The view of experts on initiatives to be undertaken to promote equity in the access to orphan drugs and specialised care for rare diseases in Spain: A Delphi consensus

OBJECTIVES

To reach a consensus amongst experts on the most feasible actions to be undertaken to facilitate patient access to specialised care and orphan drugs (OD) in the public health sector in Spain.

METHODS

Two Delphi rounds were completed. The questionnaire was based on a literature review and 2 focus groups. Agreement was sought on the desire (D) and prognosis (P) for the implementation within the next 5 years, on a 5-point Likert scale. Consensus was reached when ≥75% participants chose agreement (1-2) or disagreement options (4-5).

RESULTS

82 experts on rare disease (RD) participated. Agreement on the D and P was reached in 66.07% statements: OD pricing review [absence of clinical effectiveness (D:85.37%; P:85.90%), target population increase (D:79.27%; P:91.03%)]; reference team definition of referral protocols and clinical practice guidelines (D: 97.56%; P: 89.74%); and a unified, usable, etiology-based registry (D:97.56%; P:84.62%). D and P assessment diverged in 32.14% items: creation of a specific funding system for OD (D: 97.56%; P: 60.25%); and a network of medical teams to coordinate the care of RD patients (D: 99%; P: 62%).

CONCLUSIONS

The results have shown the need to promote dialogue between stakeholders, introduce European recommendation to national and regional Spanish policies and set up priorities and undertake actions to drive relevant changes in current medical practice in managing RD patients.

Childhood vasculitis hospitalizations in Spain, 1997-2011

The aim of this study is to describe the childhood vasculitis hospital burden in Spain (1997-2011), considering type of disease, hospitalization rates and time trends. Data were obtained from the National Discharges Basic Minimum Data Set (National Patient Data Base). Inpatient events of children younger than 15 years of age were analyzed. Principal diagnosis of vasculitis were selected according Ninth Revision of the International Classification of Diseases: Takayasu arteritis, Polyarteritis nodosa, Kawasaki disease, Wegener`s granulomatosis, Churg-Strauss syndrome, and Henoch-Schönlein purpura. A total of 14518 children hospitalizations related to vasculitis were identified in Spain from 1997 to 2011. The average hospitalization rate for children was 13.33±1.71 per 100,000. Henoch-Schönlein purpura and Kawasaki disease were the most common type of vasculitis, hospitalization rates were 11.00 and 3.97 per 100,000 children, respectively. Other vasculitis hospitalizations are much rare in childhood. Average length of stay was 6.04 days and estimated cost per inpatient hospital care was 2,847€. Hospital case fatality rate was 0.05% for overall vasculitis. In conclusion, epidemiological data of childhood vasculitis are useful both to health decision-making and to identify research priorities.

Public health research on rare diseases

Despite the low prevalence of Rare Diseases (RD), over 30 million EU citizens suffer from these conditions. This paper summarizes some aspects of these life-threatening chronic and debilitating diseases that usually require long term specialist care and costly formal and informal surveillance. Epidemiology does have an important role to play in the field of RD, since it provides appropriate methods and tools for assessing exposures and health outcomes. In this regard, the utility of registries, biobanks and population-based surveillance systems are discussed. The lack of effective diagnoses and treatments in RD patients often underlies their shortened life expectancy and quality of life. Due to the limited number of patients and the scarcity of relevant knowledge and expertise, coordination at European level is probably the best way of pooling the very limited resources available and provides a very high added-value. RD require the combined efforts of health and social care professionals, politicians, managers and researchers to increase the availability of effective disease management tools to improve care and to extend both life expectancy and Health Related Quality of Life.

Revisión de los aspectos éticos en la investigación biomédica: la experiencia del Comité de Ética del Centro de Investigación sobre el Síndrome del Aceite Tóxico y Enfermedades Raras (CISATER)

This Field Note aims to make known the decisions taken by the Ethics Committee of the Instituto de Salud Carlos III for Toxic Oil Syndrome regarding the secondary use of research specimens in biological research when informed consent is lacking. This is a common concern in the field of biomedical research. After debating the ethical suitability of the secondary use of these samples, our main conclusion is that researchers conducting prospective studies should expressly solicit written informed consent from participants in the study about i) whether there will or could be any secondary use of the samples and, if so, ii) whether such secondary use would be conditional on the type of research.

Epidemiologic evidence for a new class of compounds associated with toxic oil syndrome

Toxic oil syndrome appeared in epidemic form in Spain in 1981. Epidemiologic studies have demonstrated that illness was caused by consumption of rapeseed oil that had been denatured with aniline. Chemical analyses of oil specimens conducted in conjunction with epidemiologic studies have established that consumption of specific oils containing fatty acid anilide contaminants was associated with increased risk for disease. New chemical analytic methods identified a family of compounds, the di-fatty acid esters of phenylamino propane-diol, and one of these compounds, the 1,2-di-oleyl ester of 3-(N-phenylamino)-1,2-propanediol (DPAP), has been found to be more strongly associated with disease status than the fatty acid anilides. We found the odds ratio for exposure to DPAP (OR = 26.4, 95% CI = 6.4-76.3) is much higher than the odds ratio for exposure to oleyl anilide (OR = 4.1, 95% CI = 2.2-7.8), implying that exposure to DPAP was a more relevant risk factor for development of toxic oil syndrome than exposure to oleyl anilide. In this paper, we review and present analyses of data from multiple studies of the possible etiologic role of DPAP in toxic oil syndrome. The presence of DPAP in oil collected from affected and unaffected households was a more specific correlate of case relatedness than was the presence of fatty acid anilides, and it was equally sensitive. Moreover, DPAP was found in oil from the only refinery whose oil was clearly associated with illness.

Immunological basis of toxic oil syndrome (TOS)

The toxic oil syndrome (TOS), a multisystemic disease, that occurred in Spain in 1981, was caused by the ingestion of rapeseed oil denatured with 2% aniline. Due to the clinical course of the disease, immunopathological mechanisms have been suspected but a direct connection was never demonstrated. To analyse this possibility, we determined several immunological parameters in the sera of patients with TOS and without the disease, using a case-control design: total immunoglobulins, IgG and IgE antibodies against different toxic agents (oleylanilide, aniline, linoleyl-anilide, and 3-phenylaminopropane-1-2-diol), autoantibodies, cytokines (IL-4, IL-6, TNF, GM-CSF) and soluble receptors (sCD23 and sIL-2R). We detected high levels of sIL-2R in TOS patients compared to controls (P < 0.0001). A higher levels of sCD23 and IgE were also found. In addition, the response to oleyl-anilide of peripheral blood lymphocytes from TOS patients was studied and a significant proliferative response in 30% of TOS patients versus 5% controls was observed. Our data support the implication of the immune system in the acute phase of TOS, with a possible activation of T-cells and release of cytokines, that could explain some of the clinical findings in this phase of the disease.

Participation of eosinophils in the toxic oil syndrome

The participation of eosinophils in the Spanish toxic oil syndrome (TOS) was investigated. Eosinophil infiltration and degranulation in tissues from 52 patients with the TOS were examined by immunofluorescence staining for the eosinophil granule major basic protein (MBP). Serum MBP levels were determined in sera from 323 patients. Eosinophil infiltration and degranulation were found in several tissues, especially during the acute phase of the TOS, and serum MBP was significantly elevated during all phases of the disease, suggesting that eosinophils play a role in the pathogenesis of the TOS.

Toxic-oil syndrome: case reports associated with the ITH oil refinery in Sevilla

Toxic-oil syndrome (TOS), a new disease that occurred in epidemic form in Spain in 1981, has been associated with the ingestion of unlabelled oil bought principally from travelling salesmen. Chemical analysis of oils taken from ill families has shown them to consist of varying proportions of different vegetable oils and animal fats, often showing chemical evidence of prior treatment with aniline. We investigated the unusual circumstances surrounding the reported occurrence of three TOS cases in two families in Sevilla, a city located far away (approximately 300 km) from the group of 14 provinces in central and northwestern Spain where 99% of the TOS cases occurred. Each case we investigated fitted the clinical picture of TOS and was not consistent with any other diagnosis. Illness apparently occurred as a result of ingestion of oil taken from the ITH oil refinery in Sevilla, a plant in which rapeseed and grapeseed oils were refined for the distributing firm through which oil bearing the causative agent of TOS is thought to have entered the market. These data provide further strong support for the hypothesis that food oil was the vehicle by which the aetiological agent of TOS was transmitted. Because ingestion of refined denatured rapeseed oil was most closely associated with the illness in time, the TOS agent was probably contained initially in this type of oil. The agent very probably entered later oil mixtures through such contaminated rapeseed oil.

Myotonic dystrophy associated with thyroid disease

Two patients with hereditary, clinical, electromyographical and histological data typical of myotonic dystrophy are discussed. In both there was a thyroid disorder. The first patient had primary hypothyroidism, and the second a non-toxic multinodular goiter which necessitated total thyroidectomy. The EMG findings and the muscle histopathology of both patients are commented on and compared with the changes described in hypothyroidism. The disease processes in both patients are also discussed in relation to the muscle and metabolic changes described in myotonic dystrophy. The coexistence of these two diseases is not explicable in the light of present knowledge on the basis of a known genetic predisposition. Only two similar cases of myotonic dystrophy and hypothyroidism have been reported.