Common themes and challenges in hemophilia care: a multinational perspective

OBJECTIVE

To identify ways that provision of hemophilia care can be maximized at the local level, irrespective of available resources or cultural or geographic challenges.

METHODS

The SHIELD group used its multinational experience to share examples of local initiatives that have been employed to deliver optimal hemophilia care.

RESULTS

The examples were reviewed and categorized into four key themes: guidelines and algorithms for delivery of care; collaboration with patients and allied groups for care and education; registries for the monitoring of treatment and outcomes and health care planning and delivery; and opportunities for personalization of care. These themes were then incorporated into a road map for collaborative care in hemophilia that reflected the contribution of best practice.

DISCUSSION

Differing healthcare reimbursement systems, budgetary constraints, and geographical and cultural factors make it difficult for any country to fully deliver ideal care for people with hemophilia. The SHIELD approach for collaborative care provides illustrative examples of how four key themes can be used to optimize hemophilia care in any setting.

ABBREVIATIONS

AHCDC: Association of Hemophilia Clinic Directors of Canada; AICE: Italian Association of Hemophilia Centres; ATHN: American Thrombosis and Hemostasis Network; EAHAD: European Association for Haemophilia and Allied Disorders; EHC: European Hemophilia Consortium; FIX: Coagulation Factor IX; FVIII: Coagulation Factor VIII; HAL: Haemophilia Activity List; HJHS: Haemophilia Joint Health Score; HTC: Hemophilia Treatment Centre; HTCCNC: Hemophilia Treatment Centre Collaborative Network of China; MASAC: Medical and Scientific Advisory Council; MDT: Multidisciplinary team; NHD: National Haemophilia Database; NHF: National Hemophilia Foundation; PK: Pharmacokinetics; POCUS: Point of care ultrasound; PWH: People with haemophilia; SHIELD: Supporting Hemophilia through International Education, Learning and Development; WFH: World Federation of Hemophilia.

How I treat inhibitors in haemophilia

The management of patients with inhibitors is the greatest challenge facing haemophilia health professionals. Immune tolerance induction (ITI) can be successful in eliminating the inhibitor in the majority of patients, provided it is started soon after the inhibitor develops and the titre of the inhibitor is <10 BU at commencement of ITI. Acute bleeding is treated using one of two bypassing agents, which exhibit similar efficacy and safety. Surgery in inhibitor patients is challenging and should only be carried out in experienced centres.

Successful immune tolerance induction by FVIII in hemophilia A patients with inhibitor may occur without deletion of FVIII-specific T cells

BACKGROUND

 The development of an inhibitor is the major complication facing patients with hemophilia A treated by administration of factor (F) VIII concentrates. Restoration of tolerance to FVIII can be achieved by prolonged administration of FVIII (immune tolerance induction, ITI). Although ITI has been used for more than 30years in patients with hemophilia A and inhibitor, its mechanism of action is still poorly understood.

OBJECTIVES

 As administration of high doses of antigen can induce the apoptosis of the T cells recognizing the antigen, a potential mechanism of action of ITI may be the deletion of FVIII-specific T cells.

PATIENTS/METHODS

 We studied the CD4+ T-cell response to FVIII in five (one mild, one moderate and three severe) patients successfully desensitized by administration of FVIII and in control subjects.

RESULTS

 Following repeated stimulation with autologous dendritic cells loaded with FVIII, FVIII-specific T oligoclonal cell lines were expanded from the blood of one of the successfully desensitized patients. The FVIII-specific T cells produced IL-5, IL-13 and IL-2. By contrast, FVIII-specific T-cell lines could not be derived from three patients with mild hemophilia A without inhibitor or from four normal control subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

 These data represent the first analysis of the cellular mechanisms regulating the induction of tolerance to FVIII. They demonstrate that successful tolerance induction may occur without deletion of FVIII-specific T cells.

Factor VIII genotype and inhibitor development in patients with haemophilia A: highest risk in patients with splice site mutations

The appearance of inhibitory antibodies against factor VIII (FVIII) is the most severe and costly complication of replacement therapy in patients with haemophilia A (HA). To determine the relationship between FVIII genotype and inhibitor development, baseline FVIII activity, genotype and inhibitor development were reviewed in 1104 patients with HA. In patients with severe HA, splicing errors present the highest frequency of inhibitors, ahead of inversion of intron 1 and of intron 22, nonsense mutations and large deletions. The lowest inhibitor frequency in severe HA is found in patients with missense mutations and small deletions/insertions. Subanalyses indicate that nonsense mutations and small deletions/insertions leading to a frameshift in the light chain are associated with a significant higher risk of inhibitor formation than similar mutations occurring in the heavy chain (27% vs. 14%). These mutation types also have a higher frequency of inhibitors when occurring in exons 23-26, where a second FVIII transcript originates, compared with similar mutations in exons 1-22 (28% vs. 17%). These results suggest that complete absence of FVIII because of null mutations, including splice site mutations, or the absence of a second transcript result in an increased risk of inhibitor development.

A systematic approach to controlling problem bleeds in patients with severe congenital haemophilia A and high-titre inhibitors

The presence of inhibitory antibodies to clotting factors complicates the treatment of bleeding in haemophilia patients. For patients with high-titre inhibitors, bypassing agents are essential to haemostatic management. To determine optimal treatment practices, an international panel of physicians convened to develop a systematic treatment approach for problem bleeds (i.e. bleeds that are unresponsive to initial therapy with a single agent within a reasonable amount of time) in haemophilia patients with inhibitors.

AIM

The goal of this panel was to develop a consensus algorithm that would aid physicians in considering a variety of treatment approaches to optimize patient care by preventing extensive therapy with inadequate treatments that may lead to suboptimal patient outcomes and unnecessary costs.

METHODS

Consensus opinions were analyzed for clinical preferences at different time periods, depending on patient response to treatment. Decision-making points were defined based on the type of bleed: every 8-12 h for the first 24 h, then every 24 h thereafter for limb-threatening bleeds; every 2-4 h for 2-7 days for life-threatening bleeds.

RESULTS

The resultant consensus guidelines provide a generalized methodology to guide the treatment of problem bleeds in patients with severe haemophilia A and inhibitors, and emphasize changing treatment at the first sign of an inadequate haemostatic response. The treatment algorithms apply to both paediatric and adult patients, although the differences between the two groups were reviewed.

CONCLUSION

These guidelines are focused on optimising the timing of treatment decisions, which may lead to faster responses and improved outcomes.

Prophylactic and therapeutic recombinant factor VIIa administration to patients with Glanzmann's thrombasthenia: results of an international survey

BACKGROUND

Antibodies to glycoprotein (GP) IIb-IIIa and/or HLA may render platelet transfusions ineffective to stop bleeding or to cover surgery in patients with Glanzmann's thrombasthenia (GT). Anecdotal reports suggest recombinant factor (rF)VIIa might be a therapeutic alternative in these situations.

OBJECTIVES

An international survey was conducted to evaluate further the efficacy and safety of rFVIIa in GT patients.

PATIENTS

We analyzed the use of rFVIIa during 34 surgical/invasive procedures and 108 bleeding episodes in 59 GT patients including 29 with current or previous antiplatelet antibodies, and 23 with a history of refractoriness to platelet transfusion.

RESULTS

rFVIIa was effective in 29 of the 31 evaluable procedures, and in 77 of the 103 evaluable bleeding episodes of which eight had a recurrence. A significantly higher success rate was observed in severe bleeding episodes when an arbitrarily defined 'optimal regimen' derived from the Canadian pilot study results (> or = 80 micro g kg(-1) rFVIIa/injection, dosing interval < or = 2.5 h, three or more doses before failure declaration) was used compared with other regimens (77%; 24/31 vs. 48%, 19/40; chi(2), P = 0.010). Patients given maintenance doses had significantly fewer recurrences within 48 h of bleed cessation compared with those not given any (Fisher's exact test, P = 0.022). One thromboembolic event and one blood clot in the ureter occurring in surgical patients following prolonged continuous infusion of high-dose rFVIIa and antifibrinolytic drug use have been previously reported.

CONCLUSION

rFVIIa seems a potential alternative to platelet transfusion in GT patients, particularly in those with antiplatelet antibodies and/or platelet refractoriness.

Molecular mechanisms of mild and moderate hemophilia A

Mutations responsible for mild/moderate hemophilia A were extensively characterized over the last 15 years and more than 200 mutations have been identified. However, most of the molecular mechanisms responsible for the reduced factor (F)VIII levels in patients' plasma were determined only recently. Recent progresses in the study of the FVIII molecule three-dimensional structure provided a major insight for understanding molecular events leading to mild/moderate hemophilia A. This allowed prediction of mutations impairing FVIII folding and intracellular processing, which result in reduced FVIII secretion. Mutations potentially slowing down FVIII activation by thrombin were also identified. A number of mutations were also predicted to result in altered stability of activated FVIII. Biochemical analyses allowed identification of mutations reducing FVIII production. Mutations impairing FVIII stability in plasma, by reducing FVIII binding to von Willebrand factor (VWF) were also characterized. Defects in FVIII activity, notably slow activation by thrombin, or abnormal interaction with FIXa, were also recently demonstrated. Biochemical analysis of FVIII variants provided information regarding the structure/function relationship of the FVIII molecule and validated predictions of the three-dimensional structure of the molecule. These observations also contributed to explain the discrepant activities recorded for some FVIII variants using different types of FVIII assays. Altogether, the study of the biochemical properties of FVIII variants and the evaluation of the effects of mutations in three-dimensional models of FVIII identified molecular mechanisms potentially explaining reduced FVIII levels for a majority of patients with mild/moderate hemophilia A. It is expected that these studies will improve diagnosis and treatment of this disease.

Protein A sepharose immunoadsorption: immunological and haemostatic effects in two cases of acquired haemophilia

Acquired haemophilia is a life-threatening disorder caused by circulating auto-antibodies that inhibit factor VIII coagulant activity (FBIII:C). Immunoadsorption on protein A sepharose (IA-PA) was performed in two bleeding patients with acquired haemophilia: we observed a dramatic and quick decrease in the anti-FVIII:C inhibitor titre leading to a normal, albeit transient, haemostatic status. In one case, IA-PA was the only procedure which succeeded in stopping massive haemorrhage. In the second case, IA-PA reinforced the haemostatic effect of recombinant activated factor VII by increasing the endogenous plasma factor VIII level. The efficacy of IA-PA was sustained with immunosuppressive treatment introduced, respectively, 10 and 15 d before the IA-PA procedures. Our experience with IA-PA suggests that this extracorporeal anti-FVIII:C removal procedure is a valuable therapeutic tool for acquired haemophilia and can alleviate life-threatening haemorrhages.

[Which urologic treatment alternatives are there for the hemophiliac patient?]

OBJECTIVE

Urological procedures are hazardous for hemophilic patients. The aim of this work is to report the treatment of 22 hemophilic patients in order to define prognosis factors and treatment options.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

22 patients have been treated: 8 had severe hemophilia, 5 A (FVIII < 1%), 3 B (F IX < 1%), 2 had moderate hemophilia A (FVIII 2 to 6%) and 10 minor hemophilia A (F VIII 7 to 30%). Two had acquired hemophilia with auto-anti-FVIII antibodies (ab). Four patients were HIV+. Eighteen patients were first referred to our hospital, and 3 were transferred from an other institution for persistent hematuria: one with anuria, one after bladder neck incision, and the other following suprapubic prostatectomy.

RESULTS

For patients without FVIII ab, a sufficient level of FVIII or IX (> 60%), could be achieved pre-operatively and maintained post operatively (4 to 20 days, according to the surgical procedure) by injections of FVIII, FIX or by injections of desmopressin. For one haemophilia A patient with anti-F VIII ab, transferred for uncontrollable bleeding after bladder neck incision, selective arterial embolization was successful. But for 2 patients with acquired haemophilia, improvement of the coagulation was insufficient, with human or porcine FVIII, activated prothombic complex concentrates or recombinant activated FVII. In spite of surgical procedures and arterial embolizations the 2 patients died.

CONCLUSION

The urological treatment of haemophilic patients needs to be performed in specialised centers. For patients without FVIII ab, classical urological procedures can be performed. But for patients with FVIII ab when alternative treatments (radiotherapy, LHRH agonists) can be used, the surgical procedures must be delayed; in emergency if hemostasis cannot be achieved arterial embolization could be useful.

Antibodies to the FVIII light chain that neutralize FVIII procoagulant activity are present in plasma of nonresponder patients with severe hemophilia A and in normal polyclonal human IgG

We have analyzed the properties of anti-factor VIII (FVIII) immunoglobulin (Ig) G recovered by affinity chromatography on FVIII-Sepharose from the IgG fraction of the plasma of healthy individuals and nonresponder patients with hemophilia A. Affinity-purified anti-FVIII antibodies were found to neutralize FVIII activity and to bind to FVIII with an affinity similar to that of anti-FVIII IgG that had been affinity-purified from the plasma of inhibitor-positive hemophilia patients and of patients with anti-FVIII autoimmune disease. The antibodies also exhibited patterns of reactivity with thrombin-digested FVIII similar to those of FVIII inhibitors and preferentially recognized epitopes located in the light chain of FVIII. These observations suggest that FVIII inhibitors occurring in hemophilia A and in patients with anti-FVIII autoimmune disease originate from the expansion of preexisting natural anti-FVIII clones that exhibit FVIII-neutralizing properties.