Multiple neighboring active sites of an atomically precise copper nanocluster catalyst for efficient bond-forming reactions

Atomically precise copper nanoclusters (NCs) are an emerging class of nanomaterials for catalysis. Their versatile core-shell architecture opens the possibility of tailoring their catalytically active sites. Here, we introduce a core-shell copper nanocluster (CuNC), [Cu29(StBu)13Cl5(PPh3)4H10]tBuSO3 (StBu: tert-butylthiol; PPh3: triphenylphosphine), Cu29NC, with multiple accessible active sites on its shell. We show that this nanocluster is a versatile catalyst for C-heteroatom bond formation (C-O, C-N, and C-S) with several advantages over previous Cu systems. When supported, the cluster can also be reused as a heterogeneous catalyst without losing its efficiency, making it a hybrid homogeneous and heterogeneous catalyst. We elucidated the atomic-level mechanism of the catalysis using density functional theory (DFT) calculations based on the single crystal structure. We found that the cooperative action of multiple neighboring active sites is essential for the catalyst's efficiency. The calculations also revealed that oxidative addition is the rate-limiting step that is facilitated by the neighboring active sites of the Cu29NC, which highlights a unique advantage of nanoclusters over traditional copper catalysts. Our results demonstrate the potential of nanoclusters for enabling the rational atomically precise design and investigation of multi-site catalysts.

Tunable reactivity of silver nanoclusters: a facile route to synthesize a range of bimetallic nanostructures

Quantized energy levels and unique optoelectronic properties of atomically precise noble metal nanoclusters (NCs) have made them important in materials science, catalysis, sensors, and biomedicine. Recent studies on the profound chemical interactions of such NCs within themselves and with ultrasmall plasmonic nanoparticles (NPs) indicate that depending on the size, shape, and composition of the second reactant, NCs can either take part in colloidal assembly without any chemical modifications or lead to products with atoms exchanged. Anisotropic NPs are a unique class of plasmonic nanomaterials as their sharp edges and protrusions show higher chemical reactivity compared to flat surfaces, often leading to site-specific growth of foreign metals and metal oxide shells. Here, using chemical interactions between gold nanotriangles (AuNTs) and Ag NCs of different compositions, we show for the first time that metal atom etching, alloying/atom exchange, and colloidal assembly can all happen at a particular length scale. Specifically, Ag₂₅(DMBT)₁₈ NCs (denoted as 1), upon reacting with AuNTs of ∼57 nm edge length, etch gold atoms from their sharp tips and edges. Simultaneously, the two nanosystems exchange metal atoms, resulting in Ag-doped AuNTs and Au_xAg_24-x(DMBT)₁₈ (x = 1, 2). However, another Ag NC with the same metallic core, but a different ligand shell, namely, Ag₂₅H₂₂(DPPE)₈ (denoted as 2), creates dendritic shells made of Ag, surrounding these AuNTs under the same reaction conditions. Furthermore, we show that in the case of a more reactive thiol-protected Ag NC, namely, Ag₄₄(pMBA)₃₀ (denoted as 3), gold etching is faster from the edges and tips, which drastically alters the identities of both the reactants. Interestingly, when the AuNTs are protected by pMBA, 3 systematically assembles on AuNTs through H-bonding, resulting in an AuNT core-Ag NC shell nanocomposite. Thus, while shedding light on various factors affecting the reactivity of Ag NCs towards AuNTs, the present study proposes a single strategy to obtain a number of bimetallic nanosystems of targeted morphology and functionality.

Cocrystals of Atomically Precise Noble Metal Nanoclusters

Cocrystallization is a phenomenon involving the assembly of two or more different chemical entities in a lattice, occurring typically through supramolecular interactions. In this concept, recent advancements in the cocrystallization of atomically precise noble metal clusters and their potential future directions are presented. Different strategies to create coassemblies of thiolate-protected noble metal nanoclusters are presented first. An approach is the simultaneous synthesis, and cocrystallization of two clusters having similar structures. A unique pair of clusters found recently, namely Ag₄₀ and Ag₄₆ with same core but different shell are taken to illustrate this. In another category, the case of the same core is presented, namely Ag₁₁₆ with different shells, as in a mixture of Ag₂₁₀ and Ag₂₁₁ . Next, an intercluster reaction is presented to create cocrystals through selective crystallization of the reaction products. The coexistence of competing effects, magic sizes, and magic electron shells in a coassembly of alloy nanoclusters is discussed next. Finally, an assembly strategy for nanoclusters using electrostatic interactions is described. This concept is concluded with a future perspective on the emerging possibilities of such solids. Advancements in this field will certainly help the development of novel materials with exciting properties.

Reaction between Ag17+ and acetylene outside the mass spectrometer: dehydrogenation in the gas phase

We present the first example of acetylide protected silver clusters by a reaction between Ag₁₇⁺ and acetylene, conducted around atmospheric pressure. The products were obtained after dehydrogenation of acetylene in the gas phase. The observed reaction mechanism may be helpful to design new catalysts useful in organometallic chemistry.

Interparticle Reactions between Silver Nanoclusters Leading to Product Cocrystals by Selective Cocrystallization

We present an example of an interparticle reaction between atomically precise nanoclusters (NCs) of the same metal, resulting in entirely different clusters. In detail, the clusters [Ag₁₂(TBT)₈(TFA)₅(CH₃CN)]⁺ (TBT = tert-butylthiolate, TFA = trifluoroacetate, CH₃CN = acetonitrile) and [Ag₁₈(TPP)₁₀H₁₆]²⁺ (TPP = triphenylphosphine) abbreviated as Ag₁₂ and Ag₁₈, respectively, react leading to [Ag₁₆(TBT)₈(TFA)₇(CH₃CN)₃Cl]⁺ and [Ag₁₇(TBT)₈(TFA)₇(CH₃CN)₃Cl]⁺, abbreviated as Ag₁₆ and Ag₁₇, respectively. The two product NCs crystallize together as both possess the same metal chalcogenolate shell, composed of Ag₁₆S₈, making them indistinguishable. The occupancies of Ag₁₆ and Ag₁₇ are 66.66 and 33.33%, respectively, in a single crystal. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI MS) of the reaction product and a dissolved crystal show the population of Ag₁₆ and Ag₁₇ NCs to be in a 1:1 and 2:1 ratio, respectively. This suggests selective crystallization in the cocrystal. Time-dependent ESI MS was employed to understand the formation of product clusters by monitoring the reaction intermediates formed in the course of the reaction. We present an unprecedented growth mechanism for the formation of silver NCs mediated by silver thiolate intermediates.

Confining an Ag10 Core in an Ag12 Shell: A Four-Electron Superatom with Enhanced Photoluminescence upon Crystallization

We introduce a cluster coprotected by thiol and diphosphine ligands, [Ag₂₂(dppe)₄(2,5-DMBT)₁₂Cl₄]²⁺ (dppe = 1,2-bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane; 2,5-DMBT= 2,5-dimethylbenzenethiol), which has an Ag₁₀ core encapsulated by an Ag₁₂(dppe)₄(2,5-DMBT)₁₂Cl₄ shell. The Ag₁₀ core comprises two Ag₅ distorted trigonal bipyramidal units and is uncommon in Au and Ag nanoclusters. The electrospray ionization mass spectrum reveals that the cluster is divalent and contains four free electrons. An uncommon crystallization-induced enhancement of emission is observed in the cluster. The emission is weak in the solution and amorphous states. However, it is enhanced 12 times in the crystalline state compared to the amorphous state. A detailed investigation of the crystal structure suggests that well-arranged C-H···π and π···π interactions between the ligands are the major factors for this enhanced emission. Further, in-depth structural elucidation and density functional theory calculations suggest that the cluster is a superatom with four magic electrons.

Formation of an NIR-emitting Ag34S3SBB20(CF3COO)62+ cluster from a hydride-protected silver cluster

Formation of an NIR emitting Ag₃₄S₃SBB₂₀(CF₃COO)₆²⁺ cluster.

A covalently linked dimer of [Ag25(DMBT)18]−

We report the first example of a covalently bound dimer of monolayer protected atomically precise silver nanocluster [Ag₂₅(DMBT)₁₈]⁻ (DMBT stands for 2,4-dimethylbenzenethiol).

A thirty-fold photoluminescence enhancement induced by secondary ligands in monolayer protected silver clusters

In this paper, we demonstrate that systematic replacement of the secondary ligand PPh3 leads to an enhancement in the near-infrared (NIR) photoluminescence (PL) of [Ag29(BDT)12(PPh3)4]3-. While the replacement of PPh3 with other monophosphines enhances luminescence slightly, the replacement with diphosphines of increasing chain length leads to a drastic PL enhancement, as high as 30 times compared to the parent cluster, [Ag29(BDT)12(PPh3)4]3-. Computational modeling suggests that the emission is a ligand to metal charge transfer (LMCT) which is affected by the nature of the secondary ligand. Control experiments with systematic replacement of the secondary ligand confirm its influence on the emission. The excited state dynamics shows this emission to be phosphorescent in nature which arises from the triplet excited state. This enhanced luminescence has been used to develop a prototypical O2 sensor. Moreover, a similar enhancement was also found for [Ag51(BDT)19(PPh3)3]3-. The work presents an easy approach to the PL enhancement of Ag clusters for various applications.

Preparation of gas phase naked silver cluster cations outside a mass spectrometer from ligand protected clusters in solution

Gas phase clusters of noble metals prepared by laser desorption from the bulk have been investigated extensively in a vacuum using mass spectrometry. However, such clusters have not been known to exist under ambient conditions to date. In our previous work, we have shown that in-source fragmentation of ligands can be achieved starting from hydride and phosphine co-protected silver clusters leading to naked silver clusters inside a mass spectrometer. In a recent series of experiments, we have found that systematic desorption of ligands of the monolayer protected atomically precise silver cluster can also occur in the atmospheric gas phase. Here, we present the results, wherein the [Ag18H16(TPP)10]2+ (TPP = triphenylphosphine) cluster results in the formation of the naked cluster, Ag17+ along with Ag18H+ without mass selection, outside the mass spectrometer, in air. These cationic naked metal clusters are prepared by passing electrosprayed ligand protected clusters through a heated tube, in the gas phase. Reactions with oxygen suggest Ag17+ to be more reactive than Ag18H+, in agreement with their electronic structures. The more common thiolate protected clusters produce fragments of metal thiolates under identical processing conditions and no naked clusters were observed.

Polymorphism of Ag29(BDT)12(TPP)43- cluster: interactions of secondary ligands and their effect on solid state luminescence

We present the first example of polymorphism (cubic & trigonal) in single crystals of an atomically precise monolayer protected cluster, Ag29(BDT)12(TPP)43-. We demonstrate that C-Hπ interactions of the secondary ligands (TPP) are dominant in a cubic lattice compared to a trigonal lattice, resulting in a greater rigidity of the structure, which in turn, results in a higher luminescence efficiency in it.

Sequential Dihydrogen Desorption from Hydride-Protected Atomically Precise Silver Clusters and the Formation of Naked Clusters in the Gas Phase

We report the formation of naked cluster ions of silver of specific nuclearities, uncontaminated by other cluster ions, derived from monolayer-protected clusters. The hydride and phosphine co-protected cluster, [Ag₁₈(TPP)₁₀H₁₆]²⁺ (TPP, triphenylphosphine), upon activation produces the naked cluster ion, Ag₁₇⁺, exclusively. The number of metal atoms present in the naked cluster is almost the same as that in the parent material. Two more naked cluster ions, Ag₂₁⁺ and Ag₁₉⁺, were also formed starting from two other protected clusters, [Ag₂₅(DPPE)₈H₂₂]³⁺ and [Ag₂₂(DPPE)₈H₁₉]³⁺, respectively (DPPE, 1,2-bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane). By systematic fragmentation, naked clusters of varying nuclei are produced from Ag₁₇⁺ to Ag₁⁺ selectively, with systematic absence of Ag₁₀⁺, Ag₆⁺, and Ag₄⁺. A seemingly odd number of cluster ions are preferred due to the stability of the closed electronic shells. Sequential desorption of dihydrogen occurs from the cluster ion, Ag₁₇H₁₄⁺, during the formation of Ag_n⁺. A comparison of the pathways in the formation of similar naked cluster ions starting from two differently ligated clusters has been presented. This approach developed bridges the usually distinct fields of gas-phase metal cluster chemistry and solution-phase metal cluster chemistry. We hope that our findings will enrich nanoscience and nanotechnology beyond the field of clusters.