A critical review of the pharmacological treatment of REM sleep behavior disorder in adults: time for more and larger randomized placebo-controlled trials

Rapid Eye Movement sleep behavior disorder (RBD) is a parasomnia causing sufferers to physically act out their dreams. These behaviors can disrupt sleep and sometimes lead to injuries in patients and their bed-partners. Clonazepam and melatonin are the first-line pharmacological treatment options for RBD based on direct uncontrolled clinical observations and very limited double-blind placebo-controlled trials. Given the risk for adverse outcomes, especially in older adults, it is of great importance to assess the existing level of evidence for the use of these treatments. In this update, we therefore critically review the clinical and scientific evidence on the pharmacological management of RBD in people aged over 50. We focus on the first-line treatments, and provide an overview of all other alternative pharmacological agents trialed for RBD we could locate as supplementary materials. By amalgamating all clinical observations, our update shows that 66.7% of 1,026 RBD patients reported improvements from clonazepam and 32.9% of 137 RBD patients reported improvements from melatonin treatment on various outcome measures in published accounts. Recently, however, three relatively small randomized placebo-controlled trials did not find these agents to be superior to placebo. Given clonazepam and melatonin are clinically assumed to majorly modify or eliminate RBD in nearly all patients-there is an urgent need to test whether this magnitude of treatment effect remains intact in larger placebo-controlled trials.

Advances of Melatonin-Based Therapies in the Treatment of Disturbed Sleep and Mood

Melatonin and melatonin agonists offer novel treatments for sleep and mood disorders, particularly where circadian misalignment is also present. The therapies offer both phase-shifting and sleep-promoting effects and have shown potential to treat advanced and delayed sleep-wake phase disorder, non-24-h sleep-wake cycle, jetlag, shift work disorder, insomnia, seasonal affective disorder and major depressive disorder.

Withdrawing Benzodiazepines in Patients With Anxiety Disorders

The large class of CNS-depressant medications-the benzodiazepines-have been extensively used for over 50 years, anxiety disorders being one of the main indications. A substantial proportion (perhaps up to 20-30 %) of long-term users becomes physically dependent on them. Problems with their use became manifest, and dependence, withdrawal difficulties and abuse were documented by the 1980s. Many such users experience physical and psychological withdrawal symptoms on attempted cessation and may develop clinically troublesome syndromes even during slow tapering. Few studies have been conducted to establish the optimal withdrawal schedules. The usual management comprises slow withdrawal over weeks or months together with psychotherapy of various modalities. Pharmacological aids include antidepressants such as the SSRIs especially if depressive symptoms supervene. Other pharmacological agents such as the benzodiazepine antagonist, flumazenil, and the hormonal agent, melatonin, remain largely experimental. The purpose of this review is to analyse the evidence for the efficacy of the usual withdrawal regimes and the newer agents. It is concluded that little evidence exists outside the usual principles of drug withdrawal but there are some promising leads.

Therapeutic potential of melatonin agonists

Melatonin, a hormone secreted by the pineal gland, has been successfully employed to improve sleep in both normal patients and insomniacs, and for the treatment of circadian rhythm sleep disorders. Melatonergic MT₁ and MT₂ receptors exist in high concentrations in the suprachiasmatic nucleus of the hypothalamus and have been shown to be instrumental for the sleep-promoting and circadian rhythm-regulating effects of melatonin. A lack of consistency among reports on the therapeutic efficacy of melatonin has been attributed to differences in melatonin's bioavailability and the short half-life of the hormone. In view of the need for longer acting melatonergic agonists that improve sleep efficiency without causing drug abuse or dependency, ramelteon (Rozerem™, Takeda) was developed. Ramelteon, which acts via MT₁/MT₂ melatonergic agonism, has been found clinically effective for improving total sleep time and sleep efficiency in insomniacs. Agomelatine (Valdoxan™, Servier) is another MT₁/MT₂ melatonergic agonist that also displays antagonist activity at 5-HT_2C serotonin receptors. Agomelatine has been found effective in treating depression and sleep disorders in patients with major depressive disorder. A slow-release preparation of melatonin (Circadin™, Neurim) has been shown to be effective in treating sleep disorders in the elderly population.