Differential ranking of causes of fatal versus non-fatal injuries among US children

OBJECTIVE

Leading causes of fatal and non-fatal injury among US children aged <15 years were compared.

METHOD

A descriptive study was conducted using nationally representative data on injury related deaths (National Vital Statistics System) and on non-fatal injury related emergency department visits (IEDV; National Electronic Injury Surveillance System-All Injury Program). Data were accessed using a publicly available web based system.

RESULTS

Annually, an estimated 7100000 pediatric IEDV and 7400 injury deaths occurred. The overall non-fatal to fatal ratio (NF:F) was 966 IEDV:1 death. Among deaths, the leading causes were motor vehicle traffic occupants (n = 1700; NF:F = 150:1), suffocations (n = 1037; NF:F = 14:1), and drownings (n = 971, NF:F = 6:1). Among non-fatal injuries, falls (estimated 2400000) and struck by/against (estimated 1800000) were the most common causes, but substantially less lethal (NF:F = 19000:1 and 15000:1, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

The leading causes of pediatric fatal and non-fatal injuries differed substantially. This study indicates the need for consideration of common causes of non-fatal injury, especially falls.

Surveillance for homicide among intimate partners--United States, 1981-1998

PROBLEM/CONDITION

A substantial percentage of all homicides in the United States are committed by intimate partners of the victims. Among females, approximately 1 in 3 homicides are intimate partner homicides (IPHs). Intimate partner homicides cannot be tracked by using death certificates because death certificates do not record the victim's relationship to the perpetrator.

REPORTING PERIOD COVERED

This report summarizes information regarding IPHs that occurred in the United States during 1981-1998.

DESCRIPTION OF THE SYSTEM

This report is based on Supplemental Homicide Reports (SHRs) collected by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) as part of their Uniform Crime Reporting System. SHRs are filed voluntarily by police departments for homicides occurring within their jurisdiction. SHRs include demographic variables regarding victims and perpetrators, their relationship, and weapon(s) used. Data from the SHR file were weighted by comparison with homicide data from death certificates to compensate for underreporting. IPHs were restricted to victims aged > or = 10 years.

RESULTS

The risk for death from IPH among males was 0.62 times the risk among females. However, the rate among black males was 1.16 times the rate among black females. Among racial groups, rates among blacks were highest, and the rates among Asian or Pacific Islanders were lowest. Rates were highest among females aged 20-49 years and among males aged 30-59 years. During the study period, rates among white females decreased 23%, and rates among white males decreased 61.9%. Rates among black females decreased 47.6%, and rates among black males decreased 76.4%. Highest rates occurred in the southern and western states among both white and black females. A graded increase in IPH risk occurred with community population size. Approximately 50% of IPHs were committed by legal spouses and 33% by boyfriends or girlfriends for both male and female victims. IPH rates were less than expected during the months of January, October, and November.

INTERPRETATION

Although total homicide rates have fluctuated during 1981-1998, IPH rates have decreased steadily during this period, and among certain subpopulations, the decrease has been substantial. Decreases are temporally associated with the introduction of social programs and legal measures to curb intimate partner violence, but a causal relationship has not been established. Likewise, no confirmed explanation exists for the greater decrease in rates among males compared with rates among females. The differences in IPH rates by race indicate that economic, social, and cultural factors are involved. The analysis by community population size and state demonstrates that regional sociocultural differences might be involved also. Access to firearms might be a key factor in both male and female IPHs.

PUBLIC HEALTH ACTIONS

The descriptive epidemiology of IPH is changing rapidly and should continue to be monitored. Understanding the reasons forthe recent decreases in IPHs might help identify methods for primary and secondary prevention and further reduce IPH rates.

Tocolytic magnesium sulfate exposure and risk of cerebral palsy among children with birth weights less than 1,750 grams

The authors examined the relation between intrapartum magnesium sulfate exposure and risk of cerebral palsy in a case-control study of low birth weight children designed to control for confounding by the clinical indications for magnesium in pregnancy. Case children (n = 97) included all singleton children with cerebral palsy who were born in 1985-1989 in Atlanta, Georgia with a birth weight less than 1,750 g and whose mothers had not had a hypertension-related disease during pregnancy. Control children (n = 110) were randomly selected from the infant survivors using identical selection criteria. Data on magnesium sulfate exposure, labor and delivery, and infant characteristics were abstracted from hospital records. The authors found no association between exposure to magnesium sulfate and cerebral palsy risk (odds ratio = 0.9; 95% confidence interval: 0.3, 2.6) either in all children or in subgroups with varying likelihoods for exposure to magnesium. However, the association did vary by birth weight, with a protective effect being seen in children born weighing less than 1,500 g and an elevated risk in children with birth weights of 1,500 g or more; all confidence intervals included 1.0 except for the combined <1,500 g group. Several ongoing randomized clinical trials of magnesium and cerebral palsy may shed more definitive light on this relation.

Prevalence and phenotype consequence of FRAXA and FRAXE alleles in a large, ethnically diverse, special education-needs population

We conducted a large population-based survey of fragile X (FRAXA) syndrome in ethnically diverse metropolitan Atlanta. The eligible study population consisted of public school children, aged 7-10 years, in special education-needs (SEN) classes. The purpose of the study was to estimate the prevalence among whites and, for the first time, African Americans, among a non-clinically referred population. At present, 5 males with FRAXA syndrome (4 whites and 1 African American), among 1,979 tested males, and no females, among 872 tested females, were identified. All males with FRAXA syndrome were mentally retarded and had been diagnosed previously. The prevalence for FRAXA syndrome was estimated to be 1/3,460 (confidence interval [CI] 1/7,143-1/1,742) for the general white male population and 1/4, 048 (CI 1/16,260-1/1,244) for the general African American male population. We also compared the frequency of intermediate and premutation FRAXA alleles (41-199 repeats) and fragile XE syndrome alleles (31-199 repeats) in the SEN population with that in a control population, to determine if there was a possible phenotype consequence of such high-repeat alleles, as has been reported previously. No difference was observed between our case and control populations, and no difference was observed between populations when the probands were grouped by a rough estimate of IQ based on class placement. These results suggest that there is no phenotype consequence of larger alleles that would cause carriers to be placed in an SEN class.

Prevalence of selected developmental disabilities in children 3-10 years of age: the Metropolitan Atlanta Developmental Disabilities Surveillance Program, 1991

PROBLEM/CONDITION

Serious developmental disabilities affect approximately 2% of school-age children and are lifelong conditions that incur substantial financial and societal costs.

REPORTING PERIOD

January 1991-December 1991.

DESCRIPTION OF SYSTEM

The Metropolitan Atlanta Developmental Disabilities Surveillance Program (MADDSP) monitors the prevalence of four serious developmental disabilities--mental retardation, cerebral palsy, vision impairment, and hearing impairment--among children 3-10 years of age in the five-county metropolitan-Atlanta area. Children who have at least one of the four developmental disabilities are ascertained through annual review of records at schools, hospitals, and other sources.

RESULTS AND INTERPRETATION

During 1991, rates for mental retardation varied by age, race, and sex; rates ranged from 5.2 per 1,000 children to 16.6 per 1,000 children. Regardless of the absolute rate of mental retardation in each of the age-, race-, and sex-specific categories, severe mental retardation (i.e., an intelligence quotient of <50) accounted for one third of all cases. The overall crude rate of cerebral palsy was 2.4 per 1,000 children; however, the rate was higher among black children (3.1 per 1,000 children) than among white children (2.0 per 1,000 children). The rate of moderate to severe hearing impairment was 1.1 per 1,000 children, and the rate of vision impairment was 0.8 per 1,000 children. Rates of hearing impairment were higher among black males than among children in the other race and sex groups, whereas rates for vision impairment varied only slightly between these groups. The rates of the developmental disabilities were not adjusted for possible confounding factors (e.g., maternal education, family income, and various medical conditions). Consequently, the variation in rates may reflect social or other characteristics unique to the study population.

ACTIONS TAKEN

MADDSP data will be used to direct early childhood intervention efforts to reduce the prevalence of these four developmental disabilities. MADDSP data also are being used to measure progress toward the year 2000 national objectives for the prevention of serious mental retardation.

Contribution of developmental disabilities to childhood mortality in the United States: a multiple-cause-of-death analysis

Although developmental disabilities are among the major chronic health problems affecting children in the United States, the contribution of developmental disabilities to childhood mortality is unknown. To investigate the magnitude of this contribution, multiple cause-of-death data were examined for US children, aged 1-19 years, for 1980 and 1983-1989. The following conditions were included as developmental disabilities: autism, attention deficit disorder, learning disorders, mental retardation, cerebral palsy, epilepsy, muscular dystrophy, blindness and deafness. Based on underlying cause only, it was found that developmental disabilities were the fifth leading cause of nontraumatic death for children between 1 and 14 years of age and the third leading cause of non-traumatic death for children between 15 and 19 years. When a multiple cause approach was used to define developmental disability-related deaths (i.e. when contributing as well as underlying cause was considered), the number of such deaths nearly doubled. On the basis of both underlying- and multiple-cause analyses, cerebral palsy was the developmental disability most frequently cited as a cause of death. Mental retardation ranked second according to the multiple-cause approach but only fourth according to the underlying-cause approach. The least frequent causes of death (autism, attention deficit disorder, learning disorders, blindness, and deafness) were the ones most likely to be coded as contributing rather than underlying causes. Developmental disability-related mortality rates were highest among children aged 1-4 and 15-19 years, highest among blacks and lowest among racial groups other than blacks and whites, and higher among males than females. Although results of multiple-cause-of-death analyses more accurately reflect the proportion of deaths related to developmental disabilities, even this approach may underestimate the degree to which mortality is associated with a developmental disability.

Prevalence of depression among electrical workers

To address the possible association between electric and magnetic field exposure and depression, we analyzed data from the Vietnam Experience Study. In order to compare the risk of diagnosed depression, depressive symptoms, and elevations in personality scales indicative of depression, we classified employed participants as electrical workers (N = 183) and nonelectrical workers (N = 3,861) and compared their scores on the Diagnostic Interview Survey (DIS) and the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI). Electrical workers in the aggregate showed little evidence of increased risk, with the possible exception of an increase in elevated MMPI depression scores among short-term workers. Data on electricians yielded indications of increased risk for several markers of depression. Despite the limited number of electrical workers, uncertainty regarding exposure, and our inability to address other workplace exposures, these results suggest that electrical workers in general are not at increased risk for depression. However, our results encourage further evaluation of depression among electricians.

Evaluation of an intervention to reduce playground hazards in Atlanta child-care centers

In 1988, we identified playground hazards at 58 child-care centers (CCCs) and intervened by showing the director the hazards and distributing safety information. In 1990, we evaluated the 58 intervention CCCs as well as 71 randomly selected control CCCs. Intervention centers had 9.4 hazards per playground; control centers had 8.0. We conclude that the intervention was ineffective.

Self-reported health status of Vietnam veterans in relation to perceived exposure to herbicides and combat

The authors examined how the self-reported health of 7,924 US Army Vietnam veterans in 1985-1986 related to the men's perceived exposure to herbicides and combat in Vietnam. The results showed strong, positive associations between the extent of reported herbicide exposure (classified as a four-level ordinal index) and all 21 health outcomes studied, with clear "dose-response" relations in most instances. In contrast, only chloracne and psychological symptoms, including a symptom pattern consistent with posttraumatic stress disorder, were found to be strongly related to the amount of reported combat exposure (classified as a four-level ordinal index). The multiple herbicide/outcome associations seem implausible because of their nonspecificity and because of collateral biologic evidence suggesting the absence of widespread exposure to dioxin-containing herbicides among US Army combat units. These associations may have resulted from long-term stress reactions that produced somatization, hypochondriasis, and increased utilization of medical care among some Vietnam veterans. The available data suggest, however, that the association between reported combat exposure and psychological symptoms consistent with posttraumatic stress disorder may be causal.

Bicycle-associated head injuries and deaths in the United States from 1984 through 1988. How many are preventable?

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the potential benefits from more widespread bicycle safety helmet use.

DESIGN

Review of death certificates and emergency department injury data for 1984 through 1988. Categorization of deaths and injuries as related to bicycling and head injury. Using relative risks of 3.85 and 6.67 derived from a case-control study and varying helmet usage from 10% to 100%, population attributable risk was calculated to estimate preventable deaths and injuries.

SETTING

Entire United States.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Numbers of US residents coded as dying from bicycle-related head injuries, numbers of persons presenting to emergency departments for bicycle-related head injuries, and numbers of attributable bicycle-related deaths and head injuries.

MAIN RESULTS

From 1984 through 1988, bicycling accounted for 2985 head injury deaths (62% of all bicycling deaths) and 905,752 head injuries (32% of persons with bicycling injuries treated at an emergency department). Forty-one percent of head injury deaths and 76% of head injuries occurred among children less than 15 years of age. Universal use of helmets by all bicyclists could have prevented as many as 2500 deaths and 757,000 head injuries, ie, one death every day and one head injury every 4 minutes.

CONCLUSIONS

Effective community-based education programs and legislated approaches for increasing bicycle safety helmet usage have been developed and await only the resources and commitment to reduce these unnecessary deaths and injuries.

Discrepancies in the reported frequency of cocaine-related deaths, United States, 1983 through 1988

OBJECTIVE

--To assess the validity of cocaine-related mortality data available from the principal federal sources of information about the frequency of drug abuse deaths in the United States: the national vital statistics system and the Drug Abuse Warning Network (DAWN).

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

--We compared the number of cocaine-related deaths reported to national vital statistics and DAWN from 25 metropolitan areas during the years 1983 through 1988. We also compared cocaine-related mortality data reported to national vital statistics with data from all published forensic case series of cocaine-related deaths that occurred during the mid-1980s.

RESULTS

--During the 6-year study period, 75% more cocaine-related deaths were reported to DAWN (6057) than to national vital statistics (3466) from the 25 metropolitan areas that were studied. For individual metropolitan areas, the discrepancy between DAWN and vital statistics counts of cocaine-related deaths was as large as a sixfold difference. In six of the seven forensic case series identified in our literature search, the number of cocaine-related deaths exceeded the number of these deaths reported to vital statistics. The largest discrepancy was for cocaine-related deaths in New York, NY, during a 10-month period in 1986 for which 151 deaths were reported in a case series and seven deaths were reported to vital statistics.

CONCLUSION

--Improvements in existing public health surveillance systems are needed for (1) full and accurate measurements of the lethal impact of drug abuse epidemics and (2) valid and comprehensive assessments of the effectiveness of national programs designed to prevent drug-related morbidity and mortality.

Nonresponse and intensity of follow-up in an epidemiologic study of Vietnam-era veterans

Characteristics of nonrespondents, respondents who were easy to locate, and respondents who were hard to locate were examined with the use of data from a telephone health survey of male, US Army, Vietnam-era veterans. Of 17,867 eligible men discharged from active military duty in the late 1960s and early 1970s, 15,288 (86%) were successfully located and interviewed during 1985-1986. Veterans who could not be located were more likely than respondents to possess baseline characteristics predictive of increased mortality. In contrast, subjects who were located but refused to be interviewed were similar to respondents. Among veterans who were interviewed, those who were hardest to locate had the highest prevalence of known risk factors for diminished health status and reported many health problems with higher relative frequencies than respondents who were easier to locate. Odds ratios comparing the prevalence of each of 11 health outcomes in men who had served in Vietnam with that in men who had served elsewhere did not vary appreciably by intensity of follow-up. In particular, the subgroup of respondents that was located and interviewed within 2 weeks of initiation of follow-up (comprising 25% of all respondents) produced odds ratios for 10 of the 11 outcomes that were not appreciably different from odds ratios based on all respondents.

Head injury--associated deaths from motorcycle crashes. Relationship to helmet-use laws

A review of US mortality data from 1979 to 1986 identified 15,194 deaths and nearly 600,000 years of potential life lost before age 65 years that were associated with head injuries from motorcycle crashes. White males from 15 to 34 years of age accounted for 69% of the deaths. The rate of motorcycle-related deaths associated with head injury declined modestly between 1979 and 1986 (19% using rates based on resident population and 8% based on motorcycle registrations). Population-based rates adjusted for age, sex, and race in states with partial or no motorcycle helmet-use laws were almost twice those in states with comprehensive helmet-use laws. Two states that weakened their helmet-use laws from comprehensive to partial during the study period had increases in motorcycle-related head injury death rates (184% and 73%), and one state that strengthened its law from partial to comprehensive had a decline in its death rate (44%). Head injury death rates based on motorcycle registrations were also lowest in states with comprehensive helmet-use laws. Since helmets reduce the severity of nonfatal head injuries in addition to lowering the rate of fatal injuries, we urge the adoption and enforcement of comprehensive motorcycle helmet-use legislation.

Playground hazards in Atlanta child care centers

We identified 684 playground hazards in 66 child care centers despite regulations mandating that the grounds be hazard-free. Of 21 centers with less than or equal to 5 hazards, 42.9 percent reported a playground-related injury in the previous year; of 25 centers with 6-11 hazards, 52.0 percent reported a playground-related injury; and of 20 centers with greater than or equal to 12 hazards, 60.0 percent reported a playground-related injury. Climbing equipment greater than or equal to 6 feet tall generally had inadequate impact-absorbing undersurfacing and had over twice the rate of fall injuries as climbing equipment less than 6 feet.

Prevalence of rubella antibodies in Massachusetts schoolchildren

In 1982, 1,871 (79%) of 2,368 eligible 6th, 10th and 12th grade students in Massachusetts participated in a statewide serosurvey for rubella antibodies. Sera were screened at the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) by a reference hemagglutination inhibition assay at 1:8, equivalent to approximately 15 International Units (IU)/ml. Sera negative by the CDC hemagglutination inhibition assay were retested using an enzyme immunoassay, a passive hemagglutination assay, and a commercial hemagglutination inhibition test. The approximate screening levels were 10 IU/ml, 7.5 IU/ml, and 5 IU/ml, respectively. Overall seroprevalence levels varied from 76.4% screening at 15 IU to 93.1% including seropositives from any of the tests. Persons with a school record of vaccination had significantly higher seroprevalence levels than persons without records. However, only 78.3% of persons with a record had antibody greater than or equal to 15 IU compared with 60.0% without records; considering any detectable antibody, the comparison is 95.6% versus 71.4%. The low titers in vaccinees appeared to be due to a falloff of antibody with time since vaccination. Of students with a single vaccination noted in the record with exact dates, 92.3% who were vaccinated 0-4 years prior to the study had antibody at 15 IU compared with less than 78% of students with antibody who were vaccinated five or more years prior to the study. In contrast, using more sensitive assays, there was no significant decline in seroprevalence with time since vaccination. Revaccination studies and epidemiologic data suggest that almost all persons with detectable antibody whether above or below 15 IU/ml are immune to rubella. Thus, immunity levels in Massachusetts schoolchildren in the 6th, 10th, and 12th grades are probably in excess of 90%.