Differences in color fading and recovery under sustained fixation

More than two centuries ago, Swiss philosopher I. P. V. Troxler announced in 1804 that fixated images fade away during normal vision. Since this declaration, the phenomenon now known as Troxler fading has become the subject of intensive research. Many researchers were eager to find out why we experience image fading and under what conditions image restoration happens. Here, we investigated the dynamics of color stimulus fading and recovery under sustained eye fixation. The objective of the experiments was to find out which colors fade and recover faster under isoluminant conditions. The stimuli were eight blurred color rings extending to 13° in size. Four unique colors (red, yellow, green, and blue) and four intermediate colors (magenta, cyan, yellow-green, and orange) were used. Stimuli were displayed on a computer monitor with a gray background and were isoluminant to the background. The presentation of the stimulus lasted 2 min and subjects were required to look at the fixation point in the middle of the ring and suppress eye movements. The task for subjects was to report the moments of change in the stimulus visibility by four stages of stimulus completeness. We found that all investigated colors undergo fading and recovery cycles during 2 min of observation. The data suggest that magenta and cyan colors have faster stimulus fading and undergo more recovery cycles, while longer wavelength colors slow down stimulus fading.

Chromatic fading following complete adaptation to unique hues

Profound vision loss occurs after prolonged exposure to an unchanging featureless visual environment. The effect is sometimes called visual fade. Here we investigate this phenomenon in the color domain using two different experiments. In the first experiment we determine the time needed for a colored background to appear achromatic. Four backgrounds were tested. Each represented the observers’ four unique hues. This adaptation time was compared with time to recover after adaptation Hue shifts at the end of the adaptation period were also measured. There were wide individual differences in adaptation times and recovery times. Overall recovery was faster than adaptation (p < 0.02). There were minimal shifts in hue. In the second experiment the changes in saturation (Munsell chroma) and lightness (Munsell value) of the background were monitored at six time intervals during the adapting process. Again asymmetric matching with Munsell samples was used. There were two distinct components to both the adaptation and recovery phases; one fast with time constant <1s, the other slow with time constant between 40 and 160s.

The experiments show that the special case of visual fade involving color represents the sensory basis for many color-related effects involving adaptation.

Fast cyclic stimulus flashing modulates perception of bi-stable figure

Many experiments have demonstrated that the rhythms in the brain influence the initial perceptual information processing. We investigated whether the alternation rate of the perception of a Necker cube depends on the frequency and duration of a flashing Necker cube. We hypothesize that synchronization between the external rhythm of a flashing stimulus and the internal rhythm of neuronal processing should change the alternation rate of a Necker cube. Knowing how a flickering stimulus with a given frequency and duration affects the alternation rate of bistable perception, we could estimate the frequency of the internal neuronal processing. Our results show that the perception time of the dominant stimulus depends on the frequency or duration of the flashing stimuli. The duration of the stimuli, at which the duration of the perceived image was maximal, was repeated periodically at 4 ms intervals. We suppose that such results could be explained by the existence of an internal rhythm of 125 cycles/s for bistable visual perception. We can also suppose that it is not the stimulus duration but the precise timing of the moments of switching on of external stimuli to match the internal stimuli which explains our experimental results. Similarity between the effects of flashing frequency on alternation rate of stimuli perception in present and previously performed experiment on binocular rivalry support the existence of a common mechanism for binocular rivalry and monocular perception of ambiguous figures.

Colour Matching of Isoluminant Samples and Backgrounds: A Model

A cone-opponent-based vector model is used to derive the activity in the red-green, yellow-blue, and achromatic channels during a sequential asymmetric colour-matching experiment. Forty Munsell samples, simulated under illuminant C, were matched with their appearance under eight test illuminants. The test samples and backgrounds were photometrically isoluminant with each other. According to the model, the orthogonality of the channels is revealed when test illuminants lie along either red-green or yellow-blue cardinal axes. The red-green and yellow-blue outputs of the channels are described in terms of the hue of the sample. The fact that the three-channel model explains the data in a colour-matching experiment indicates that an early form of colour processing is mediated at a site where the three channels converge, probably the input layer of V1.

Lightness constancy and its link with cone contrast

The link between chromatic constancy (compensation for hue and saturation shifts) and lightness constancy (compensation for a change in surface reflectance) was tested theoretically by computing cone contrasts and by asymmetric matching experiments. The effect of a thin achromatic line (a frame) around the test sample was tested empirically. When the samples were outlined by the frame, lightness constancy was increased and chromatic constancy reduced (p<0.001). Changes in luminance are more likely to be compensated when the luminance contrast edge around the test stimulus is disturbed as with the addition of an achromatic frame.

Systematic violations of von Kries rule reveal its limitations for explaining color and lightness constancy

Cone contrast remains constant, when the same object/background is seen under different illuminations-the von Kries rule [Shevell, Vis. Res. 18, 1649 (1978)]. Here we explore this idea using asymmetric color matching. We find that von Kries adaptation holds, regardless of whether chromatic constancy index is low or high. When illumination changes the stimulus luminance (reflectance), lightness constancy is weak and matching is dictated by object/background luminance contrast. When this contrast is masked or disrupted, lightness constancy mechanisms are more prominent. Thus von Kries adaptation is incompatible with lightness constancy, suggesting that cortical mechanisms must underlie color constancy, as expected from neurophysiological studies [Zeki, Nature 284, 412 (1980); Wild, Nature 313, 133 (1985)].

Influences of prolonged viewing of tilted lines on perceived line orientation: the normalization and tilt after-effect

Gibson [J. Exp. Psychol. 16, 1 (1993)] observed that during prolonged viewing, a line perceptually rotates toward the nearest vertical or horizontal meridian (the normalization effect), and moreover, the perceived orientation of a subsequently presented line depends on the orientation of the adapting one (the tilt after-effect). The mechanisms of both phenomena remain poorly understood. According to our experimental results, the adapting line perceptually rotates to the nearest of three orientations: vertical, horizontal, and diagonal. We propose a simple neuronal model of orientation detectors whose responses are determined by the cardinal detectors. It is shown that both normalization and tilt after-effect may be explained by adaptation of these cardinal detectors.

Encoding of stimulus movement parameters in the cat visual system

Analysis of matrixes consisting of the numbers of spikes evoked by the movement of simple and complex stimuli in cat visual cortex neurons by the principal components method demonstrated vector encoding. The responses of direction detectors to the movement of points and orientation detectors to changes in the angle of a line were encoded independently in areas V1 and V2 of the cortex. Each type of detector was represented by excitation of two cardinal neurons generating sine and cosine functions. The responses of neurons in the associative cortex with selectivity for the direction of movement of specifically oriented bars depended on four cardinal neurons formed by summation of the excitations of the cardinal neurons of the directional and orientational channels.

Almost complete colour constancy achieved with full-field adaptation

A successive asymmetric colour-matching task was used to study the changes in colour appearance of simulated Munsell samples. Colour shifts were induced with two Planckian illuminants, standard illuminant A (u'=0.256, v'=0.524) and illuminant S (u'=0.174, v'=0.392). Measurements were conducted with a 20 degrees field and a 120 degrees field. Adaptation period varied from 1 to 30s with the smaller field and from 1 to 60s with the larger field. Colour shifts were specified in terms of a modified Brunswik ratio (BR). Higher values of BR were associated with longer adaptation periods but only when the larger background was used. Supplementary experiments showed that the changes in colour appearance were related to a slight shift in the perceived colour of the background. The timing of the colour shifts are modelled in terms of cone opponent responses. High values of BR correspond to almost complete von Kries adaptation in all three cone types.

Cone contrasts do not predict color constancy

A successive, asymmetric color-matching paradigm was used to investigate the link between cone contrast and the stability of perceived colors. We measured the perceived color shifts of 10 Munsell samples, induced by test illuminant A, simulated in u'v' color space. The capacity of the visual system to resist these shifts, otherwise known as color constancy, is measured in terms of the Brunswik ratio, BR. Cone contrasts are calculated with respect to either the physical or perceived background. Subjective cone contrasts show a better fit to the von Kries law than those based on the physical background. Complete cone adaptation occurs when color constancy is high. However we show conditions where cone adaptation seems complete but color constancy is poor.

[Coding of stimulus movement parameters in cat visual system]

The principal component analysis of matrices composed of spike numbers generated by visual neurons of cats in response to motion of simple and complex stimuli revealed vector encoding. Responses of detectors of moving dot direction and detectors of oblique line orientation are encoded independently in V1 and V2 cortices by excitation of two cardinal neurons. Each pair of these neurons generates sine and cosine functions. Responses of detectors in the association cortex selective to specific orientation of moving stripes depend on the activity of four cardinal neurons which sum up the excitation incoming from the direction and orientation channels.

Colour matching of isoluminant samples and backgrounds: a dimming effect

Sequential asymmetrical colour matching of forty Munsell samples simulated under illuminant C and one of eight test illuminants was carried out. The subjects matched the appearance of each sample under illuminant C with its appearance under the test illuminant. Samples and background (N7) were presented for 1 s under the test illuminant and were isoluminant with each other. Subjects adjusted hue, chroma, and value under illuminant C. The experiments distinguished two groups of subjects; some observers needed to reduce the luminance of the sample to make a match while others did not. This 'dimming' occurred when the matches were close to cardinal axes, especially the tritanopic confusion line. A model of luminance and cone-opponent mechanisms contributing to brightness can account for the dimming effect. Details of analysis in cone-opponent space (L - M, L + M - S, L + M) are presented in the companion paper (Stanikunas et al, 2005 Perception 34 this issue).

Investigation of color constancy with a neural network

The perceptual stability of an object's color under different illuminants is called color constancy. We created a neural network to investigate this phenomenon. The net consisted of one input channel for the background and one for the test object. Each channel had a set of three (L, M, and S) receptors that were transmitting to three opponent neurons. The signals from the opponent neurons were passed to hidden neurons, which were connected to the output neurons. The output signal was generated from the three components of a color vector. The neural net was trained to identify the color of Munsell samples under various illuminants using the back-propagation algorithm. Our study investigated the properties of a successfully trained neural network. Based on the cross-neuron weight analysis, we report that the successfully trained neural net calculates color differences between the test object and the background. By comparing the human visual system to the neural net, we conclude that to satisfy the color constancy phenomenon, the human visual system has to contain two separate components: one to approximate the background color and the other to estimate the color difference between the object and the background.

A Neural Net for Reconstructing 3-D Images of Object Surfaces

There are some algorithms for reconstructing a 3-D surface from two 2-D images. Usually these algorithms are different for shaded objects and for 3-D surfaces from random-dot stereograms. We here propose a neural net for the reconstruction of images of such objects. Two arrays (matrices) of photosensitive elements act as inputs to the neural net. The real 3-D object (shaded sphere and planes) illuminated by a point light source produces two images in the plane of these matrices. The information from photomatrices is processed by many independent channels. Each channel obtains information only from a delimited area of the matrices. This area is called the receptive field (RF) of the channel. RFs of the different channels overlap. If RFs have the same coordinates on the two matrices, they form a pair of corresponding RFs. The information obtained from this pair is integrally processed, determining both the spatial position of the single object surface fragment and its averaged brightness. Two subsystems (coarse and fine) are used to determine the spatial position. First, the orientations of the matrices are chosen so as to bring down to a minimum the integral differences of light intensities between the images in all corresponding RFs. The coarse subsystems determine the disparities of the corresponding RFs, taking into account the orientation (fixation disparity) of the matrices. The fine subsystems calculate the centroids of the images within the RFs and the averaged intensity across the RFs. This information is used to calculate the exact position of the fragment in space and the averaged brightness. All calculations are carried out by neuron detectors sensitive to object location in space. These neurons form the output layer of the neural net.