Host cell invasion and intracellular residence by Aeromonas salmonicida: role of the S-layer

Virulent strains of the fish pathogen Aeromonas salmonicida, which have surface S-layers (S+), efficiently adhere to, enter, and survive within macrophages. Here we report that S+ bacteria were 10- to 20-fold more adherent to non-phagocytic fish cell lines than S-layer-negative (S-) mutants. When reconstituted with exogenous S-layers, these S- mutants regained adherence. As well, latex beads coated with purified S-layers were more adherent to fish cell lines than uncoated beads, or beads coated with disorganized S-layers, suggesting that purified S-layers were sufficient to mediate high levels of adherence, and that this process relied on S-layer structure. Gentamicin protection assays and electron microscopy indicated that both S+ and S- A. salmonicida invaded non-phagocytic fish cells. In addition, these fish cells were unable to internalize S-layer-coated beads, clearly suggesting that the S-layer is not an invasion factor. Lipopolysaccharide (which is partially exposed in S+ bacteria) appeared to mediate invasion. Surprisingly, A. salmonicida did not show net growth inside fish cells cultured in the presence of gentamicin, as determined by viable bacterial cell counts. On the contrary, bacterial viability sharply decreased after cell infection. We thus concluded that the S-layer is an adhesin that promotes but does not mediate invasion of non-phagocytic fish cell lines. These cell lines should prove useful in studies aimed at characterizing the invasion mechanisms of A. salmonicida, but of limited value in studying the intracellular residence and replication of this invasive bacterium in vitro.

Co-culture of Aeromonas salmonicida and host cells in intraperitoneal implants is associated with enhanced bacterial survival

An experimental procedure that we named "in vivo co-culture technology" allowed us to study the interactions between Aeromonas salmonicida and host cells, inside semipermeable chambers implanted in the peritoneal cavity of Atlantic salmon. Intraperitoneal implants containing bacteria and host cells, or bacteria and lysed cells, consistently yielded higher numbers of viable bacteria than implants containing bacteria only. Electron microscopy confirmed that 30 min after chamber inoculation, numerous bacteria were already internalized by exudate cells, and that at 3 h, destruction of these cells was evident. Thus, the rapid invasion and (or) the A. salmonicida-mediated lysis of host cells may constitute a survival strategy in vivo. The co-culture of bacteria with exudate peritoneal cells may be applicable to the in vivo study of other pathogens.

Surface-associated hsp60 chaperonin of Legionella pneumophila mediates invasion in a HeLa cell model

HeLa cells have been previously used to demonstrate that virulent strains of Legionella pneumophila (but not salt-tolerant avirulent strains) efficiently invade nonphagocytic cells. Hsp60, a member of the GroEL family of chaperonins, is displayed on the surface of virulent L. pneumophila (R. A. Garduño et al., J. Bacteriol. 180:505-513, 1988). Because Hsp60 is largely involved in protein-protein interactions, we investigated its role in adherence-invasion in the HeLa cell model. Hsp60-specific antibodies inhibited the adherence and invasiveness of two virulent L. pneumophila strains in a dose-dependent manner but had no effect on the association of their salt-tolerant avirulent derivatives with HeLa cells. A monospecific anti-OmpS (major outer membrane protein) serum inhibited the association of both virulent and avirulent strains of L. pneumophila to HeLa cells, suggesting that while both Hsp60 and OmpS may mediate bacterial association to HeLa cells, only virulent strains selectively displayed Hsp60 on their surfaces. Furthermore, the surface-associated Hsp60 of virulent bacterial cells was susceptible to the action of trypsin, which rendered the bacteria noninvasive. Additionally, pretreatment of HeLa cells with purified Hsp60 or precoating of the plastic surface where HeLa cells attached with Hsp60 reduced the adherence and invasiveness of the two virulent strains. Finally, recombinant Hsp60 covalently bound to latex beads promoted the early association of beads with HeLa cells by a factor of 20 over bovine serum albumin (BSA)-coated beads and competed with virulent strains for association with HeLa cells. Hsp60-coated beads were internalized in large numbers by HeLa cells and remained in tight endosomes that did not fuse with other vesicles, whereas internalized BSA-coated beads, for which endocytic trafficking is well established, resided in more loose or elongated endosomes. Mature intracellular forms of L. pneumophila, which were up to 100-fold more efficient than agar-grown bacteria at associating with HeLa cells, were enriched for Hsp60 on the bacterial surface, as determined by immunolocalization techniques. Collectively, these results establish a role for surface-exposed Hsp60 in invasion of HeLa cells by L. pneumophila.

HeLa cells as a model to study the invasiveness and biology of Legionella pneumophila

HeLa cells were established as a model system to study the invasiveness and biology of Legionella pneumophila. In this model, invasion could be distinguished from adherence; virulent strains of L. pneumophila were adherent and invasive, whereas nonvirulent strains were adherent but poorly invasive. Invasion was rapid and did not require de novo bacterial protein synthesis, suggesting that the invasion factor is constitutively expressed by virulent strains. Entry into HeLa cells required actin polymerization and an intact microtubule cytoskeleton and was only moderately inhibited by the presence of 100 mM glucose or galactose. Intracellular replication of virulent L. pneumophila took place in ribosome-studded complex endosomes and led to the formation of free bacteria-laden vesicles presumably released from lysed HeLa cells. These free vesicles (referred to as mature vesicles) were isolated in continuous density gradients of Percoll. The bacteria contained in the isolated mature vesicles had a unique envelope structure and were highly adherent to HeLa cells, characteristics that correlated with a bright red appearance after the Giménez stain (Giménez positive). Plate-grown legionellae and replicating legionellae, harboured in complex endosomes, displayed a typical Gram-negative envelope and stained green after the Giménez stain (Giménez negative). Chronically infected cultures of HeLa cells were also established that may be a useful tool for studying long-term interactions between virulent L. pneumophila and mammalian cells. HeLa cells constitute a valuable model system that offers unique opportunities to study parasite-directed endocytosis, as well as stage specific-parasite interactions.

Immunolocalization of Hsp60 in Legionella pneumophila

One of the most abundant proteins synthesized by Legionella pneumophila, particularly during growth in a variety of eukaryotic host cells, is Hsp60, a member of the GroEL family of molecular chaperones. The present study was initiated in response to a growing number of reports suggesting that for some bacteria, including L. pneumophila, Hsp60 may exist in extracytoplasmic locations. Immunolocalization techniques with Hsp60-specific monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies were used to define the subcellular location and distribution of Hsp60 in L. pneumophila grown in vitro, or in vivo inside of HeLa cells. For comparative purposes Escherichia coli, expressing recombinant L. pneumophila Hsp60, was employed. In contrast to E. coli, where Hsp60 was localized exclusively in the cytoplasm, in L. pneumophila Hsp60 was predominantly associated with the cell envelope, conforming to a distribution pattern typical of surface molecules that included the major outer membrane protein OmpS and lipopolysaccharide. Interestingly, heat-shocked L. pneumophila organisms exhibited decreased overall levels of cell-associated Hsp60 epitopes and increased relative levels of surface epitopes, suggesting that Hsp60 was released by stressed bacteria. Putative secretion of Hsp60 by L. pneumophila was further indicated by the accumulation of Hsp60 in the endosomal space, between replicating intracellular bacteria. These results are consistent with an extracytoplasmic location for Hsp60 in L. pneumophila and further suggest both the existence of a novel secretion mechanism (not present in E. coli) and a potential role in pathogenesis.

Capsulated cells of Aeromonas salmonicida grown in vitro have different functional properties than capsulated cells grown in vivo

When grown in vivo in the peritoneal cavity of rainbow trout, Aeromonas salmonicida produces a clearly defined capsule with virulence-related functions. Aeromonas salmonicida grown in vitro in a glucose-rich medium (GRM) has also been reported to reproduce capsular material. Because in vitro mimicry of in vivo induced traits is highly desirable in vaccine design, the extent to which growth in GRM mimicked in vivo growth was examined. Antibodies specific to in vivo grown cells partially labeled the surface of GRM-grown cells, as well as two distinct proteins (81,700 and 41,000 Mr) in immunoblots of mutants with S-layer or lipopolysaccharide defects. GRM-grown strains showed an increased sensitivity to trout serum in contradistinction to the complete serum resistance of in vivo grown cells; as well, GRM-grown cells were more adherent to trout macrophages. Thus in spite of possessing some surface antigens normally expressed in vivo, cells grown on solid GRM did not possess all functional properties of in vivo grown cells.

Physical and functional S-layer reconstitution in Aeromonas salmonicida

The various functions attributed to the S-layer of Aeromonas salmonicida have been previously identified by their conspicuous absence in S-layer-defective mutants. As a different approach to establish the multifunctional nature of this S-layer, we established methods for reconstitution of the S-layer of A. salmonicida. Then we investigated the functional competence of the reconstituted S-layer. S-layers were reconstituted in different systems: on inert membranes or immobilized lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from purified S-layer protein (A-protein) or on viable cells from either A-protein or preassembled S-layer sheets. In the absence of divalent cations and LPS, purified A-protein in solution spontaneously assembled into tetrameric oligomers and, upon concentration by ultrafiltration, into macroscopic, semicrystalline sheets formed by oligomers loosely organized in a tetragonal arrangement. In the presence of Ca2+, purified A-protein assembled into normal tetragonal arrays of interlocked subunits. A-protein bound with high affinity (Kd, 1.55 x 10(-7) M) and specificity to high-molecular-weight LPS from A. salmonicida but not to the LPSs of several other bacterial species. In vivo, A-protein could be reconstituted only on A. salmonicida cells which contained LPS, and Ca2+ affected both a regular tetragonal organization of the reattached A-protein and an enhanced reattachment of the A-protein to the cell surface. The reconstitution of preformed S-layer sheets (produced by an S-layer-secreting mutant) to an S-layer-negative mutant occurred consistently and efficiently when the two mutant strains were cocultured on calcium-replete solid media. Reattached A-protein (exposed on the surface of S-layer-negative mutants) was able to bind porphyrins and an S-layer-specific phage but largely lacked regular organization, as judged by its inability to bind immunoglobulins. Reattached S-layer sheets were regularly organized and imparted the properties of porphyrin binding, hydrophobicity, autoaggregation, adherence to and invasion of fish macrophages and epithelial cells, and resistance to macrophage cytotoxicity. However, cells with reconstituted S-layers were still sensitive to complement and insensitive to the antibiotics streptonigrin and chloramphenicol, indicating incomplete functional reconstitution.

Physiological consequences of the S-layer of Aeromonas salmonicida in relation to growth, temperature, and outer membrane permeation

S-layers are paracrystalline protein multimers that cover the entire cell surface of many bacterial species. The presence of an S-layer in Aeromonas salmonicida (also known as A-layer) predisposed this bacterium to apparently unrelated physiological consequences: inhibition of growth at 30 degrees C, enhanced cell filamentation at 37 degrees C, and enhanced uptake of the hydrophobic antibiotics streptonigrin and chloramphenicol. Growth inhibition or enhanced filamentation was not observed when the native A-layer was missing or its arrangement altered, as in Ca(2+)-limited or Ca(2+)- and Mg(2+)-limited cells, in A-layer-negative (A-) cells with an artificially reconstituted A-layer, or in mutants unable to correctly assemble this layer. A-layer-positive cells (A+) were far more sensitive to the intracellularly acting antibiotics streptonigrin and chloramphenicol than were A- cells, and streptonigrin-resistant mutants were predominantly A-. Hemin, a compound known to specifically bind to the A-layer, alleviated streptonigrin toxicity to A+, but not A-, cells. As well, Ca(2+)- and Mg(2+)-limited cells, or mutants harboring A-layer defects had a reduced sensitivity to streptonigrin, and A- cells with reconstituted A-layers remained resistant to streptonigrin and chloramphenicol. Thus, the presence of a native A-layer arrangement on the cell surface, and not the mere presence of A-layer protein subunits, predisposed A. salmonicida toward the aforementioned physiological consequences. The A-layer is suggested to specifically effect these consequences, in particular the permeation of streptonigrin or chloramphenicol, by a specific interaction of A-layer subunits with the outer membrane.

Novel antigens expressed by Aeromonas salmonicida grown in vivo

Virulent and avirulent Aeromonas salmonicida strains grown inside intraperitoneal implants in Rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) were examined for unique antigen expression. Western blots (immunoblots), performed with immune rabbit serum raised against in vivo-grown cells, revealed several unique antigens. With the exception of lipopolysaccharide (LPS), these novel antigens were destroyed after proteinase K treatment. The majority of these antigens were not induced in vitro in response to either iron limitation or anaerobiosis. In addition, electron microscopy demonstrated the presence of a putative capsule on in vivo-grown cells. Purification and fractionation of this carbohydrate material from cells grown in carbon-rich synthetic media resulted in the isolation and separation of an antigenically distinct LPS not seen with cells grown in standard media. Antiserum raised against in vivo-grown cells recognized both this LPS and the typical LPS of A. salmonicida apparent in in vitro-grown cells. Antiserum raised against in vitro-grown cells recognized only the LPS expressed in vitro. Antiserum directed against in vivo-grown cells was approximately 10 times more sensitive than serum directed against in vitro-grown cells in detecting A. salmonicida in infected fish kidney tissue.

Fate of the fish pathogen Aeromonas salmonicida in the peritoneal cavity of rainbow trout

A model was developed to study the fate of the fish pathogen Aeromonas salmonicida in vivo, inside a specialized intraperitoneal chamber implanted in rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss. Although normally recalcitrant to lytic agents in vitro, owing to the presence of its regular surface array (S layer), A. salmonicida was rapidly killed in the peritoneal cavity by a host-derived, soluble lytic activity present in peritoneal fluid. Peritoneal fluid was also found to kill other bacteria and lyse various types of erythrocytes, but was particularly lytic to A. salmonicida. Intraperitoneal survival of injected (free) A. salmonicida cells was several orders of magnitude higher than survival of implanted (restrained) cells. Injected free cells could evade the lytic activity of peritoneal fluid because they readily spread, initiating lethal infections. One evasion strategy was envisioned to be the penetration of peritoneal and (or) tissue macrophages. In spite of the killing mechanisms of these phagocytic cells, A. salmonicida was still able to survive and even replicate inside head kidney macrophages, thereby supporting the notion of A. salmonicida as a facultatively intracellular pathogen. Intraperitoneal chambers in rainbow trout may constitute a valuable experimental tool for studying the in vivo fate of A. salmonicida, and perhaps of other fish pathogens as well.

Aeromonas salmonicida grown in vivo

The virulent fish pathogen Aeromonas salmonicida was rapidly killed in vivo when restricted inside a diffusion chamber implanted intraperitoneally in rainbow trout. After a period of regrowth, the survivors had acquired resistance to host-mediated bacteriolysis, phagocytosis, and oxidative killing, properties which were subsequently lost by growth in vitro. Resistance to bacteriolysis and phagocytosis was associated with a newly acquired capsular layer revealed by acidic polysaccharide staining and electron microscopy. This capsular layer shielded the underlying, regular surface array (S-layer) from immunogold labeling with a primary antibody to the S-layer protein. Resistance to oxidative killing was mediated by a mechanism not associated with the presence of the capsular layer. An attenuated vaccine strain of A. salmonicida grown in vivo failed to express the capsular layer. Consequently, the in vivo-grown cells of this attenuated strain remained as sensitive to bacteriolysis, and as avidly adherent to macrophages, as the in vitro-grown cells. The importance of these new virulence determinants and their relation to the known virulence factors of A. salmonicida are discussed.

Novel structural patterns in divalent cation-depleted surface layers of Aeromonas salmonicida

The fish pathogen Aeromonas salmonicida possesses a regular surface layer (or A-layer) which is an important virulence determinant. The A-protein, a single bilobed protein organized in a p4 lattice of M4C4 arrangement with two morphological domains, comprises this layer. The role of divalent cations in the A-layer structure was studied to better understand A-protein subunit interactions affecting structural flexibility and function. Divalent cation bridges were found to be involved in the integrity of the A-layer. Two novel A-layer patterns were formed as the result of growth under calcium limitation or by chelation of divalent cations with EDTA or EGTA, thereby constituting the first reported case of formation of distinct regular arrays upon divalent cation depletion. Furthermore, under these conditions A-protein was sometimes released as tetrameric units, rather than in monomeric form. The formation of the two novel patterns is best explained by a sequence of structural rearrangements, following disruption of only one of the two A-layer morphological units, that is, those held together by divalent cation bridges. The free tetrameric units represent four A-protein subunits clustered around the unaffected four-fold axis.

Interaction of the fish pathogen Aeromonas salmonicida with rainbow trout macrophages

A procedure was developed to culture rainbow trout macrophages (M phi) on supported glass coverslips. Using this method and a variety of well-characterized Aeromonas salmonicida strains with normal or altered cell surfaces, we investigated the role of this unusual bacterial surface in the bacterium-M phi interaction. An intact crystalline protein array, the A-layer, mediated adherence of A. salmonicida cells to M phi even in the absence of opsonins. In contrast, unopsonized cells of an A-layer-negative (A-) mutant with a smooth lipopolysaccharide (LPS) layer were unable to interact with M phi. However, this ability was recovered when the A-layer was reconstituted onto the smooth LPS surface of these A- LPS+ cells. Two A. salmonicida mutants possessing the A-layer in different disorganized states had a reduced ability to interact with M phi. A+ cells grown under calcium limitation produced A-layers locked into an alternative conformation which mediated the highest levels of M phi association in the absence of opsonins or any other surface coating. Coating A+ cells with hemin greatly increased their levels of M phi association, and bacterial cells grown on trout blood agar plates also had a dramatic increase in their ability to interact with M phi. Only A+ A. salmonicida cells were highly cytotoxic to trout M phi, especially after being coated with hemin, presumably due to a more focused targeting of the bacterial cell onto the M phi surface and/or into the intracellular regions of the M phi.

S-layer-mediated association of Aeromonas salmonicida with murine macrophages

The interaction of Aeromonas salmonicida with the murine macrophage (M phi) cell line P388D1 was used as a convenient model to study the involvement of the bacterial crystalline surface array (or A-layer) in the association with M phi s. A-layer-positive (A+) cells readily associated with M phi s in phosphate-buffered saline, whereas A- mutants were unable to do so, even when the bacterium-M phi interaction was forced by centrifugation. M phi s selectively interacted with A+ cells when challenged with mixtures of A+ and excess A- cells. Electron microscopy indicated that in phosphate-buffered saline only A+ bacteria were readily internalized, although by a nonconventional mechanism, suggesting that efficient phagocytosis in the absence of opsonins was A-layer mediated. Latex beads coated with a partially assembled A-layer were more efficiently taken up than uncoated or A-protein-coated beads, indicating that an organized A-layer was essential for M phi uptake. The reduced ability of M phi s plated on a substratum coated with the A-layer to bind A+ bacteria also suggested that association was both A-layer and receptor mediated. In the presence of tissue culture medium, competent M phi s interacted efficiently with A- bacteria and internalized them through conventional phagocytosis. A+ cells were markedly cytotoxic to M phi s, whereas the A-protein or A-layer was not. A- cells were cytotoxic to a lesser extent, suggesting that cytotoxicity was targeted.

Surface-disorganized, attenuated mutants of Aeromonas salmonicida as furunculosis live vaccines

A slow-growing, aminoglycoside-resistant mutant and a rapidly-growing pseudo-revertant were isolated from Aeromonas salmonicida, the causative agent of salmonid furunculosis. These mutants continued to elicit a variety of classical virulence factors associated with A. salmonicida pathogenesis. They differed morphologically from the wild-type and from one another with respect to A-layer organization, membrane antagonist sensitivity and particularly to aerobic metabolism. Both mutants were drastically altered in the architecture of the 2D crystalline surface array (A-layer), although both were similar to wild-type with respect to cell surface composition. The slow-growing, antibiotic-resistant mutant differed significantly from the wild-type by the apparent loss of virtually all aerobic metabolism; the pseudo-revertant had partially recovered the ability to aerobically metabolize certain carbon sources. Both mutants were avirulent and incapable of tissue persistence. The rapidly-growing, antibiotic-sensitive pseudo-revertant, when administered either intraperitoneally or by immersion, effectively protected salmonid fish from challenge by a heterologous virulent stain suggesting its candidature as a live, attenuated furunculosis vaccine.