Effect of genetic modification of acute inflammatory responsiveness on tumorigenesis in the mouse

Two distinct bidirectional selective breedings for quantitative traits were initiated from identical genetically heterogeneous mouse populations. The resulting lines are characterized by maximal or minimal acute inflammatory responsiveness (AIR): AIRmax and AIRmin lines, respectively, and by resistance or susceptibility to chemical skin tumorigenesis: Car-R and Car-S lines, respectively. The AIR response to s.c. injection of polyacrylamide microbeads, measured by cell content in the local exudate, was 10 times higher in AIRmax than in AIRmin mice. The response to selection was asymmetrical: the realized heritability was 0.26 in AIRmax and 0.008 in AIRmin, and resulted from the additive effect of 7-11 quantitative trait loci (QTL). Low responsiveness was globally dominant in F1 and 48% of F2 segregant variance was found to be due to genetic factors. These findings are the first demonstration of innate regulation of AIR by germ line genes. Susceptibility to skin tumorigenesis induced by a two-stage initiation (DMBA)-promotion (TPA) protocol was lower in AIRmax mice than in AIRmin mice, a 6-fold difference in tumor induction rate. Intense AIR was found to be associated with resistance, and low AIR with susceptibility to tumorigenesis, in F2 segregants chosen for extreme AIR phenotypes. At least some of the AIR QTLs therefore contain genes controlling tumorigenesis. Tumor phenotypes differed more in Car-R and Car-S than in AIRmax and AIRmin lines, indicating that QTLs unrelated to AIR, contribute to the host response to tumorigenesis. The extreme phenotypes/genotypes of the four selected lines and the known genetic constitution of their foundation population, offer new possibilities to discriminate the genes/mechanisms controlling two important traits: AIR and response to chemical tumorigenesis. Collaborative projects will be favorably considered. The description of tumor resistance genes in AIRmax and Car-R mice may be helpful for epidemiology and therapy of human cancer.

Specific and non-specific T-cell activation in high and low antibody-producing mice (selection IV-A)

The T-cell regulatory function has been evaluated in lines of mice genetically selected according to the High (H) and Low (L) antibody responsiveness to heterologous erythrocytes. The inhibition of antibody production following CD4+ subset depletion was stronger in L than in H mice. The dose of CD4-specific monoclonal antibody (MoAb) needed for a 50% inhibition of the anti-sheep erythrocyte antibody response was much lower in L mice, even when their responsiveness was improved by repeated antigen injections or by co-injection of lipopolysaccharide as an adjuvant. Lymph-node cells from L mice responded normally or even better than those from H mice to in vitro non-specific triggering via lectins, exogenous superantigens or CD3-specific MoAb. In contrast, the antigen-specific responses of the lymph-node cells from protein-primed mice were consistently lower in the Low responder mice. Altogether the results suggest that a defective stimulation of T helper lymphocytes by the antigen contributes to the weak antibody response of L mice.

Genetics of nonspecific immunity: I. Bidirectional selective breeding of lines of mice endowed with maximal or minimal inflammatory responsiveness

The genetic regulation of acute inflammatory reaction (AIR) was studied by the method of bidirectional selective breeding, used to produce a line of mice giving the maximal and a line of mice giving the minimal inflammatory reaction (AIR max and AIR min, respectively). The AIR was triggered by subcutaneous injection of a neutral substrate (suspension of polyacrylamide microbeads), and measured by the leukocyte and serum protein accumulation in the exudate. The two parameters are positively correlated and present a normal frequency distribution. The highly genetically heterogeneous foundation population was produced by the equipoised intercrossing of eight inbred strains of mice, and selective breeding carried out by assortative matings of extreme phenotypes. The response to selection in 11 consecutive generations was highly asymmetrical: a marked AIR increase in the AIR max and no change in the AIR min line occurred. The mean value of realized heritability in the AIR max line was 0.26 and 0.18 for cell and protein concentrations, respectively. The response to selection must have resulted from the interaction of seven to nine independent gene loci endowed with additive effects. The lack of response to selection of the AIR min line is discussed. The large inter-line difference opens new possibilities for studying the biochemistry and molecular genetics of inflammation, and also for investigating the beneficial or detrimental effect of inflammatory responses.

T-helper functions in lines of mice selected for high or low antibody production (Selection III): modulation by anti-CD4+ monoclonal antibody

T-helper function was evaluated in mice genetically selected for high (H) or low (L) antibody (Ab) responsiveness to Salmonella flagellar antigen (Ag) (Selection III). In this Selection as opposed to what was demonstrated in Selections I, II and IVA, the interline difference was not proven to be based upon the modification of Ag processing and presentation at macrophage level. CD4+/CD8+ lymph node ratio is similar in HIII and LIII mice, both lines being equally susceptible to in vivo depletion of CD4+ T cells by GK 1-5 monoclonal antibody (mAb) treatment. Nevertheless, the Ab responsiveness of the two lines was differently modulated by GK 1-5 mAb: the inhibition of Ab responses to various Ag required lower mAb doses and was long lasting in LIII as compared to the transient effect of higher mAb doses observed in HIII. LIII mice were also refractory to Salmonella-induced reversion of GK 1-5 mAb inhibition. Moreover, in vitro specific I proliferation was constantly lower in LIII, though its IL-2 production was unexpectedly similar to that of HIII T cells. Results of in vivo and in vitro experiments are thus consistent with a defective response of T-helper cells to immunogenic challenge in LIII mice.

Salmonella typhimurium infection in high and low antibody responder mice: inverse correlation between antibody responsiveness and resistance to infection

Susceptibility to Salmonella typhimurium infection was compared in H (high Ab responder) and L (low Ab responder) mice obtained by several selective breeding experiments (Selections I, II, III, IV and IV A). H mice were always much more susceptible to infection than their L mice counterparts within a continuous LD 50 variation range. In three of the selections (I, II and IV A) the low responsiveness character is known to result mainly from rapid Ag degradation in L mice macrophages. It was hypothesized that resistance to multiplication of intracellular pathogens could be related to an increased catabolic activity towards Ag. This was actually demonstrated, in F2 segregant hybrids of selection IV A, by the significant inverse correlation between capacity for Ab production and resistance to infection.

Polygenic control of quantitative antibody responsiveness: restrictions of the multispecific effect related to the selection antigen

Among the differences observed between the various high (H) and low (L) antibody responder lines of mice resulting from distinct bidirectional selective breedings, one of the most puzzling is the variation in the "multispecific effect," i.e., in the modification of antibody responses to antigens unrelated to those used during the selection. The best examples are the H and L lines of selection IV, selected on the basis of responses to somatic antigen of Salmonella which do not differ in their antibody responses to sheep erythrocytes (SE). However, a wide range of variability is observed in the responses of (HIV X LIV)F2 hybrids to this antigen, and it was therefore hypothesized that distinct groups of genes might regulate antibody responses to SE and the somatic antigen. Indeed, a new selection (IV-A) for anti-SE responsiveness started from these (HIV X LIV)F2 successfully produced a high and a low anti-SE responder line. The results of selection IV-A and the variance analysis of (HIV-A X LIV-A)F2 hybrids are reported. They are roughly similar to those in selection I, also carried out for anti-SE responsiveness. In vivo attempts to identify the major regulatory mechanism which contributes to the interline difference indicate that the efficiency of macrophage accessory function has been modified in selection IV-A, as was observed in selection I, whereas this function did not differ in HIV and LIV lines. Probably in relation to the involvement of macrophage function there is a notable increase of the multispecific effect in selection IV-A when compared with selection IV. The results of selection IV-A demonstrate that responsiveness to heterologous erythrocytes and to somatic antigen of Salmonella are under separate polygenic control operating through distinct regulatory mechanisms. The choice of the selection antigen and immunization procedure is of major importance for defining the gene interaction operating in each selective breeding experiment and the extent of its multispecific effect.

Genetic regulation of the specific and non-specific component of immunity

Bi-directional selective breeding for antibody (Ab) responsiveness to heterologous erythrocytes (Selection I) produced a high (H) and a low (L) responder line of mice which were also remarkably separated for Ab responses to many unrelated natural antigens (Ags) such as heterologous proteins, viruses, bacteria, parasites and haptens carried by these immunogens. The character "quantitative Ab responsiveness" is controlled by several independently segregating loci (polygenic regulation). The major genetic modification is produced at the level of macrophage activities. The Ag is slowly catabolized and persists for a long time on the macrophage membrane of the H line, whereas it is rapidly destroyed in L line macrophages. The bactericidal and bacteriostatic activity of the macrophage is also strong in the L line and weak in the H line. The opposite genetic regulation of Ab responsiveness and macrophage activity is a fundamental phenomenon for understanding natural and vaccination-induced anti-infectious immunity. The L line is more resistant than the H line against the infections due to intracellular microorganisms (Salmonellae, Yersinia, Mycobacteria, Brucellae, Leishmania) where the macrophage plays the dominant defensive barrier. The H line is more resistant than the L line to the extracellular microorganisms which are efficiently counteracted by a strong antibody response (Pneumococcus, Klebsiella, Plasmodia, Trypanosoma). The intensity of T cell-mediated immunity as measured by delayed type hypersensitivity, which is independent of the genetic regulation of antibody responsiveness, is correlated with the degree of nonspecific inflammation produced at the site of the reaction by the Ag injection in non-sensitized mice.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of silica on the genetic regulation of antibody responsiveness

The high (H) and low (L) antibody responder lines of mice produced by selective breeding are characterized by different modifications in immunocompetent cell potentialities, according to the immunization procedure used for the selection process. In selections I and II, the difference in antibody responsiveness between H and L lines was clearly shown to depend mainly on macrophage function: the more rapid catabolism of antigens in L mice was the main cause of the low antibody production. In contrast, up to now, no difference has been observed between H and L mice of selections III and IV in terms of the macrophage accessory role. The administration of silica particles has a well known impairment effect on macrophage activity. Therefore, the effect of silica injection on the kinetics of antibody responses to selection antigens was compared in H and L mice of the four selections. Silica was given either intravenously or locally in one hind footpad 6 or 24 h before immunization by the same route. Silica treatment consistently improved antibody responsiveness in the L mice of selections I and II, but had no effect in the L mice of selections III and IV. The antibody responses of the H lines of the four selections were not substantially modified by silica injections. Therefore, the silica treatment reduced the interline difference in antibody responses in selections I and II only, by interfering with the expression of the genetic modification of macrophage activity. However, a similar effect was not obtained with other substances known to affect macrophages, including dextran sulphate or carrageenan. The results reported here are in agreement with the above-mentioned statement that the genetic modification of macrophage function plays a major role in the interline difference in selections I and II and is not involved in selections III and IV.

Basal immunoglobulin serum concentration and isotype distribution in relation to the polygenic control of antibody responsiveness in mice

Serum Ig concentration and isotype distribution were determined in the high (H) and low (L) responder lines selected for antibody response to complex immunogens. Data were recorded in normal and postimmunization sera from the H and L lines produced by five independent selective breedings (selections I, II, III, IV, and V). Ig levels were much higher in H than in L mice of all the selections. In four selections this interline difference increased further after immunization with the selection antigens. This is in agreement with the general effect of the polygenic control of antibody responses operating in H and L lines. The Ig isotype profiles of normal sera were different in each line; however, similitudes were noticed between H and L lines in selections I and II. In contrast, in selections III, IV, and V a similar interline difference was observed: the lack of IgG2a isotype in L lines only. After immunization there were minor alterations of the isotype profiles except in the H lines of selections III and IV, in which a clear inverse modification of IgG1 and IgG2a proportions occurred. The characteristic pattern of each selection may be partially dependent on isotype-restricted regulatory effects in relation to the immunization procedure used for selective breeding.

Inverse modification of antibody responsiveness to RGG in lines of mice selected for high or low responses to somatic antigen of Salmonella

High (H/s) and low (L/s) antibody responder lines of mice selected according to their response to the somatic (s) antigen of Salmonella (Selection IV) have unexpected inverse capacity for antibody production to rabbit gamma globulin (RGG): H/s mice are low or even nonresponders to this antigen, whereas L/s mice are high responders. It was shown that the phenotypic variability within each line is due to environmental factors. RGG was a selection antigen in Selection V; the high (H/p) and low (L/p) responder mice are therefore considered as homozygous for the RGG genes. Responsiveness to RGG was investigated in F1 and F2 hybrids obtained by crossing the phenotypically similar RGG responder or nonresponder mice of Selections IV and V. The results support the hypothesis that the same genes control the response to RGG in L/s and H/p lines as well as in H/s and L/p lines. This means that the genes specific for RGG responsiveness were independent from those regulating responses to the s antigen. Unaffected by the selective breeding in Selection IV, they have been fixed by chance in an inverse way in H/s and L/s lines.

Evidence for distinct polygenic regulation of antibody responses to some unrelated antigens in lines of mice selected for high or low antibody responses to somatic antigen of Salmonella

The effect of the selective breeding of mice for high or low antibody production to complex immunogens is largely "nonspecific", since it modifies the responsiveness of high (H) and low (L) lines to many antigens unrelated to the selection antigen. However, the nonspecific effect of the polygenic control operating in these lines is not a general feature. For example, the group of genes in selection IV, carried out for responsiveness to somatic antigen of Salmonella, does not modify the responses to sheep erythrocytes (SE). Despite equivalent responses in H and L mice of selection IV, a large variability was found in individual responses of F2 interline hybrids, which demonstrates the presence of alleles with high or low effect on responses to SE. A selective breeding (Selection IV-A) was therefore initiated from this F2 population for responsiveness to SE.A progressive interline divergence occurred during the first seven generations of selection; the interline separation was due to polygenic regulation (about four independent loci from a preliminary estimate). Equivalent responses to the s antigen of Salmonella are observed in the two lines. This constitutes additional evidence for distinct polygenic regulation of responses to SE and to somatic antigen. Moreover, the pattern of responses to several unrelated antigens (nonspecific effect) also differs between Selections IV and IV-A.

Nonspecific genetic regulation of antibody responsiveness in the mouse

Four lines of mice were produced by selective breeding for quantitative agglutinin responsiveness to flagellar (f) or somatic (s) antigens (Ags) of Salmonellae: high (H) or low (L) responder lines to fAg and H and L responder lines to sAg. The Salmonellae contained both f and sAgs, the Ag used to perform the selection was the Selection Ag and the other was the Associated Ag. The selective breeding produced a progressive interline separation with an equivalent effect for both Ags. After 15 generations (F15) the level of agglutinin response was about 60 times higher in H than in L responders. About 50% of the phenotypic variation of the character investigated is determined by a group of immune response genes, the rest is due to environmental factors. The nonspecific effect of this group of immune response genes was investigated by measuring the responses to three independent antigens: Sheep erythrocytes (SE), dinitrophenyl-conjugated human IgG (DNP-HGG) and bovine IgG (BGG). The selection for fAg response produced an equivalent modification in the respnsiveness to the Associated Ag (97%) and to BGG (130%). This nonspecific effect was smaller for responsiveness to SE and DNP-HGG, 58% and 41% of the Selection Ag response, respectively. The selection for sAg response produced a nonspecific modification of responsiveness of 94% for the Associated Ag of 74% for BGG and 63% for DNP-HGG. An important exception concerned SE to which an equal antibody response is produced in high and low lines of sAg selection.