Response to Comment on "The role of electron-electron interactions in two-dimensional Dirac fermions"

Hesselmann et al question one of our conclusions: the suppression of Fermi velocity at the Gross-Neveu critical point for the specific case of vanishing long-range interactions and at zero energy. The possibility they raise could occur in any finite-size extrapolation of numerical data. Although we cannot definitively rule out this possibility, we provide mathematical bounds on its likelihood.

Quantum critical points with the Coulomb interaction and the dynamical exponent: when and why z = 1

A general scenario that leads to Coulomb quantum criticality with the dynamical critical exponent z = 1 is proposed. I point out that the long-range Coulomb interaction and quenched disorder have competing effects on z, and that balance between the two may lead to charged quantum critical points at which z = 1 exactly. This is illustrated with the calculation for the Josephson junction array Hamiltonian in dimensions D = 3 - epsilon. Precisely in D = 3, however, the above simple result breaks down, and z > 1. Relation to other studies is discussed.

Zero-temperature d-wave superconducting phase transition

The Ginzburg-Landau-Wilson theory that describes the disordered-metal- d-wave-superconductor phase transition at zero temperature is derived at weak coupling. The theory represents an interacting dissipative system of bosonic Cooper pairs in an effective random potential. I show that there exists a wide crossover regime in the theory controlled by a line of Gaussian fixed points, each of which in two dimensions is characterized by a different universal value of the dc critical conductivity. Relation to experiments on overdoped and underdoped cuprates is discussed.