The effect of sex and estrus cycle stage on optogenetic spreading depression induced migraine-like pain phenotypes

BACKGROUND

Migraine is more prevalent in females, raising the possibility that sex and gonadal hormones modulate migraine. We recently demonstrated that minimally invasive optogenetic spreading depolarization (opto-SD) elicits robust periorbital allodynia. The objective of this study was to test the hypothesis that opto-SD induced migraine-like pain behavior is worse in females and varies during the estrus cycle.

METHODS

Single or repeated opto-SDs were induced in male and female adult Thy1-ChR2-YFP transgenic mice. Von Frey monofilaments were used to test periorbital mechanical allodynia. Mouse grimace was also examined under increasing light intensity to quantify spontaneous discomfort and light-aversive behavior. Vaginal smears were obtained for estrus cycle staging at the end of behavioral testing.

RESULTS

A multi-variable regression analysis was performed using a male and female cohort to test the effect of independent variables on periorbital allodynia. Opto-SD predicted lower periorbital thresholds as compared with sham stimulation (p < 0.0001). Additionally, female sex predicted lower periorbital thresholds compared with males (p = 0.011). There were significant interactions between opto-SD and time (interaction p = 0.030) as animals tended to recover from opto-SD allodynia over time, and between sex and time (p = 0.020) as females tended to take longer to recover. Proestrus, estrus (PE) and metestrus, diestrus (MD) stages were combined to represent high versus low circulating estradiol relative to progesterone, respectively. Multi-variable regression revealed an effect of estrus cycle (p = 0.015) on periorbital thresholds. In the sham group, PE had lower thresholds than MD. However, there was no interaction between opto-SD and the estrus cycle (p = 0.364). Grimace scores were also examined at incremental light intensities. There was an effect of opto-SD (p < 0.0001), light intensity (p = 0.001) and estrus cycle (p = 0.024) on grimace without interaction among them (three-way ANOVA).

CONCLUSIONS

Female sex and estrus stages with high circulating estradiol relative to progesterone lower trigeminal pain thresholds and augment photosensitivity. In females, opto-SD increased pain behavior and photosensitivity irrespective of the estrus stage.

The sensory innervation of the calvarial periosteum is nociceptive and contributes to headache-like behavior

Headaches are thought to result from the activation and sensitization of nociceptors that innervate deep cephalic tissues. A large body of evidence supports the view that some types of headaches originate intracranially, from activation of sensory neurons that innervate the cranial meninges. However, the notion of an extracranial origin of headaches continues to be entertained, although the identity of deep extracranial cephalic tissues that might contribute to headaches remains elusive. Here we employed anatomical, electrophysiological, and behavioral approaches in rats to test the hypothesis that the sensory innervation of the calvarial periosteum is nociceptive. Neural tracing indicated that the calvarial periosteum overlying the frontal and parietal bones is innervated primarily by small and medium-sized neurons in the trigeminal ganglion's ophthalmic division. In vivo single-unit recording in the trigeminal ganglion revealed that calvarial periosteal afferents have slowly conducting axons, are mechanosensitive, and respond to inflammatory mediators, consistent with a nociceptive function. Two distinct neuronal populations were distinguished based on their peripheral axonal trajectory: one that reached the periosteum through extracranial branches of the trigeminal nerve, and another that took an intracranial trajectory, innervating the cranial dura and apparently reaching the periosteum via the calvarial sutures. In behavioral studies, inflammatory stimulation of these afferents promoted periorbital tactile hypersensitivity, a sensory change linked to primary headaches. Activation and sensitization of calvarial periosteal afferents could play a role in mediating primary headaches of extracranial and perhaps also intracranial origin, as well as secondary headaches such as postcraniotomy and posttraumatic headaches. Targeting calvarial periosteal afferents may be effective in ameliorating these headaches.