Wedge resection combined with 3D-printed polycaprolactone mesh for caudal septal deviation

BACKGROUND

Biocompatibility and stability of three-dimensional printed polycaprolactone mesh grafts for nasal surgery are proven in both animal and human models. However, their safety and durability as batten grafts for caudal septal deviation has not been documented. This study was designed to investigate the efficacy and safety of three-dimensional printed polycaprolactone mesh batten graft in septoplasty using the wedge resection technique for the correction of caudal septal deviation.

METHODS

This retrospective study reviewed the medical records of 20 patients aged ≥ 18 years with caudal septal deviation who underwent septoplasty with wedge resection and three-dimensional printed polycaprolactone mesh graft from a tertiary medical center in South Korea, between December 1, 2019 and May 31, 2021. Those without nasal obstruction before surgery or with a short follow-up period (< 28 days) were excluded from the survey analysis.

RESULTS

Of the 20 patients (mean age, 48.0 [range, 19-65] years), 17 (85.0%) were male, and three (15.0%) were female. A significant change was noted in the mean nasal obstruction symptom evaluation score (68.2 vs. 15.0, P < .001) in the 17 patients included in the analysis. Postoperative endoscopic evaluation revealed a straight septum in 19/20 (95.0%) patients, and no complications were noted in the postoperative follow-up period of up to 364 days.

CONCLUSIONS

The three-dimensional printed polycaprolactone nasal mesh is safe and provides adequate support to resist the intrinsic memory of the cartilage of the caudal septum. In addition to nasal surgeries, it has great potential as a graft in other reconstructive surgeries. Trial registration Retrospectively registered.

Caudal Septal Deviation: New Classification and Management Strategy

To propose a classification of anatomical variation of the caudal septal deviation and propose strategy for the management of caudal septal deviation by septo-rhinoplasty and to evaluate the efficacy of treatment of different types of caudal septal deviation in terms of aesthetic and functional outcome. The study is a retrospective review of 124 cases with significant anterior caudal deviation causing aesthetic and or functional problems, treated by septo-rhinoplasty within a 5 year period from December 2014 to December 2019, with a minimum follow up of 6 months. Visual analogue scale, photographic evaluation and subjective assessment were used for postoperative outcomes. Significant improvement in the treatment of nasal obstruction was achieved, with mean visual analogue scale score of 7.83 preoperatively to 3.56 postoperatively, Subjective assessment showed marked satisfaction in 96 patients, moderate satisfaction in 21 and no improvement in seven patients of total 124 patients. The rate of revision was (4%). A novel classification of anterior caudal septal deviation is proposed with surgical technique directed for individual deformity and we have achieved very good results.

Effectiveness of modified cutting and suture technique for endonasal caudal septoplasty in correcting nasal obstruction and preventing nasal tip projection loss

PURPOSE

Caudal septoplasty is a difficult procedure. The cutting and suture technique is suitable for caudal septoplasty, but a batten graft is always necessary and bears the risk of nasal tip projection loss. We established a modified cutting and suture technique (MCAST), without using a batten graft, and investigated its effectiveness in correcting nasal obstruction and preventing nasal tip projection loss.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the medical records of 22 patients who underwent caudal septoplasty using MCAST. Subjective assessment by Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation (NOSE) score and objective assessment by computed tomography (CT) were performed before and after the surgery. For evaluating nasal tip projection, we asked patients about their awareness of external nasal deformity. Additionally, the nasal tip projection was measured by CT and compared before and after surgery.

RESULTS

The median preoperative NOSE score reduced significantly after MCAST (P < 0.001). On CT, the ratio of the area of the convex side to that of the concave side in the anterior portion of the nasal cavity increased significantly after MCAST (P < 0.001). All patients were unaware of external nasal deformity. There were no significant differences in the mean preoperative and postoperative nasal tip height and nasolabial angle. The mean supra tip height was significantly greater postoperatively than preoperatively (P = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

The MCAST was useful for correcting nasal obstruction with caudal septal deviation. There was no postoperative loss of nasal tip projection. The MCAST can be suitable for correcting C-shaped caudal deviations without dislocating the caudal septum from the anterior nasal septum.

North American survey and systematic review on caudal Septoplasty

Background

Surgical correction of caudal septal deviation is a technically challenging step of functional rhinoplasty. Multiple surgical techniques have been described in the literature but comparing the efficacy of each in relieving obstruction presents a challenge. Outcome measures are necessary to adequately compare techniques. This study aims to describe the current caudal septoplasty techniques of Otolaryngologists and Facial plastic and reconstructive surgeons (FPRS), as well as their use of outcome measures, and to compare these practices with surgical trends described in the literature.

Methods

An online survey was sent to three Otolaryngology and FPRS associations in Canada and the United States. A systematic review was conducted on SCOPUS and PubMed to classify the caudal septoplasty techniques described in the literature and the outcome measurement tools used.

Results

Our survey identified that caudal septoplasty is more commonly performed by surgeons with an FPRS training background. The most common techniques were the swinging door technique (69.5%), extracorporeal septoplasy (46.7%), cartilage scoring (45.3%), and splinting with bone (25.4%). Despite using a vast array of surgical techniques, North American physicians rarely rely on standardized outcome assessment tools. Patient reported outcome measures (PROMs) are used almost twice as frequently in the literature as they are by surgeons in their clinical practice.

Conclusion

We recommend that future studies of caudal septoplasty include an assessment of both form and function using a validated PROM such as the Standardized Cosmesis and Health Nasal Outcomes Survey.

A new "J septoplasty" technique for correction of mild caudal septal deviation

OBJECTIVE

A major drawback of the Killian incision is its inability to access the caudal septum and correct caudal septal deviation. Open and hemitransfixion septorhinoplasty are considered necessary in such cases. We developed a new septoplasty method that can be successfully applied in patients with mild caudal septal deviation. In this study, we evaluated the outcome of this technique.

METHODS

We prospectively collected data of 16 patients with mild caudal septal deviation who underwent endoscopic septoplasty between November 2015 and October 2017. A modified Killian incision was made on the concave side of the septum. The central part of the cartilage was preserved, and excess cartilage was resected; the central part of the cartilage was sutured to the caudal cartilage.

RESULTS

Postoperatively, the ratio of the area of the convex side to that of the concave side in the anterior portion of the nasal cavity was significantly improved, as revealed on CT analysis (p < 0.001). Nasal obstruction was significantly reduced or eliminated in all patients (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

The J septoplasty method for the correction of mild caudal septal deviation is easy to perform through a modified Killian incision, and seems to be useful in selected cases.

Transcutaneous Columellar Strut for Correcting Caudal Nasal Septal Deviation

Correction of caudal septal deviation is a challenging issue because of its significant role in tip support mechanisms. Some interventions especially aggressive resection of caudal septum to correct deviation, may compromise external nasal valve, tip ptosis and persistence of nasal obstruction. Many surgical techniques have been suggested to correct this type of nasal septal deviation. This study presents a technique to correct caudal septal deviation without weakening of tip support mechanisms. To evaluate the efficacy of insertion of a transcutaneous columellar strut during correction of caudal septal deviation. The study was performed in patients complaining from nasal obstruction with caudal septal deviation. After intranasal incision and elevation of mucoperichondrial flap, Caudal septum released from anterior nasal spine (ANS) and a band of cartilage removed from inferior and caudal part of septum and septum again fixed to ANS. Through a vertical transcutaneous incision, a cartilaginous strut is placed in columella, between medial crurae. Preoperative and postoperative NOSE score determined and photographs were taken. In 14 patients we performed this technique, the postoperative NOSE score showed significant improvement, (p = 0.001). Nasal breathing improved in all patients without any complication or tip ptosis or worsening of nasal appearance. This septoplasty technique along with placement of transcolumellar strut, is an easy, efficient and complication free method for simultaneously correction of caudal deviation of nasal septum, reinforcing external nasal valve and prevents tip ptosis.