Mechanism of inactivation of a catalytic antibody by p-nitrophenyl esters

Antibody CNJ206 catalyses the hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl esters with significant rate enhancement; however, after a few cycles, 90% of the catalytic activity of CNJ206 is irreversibly lost. This report investigates the properties of the inactivated Fab (fragment antigen binding). After inactivation, the residual esterase activity of CNJ206 is similar to that of the catalytic antibody inhibited by the transition-state analogue (TSA) used to elicit it; the affinity of CNJ206 for the TSA is also dramatically lowered. Here we propose a simple scheme that accounts for the steady-state kinetics of inactivation. The following lines of evidence, when taken together, suggest that stable acylated tyrosine side chains within or close to the Fab combining site are involved in the inactivation process: isoelectric focusing and matrix-assisted-laser-desorption-ionisation-time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry show that incubation with substrate results in several acylated Fab species; inactivation is stable at pH 8, is reversed by mild hydroxylamine treatment and follows the same kinetics as inhibition of binding, which is slowed down by the presence of the TSA hapten. Analysis of the Fab-TSA X-ray structure shows that three tyrosine residues are potential candidates for the inactivation of CNJ206 by its substrates, Tyr L96 being the most likely one; this also suggests that site-directed mutation of one or more of these residues might prevent substrate inactivation and significantly improve catalysis.

Simple method for selecting catalytic monoclonal antibodies that exhibit turnover and specificity

Monoclonal antibodies were raised against a mono-p-nitrophenyl phosphonate ester to elicit catalytic antibodies capable of hydrolyzing the analogous p-nitrophenyl ester or carbonate. Potential catalytic antibody producing clones were selected, by use of a competitive inhibition assay, on the basis of their affinity for a "short" transition-state analogue, a truncated hapten which maximizes the relative contribution of the transition-state structural elements to binding. Of 30-40 clones that would have been examined on the basis of hapten binding alone, 7 were selected and 4 of these catalyzed the hydrolysis of the relevant p-nitrophenyl ester. This competitive inhibition technique represents a general approach for selecting potential catalytic antibodies and significantly increases the probability of obtaining efficient catalytic monoclonal antibodies. Further study of the catalytic antibodies revealed significant rate enhancement (kcat/kuncat approximately 10(4)) and substrate specificity for the hydrolysis of the analogous ester and, for three of the antibodies, of the analogous carbonate. The antibodies displayed turnover, an essential feature of enzymes. Evidence that catalysis occurred at the antibody combining sites was provided by the identity of the binding and the catalysis-inhibition specificity patterns.