Clinical relevance of findings in trials of CBT for depression

Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) is beneficial in depression. Symptom scores can be translated into Clinical Global Impression (CGI) scale scores to indicate clinical relevance. We aimed to assess the clinical relevance of findings of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of CBT in depression. We identified RCTs of CBT that used the Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression (HAMD). HAMD scores were translated into Clinical Global Impression – Change scale (CGI-I) scores to measure clinical relevance. One hundred and seventy datasets from 82 studies were included. The mean percentage HAMD change for treatment arms was 53.66%, and 29.81% for control arms, a statistically significant difference. Combined active therapies showed the biggest improvement on CGI-I score, followed by CBT alone. All active treatments had better than expected HAMD percentage reduction and CGI-I scores. CBT has a clinically relevant effect in depression, with a notional CGI-I score of 2.2, indicating a significant clinical response. The non-specific or placebo effect of being in a psychotherapy trial was a 29% reduction of HAMD.

Exploratory randomized controlled trial of a group psychological intervention for postnatal depression in British mothers of South Asian origin

Introduction

The rates of postnatal depression (PND) in British South Asian (BSA) women are higher than the general population. PND is known to cause disability and suffering in women and negative consequences for their infants and their family with huge costs to society. Due to linguistic and cultural barriers, BSA women do not access health care services.

Objectives

To conduct an exploratory trial to test the feasibility and acceptability of a culturally adapted group Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) intervention (Positive Health Programme (PHP).

Aim

We aimed to determine if depressed BSA women receiving the PHP intervention will show significant improvements in terms of severity of depression, marital support, and social support as compared to the control group.

Methods

We used a two-arm pragmatic single-blind randomised controlled design. Women meeting the inclusion criteria were randomised either to the experimental group receiving PHP or treatment as usual (TAU) that is standard care usually provided by the GP.

Results

A total of 615 mothers were screened for participation in the trial, of these 137 were assessed further to determine eligibility. Eighty-three mothers were randomized to receive either PHP (n = 42) or treatment as usual (TAU) (n = 41). Mothers found the intervention to be acceptable and felt an overall positive change in their attitudes, behaviour and confidence level.

Conclusion

The recruitment and retention figures (70%) highlight the ability of the research team to engage with the population. The findings suggest the acceptability of the culturally adapted PHP intervention for British South Asian women with postnatal depression.

Disclosure of interest

The authors have not supplied their declaration of competing interest.

Increasing equity of access to high-quality mental health services in primary care: a mixed-methods study

Background

Evidence-based interventions exist for common mental health problems. However, many people are unable to access effective care because it is not available to them or because interactions with caregivers do not address their needs. Current policy initiatives focus on supply-side factors, with less consideration of demand.

Aim and objectives

Our aim was to increase equity of access to high-quality primary mental health care for underserved groups. Our objectives were to clarify the mental health needs of people from underserved groups; identify relevant evidence-based services and barriers to, and facilitators of, access to such services; develop and evaluate interventions that are acceptable to underserved groups; establish effective dissemination strategies; and begin to integrate effective and acceptable interventions into primary care.

Methods and results

Examination of evidence from seven sources brought forward a better understanding of dimensions of access, including how people from underserved groups formulate (mental) health problems and the factors limiting access to existing psychosocial interventions. This informed a multifaceted model with three elements to improve access: community engagement, primary care quality and tailored psychosocial interventions. Using a quasi-experimental design with a no-intervention comparator for each element, we tested the model in four disadvantaged localities, focusing on older people and minority ethnic populations. Community engagement involved information gathering, community champions and focus groups, and a community working group. There was strong engagement with third-sector organisations and variable engagement with health practitioners and commissioners. Outputs included innovative ways to improve health literacy. With regard to primary care, we offered an interactive training package to 8 of 16 practices, including knowledge transfer, systems review and active linking, and seven agreed to participate. Ethnographic observation identified complexity in the role of receptionists in negotiating access. Engagement was facilitated by prior knowledge, the presence of a practice champion and a sense of coproduction of the training. We developed a culturally sensitive well-being intervention with individual, group and signposting elements and tested its feasibility and acceptability for ethnic minority and older people in an exploratory randomised trial. We recruited 57 patients (57% of target) with high levels of unmet need, mainly through general practitioners (GPs). Although recruitment was problematic, qualitative data suggested that patients found the content and delivery of the intervention acceptable. Quantitative analysis suggested that patients in groups receiving the well-being intervention improved compared with the group receiving usual care. The combined effects of the model included enhanced awareness of the psychosocial intervention among community organisations and increased referral by GPs. Primary care practitioners valued community information gathering and access to the Improving Access to Mental Health in Primary Care (AMP) psychosocial intervention. We consequently initiated educational, policy and service developments, including a dedicated website.

Conclusions

Further research is needed to test the generalisability of our model. Mental health expertise exists in communities but needs to be nurtured. Primary care is one point of access to high-quality mental health care. Psychosocial interventions can be adapted to meet the needs of underserved groups. A multilevel intervention to increase access to high-quality mental health care in primary care can be greater than the sum of its parts.

Study registration

Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN68572159.

Funding

The National Institute for Health Research Programme Grants for Applied Research programme.

MR imaging of psychosurgery: rostral atrophy following stereotacic subcaudate tractotomy

There are few reports of MR imaging findings following psychosurgery. Here, we report the findings of 3T MR imaging of the sequelae of stereotactic subcaudate tractotomy (SST). Rostral atrophy is noted on conventional imaging. Diffusion tensor (DT) tractography demonstrated no communicating white matter tracts between the inferior frontal lobes, which appeared normally as thick fibre bundles in age-matched controls. DT tractography provides a unique tool for the evaluation of sequelae of ablative psychosurgical procedures.

The validation of personal health questionnaire amongst people of Pakistani family origin living in the United Kingdom

BACKGROUND

The Personal Health Questionnaire (PHQ) was developed to screen for depressive disorder in an English speaking population. Its validity in Urdu speaking people of Pakistani family origin living in UK is yet to be established.

METHODS

The PHQ was used to screen for depression in a two phase primary care based study of depressive disorder in people of Pakistani family origin residing in Manchester, UK. A proportion of high scorers (PHQ> or =7) and a random selection of low scorers (PHQ 0-6) were interviewed with the Psychiatric Assessment Schedule (PAS) to confirm caseness (ID> or =5). A receiver operator characteristic curve (ROC) analysis was carried out to confirm the optimum threshold value.

RESULTS

The PHQ was used to screen 218 subjects with cut off of PHQ> or =7. 46 high scorers and 31 low scorers were interviewed in second stage using PAS. At this threshold PHQ has a sensitivity of 70.4% and specificity of 89.3%.

CONCLUSIONS

Findings of this study confirm high sensitivity and specificity of PHQ amongst people of Pakistani family origin. It can be used as a screening instrument to detect depression in Urdu speaking population in UK.

Management strategies in geriatric depression by primary care physicians and factors associated with the use of psychiatric services: a naturalistic study

Approximately 10% of elderly patients in primary care have depression yet it is often under-diagnosed and under-treated. It is unclear exactly how patients are being managed in primary care or what factors are associated with referral to psychiatric services. This study aimed to establish in a naturalistic setting how older depressed patients are managed in primary care; to determine which patients are referred to psychiatric services and the differences between patients referred and those not; in terms of primary care consultation rate and degree of co-morbid illness. Computerised records and referral letters were read for 1089 elderly patients in a large practice in central Manchester, UK. Of the 9% identified as depressed, 90% were managed in primary care alone, a third without antidepressants. More than half of those prescribed antidepressants received tricyclic antidepressants. Suicidal ideation and treatment failure were the principle reasons for referral. Patients referred had a greater psychiatric co-morbidity and had consulted their GP more frequently in the past year. Management of depression in the elderly may be conservative and older antidepressants may be over-prescribed. Increased primary care consultation rate and a greater psychiatric co-morbidity may be associated with referral to psychiatric services.

Self-harm in British South Asian women: psychosocial correlates and strategies for prevention

OBJECTIVE

To review the rates of self-harm in British South Asian women, look into the factors that contribute to these high rates of self-harm and discuss possible strategies for prevention and provision of culturally sensitive service for South Asian women who harm themselves.

METHOD

Review.

RESULTS

South Asian women are significantly more likely to self harm between ages 16-24 years than white women. Across all age groups the rates of self harm are lower in South Asian men as compared to South Asian women. These women are generally younger, likely to be married and less likely to be unemployed or use alcohol or other drugs. They report more relationship problems within the family. South Asian women are less likely to attend the ER with repeat episode since they hold the view that mainstream services do not meet their needs.

CONCLUSION

South Asian women are at an increased risk of self harm. Their demographic characteristics, precipitating factors and clinical management are different than whites. There is an urgent need for all those concerned with the mental health services for ethnic minorities to take positive action and eradicate the barriers that prevent British South Asians from seeking help. There is a need to move away from stereotypes and overgeneralisations and start from the user's frame of reference, taking into account family dynamics, belief systems and cultural constraints.

Peripheral neuropathies in Waldenström's macroglobulinaemia

OBJECTIVE

We sought to determine the prevalence, clinical features, and laboratory characteristics of polyneuropathies in Waldenström's macroglobulinaemia (WM), a malignant bone marrow disorder with lymphocytes that produce monoclonal IgM.

METHODS

We prospectively studied 119 patients with WM and 58 controls. Medical history was taken, and neurological examinations, electrodiagnostic tests, and serum studies were performed by different examiners who were blinded to results except the diagnosis of WM.

RESULTS

Polyneuropathy symptoms, including discomfort and sensory loss in the legs, occurred more frequently (p<0.001) in patients with WM (47%) than in controls (9%). Patients with WM had 35% lower quantitative vibration scores, and more frequent pin loss (3.4 times) and gait disorders (5.5 times) than controls (all p<0.001). Patients with IgM binding to sulphatide (5% of WM) had sensory axon loss; those with IgM binding to myelin associated glycoprotein (MAG) (4% of WM) had sensorimotor axon loss and demyelination. Patients with WM with IgM binding to sulphatide (p<0.005) or MAG (p<0.001) had more severe sensory axon loss than other patients with WM. Demyelination occurred in 4% of patients with WM with no IgM binding to MAG. Age related reductions in vibration sense and sural SNAP amplitudes were similar ( approximately 30%) in WM and controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Peripheral nerve symptoms and signs occur more frequently in patients with WM than controls, involve sensory modalities, and are often associated with gait disorders. IgM binding to MAG or sulphatide is associated with a further increase in the frequency and severity of peripheral nerve involvement. Age related changes, similar to those in controls, add to the degree of reduced nerve function in patients with WM.

Sensory exam with a quantitative tuning fork: rapid, sensitive and predictive of SNAP amplitude

BACKGROUND

In the standard neurologic examination, outcome measures of sensation testing are typically qualitative and subjective. The authors compared the outcome of vibratory sense evaluation using a quantitative Rydel-Seiffer 64 Hz tuning fork with qualitative vibration testing, and two other features of the neurologic evaluation, deep tendon reflexes and sensory nerve conduction studies.

METHODS

The authors studied 184 subjects, including 126 with Waldenström's macroglobulinemia and 58 controls, over the course of a weekend. Standard neurologic examinations and quantitative vibratory testing were performed. Sensory nerve action potentials (SNAP) were tested as a measure of sensory nerve function. Tests were carried out by different examiners who were blinded to the results of other testing and to clinical information other than the diagnosis of Waldenström's macroglobulinemia.

RESULTS

Quantitative vibration measurements in all body regions correlated with sural SNAP amplitudes. Quantitative vibration outcomes were more strongly related to sural SNAP results than qualitative evaluations of vibration. Quantitative vibration testing also detected a loss of sensation with increased age in all body regions tested.

CONCLUSIONS

Quantitative vibratory evaluation with Rydel-Seiffer tuning fork is rapid, has high inter- and intrarater reliability, and provides measures for evaluating changes in sensory function over time. Examinations with the quantitative tuning fork are also more sensitive and specific than qualitative vibration testing for detecting changes in sensory nerve function. Use of the quantitative tuning fork takes no more time, provides more objective information, and should replace the qualitative vibratory testing method that is now commonly used in the standard neurologic examination.

Translation and cultural adaptation of health questionnaires

BACKGROUND

Health research in Pakistan often requires questionnaires in English language developed in the West to be translated into the local language. Many of the factors measured by these questionnaires are complex and apply to a different culture. Simple translations may lead to problems of validity and reliability in the Pakistani setting. This paper describes the strategies adopted for the translation and cross-cultural adaptation of the Self-Reporting Questionnaire (SRQ), a screening questionnaire for mental health developed by the World Health Organisation.

METHODS

A general protocol was developed for translation of questionnaires into Urdu, describing each step in the translation procedure. Key informant interviews were carried out to obtain better cultural understanding of difficult concepts. The translation was tested and disputed items discussed in a focus group in a structured manner.

RESULTS

Modifications were made to the questionnaire in light of the target population's culture and language.

CONCLUSION

Simple translations are often insufficient for complex questionnaires. Key informant interviews and focus groups are useful to address conceptual and construct issues in such questionnaires.