Complex organisational factors influence multidisciplinary care for patients with hip fractures: a qualitative study of barriers and facilitators to service delivery

BACKGROUND

Hip fractures are devastating injuries, with high health and social care costs. Despite national standards and guidelines, substantial variation persists in hospital delivery of hip fracture care and patient outcomes. This qualitative study aimed to identify organisational processes that can be targeted to reduce variation in service provision and improve patient care.

METHODS

Interviews were conducted with 40 staff delivering hip fracture care in four UK hospitals. Twenty-three anonymised British Orthopaedic Association reports addressing under-performing hip fracture services were analysed. Following Thematic Analysis of both data sources, themes were transposed onto domains both along and across the hip fracture care pathway.

RESULTS

Effective pre-operative care required early alert of patient admission and the availability of staff in emergency departments to undertake assessments, investigations and administer analgesia. Coordinated decision-making between medical and surgical teams regarding surgery was key, with strategies to ensure flexible but efficient trauma lists. Orthogeriatric services were central to effective service delivery, with collaborative working and supervision of junior doctors, specialist nurses and therapists. Information sharing via multidisciplinary meetings was facilitated by joined up information and technology systems. Service provision was improved by embedding hip fracture pathway documents in induction and training and ensuring their consistent use by the whole team. Hospital executive leadership was important in prioritising hip fracture care and advocating service improvement. Nominated specialty leads, who jointly owned the pathway and met regularly, actively steered services and regularly monitored performance, investigating lapses and consistently feeding back to the multidisciplinary team.

CONCLUSION

Findings highlight the importance of representation from all teams and departments involved in the multidisciplinary care pathway, to deliver integrated hip fracture care. Complex, potentially modifiable, barriers and facilitators to care delivery were identified, informing recommendations to improve effective hip fracture care delivery, and assist hospital services when re-designing and implementing service improvements.

995 MULTIPLE ORGANISATIONAL FACTORS IMPROVE MULTI-DISCIPLINARY CARE DELIVERY TO PATIENTS WITH HIP FRACTURES: A QUALITATIVE STUDY

Introduction

Hip fractures are devastating injuries which incur high healthcare costs. Despite national standards and guidelines, there is substantial variation in hospital delivery of hip fracture care and in patient outcomes. This study aimed to understand organisational processes that facilitate successful delivery of hip fracture services.

Method

Forty qualitative interviews were conducted with healthcare professionals involved in delivering hip fracture care at four English hospitals. Interview data were supplemented with documentary analysis of 23 anonymised British Orthopaedic Association hospital-initiated peer-review reports of services. Data were analysed thematically, with themes transposed onto key components of the care pathway.

Results

We identified multiple aspects of service organisation that facilitated good care delivery. At admission, standardisation of training in nerve block administration impacted care delivery. During hospital stays, service delivery was improved by integrated, shared-care between orthopaedics and orthogeriatrics, and by strategies to improve trauma list efficiency. Adequately staffed orthogeriatric services and the ‘right’ skills and seniority mix were important to holistic care provision. Placing patients on designated hip fracture wards concentrated staff expertise. Collaborative working was achieved through multi-disciplinary team (MDT) meetings between key staff, protocols and care pathways that defined roles and responsibilities, MDT documentation, ‘joined-up’ IT systems within hospitals and with primary care, and shared working spaces such as shared offices and onwards. Trauma and hip fracture coordinators organised care processes and provided a valuable central point of contact within teams. Nominated leads, representing diverse specialties, worked together in MDT planning meetings to develop joint protocols, establish audit priorities, and agree shared goals. Routine, comprehensive monitoring and evaluation of service delivery, with findings shared throughout the MDT, was beneficial.

Conclusion

Our study has characterised potentially modifiable elements of successful hip fracture service delivery. Findings are intended to help services overcome organisational barriers towards delivery of high-quality hip fracture services.

How Schwartz’ Basic Human Values Influence Food Choices in Kenya and Tanzania

Objectives

To identify and describe how values drive food choice of vulnerable consumers in two East African countries, Kenya and Tanzania.

Methods

Secondary data analysis was conducted on focus group discussions from studies in Kenya and Tanzania. A codebook was developed based on Schwartz's theory of basic human values. A priori coding was conducted in NVivo 12 followed by a narrative comparative analysis, which included review by original principal investigators.

Results

Values of conservation (security, conformity, tradition), openness to change (self-directed thought and action, stimulation, indulgence), self-enhancement (achievement, power, face), and self-transcendence (benevolence dependability and caring) were prominent drivers of food choice in both settings. While tradition was an important value in food choice, new social situations and food environments rendered reprioritization, especially pertaining to youth and animal source foods. Openness to change values were readily cited, especially in peri-urban Kenya with many new foods and diverse neighborhoods. Values of independent thought and action were drivers of mothers’ food choices for families. Benevolence security and caring were drivers choices for child feeding and selecting trustworthy food vendors. Many participants described how values existed in tension. For example, changes in livelihood led to a reprioritization of values like stimulation or indulgence over tradition.

Conclusions

Values were important drivers of food choice in both settings, particularly for meat. Future efforts to promote healthy, sustainable diets will require policy and broad consumer support to succeed. Examining the values that drive food choice in different contexts is necessary especially to minimize unintended consequences, controversy, and perhaps opposition in the implementation of policies and programs.

Funding Sources

UK Government's Foreign, Commonwealth, and Development Office and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation; the views expressed do not necessarily reflect the UK Government's official policies.

POS1514-HPR UNDERSTANDING AND CHARACTERISING PATIENT PATHWAYS TO TREATMENT FOR VERTEBRAL FRACTURES: A QUALITATIVE STUDY

Background

Osteoporosis involves thinning of the bones, making them more prone to break. The most common osteoporotic fracture is a vertebral fracture (OVF). People with OVFs are at high risk of further fractures. To reduce this risk, guidelines recommend prescription of bone protection therapies to people who have experienced a fracture. However, many patients do not receive diagnosis. Understanding patient pathways to treatment for OVFs will provide information to improve practice and aid in effective identification and management.

Objectives

To understand and characterise patient pathways to treatment for OVFs.

Methods

Twenty-three semi-structured qualitative interviews were conducted with patients aged ≥50 years with diagnosis of OVF. Patients were recruited through two hospitals in England and were purposively sampled to capture variation in pathways to diagnosis, sex, age, comorbidities and other relevant characteristics. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and analysed thematically, with themes transposed onto key stages of the patient pathway.

Results

Several factors influenced patient pathways to treatment:

Patient appraisal and self-management: Characteristics and attitudes towards back pain impacted treatment-seeking behaviour. Patients who appraised their pain as ‘different’, severe or disruptive, or associated with an injury such as a fall, were more likely to seek help. Limited availability of information about OVFs and risk factors meant most patients did not associate symptoms with a potential OVF. Factors contributing to delayed consultation included the normalisation of back pain and prioritisation of comorbid conditions. Several misappraised their symptoms as a “pulled muscle” or other minor injury. Many adopted strategies to manage pain, including use of painkillers, lying flat or resting. For some, a lack of improvement in symptoms over time, combined with worsening pain, created a ‘tipping point’ in seeking care. There was a moral dimension for some patients who did not want to “bother” healthcare professionals.

Healthcare professional appraisal: Differential diagnosis was a barrier to treatment and healthcare professionals interpreted OVF pain as broken ribs, muscular pain, kidney pain or sciatica. GPs tended to instigate watchful waiting, in which patients were asked to re-consult if pain did not improve. Feeling disbelieved caused some patients to become disillusioned and reluctant to re-consult and a small number of patients presented at Accident and Emergency. Those already having treatment for musculoskeletal conditions with access to specialist care, were more likely to receive timely diagnosis.

Communication of diagnosis: Patients discussed multiple methods of communication, including written communication and clinical conversations. Several expressed confusion around the use of unfamiliar medical terminology, the implications of OVFs, how many OVFs they had experienced and how they had been identified.

Treatment initiation: Bone protection therapies were not consistently prescribed after diagnosis. Patients who were familiar with these therapies were unsure whether treatment should be initiated in primary or secondary care. Patients described how they felt a need to be proactive by arranging appointments and asking for treatment.

Conclusion

The study provides novel findings about patient pathways to treatment and will be used to identify targeted solutions to improve management of OVFs. This work addresses stages of the Model of Pathways to Treatment[1] and provides detailed understanding of patients’ experiences of these stages. Further work with healthcare professionals in primary care is underway to identify additional system-level factors that may impact patients’ journeys to treatment.

References

[1]Scott, S.E., et al., The model of pathways to treatment: conceptualization and integration with existing theory. Br J Health Psychol, 2013. 18(1): p. 45-65.

Acknowledgements

This study is funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Research for Patient Benefit (RfPB) programme NIHR201523. The views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care.

Disclosure of Interests

None declared

Reference Echocardiographic Measurements in Very Low Birth Weight Preterm Infants

BACKGROUND

Echocardiography is an important technique in neonatal care. The heart of a premature baby is known to be different from that of a term baby, and there is a paucity of literature regarding reference cardiac measurements for this population, especially for the very low birth weight (VLBW) infants.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to present reference values for echocardiography in VLBW preterm infants.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a retrospective observational study taking place over an 11-year period. We collected data from the reports of echocardiographic examinations performed in a population of preterm infants born with gestational age ≤ 32 weeks and birth weight (BW) ≤ 1,500 g in the first week of life.

RESULTS

Our study population included 1,244 preterm infants. We found BW to be an adequate and practical variable to use in relation to the cardiac measurements. We propose reference values for seven cardiac measurements presented in tables for each 100 g weight subgroup.

CONCLUSION

Our study, to the best of our knowledge, has the largest sample of VLBW preterm infants and provides easy-to-use information on cardiac measurements by echocardiography for both pediatric cardiologists and neonatologists.

An observational cohort study to produce and evaluate an improved tool to screen older women with back pain for osteoporotic vertebral fractures (Vfrac): study protocol

The aim of this study is to produce an easy to use checklist for general practitioners to complete whenever a woman aged over 65 years with back pain seeks healthcare. This checklist will produce a binary output to determine if the patient should have a radiograph to diagnose vertebral fracture.

PURPOSE

People with osteoporotic vertebral fractures are important to be identified as they are at relatively high risk of further fractures. Despite this, less than a third of people with osteoporotic vertebral fractures come to clinical attention due to various reasons including lack of clear triggers to identify who should have diagnostic spinal radiographs. This study aims to produce and evaluate a novel screening tool (Vfrac) for use in older women presenting with back pain in primary care based on clinical triggers and predictors identified previously. This tool will generate a binary output to determine if a radiograph is required.

METHODS

The Vfrac study is a two-site, pragmatic, observational cohort study recruiting 1633 women aged over 65 years with self-reported back pain. Participants will be recruited from primary care in two sites. The Vfrac study will use data from two self-completed questionnaires, a simple physical examination, a lateral thoracic and lateral lumbar radiograph and information contained in medical records.

RESULTS

The primary objective is to develop an easy-to-use clinical screening tool for identifying older women who are likely to have vertebral fractures.

CONCLUSIONS

This article describes the protocol of the Vfrac study; ISRCTN16550671.

Secondary prevention of fractures after hip fracture: a qualitative study of effective service delivery

There is variation in how services to prevent secondary fractures after hip fracture are delivered and no consensus on best models of care. This study identifies healthcare professionals' views on effective care for the prevention of these fractures. It is hoped this will provide information on how to develop services.

INTRODUCTION

Hip fracture patients are at high risk of subsequent osteoporotic fractures. Whilst fracture prevention services are recommended, there is variation in delivery and no consensus on best models of care. This study aims to identify healthcare professionals' views on effective care for prevention of secondary fracture after hip fracture.

METHODS

Forty-three semi-structured interviews were undertaken with healthcare professionals involved in delivering fracture prevention across 11 hospitals in one English region. Interviews explored views on four components of care: (1) case finding, (2) osteoporosis assessment, (3) treatment initiation, and (4) monitoring and coordination. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed, anonymised and coded using NVivo software.

RESULTS

Case finding: a number of approaches were discussed. Multiple methods ensured there was a 'backstop' if patients were overlooked. Osteoporosis assessment: there was no consensus on who should conduct this. The location of the dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) scanner influenced the likelihood of patients receiving a scan. Treatment initiation: it was felt this was best done in inpatients rather request initiation in the post-discharge/outpatients period. Monitoring (adherence): adherence was a major concern, and participants felt more monitoring could be conducted by secondary care. Coordination of care: participants advocated using dedicated coordinators and formal and informal methods of communication. A gap between primary and secondary care was identified and strategies suggested for addressing this.

CONCLUSIONS

A number of ways of organising effective fracture prevention services after hip fracture were identified. It is hoped that this will help professionals identify gaps in care and provide information on how to develop services.

Fractures of the distal third of the clavicle treated by hook plating

We retrospectively assessed the union and shoulder function following hook plate fixation in 18 patients with Neer type 2 fractures of the lateral end of the clavicle. The average age was 40 (range 22-62) years, and the mean follow-up was 25 (range 6-48) months. Fifteen patients had acute fractures and the rest were non-unions. Complications included two non-unions, one following a deep infection. There were no iatrogenic fractures. Acromial osteolysis was seen in five patients who had their plates in situ. The average pain score at rest was 1 (range 0-4), and the average pain score on abduction was 2.2 (range 0-5). The average Constant score was 88.5 (range 63-100). Patients were asked to rate their shoulder function; three rated it as normal, 11 as nearly normal and one as not normal. Hook plate fixation appears to be a valuable method of stabilising Neer type 2 fractures of the clavicle, resulting in high union rates and good shoulder function. These plates need to be removed after union to prevent acromial osteolysis.

Low-energy arterial injury at the shoulder with progressive or delayed nerve palsy

We describe 20 patients, aged between 43 and 88 years, with delayed nerve palsy or deepening of an initial palsy caused by arterial injury from low-energy injuries to the shoulder. The onset of palsy ranged from immediately after the injury to four months later. There was progression in all the patients with an initial partial nerve palsy. Pain was severe in 18 patients, in 16 of whom it presented as neurostenalgia and in two as causalgia. Dislocation of the shoulder or fracture of the proximal humerus occurred in 16 patients. There was soft-tissue crushing in two and prolonged unconsciousness from alcoholic intoxication in another two. Decompression of the plexus and repair of the arterial injury brought swift relief from pain in all the patients. Nerve recovery was generally good, but less so in neglected cases. The interval from injury to the repair of the vessels ranged from immediately afterwards to 120 days. Delayed onset of nerve palsy or deepening of a nerve lesion is caused by bleeding and/or impending critical ischaemia and is an overwhelming indication for urgent surgery. There is almost always severe neuropathic pain.

Application of radiolabeled tracers to biocatalytic flux analysis

Radiolabeled tracers can provide valuable information about the structure of and flux distributions in biocatalytic reaction networks. This method derives from prior studies of glucose metabolism in mammalian systems and is implemented by pulsing a culture with a radiolabeled metabolite that can be transported into the cells and subsequently measuring the radioactivity of all network metabolites following separation by liquid chromatography. Intracellular fluxes can be directly determined from the transient radioactivity count data by tracking the depletion of the radiolabeled metabolite and/or the accompanying accumulation of any products formed. This technique differs from previous methods in that it is applied within a systems approach to the problem of flux determination. It has been used for the investigation of the indene bioconversion network expressed in Rhodococcus sp. KY1. Flux estimates obtained by radioactive tracers were confirmed by macroscopic metabolite balancing and showed that indene oxidation in steady state chemostat cultures proceeds primarily through a monooxygenase activity forming (1S,2R)-indan oxide, with no dehydrogenation of trans-(1R,2R)-indandiol. These results confirmed the significance of indan oxide formation and identified the hydrolysis of indan oxide as a key step in maximizing the production of (2R)-indandiol, a chiral precursor of the HIV protease inhibitor, Crixivan.

Effectiveness of Ginkgo biloba in treating tinnitus: double blind, placebo controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether Ginkgo biloba is effective in treating tinnitus.

DESIGN

Double blind, placebo controlled trial using postal questionnaires.

PARTICIPANTS

1121 healthy people aged between 18 and 70 years with tinnitus that was comparatively stable; 978 participants were matched (489 pairs).

INTERVENTION

12 weeks' treatment with either 50 mg Ginkgo biloba extract LI 1370 three times daily or placebo.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Participants' assessment of tinnitus before, during, and after treatment. Questionnaires included items assessing perception of how loud and how troublesome tinnitus was. Changes in loudness were rated on a six point scale. Changes in how troublesome were rated on a five point scale.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in primary or secondary outcome measures between the groups. 34 of 360 participants receiving active treatment reported that their tinnitus was less troublesome after 12 weeks of treatment compared with 35 of 360 participants who took placebo.

CONCLUSIONS

50 mg Ginkgo biloba extract LI 1370 given 3 times daily for 12 weeks is no more effective than placebo in treating tinnitus.

Bacterial endocarditis in neonatal intensive care

OBJECTIVES

To ascertain the incidence of bacterial endocarditis in a level III neonatal nursery. To document the clinical features, assess survival, and evaluate the role of central venous catheters in neonates with bacterial endocarditis.

METHODOLOGY

Index cases were identified by retrospective review of the echocardiographic records of infants admitted to the neonatal nursery from 1983 to 1995. Data obtained by review of the clinical records of these infants, and case-matched controls.

RESULTS

From January 1983 to December 1995, 12,249 infants were admitted to the Special Care Nursery. Eight infants with endocarditis were identified, an incidence of 0.07%. Presenting symptoms and signs were often vague and nonspecific. Gestation less than 32 weeks, birthweight less than 1500 g, thrombocytopenia and neutropenia or neutrophilia were common features. Infants with endocarditis had a significantly higher Clinical Risk Index for Babies score than those without endocarditis. The tricuspid valve was involved in seven infants, six of whom had a percutaneous central venous catheter in situ before diagnosis. Mitral valve involvement occurred in two infants, neither of whom had central lines inserted. However, compared to infants without endocarditis, the placement of a central venous line was not of statistical significance. Seven of the eight infants survived following prolonged antibiotic therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

Bacterial endocarditis is a rare but serious condition which is usually not fatal. In the premature newborn infant, presenting signs and symptoms are often nonspecific. Endocarditis should therefore be considered in the unwell very low birthweight infant.

Possible involvement of nitric oxide in the sensorineural hearing loss of bacterial meningitis

Microperfusion of scala tympani with the NO donors, sodium nitroprusside (SNP) and S-nitroso-N-acetylpenicillamine (SNAP), produced marked depression of the compound action potential (CAP) and cochlear microphonic (CM) together with severe and widespread morphological damage to hair cells and supporting cells in the organ of Corti. In addition, direct perfusion of N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) into scala tympani, which probably induces excess stimulation of NMDA receptors within the cochlea and which is known to lead to the release of NO, was found to elicit similar electrophysiological and structural lesions in the cochlea. Pre-perfusion of scala tympani with L-methyl arginine (L-MA), which inhibits the release of NO, or superoxide dismutase (SOD), an O2-scavenger, conferred marked protection upon the cochlea from the lesions caused by NO donors. These observations indicate that enhanced NO production is likely to be an important factor responsible for pathological insult of the cochlea. The possibility is discussed that this factor is involved in the chain of events leading to hearing loss caused by bacterial meningitis. Such hearing loss is a major sequela of bacterial meningitis in children.

Suction tip contamination in the ultraclean-air operating theatre

The surgical suction tip forms a reservoir for microorganisms during total hip replacement in conventional operating theatres. We assessed the colonisation of the tip in an ultraclean-air operating theatre in 39 patients, and found that 41% of them had evidence of bacterial colonisation with one or more bacteria. To avoid contamination we suggest that the suction tip is changed before preparation of the femoral canal and insertion of cement and prosthesis.

Skeletal muscle differentiation in Wilms' tumor. Antibody identification and explant culture

We studied a case of Wilms' tumor with focal areas of well-differentiated skeletal muscle by immunoperoxidase staining using anti-skeletal muscle myosin and by tissue culture explant of the tumor. Strong immunostaining occurred in areas of well-differentiated muscle but also occurred in focal areas where the cells were undifferentiated. The primary explant of this tumor was attempted using standard serum-containing culture media and a serum-free hormonally defined culture medium. While serum-containing culture media gave rise to a fibroblastlike cell population, the serum-free hormonally defined medium produced cells of myoid origin. Ultrastructurally, all stages of early myogenesis from myoblasts to myotubules were observed in this primary explant grown in serum-free medium.