A longitudinal study comparing scaling, osseous surgery, and modified Widman procedures: results after 5 years

BACKGROUND

Scaling and root planing, osseous surgery, and modified Widman procedures are effective methods for treating periodontal diseases. Studies have been carried out to determine if these procedures are more effective than others in reducing clinical probing depths, while maintaining clinical attachment levels. The purpose of this report is to present 5-year results from a longitudinal study comparing scaling and root planing (SRP), osseous surgery (OS), and modified Widman (MW) therapies. The study has been completed for 12 years.

METHODS

Sixteen adult patients with moderate to advanced periodontal disease were treated with initial scaling and oral hygiene procedures in a private practice. Posthygiene data were used to compare changes in plaque and gingival indices, probing depth (PD), clinical attachment levels (CAL), and recession. Frequency distributions were used to compare changes at individual sites. The first published report was from baseline to one year. This follow-up report is from baseline through 5 years.

RESULTS

At 5 years, there were significant decreases in gingival and plaque scores. For the 3 procedures, there were significant decreases in baseline 4 to 6 mm PD (P<0.0001); however, there were no differences between the methods. Similar findings were noted for PD initially greater than 7 mm. At 5 years, OS had the greatest number of 1 to 3 mm sites (332 sites, 73.2%), while MW had the fewest number of 4 to 6 mm PD (98 sites, 21.8%). SRP had the fewest 7 mm and greater sites (15 sites, 3.4%). At 5 years, CAL loss for 1 to 3 mm PD was statistically significant for the 3 procedures. There were slight gains in CAL for 4 to 6 mm probing depths. These gains were not significant. Similar findings were seen for CAL for probing depths greater than 7 mm. OS had the greatest number of sites losing more than 2 mm of CAL (64 sites), followed by SRP (21 sites) and MW (34 sites), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This 5-year clinical trial demonstrates that with good patient maintenance excellent clinical results can be achieved with various methods of treatment. Within the limits of this study, SRP, OS, and MW were effective at reducing probing depths with slight changes in clinical attachment levels.

Histological evaluation of healing and revascularization of the subepithelial connective tissue graft

BACKGROUND

The goal of this investigation was to histologically evaluate the healing and revascularization of the subepithelial connective tissue graft in dogs.

METHODS

Six beagle dogs were used in this study. Recession defects were surgically created on maxillary left P2 and right P2, and maxillary and mandibular left central and lateral incisors. The defects were left untreated for 35 days. After elevating a split thickness flap, the graft was harvested from the palate and placed over the denuded root surfaces. The flap was then coronally repositioned and sutured. Three dogs provided the specimens for 7- and 14-day time points and 3 dogs for 28- and 60-day time points. The animals were sacrificed and the blocks obtained were divided in half. One half was processed following the Spalteholtz method and the other was processed for routine histologic examination.

RESULTS

At 7 days, a clot was present at the demarcation zones and it was more organized at 14 days. At 28 days, the junctional epithelium was formed and the demarcation zones could not be delineated. At 60 days, the oral epithelium had regained its normal appearance. The attachment of the graft to the root surface was mediated by a combination of epithelial downgrowth and connective tissue attachment. Minimal new bone and cementum formation was observed. The vascularization of the graft at 7 days originated from the periodontal plexus and the overlying flap. At 14 days, the graft was completely vascularized. At 28 and 60 days, normal vascularization was present.

CONCLUSIONS

The vascularization of the connective tissue graft originates from the periodontal plexus, the supraperiosteal plexus, and the overlying flap. The attachment of the graft to the root surface appears to be mediated by a combination of epithelial downgrowth and connective tissue attachment. There is little potential for new cementum and new bone formation.

Treatment of intraosseous defects with bioabsorbable barriers alone or in combination with decalcified freeze-dried bone allograft: a randomized clinical trial

BACKGROUND

This study clinically compares the outcomes obtained from the use of a bioabsorbable barrier device in combination with demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA) to the results obtained from the barrier device used alone in the treatment of human intraosseous defects.

METHODS

The study consisted of 30 patients with one intraosseous periodontal defect each. The trial included defects with loss of attachment of > or = 6 mm, with a radiographically detectable defect of at least 4 mm and with at least 2 remaining osseous walls. After the hygienic phase, at baseline, probing depth (PD), clinical attachment level (CAL), and recession (REC) were measured. During open flap debridement, the defects were randomly assigned to receive either a polylactic acid (PLA) barrier in combination with DFDBA (test) or a PLA barrier alone (control). Additionally, baseline osseous intrasurgical measurements of the periodontal defect were obtained to evaluate the amount of bone regeneration. PD, CAL, and REC were remeasured at 6 and 12 months postsurgery and osseous measurements repeated at 12 months during a re-entry procedure.

RESULTS

Two-sample t-test comparisons of mean PD, CAL, and REC measurements (mm) between test (PLA+DFDBA) and control (PLA alone) groups at baseline, PLA+DFDBA: PD = 7.3, CAL = 8.1, REC = -0.7; PLA-alone: PD = 7.9, CAL = 8.4, REC = -0.5, were not statistically different (P>0.05). The following mean changes (delta) at 6 months for the test and the control groups were: decreased PD = 3.6 and 4.0 mm; gain CAL = 2.7 and 3.1 mm; and increased REC = -0.8 and -0.8 mm, respectively. At 12 months the changes for the test and control groups were: decreased PD = 3.3 and 4.1 mm; gain CAL = 2.3 and 3.2 mm; and increased REC = -0.8 and -1.0 mm, respectively. Two-sample t-test comparisons between PD, CAL, and REC changes yielded no significant differences between treatments (P > 0.05), except for the change in CAL at 12 months in favor of the control group, P = 0.008. Comparisons of osseous measurements resulted in no significant differences between groups at baseline and at 12 months (P > 0.05). The intrabony defect filled on the average 3.72 mm for the test and 4.85 mm for the control group. The experimental defects showed a 4.73 mm defect depth reduction, while the control defects reduced 5.35 mm. Re-entry measurements of osseous crest resorption were 1.1 mm for the test and 0.61 mm for the control.

CONCLUSIONS

In the intraosseous defects treated in this study, the addition of DFDBA to the GTR procedure did not significantly enhance the clinical results obtained with the GTR procedure alone.

Assessment of guided tissue regeneration procedures in intrabony defects with bioabsorbable and non-resorbable barriers

THE PURPOSE OF THIS STUDY was to assess periodontal regenerative techniques in intrabony defects utilizing a bioabsorbable, polylactic acid (PLA) barrier or the non-resorbable, expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) barrier. Thirty patients (26 to 64 years old) each with one radiographically evident intrabony periodontal lesion of probing depth > or = 6 mm participated in a 12-month controlled clinical trial. The subjects were randomly divided into two independent groups. The test group (n = 16) received a PLA barrier. The control group (n = 14) received an ePTFE barrier. Plaque index (PI), gingival index (GI), probing depth (PD), clinical attachment level (CAL), and bone fill were recorded by a single calibrated examiner not involved with the surgical treatment prior to surgery, and at 6, 9, and 12 months postsurgery. The treatment results were statistically analyzed utilizing two sets of data. The "averaged-site" data set consisted of values computed from the averaging of measurements from all sites encompassing the defect. The second data set was comprised of only the deepest measurement of the defect. Statistical tests used to analyze these data sets included the t-test and paired t-test for parametric data and the Wilcoxon rank sum test and the Wilcoxon signed rank test for non-parametric data. Analyses with both the averaged-site data and deepest-site data resulted in significant improvements in PD reductions, CAL, and bone fill, after 12 months of healing with both the PLA and ePTFE barrier devices. Comparisons of healing response between treatments found no significant differences when the averaged-site data were analyzed. When only the deepest site of the defect was considered, the control group resulted in significantly more attachment gain (ePTFE, 3.36 mm; PLA, 1.75 mm; P < 0.02) and shallower probing depths (ePTFE, 3.29 mm; PLA, 4.69 mm; P < 0.01) than the test group. In intrabony defects, the use of PLA or ePTFE barriers in GTR procedures yielded comparable clinical results; however, in this study, data analysis using the deepest site of the defect found, after 12 months of healing, significantly more attachment gain and shallower probing depths with ePTFE.

A comparison of demineralized freeze-dried bone and autologous bone to induce bone formation in human extraction sockets

The purpose of this study was to test the bone-forming capacity of demineralized freeze-dried bone (DFDBA) and autologous bone grafts in extraction sockets. Seven paired sites were grafted with either DFDBA or autologous bone. The sites were reentered between 3 and 13 months for the purposes of obtaining biopsies of the grafted sites and to place endosseous implants. Biopsies from 6 of the 7 grafted sites were evaluated for new bone formation. DFDBA sites revealed the presence of dead particles of DFDBA with no evidence of bone formation on the surfaces of the implanted particles and no evidence of osteoclastic resorption of the bone particles. Biopsies from the 6 autologous sites revealed vascular channels with woven and lamellar bone. Some specimens had retained cortical, non-vital bone chips. These bone chips were undergoing active osteoclastic resorption. The results of this study questions the use of DFDBA as a bone inductive graft material.

A comparison of ePTFE membranes alone or in combination with platelet-derived growth factors and insulin-like growth factor-I or demineralized freeze-dried bone in promoting bone formation around immediate extraction socket implants

The purpose of this study was to compare bone promotion around implants which were augmented with ePTFE membranes alone or in combination with cortical demineralized freeze-dried bone (DFDB) or the combination of platelet derived growth factor-BB (PDGF) and insulin like growth factor I (PDGF/IGF-I). Membranes were placed over titanium implants which had been inserted into fresh extraction sockets with large buccal dehiscences. Twenty-four implants were placed in 4 dogs. At 18 weeks clinical bone height measurements were taken, the animals were sacrificed, and all specimens retrieved for histologic evaluation. Clinically, a significant gain in bone levels was present in both the ePTFE membrane alone group (P < 0.005) and PTFE plus PDGF/IGF-I group (P < 0.01), but not in the PTFE plus DFDB group. Results from histometric measurements revealed an approximately 2-fold increase in the percentage of implant surface in contact with bone, area of bone adjacent to the implant surface, and in the total length of the implant surface in contact with bone in the dehiscence defects treated with ePTFE plus PDGF/IGF-I compared to the defects receiving ePTFE membranes alone (each P < 0.05). The response to the DFDB was highly variable and it did not significantly improve the efficacy of the PTFE membranes for any parameter measured. The distance from the outer surface of the new bone to the implant surface was statistically significant for ePTFE membranes alone and membranes plus PDGF/IGF-I. The results demonstrated that clinically, ePTFE membranes alone or ePTFE membranes with PDGF/IGF-I were equally effective in promoting bone growth around the implants. Histologic measurements demonstrated that sites treated with ePTFE membranes plus PDGF/IGF-I had the highest bone density compared with sites which received ePTFE membranes alone or with ePTFE membranes and DFDB. The results of this study question the use of DFDB and support the use of ePTFE membranes alone or with PDG-F-BB/IGF-I as potential methods of promoting bone formation around dental implants.

Effects of metronidazole on periodontal treatment needs

Periodontitis, a common cause of tooth loss in adult populations, is an inflammatory response to the overgrowth of anaerobic organisms such as spirochetes and bacteroides and, in some cases, micro-aerophilic organisms in the subgingival plaque. In the present investigation, using a double-blind clinical design, we sought to determine whether 1 week of metronidazole treatment plus debridement of the tooth surfaces was superior to 1 week of placebo treatment plus debridement (positive control) in reducing the subsequent amount of periodontal surgery given to the patients. Thirty-nine patients were randomly assigned to either the metronidazole or placebo (positive control) groups. All patients were given the necessary scaling and root planing and were unsupervised in their usage of the medication. After the completion of this treatment, they were reexamined and it was found that the metronidazole regimen caused a significant reduction in surgical needs of about 5 teeth per patient compared to the positive control (difference before and after treatment 8.3 +/- 6.8 teeth metronidazole versus 2.9 +/- 4.8 positive control, P = 0.007). The difference between groups was maintained during the 2 to 3 years' recall period. Metronidazole had a significant effect on the site specific reduction of spirochetes: 90% of the sites in the metronidazole group versus 64% in the positive-control group had a decrease in the percentage of spirochetes (P less than 0.05). We conclude that systemic metronidazole given 250 mg tid for 7 days in conjunction with debridement of the tooth surfaces can significantly reduce the need for periodontal surgery compared to the standard regimen which included only debridement.

A longitudinal study comparing scaling, osseous surgery and modified Widman procedures. Results after one year

The purpose of this study was to compare, longitudinally, the effectiveness of scaling and root planing, osseous surgery, and the modified Widman procedures. The study was carried out in a private practice setting. Sixteen adult patients with moderate to advanced adult periodontitis were treated with initial scaling and oral hygiene procedures. Posthygiene data were used for comparison of changes in probing depth, clinical attachment levels and gingival recession. The initial examination data were used to compare changes in plaque and gingival indices. Frequency distributions were used to compare changes that occurred at individual sites. At one year, plaque and gingival indices were significantly reduced when compared with the initial examination. At one year, shallow pockets (1-3 mm) were reduced when compared to posthygiene. Four- to six-millimeter pockets were significantly reduced by the three procedures. Osseous surgery and modified Widman had significantly greater pocket reduction when compared with scaling. For pockets greater than 7 mm, osseous surgery and the modified Widman had significantly greater reduction when compared with scaling. For pockets 1-3 mm at one year osseous surgery had significantly greater clinical attachment loss when compared with scaling. For 4-6 mm pockets at one year, the three procedures had slight gains in clinical attachment levels. The results were similar for pockets with greater than 7 mm. Interproximal soft tissue craters were measured for six postoperative weeks. Initially, the modified Widman had a higher percentage of soft tissue craters when compared with osseous surgery. At six weeks, however, there were no significant differences when the surgical procedures were compared. Recession was measured at each examination. Recession for 1-3 mm pockets at one year was greater for osseous surgery when compared with scaling and the modified Widman. Recession for 4-6 mm and greater than 7 pockets was greater for the surgical procedures than scaling. The results from this study indicate that with three-month maintenance recalls, both the modified Widman and osseous surgery are effective for pocket reduction, and each will produce a slight gain of clinical attachment over one year. Scaling was effective at maintaining attachment levels but was not as effective in reducing pocket depth.

Root isolation for new attachment procedures. A surgical and suturing method: three case reports

A surgical and suturing method is described for the subgingival placement of Gore-tex periodontal material during new attachment procedures. The periodontal material isolates the root surface from epithelium and gingival connective tissue. Three cases were treated. Clinical new attachment was evident from clinical probings and reentry. The term "open probing new attachment" describes the type of tissue that was evident at reentry after treatment of a Class III furcation. A combination of new bone and "open probing new attachment" was evident after one-wall defects were treated adjacent to a mandibular cuspid. A two-wall defect was treated and biopsied three months later. A reference notch was placed 1 mm coronal to the apical aspect of the defect. Histologic examination of the biopsy showed new bone, cementum and periodontal fibers coronal to the notch. Clinical and histologic new attachment was achieved using the technique for root isolation. The long-term predictability and stability of this type of new attachment is not known at this time.

Effects of citric acid and fibronectin and laminin application in treating periodontitis

To determine the effect on new connective tissue attachment of citric acid conditioning and fibronectin-laminin application in treating naturally occurring periodontitis, all 4 quadrants in each of 2 Beagle dogs were used. Each quadrant included: P2, P3, P4, and M1 teeth. 2 treatment modalities were employed and comparatively analyzed for differences in histological healing respponses at 120 days after surgery. The treatments were: (1) surgery (mucoperiosteal flaps) plus citric acid; (2) surgery plus citric acid followed by fibronectin-laminin application. After scaling and root planing, coronal and root surface reference notches were placed for histometric measurements. Following each of the randomly assigned treatments, flaps were sutured. After sacrifice, tissue blocks of treated areas were decalcified and serially cut, obtaining bucco-lingual and mesiodistal sections. Using a Filar micrometer, 5 distances were masured on the buccal aspect: (1) from root surface notch to alveolar bone crest; (2) from root surface notch to coronal extent of the cementum; (3) from root surface notch to apical extent of the junctional epithelium; 84) from free gingival margin to apical extent of junctional epithelium; (5) from the coronal notch to the alveolar bone crest. Results showed no differences among the 5 measurements between the 2 treatments tested. On mesio-distal sections, surface area determinations were made in the furcations, evaluating the space occupied by new connective tissue, with or without bone, or by epithelium. For this, images were digitized using a Zeiss IBAS Image analysis system with a 4mB of array processor memory coupled to a Newvicon TV camera and a microcomputer.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)