Lactococcus lactis, an efficient cell factory for recombinant protein production and secretion

The use of Gram-positive bacteria for heterologous protein production proves to be a useful choice due to easy protein secretion and purification. The lactic acid bacterium Lactococcus lactis emerges as an attractive alternative to the Gram-positive model Bacillus subtilis. Here, we review recent work on the expression and secretion systems available for heterologous protein secretion in L. lactis, including promoters, signal peptides and mutant host strains known to overcome some bottlenecks of the process. Among the tools developed in our laboratory, inactivation of HtrA, the unique housekeeping protease at the cell surface, or complementation of the Sec machinery with B. subtilis SecDF accessory protein each result in the increase in heterologous protein yield. Furthermore, our lactococcal expression/secretion system, using both P(Zn)zitR, an expression cassette tightly controlled by environmental zinc, and a consensus signal peptide, SP(Exp4), allows efficient production and secretion of the staphylococcal nuclease, as evidenced by protein yields (protein amount/biomass) comparable to those obtained using NICE or P170 expression systems under similar laboratory conditions. Finally, the toolbox we are developing should contribute to enlarge the use of L. lactis as a protein cell factory.

HtrA is the unique surface housekeeping protease in Lactococcus lactis and is required for natural protein processing

We identified an exported protease in Lactococcus lactis ssp. lactis strain IL1403 belonging to the HtrA/DegP family. Inactivation of the chromosomal gene (htrALl) encoding this protease (HtrALl) results in growth thermo-sensitivity at very high temperatures (above 37 degrees C for L. lactis). The role of htrALl in extracellular proteolysis under normal growth conditions was examined by testing the stability of different exported proteins (i.e. fusions, a heterologous pre-pro-protein or a native protein containing repeats), having different locations. In the wild-type (wt) strain, degradation products, including the C-terminal protein ends, were present in the medium, indicating that proteolysis occurs during or after export to the cell surface; in one case, degradation was nearly total. In contrast, proteolysis was totally abolished in the htrA strain for all five proteins tested, and the yield of full-length products was significantly increased. These results suggest that HtrALl is the sole extracellular protease that degrades abnormal exported proteins. In addition, our results reveal that HtrALl is needed for the pro-peptide processing of a natural pro-protein and for maturation of a native protein. We propose that in lactococci, and possibly in other Gram-positive organisms with small sized-genomes, a single surface protease, HtrA, is totally responsible for the housekeeping of exported proteins.

An export-specific reporter designed for gram-positive bacteria: application to Lactococcus lactis

The identification of exported proteins by fusion studies, while well developed for gram-negative bacteria, is limited for gram-positive bacteria, in part due to drawbacks of available export reporters. In this work, we demonstrate the export specificity and use of the Staphylococcus aureus secreted nuclease (Nuc) as a reporter for gram-positive bacteria. Nuc devoid of its export signal (called delta(SP)Nuc) was used to create two fusions whose locations could be differentiated. Nuclease activity was shown to require an extracellular location in Lactococcus lactis, thus demonstrating the suitability of delta(SP)Nuc to report protein export. The shuttle vector pFUN was designed to construct delta(SP)Nuc translational fusions whose expression signals are provided by inserted DNA. The capacity of delta(SP)Nuc to reveal and identify exported proteins was tested by generating an L. lactis genomic library in pFUN and by screening for Nuc activity directly in L. lactis. All delta(SP)Nuc fusions displaying a strong Nuc+ phenotype contained a classical or a lipoprotein-type signal peptide or single or multiple transmembrane stretches. The function of some of the predicted signals was confirmed by cell fractionation studies. The fusions analyzed included long (up to 455-amino-acid) segments of the exported proteins, all previously unknown in L. lactis. Homology searches indicate that several of them may be implicated in different cell surface functions, such as nutrient uptake, peptidoglycan assembly, environmental sensing, and protein folding. Our results with L. lactis show that delta(SP)Nuc is well suited to report both protein export and membrane protein topology.

Controlled production of stable heterologous proteins in Lactococcus lactis

The use of Lactococcus lactis (the most extensively characterized lactic acid bacterium) as a delivery organism for heterologous proteins is, in some cases, limited by low production levels and poor-quality products due to surface proteolysis. In this study, we combined in one L. lactis strain use of the nisin-inducible promoter P(nisA) and inactivation of the extracellular housekeeping protease HtrA. The ability of the mutant strain, designated htrA-NZ9000, to produce high levels of stable proteins was confirmed by using the staphylococcal nuclease (Nuc) and the following four heterologous proteins fused or not fused to Nuc that were initially unstable in wild-type L. lactis strains: (i) Staphylococcus hyicus lipase, (ii) the bovine rotavirus antigen nonstructural protein 4, (iii) human papillomavirus antigen E7, and (iv) Brucella abortus antigen L7/L12. In all cases, protein degradation was significantly lower in strain htrA-NZ9000, demonstrating the usefulness of this strain for stable heterologous protein production.

The general protein-export pathway is directly required for extracellular pullulanase secretion in Escherichia coli K12

Pullulanase is an extracellular, cell surface-anchored lipoprotein produced by Gram-negative bacteria belonging to the genus Klebsiella. Its correct localization in recombinant Escherichia coli requires the products of 14 genes that are linked to the enzyme structural gene in the Klebsiella chromosome. In addition, we show here that six sec genes (secA, secB, secD, secE, secF and secY) are all required for processing of the prepullulanase signal peptide to occur. This implies that pullulanase crosses the cytoplasmic membrane via the general export pathway of which the sec gene products are essential components. Removal or drastic alteration of the prepullulanase signal peptide cause the enzyme to remain cytoplasmic. We propose that pullulanase secretion occurs in two steps, the first of which is common to all signal peptide-bearing precursors of exported and secreted proteins, whereas the second is specifically involved in translocating pullulanase to the cell surface.

Two distinct steps in pullulanase secretion by Escherichia coli K12

Two distinct steps in the secretion of the extracellular, cell-surface-anchored lipoprotein pullulanase by Escherichia coli were uncoupled by allowing export of the enzyme to the cytoplasmic membrane via the signal peptide/sec-gene-dependent general export pathway, and then inducing the pulC-O operon of genes required for translocation to the cell surface. The secretion intermediate cofractionated mainly with intermediate-density vesicles when cells were gently lysed and the resulting vesicles were separated by isopycnic sucrose density centrifugation. Cytoplasmic forms of pullulanase (which are not exported because they lack a functional signal peptide) are more sensitive to heat inactivation, denaturation by sodium dodecyl sulphate and carboxymethylation than the intermediate and cell-surface forms. The latter are distinguished only by the fact that the secretion intermediate is less susceptible to proteinase K and trypsin, and is partially inaccessible to substrate or in an inactive conformation in sphaeroplasts. These and other results indicate that the secretion intermediate can acquire considerable higher-ordered structure, including disulphide bridges, before it is transported to the cell surface; this seems to rule out the possibility that it is threaded through this membrane as a locally unfolded polypeptide.

New expression system tightly controlled by zinc availability in Lactococcus lactis

Here we developed the new expression system P(Zn) zitR, based on the regulatory signals (P(Zn) promoter and zitR repressor) of the Lactococcus lactis zit operon, involved in Zn(2+) high-affinity uptake and regulation. A P(Zn) zitR-controlled expression vector was constructed, and expression regulation was studied with two reporter genes, uspnuc and lacLM; these genes encode, respectively, a protein derived from Staphylococcus aureus secreted nuclease and Leuconostoc mesenteroides cytoplasmic beta-galactosidase. Nuclease and beta-galactosidase activities of L. lactis MG1363 cells expressing either uspnuc or lacLM under the control of P(Zn) zitR were evaluated on plates and quantified from liquid cultures as a function of divalent metal ion, particularly Zn(2+), availability in the environment. Our results demonstrate that P(Zn) zitR is highly inducible upon divalent cation starvation, obtained either through EDTA addition or during growth in chemically defined medium, and is strongly repressed in the presence of excess Zn(2+). The efficiency of the P(Zn) zitR expression system was compared to that of the well-known nisin-controlled expression (NICE) system with the same reporter genes cloned under either P(Zn) zitR or P(nisA) nisRK control. lacLM induction levels reached with both systems were on the same order of magnitude, even though the NICE system is fivefold more efficient than the P(Zn) zitR system. An even smaller difference or no difference was observed after 3 h of induction when nuclease was used as a reporter for Western blotting detection. P(Zn) zitR proved to be a powerful expression system for L. lactis, as it is tightly controlled by the zinc concentration in the medium.

Construction and characterization of a Lactococcus lactis strain deficient in intracellular ClpP and extracellular HtrA proteases

A Lactococcus lactis strain deficient in both its major proteases, intracellular (ClpP) and extracellular (HtrA), was constructed and characterized. This strain, hereafter called clpP-htrA, could be obtained only by conjugation between a clpP donor strain and an htrA recipient strain in the NZ9000 context, allowing heterologous gene expression under the control of the NICE (nisin-controlled expression) system. The clpP-htrA double mutant showed both higher stress tolerance (e.g. high temperature and ethanol resistance) and higher viability than single clpP or htrA mutant strains. In addition, the secretion rate of two heterologous proteins (staphylococcal nuclease Nuc and Nuc-E7) was also higher in clpP-htrA than in the wild-type strain. This strain should be a useful host for high-level production and quality of stable heterologous proteins.

Stable periplasmic secretion intermediate in the general secretory pathway of Escherichia coli

The secretion of the Klebsiella oxytoca cell surface lipoprotein pullulanase involves translocation across the cytoplasmic and outer membranes of the Gram-negative bacterial cell envelope. A variant of pullulanase was created by fusing the signal peptide-encoding 5' region of the Escherichia coli gene for periplasmic MalE protein to the 3' end of the pulA gene encoding almost the entire mature part of pullulanase. When produced in E. coli carrying the malE-pulA gene fusion on a high copy number plasmid and the complete set of genes specifically required for pullulanase secretion on a second plasmid, the hybrid protein differed from wild-type pullulanase as follows: (i) it was not fatty-acylated; (ii) it was apparently processed by LepB signal peptidase rather than by LspA lipoprotein signal peptidase; (iii) it was released into the periplasm and was only slowly transported across the outer membrane, and (iv) it was released directly into the medium rather than via the usual surface-anchored intermediate. The hybrid protein was secreted more rapidly when malE-pulA was expressed from a low copy number plasmid. The two steps in the secretion pathway could be totally uncoupled by expressing first the malE-pulA gene fusion and then the cognate secretion genes. These results show that fatty-acylation of wild-type PulA is not essential for secretion but may improve its efficiency when large amounts of the protein are produced, that the two steps in secretion can occur quite independently and that the periplasmic intermediate can persist for long periods under certain circumstances.

Involvement of Escherichia coli FIS protein in maintenance of bacteriophage mu lysogeny by the repressor: control of early transcription and inhibition of transposition

The Escherichia coli FIS (factor for inversion stimulation) protein has been implicated in assisting bacteriophage Mu repressor, c, in maintaining the lysogenic state under certain conditions. In a fis strain, a temperature-inducible Mucts62 prophage is induced at lower temperatures than in a wild-type host (M. Bétermier, V. Lefrère, C. Koch, R. Alazard, and M. Chandler, Mol. Microbiol. 3:459-468, 1989). Increasing the prophage copy number rendered Mucts62 less sensitive to this effect of the fis mutation, which thus seems to depend critically on the level of repressor activity. The present study also provides evidence that FIS affects the control of Mu gene expression and transposition. As judged by the use of lac transcriptional fusions, repression of early transcription was reduced three- to fourfold in a fis background, and this could be compensated by an increase in cts62 gene copy number. c was also shown to inhibit Mu transposition two- to fourfold less strongly in a fis host. These modulatory effects, however, could not be correlated to sequence-specific binding of FIS to the Mu genome, in particular to the strong site previously identified on the left end. We therefore speculate that a more general function of FIS is responsible for the observed modulation of Mu lysogeny.

Extracellular secretion of pullulanase is unaffected by minor sequence changes but is usually prevented by adding reporter proteins to its N- or C-terminal end

Linker insertions in the pullulanase structural gene (pulA) were examined for their effects on pullulanase activity and cell surface localization in Escherichia coli carrying the cognate secretion genes from Klebsiella oxytoca. Of the 23 insertions, 11 abolished pullulanase activity but none were found to prevent secretion. To see whether more drastic changes affected secretion, we fused up to five reporter proteins (E. coli periplasmic alkaline phosphatase, E. coli periplasmic maltose-binding protein, periplasmic TEM beta-lactamase, Erwinia chrysanthemi extracellular endoglucanase Z, and Bacillus subtilis extracellular levansucrase) to three different positions in the pullulanase polypeptide: close to the N terminus of the mature protein, at the C terminus of the protein, or at the C terminus of a truncated pullulanase variant lacking the last 256 amino acids. Only 3 of the 13 different hybrids were efficiently secreted: 2 in which beta-lactamase was fused to the C terminus of full-length or truncated pullulanase and 1 in which maltose-binding protein was fused close to the N terminus of pullulanase. Affinity-purified endoglucanase-pullulanase and pullulanase-endoglucanase hybrids exhibited apparently normal levels of pullulanase activity, indicating that the conformation of the pullulanase segment of the hybrid had not been dramatically altered by the presence of the reporter. However, pullulanase-endoglucanase hybrids were secreted efficiently if the endoglucanase component comprised only the 60-amino-acid, C-terminal cellulose-binding domain, suggesting that at least one factor limiting hybrid protein secretion might be the size of the reporter.

The role of the lipoprotein sorting signal (aspartate +2) in pullulanase secretion

The analyses of hybrid proteins and of deletion and insertion mutations reveal that the only amino acid at the amino-proximal end of the cell surface lipoprotein pullulanase that is specifically required for its extracellular secretion is an aspartate at position +2, immediately after the fatty acylated amino-terminal cysteine. To see whether the requirement for this amino acid is related to its proposed role as a cytoplasmic membrane lipoprotein sorting signal, we used sucrose gradient floatation analysis to determine the subcellular location of pullulanase variants (with or without the aspartate residue) that accumulated in cells lacking the pullulanase-specific secretion genes. A non-secretable pullulanase variant with a serine at position +2 cofractionated mainly with the major peak of outer membrane porin. In contrast, most (55%) of a pullulanase variant with an aspartate at position +2 cofractionated with slightly lighter fractions that contained small proportions of both outer membrane porin and the cytoplasmic membrane marker NADH oxidase. Only 5% of this pullulanase variant cofractionated with the major NADH oxidase peak, while the rest (c. 40%) remained at the bottom of the gradient in fractions totally devoid of porin and NADH oxidase. When analysed by sedimentation through sucrose gradients, however, a large proportion of this variant was recovered from fractions near the top of the gradient that also contained the major NADH oxidase peak. When this peak fraction was applied to a floatation gradient the pullulanase activity remained at the bottom while the NADH oxidase floated to the top.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)