Structure-Activity Relationships for 5''-Modifications of 4,5-Aminoglycoside Antibiotics

Modification at the 5''-position of 4,5-disubstituted aminoglycoside antibiotics (AGAs) to circumvent inactivation by the APH(3',5'') class of aminoglycoside modifying enzymes (AMEs) has been widely reported.  Such modifications, however, impact activity against wild type bacteria and affect target selectivity in unpredictable ways thereby hindering drug development.  We present a systematic survey of modifications to the 5''-position of the 4,5-AGAs and of the related 5- O -furanosyl apramycin derivatives. In the neomycin and the apralog series, all modifications were well-tolerated, but other 4,5-AGAs require the presence of a hydrogen bonding group at the 5''-position for maintenance of high antibacterial activity. Though the 5''-amino modification resulted in comparable activity to the parent compounds, reduced selectivity against the human cytosolic decoding A site renders this modification generally unfavorable in paromomycin, propylamycin, and ribostamycin. Installation of a 5''-formamido group and, to a lesser degree, a 5''-ureido group resulted in comparable activity to the parents without the selectivity cost of the 5''-amino modification. The lessons learned from this work will aid in the design of next-generation AGAs capable of circumventing susceptibility to AMEs while maintaining high antibacterial activity and target selectivity.

GH47 and Other Glycoside Hydrolases Catalyze Glycosidic Bond Cleavage with the Assistance of Substrate Super-arming at the Transition State

Super-armed glycosyl donors, whose substituents are predominantly held in pseudoaxial positions, exhibit strongly increased reactivity in glycosylation through significant stabilization of oxocarbenium-like transition states. Examination of X-ray crystal structures reveals that the GH47 family of glycoside hydrolases have evolved so as to distort their substrates away from the ground state conformation in such a manner as to present multiple C-O bonds in pseudoaxial positions and so benefit from conformational super-arming of their substrates, thereby enhancing catalysis. Through analysis of literature mutagenic studies, we show that a suitably placed aromatic residue in GHs 6 and 47 sterically enforces super-armed conformations on their substrates. GH families 45, 81, and 134 on the other hand impose conformational super-arming on their substrates, by maintaining the more active ring conformation through hydrogen bonding rather than steric interactions. The recognition of substrate super-arming by select GH families provides a further parallel with synthetic carbohydrate chemistry and nature and opens further avenues for the design of improved glycosidase inhibitors.

Side Chain Conformation Restriction in the Catalysis of Glycosidic Bond Formation by Leloir Glycosyltransferases, Glycoside Phosphorylases, and Transglycosidases

Carbohydrate side chain conformation is an important factor in the control of reactivity at the anomeric center, ie, in the making and breaking of glycosidic bonds, whether chemically or, for hydrolysis, by glycoside hydrolases. In nature glycosidic bond formation is catalyzed out by glycosyltransferases (GTs), glycoside phosphoryases, and transglycosidases. By analysis of 118 crystal structures of sugar nucleotide dependent (Leloir) GTs, 136 crystal structures of glycoside phosphorylases, and 54 crystal structures of transglycosidases bound to hexopyranosides or their analogs at the donor site (-1 site), we determined that most enzymes that catalyze glycoside synthesis, be they GTs, glycoside phosphorylases or transglycosidases, restrict their substrate side chains to the most reactive gauche,gauche (gg) conformation to achieve maximum stabilization of the oxocarbenium ion-like transition state for glycosyl transfer. The galactose series deviates from this trend, with α-galactosyltransferases preferentially restricting their substrates to the second-most reactive gauche,trans (gt) conformation, and β-galactosyltransferases favoring the least reactive trans,gauche (tg) conformation. This insight will help progress the design and development of improved, conformationally-restricted GT inhibitors that take advantage of these inherent side chain preferences.

An Advanced Apralog with Increased in vitro and in vivo Activity toward Gram-negative Pathogens and Reduced ex vivo Cochleotoxicity

We describe the convergent synthesis of a 5-O-β-D-ribofuranosyl-based apramycin derivative (apralog) that displays significantly improved antibacterial activity over the parent apramycin against wild-type ESKAPE pathogens. In addition, the new apralog retains excellent antibacterial activity in the presence of the only aminoglycoside modifying enzyme (AAC(3)-IV) acting on the parent, without incurring susceptibility to the APH(3') mechanism that disables other 5-O-β-D-ribofuranosyl 2-deoxystreptamine type aminoglycosides by phosphorylation at the ribose 5-position. Consistent with this antibacterial activity, the new apralog has excellent 30 nM activity (IC50 ) for the inhibition of protein synthesis by the bacterial ribosome in a cell-free translation assay, while retaining the excellent across-the-board selectivity of the parent for inhibition of bacterial over eukaryotic ribosomes. Overall, these characteristics translate into excellent in vivo efficacy against E. coli in a mouse thigh infection model and reduced ototoxicity vis à vis the parent in mouse cochlear explants.

Glycoside Hydrolases Restrict the Side Chain Conformation of Their Substrates To Gain Additional Transition State Stabilization

Carbohydrate side chain conformation confers a significant influence on reactivity during glycosylation and anomeric bond hydrolysis due to stabilization of the oxocarbenium-like transition state. By analysis of 513 pyranoside-bound glycoside hydrolase (GH) crystal structures, we determine that most glucosidases and β-mannosidases preferentially bind their substrates in the most reactive gauche,gauche (gg) conformation, thereby maximizing stabilization of the corresponding oxocarbenium ion-like transition state during hydrolysis. α-Galactoside hydrolases mostly show a preference for the second most activating gauche,trans (gt) conformation to avoid the energy penalty that would arise from imposing the gg conformation on galacto-configured ligands. These preferences stand in stark contrast to the side chain populations observed for these sugars both in free solution and bound to nonhydrolytic proteins, where for the most part a much greater diversity of side chain conformations is observed. Analysis of sequences of GH-ligand complexes reveals that side chain restriction begins with the enzyme-substrate complex and persists through the transition state until release of the hydrolysis product, despite changes in ring conformation along the reaction coordinate. This work will inform the design of new generations of glycosidase inhibitors with restricted side chains that confer higher selectivity and/or affinity.

Apralogs: Apramycin 5-O-Glycosides and Ethers with Improved Antibacterial Activity and Ribosomal Selectivity and Reduced Susceptibility to the Aminoacyltranserferase (3)-IV Resistance Determinant

Apramycin is a structurally unique member of the 2-deoxystreptamine class of aminoglycoside antibiotics characterized by a monosubstituted 2-deoxystreptamine ring that carries an unusual bicyclic eight-carbon dialdose moiety. Because of its unusual structure, apramycin is not susceptible to the most prevalent mechanisms of aminoglycoside resistance including the aminoglycoside-modifying enzymes and the ribosomal methyltransferases whose widespread presence severely compromises all aminoglycosides in current clinical practice. These attributes coupled with minimal ototoxocity in animal models combine to make apramycin an excellent starting point for the development of next-generation aminoglycoside antibiotics for the treatment of multidrug-resistant bacterial infections, particularly the ESKAPE pathogens. With this in mind, we describe the design, synthesis, and evaluation of three series of apramycin derivatives, all functionalized at the 5-position, with the goals of increasing the antibacterial potency without sacrificing selectivity between bacterial and eukaryotic ribosomes and of overcoming the rare aminoglycoside acetyltransferase (3)-IV class of aminoglycoside-modifying enzymes that constitutes the only documented mechanism of antimicrobial resistance to apramycin. We show that several apramycin-5-O-β-d-ribofuranosides, 5-O-β-d-eryrthofuranosides, and even simple 5-O-aminoalkyl ethers are effective in this respect through the use of cell-free translation assays with wild-type bacterial and humanized bacterial ribosomes and of extensive antibacterial assays with wild-type and resistant Gram negative bacteria carrying either single or multiple resistance determinants. Ex vivo studies with mouse cochlear explants confirm the low levels of ototoxicity predicted on the basis of selectivity at the target level, while the mouse thigh infection model was used to demonstrate the superiority of an apramycin-5-O-glycoside in reducing the bacterial burden in vivo.