A Novel COL4A5 Pathogenic Variant Joins the Dots in a Family with a Synchronous Diagnosis of Alport Syndrome and Polycystic Kidney Disease

Alport Syndrome (AS) is the most common genetic glomerular disease, and it is caused by COL4A3, COL4A4, and COL4A5 pathogenic variants. The classic phenotypic spectrum associated with AS ranges from isolated hematuria to chronic kidney disease (CKD) with extrarenal abnormalities. Atypical presentation of the disorder is possible, and it can mislead the diagnosis. Polycystic kidney disease (PKD), which is most frequently associated with Autosomal Dominant PKD (ADPKD) due to PKD1 and PKD2 heterozygous variants, is emerging as a possible clinical manifestation in COL4A3-A5 patients. We describe a COL4A5 novel familial frameshift variant (NM_000495.5: c.1095dup p.(Leu366ValfsTer45)), which was associated with AS and PKD in the hemizygous proband, as well as with PKD, IgA glomerulonephritis and focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) in the heterozygous mother. Establishing the diagnosis of AS can sometimes be difficult, especially in the context of misleading family history and atypical phenotypic features. This case study supports the emerging genotypic and phenotypic heterogeneity in COL4A3-A5-associated disorders, as well as the recently described association between PKD and collagen type IV (Col4) defects. We highlight the importance of the accurate phenotyping of all family members and the relevance of next-generation sequencing in the differential diagnosis of hereditary kidney disease.

Clinical Significance of the Cystic Phenotype in Alport Syndrome

RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE

Alport Syndrome (AS) is the most common genetic glomerular disease caused by mutations that affect Type IV collagen. However, the clinical characteristics and significance of AS with kidney cysts are not well defined. This study investigated the prevalence and clinical significance of cystic kidney phenotype in AS.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

& Participants: One hundred-eight patients with AS and a comparison cohort of 79 patients with IgA Nephropathy (IgAN). Clinical, genetic, and imaging data were collected from medical records.

EXPOSURES

Cystic kidney phenotype evaluated by ultrasonography and defined as the presence of ≥3 cysts in each kidney. Demographic characteristics and eGFR at disease onset.

OUTCOMES

Cystic kidney phenotype in the AS and IgAN cohorts. Time to CKD stage 3b and longitudinal changes in eGFR in the AS cohort.

ANALYTICAL APPROACH

Logistic regression analysis to test independent strengths of associations of clinical/demographic features with the binary outcome of cystic phenotype. Survival analysis for the outcome of reaching CKD stage 3b and linear mixed models for changes in eGFR over time in the AS cohort.

RESULTS

We studied 108 patients with AS; 76 (70%) had genetic diagnosis. Autosomal dominant AS was prevalent, accounting for 68% of patients with genetic diagnosis. Cystic kidney phenotype was observed in 38% of patients with AS and was associated with normal sized kidneys in all but 3 patients, who showed increased total kidney volume, mimicking autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD). The prevalence of cystic kidney phenotype was significantly higher in patients with AS when compared to comparison group of patients with IgAN (42% vs 19%; p=0.002). Patients with cystic kidney phenotype were older and had more marked reductions in eGFR than patients without cystic changes. Among patients with AS, the cystic phenotype was associated with older age and a faster decline eGFR.

LIMITATIONS

Retrospective, single-center study.

CONCLUSIONS

Cystic kidney phenotype is a common finding in AS. The cystic kidney phenotype is a common finding in AS suggesting a possible role in cystogenesis for the genetic variants that cause this disease.

A Drosophila model to screen Alport syndrome COL4A5 variants for their functional pathogenicity

Alport syndrome is a hereditary chronic kidney disease, attributed to rare pathogenic variants in either of three collagen genes (COL4A3/4/5) with most localized in COL4A5. Trimeric type IV Collagen α3α4α5 is essential for the glomerular basement membrane that forms the kidney filtration barrier. A means to functionally assess the many candidate variants and determine pathogenicity is urgently needed. We used Drosophila, an established model for kidney disease, and identify Col4a1 as the functional homolog of human COL4A5 in the fly nephrocyte (equivalent of human podocyte). Fly nephrocytes deficient for Col4a1 showed an irregular and thickened basement membrane and significantly reduced nephrocyte filtration function. This phenotype was restored by expressing human reference (wildtype) COL4A5, but not by COL4A5 carrying any of three established pathogenic patient-derived variants. We then screened seven additional patient COL4A5 variants; their ClinVar classification was either likely pathogenic or of uncertain significance. The findings support pathogenicity for four of these variants; the three others were found benign. Thus, demonstrating the effectiveness of this Drosophila in vivo kidney platform in providing the urgently needed variant-level functional validation.

The Phenotypic Spectrum of COL4A3 Heterozygotes

Introduction

The penetrance and phenotypic spectrum of autosomal dominant Alport Syndrome (ADAS), affecting 1 in 106, remains understudied.

Methods

Using data from 174,418 participants in the Geisinger MyCode/DiscovEHR study, an unselected health system-based cohort with whole exome sequencing, we identified 403 participants who were heterozygous for likely pathogenic COL4A3 variants. Phenotypic data was evaluated using International Classification of Diseases (ICD) codes, laboratory data, and chart review. To evaluate the phenotypic spectrum of genetically-determined ADAS, we matched COL4A3 heterozygotes 1:5 to nonheterozygotes using propensity scores by demographics, hypertension, diabetes, and nephrolithiasis.

Results

COL4A3 heterozygotes were at significantly increased risks of hematuria, decreased estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR), albuminuria, and kidney failure (P < 0.05 for all comparisons) but not bilateral sensorineural hearing loss (P = 0.9). Phenotypic severity was more severe for collagenous domain glycine missense variants than protein truncating variants (PTVs). For example, patients with Gly695Arg (n = 161) had markedly increased risk of dipstick hematuria (odds ratio [OR] 9.50; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 6.32, 14.28) and kidney failure (OR 7.02; 95% CI: 3.48, 14.16) whereas those with PTVs (n = 119) had moderately increased risks of dipstick hematuria (OR 1.64; 95% CI: 1.03, 2.59) and kidney failure (OR 3.44; 95% CI: 1.28, 9.22). Less than a third of patients had albuminuria screening completed, and fewer than 1 of 3 were taking inhibitors of the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates a wide spectrum of phenotypic severity in ADAS due to COL4A3 with phenotypic variability by genotype. Future studies are needed to evaluate the impact of earlier diagnosis, appropriate evaluation, and treatment of ADAS.

Bilateral Giant Full Thickness Macular Holes: An Infrequent Manifestation of Alport Syndrome

Purpose

To report a case of Alport syndrome presenting with bilateral giant full-thickness macular holes, hypertensive chorioretinopathy, and exudative retinal detachment.

Case Report

A 20 year-old man, a known case of Alport syndrome on hemodialysis, was referred to our clinic with bilateral vision loss initiated about 10 years prior to presentation, which exacerbated in the month prior to our visit. Bilateral large full-thickness macular holes, hypertensive chorioretinopathy, and exudative retinal detachment were detected in fundus examination. The patient had previous genetic counseling confirming the diagnosis of Alport syndrome. During follow-up, macular holes were covered with a thick epiretinal membrane and visual acuity decreased progressively in two weeks. Pars plana vitrectomy was performed in the right eye. Two weeks following surgery, the macular hole was closed and visual acuity improved significantly.

Conclusion

Bilateral giant full-thickness macular holes are uncommon presentations of Alport syndrome. The retinal findings may be caused by an inefficient type IV collagen presenting in the Bruch's membrane and in the internal limiting membrane. Pars plana vitrectomy can be considered to repair macular holes in these patients.

A wave of deep intronic mutations in X-linked Alport Syndrome

X-linked Alport syndrome (XLAS) is an inherited kidney disease caused exclusively by pathogenic variants in the COL4A5 gene. In 10-20% of cases, DNA sequencing of COL4A5 exons or flanking regions cannot identify molecular causes. Here, our objective was to use a transcriptomic approach to identify causative events in a group of 19 patients with XLAS without identified mutation by Alport gene panel sequencing. Bulk RNAseq and/or targeted RNAseq using a capture panel of kidney genes was performed. Alternative splicing events were compared to those of 15 controls by a developed bioinformatic score. When using targeted RNAseq, COL4A5 coverage was found to be 23-fold higher than with bulk RNASeq and revealed 30 significant alternative splicing events in 17 of the 19 patients. After computational scoring, a pathogenic transcript was found in all patients. A causative variant affecting COL4A5 splicing and absent in the general population was identified in all cases. Altogether, we developed a simple and robust method for identification of aberrant transcripts due to pathogenic deep-intronic COL4A5 variants. Thus, these variants, potentially targetable by specific antisense oligonucleotide therapies, were found in a high percentage of patients with XLAS in whom pathogenic variants were missed by conventional DNA sequencing.

Alport syndrome misdiagnosed with IgA nephropathy from familial history: a case report and brief review

BACKGROUND

Alport syndrome is a rare inherited disease resulting from a primary disorder of the glomerular basement membrane. This disease results from mutations in genes encoding alpha chains of type IV collagen. In the differential diagnosis of this disease, IgA nephropathy is the most common primary glomerular disease with gross or microscopic hematuria.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 50-year-old woman was presented with microscopic hematuria and proteinuria of under one gram. Due to the diagnosis of IgA nephropathy in family members, she was treated and followed up for 4 years as a possible case of IgA nephropathy. Eye examination and audiometry were normal. She underwent renal biopsy with an exacerbation of proteinuria. There was no finding in favor of IgA nephropathy in the histological examination, but the findings of electron microscopy and family history favored Alport syndrome.

CONCLUSIONS

This case demonstrates the importance of accurate history and electron microscopy in the complete histological evaluation and diagnosis of glomerular disease. Although in most cases the two can be differentiated based on clinical manifestations, laboratory findings, and histopathological examination, sometimes the association of these two diseases in the families involved or the lack of accurate history and complete histological examinations can complicate the diagnosis.

Genotype-phenotype correlation and prognostic impact in Chinese patients with Alport Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Alport Syndrome (AS) is a progressive hereditary glomerular disease. It is often accompanied by sensorineural hearing loss and ocular abnormalities and can sometimes develop into end stage renal disease (ESRD), which is caused by mutations in the genes encoding the collagen type IV family of proteins.

METHODS

This study analyzed the association between the clinical data of seven AS families and genes and the disease progression of different mutation types, including COL4A3 (OMIM 120070)，COL4A4 (OMIM 120131), and COL4A5 (OMIM303630).

RESULTS

A total of six new pathogenic mutation sites, one complex heterozygous mutation at COL4A3, and a combined mutation of COL4A5 and INF2 (OMIM 610982) were identified in this study. It was revealed that the clinical manifestations of X-linked AS caused by mutations in the COL4A5 gene were more severe in males than in females. In addition, the difference in patient phenotype can be attributed to the location of gene mutations affecting the protein domain or functional domain. Our data suggested that the gene deletion and nonsense mutations had a high risk for progression to ESRD.

CONCLUSION

Our results revealed the spectrum of type IV collagen genes, which contribute to the enrichment of database resources and has important implications in the diagnosis, prognosis, and guiding treatment of AS.

Improved genetic counseling in Alport syndrome by new variants of COL4A5 gene

There are current requirements of using genetic databases for offering a better genetic assistance to patients of some syndromes, especially those with X-linked heredity patterns (like Alport Syndrome) for the high probability of having descendants affected by the disease. We describe the first reported case of COL4A5 gene missense c.1499 G>T mutation in a 16-year-old girl confirmed to be affected by Alport Syndrome after genetic counseling. Next Generation Sequencing procedures let discover this mutation and offer an accurate clinical treatment to this patient. Current scientific understanding of genetic syndromes suggests the high importance of updated databases and the inclusion of Variant of Unknown Significance related to clinical cases. All of this updating could enable patients to have a better opportunity of diagnosis and having genetic and clinical counseling. This event is even more important in women planning to start a family to have correct genetic counseling regarding the risk posed to offspring, and allowing the decision to undergo prenatal testing.

Progressive posterior lenticonus in a patient with alport syndrome

We report a rare case of Alport syndrome with progressive posterior lenticonus. A 24-year-old male presented to our tertiary eye care center with history of poor vision. At initial presentation, the patient had bilateral anterior lenticonus, posterior subcapsular cataract, and renal failure. The patient was diagnosed with Alport syndrome based on a positive family history of the disease and clinical findings. Further examination revealed progressive posterior lenticonus that was not present initially. The presence of such finding is important because it influences the surgical approach to avoid complications during cataract surgery.