Estimation of contact tympanic membrane temperature with a noncontact infrared thermometer

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To investigate the agreement between contact tympanic membrane (TM) and noncontact infrared ear thermometers in children.

METHODS

Twenty-three children (ages .5 to 10 years) undergoing elective tympanostomy tube placement were studied. An assistant used standard technique to record temperature with an infrared ear thermometer before and after TM temperature was obtained with a bead thermistor placed against the anterior-inferior quadrant of the TM.

RESULTS

Mean temperatures were not significantly different: initial IR ear, 36.66 degrees +/-.33 degrees C; TM, 36.71 degrees +/- .42 degrees C; final infrared ear, 36.57 degrees +/- .33 degrees C. The mean bias (difference between initial individual IR ear and TM temperatures) of -.05 degrees +/-.29 degrees C and the 95% limits of agreement of +.53 degrees to -.63 degrees C indicate an acceptable confidence (error range within 3.2% of average TM temperature) for use of the initial infrared ear temperature as an estimate of TM temperature.

CONCLUSION

The IR ear thermometer provides an accurate estimate of TM temperature in healthy children and may accurately reflect core body temperature.

Impact of operator technique and device on infrared emission detection tympanic thermometry

Preliminary data on the use of infrared emission detection (IRED) tympanic thermometers suggest that operator technique may be important in IRED readings. No systematic investigation of specific technique and available IRED devices has previously been performed. In a prospective, blinded trial, 40 healthy adult subjects using six IRED thermometers with two techniques were examined in random sequence. Differences between IRED tympanic, oral, and rectal temperatures were compared using ANOVA. Significant differences were observed between all temperatures, the IRED devices, and the method of probe insertion. Differences between oral or rectal temperatures and IRED tympanic readings were reduced by an ear tug (as for routine otoscopy) for all but one device. An "ear tug" results in increased IRED readings that may improve accuracy of tympanic thermometers using IRED.