Segmental differences found in aqueous angiographic-determined high - and low-flow regions of human trabecular meshwork

This work sought to compare aqueous angiographic segmental patterns with bead-based methods which directly visualize segmental trabecular meshwork (TM) tracer trapping. Additionally, segmental protein expression differences between aqueous angiographic-derived low- and high-outflow human TM regions were evaluated. Post-mortem human eyes (One Legacy and San Diego eye banks; n = 15) were perfused with fluorescent tracers (fluorescein [2.5%], indocyanine green [0.4%], and/or fluorescent microspheres). After angiographic imaging (Spectralis HRA+OCT; Heidelberg Engineering), peri-limbal low- and high-angiographic flow regions were marked. Aqueous angiographic segmental outflow patterns were similar to fluorescent microsphere TM trapping segmental patterns. TM was dissected from low- and high-flow areas and processed for immunofluorescence or Western blot and compared. Versican expression was relatively elevated in low-flow regions while MMP3 and collagen VI were relatively elevated in high-flow regions. TGF-β2, thrombospondin-1, TGF-β receptor1, and TGF-β downstream proteins such as α-smooth muscle actin were relatively elevated in low-flow regions. Additionally, fibronectin (FN) levels were unchanged, but the EDA isoform (FN-EDA) that is associated with fibrosis was relatively elevated in low-flow regions. These results show that segmental aqueous angiographic patterns are reflective of underlying TM molecular characteristics and demonstrate increased pro-fibrotic activation in low-flow regions. Thus, we provide evidence that aqueous angiography outflow visualization, the only tracer outflow imaging method available to clinicians, is in part representative of TM biology.

Deep tissue analysis of distal aqueous drainage structures and contractile features

Outflow resistance in the aqueous drainage tract distal to trabecular meshwork is potentially an important determinant of intraocular pressure and success of trabecular bypass glaucoma surgeries. It is unclear how distal resistance is modulated. We sought to establish: (a) multimodal 2-photon deep tissue imaging and 3-dimensional analysis of the distal aqueous drainage tract (DT) in transgenic mice in vivo and ex vivo; (b) criteria for distinguishing the DT from blood and lymphatic vessels; and (c) presence of a DT wall organization capable of contractility. DT lumen appeared as scleral collagen second harmonic generation signal voids that could be traced back to Schlemm's canal. DT endothelium was Prox1-positive, CD31-positive and LYVE-1-negative, bearing a different molecular signature from blood and true lymphatic vessels. DT walls showed prominent filamentous actin (F-actin) labeling reflecting cells in a contracted state. F-actin co-localized with mesenchymal smooth muscle epitopes of alpha-smooth muscle actin, caldesmon and calponin, which localized adjacent and external to the endothelium. Our findings support a DT wall organization resembling that of blood vessels. This reflects a capacity to contract and support dynamic alteration of DT caliber and resistance analogous to the role of blood vessel tone in regulating blood flow.

Aqueous Angiography-Mediated Guidance of Trabecular Bypass Improves Angiographic Outflow in Human Enucleated Eyes

Purpose

To assess the ability of trabecular micro-bypass stents to improve aqueous humor outflow (AHO) in regions initially devoid of AHO as assessed by aqueous angiography.

Methods

Enucleated human eyes (14 total from 7 males and 3 females [ages 52–84]) were obtained from an eye bank within 48 hours of death. Eyes were oriented by inferior oblique insertion, and aqueous angiography was performed with indocyanine green (ICG; 0.4%) or fluorescein (2.5%) at 10 mm Hg. With an angiographer, infrared and fluorescent images were acquired. Concurrent anterior segment optical coherence tomography (OCT) was performed, and fixable fluorescent dextrans were introduced into the eye for histologic analysis of angiographically positive and negative areas. Experimentally, some eyes (n = 11) first received ICG aqueous angiography to determine angiographic patterns. These eyes then underwent trabecular micro-bypass sham or stent placement in regions initially devoid of angiographic signal. This was followed by fluorescein aqueous angiography to query the effects.

Results

Aqueous angiography in human eyes yielded high-quality images with segmental patterns. Distally, angiographically positive but not negative areas demonstrated intrascleral lumens on OCT images. Aqueous angiography with fluorescent dextrans led to their trapping in AHO pathways. Trabecular bypass but not sham in regions initially devoid of ICG aqueous angiography led to increased aqueous angiography as assessed by fluorescein (P = 0.043).

Conclusions

Using sequential aqueous angiography in an enucleated human eye model system, regions initially without angiographic flow or signal could be recruited for AHO using a trabecular bypass stent.

Aqueous Angiography with Fluorescein and Indocyanine Green in Bovine Eyes

Purpose

We characterize aqueous angiography as a real-time aqueous humor outflow imaging (AHO) modality in cow eyes with two tracers of different molecular characteristics.

Methods

Cow enucleated eyes (n = 31) were obtained and perfused with balanced salt solution via a Lewicky AC maintainer through a 1-mm side-port. Fluorescein (2.5%) or indocyanine green (ICG; 0.4%) were introduced intracamerally at 10 mm Hg individually or sequentially. With an angiographer, infrared and fluorescent images were acquired. Concurrent anterior segment optical coherence tomography (OCT) was performed, and fixable fluorescent dextrans were introduced into the eye for histologic analysis of angiographically positive and negative areas.

Results

Aqueous angiography in cow eyes with fluorescein and ICG yielded high-quality images with segmental patterns. Over time, ICG maintained a better intraluminal presence. Angiographically positive, but not negative, areas demonstrated intrascleral lumens with anterior segment OCT. Aqueous angiography with fluorescent dextrans led to their trapping in AHO pathways. Sequential aqueous angiography with ICG followed by fluorescein in cow eyes demonstrated similar patterns.

Conclusions

Aqueous angiography in model cow eyes demonstrated segmental angiographic outflow patterns with either fluorescein or ICG as a tracer.

Translational Relevance

Further characterization of segmental AHO with aqueous angiography may allow for intelligent placement of trabecular bypass minimally invasive glaucoma surgeries for improved surgical results.

Toward in vivo two-photon analysis of mouse aqueous outflow structure and function

The promise of revolutionary insights into intraocular pressure (IOP) and aqueous humor outflow homeostasis, IOP pathogenesis, and novel therapy offered by engineered mouse models has been hindered by a lack of appropriate tools for studying the aqueous drainage tissues in their original 3-dimensional (3D) environment. Advances in 2-photon excitation fluorescence imaging (TPEF) combined with availability of modalities such as transgenic reporter mice and intravital dyes have placed us on the cusp of unlocking the potential of the mouse model for unearthing insights into aqueous drainage structure and function. Multimodality 2-photon imaging permits high-resolution visualization not only of tissue structural organization but also cells and cellular function. It is possible to dig deeper into understanding the cellular basis of aqueous outflow regulation as the technique integrates analysis of tissue structure, cell biology and physiology in a way that could also lead to fresh insights into human glaucoma. We outline recent novel applications of two-photon imaging to analyze the mouse conventional drainage system in vivo or in whole tissues: (1) collagen second harmonic generation (SHG) identifies the locations of episcleral vessels, intrascleral plexuses, collector channels, and Schlemm's canal in the distal aqueous drainage tract; (2) the prospero homeobox protein 1-green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter helps locate the inner wall of Schlemm's canal; (3) Calcein AM, siGLO™, the fluorescent reporters m-Tomato and GFP, and coherent anti-Stokes scattering (CARS), are adjuncts to TPEF to identify live cells by their membrane or cytosolic locations; (4) autofluorescence and sulforhodamine-B to identify elastic fibers in the living eye. These tools greatly expand our options for analyzing physiological and pathological processes in the aqueous drainage tissues of live mice as a model of the analogous human system.

Optimizing two-photon multiple fluorophore imaging of the human trabecular meshwork

PURPOSE

Advances in two-photon (2P) deep tissue imaging provide powerful options for simultaneously viewing multiple fluorophores within tissues. We determined imaging parameters for optimally visualizing three fluorophores in the human trabecular meshwork (TM) to simultaneously detect broad-spectrum autofluorescence and multiple fluorophores through a limited number of emission filters.

METHODS

2P imaging of viable human postmortem TM was conducted to detect Hoechst 33342-labeled nuclei, Alexa-568-conjugated phalloidin labeling of filamentous actin, and autofluorescence of the structural extracellular matrix (ECM). Emission detection through green (500-550 nm), near-red (565-605 nm), and far-red (590-680 nm) filters following 2P excitation at 750, 800, 850, and 900 nm was analyzed. Region-of-interest (ROI) image analysis provided fluorescence intensity values for each fluorophore.

RESULTS

Red-channel Alexa 568 fluorescence was of highest intensity with 2P 750 nm and 800 nm excitation. Alexa 568 was imperceptible with 900 nm excitation. With excitation at 750 nm and 800 nm, Hoechst 33,342 intensity swamped autofluorescence in the green channel, and marked bleed-through into red channels was seen. 850 nm excitation yielded balanced Hoechst 33342 and autofluorescence intensities, minimized their bleed-through into the far-red channel, and produced reasonable Alexa 568 intensities in the far-red channel.

CONCLUSIONS

2P excitation at 850 nm and long-wavelength emission detection in the far-red channel allowed simultaneous visualization of the specific mix of endogenous and exogenous fluorophores with reasonably balanced intensities while minimizing bleed-through when imaging the human TM.

Tissue-based multiphoton analysis of actomyosin and structural responses in human trabecular meshwork

The contractile trabecular meshwork (TM) modulates aqueous humor outflow resistance and intraocular pressure. The primary goal was to visualize and quantify human TM contractile state by analyzing actin polymerization (F-actin) by 2-photon excitation fluorescence imaging (TPEF) in situ. A secondary goal was to ascertain if structural extracellular matrix (ECM) configuration changed with contractility. Viable ex vivo human TM was incubated with latrunculin-A (Lat-A) or vehicle prior to Alexa-568-phalloidin labeling and TPEF. Quantitative image analysis was applied to 2-dimensional (2D) optical sections and 3D image reconstructions. After Lat-A exposure, (a) the F-actin network reorganized as aggregates; (b) F-actin-associated fluorescence intensity was reduced by 48.6% (mean; p = 0.007; n = 8); (c) F-actin 3D distribution was reduced by 68.9% (p = 0.040); (d) ECM pore cross-sectional area and volume were larger by 36% (p = 0.032) and 65% (p = 0.059) respectively and pores appeared more interconnected; (e) expression of type I collagen and elastin, key TM structural ECM proteins, were unaltered (p = 0.54); and (f) tissue viability was unchanged (p = 0.39) relative to vehicle controls. Thus Lat-A-induced reduction of actomyosin contractility was associated with TM porous expansion without evidence of reduced structural ECM protein expression or cellular viability. These important subcellular-level dynamics could be visualized and quantified within human tissue by TPEF.

Tissue-based imaging model of human trabecular meshwork

We have developed a tissue-based model of the human trabecular meshwork (TM) using viable postmortem corneoscleral donor tissue. Two-photon microscopy is used to optically section and image deep in the tissue to analyze cells and extracellular matrix (ECM) within the original three-dimensional (3D) environment of the TM. Multimodal techniques, including autofluorescence (AF), second harmonic generation (SHG), intravital dye fluorescence, and epifluorescence, are combined to provide unique views of the tissue at the cellular and subcellular level. SHG and AF imaging are non-invasive tissue imaging techniques with potential for clinical application, which can be modeled in the system. We describe the following in the tissue-based model: analysis of live cellularity to determine tissue viability; characteristics of live cells based on intravital labeling; features and composition of the TM's structural ECM; localization of specific ECM proteins to regions such as basement membrane; in situ induction and expression of tissue markers characteristic of cultured TM cells relevant to glaucoma; analysis of TM actin and pharmacological effects; in situ visualization of TM, inner wall endothelium, and Schlemm's canal; and application of 3D reconstruction, modeling, and quantitative analysis to the TM. The human model represents a cost-effective use of valuable and scarce yet available human tissue that allows unique cell biology, pharmacology, and translational studies of the TM.

Contractile markers distinguish structures of the mouse aqueous drainage tract

PURPOSE

Structures of the aqueous humor drainage tract are contractile, although the tract is not entirely composed of muscle. We characterized the mouse aqueous drainage tract by immunolabeling contractile markers and determined whether profiling these markers within the tract distinguished its key structures of the trabecular meshwork (TM) and ciliary muscle (CM).

METHODS

Enucleated eyes from pigmented C57BL/6 (n=8 mice) and albino BALB/c (n=6 mice) mice were processed for cryo- and formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded sectioning. Immunofluorescence labeling was performed for the following: (a) filamentous actin (using fluorescence-conjugated phalloidin), representing a global contractile marker; (b) α-smooth muscle actin (α-SMA), caldesmon, and calponin, representing classic smooth muscle epitopes; and (c) nonmuscle myosin heavy chain, representing a nonmuscle contractile protein. Tissue labeling was identified by confocal microscopy and analyzed quantitatively. Hematoxylin and eosin staining provided structural orientation.

RESULTS

A small portion of the TM faced the anterior chamber; the rest extended posteriorly alongside Schlemm's canal (SC) within the inner sclera. Within the drainage tract, filamentous actin labeling was positive in TM and CM. α-SMA and caldesmon labeling was seen primarily along the CM, which extended from the anterior chamber angle to its posterior termination beyond the SC near the retina. Low intensity, patchy α-SMA and caldesmon labeling was seen in the TM. Myosin heavy chain immunoreactivity was primarily found in the TM and calponin was primarily observed in the CM. C57BL/6 and BALB/c comparison showed that pigment obscured fluorescence in the ciliary body.

CONCLUSIONS

Our strategy of profiling contractile markers distinguished mouse aqueous drainage tract structures that were otherwise indistinguishable by hematoxylin and eosin staining. The mouse TM was seen as an intervening structure between SC, a part of the conventional drainage tract, and CM, a part of the unconventional drainage tract. Our findings provide important insights into the structural and functional organization of the mouse aqueous drainage tract and a basis for exploring the role of contractility in modulating aqueous outflow.

Sources of structural autofluorescence in the human trabecular meshwork

PURPOSE

In situ 2-photon excitation fluorescence (TPEF) of the human trabecular meshwork (TM) reveals beams of heterogeneous autofluorescence (AF) comprising high intensity fluorescent fibers (AF-high) on a background of lower intensity fluorescence (AF-low). To determine the sources of this AF heterogeneity, we imaged human TM to characterize AF, second harmonic generation (SHG) for collagen, and eosin-labeled fluorescence identifying elastin.

METHODS

Corneoscleral rims retained after corneal transplantation were incubated with and without eosin, and imaged by TPEF. TPEF was collected through multiphoton bandpass filters to obtain AF, SHG (collagen bandwidth), and eosin-labeled fluorescence images. For qualitative comparisons, near-simultaneous image acquisition pairs of AF-SHG (+/-eosin coincubation), AF-eosin, and SHG-eosin were captured. For quantitative comparisons, multiple regions of interest (ROI) were defined in separate TM beam regions within the uveal and corneoscleral meshwork for image acquisition pairs of AF-SHG (without eosin coincubation) and SHG-eosin. We defined 18 ROI within each acquisition pair as the basis for Manders colocalization analysis. Perfect colocalization was defined as a Manders coefficient (Mcoeff) of 1.

RESULTS

Qualitatively and quantitatively, AF-low colocalized with SHG (Mcoeff=1), but not SHG signal-voids. AF-high colocalized with SHG signal-voids (Mcoeff=1), but not the SHG signal. Like AF-high, eosin-labeled fluorescence qualitatively and quantitatively colocalized (Mcoeff=1) with SHG signal-voids, but not the SHG signal.

CONCLUSIONS

Heterogeneous AF in human TM is comprised of high intensity signal originating from elastin fibers in beam cores and lower intensity signal originating from collagen. These findings are relevant to interpreting structural extracellular matrix signals in AF images of the TM.

Analyzing live cellularity in the human trabecular meshwork

PURPOSE

To directly visualize the live cellularity of the intact human trabecular meshwork (TM) and quantitatively analyze tissue viability in situ.

METHODS

Human donor corneoscleral rims were sectioned immediately before intravital dye incubation to label nuclei (Hoechst 33342 & propidium iodide [PI]); cytosol (CellTracker Red CMTPX, calcein AM); and membranes (octadecyl rhodamine B chloride [R18]), followed by 2-photon microscopy. Viability was assessed by counting cells in tissue colabeled with PI and Calcein AM. Some tissues were exposed to Triton X-100 to establish dead tissue controls. Fresh postmortem eyes (within 48 hours of death) represented viable tissue controls. Tissues with live cellularity exceeding 50% were considered viable.

RESULTS

Hoechst nuclear labeling was seen throughout the TM, among the autofluorescent beams, plate-like structures and fibers of the meshwork, and within tissue gaps and pores. CellTracker-labeled live cells were attached to autofluorescent TM structures and filled corneoscleral meshwork pores. R18-labeling revealed the membrane distributions of interconnected cells. Calcein-positive cells were visible in all TM layers, but not in tissues killed by Triton X-100 exposure. Dead control tissues showed PI staining in the absence of Calcein-positive cells. Two-thirds of the standard donor tissues we received possessed viable TM, having a mean live cellularity of 71% (n = 14), comparable with freshly postmortem eyes (76%; n = 2). Mean live cellularity of nonviable tissue was 11% (n = 7).

CONCLUSIONS

We have visualized and quantified the live cellularity of the TM in situ. This provided unique perspectives of live cell-matrix organization and a means of assaying tissue viability.

Two-photon immunofluorescence characterization of the trabecular meshwork in situ

PURPOSE

To develop an in situ model to study biological responses and glaucoma pathology in the human trabecular meshwork (TM). Characteristic TM cell- and glaucoma-associated markers were localized in situ in relation to the tissue's autofluorescent structural extracellular matrix (ECM) by two-photon excitation fluorescence optical sectioning (TPEF).

METHODS

Human donor corneoscleral (CS) tissue containing the intact aqueous drainage tract was incubated with dexamethasone (Dex) or TGF-β1, and immunostained for epifluorescence (EF) microscopy with antibodies to myocilin and alpha smooth muscle (α-SMA). Separate specimens were labeled for Type-IV collagen and fibronectin. Nuclei were stained with Hoechst 33342. Multimodal TPEF was used to visualize EF, intravital dyes, and autofluorescence (AF) in situ. Three-dimensional (3D) localization of fluorescence within the TM was analyzed using reconstruction software.

RESULTS

Autofluorescent beams, perforated sheets, and fibers, consistent with the uveal (UV), CS, and juxtacanalicular (JCT) meshwork, respectively, were captured at different depths of the TM. Type-IV collagen EF distinctly outlined the AF beams in a location consistent with basement membrane. Fibronectin EF showed a diffuse reticular pattern throughout the TM. TGF-β1-induced α-SMA expression, which was distributed perinuclearly in cells among autofluorescent structures. Dex-induced myocilin expression had both cytosolic and extracellular distributions.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors have localized markers that are characteristic of TM cells and relevant to glaucoma pathogenesis in situ using multimodal TPEF without conventional histological embedding and sectioning. Protein expression was inducible in situ and could be analyzed with respect to cells and the ECM within the 3D environment of the human TM.

In situ autofluorescence visualization of human trabecular meshwork structure

PURPOSE

To characterize the three-dimensional (3-D) structure of the human trabecular meshwork (TM) by two-photon excited (TPEF) autofluorescence (AF) and optical sectioning without conventional histologic embedding and sectioning.

METHODS

Viable human ex vivo explants of the anterior chamber angle containing the aqueous humor drainage tissue in situ were imaged by TPEF to localize AF and Hoechst 33342 nuclear fluorescence. An autofluorescent marker in Schlemm's Canal (SC) aided SC situ visualization. En face and orthogonal views of the TM were generated.

RESULTS

In the innermost uveal TM, AF signals outlined an intricate 3-D network of fine branching beams with large openings between the beams. In the adjacent corneoscleral TM, beams were thicker and coalesced as plate-like structures with pore-like openings. Linear and coiled AF fibers were visible on the background AF of beams. Deeper, in the external TM, this organization changed to fine fiber arrays orientated in the tissue's longitudinal axis, reminiscent of the cribriform plexus of the juxtacanalicular TM (JCT). In the outermost JCT, AF of fine fibers was sparse, then undetectable as optical sections approached the inner wall of SC. Cell nuclei were closely associated with the TM structural extracellular matrix.

CONCLUSIONS

We have used TPEF and optical sectioning to exploit AF as a useful method to visualize the structure of the human conventional aqueous drainage pathway in situ. Ancillary nuclear staining allowed cell association with the AF structures to be seen. This approach revealed a unique 3-D perspective of the TM that is consistent with known TM structural characteristics.

Sodium orthovanadate effect on outflow facility and intraocular pressure in live monkeys

Sodium orthovanadate (Na(3)VO(4)) is reported to reduce IOP by affecting aqueous formation, but whether it also affects outflow facility (OF) is unclear. We tested the effect of Na(3)VO(4) on OF and intraocular pressure (IOP) in live cynomolgus monkeys, and on actin and cell adhesion organization in cultured human trabecular meshwork (HTM) cells. Total OF (n = 12) was measured by 2-level constant pressure perfusion of the monkey anterior chamber (AC) before and after exchange with 1 mM Na(3)VO(4) or vehicle in opposite eyes. Topical 1% Na(3)VO(4) or vehicle only was given twice daily (each 2 × 20 μL drops) for 4 days to opposite eyes (n = 8), and Goldmann IOP was measured before and hourly after treatment for 6 h on Days 1 and 4. Filamentous actin and vinculin-containing cell adhesions were examined by epifluorescence microscopy after the cells had been incubated with 1 mM Na(3)VO(4) for 24 h. A) In monkeys, Na(3)VO(4) increased OF by 29.3 ± 8.8% (mean ± s.e.m.) over the perfusion interval when adjusted for baseline and contralateral eye washout (p = 0.01; n = 12). B) Day 1 baseline IOP was 16.2 ± 1.5 mmHg in treated eyes and 15.9 ± 1.3 mmHg in the contralateral control eyes. Following treatment on Day 1, IOP was no different (p > 0.05) between treated eyes and control eyes at any time-point or compared to baseline. Day 4 mean IOP averaged over hours 2-6 was 13.5 ± 0.8 mmHg in treated eyes and 16.1 ± 0.2 mmHg in control eyes. Treated eye IOP was lower than its Day 4 baseline (p < 0.005), lower than control eyes for the same Day 4 interval (p = 0.009), and lower than the Day 1 baseline (p = 0.0000). Control eye IOP on Day 4 was not significantly different from baseline on Day 1. C) Incubation of HTM cells with 1 mM Na(3)VO(4) for 24 h caused a loss of actin stress fibers and vinculin-containing adhesions. Cell retraction and separation was also observed in vanadate-treated cultures. Reformation of actin stress fibers, vinculin-containing adhesions and confluent monolayers occurred within 24 h after Na(3)VO(4)-containing culture medium was replaced with Na(3)VO(4)-free medium. Ocular administration of Na(3)VO(4) to live monkeys significantly increases OF and reduces IOP. Na(3)VO(4) reversibly disrupts actin and cell adhesion organization and causes retraction and separation of cultured HTM cells. Na(3)VO(4) increases pressure-dependent outflow in live monkeys. Altered actin architecture in the TM may play a part in this increased OF.

Mechanosensitivity and the eye: cells coping with the pressure

The cells of the various organ systems in humans are subject to mechanical forces to which they must respond. Here the authors review what is known of the ways in which the cells of animals, ranging from the prokaryotic to humans, sense and transduce mechanical forces to respond to such stimuli. In what way this pertains to the eye, especially with respect to axial myopia and the pressure related disease of glaucoma, is then surveyed.

Stretch-activated channels: a mini-review. Are stretch-activated channels an ocular barometer?

All cells are subject to physical forces by virtue of their position in a dynamically changing environment. This review outlines the various putative 'mechanosensors', or sensors of pressure cells possess, and discusses in particular the role stretch-activated membrane channels play in pressure recognition and transduction. The widespread occurrence of these channels is discussed and these 'mechanosensors' are related to pressure-related diseases, in particular, glaucoma.

Reversal of Disc Cupping after Intraocular Pressure Reduction in Topographic Image Series

PURPOSE

To identify and characterize 'reversal' of optic nerve cupping following intraocular pressure (IOP) lowering in scanning laser tomography (SLT) longitudinal image series.

METHODS

Modification was made to a previously described analytical approach to longitudinally study putatively increased rim area following IOP lowering. Sustained IOP reduction of 25% was by topical medication. Forty SLT image series with equivalent follow up were assessed: 10 with ocular hypertension (OHT), 10 with primary open angle glaucoma (POAG), and as controls, 20 normal. Reproducible rim area reversal was identified by sector and its time-course over 1 year examined.

RESULTS

By a 2-of-3 reproducibility criterion, reversal following IOP lowering was confirmed in about a third of treated eyes (POAG and OHT) but not in any controls. Rim sectors showing reversal were mostly nasal, with a few occurring superotemporally. Reversal in a fifth of treated eyes persisted for at least 1 year; all these were in the nasal half of the disc. The number of sectors with persisting reversal affected less than 6% of all treated eyes' rim sectors.

CONCLUSION

Rim area is not uncommonly increased after IOP lowering and this 'reversal' may persist for at least a year. Within topically treated eyes having IOP lowering of at least 25%, the proportion of rim sectors with persistent reversal appears small. Nevertheless, the effects of IOP reduction on topography, especially in the short term, should be considered when longitudinally assessing progressive rim loss in SLT images.

Tomographic Identification of Neuroretinal Rim Loss in High-Pressure, Normal-Pressure, and Suspected Glaucoma

PURPOSE

To identify progressive rim loss and describe patterns of regional change in various clinical presentations of glaucoma by scanning laser tomography (SLT).

METHODS

A previously described analytical approach was used to identify progressive rim area loss in SLT disc images of eyes of people with ocular hypertension (OHT, n = 97), early POAG (OHT converters; n = 30), asymmetric normal-pressure glaucoma (NPG, established and suspected in contralateral eyes; n = 26), and normal control subjects (n = 32). Analysis was performed longitudinally in individual image series, and cross-sectionally within groups at different time points.

RESULTS

Reproducibly reduced rim area was detected in 2 (6.2%) of 32 normal control subjects, 11 (11%) of 97 OHT subjects, 27 (90%) of 30 OHT converters, 16 (58%) of 26 of suspected NPG eyes, and 15 (54%) of 26 of established NPG eyes (mean MD = -6.5 dB). Of 5 (19%) of 26 of suspected NPG eyes that converted on visual field testing, rim loss was detected in 3 of 5. In all groups, rim loss was common in the disc poles, especially inferiorly. Patterns of rim loss were similar within high-pressure and normal-pressure groups, whether or not eyes had field defects in each. In high-pressure groups, rim loss was more common nasally than temporally. Normal-pressure groups, unlike high-pressure groups, frequently had rim loss temporally. Suspected NPG eyes had more rim loss temporally and their rim area tended to be less compared with OHT and OHT converters, despite the three groups having equivalent baseline fields.

CONCLUSIONS

There were similarities and differences in the pattern of rim loss in SLT disc images of high- and normal-pressure presentations of glaucoma. Progressive rim loss was detected in eyes without visual field defects, eyes that progressed to develop field defects, and eyes with established and more severe glaucoma.

Validity of Rim Area Measurements by Different Reference Planes

PURPOSE

Reference plane description of the neuroretinal rim in scanning laser tomography should correctly represent optic nerve morphology. We evaluated how well rim area analysis by different reference planes agreed with the appearance of rim area in disc images.

METHODS

Three expert observers subjectively and repeatedly analyzed rim area in Heidelberg Retina Tomograph (HRT) images so that each optic disc was measured six times in 100 eyes, 50 normal and 50 glaucoma. Rim area was evaluated globally and in 30 degree sectors. Agreement between rim appearance, as subjectively analyzed, and objective analysis by an experimental reference plane, the standard reference plane, and a reference plane fixed 320 microm below the reference ring was assessed in HRT images.

RESULTS

Subjective analysis of rim area in HRT images was consistent between expert observers. Their analysis of rim appearance agreed more closely with experimental reference plane analysis than analysis by the standard or 320-microm reference planes; this was true globally and in every region of the nerve (P = 0.000). The experimental reference plane yielded higher estimates of rim area than did the standard or 320-microm reference planes.

CONCLUSION

There was closer correspondence between the appearance of the neuroretinal rim in images and description by the experimental reference plane compared with description by the standard and 320-microm reference planes.

Optimizing and validating an approach for identifying glaucomatous change in optic nerve topography

PURPOSE

To determine and validate optimal parameters for analysis in a previously described approach for identifying glaucomatous optic nerve progression by scanning laser tomography.

METHODS

Thirty-degree sectors of rim area, as defined by an experimental reference plane, were analyzed for change with respect to different statistical limits of variability (80%, 90%, 95%, 98%, 99%, and 99.9%) in the longitudinal image series of 62 eyes from 30 ocular hypertension converters and 32 normal control subjects. A criterion requiring that change is repeatable in two of three consecutive tests (the 2-of-3 criterion) was compared with a single-test strategy not requiring confirmation, and four other plausible criteria. The influence of these various parameters on sensitivity and the false-positive rate was evaluated. The same series were also assessed for change by the known method of computer-generated probability maps.

RESULTS

More sectors were identified as progressing in converter eyes than in control eyes at every limit of variability. With stricter limits of variability and a requirement of confirmation, fewer sectors were identified as changing, especially in control eyes. The 2-of-3 criterion had the most favorably balanced sensitivity and false-positive rates: these were, for the 90% limit of variability, 90.0% and 6.2%, respectively, and for the 95% limit, 83.3% and 3.1%, respectively. Confirmed rim loss in converter eyes was most frequent in the disc poles and corresponded with the field hemisphere of conversion in 80%. Probability maps detected significant and repeatable change in 26 (86.7%) of 30 converter eyes and 14 (43.8%) of 32 of control eyes.

CONCLUSIONS

This study was conducted to optimize and validate an approach for identifying progression. The method distinguished eyes with glaucomatous change from unchanging control eyes.

Magnification changes in scanning laser tomography

PURPOSE

It is important when evaluating glaucomatous optic disc progression in longitudinal images that image magnification remains unchanged. We studied the effect of changed lens power on magnification in scanning laser tomography. The relative contribution to magnification of axial length, eye-scanner distance, and image-to-image scaling was also assessed.

METHODS

A simulated optic disc in a model eye was imaged using the Heidelberg Retina Tomograph. Lens power was alterable by exchanging intraocular lenses (IOL) mounted at the lens plane of the eye to mimic changes in the crystalline lens. IOL power of +20.0D and axial length of 21.5 mm was compatible with emmetropia. The optic disc was imaged through IOLs differing in power (+16.0D to +25.0D) but with axial length kept constant. IOL power was then held constant and imaging was repeated for various axial lengths (17.5-23.5 mm). Model eye-scanner distance was varied with each test sequence. The distances between landmarks on the disc was measured before and after contour lines were exported.

RESULTS

Image size varied with IOL power and axial length (r > 0.98; P < 0.0001), with the magnification effect of a +1D increase in lens power equivalent to a third the magnification effect of a 1-mm increase in axial length. Magnification tended to increase with myopia (IOL power > +20.0D) and was accentuated by longer eye-scanner distances. Image-to-image scaling corrected some magnification though this varied with ametropia.

CONCLUSIONS

Changed lens power, axial length, and eye-scanner distance can affect the size of the optic disc in scanning laser tomography images. The exported contour line partly compensates for changed magnification.

Approach for identifying glaucomatous optic nerve progression by scanning laser tomography

PURPOSE

To describe and test an analytical approach for identifying glaucomatous optic nerve change by scanning laser tomography.

METHODS

The approach (1). analyzed 30 degrees sectors of rim area by (2). a novel and reproducible experimental reference plane, (3). estimated and accounted for measurement variability in each sector, and (4). required that any change exceeding variability in a single (positive) test should be confirmed as repeatable by a criterion requiring two of three consecutive tests to be positive. The sensitivity and false-positive rate of a single positive test and the two-of-three criterion were assessed in image series of one eye each of 20 ocular hypertension patients who converted to glaucoma (referred to as converters) who had unambiguous disease progression, and in one eye each of 20 normal control subjects.

RESULTS

Eighteen of 20 (90% sensitivity) converters and 7 of 20 (35% false-positive responses) control subjects had single positive test results, but with confirmation by the two-of-three criterion, the false-positive rate improved to 5% (1/20) whereas sensitivity was relatively preserved at 85% (17/20).

CONCLUSIONS

Estimates of rim area variability in each sector of each nerve allowed change consistent with disease progression to be distinguished from measurement variability. Confirming that change is repeatable by the criterion used in the study resulted in considerably fewer false-positive responses than did testing without confirmation, but with sensitivity not significantly compromised in the former. By this approach, eyes with progressive glaucoma could be distinguished from unchanging normal control eyes.

Variability across the optic nerve head in scanning laser tomography

AIM

To characterise measurement variability in scanning laser tomography of the optic nerve head.

METHODS

21 normal and 21 glaucoma subjects underwent same and separate day test-retest Heidelberg retina tomograph imaging by the same and different operators.

RESULTS

Rim area was most reproducible among parameters. Its variability tended to be highest temporally and increased (p<0.05) with testing involving different operators and visits. Nature of regional variability differed between glaucoma and normal eyes and between standard and 320 micro m reference planes.

CONCLUSIONS

Rim area is reproducible and potentially useful as a marker of progression. Pattern of variability and the influence of different reference planes, disease, operators, and visits should be considered when evaluating progression.

Reasons for rim area variability in scanning laser tomography

PURPOSE

To determine reasons for rim area variability in scanning laser tomography.

METHODS

Regional rim area variability from testing in same and different visits and by same and different observers was characterized in 30 normal and 42 glaucomatous eyes. Variations in (1) optic nerve head (ONH) surface geometry (center of gravity: X, Y, Z), (2) image tilting (horizontally and vertically), and (3) position of the reference plane in relation to the ONH (REF) were analyzed by multiple regression analysis. Whether and how much these factors explain rim area variability was studied in cross-sectional and longitudinal data by using two different reference planes.

RESULTS

Variability was higher in glaucoma and in testing by different observers in separate visits. Across a range of eyes, approximately 40% of variability in single-topography images and 60% of variability in mean-topography images was explained. In individual image series, a median 85% of variability was explained, exceeding 90% in at least 25% of eyes. The most frequent contributors to rim area variability were REF (in > or =95%) and Z (in > or =80%); they also usually explained more variability than other factors. The nature of variability differed between reference planes.

CONCLUSIONS

A large proportion of rim area variability was explained by variation in the topographical features studied, especially REF and Z. Reference plane definition also influenced variability. Variation in the position of the reference plane in relation to the ONH can affect rim area measurements and should be considered when evaluating the progression of glaucoma.

Reference plane definition and reproducibility in optic nerve head images

PURPOSE

To describe and evaluate a new experimental reference plane for measuring rim area in scanning laser tomography.

METHODS

The experimental reference plane was positioned so that (1) it always lay entirely below the margin of the optic nerve head (ONH), (2) it remained at a set z-axis distance below the ONH in images of each eye, and (3) it was at a level where variability in rim area is least. Twenty normal control subjects and 20 patients with glaucoma underwent test-retest scanning laser tomographic imaging by same and different operators during same and separate visits. Control subjects had image series spanning at least 3 years. The effect of the positioning of the reference plane on global and regional rim area variability was assessed in intra- and intervisit test-retest images and longitudinal image series and compared with the standard and 320- microm reference planes.

RESULTS

Variability in the experimental reference plane was less in test-retest images and longitudinal data (P < 0.05) and more uniform around the ONH than with other reference planes. Variability in the former was not appreciably affected by testing involving different operators and visits, or by the presence of glaucoma.

CONCLUSIONS

Variability in rim area by the experimental reference plane was significantly less, more uniform around the ONH, not affected by different operators and visits, and less affected by glaucomatous morphology than other reference planes. This difference was pronounced in sequential data and has implications for detecting progression of glaucoma.

Interpreting glaucoma progression by white-on-white perimetry

Sequential automated static perimetry is commonly used to test whether glaucoma is progressing, but its interpretation depends on analysing complex numerical data and can be complicated. Various methods of analysis - both subjective and objective - can be used, but these methods differ in their interpretation of change. Test fluctuation and media opacities can also confound the evaluation of change. Recently, innovations in perimetric testing and analysis have sought to provide solutions. This article reviews what is known about the nature of visual field progression and examines the usefulness of perimetry in detecting worsening glaucoma.