Intellectual disability genomics: current state, pitfalls and future challenges

Intellectual disability (ID) can be caused by non-genetic and genetic factors, the latter being responsible for more than 1700 ID-related disorders. The broad ID phenotypic and genetic heterogeneity, as well as the difficulty in the establishment of the inheritance pattern, often result in a delay in the diagnosis. It has become apparent that massive parallel sequencing can overcome these difficulties. In this review we address: (i) ID genetic aetiology, (ii) clinical/medical settings testing, (iii) massive parallel sequencing, (iv) variant filtering and prioritization, (v) variant classification guidelines and functional studies, and (vi) ID diagnostic yield. Furthermore, the need for a constant update of the methodologies and functional tests, is essential. Thus, international collaborations, to gather expertise, data and resources through multidisciplinary contributions, are fundamental to keep track of the fast progress in ID gene discovery.

Diurnal variations in keratometry and refraction with intracorneal ring segments

PURPOSE

To study refraction variations during the day in eyes with intrastromal corneal ring segments (ICRS) to correct low myopia.

SETTING

Monticelli Clinic, Marseille, France.

METHODS

Thirteen eyes with ICRS were included in the study; the ICRS was explanted from 3 eyes because of undercorrection. The minimum follow-up in all eyes was 1 year. The same observer measured refraction and keratometry at 9:00 AM, 1:00 PM, and 7:00 PM with the same autokeratorefractometer. To validate the analysis method, these eyes were compared with a group of emmetropic control eyes that had not had surgery and with a group of eyes that had photorefractive keratectomy for a similar degree of myopia. All measurements were done under the same conditions.

RESULTS

After 1 year, the ICRS eyes showed a tendency toward an evening myopic shift. This was confirmed by the objective keratometry study, which showed variations closely correlated with the myopia observed. These phenomena were not observed in the other groups.

CONCLUSION

The ICRS had satisfactory predictability in eyes with up to -3.50 diopters of myopia. However, the evening myopic shift appeared similar to that observed after radial keratotomy.

Impaired catabolism of free oligosaccharides due to MAN2C1 variants causes a neurodevelopmental disorder

Free oligosaccharides (fOSs) are soluble oligosaccharide species generated during N-glycosylation of proteins. Although little is known about fOS metabolism, the recent identification of NGLY1 deficiency, a congenital disorder of deglycosylation (CDDG) caused by loss of function of an enzyme involved in fOS metabolism, has elicited increased interest in fOS processing. The catabolism of fOSs has been linked to the activity of a specific cytosolic mannosidase, MAN2C1, which cleaves α1,2-, α1,3-, and α1,6-mannose residues. In this study, we report the clinical, biochemical, and molecular features of six individuals, including two fetuses, with bi-allelic pathogenic variants in MAN2C1; the individuals are from four different families. These individuals exhibit dysmorphic facial features, congenital anomalies such as tongue hamartoma, variable degrees of intellectual disability, and brain anomalies including polymicrogyria, interhemispheric cysts, hypothalamic hamartoma, callosal anomalies, and hypoplasia of brainstem and cerebellar vermis. Complementation experiments with isogenic MAN2C1-KO HAP1 cells confirm the pathogenicity of three of the identified MAN2C1 variants. We further demonstrate that MAN2C1 variants lead to accumulation and delay in the processing of fOSs in proband-derived cells. These results emphasize the involvement of MAN2C1 in human neurodevelopmental disease and the importance of fOS catabolism.

Classical fragile-X phenotype in a female infant disclosed by comprehensive genomic studies

BACKGROUND

We describe a female infant with Fragile-X syndrome, with a fully expanded FMR1 allele and preferential inactivation of the homologous X-chromosome carrying a de novo deletion. This unusual and rare case demonstrates the importance of a detailed genomic approach, the absence of which could be misguiding, and calls for reflection on the current clinical and diagnostic workup for developmental disabilities.

CASE PRESENTATION

We present a female infant, referred for genetic testing due to psychomotor developmental delay without specific dysmorphic features or relevant family history. FMR1 mutation screening revealed a methylated full mutation and a normal but inactive FMR1 allele, which led to further investigation. Complete skewing of X-chromosome inactivation towards the paternally-inherited normal-sized FMR1 allele was found. No pathogenic variants were identified in the XIST promoter. Microarray analysis revealed a 439 kb deletion at Xq28, in a region known to be associated with extreme skewing of X-chromosome inactivation.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall results enable us to conclude that the developmental delay is the cumulative result of a methylated FMR1 full mutation on the active X-chromosome and the inactivation of the other homologue carrying the de novo 439 kb deletion. Our findings should be taken into consideration in future guidelines for the diagnostic workup on the diagnosis of intellectual disabilities, particularly in female infant cases.

Characterisation of several ankyrin repeat protein variant 2, a phosphoprotein phosphatase 1-interacting protein, in testis and spermatozoa

Phosphoprotein phosphatase 1 (PPP1) catalytic subunit gamma 2 (PPP1CC2), a PPP1 isoform, is largely restricted to testicular germ cells and spermatozoa. The key to understanding PPP1 regulation in male germ cells lies in the identification and characterisation of its interacting partners. This study was undertaken to determine the expression patterns of the several ankyrin repeat protein variant 2 (SARP2), a PPP1-interacting protein, in testis and spermatozoa. SARP2 was found to be highly expressed in testis and spermatozoa, and its interaction with human spermatozoa endogenous PPP1CC2 was confirmed by immunoprecipitation. Expression analysis by RT-qPCR revealed that SARP2 and PPP1CC2 mRNA levels were significantly higher in the spermatocyte fraction. However, microscopy revealed that SARP2 protein was only present in the nucleus of elongating and mature spermatids and in spermatozoa. In spermatozoa, SARP2 was prominently expressed in the connecting piece and flagellum, as well as, to a lesser extent, in the acrosome. A yeast two-hybrid approach was used to detect SARP2-interacting proteins and a relevant interaction with a novel sperm-associated antigen 9 (SPAG9) variant, a testis and spermatozoa-specific c-Jun N-terminal kinase-binding protein, was validated in human spermatozoa. Given the expression pattern of SARP2 and its association with PPP1CC2 and SPAG9, it may play a role in spermiogenesis and sperm function, namely in sperm motility and the acrosome reaction.

Two Compound Heterozygous Variants in SNX14 Cause Stereotypies and Dystonia in Autosomal Recessive Spinocerebellar Ataxia 20

Autosomal Recessive Spinocerebellar Ataxia 20, SCAR20, is a rare condition characterized by intellectual disability, lack of speech, ataxia, coarse facies and macrocephaly, caused by SNX14 variants. While all cases described are due to homozygous variants that generally result in loss of protein, so far there are no other cases of reported compound heterozygous variants. Here we describe the first non-consanguineous SCAR20 family, the second Portuguese, with two siblings presenting similar clinical features caused by compound heterozygous SNX14 variants: NM_001350532.1:c.1195C>T, p.(Arg399*) combined with a novel complex genomic rearrangement. Quantitative PCR (Q-PCR), long-range PCR and sequencing was used to elucidate the region and mechanisms involved in the latter: two deletions, an inversion and an AG insertion: NM_001350532.1:c.[612+3028_698-2759del;698-2758_698-516inv;698-515_1171+1366delinsAG]. In silico analyses of these variants are in agreement with causality, enabling a genotype-phenotype correlation in both patients. Clinical phenotype includes dystonia and stereotypies never associated with SCAR20. Overall, this study allowed to extend the knowledge of the phenotypic and mutational spectrum of SCAR20, and to validate the role of Sorting nexin-14 in a well-defined neurodevelopmental syndrome, which can lead to cognitive impairment. We also highlight the value of an accurate clinical evaluation and deep phenotyping to disclose the molecular defect underlying highly heterogeneous condition such as intellectual disability.

Development and Validation of a Mathematical Model to Predict the Complexity of FMR1 Allele Combinations

The polymorphic trinucleotide repetitive region in the FMR1 gene 5'UTR contains AGG interspersions, particularly in normal-sized alleles (CGG < 45). In this range repetitive stretches are typically interrupted once or twice, although alleles without or with three or more AGG interspersions can also be observed. AGG interspersions together with the total length of the repetitive region confer stability and hinder expansion to pathogenic ranges: either premutation (55 < CGG < 200) or full mutation (CGG > 200). The AGG interspersions have long been identified as one of the most important features of FMR1 repeat stability, being particularly important to determine expansion risk estimates in female premutation carriers. We sought to compute the combined AGG interspersion numbers and patterns, aiming to define FMR1 repetitive tract complexity combinations. A mathematical model, the first to compute this cumulative effect, was developed and validated using data from 131 young and healthy females. Plotting of their allelic complexity enabled the identification of two statistically distinct groups - equivalent and dissimilar allelic combinations. The outcome, a numerical parameter designated allelic score, depicts the repeat substructure of each allele, measuring the allelic complexity of the FMR1 gene including the AGGs burden, thus allowing new behavioral scrutiny of normal-sized alleles in females.

Expanding the pre- and postnatal phenotype of WASHC5 and CCDC22 -related Ritscher-Schinzel syndromes

Ritscher-Schinzel syndrome (RTSCS) is a rare genetic condition characterized by peculiar craniofacial features and cerebellar and cardiovascular malformations. To date, four genes are implicated in this condition. The first two genes described were the autosomal recessive inherited gene WASHC5 associated with Ritscher-Schinzel syndrome 1 (RTSCS1), and CCDC22, an X-linked recessive gene causing Ritscher-Schinzel syndrome 2 (RTSCS2). In recent years, two other genes have been identified: VPS35L (RTSCS3) and DPYSL5 (RTSCS4). Only few patients with a molecular diagnosis of RTSCS have been reported, leaving the phenotypical spectrum and genotype-phenotype correlations ill-defined. We expand the number of genetically confirmed patients with RTSCS1 and 2; reporting three live born and three terminated pregnancies from two unrelated families. Four siblings carried compound heterozygous variants in WASHC5 while two siblings harboured a hemizygous CCDC22 variant. The most common findings in all patients were craniofacial dysmorphism, particularly macrocephaly, down slanted palpebral fissures and low set-ears. Developmental delay, intellectual disability and ataxic gait were present in all patients. One of the patients with the CCDC22 variant presented pubertas tarda. Elevation of nuchal translucency was observed in the first trimester ultrasound in three foetuses with compound heterozygous variants in WASHC5. None of the patients had epilepsy. The pre- and postnatal findings of this cohort expand the known phenotype of RTSCS1 and 2, with direct impact on postnatal outcome, management, and familial counseling.

Two Novel Pathogenic MID1 Variants and Genotype-Phenotype Correlation Reanalysis in X-Linked Opitz G/BBB Syndrome

X-linked Opitz G/BBB syndrome (XLOS) is a multisystemic congenital condition, caused by mutations in the midline-1 gene (MID1), characterized by a large inter- and intrafamilial phenotypic variability and often associated with intellectual disability (ID). We report clinical, genetic, and molecular findings in 4 patients with typical XLOS dysmorphic features belonging to 2 unrelated families. Two novel pathogenic loss-of-function MID1 variants, a maternally inherited c.1656del and a de novo c.1215_1228dup, were identified. Subsequently, we performed a genotype-phenotype analysis using data from 91 male XLOS patients. To test the mutation impact on the phenotype; the type of mutation, the MID1-impaired domain and function were compared with the presence of each of the major clinical features (hypertelorism, clefts of the lip and/or palate, laryngo-tracheo-esophageal abnormalities, hypospadias and ID) and minor clinical features (brain, heart, and anal defects). No statistically significant correlation was found with these features. Further investigations, as well as exhaustive and unequivocal phenotyping, may be required to improve our knowledge of the biological mechanisms underlying this syndrome and to provide more adequate disease management.

Missense MED12 variants in 22 males with intellectual disability: From nonspecific symptoms to complete syndromes

We describe the phenotype of 22 male patients (20 probands) carrying a hemizygous missense variant in MED12. The phenotypic spectrum is very broad ranging from nonspecific intellectual disability (ID) to the three well-known syndromes: Opitz-Kaveggia syndrome, Lujan-Fryns syndrome, or Ohdo syndrome. The identified variants were randomly distributed throughout the gene (p = 0.993, χ2 test), but mostly outside the functional domains (p = 0.004; χ2 test). Statistical analyses did not show a correlation between the MED12-related phenotypes and the locations of the variants (p = 0.295; Pearson correlation), nor the protein domain involved (p = 0.422; Pearson correlation). In conclusion, establishing a genotype-phenotype correlation in MED12-related diseases remains challenging. Therefore, we think that patients with a causative MED12 variant are currently underdiagnosed due to the broad patients' clinical presentations.

Usher syndrome and Nebulin-associated myopathy in a single patient due to variants in MYO7A and NEB

In a patient with Usher syndrome and atypical muscle complaints, we have identified two separate variants in MYO7A andNEB genes by exome sequencing. The homozygous variants in these two recessive genes could explain the full phenotype of our patient.

[Diagnosis wi transesophageal echocardiography and clinical course of 35 patients with flail mitral valve]

PURPOSE

To describe transesophageal echocardiographic findings in patients presenting with flail mitral valve and to obtain their clinical follow-up.

METHODS

From January/93 to March/97, 1675 patients were submitted to transesophageal echocardiogram at our institution; 35 of them were diagnosed as having flail mitral valve and their clinical follow-up was obtained.

RESULTS

Thirty-five patients with the diagnosis of flail mitral valve were studied. Mean age was 65 +/- 15 years (12-87) and 27 (77%) were male. The posterior leaflet was involved in 25 (71%) patients. Ruptured chrodae tendineae was present in all but one patient in whom flail mitral valve was due to a very elongated and redundant chordae. The etiology was prolapse and/or mixomatous degeneration in 16 patients, degenerative in 10, ischemic in 5, rheumatic in 4 and endocarditis in 3. Mitral regurgitation was severe in 25 (71%) patients and moderate in 10 (29%). The mean follow-up was 375 +/- 395 days (1 to 1380). Nineteen patients were followed clinically and 16 were submitted to surgery (transesophageal echocardiogram findings were confirmed in all 16). Overall mortality was high (34%). Among the survivors, 17 are in NYHA class I and 6 in class II.

CONCLUSION

The diagnosis of flail mitral valve by transesophageal echocardiography is accurate, allowing for the definition of its mechanism and etiology, as well as the evaluation of hemodynamic compromise. The observed high mortality at the time of diagnosis may be related to the severity of the disease causing the flail mitral valve. Although non-operated survivors are doing well, the observed low functional class in these patients may be related to the short period of follow-up.

[Diurnal variations of refraction and keratometry after intracorneal rings]

Within a European evaluation, we participated in the study of ICRS on low myopia. During the period of observation, subjective refraction variations in the day were underlined. This phenomenon remains to be specified.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Thirteen eyes were included in the study, 3 were explanted because of under-correction. The minimum follow-up is one year for all eyes. The same observer measured refraction and keratometry in all eyes on the same day at 9:00 am, 1:00 p.m. and 7:00 p.m., with the same automatic autokeratorefractometer. To validate the analysis method, these patients were compared with a group of emmetropic control eyes never operated on and with a group of eyes operated on with a PRK for similar myopia. All measurements were done under the same conditions.

RESULTS

After one year, a tendency to evening myopisation was noticed in ICRS eyes and confirmed by the objective keratometry study showing variations closely correlated with the myopia observed. These phenomena were not observed in the two other groups.

DISCUSSION

The examination technique was validated by the absence of variation observed on normal eyes. The tendency to diurnal myopisation is rather constant on the whole population studied with a more or less important degree from patient to patient. These observations never reported in the literature, deserve to be confirmed on other sites.

CONCLUSION

In this study ICRS allowed to correct low myopia with a satisfactory predictability up to -3.50 D. However, the appearance of an evening myopisation recalls that observed after radial keratotomy. Complementary studies are necessary to explain the intimate mechanism of this phenomenon.

Development and validation in 500 female samples of a TP-PCR assay to identify AFF2 GCC expansions

Over 100 X-linked intellectual disability genes have been identified, with triplet repeat expansions at the FMR1 (FRAXA) and AFF2 (FRAXE) genes being the causative agent in two of them. The absence of FRAXE pathognomonic features hampers early recognition, delaying testing and molecular confirmation. Hence, our laboratory uses a multiplex PCR-based strategy to genotype both FRAXA and FRAXE. However, AFF2 expansions are missed giving rise to an uninformative result in around 20% of female samples. To rule out undetected expansions and confirm homozygosity Southern blot analysis is performed being labour- and resource-intensive. The aim of this study is to develop a timely and economic triplet-primed amplification (TP-PCR) screening strategy to size the AFF2 GCC repeat and accurately assess homozygosity as well as pinpoint multiplex-PCR false negatives in female samples. In order to achieve this, validation was performed in a cohort of 500 females with a previous uninformative FRAXE PCR result. Interestingly, the presence of a T > C SNP (rs868949662), contiguous to the GCC repetitive tract, allows triplet primer binding in two additional repeats, increasing the discrimination power of the TP-PCR assay in heterozygous and homozygous samples. Twelve alleles outside the normal range were recognized: eight intermediate and four premutated, which seems relevant considering the rarity of the AFF2 expansions. All genotypes are concordant with that obtained by Southern blotting, confirming this as a strict, reproducible and low-cost homozygosity screening strategy that enables the identification of small expanded alleles missed by the routine multiplex-PCR due to allele dropout. Overall, this assay is capable of spotting multiplex-PCR false negatives besides identifying alleles up to > 80 GCC repeats. Furthermore, the occurrence of intermediate repeat sizes with unexpected frequency, introduces new areas of clinical research in this cohort in understanding these less explored AFF2 repeat sizes and newly associated phenotypes.

Can the Synergic Contribution of Multigenic Variants Explain the Clinical and Cellular Phenotypes of a Neurodevelopmental Disorder?

We describe an infant female with a syndromic neurodevelopmental clinical phenotype and increased chromosome instability as cellular phenotype. Genotype characterization revealed heterozygous variants in genes directly or indirectly linked to DNA repair: a de novo X-linked HDAC8 pathogenic variant, a paternally inherited FANCG pathogenic variant and a maternally inherited BRCA2 variant of uncertain significance. The full spectrum of the phenotype cannot be explained by any of the heterozygous variants on their own; thus, a synergic contribution is proposed. Complementation studies showed that the FANCG gene from the Fanconi Anaemia/BRCA (FA/BRCA) DNA repair pathway was impaired, indicating that the variant in FANCG contributes to the cellular phenotype. The patient's chromosome instability represents the first report where heterozygous variant(s) in the FA/BRCA pathway are implicated in the cellular phenotype. We propose that a multigenic contribution of heterozygous variants in HDAC8 and the FA/BRCA pathway might have a role in the phenotype of this neurodevelopmental disorder. The importance of these findings may have repercussion in the clinical management of other cases with a similar synergic contribution of heterozygous variants, allowing the establishment of new genotype-phenotype correlations and motivating the biochemical study of the underlying mechanisms.

Postpartum Ankle Pain: A Suspected Complex Regional Pain Syndrome or a Rare Cause of Septic Arthritis?

Ankle tuberculosis is a relatively rare condition and may develop after hematogenous dissemination from the pulmonary origin, particularly in cases of immunosuppression. Both pregnancy and delivery are relatively immunosuppressive states, and immune modulations during these periods can contribute to the pathogenesis of disseminated tuberculosis. A 26-year-old mother presented with severe, continuous, and debilitating pain in the left ankle, lasting for three months after delivery and associated with fever. Inspection demonstrated ankle swelling and redness, with a cold and cyanotic forefoot. Ankle radiograph and musculoskeletal ultrasound evaluation were obtained. Tibiotalar joint arthrocentesis revealed purulent liquid suggestive of septic arthritis and an emergent arthroscopic washout of the ankle was performed. The synovial mycobacterial culture was posteriorly positive and the diagnosis established was both pulmonary and osteoarticular tuberculosis. A comprehensive rehabilitation program was then implemented to achieve maximum functional gains. This report presents a rare case of ankle tuberculosis diagnosed in the postpartum period. Early evaluation, treatment, and adequate rehabilitation interventions can be crucial to promote functionality and enhance the quality of life.

Enhancing clinical decision-making for CNVs of uncertain significance in neurodevelopmental disorders: the relevance (or uselessness) of scoring and segregating

BACKGROUND

Clinicians often deal with copy-number variants of unknown significance (CNVUS) when managing neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs). Variant classification is often complemented with textual comments, while the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG)/Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) numerical scores are rarely reported. Our aim was to determine if the application of ACMG/ClinGen scoring and inheritance/segregation studies are relevant for the reclassification of CNVUS.

METHODS

We retrieved 167 CNVUS (112 duplications, 55 heterozygous deletions) from test reports of 141 patients with NDD in a 5-year period. None of those testing reports included ACMG/ClinGen scoring information for the CNVUS. One clinical and one laboratorial geneticist independently applied the ACMG/ClinGen scoring system for CNVs. Final scores/categories were assessed for potential modification when adding inheritance/segregation criteria.

RESULTS

138 (83%) of the CNVUS retained the VUS classification, 14 (8%) changed to benign and 15 (9%) to (likely) pathogenic. Variants deemed benign (11 duplications, 3 deletions) mostly overlapped with ClinGen-established benign regions or were common in the general population; variants deemed (likely) pathogenic (all deletions) were either associated with unrelated autosomal recessive/later-onset autosomal dominant (AD) conditions, or with an AD NDD phenotype in a single case. Inheritance studies were available for 20 (12%) variants (17 inherited, 3 de novo), and none led to a change in classification. A simulation showed that adding inheritance information would also not change the classification of any other variant.

CONCLUSION

Application of the ACMG/ClinGen scoring system led by itself to reclassification of 17% of VUS, despite a very low increase in diagnostic yield (1/141, 0.7%). Additionally, segregation/inheritance studies in CNVUS were mostly irrelevant in most NDD cases, challenging their routine broad application in clinical practice.

Use of the FMR1 Gene Methylation Status to Assess the X-Chromosome Inactivation Pattern: A Stepwise Analysis

X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) is a developmental process to compensate the imbalance in the dosage of X-chromosomal genes in females. A skewing of the XCI pattern may suggest a carrier status for an X-linked disease or explain the presence of a severe phenotype. In these cases, it is important to determine the XCI pattern, conventionally using the gold standard Human Androgen-Receptor Assay (HUMARA), based on the analysis of the methylation status at a polymorphic CAG region in the first exon of the human androgen receptor gene (AR). The aim of this study was to evaluate whether the methylation status of the fragile mental retardation protein translational regulator gene (FMR1) can provide an XCI pattern similar to that obtained by HUMARA. A set of 48 female carriers of FMR1 gene normal-sized alleles was examined using two assays: HUMARA and a FMR1 methylation PCR (mPCR). Ranges were defined to establish the XCI pattern using the methylation pattern of the FMR1 gene by mPCR. Overall, a 77% concordance of the XCI patterns was obtained between the two assays, which led us to propose a set of key points and a stepwise analysis towards obtaining an accurate result for the XCI pattern and to minimize the underlying pitfalls.