Extreme shifts in pyrite sulfur isotope compositions reveal the path to bonanza gold

Pyrite is the most common sulfide mineral in hydrothermal ore-forming systems. The ubiquity and abundance of pyrite, combined with its ability to record and preserve a history of fluid evolution in crustal environments, make it an ideal mineral for studying the genesis of hydrothermal ore deposits, including those that host critical metals. However, with the exception of boiling, few studies have been able to directly link changes in pyrite chemistry to the processes responsible for bonanza-style gold mineralization. Here, we report the results of high-resolution secondary-ion mass spectrometry and electron microprobe analyses conducted on pyrite from the Brucejack epithermal gold deposit, British Columbia. Our δ34S and trace element results reveal that the Brucejack hydrothermal system experienced abrupt fluctuations in fluid chemistry, which preceded and ultimately coincided with the onset of ultra-high-grade mineralization. We argue that these fluctuations, which include the occurrence of extraordinarily negative δ34S values (e.g., -36.1‰) in zones of auriferous, arsenian pyrite, followed by sharp increases of δ34S values in syn-electrum zones of nonarsenian pyrite, were caused by vigorous, fault valve-induced episodic boiling (flashing) and subsequent inundation of the hydrothermal system by seawater. We conclude that the influx of seawater was the essential step to forming bonanza-grade electrum mineralization by triggering, through the addition of cationic flocculants and cooling, the aggregation of colloidal gold suspensions. Moreover, our study demonstrates the efficacy of employing high-resolution, in situ analytical techniques to map out individual ore-forming events in a hydrothermal system.

Colloidal transport and flocculation are the cause of the hyperenrichment of gold in nature

Hydrothermal veins supply much of the Earth’s gold. Their propensity to contain “bonanza” occurrences of gold that have concentrations millions of times greater than the concentration of gold in Earth’s crust makes them important targets for exploration and resource development. The mechanisms by which such hyperenrichment occurs are enigmatic. The accepted wisdom is that this enrichment reflects the saturation and precipitation of gold from hydrothermal fluids. Laboratory experiments and measurements of active hydrothermal systems, however, have shown that the solubility of this noble metal is exceptionally low. Here, we demonstrate that this issue is resolved by the physical transport of gold in the solid state as nanoparticles and their flocculated aggregates, thereby explaining the paradox of bonanza gold ore formation.

Aqueous complexation has long been considered the only viable means of transporting gold to depositional sites in hydrothermal ore-forming systems. A major weakness of this hypothesis is that it cannot readily explain the formation of ultrahigh-grade gold veins. This is a consequence of the relatively low gold concentrations typical of ore fluids (tens of parts per billion [ppb]) and the fact that these “bonanza” veins can contain weight-percent levels of gold in some epithermal and orogenic deposits. Here, we present direct evidence for a hypothesis that could explain these veins, namely, the transport of the gold as colloidal particles and their flocculation in nanoscale calcite veinlets. These gold-bearing nanoveinlets bear a remarkable resemblance to centimeter-scale ore veins in many hydrothermal gold deposits and give unique insight into the scale invariability of colloidal flocculation in forming hyperenriched gold deposits. Using this evidence, we propose a model for the development of bonanza gold veins in high-grade deposits. We argue that gold transport in these systems is largely mechanical and is the result of exceptionally high degrees of supersaturation that preclude precipitation of gold crystals and instead lead to the formation of colloidal particles, which flocculate and form much larger masses. These flocculated masses aggregate locally, where they are seismically pumped into fractures to locally form veins composed largely of gold. This model explains how bonanza veins may form from fluids containing ppb concentrations of gold and does not require prior encapsulation of colloidal gold particles in silica gel, as proposed by previous studies.