential components of the welfare protocol. The aim of this study was to generate a descriptive analysis of a sample of Italian long-term shelters and identify potential hazards regarding the welfare of shelter dogs. This was achieved through application of the Shelter Quality Protocol (SQP) to link income/outcome variables and the inclusion of sixty-four long-term shelters in Italy. Descriptive and logistic regression analyses were conducted. Key findings showed feeding regime, type of diet and access to outdoor area to be significantly associated with inadequate body condition score (BCS). The probability of observing skin lesions was shown to be influenced by bedding inadequacy and bedding type. Limiting beds to one per dog and utilising clean bedding materials was significantly associated with a reduced probability of observing dirty/wet dogs. Protection from adverse weather conditions and inadequate bedding were significantly associated with the manifestation of polypnea. Non-existent dog training facilities, outdoor access or leash walking were all found to significantly increase the likelihood of fearful or aggressive attitudes to people. Outdoor access also, in conjunction with feeding regime, was associated with the presence of diarrhoea. The SQP proved useful in identifying welfare hazards, both as regards shelter environment and shelter management. Identification of these hazards creates the opportunity for interventions to be applied, minimising the risks and improving the welfare of long-term shelter dogs.

Development of a forecasting model for brucellosis spreading in the Italian cattle trade network aimed to prioritise the field interventions

Brucellosis caused by Brucella abortus is an important zoonosis that constitutes a serious hazard to public health. Prevention of human brucellosis depends on the control of the disease in animals. Livestock movement data represent a valuable source of information to understand the pattern of contacts between holdings, which may determine the inter-herds and intra-herd spread of the disease. The manuscript addresses the use of computational epidemic models rooted in the knowledge of cattle trade network to assess the probabilities of brucellosis spread and to design control strategies. Three different spread network-based models were proposed: the DFC (Disease Flow Centrality) model based only on temporal cattle network structure and unrelated to the epidemiological disease parameters; a deterministic SIR (Susceptible-Infectious-Recovered) model; a stochastic SEIR (Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered) model in which epidemiological and demographic within-farm aspects were also modelled. Containment strategies based on farms centrality in the cattle network were tested and discussed. All three models started from the identification of the entire sub-network originated from an infected farm, up to the fifth order of contacts. Their performances were based on data collected in Sicily in the framework of the national eradication plan of brucellosis in 2009. Results show that the proposed methods improves the efficacy and efficiency of the tracing activities in comparison to the procedure currently adopted by the veterinary services in the brucellosis control, in Italy. An overall assessment shows that the SIR model is the most suitable for the practical needs of the veterinary services, being the one with the highest sensitivity and the shortest computation time.

MLVA as an Epidemiological Tool To Trace Back Brucella melitensis Biovar 1 Re-Emergence in Italy

Brucellosis is an important zoonosis caused by Brucella spp., still prevalent in most areas of the world. Brucellosis control in animals is the key to protect humans. The knowledge of Brucella spp. prevailing genotypes in a territory represents an important epidemiological tool to formulate policies and strategies for disease control and to trace back the introduction of new strains previously considered as exotic. In the last years, multiple-locus variable number tandem repeat analysis (MLVA) has been proposed as complementary to classical biotyping methods. MLVA may add important information to the classical epidemiological investigation techniques, to help in tracing back sources of infection in brucellosis outbreaks. Sardinia is an Italian region officially free from sheep and goats brucellosis since 1998. In 2011, Brucella melitensis biovar 1, a biotype not reported in Italy since 1995, was isolated in one flock in the region. The genotyping MLVA-16 showed that isolates belonged to a rare American lineage, confirming it was introduced from other countries. The strain was considered as probably originating from Spain, where this lineage is endemic. BrucellaMLVA-16 has been proved to be useful to analyse the epidemiological correlation of strains enabling to trace its geographic origin by comparing their previously reported genetic patterns.

Identification of Suitable Areas for West Nile Virus Circulation in Tunisia

West Nile virus (WNV) is a mosquito-transmitted Flavivirus belonging to the Japanese encephalitis antigenic complex of the Flaviviridae family. It is transmitted primarily by the bite of infected mosquitoes, particularly Culex spp. and Aedes/Ochlerotatus spp., which acquire the virus by feeding on viraemic birds. Humans, horses and other mammals are regarded as incidental or dead-end hosts. In the last decades, an increasing number of cases of WNV infection in horses and humans have been notified in the Mediterranean basin. In Tunisia, human cases of WNV-related meningoencephalitis were detected in 1997, 2003, 2007, 2010, 2011 and 2012. Based on the analysis of climatic and environmental conditions found in the locations where human cases have been reported in 2012, the aim of this study was to identify similar areas in Tunisia potentially at risk of disease occurrence. Data related to 85 neuroinvasive West Nile fever (WNF) human cases were georeferenced and a set of environmental and climatic variables (wetlands and humid areas, normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), temperatures and elevation, migratory bird settlements) were used in the analysis. Areas, ecologically similar to those where human cases were detected, were identified using the Mahalanobis distance statistic. A leave-one-out cross-validation was performed to validate the sensitivity of the model, and 78 of 85 points were correctly classified.

First detection of co-circulation of West Nile and Usutu viruses in equids in the south-west of Tunisia

In the last fifteen years, West Nile Virus (WNV) has dramatically expanded its geographic range and is now considered the most widespread arbovirus in the world. In Tunisia, West Nile Fever (WNF) outbreaks were reported in humans in 1997, 2003 and 2012. Usutu Virus (USUV), which is a 'new' emerging Flavivirus antigenically close to WNV, has never been reported in Tunisia. A serological investigation in 284 equids was conducted in 2012 in the southern west region of the country to assess the presence and prevalence of the WNV and USUV infection. Of the 284 samples tested by competitive enzyme-linked immunoassay, 129 were positive. Of these, 120 (42.3%) had WNV-specific neutralizing antibodies. The prevalence was significantly higher in areas closer to the oasis compared with that of the surrounding arid areas. Antibody titres against USUV were also reported in 10 equids. This was the first evidence of USUV circulation in Tunisia. Data recorded by this study indicate that WNV and USUV have circulated/are circulating in the region and that there is an urgent need to adapt the current surveillance programmes to this new scenario.

An indirect ELISA for the detection of antibody in milk from sheep experimentally infected with Brucella melitensis biovar 3

An indirect ELISA was evaluated for the detection of Brucella antibodies in milk (m-ELISA) from sheep experimentally infected with B. melitensis biovar 3. At the end of the second reproductive cycle (13 months post infection), the milk of 22 lactating sheep was tested using the m-ELISA. Sera from the same sheep were also tested for Brucella antibodies using the Rose Bengal test (RBT) and the complement fixation test (CFT). The first serum sampling after parturition showed 100% sensitivity in both the RBT and the CFT (confidence interval [CI] 94-100%), but in subsequent samplings the sensitivity of the RBT decreased to 73% (CI 55-85%). Similarly, the sensitivity of the CFT decreased two months after the first sampling, when respective sensitivities of 95% (CI 81-98%) and 81% (CI 61-93%) were recorded for the final two samplings. The sensitivity of the m-ELISA decreased initially (68% on the third sampling, CI 50-81%), but then increased to 95% (CI 81-98%) for the final sampling. When disease prevalence in a flock is below 5%, the estimated probability of not detecting an infected flock through m-ELISA bulk milk testing is over 25%. Under field conditions in Italy (average sheep flock size of 70), the probability that the infection will not be detected is over 25% when four (or less) infected milking sheep are present in the flock. The results show that the m-ELISA is not a reliable screening test for bulk milk samples when the prevalence of brucellosis in a sheep flock is low.

Reliability evaluation of sampling plan fixed by Council Directive 91/68/EEC for the maintenance of officially brucellosis-free flock status

The European Union (EU) strategy with respect to sheep and goat brucellosis aims to eradicate the infection and achieve officially brucellosis-free (OBF) status in all EU holdings and territories. Council Directive 91/68/EEC of 28 January 1991 states that to maintain OBF status of ovine or caprine holdings located outside an OBF territory, only a representative number of animals need to be tested annually. However, depending on the number of animals in a holding, this testing method risks non-detection of the infection, thereby reducing the efficacy of the brucellosis control plan. The recommended sampling procedure has a low sensitivity for detecting infection in medium-sized flocks; furthermore, the risk of not detecting re-infection in OBF flocks, particularly in territories that have not yet gained OBF status, is also not acceptable. Moreover, in large-sized flocks, the Directive sampling procedure entails taking an excessive number of samples, which can be very expensive. The authors evaluated, by using statistical analyses and a simulation model based on field data, the possible consequences of the current EU strategy. It is suggested that the sampling criteria for the maintenance of OBF status in the EU should be modified and that a statistically based sampling method should be applied instead of the fixed percentage method that is currently in use.

The Persistence of Brucella melitensis in Experimentally Infected Ewes Through Three Reproductive Cycles

The authors studied the persistence of infection in 46 ewes experimentally infected with Brucella melitensis biovar 3 and monitored through three subsequent reproductive cycles. The entire experimental period lasted for 151 weeks. Infection of ewes and elimination of Brucella in milk, or its presence in vaginal discharges, persisted throughout the duration of the trial, as demonstrated by recurrent elimination of Brucella in milk and vaginal discharges. Brucella melitensis was recovered from the tissues of one ewe killed at the end of the trial. The strain was recovered from vaginal swabs and milk following parturition in the third reproductive cycle from an ewe that had aborted in the first cycle but was not pregnant in the second cycle. From a public health point of view, the periodical recovery of Brucella from the milk during the entire trial period illustrated that brucellosis in sheep remains a continuous occupational risk and a significant public health problem for consumers of fresh milk and milk products. That risk may persist for at least 3 years following the initial infection of the flock. Lamb antibody titres became negative in all lambs within 5 months after birth. This suggested that serological tests on lambs may have no practical diagnostic significance if performed during the first 5 months of life. Nevertheless, the birth of three infected lambs suggested that the phenomenon of latent carrier state may represent another way for B. melitensis to persist in a flock.

Use of the complement fixation and brucellin skin tests to identify cattle vaccinated with Brucella abortus strain RB51

In the European Union, RB51 vaccine can be used only under strictly controlled conditions for the immunisation of cattle at risk of infection with Brucella abortus. A test is therefore necessary to distinguish vaccinated from unvaccinated animals. The complement fixation test with RB51 antigen (RB51-CFT), dot-blot and gamma-interferon used to identify vaccinated animals have been described, but sensitivity of the tests has been poor and positivity transient after calfhood vaccination. To avail of a rapid and accurate diagnostic tool, the authors produced, controlled and evaluated an experimental brucellin prepared from strain RB51 (RB51 brucellin). The potency of this brucellin was evaluated in guinea-pigs sensitised with RB51 and compared with a commercially available brucellin. Both allergens produced similar biological activity in guinea-pigs. The RB51 brucellin skin test was performed in 10 cattle 414 days after calfhood vaccination with RB51 when they were negative to the RB51-CFT. The skin test revealed 60% sensitivity (with a confidence interval of 95%, CI 30.8%-83.3%) and 100% specificity (CI 60.7%-100%). These findings limit the use of the skin test only for screening to detect RB51 vaccinated herds, not individual animals. Nevertheless, following intradermal inoculation of RB51 brucellin, a transient antibody increase to the RB51-CFT was observed, from day 9 to day 20 post inoculation with RB51 brucellin. This transient antibody increase, when evaluated in parallel with the RB51 brucellin skin test results, enables detection of individual vaccinated animals (sensitivity 100%; CI 76.2%-100%).

Correlation between animal and human brucellosis in Italy during the period 1997-2002

The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that brucellosis in Italy is a food-borne, rather than an occupational disease. This hypothesis was tested using data for both human and animal populations from the period 1997-2002. The correlation between the distribution of the disease in the human, sheep and goat populations was analysed, as were the risk factors for the disease, with respect to gender, age, occupation and residence of the individuals involved. Notifications of human brucellosis, which are mandatory in Italy, reach a peak between April and June. However, considering the standard incubation period of 2-4 weeks, and the fact that lamb slaughter is traditionally at a peak during the Easter period, it might be expected that occupational exposure would result in a peak of human cases between March and May. The observed peak between April and June could be related to the production and consumption of fresh cheese, starting just after lamb slaughter. The age of patients showed a fairly uniform distribution, and analysis of incidence rates of human brucellosis between 1997 and 2002 showed that the incidence rates were consistent with an occupational exposure risk of about 25%.

Evaluation of an indirect ELISA for the detection of Brucella antibodies in cow's milk

An indirect ELISA was developed by the Istituto Zooprofilattico Sperimentale dell'Abruzzo e del Molise 'G. Caporale' (IZS A&M) for the detection of Brucella antibodies in cow's milk. Specific monoclonal antibody was used against a bovine IgG(1) epitope and complies with European Commission requirements. The test accuracy was evaluated on milk samples from the regions of Abruzzo and Molise in Italy. The negative samples came from 1,250 officially brucellosis-free herds from the Molise region (Italy). The positive samples were taken from three herds in the Abruzzo and Molise regions where animals positive to the official tests were present and Brucella abortus was isolated. Test specificity was 99.8% (with a confidence interval [CI] of 99.6%-99.9%), while sensitivity was 100% (CI 91.2%-100%). The probability of detecting antibodies in positive milk samples was higher than 50% up to a dilution of 1:256 in negative milk. The probability of identifying an infected herd in the dairy cattle population. Under study was 88.6% (CI 73.9%-95.3%).

Kinetics of the antibody response in ewes experimentally infected with Brucella melitensis biovar 3

The authors evaluated the kinetics of antibody response in 46 ewes coming from officially brucellosis free flocks that were experimentally infected with Brucella melitensis biovar 3, and monitored through three subsequent reproductive cycles. In this study, results of Rose Bengal test (RBT) and complement fixation test (CFT) were considered. Test results of 2nd and 3rd reproductive cycle show a peak in the antibody production at parturition, followed by a drop in the following months. The peak at parturition is significantly lower in the 3rd reproductive cycle compared to the 2nd. The drop in antibody production observed after parturition of the 3rd reproductive cycle is significantly higher than that observed after parturition of the 2nd reproductive cycle. Nevertheless, the infection can still be revealed at flock level after three years post infection.