Validation of cDNA microarray gene expression data obtained from linearly amplified RNA

BACKGROUND

DNA microarray technology has permitted the analysis of global gene expression profiles for several diseases, including cancer. However, standard hybridisation and detection protocols require micrograms of mRNA for microarray analysis, limiting broader application of this technology to small excisional biopsies, needle biopsies, and/or microdissected tissue samples. Therefore, linear amplification protocols to increase the amount of RNA have been developed. The correlation between the results of microarray experiments derived from non-amplified RNA and amplified samples needs to be evaluated in detail.

METHODS

Total RNA was amplified and replicate hybridisation experiments were performed with linearly amplified (aRNA) and non-amplified mRNA from tonsillar B cells and the SUDHL-6 cell line using cDNA microarrays containing approximately 4500 genes. The results of microarray differential expression using either source of RNA (mRNA or aRNA) were also compared with those found using real time quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (QRT-PCR).

RESULTS

Microarray experiments using aRNA generated reproducible data displaying only small differences to data obtained from non-amplified mRNA. The quality of the starting total RNA template and the concentration of the promoter primer used to synthesise cDNA were crucial components of the linear amplification reaction. Approximately 80% of selected upregulated and downregulated genes identified by microarray analysis using linearly amplified RNA were confirmed by QRT-PCR using non-amplified mRNA as the starting template.

CONCLUSIONS

Linear RNA amplification methods can be used to generate high fidelity microarray expression data of comparable quality to data generated by microarray methods that use non-amplified mRNA samples.

Solution-based scanning for single-base alterations using a double-stranded DNA binding dye and fluorescence-melting profiles

DNA molecules differing by as little as a single-base substitution have traditionally been distinguished by gel electrophoresis-based methodologies that exploit differences in the sequence-specific properties of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) such as melting temperature and secondary conformational configuration. By comparison, solution-based fluorescence methods using sequence-specific probes are limited to detecting mutations restricted to very short segments of DNA ( approximately 20 bp). We describe a solution-based fluorescence method that discriminates between wild-type and mutant sequences using a dsDNA binding dye, and interrogates a region of >200 nucleotides. This method is based on melting theory and entails fluorescence monitoring of the melting temperatures of GC-clamped amplicons subjected to gradual and progressive thermal denaturation in the presence of a constant concentration of urea. Heterozygous samples are easily identified by the lower melting temperatures of the less thermodynamically stable heteroduplex mismatches from the wild-type:mutant DNA hybrids as compared to the more stable wild-type Watson-Crick duplexes. All of the four possible sets of mismatches (A.G/T.C, T.G/A.C, G.G/C.C, and T.T/A.A) represented in 17 heterozygous mutations distributed throughout the length of 20 different amplicons (104 to 212 bp), were distinguished from the wild-type by their altered melting profiles. This methodology is advantageous in that it obviates gel electrophoresis or labeled oligonucleotide probes. Significantly, it expands the region of interrogation for detection of single-base changes using fluorescence-based methods in solution, and is amenable for automation and adaptation to high-throughput systems.

Follicular lymphoma with monocytoid B-cell proliferation: molecular assessment of the clonal relationship between the follicular and monocytoid B-cell components

Although a number of studies have recognized that follicular lymphomas may be accompanied by a prominent proliferation of monocytoid B-cells, the clonal relationship between these components has not been adequately assessed. Using laser capture microdissection, we isolated the follicular and monocytoid B-cell components from four well-characterized cases of follicular lymphoma with prominent monocytoid B-cells. DNA from each component was analyzed using polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based methods to assess for clonal rearrangements of the immunoglobulin heavy chain gene (IgH) and for the presence of the bcl-2 gene major breakpoint region/joining region (MBR/JH) DNA fusion products by conventional PCR and fluorescence melting curve analysis. Evidence of clonal identity was established in the follicular and monocytoid B-cell components of three cases by demonstration of IgH gene rearrangements of identical size using IgH PCR, by comparison of complementarity determining region III (CDRIII) DNA sequences, or by detection of bcl-2 MBR/JH fusion products of identical size and/or melting temperature. Molecular analysis of the fourth case revealed a monoclonal and MBR/JH-positive follicular component accompanied by a polyclonal and MBR/JH-negative monocytoid B-cell proliferation. We conclude that the follicular and monocytoid B-cell components of this variant of follicular lymphoma are clonally identical in the majority of cases. However, in a minority of these cases, the monocytoid B-cell component is reactive. Larger studies that assess the prognostic significance of follicular lymphoma with monocytoid B-cells will benefit from molecular studies that assess the clonal relationship of both components.

PCR analysis of the immunoglobulin heavy chain gene in polyclonal processes can yield pseudoclonal bands as an artifact of low B cell number

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based analysis for detecting immunoglobulin heavy chain gene (IgH) rearrangements in lymphoproliferative disorders is well established. The presence of one or two discrete bands is interpreted as a monoclonal proliferation, whereas a smear pattern represents a polyclonal population. Prompted by our observation of discrete bands in histologically reactive processes with a relative paucity of B cells, we sought to determine whether low numbers of B cells in biopsy specimens could artifactually produce pseudomonoclonal bands. We performed IgH PCR analysis on serially diluted DNA samples from 5 B cell non-Hodgkin's lymphomas (B-NHLs), 5 reactive lymph nodes, 5 reactive tonsils and 10 microdissected germinal centers from a lymph node with follicular hyperplasia. We also assessed multiple aliquots of DNA samples from small biopsy specimens of reactive lymphocytic processes from the stomach (5 cases). PCR products were evaluated using high resolution agarose or polyacrylamide gels, and DNA sequencing was performed on IgH PCR products from two reactive germinal centers, which yielded monoclonal bands of identical size. All 5 B-NHLs harboring monoclonal B cell populations yielded single discrete bands, which were maintained in all dilutions. By contrast, all of the reactive lesions with polyclonal patterns at 50 ng/microl starting template concentration showed strong pseudomonoclonal bands at dilutions of 1:1,000 to 1:1,500 in placental DNA. Two of the microdissected reactive germinal centers that showed bands of identical size on duplicate reactions were proven to have different IgH sequences by sequencing. We conclude that specimens containing low numbers of polyclonal B cells may produce pseudomonoclonal bands on IgH PCR analysis. IgH PCR analysis should be performed on multiple aliquots of each DNA sample, and only samples that yield reproducible bands of identical size can be reliably interpreted as monoclonal.

Fluorescence melting curve analysis for the detection of the bcl-1/JH translocation in mantle cell lymphoma

PCR amplification and product analysis for the detection of chromosomal translocations such as bcl-1/JH have traditionally been performed as a two-step process with separate amplification and product detection. PCR product detection has generally entailed gel electrophoresis, hybridization, or sequencing for confirmation of assay specificity. By using a microvolume fluorimeter integrated with a thermal cycler and the PCR compatible double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) binding dye SYBR Green I, we simultaneously amplified and detected bcl-1/JH translocation products by using rapid cycle PCR and fluorescence melting curve analysis. We analyzed DNA from 25 cases of lymphoproliferative disorders comprising 12 previously documented bcl-1/JH-positive mantle cell lymphomas, and 13 reactive lymphadenopathies. The samples were coded and analyzed in a blind manner for the presence of bcl-1/JH translocations by fluorescence melting curve analysis. The results of fluorescence analysis were compared with those of conventional PCR and gel electrophoresis. All of the 12 cases (100%) previously determined to be bcl-1/JH positive by conventional PCR analysis showed a characteristic sharp decrease in fluorescence at about 86 degrees C by melting curve analysis. For easier visualization of melting temperatures (Tm), fluorescence melting peaks were obtained by plotting the negative derivative of fluorescence over temperature (-dF/dT) versus temperature (T). Dilutional assays revealed that fluorescence melting curve analysis was more sensitive than conventional PCR and agarose gel electrophoresis with ultraviolet transillumination by as much as 40-fold. Our results indicate that nucleic acid amplification integrated with fluorescence melting curve analysis is a simple, reliable, sensitive, and rapid method for the detection of bcl-1/JH translocations. The feasibility of specific PCR product detection without electrophoresis or expensive fluorescently labeled probes makes this methodology attractive for studies in molecular pathology.

Rapid simultaneous amplification and detection of the MBR/JH chromosomal translocation by fluorescence melting curve analysis

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and product analysis for the detection of chromosomal translocations, such as the t(14;18), has traditionally been a two-step process. PCR product detection has generally entailed gel electrophoresis and/or hybridization or sequencing for confirmation of assay specificity. Using a microvolume fluorimeter integrated with a thermal cycler and a PCR-compatible double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) binding fluorescent dye (SYBR Green I), we investigated the feasibility of simultaneous thermal amplification and detection of MBR/JH translocation products by fluorescence melting curve analysis. We analyzed DNA from 30 cases of lymphoproliferative disorders comprising 19 cases of previously documented MBR/JH-positive follicle center lymphoma and 11 reactive lymphadenopathies. The samples were coded and analyzed blindly for the presence of MBR/JH translocations by fluorescence melting curve analysis. We also performed dilutional assays using the MBR/JH-positive cell line SUDHL-6. Multiplex PCR for MBR/JH and beta-globin was used to simultaneously assess sample adequacy. All (100%) of the 19 cases previously determined to be MBR/JH positive by conventional PCR analysis showed a characteristic sharp decrease in fluorescence at approximately 90 degrees C by melting curve analysis after amplification. Fluorescence melting peaks obtained by plotting the negative derivative of fluorescence over temperature (-dF/dT) versus temperature (T) showed melting temperatures (Tm) at 88.85+/-1.15 degrees C. In addition, multiplex assays using both MBR/JH and beta-globin primers yielded easily distinguishable fluorescence melting peaks at approximately 90 degrees C and 81.2 degrees C, respectively. Dilutional assays revealed that fluorescence melting curve analysis was more sensitive than conventional PCR and agarose gel electrophoresis with ultraviolet transillumination by as much as 100-fold. Simultaneous amplification and fluorescence melting curve analysis is a simple, reliable, and sensitive method for the detection of MBR/JH translocations. The feasibility of specific PCR product detection without electrophoresis or utilization of expensive fluorescently labeled probes makes this method attractive for routine molecular diagnostics.