Discovery, implications and initial use of semi-synthetic organisms with an expanded genetic alphabet/code

Much recent interest has focused on developing proteins for human use, such as in medicine. However, natural proteins are made up of only a limited number of canonical amino acids with limited functionalities, and this makes the discovery of variants with some functions difficult. The ability to recombinantly express proteins containing non-canonical amino acids (ncAAs) with properties selected to impart the protein with desired properties is expected to dramatically improve the discovery of proteins with different functions. Perhaps the most straightforward approach to such an expansion of the genetic code is through expansion of the genetic alphabet, so that new codon/anticodon pairs can be created to assign to ncAAs. In this review, I briefly summarize more than 20 years of effort leading ultimately to the discovery of synthetic nucleotides that pair to form an unnatural base pair, which when incorporated into DNA, is stably maintained, transcribed and used to translate proteins in Escherichia coli. In addition to discussing wide ranging conceptual implications, I also describe ongoing efforts at the pharmaceutical company Sanofi to employ the resulting 'semi-synthetic organisms' or SSOs, for the production of next-generation protein therapeutics. This article is part of the theme issue 'Reactivity and mechanism in chemical and synthetic biology'.

Creation, Optimization, and Use of Semi-Synthetic Organisms that Store and Retrieve Increased Genetic Information

With few exceptions, natural proteins are built from only 20 canonical (proteogenic) amino acids which limits the functionality and accordingly the properties they can possess. Genetic code expansion, i.e. the creation of codons and the machinery needed to assign them to non-canonical amino acids (ncAAs), promises to enable the discovery of proteins with novel properties that are otherwise difficult or impossible to obtain. One approach to expanding the genetic code is to expand the genetic alphabet via the development of unnatural nucleotides that pair to form an unnatural base pair (UBP). Semi-synthetic organisms (SSOs), i.e. organisms that stably maintain the UBP, transcribe its component nucleotides into RNA, and use it to translate proteins, would have available to them new codons and the anticodons needed to assign them to ncAAs. This review summarizes the development of a family of UBPs, their use to create SSOs, and the optimization and application of the SSOs to produce candidate therapeutic proteins with improved properties that are now undergoing evaluation in clinical trials.

Efforts toward Further Integration of an Unnatural Base Pair into the Biology of a Semisynthetic Organism

We have developed semisynthetic organisms (SSOs) that by virtue of a family of synthetic, unnatural base pairs (UBPs), store and retrieve increased information. To date, transcription in the SSOs has relied on heterologous expression of the RNA polymerase from T7 bacteriophage; here, we explore placing transcription under the control of the endogenous host multisubunit RNA polymerase. The results demonstrate that the E. coli RNA polymerase is able to transcribe DNA containing a UBP and that with the most optimal UBP identified to date it should be possible to select for increased uptake of unnatural triphosphates. These advances should facilitate the creation of next generation SSOs.

Transcription and Reverse Transcription of an Expanded Genetic Alphabet In Vitro and in a Semisynthetic Organism

Through the development of unnatural base pairs that are compatible with native DNA and RNA polymerases and the ribosome, we have expanded the genetic alphabet and enabled in vitro and in vivo production of proteins containing noncanonical amino acids. However, the absence of assays to characterize transcription has prevented the deconvolution of the contributions of transcription and translation to the reduced performance of some unnatural codons. Here we show that RNA containing the unnatural nucleotides is efficiently reverse transcribed into cDNA, and we develop an assay to measure the combined fidelity of transcription and reverse transcription. With this assay, we examine the performance of a wide variety of unnatural codons, both in vitro and in the in vivo environment of a semisynthetic organism. We find that transcription is generally efficient, decoding at the ribosome is generally more challenging, and, correspondingly, sequence-dependent translation efficiency is the origin of variable codon performance.

Initial Analysis of the Arylomycin D Antibiotics

The arylomycins are a class of natural product antibiotics that inhibit bacterial type I signal peptidase and are under development as therapeutics. Four classes of arylomycins are known, arylomycins A-D. Previously, we reported the synthesis and analysis of representatives of the A, B, and C classes and showed that their spectrum of activity has the potential to be much broader than originally assumed. Along with a comparison of the mechanism of acquired and innate resistance, this led us to suggest that the arylomycins are latent antibiotics, antibiotics that once possessed broad-spectrum activity, but which upon examination today, have only narrow spectrum activity due to prior selection for resistance in the course of the competition with other microorganisms that drove their evolution in the first place. Interestingly, actinocarbasin, the only identified member of the arylomycin D class, has been reported to have activity against MRSA. To confirm and understand this activity, several actinocarbasin derivatives were synthesized. We demonstrate that the previously reported structure of actinocarbasin is incorrect, identify what is likely the correct scaffold, confirm that scaffold has activity against MRSA, and determine the origin of this activity.

Nanopore Sequencing of an Expanded Genetic Alphabet Reveals High-Fidelity Replication of a Predominantly Hydrophobic Unnatural Base Pair

Unnatural base pairs (UBPs) have been developed and used for a variety of in vitro applications as well as for the engineering of semisynthetic organisms (SSOs) that store and retrieve increased information. However, these applications are limited by the availability of methods to rapidly and accurately determine the sequence of unnatural DNA. Here we report the development and application of the MspA nanopore to sequence DNA containing the dTPT3-dNaM UBP. Analysis of two sequence contexts reveals that DNA containing the UBP is replicated with an efficiency and fidelity similar to that of natural DNA and sufficient for use as the basis of an SSO that produces proteins with noncanonical amino acids.

Selection of Aptamers with Large Hydrophobic 2'-Substituents

Previously, we evolved a DNA polymerase, SFM4-3, for the recognition of substrates modified at their 2' positions with a fluoro, O-methyl, or azido substituent. Here we use SFM4-3 to synthesize 2'-azido-modified DNA; we then use the azido group to attach different, large hydrophobic groups via click chemistry. We show that SFM4-3 recognizes the modified templates under standard conditions, producing natural DNA and thereby allowing amplification. To demonstrate the utility of this remarkable property, we use SFM4-3 to select aptamers with large hydrophobic 2' substituents that bind human neutrophil elastase or the blood coagulation protein factor IXa. The results indicate that SFM4-3 should facilitate the discovery of aptamers that adopt novel and perhaps more protein-like folds with hydrophobic cores that in turn allow them to access novel activities.

Progress toward Eukaryotic Semisynthetic Organisms: Translation of Unnatural Codons

We have created a bacterial semisynthetic organism (SSO) that retains an unnatural base pair (UBP) in its DNA, transcribes it into mRNA and tRNA with cognate unnatural codons and anticodons, and after the tRNA is charged with a noncanonical amino acid synthesizes proteins containing the noncanonical amino acid. Here, we report the first progress toward the creation of eukaryotic SSOs. After demonstrating proof-of-concept with human HEK293 cells, we show that a variety of different unnatural codon-anticodon pairs can efficiently mediate the synthesis of unnatural proteins in CHO cells. Interestingly, we find that there are both similarities and significant differences between how the prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes recognize the UBP, with the eukaryotic ribosome appearing more tolerant. The results represent the first progress toward eukaryotic SSOs and, in fact, suggest that such SSOs might be able to retain more unnatural information than their bacterial counterparts.

Site-Specific Labeling of DNA via PCR with an Expanded Genetic Alphabet

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is a universal and essential tool in molecular biology and biotechnology, but it is generally limited to the amplification of DNA with the four-letter genetic alphabet. Here, we describe PCR amplification with a six-letter alphabet that includes the two natural dA-dT and dG-dC base pairs and an unnatural base pair (UBP) formed between the synthetic nucleotides dNaM and d5SICS or dTPT3 or analogs of these synthetic nucleotides modified with linkers that allow for the site-specific labeling of the amplified DNA with different functional groups. Under standard conditions, the six-letter DNA may be amplified with high efficiency and with greater than 99.9% fidelity. This allows for the efficient production of DNA site-specifically modified with different functionalities of interest for use in a wide range of applications.

Structure and Dynamics of Stacking Interactions in an Antibody Binding Site

For years, antibodies (Abs) have been used as a paradigm for understanding how protein structure contributes to molecular recognition. However, with the ability to evolve Abs that recognize specific chromophores, they also have great potential as models for how protein dynamics contribute to molecular recognition. We previously raised murine Abs to different chromophores and, with the use of three-pulse photon echo peak shift spectroscopy, demonstrated that the immune system is capable of producing Abs with widely varying flexibility. We now report the characterization of the complexes formed between two Abs, 5D11 and 10A6, and the chromophoric ligand that they were evolved to recognize, 8-methoxypyrene-1,3,6-trisulfonic acid (MPTS). The sequences of the Ab genes indicate that they evolved from a common precursor. We also used a variety of spectroscopic methods to probe the photophysics and dynamics of the Ab-MPTS complexes and found that they are similar to each other but distinct from previously characterized anti-MPTS Abs. Structural studies revealed that this difference likely results from a unique mode of binding in which MPTS is sandwiched between the side chain of Phe^H98, which interacts with the chromophore via T-stacking, and the side chain of Trp^L91, which interacts with the chromophore via parallel stacking. The T-stacking interaction appears to mediate relaxation on the picosecond time scale, while the parallel stacking appears to mediate relaxation on an ultrafast, femtosecond time scale, which dominates the response. The anti-MPTS Abs thus not only demonstrate the simultaneous use of the two limiting modes of stacking for molecular recognition, but also provide a unique opportunity to characterize how dynamics might contribute to molecular recognition. Both types of stacking are common in proteins and protein complexes where they may similarly contribute to dynamics and molecular recognition.

Optimization of Replication, Transcription, and Translation in a Semi-Synthetic Organism

Previously, we reported the creation of a semi-synthetic organism (SSO) that stores and retrieves increased information by virtue of stably maintaining an unnatural base pair (UBP) in its DNA, transcribing the corresponding unnatural nucleotides into the codons and anticodons of mRNAs and tRNAs, and then using them to produce proteins containing noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs). Here we report a systematic extension of the effort to optimize the SSO by exploring a variety of deoxy- and ribonucleotide analogues. Importantly, this includes the first in vivo structure-activity relationship (SAR) analysis of unnatural ribonucleoside triphosphates. Similarities and differences between how DNA and RNA polymerases recognize the unnatural nucleotides were observed, and remarkably, we found that a wide variety of unnatural ribonucleotides can be efficiently transcribed into RNA and then productively and selectively paired at the ribosome to mediate the synthesis of proteins with ncAAs. The results extend previous studies, demonstrating that nucleotides bearing no significant structural or functional homology to the natural nucleotides can be efficiently and selectively paired during replication, to include each step of the entire process of information storage and retrieval. From a practical perspective, the results identify the most optimal UBP for replication and transcription, as well as the most optimal unnatural ribonucleoside triphosphates for transcription and translation. The optimized SSO is now, for the first time, able to efficiently produce proteins containing multiple, proximal ncAAs.

Eight-Letter DNA

Steve Benner and collaborators have recently reported an analysis of DNA containing eight nucleotide letters, the four natural letters (dG, dC, dA, and dT) and four additional letters (dP, dZ, dS, and dB). Their analysis demonstrates that the additional letters do not perturb the structure or stability of the base pairs formed between the natural letters and, remarkably, that the new base pairs, dP-dZ and dS-dB, behave virtually identically to the natural base pairs. This unprecedented result convincingly demonstrates that the thermodynamic and structural behavior previously thought to be the purview of only natural DNA is in fact not unique and can be imparted to suitably designed synthetic components. In addition, the first evidence that the eight-letter DNA can be transcribed into RNA by a mutant RNA polymerase is presented, paving the way for the transfer of more information from one biopolymer to another. Along with others working to develop unnatural DNA base pairs for both in vitro and in vivo applications, this work represents an important step toward the expansion of the genetic alphabet, a central goal of synthetic biology, and has profound implications for our understanding of the molecules and forces that can make life possible.

Progress Toward a Semi-Synthetic Organism with an Unrestricted Expanded Genetic Alphabet

We have developed a family of unnatural base pairs (UBPs), exemplified by the pair formed between dNaM and dTPT3, for which pairing is mediated not by complementary hydrogen bonding but by hydrophobic and packing forces. These UBPs enabled the creation of the first semisynthetic organisms (SSOs) that store increased genetic information and use it to produce proteins containing noncanonical amino acids. However, retention of the UBPs was poor in some sequence contexts. Here, to optimize the SSO, we synthesize two novel benzothiophene-based dNaM analogs, dPTMO and dMTMO, and characterize the corresponding UBPs, dPTMO-dTPT3 and dMTMO-dTPT3. We demonstrate that these UBPs perform similarly to, or slightly worse than, dNaM-dTPT3 in vitro. However, in the in vivo environment of an SSO, retention of dMTMO-dTPT3, and especially dPTMO-dTPT3, is significantly higher than that of dNaM-dTPT3. This more optimal in vivo retention results from better replication, as opposed to more efficient import of the requisite unnatural nucleoside triphosphates. Modeling studies suggest that the more optimal replication results from specific internucleobase interactions mediated by the thiophene sulfur atoms. Finally, we show that dMTMO and dPTMO efficiently template the transcription of RNA containing TPT3 and that their improved retention in DNA results in more efficient production of proteins with noncanonical amino acids. This is the first instance of using performance within the SSO as part of the UBP evaluation and optimization process. From a general perspective, the results demonstrate the importance of evaluating synthetic biology "parts" in their in vivo context and further demonstrate the ability of hydrophobic and packing interactions to replace the complementary hydrogen bonding that underlies the replication of natural base pairs. From a more practical perspective, the identification of dMTMO-dTPT3 and especially dPTMO-dTPT3 represents significant progress toward the development of SSOs with an unrestricted ability to store and retrieve increased information.

Expansion of the genetic code via expansion of the genetic alphabet

Current methods to expand the genetic code enable site-specific incorporation of non-canonical amino acids (ncAAs) into proteins in eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells. However, current methods are limited by the number of codons possible, their orthogonality, and possibly their effects on protein synthesis and folding. An alternative approach relies on unnatural base pairs to create a virtually unlimited number of genuinely new codons that are efficiently translated and highly orthogonal because they direct ncAA incorporation using forces other than the complementary hydrogen bonds employed by their natural counterparts. This review outlines progress and achievements made towards developing a functional unnatural base pair and its use to generate semi-synthetic organisms with an expanded genetic alphabet that serves as the basis of an expanded genetic code.

Optimization of a β-Lactam Scaffold for Antibacterial Activity via the Inhibition of Bacterial Type I Signal Peptidase

β-Lactam antibiotics, one of the most important class of human therapeutics, act via the inhibition of penicillin-binding proteins (PBPs). The unparalleled success in their development has inspired efforts to develop them as inhibitors of other targets. Bacterial type I signal peptidase is evolutionarily related to the PBPs, but the stereochemistry of its substrates and its catalytic mechanism suggest that β-lactams with the 5S stereochemistry, as opposed to the 5R stereochemistry of the traditional β-lactams, would be required for inhibition. We report the synthesis and evaluation of a variety of 5S penem derivatives and identify several with promising activity against both a Gram-positive and a Gram-negative bacterial pathogen. To our knowledge these are the first 5S β-lactams to possess significant antibacterial activity and the first β-lactams imparted with antibacterial activity via optimization of the inhibition of a target other than a PBP. Along with the privileged status of their scaffold and the promise of bacterial signal peptidase I (SPase) as a target, this activity makes these compounds promising leads for development as novel therapeutics.

Expansion of the Genetic Alphabet: A Chemist's Approach to Synthetic Biology

The information available to any organism is encoded in a four nucleotide, two base pair genetic code. Since its earliest days, the field of synthetic biology has endeavored to impart organisms with novel attributes and functions, and perhaps the most fundamental approach to this goal is the creation of a fifth and sixth nucleotide that pair to form a third, unnatural base pair (UBP) and thus allow for the storage and retrieval of increased information. Achieving this goal, by definition, requires synthetic chemistry to create unnatural nucleotides and a medicinal chemistry-like approach to guide their optimization. With this perspective, almost 20 years ago we began designing unnatural nucleotides with the ultimate goal of developing UBPs that function in vivo, and thus serve as the foundation of semi-synthetic organisms (SSOs) capable of storing and retrieving increased information. From the beginning, our efforts focused on the development of nucleotides that bear predominantly hydrophobic nucleobases and thus that pair not based on the complementary hydrogen bonds that are so prominent among the natural base pairs but rather via hydrophobic and packing interactions. It was envisioned that such a pairing mechanism would provide a basal level of selectivity against pairing with natural nucleotides, which we expected would be the greatest challenge; however, this choice mandated starting with analogs that have little or no homology to their natural counterparts and that, perhaps not surprisingly, performed poorly. Progress toward their optimization was driven by the construction of structure–activity relationships, initially from in vitro steady-state kinetic analysis, then later from pre-steady-state and PCR-based assays, and ultimately from performance in vivo, with the results augmented three times with screens that explored combinations of the unnatural nucleotides that were too numerous to fully characterize individually. The structure–activity relationship data identified multiple features required by the UBP, and perhaps most prominent among them was a substituent ortho to the glycosidic linkage that is capable of both hydrophobic packing and hydrogen bonding, and nucleobases that stably stack with flanking natural nucleobases in lieu of the potentially more stabilizing stacking interactions afforded by cross strand intercalation. Most importantly, after the examination of hundreds of unnatural nucleotides and thousands of candidate UBPs, the efforts ultimately resulted in the identification of a family of UBPs that are well recognized by DNA polymerases when incorporated into DNA and that have been used to create SSOs that store and retrieve increased information. In addition to achieving a longstanding goal of synthetic biology, the results have important implications for our understanding of both the molecules and forces that can underlie biological processes, so long considered the purview of molecules benefiting from eons of evolution, and highlight the promise of applying the approaches and methodologies of synthetic and medical chemistry in the pursuit of synthetic biology.

Scalable Access to Arylomycins via C-H Functionalization Logic

Arylomycins are a promising class of “latent” antibacterial natural products currently in preclinical development. Access to analogues within this family has previously required a lengthy route involving multiple functional group manipulations that is costly and time-intensive on scale. This study presents a simplified route predicated on simple C–H functionalization logic that is enabled by a Cu-mediated oxidative phenol coupling that mimics the putative biosynthesis. This operationally simple macrocyclization is the largest of its kind and can be easily performed on gram scale. The application of this new route to a formal synthesis of the natural product and a collection of new analogues along with their biological evaluation is also reported.

A Tool for the Import of Natural and Unnatural Nucleoside Triphosphates into Bacteria

Nucleoside triphosphates play a central role in biology, but efforts to study these roles have proven difficult because the levels of triphosphates are tightly regulated in a cell and because individual triphosphates can be difficult to label or modify. In addition, many synthetic biology efforts are focused on the development of unnatural nucleoside triphosphates that perform specific functions in the cellular environment. In general, both of these efforts would be facilitated by a general means to directly introduce desired triphosphates into cells. Previously, we demonstrated that recombinant expression of a nucleoside triphosphate transporter from Phaeodactylum tricornutum (PtNTT2) in Escherichia coli functions to import triphosphates that are added to the media. Here, to explore the generality and utility of this approach, we report a structure-activity relationship study of PtNTT2. Using a conventional competitive uptake inhibition assay, we characterize the effects of nucleobase, sugar, and triphosphate modification, and then develop an LC-MS/MS assay to directly measure the effects of the modifications on import. Lastly, we use the transporter to import radiolabeled or 2'-fluoro-modified triphosphates and quantify their incorporation into DNA and RNA. The results demonstrate the general utility of the PtNTT2-mediated import of natural or modified nucleoside triphosphates for different molecular or synthetic biology applications.

Reprograming the Replisome of a Semisynthetic Organism for the Expansion of the Genetic Alphabet

Semisynthetic organisms (SSOs) created from Escherichia coli can replicate a plasmid containing an unnatural base pair (UBP) formed between the synthetic nucleosides dNaM and dTPT3 (dNaM-dTPT3) when the corresponding unnatural triphosphates are imported via expression of a nucleoside triphosphate transporter. The UBP can also be transcribed and used to translate proteins containing unnatural amino acids. However, UBPs are not well retained in all sequences, limiting the information that can be encoded, and are invariably lost upon extended growth. Here we explore the contributions of the E. coli DNA replication and repair machinery to the propagation of DNA containing dNaM-dTPT3 and show that replication by DNA polymerase III, supplemented with the activity of polymerase II and methyl-directed mismatch repair contribute to retention of the UBP and that recombinational repair of stalled forks is responsible for the majority of its loss. This work elucidates fundamental aspects of how bacteria replicate DNA and we use this information to reprogram the replisome of the SSO for increased UBP retention, which then allowed for the first time the construction of SSOs harboring a UBP in their chromosome.

A semi-synthetic organism that stores and retrieves increased genetic information

Since at least the last common ancestor of all life on Earth, genetic information has been stored in a four-letter alphabet that is propagated and retrieved by the formation of two base pairs. The central goal of synthetic biology is to create new life forms and functions, and the most general route to this goal is the creation of semi-synthetic organisms whose DNA harbours two additional letters that form a third, unnatural base pair. Previous efforts to generate such semi-synthetic organisms culminated in the creation of a strain of Escherichia coli that, by virtue of a nucleoside triphosphate transporter from Phaeodactylum tricornutum, imports the requisite unnatural triphosphates from its medium and then uses them to replicate a plasmid containing the unnatural base pair dNaM-dTPT3. Although the semi-synthetic organism stores increased information when compared to natural organisms, retrieval of the information requires in vivo transcription of the unnatural base pair into mRNA and tRNA, aminoacylation of the tRNA with a non-canonical amino acid, and efficient participation of the unnatural base pair in decoding at the ribosome. Here we report the in vivo transcription of DNA containing dNaM and dTPT3 into mRNAs with two different unnatural codons and tRNAs with cognate unnatural anticodons, and their efficient decoding at the ribosome to direct the site-specific incorporation of natural or non-canonical amino acids into superfolder green fluorescent protein. The results demonstrate that interactions other than hydrogen bonding can contribute to every step of information storage and retrieval. The resulting semi-synthetic organism both encodes and retrieves increased information and should serve as a platform for the creation of new life forms and functions.

Synthetic Biology Parts for the Storage of Increased Genetic Information in Cells

To bestow cells with novel forms and functions, the goal of synthetic biology, we have developed the unnatural nucleoside triphosphates dNaMTP and dTPT3TP, which form an unnatural base pair (UBP) and expand the genetic alphabet. While the UBP may be retained in the DNA of a living cell, its retention is sequence-dependent. We now report a steady-state kinetic characterization of the rate with which the Klenow fragment of E. coli DNA polymerase I synthesizes the UBP and its mispairs in a variety of sequence contexts. Correct UBP synthesis is as efficient as for a natural base pair, except in one sequence context, and in vitro performance is correlated with in vivo performance. The data elucidate the determinants of efficient UBP synthesis, show that the dNaM-dTPT3 UBP is the first generally recognized natural-like base pair, and importantly, demonstrate that dNaMTP and dTPT3TP are well optimized and standardized parts for the expansion of the genetic alphabet.

Evolved polymerases facilitate selection of fully 2'-OMe-modified aptamers

Evolved DNA polymerases are used in selections with fully 2′-OMe modified libraries to identify aptamers with high affinity for HNE.

RNA or DNA aptamers with 2′-OMe-modifications have been pursued to increase resistance to nucleases, but have been difficult to identify because the OMe groups ablate polymerase recognition. We recently reported evolution of the thermostable DNA polymerases SFM4-6 and SFM4-9, which enable the efficient “transcription” and “reverse transcription”, respectively, of 2′-OMe oligonucleotides. With these polymerases, we now report the first selection of fully 2′-OMe modified aptamers, specifically aptamers that bind human neutrophil elastase (HNE). Two aptamers, 2mHNE-1 and 2mHNE-2, were isolated after five rounds of selection, and four more, 2mHNE-3–6, after an additional five rounds that included selection pressure for binding in the presence of serum. All six aptamers bind with reasonable affinity, which requires the 2′-OMe substituents. Further characterization of one aptamer, 2mHNE-5, showed that unlike a previously reported natural anti-HNE aptamer, affinity for HNE is retained in the presence of high concentrations of salt or serum. The polymerases SFM4-6 and SFM4-9 should prove valuable for the production and further exploration of modified aptamers.

Enzymatic Synthesis, Amplification, and Application of DNA with a Functionalized Backbone

The ability to amplify DNA along with its unprecedented sequence control has led to its use for different applications, but all are limited by the properties available to natural nucleotides. We previously reported the evolution of polymerase SFM4-3, which better tolerates 2'-modified substrates. To explore the utility of SFM4-3, we now report the characterization of its recognition of substrates with 2'-azido, 2'-chloro, 2'-amino, or arabinose sugars. We find that SFM4-3 can efficiently synthesize polymers composed of these nucleotides, and most interestingly, that SFM4-3 can also PCR amplify these modified oligonucleotides. When combined with post-amplification modification, the latter allows for the exponential amplification of polymers that may be functionalized with desired moieties arrayed in a controlled fashion, the utility of which we demonstrate with extensive small molecule functionalization and the production and initial characterization of a novel DNA hydrogel.

In Vivo Structure-Activity Relationships and Optimization of an Unnatural Base Pair for Replication in a Semi-Synthetic Organism

In an effort to expand the genetic alphabet and create semi-synthetic organisms (SSOs) that store and retrieve increased information, we have developed the unnatural base pairs (UBPs) dNaM and d5SICS or dTPT3 (dNaM-d5SICS and dNaM-dTPT3). The UBPs form based on hydrophobic and packing forces, as opposed to complementary hydrogen bonding, and while they are both retained within the in vivo environment of an Escherichia coli SSO, their development was based on structure-activity relationship (SAR) data generated in vitro. To address the likely possibility of different requirements of the in vivo environment, we screened 135 candidate UBPs for optimal performance in the SSO. Interestingly, we find that in vivo SARs differ from those collected in vitro, and most importantly, we identify four UBPs whose retention in the DNA of the SSO is higher than that of dNaM-dTPT3, which was previously the most promising UBP identified. The identification of these four UBPs further demonstrates that when optimized, hydrophobic and packing forces may be used to replace the complementary hydrogen bonding used by natural pairs and represents a significant advance in our continuing efforts to develop SSOs that store and retrieve more information than natural organisms.

Selection of 2'-Fluoro-Modified Aptamers with Optimized Properties

RNA or single-stranded DNA aptamers with 2'-F pyrimidines have been pursued to increase resistance to nucleases, and while it seems likely that these and other modifications, including the modification of purines, could be used to optimize additional properties, this has been much less explored because such aptamers are challenging to discover. Using a thermostable DNA polymerase, SFM4-3, which was previously evolved to accept nucleotides with 2'-modifications, we now report the selection of 2'-F purine aptamers that bind human neutrophil elastase (HNE). Two aptamers were identified, 2fHNE-1 and 2fHNE-2, that bind HNE with reasonable affinity. Interestingly, the 2'-F substituents facilitate the selection of specific interactions with HNE and overcome nonspecific electrostatic interactions that can otherwise dominate. The data demonstrate that inclusion of only a few 2'-F substituents can optimize properties far beyond simple nuclease resistance and that SFM4-3 should prove valuable for the further exploration and production of aptamers with properties optimized for various applications.

Chemical Stabilization of Unnatural Nucleotide Triphosphates for the in Vivo Expansion of the Genetic Alphabet

We have developed an unnatural base pair (UBP) and a semisynthetic organism (SSO) that imports the constituent unnatural nucleoside triphosphates and uses them to replicate DNA containing the UBP. However, propagation of the UBP is at least in part limited by the stability of the unnatural triphosphates, which are degraded by cellular and secreted phosphatases. To circumvent this problem, we now report the synthesis and evaluation of unnatural triphosphates with their β,γ-bridging oxygen replaced with a difluoromethylene moiety, yielding dNaMTP^CF2 and dTPT3TP^CF2. We find that although dNaMTP^CF2 cannot support in vivo replication, likely due to poor polymerase recognition, dTPT3TP^CF2 can, and moreover, its increased stability can contribute to increased UBP retention. The data demonstrate the promise of this chemical approach to SSO optimization, and suggest that other modifications should be sought that confer phosphatase resistance without interfering with polymerase recognition.

Not just an antibiotic target: Exploring the role of type I signal peptidase in bacterial virulence

The looming antibiotic crisis has prompted the development of new strategies towards fighting infection. Traditional antibiotics target bacterial processes essential for viability, whereas proposed antivirulence approaches rely on the inhibition of factors that are required only for the initiation and propagation of infection within a host. Although antivirulence compounds have yet to prove their efficacy in the clinic, bacterial signal peptidase I (SPase) represents an attractive target in that SPase inhibitors exhibit broad-spectrum antibiotic activity, but even at sub-MIC doses also impair the secretion of essential virulence factors. The potential consequences of SPase inhibition on bacterial virulence have not been thoroughly examined, and are explored within this review. In addition, we review growing evidence that SPase has relevant biological functions outside of mediating secretion, and discuss how the inhibition of these functions may be clinically significant.

The expanding world of DNA and RNA

DNA and RNA are remarkable because they can both encode information and possess desired properties, including the ability to bind specific targets or catalyze specific reactions. Nucleotide modifications that do not interfere with enzymatic synthesis are now being used to bestow DNA or RNA with properties that further increase their utility, including phosphate and sugar modifications that increase nuclease resistance, nucleobase modifications that increase the range of activities possible, and even whole nucleobase replacement that results in selective pairing and the creation of unnatural base pairs that increase the information content. These modifications are increasingly being applied both in vitro and in vivo, including in efforts to create semi-synthetic organisms with altered or expanded genetic alphabets.

FRET Characterization of Complex Conformational Changes in a Large 16S Ribosomal RNA Fragment Site-Specifically Labeled Using Unnatural Base Pairs

Ribosome assembly has been studied intensively using Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) with fluorophore-labeled fragments of RNA produced by chemical synthesis. However, these studies are limited by the size of the accessible RNA fragments. We have developed a replicable unnatural base pair (UBP) formed between (d)5SICS and (d)MMO2 or (d)NaM, which efficiently directs the transcription of RNA containing unnatural nucleotides. We now report the synthesis and evaluation of several of the corresponding ribotriphosphates bearing linkers that enable the chemoselective attachment of different functionalities. We found that the RNA polymerase from T7 bacteriophage does not incorporate NaM derivatives but does efficiently incorporate 5SICS(CO), whose linker enables functional group conjugation via Click chemistry, and when combined with the previously identified MMO2(A), whose amine side chains permits conjugation via NHS coupling chemistry, enables site-specific double labeling of transcribed RNA. To study ribosome assembly, we transcribed RNA corresponding to a 243-nt fragment of the central domain of Thermus thermophilus 16S rRNA containing 5SICS(CO) and MMO2(A) at defined locations and then site-specifically attached the fluorophores Cy3 and Cy5. FRET was characterized using single-molecule total internal reflection fluorescence (smTIRF) microscopy in the presence of various combinations of added ribosomal proteins. We demonstrate that each of the fragment's two three-helix junctions exist in open and closed states, with the latter favored by sequential protein binding. These results elucidate early and previously uncharacterized folding events underlying ribosome assembly and demonstrate the applicability of UBPs for biochemical, structural, and functional studies of RNAs.

Evolution of thermophilic DNA polymerases for the recognition and amplification of C2'-modified DNA

The PCR amplification of oligonucleotides enables the evolution of sequences called aptamers that bind specific targets with antibody-like affinity. However, the use of these aptamers is limited in many applications by nuclease-mediated degradation. In contrast, oligonucleotides that are modified at their sugar C2' positions with methoxy or fluorine substituents are stable to nucleases but cannot be synthesized by natural polymerases. Here, we report the development of a polymerase evolution system and its use to evolve thermostable polymerases that efficiently interconvert C2'-OMe modified oligonucleotides and their DNA counterparts via “transcription” and “reverse transcription,” or more importantly, PCR amplify partially C2'-OMe or C2'-F modified oligonucleotides. A mechanistic analysis demonstrates that the ability to amplify the modified oligonucleotides was evolved by optimizing interdomain interactions that stabilize the catalytically competent closed conformation of the polymerase. The evolved polymerases should find practical applications and the developed evolution system should be a powerful tool for the tailoring of polymerases to have other types of novel function.

The expanded genetic alphabet

All biological information, since the last common ancestor of all life on Earth, has been encoded by a genetic alphabet consisting of only four nucleotides that form two base pairs. Long-standing efforts to develop two synthetic nucleotides that form a third, unnatural base pair (UBP) have recently yielded three promising candidates, one based on alternative hydrogen bonding, and two based on hydrophobic and packing forces. All three of these UBPs are replicated and transcribed with remarkable efficiency and fidelity, and the latter two thus demonstrate that hydrogen bonding is not unique in its ability to underlie the storage and retrieval of genetic information. This Review highlights these recent developments as well as the applications enabled by the UBPs, including the expansion of the evolution process to include new functionality and the creation of semi-synthetic life that stores increased information.

The inhibition of type I bacterial signal peptidase: Biological consequences and therapeutic potential

The general secretory pathway has long been regarded as a potential antibiotic drug target. In particular, bacterial type I signal peptidase (SPase) is emerging as a strong candidate for therapeutic use. In this review, we focus on the information gained from the use of SPase inhibitors as probes of prokaryote biology. A thorough understanding of the consequences of SPase inhibition and the mechanisms of resistance that arise are essential to the success of SPase as an antibiotic target. In addition to the role of SPase in processing secreted proteins, the use of SPase inhibitors has elucidated a previously unknown function for SPase in regulating cleavage events of membrane proteins.

Adaptive mutations alter antibody structure and dynamics during affinity maturation

While adaptive mutations can bestow new functions on proteins via the introduction or optimization of reactive centers, or other structural changes, a role for the optimization of protein dynamics also seems likely but has been more difficult to evaluate. Antibody (Ab) affinity maturation is an example of adaptive evolution wherein the adaptive mutations may be identified and Abs may be raised to specific targets that facilitate the characterization of protein dynamics. Here, we report the characterization of three affinity matured Abs that evolved from a common germline precursor to bind the chromophoric antigen (Ag), 8-methoxypyrene-1,3,6-trisulfonate (MPTS). In addition to characterizing the sequence, molecular recognition, and structure of each Ab, we characterized the dynamics of each complex by determining their mechanical response to an applied force via three-pulse photon echo peak shift (3PEPS) spectroscopy and deconvoluting the response into elastic, anelastic, and plastic components. We find that for one Ab, affinity maturation was accomplished via the introduction of a single functional group that mediates a direct contact with MPTS and results in a complex with little anelasticity or plasticity. In the other two cases, more mutations were introduced but none directly contact MPTS, and while their effects on structure are subtle, their effects on anelasticity and plasticity are significant, with the level of plasticity correlated with specificity, suggesting that the optimization of protein dynamics may have contributed to affinity maturation. A similar optimization of structure and dynamics may contribute to the evolution of other proteins.

Axinellamines as broad-spectrum antibacterial agents: scalable synthesis and biology

Antibiotic-resistant bacteria present an ongoing challenge to both chemists and biologists as they seek novel compounds and modes of action to out-maneuver continually evolving resistance pathways, especially against Gram-negative strains. The dimeric pyrrole-imidazole alkaloids represent a unique marine natural product class with diverse primary biological activity and chemical architecture. This full account traces the strategy used to develop a second-generation route to key spirocycle 9, culminating in a practical synthesis of the axinellamines and enabling their discovery as broad-spectrum antibacterial agents, with promising activity against both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. While their detailed mode of antibacterial action remains unclear, the axinellamines appear to cause secondary membrane destabilization and impart an aberrant cellular morphology consistent with the inhibition of normal septum formation. This study serves as a rare example of a natural product initially reported to be devoid of biological activity surfacing as an active antibacterial agent with an intriguing mode of action.

Evidence of an unusual N-H···N hydrogen bond in proteins

Many residues within proteins adopt conformations that appear to be stabilized by interactions between an amide N-H and the amide N of the previous residue. To explore whether these interactions constitute hydrogen bonds, we characterized the IR stretching frequencies of deuterated variants of proline and the corresponding carbamate, as well as the four proline residues of an Src homology 3 domain protein. The CδD2 stretching frequencies are shifted to lower energies due to hyperconjugation with Ni electron density, and engaging this density via protonation or the formation of the Ni+1-H···Ni interaction ablates this hyperconjugation and thus induces an otherwise difficult to explain blue shift in the C-D absorptions. Along with density functional theory calculations, the data reveal that the Ni+1-H···Ni interactions constitute H-bonds and suggest that they may play an important and previously underappreciated role in protein folding, structure, and function.

Systematic exploration of a class of hydrophobic unnatural base pairs yields multiple new candidates for the expansion of the genetic alphabet

We have developed a family of unnatural base pairs (UBPs), which rely on hydrophobic and packing interactions for pairing and which are well replicated and transcribed. While the pair formed between d5SICS and dNaM (d5SICS-dNaM) has received the most attention, and has been used to expand the genetic alphabet of a living organism, recent efforts have identified dTPT3-dNaM, which is replicated with even higher fidelity. These efforts also resulted in more UBPs than could be independently analyzed, and thus we now report a PCR-based screen to identify the most promising. While we found that dTPT3-dNaM is generally the most promising UBP, we identified several others that are replicated nearly as well and significantly better than d5SICS-dNaM, and are thus viable candidates for the expansion of the genetic alphabet of a living organism. Moreover, the results suggest that continued optimization should be possible, and that the putatively essential hydrogen-bond acceptor at the position ortho to the glycosidic linkage may not be required. These results clearly demonstrate the generality of hydrophobic forces for the control of base pairing within DNA, provide a wealth of new structure–activity relationship data and importantly identify multiple new candidates for in vivo evaluation and further optimization.

A semi-synthetic organism with an expanded genetic alphabet

Organisms are defined by the information encoded in their genomes, and since the evolution of life, this information has been encoded using a two base pair genetic alphabet (A-T and G-C). In vitro, the alphabet has been expanded to include several unnatural base pairs (UBPs)^1–3. We have developed a class of UBPs formed between nucleotides bearing hydrophobic nucleobases, exemplified by the pair formed between d5SICS and dNaM (d5SICS-dNaM, Fig. 1a), which is efficiently PCR amplified¹ and transcribed^4,5in vitro, and whose unique mechanism of replication has been characterized^6,7. However, expansion of a organism’s genetic alphabet presents new and unprecedented challenges: the unnatural nucleoside triphosphates must enter the cell; endogenous polymerases must be able to faithfully incorporate the unnatural triphosphates into DNA within the complex cellular milieu; and finally, the UBP must be stable in the presence of pathways that maintain the integrity of DNA. Here we show that an exogenously expressed algal nucleotide triphosphate transporter efficiently imports the triphosphates of both d5SICS and dNaM (d5SICSTP and dNaMTP) into E. coli, and that the endogenous replication machinery uses them to accurately replicate a plasmid containing d5SICS-dNaM. Neither the presence of the unnatural triphosphates nor the replication of the UBP introduces a significant growth burden. Lastly, we find that the UBP is not efficiently excised by DNA repair pathways. Thus, the resulting bacterium is the first organism to stably propagate an expanded genetic alphabet.