Disparities in Deceased Donor Kidney Offer Acceptance: A Survey of Canadian Transplant Nephrologists, General Surgeons and Urologists

Background

Significant variability in organ acceptance thresholds have been demonstrated across the United States, but data regarding the rate and rationale for kidney donor organ decline in Canada are lacking.

Objective

To examine decision making regarding deceased kidney donor acceptance and non-acceptance in a population of Canadian transplant professionals.

Design

A survey study of theoretical deceased donor kidney cases of increasing complexity.

Setting

Canadian transplant nephrologists, urologists, and surgeons making donor call decisions responding to an electronic survey between July 22 and October 4, 2022.

Participants

Invitations to participate were distributed to 179 Canadian transplant nephrologists, surgeons, and urologists through e-mail. Participants were identified by contacting each transplant program and requesting a list of physicians who take donor call.

Measurements

Survey respondents were asked whether they would accept or decline a given donor, assuming there was a suitable recipient. They were also asked to cite reasons for donor non-acceptance.

Methods

Donor scenario-specific acceptance rates (total acceptance divided by total number of respondents for a given scenario and overall) and reasons for decline were determined and presented as a percentage of the total cases declined.

Results

In all, 72 respondents from 7 provinces completed at least one question of the survey, with considerable variability between acceptance rates for centers; the most conservative center declined 60.9% of donor cases, whereas the most aggressive center declined only 28.1%, P-value < .001. There was an increased risk of non-acceptance with advancing age, donation after cardiac death, acute kidney injury, chronic kidney disease, and comorbidities.

Limitations

As with any survey, there is the potential for participation bias. In addition, this study examines donor characteristics in isolation, however, asks respondent to assume there is a suitable candidate available. In reality, whenever donor quality is considered, it should be considered in the context of the intended recipient.

Conclusion

In a survey of increasingly medically complex deceased kidney donor cases, there was significant variability in donor decline among Canadian transplant specialists. Given relatively high rates of donor decline and apparent heterogeneity in acceptance decisions, Canadian transplant specialists may benefit from additional education regarding the benefits achieved from even medically complex kidney donors for appropriate candidates relative to remaining on dialysis on the transplant waitlist.

The impact of repeated mismatches in kidney transplantations performed after nonrenal solid organ transplantation

The aim of this study was to determine whether kidney transplantations performed after previous nonrenal solid organ transplants are associated with worse graft survival when there are repeated HLA mismatches (RMM) with the previous donor(s). We performed a retrospective cohort study using data from the Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients. Our cohort comprised 6624 kidney transplantations performed between January 1, 1990 and January 1, 2015. All patients had previously received 1 or more nonrenal solid organ transplants. RMM were observed in 35.3% of kidney transplantations and 3012 grafts were lost over a median follow-up of 5.4 years. In multivariate Cox regression analyses, we found no association between overall graft survival and either RMM in class 1 (hazard ratio [HR]: 0.97, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.89-1.07) or class 2 (HR: 0.95, 95% CI 0.85-1.06). Results were similar for the associations between RMM, death-censored graft survival, and patient survival. Our results suggest that the presence of RMM with previous donor(s) does not have an important impact on allograft survival in kidney transplant recipients who have previously received a nonrenal solid organ transplant.

Anti-LG3 Antibodies Aggravate Renal Ischemia-Reperfusion Injury and Long-Term Renal Allograft Dysfunction

Pretransplant autoantibodies to LG3 and angiotensin II type 1 receptors (AT1R) are associated with acute rejection in kidney transplant recipients, whereas antivimentin autoantibodies participate in heart transplant rejection. Ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI) can modify self-antigenic targets. We hypothesized that ischemia-reperfusion creates permissive conditions for autoantibodies to interact with their antigenic targets and leads to enhanced renal damage and dysfunction. In 172 kidney transplant recipients, we found that pretransplant anti-LG3 antibodies were associated with an increased risk of delayed graft function (DGF). Pretransplant anti-LG3 antibodies are inversely associated with graft function at 1 year after transplantation in patients who experienced DGF, independent of rejection. Pretransplant anti-AT1R and antivimentin were not associated with DGF or its functional outcome. In a model of renal IRI in mice, passive transfer of anti-LG3 IgG led to enhanced dysfunction and microvascular injury compared with passive transfer with control IgG. Passive transfer of anti-LG3 antibodies also favored intrarenal microvascular complement activation, microvascular rarefaction and fibrosis after IRI. Our results suggest that anti-LG3 antibodies are novel aggravating factors for renal IRI. These results provide novel insights into the pathways that modulate the severity of renal injury at the time of transplantation and their impact on long-term outcomes.

Antiperlecan antibodies are novel accelerators of immune-mediated vascular injury

Acute vascular rejection (AVR) is characterized by immune-mediated vascular injury and heightened endothelial cell (EC) apoptosis. We reported previously that apoptotic ECs release a bioactive C-terminal fragment of perlecan referred to as LG3. Here, we tested the possibility that LG3 behaves as a neoantigen, fuelling the production of anti-LG3 antibodies of potential importance in regulating allograft vascular injury. We performed a case-control study in which we compared anti-LG3 IgG titers in kidney transplant recipients with AVR (n=15) versus those with acute tubulo-interstitial rejection (ATIR) (n=15) or stable graft function (n=30). Patients who experienced AVR had elevated anti-LG3 titers pre and posttransplantation compared to subjects with ATIR or stable graft function (p<0.05 for both mediators). Elevated pretransplant anti-LG3 titers (OR: 4.62, 95% CI: 1.08-19.72) and pretransplant donor-specific antibodies (DSA) (OR 4.79, 95% CI: 1.03-22.19) were both independently associated with AVR. To address the functional role of anti-LG3 antibodies in AVR, we turned to passive transfer of anti-LG3 antibodies in an animal model of vascular rejection based on orthotopic aortic transplantation between fully MHC-mismatched mice. Neointima formation, C4d deposition and allograft inflammation were significantly increased in recipients of an ischemic aortic allograft passively transferred with anti-LG3 antibodies. Collectively, these data identify anti-LG3 antibodies as novel accelerators of immune-mediated vascular injury and obliterative remodeling.

Total cholesterol correlates with cyclosporine C2 levels in kidney transplant recipients under maintenance immunosuppression

The aim of this study was to assess the relationship between cyclosporine (CyA) trough level (C0) and 2-hour postdose (C2) and total cholesterol (TC) in kidney transplant (KT) recipients on Neoral maintenance immunosuppression. In KT recipients who had more than 5 years of follow-up, stable graft function, and stable Neoral dose, we measured C2 and C0 blood levels, serum creatinine, mean total cholesterol (TC) over the last 5 years, prednisone dose, use of beta-blockers and thiazides. Correlations between C0 and C2 levels and TC were performed with the Pearson coefficient. Receiver operating characteristics (ROCs) were used to define the threshold with greater accuracy for significant variables at the correlation test. Statistical tests were performed with SPSS 9.5 The C2 correlated with TC (0.31; P=.008) whereas C0 did not. The C2 level was an independent predictor for TC after adjusting for recipient age, gender, dose of prednisone, creatinine clearance, and use of beta-blockers and thiazides (B coefficient=1.124(E-3); P=.009). A threshold C2 value of 700 microg/L yielded to a TC level of 5.2 mmol/L. This is the first study to report a correlation between C2 levels and TC. Although C2 explained a small fraction of TC variability, it is an independent predictor of TC in KT recipients on Neoral maintenance immunosuppression. A long-term C2 value under 700 microg correlates with better control of hypercholesterolemia.

Mechanisms responsible for endothelial dysfunction induced by fasting hyperhomocystinemia in normotensive subjects and patients with essential hypertension

OBJECTIVES

We sought to evaluate whether fasting hyperhomocystinemia reduces endothelial function by oxidative stress in normotensive subjects and hypertensive patients.

BACKGROUND

Subjects with hyperhomocystinemia have endothelial dysfunction.

METHODS

In 23 normotensive subjects and 28 hypertensive patients, classified into normohomocystinemic and hyperhomocystinemic groups according to homocysteine plasma levels (< 8.7 and >14.6 micromol/l, respectively), we studied forearm blood flow changes (strain-gauge plethysmography) induced by intrabrachial administration of acetylcholine (0.15 to 15 microg/100 ml tissue per min) or sodium nitroprusside (1 to 4 microg/100 ml per min), an endothelium-dependent and -independent vasodilator, respectively. Acetylcholine was repeated with N(G)-monomethyl-L-arginine (L-NMMA; 100 microg/100 ml per min), vitamin C (8 mg/100 ml per min) and L-NMMA plus vitamin C.

RESULTS

Normotensive hyperhomocystinemic patients showed a blunted response to acetylcholine and a lower inhibiting effect of L-NMMA on acetylcholine, as compared with normohomocystinemic patients. Although vitamin C was ineffective in normohomocystinemic subjects, it increased the response to acetylcholine and restored the inhibiting effect of L-NMMA on acetylcholine in hyperhomocystinemic patients. Hypertensive hyperhomocystinemic patients showed a reduced response to acetylcholine, as compared with normohomocystinemic subjects. In both subgroups, L-NMMA failed to blunt the response to acetylcholine. The potentiating effect of vitamin C on acetylcholine was greater in hyperhomocystinemic patients than in normohomocystinemic subjects, although it restored the inhibitory effect of L-NMMA on acetylcholine-induced vasodilation to the same extent in both groups. Hyperhomocystinemia did not change the response to sodium nitroprusside.

CONCLUSIONS

In normotensive subjects and hypertensive patients, hyperhomocystinemia impairs endothelium-dependent vasodilation. It could be related to oxidant activity.

Influence of glomerular filtration rate on non-(1-84) parathyroid hormone (PTH) detected by intact PTH assays

BACKGROUND

Commercial intact parathyroid hormone (I-PTH) assays detect molecular form(s) of human PTH, non-(1-84) PTH, different from the 84-amino acid native molecule. These molecular form(s) accumulate in hemodialyzed patients. We investigated the importance of non-(1-84) PTH in the interpretation of the increased I-PTH in progressive renal failure.

METHODS

Five groups were studied: 26 healthy individuals, 12 hemodialyzed patients, and 31 patients with progressive renal failure subdivided according to their glomerular filtration rate (GFR) into 11 with a GFR between 60 and 100 mL. min(-1). 1.73 m(-2), 12 with a GFR between 30 and 60 mL. min(-1). 1.73 m(-2), and 8 with a GFR between 5 and 30 mL. min(-1). 1.73 m(-2). We evaluated indicators of calcium and phosphorus metabolism and creatinine clearance (CrCl) in the progressive renal failure groups, and the HPLC profile of I-PTH and C-terminal PTH in all groups.

RESULTS

Only patients with a GFR <30 mL. min(-1). 1.73 m(-2) and hemodialyzed patients had decreased Ca(2+) and 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D, and increased phosphate. In patients with progressive renal failure, I-PTH was related to Ca(2+) (r = -0.66; P <0.0001), CrCl (r = -0.61; P <0.001), 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D (r = -0.40; P <0.05), and 25-hydroxyvitamin D (r = -0.49; P <0.01) by simple linear regression. The importance of non-(1-84) PTH in the composition of I-PTH increased with each GFR decrease, being 21% in healthy individuals, 32% in progressive renal failure patients with a GFR <30 mL. min(-1). 1.73 m(-2), and 50% in hemodialyzed patients, with PTH(1-84) making up the difference.

CONCLUSIONS

As I-PTH increases progressively with GFR decrease, part of the increase is associated with the accumulation of non-(1-84) PTH, particularly when the GFR is <30 mL. min(-1). 1.73 m(-2). Concentrations of I-PTH 1.6-fold higher than in healthy individuals are necessary in hemodialyzed patients to achieve PTH(1-84) concentrations similar to those in the absence of renal failure.

The set point of parathyroid hormone stimulation by calcium is normal in progressive renal failure

An increased set point of PTH stimulation by ionized calcium (Ca++) has been observed in renal failure patients with severe secondary hyperparathyroidism. The extension of this concept to all renal failure patients has remained problematic, even if it could explain elevated PTH levels in the absence of other biochemical abnormalities. We were particularly interested in seeing whether the concept could fit patients with progressive renal failure (PRF). To achieve this, we studied 26 normals (N), 9 patients with PRF, and 12 hemodialyzed patients (HD) in the basal state and during parathyroid function tests. The latter two groups were studied at the end of winter and end of summer, respectively. Patients with PRF had normal levels of Ca++, PO4, and 1,25(OH)2D, and they had low-normal concentrations of 25(OH)D; their basal I- and C-PTH levels were 3- and 4-fold higher than N, as were their creatinine levels. HD had significantly lower levels of Ca++ and 1,25(OH)2D, and they had higher levels of phosphate, creatinine, I-PTH, and C-PTH than N or PRF. Stimulated levels of I-PTH were similar in N (13.6 +/- 4.3 pmol/L) and PFR (18 +/- 3.3 pmol/L) and elevated in HD (37.1 +/- 28.7 pmol/L; P < 0.001 vs. N, and P < 0.05 vs. PRF). Nonsuppressible I-PTH was increased 2-fold in PRF (N = 0.64 +/- 0.19 vs. PRF = 1.28 +/- 0.46 pmol/L; P < 0.01) and 6-fold in HD (3.95 +/- 2.85 pmol/L; P < 0.001 vs. others). But the set point of I-PTH stimulation by Ca++ was normal in PRF (N = 1.18 +/- 0.03 vs. PRF = 1.20 +/- 0.04 mmol/L; not significant) and decreased in HD (1.09 +/- 0.04 mmol/L; P < 0.001 vs. others). Similar results were obtained with the set point of C-PTH and of the C-PTH/I-PTH ratio. A positive correlation was observed between serum Ca++ concentration and the set point value when all three populations were analyzed together (r = 0.759, n = 47, P < 0.0001). These results indicate that the set point of PTH stimulation is normal in PRF and decreased in hypocalcemic HD. The set point seems to adjust to the ambient Ca++ concentration of the patients, by mechanisms yet to be elucidated. This does not suggest participation of this factor to the genesis of the secondary hyperparathyroidism of PRF.