A systematic review of the benefits of occupation-based intervention for patients with upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review of intervention studies (level 3a).

INTRODUCTION

Occupation-based intervention (OBI) uses daily activities as a treatment modality. Its growing use with patients diagnosed with upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders (UE MSK) has driven interest in its supporting body of evidence.

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY

The purpose of this study was to locate, appraise, and summarize current evidence of the effectiveness of OBI in treating patients with UE MSK.

METHODS

Searches of PubMed, CINAHL, the Cochrane Register for Controlled Trials, and PEDro databases were conducted using predetermined keywords. Studies included in this systematic review described the use of OBI in UE MSK. Two examiners independently reviewed and assessed the quality of each study using the PEDro scale.

RESULTS

Results of the database searches yielded 991 studies, 13 of which were deemed eligible to include in this review (6 randomized controlled trials, 4 pretreatment/post-treatment cohort or case series studies, and 3 single case reports). Quality of the studies varied, with 4 rated poor, 2 moderate, and 4 excellent. Overall, individuals receiving OBI showed superior benefits in patient-reported, performance, and physical measures assessing the upper extremity.

DISCUSSION

Findings of this review provide preliminary evidence for the use of OBI with patients with UE MSK, however, generalizability of the evidence was compromised due to heterogeneity in study subjects as well as conceptualization, dosage, and delivery of OBI.

CONCLUSIONS

The existing literature reflects promising trends in the use of OBI, underscoring its utility as a treatment option for UE MSK-related impairment, limitations, and restrictions. Nonetheless, scientific evidence concerning the effectiveness of OBI needs to be improved by conducting high-quality studies that clearly conceptualize this intervention and heighten understanding of its role in hand therapy practice.

Incorporation of occupational based intervention into joint protection education for individuals with thumb carpometacarpal osteoarthritis: A case series

BACKGROUND

To our knowledge, the use of occupational performance in education on joint protection techniques has not been studied for individuals with thumb carpometacarpal (CMC) osteoarthritis.

PURPOSE

This case series was designed to investigate if occupation-based instruction inside the clinic was useful and found satisfactory as an educational tool for individuals with thumb CMC joint arthritis.

METHODS

Three participants with thumb CMC joint osteoarthritis performed washing, rinsing, and drying a dish, moving a pot and pan, maneuvering a laundry basket, and pouring from a pitcher during joint protection education in the therapy clinic with a skilled hand therapist in addition to routine treatment. Satisfaction with this intervention was assessed via a 3-question satisfaction survey. Pain with activity and function via the Thumb Disability Examination were assessed at baseline and a 4week follow up.

RESULTS

Patients in this study expressed satisfaction with the inclusion of the performance of occupations in their joint protection education in the clinic. Pain with activity improved by an average of 1.7/10 on a 10-point Numeric Pain Rating Scale and function improved by an average of 10.04 on the Thumb Disability Examination.

CONCLUSIONS

Although no causal relationships can be assumed in this study, hand therapists should consider adding occupation-based intervention as a component of patient education on joint protection for individuals with thumb CMC joint osteoarthritis.

The effectiveness of therapeutic craft-making activities in treating lower-third forearm fracture: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Occupational Therapists use craft-making activities as therapeutic interventions to improve physical and psychological functioning of injured people. Despite the therapeutic effects, craft-making is not routinely used in hand rehabilitation as an intervention for patients with upper limb fractures. These patients often experience physical and psychosocial issues; however, without supportive evidence, therapists hesitate to integrate craft-making into upper limb rehabilitation.

PURPOSE

This study aims to determine the effect of a conventional therapy combined with therapeutic craft-making on disability, post-traumatic stress, and physical performance in patients with lower-third forearm fractures.

METHODS

Priori analysis determined that 38 patients will be needed for this superiority randomized controlled trial to be conducted in a hand and upper limb rehabilitation center. Eligible participants must comprehend English, be diagnosed with lower-third forearm fracture(s) stabilized by open reduction internal fixation, and referred to therapy within 2-4 weeks of surgery. Following the CONSORT guidelines, participants will be randomly assigned to a Control (conventional therapy) group or an Intervention (conventional therapy and craft) group. Twice weekly for 6 weeks, Therapist A will provide both groups with 1-h of conventional therapy while the Intervention group will also receive 15 min of craft-making supervised by the Researcher. The primary outcome of disability will be measured with the Quick-Disabilities of Arm, Shoulder and Hand. The secondary outcome measurements include the Patient-Rated-Wrist-Evaluation; Impact of Event Scale-revised and physical performance, i.e., the Purdue Pegboard Test, AROM, and grip strength. All outcome measures will be obtained by Therapist B prior to the 1st therapy visit and after the 12th visit. Descriptive analysis will be done for the categorical and continuous data and a mixed model ANOVA for analysis of the initial and final assessment scores within and between groups.

RESULTS

This study is ongoing.

DISCUSSION

The intent of this study is to determine if therapeutic crafts have value as an intervention when used in combination with conventional therapy for patients with lower-third forearm fractures. If the value of crafts is supported, this evidence may reduce hesitancy of therapists to implement craft-making with patients referred to hand therapy after upper limb fracture.

CONCLUSION

This study is ongoing.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

ANZCTR, ACTRN12622000150741. Retrospectively registered on 28 January 2022 https://anzctr.org.au/Trial/Registration/TrialReview.aspx?id=382676&isReview=true ..

Development of decision-aid of goal-setting for patients with distal radius fracture: Aid for decision-making in occupation choice for distal radius fracture

BACKGROUND

Patients with distal radius fractures (DRFs) encounter significant difficulties and challenges in their daily lives due to their medical condition and a lack of strategies for modifying activities. Occupation-based interventions have emerged as promising strategies to improve occupational performance and participation outcomes, addressing these challenges.

PURPOSE

This study aims to develop the aid for decision-making in occupation choice for distal radius fracture (ADOC-DRF), a novel decision-aid tool designed to facilitate patient-centered and occupation-based goal-setting by offering illustrations tailored to the postsurgical recovery period and prescribed activity loads.

STUDY DESIGN

We utilized consensus development methods, including the nominal group technique and a web-based Delphi survey.

METHODS

Through the nominal group technique with three experts, we established the development concept, items, and illustrations for the ADOC-DRF prototype. Subsequently, a Delphi web survey was conducted to gather expert opinions using a five-point Likert scale (1 = disagree and 5 = agree) and achieve consensus among 22 experts, aiming for a consensus point of 3.75 (75%) or higher.

RESULTS

Three rounds of Delphi web surveys were conducted, involving a variety of items and comments, ultimately achieving the required consensus rate. This process identified 52 items, which were categorized into four distinct post-DRF progression phases: phase 1: immobilization, phase 2 early: immobilization removal (start of active motion), phase 2 late: immobilization removal (callus formation), and phase 3: resistance period (bone healing).

CONCLUSIONS

The ADOC-DRF shows promise as an innovative tool for facilitating occupation-based intervention in hand therapy for DRF patients. However, its generalizability is currently limited to Japan. To ensure broader applicability and utility, it is essential to validate the tool in diverse cultural contexts through international multicenter studies, thereby enhancing its global relevance.

Depression, anxiety and insomnia among isolated covid-19 patients: tele occupational therapy intervention vs. conventional one: a comparative study

BACKGROUND

COVID-19 is known to cause psychological problems. Psychological rehabilitation can be performed to reduce anxiety, depression, and insomnia. Facing patients with infectious diseases can be difficult for medical staff. Therefore, this study compared the effects of psychiatric tele-rehabilitation (TR) and conventional psychiatric rehabilitation (CR) in isolated patients with COVID-19.

METHODS

This randomized controlled study, conducted at a single community-based hospital, included 40 patients (24 in the psychiatric tele-rehabilitation group [TRG] and 16 in the conventional psychiatric rehabilitation group [CRG]) with COVID-19 were recruited from November 18, 2021, to April 7, 2022. Psychiatric rehabilitation is an occupation-based intervention in which patients perform meaningful activities and tasks. Patients in the TRG selected activities, received counseling, and underwent monitoring over the phone, while those in the CRG participated in face-to-face sessions. The interventions were conducted for 50 min each day during an isolation period of 7 days in both groups, and all participants received the interventions individually. The primary outcome was anxiety assessed using the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) and the Zung Self-Rating Anxiety Scale (SAS). Secondary outcomes include the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) and the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) to evaluate depression, the Multidimensional State Boredom Scale-8 (MSBS-8) to assess boredom. The Korean version of the Insomnia Severity Index (ISI-K) was used to assess the quality of sleep, and the World Health Organization Quality of Life Assessment Instrument-BRIEF (WHOQOL-BREF) was used to evaluate quality of life. Questionnaires were administered at admission, discharge, and at the 6-month follow-up.

RESULTS

In the time × group analysis, the SAS total score (p = .033) and the VAS score for depression (p = .012) in the CRG were significantly lower than those in the TRG at the time of discharge. The VAS score for anxiety (p = .007), total SAS score (p = .050), and VAS score for depression (p = .003) in the CRG were also significantly lower than those in the TRG at the 6-month follow-up. The PHQ-9, MSBS-8, ISI-K, and WHOQOL-BREF scores showed no significant interactions in the time × group analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

TR was effective in reducing anxiety and improving quality of life during hospitalization, but had no remained effects after discharge. Otherwise, CR was more effective than TR for anxiety and depression during hospitalization and had remained effects at 6-month follow-up. However, considering the characteristics of infectious conditions that involve risk in contact, TR will still play an important role, and efforts will be needed to improve the effect that remained.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

The trial was registered with the Korea Clinical Trials Registry (KCT0006714, Date of registration 08/11/2021).

Effects of occupational balance and client-centered occupational management in a patient with schizophrenia

BACKGROUND

Occupational balance is an essential element for social participation and quality of life. However, it is difficult for patients with schizophrenia to participate in occupation and achieve occupational balance in daily life due to physical and mental symptoms.

OBJECTIVE

This study investigated the form of time use and occupational balance in a schizophrenic patient, and examined the effect of client-centered occupation-based case management.

METHODS

The research was conducted at a private center visited using one-on-one weekly client interactions for 10 weeks from September 1, 2020, and time use was analyzed using the Occupational Questionnaire (OQ) and the 2019 Life Time Survey Table of the National Statistical Office. In addition, data on work performance and satisfaction were collected using Canadian Occupational Performance Measure (COPM), and client-centered occupation-based interventions were conducted.

RESULTS

As a result of identifying the balance of work of clients, 38.46% of rest and sleep during the day, 30.77% of IADL, 17.94% of Work, 10.26% of BADL, and 2.57% of leisure. Through occupation-based case management for child care and work, which are the main goals of the client, the COPM score increased on average by 2 or more points per item, showing a positive effect.

CONCLUSION

In order to resolve the occupation imbalance of schizophrenic patients, it is necessary to closely understand the type of time use and actively intervene in client-centered occupation-based interventions.

DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT

Data pertinent to this report will be made available upon reasonable request to the author.

Early Daily Activity: Development and description of an occupation-based intervention for surgically repaired distal radius Fractures

OBJECTIVE

To describe the theoretical development and structure of an occupation-based intervention for people with a surgically repaired distal radius fracture.

INTERVENTION DEVELOPMENT AND RATIONALE

The Early Daily Activity (EDA) intervention uses the performance of strategically selected daily activities as the primary rehabilitative strategy. Occupation-based interventions are recommended for hand injury rehabilitation but are often poorly described and lack explicit theoretical underpinnings. The EDA-intervention was developed from exploratory research that informed the theory and structure. The theoretical principles are that daily activity performance is (i) safe within defined parameters (ii) appropriately self-determined (iii) produces high ranges and amounts of therapeutic movement, and (iv) builds psychosocial competencies.

INTERVENTION DESCRIPTION

The EDA-intervention is designed to be commenced within 2 weeks of surgery. There are three key components. The first is activity-specific education to emphasise the safety, benefits, and therapeutic actions of activity performance. A set of parameters for defining safe activities is described to support education. The second component is patient-therapist collaboration to select a range of daily activities that provide a 'just-right' challenge. Collaboration occurs at regular intervals throughout the rehabilitation period to incrementally increase the challenge of activities. The third component is performance of activities at-home targeted at improving range of movement and function.

NEXT STEPS

The EDA-intervention can be used by hand therapists, but it has not yet undergone effectiveness evaluation. A planned study will explore clinician readiness to adopt the EDA-intervention, inform iterative changes to the protocol and the design of feasibility and effectiveness studies.