Benefits and risks of protocol biopsies in pediatric renal transplantation

Protocol biopsies are defined as sampling of allograft tissue at predetermined times regardless of function. This procedure can be justified due to the lack of non-invasive methods to reliably diagnose rejection (acute or subclinical). Changes in creatinine are not seen with subclinical rejection or early acute rejection and do not always correlate with efficacy of treatment. Parents and providers are still hesitant to pursue protocol biopsy due to the potential complications and lack of definitive evidence of a benefit from doing this procedure. Importantly, the rate of transplant renal biopsy complications requiring additional intervention is low. It is unclear if detection and treatment of subclinical rejection detected on protocol biopsy will lead to improved graft survival. Our goal is to review the literature on this topic and share some of the experience in our center. Definition, indications, and complications of diagnostic transplant renal biopsies are not included in this review.

Post-transplant soluble CD30 levels are associated with early subclinical rejection in kidney transplantation

Several studies have shown association of high pre- or post-transplant levels of soluble CD30 (sCD30) with acute rejection and poor late kidney transplant outcome. Our goal was to investigate whether sCD30 levels at month-3 post-transplant are associated with subclinical rejection, presence of CD30(+) cells within the graft, and expression of immune response genes in peripheral blood mononuclear cells. The study comprised 118 adult first kidney graft recipients, transplanted at a single center, receiving tacrolimus in low concentration. All were submitted to a protocol biopsy at month-3. Subclinical rejection was identified in 10 biopsies and sCD30 levels ≥ 61.88 ng/mL (P = 0.004), younger recipient age (P = 0.030) and non-Caucasian ethnicity (P = 0.011) were independently associated with this outcome. Rare CD30(+) cells were present in only two biopsies. There was a correlation between sCD30 levels and CD30 gene expression in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (r = 0.385, P = 0.043). These results show that high sCD30 levels are independent predictors of graft dysfunction and may contribute to patient selection protocols by indicating those who could benefit from a more thorough evaluation.

Protocol biopsies in pediatric renal transplantation: a precious tool for clinical management

BACKGROUND

Kidney transplantation is the best treatment for children with end-stage kidney disease. Early results have improved, but late graft loss is still a major problem. Non-invasive, fully reliable early biomarkers of acute rejection are currently missing.

METHODS

Our aim was to evaluate the efficacy of protocol biopsies (PBXs) in a pediatric population. During 11 years, 209 renal transplantations were performed in 204 pediatric patients. Biopsies were performed 3-6 months, 1 year, and 5 years after transplantation. Procedure-related complications were systematically looked for by means of ultrasound scans.

RESULTS

Unexpected findings (mainly subclinical rejections) requiring therapeutic intervention were found in 19.3% biopsies performed at 3-6 months, in 18.4% in 12-month biopsies and in none of those performed after 5 years. The 13.6% patients at 12-month biopsies and 23.6% at 5-year biopsies showed calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) toxicity. Interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy (IF/TA) was found in 17.6 and 83.6% of patients at 12-month and 5-year biopsies, respectively. Complications of the PBX were infrequent. Five-year estimated glomerular filtration rate (GFR) was not significantly different in patients who received treatment for any cause and patients with normal histology.

CONCLUSIONS

Although we do not have a control group, we may speculate that patients who received treatment returned to a "standard" condition possibly improving final outcome. Protocol biopsies are a powerful diagnostic tool for the management of pediatric renal transplant recipients. In view of the lack of evidence that biopsies taken 5 years after transplantation lead to any therapeutic change, their use should be reconsidered.

Biomarkers and a tailored approach for immune monitoring in kidney transplantation

A literature review on immune monitoring in kidney transplantation produced dozens of research articles and a multitude of promising biomarkers, all in the quest for the much sought after - but perennially elusive - “holy grail” of kidney biomarkers able to unequivocally predict acute transplant rejection vs non-rejection. Detection methodologies and study designs were many and varied. Hence the motivation for this editorial, which espouses the notion that in today’s kidney transplantation milieu, the judicious use of disease classifiers tailored to specific patient immune risks may be more achievable and productive in the long run and confer a greater advantage for patient treatment than the pursuit of a single “omniscient” biomarker. In addition, we desire to direct attention toward greater scrutiny of biomarker publications and decisions to implement biomarkers in practice, standardization of methods in the development of biomarkers and consideration for adoption of “biomarker-driven” biopsies. We propose “biomarker-driven” biopsies as an adjunctive to and/or alternative to random surveillance (protocol) biopsies or belated indication biopsies. The discovery of a single kidney transplantation biomarker would represent a major breakthrough in kidney transplantation practice, but until that occurs - if ever it does occur, other approaches offer substantial potential for unlocking prognostic, diagnostic and therapeutic options. We conclude our editorial with suggestions and recommendations for productively incorporating current biomarkers into diagnostic algorithms and for testing future biomarkers of acute rejection in kidney transplantation.

Preceding T-Cell-Mediated Rejection Is Associated with the Development of Chronic Active Antibody-Mediated Rejection by de Novo Donor-Specific Antibody

AIM

Chronic active antibody-mediated rejection (CAABMR) is an important cause of late-stage renal allograft loss. Early inflammatory events such as acute rejection and infection after transplantation are considered to be the risk factors of de novo donor-specific antibody (dnDSA) production. In this study, we investigated the relationship between pre-disposing T-cell-mediated rejection and dnDSA-positive CAABMR.

METHODS

We recruited 365 patients who underwent ABO-compatible renal transplantation at our hospital. Among them, 16 patients diagnosed as having dnDSA-positive CAABMR were designated as a CAABMR group, and 38 randomly selected patients were designated as a control group. All biopsies from 1 month after transplantation were included in the study. The presence or absence of borderline changes (BLCs), acute T-cell-mediated rejection (ATMR), microvascular inflammation (MVI), and C4d positive on peritubular capillaries (C4d-P) was examined.

RESULTS

In the CAABMR group, BLC/ATMR was found in 12 cases (75%), and the mean duration until appearance of BLC/ATMR was 282.7 ± 328.7 days. C4d-P was found in 11 cases (68.8%), and the mean duration until its appearance was 1,432 ± 1,307 days. MVI was found in all cases, and the mean duration until its appearance was 1,333 ± 1,126 days. The mean duration until diagnosis of CAABMR was 2,268 ± 1,191 days. In the control group, BLC/ATMR was found in 13 cases (34.2%), and the mean duration until the appearance of BLC/ATMR was 173.1 ± 170.4 days. C4d-P was found in 2 cases (5.3%), and the durations until its appearance were 748 and 1,881 days. No cases of MVI were found in the control group. The frequency of BLC/ATMR was significantly higher in the CAABMR group (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Preceding BLC/ATMR is associated with the development of CAABMR with dnDSA.

Progress in Pathological Diagnosis after Kidney Transplantation: Current Trend and Future Perspective

Advances in immunosuppressive therapy; posttransplant management of allograft rejection; and measures against infectious diseases, cardiovascular diseases, and malignancy dramatically improved graft and patient survival after kidney transplantation (KT). Among them, kidney allograft biopsy is an important tool and the gold standard for the diagnosis of various kidney allograft injuries, including allograft rejection, virus-induced nephropathy, calcineurin inhibitor toxicity, and posttransplant glomerular diseases. The Banff Conference on Allograft Pathology has contributed to establishing the diagnostic criteria for kidney allograft rejection and polyomavirus-associated nephropathy that are used as a common standard worldwide. In addition to the for-cause biopsy, many transplant centers perform protocol biopsies in the early and late posttransplant periods to detect and treat allograft injury earlier. Preimplantation biopsy in deceased-donor KT has also been performed, especially in the marginal donor, and attempts have been made to predict the prognosis in combination with clinical information and the renal resistance of hypothermic machine perfusion. Regarding the preimplantation biopsy from a living kidney donor, it can provide useful information on aging and/or early changes in lifestyle diseases, such as glomerulosclerosis, tubulointerstitial changes, and arterial and arteriolar sclerosis, and be used as a reference for the subsequent management of living donors. In this review, morphologic features of important kidney allograft pathology, such as allograft rejection and polyomavirus-associated nephropathy, according to the latest Banff classification and additional information derived from protocol biopsy, and future perspectives with recently developed technologies are discussed.

Clinicopathological Analysis of Medullary Ray Injury in 1-Year Protocol Paediatric Renal Allograft Biopsies

AIM

Medullary ray injury was recently reported in renal transplant biopsies. This study was performed to clarify the clinicopathological features of medullary ray injury in paediatric living renal transplant recipients.

METHODS

Paediatric recipients who completed a 5-year follow-up after living renal transplantation were enroled. We evaluated the clinical and pathological parameters of the presence or absence of medullary ray injury in their 1-year protocol biopsies.

RESULTS

Of 48 1-year protocol biopsies, 18 (37.5%) showed histological evidence of medullary ray injury. The 48 paediatric recipients were classified as those with medullary ray injury (n = 18; MRI-1Y [+] group) and those without medullary ray injury (n = 30; MRI-1Y [-] group) in the 1-year protocol biopsies. The prevalence of histological evidence of calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) nephrotoxicity, chronic obstruction or reflux nephropathy, and imaging findings of vesicoureteral reflux was 66.7, 22.2, and 7.7% in the MRI-1Y (+) group and 33.3, 13.3, and 15.4% in the MRI-1Y (-) group, respectively. Only the prevalence of CNI nephrotoxicity was significantly different between the 2 groups. There was no significant difference in the mean estimated glomerular filtration rate at 1, 3, or 5 years after transplantation between the 2 groups.

CONCLUSION

In total, 37.5% of 1-year protocol biopsies showed histological evidence of medullary ray injury. This finding suggests that CNI nephrotoxicity might be the main contributor to medullary ray injury in 1-year protocol biopsies. The presence of medullary ray injury had little influence on renal function, at least during the first 5 years after transplantation.

The Spectrum of Histopathological Changes in the Renal Allograft - a 12 Months Protocol Biopsy Study

INTRODUCTION

Renal transplantation became a routine and successful medical treatment for Chronic Kidney Disease in the last 30 years all over the world. Introduction of Luminex based Single Antigen Beads (SAB) and recent BANFF consensus of histopathological phenotypes of different forms of rejection enables more precise diagnosis and changes the therapeutic approach. The graft biopsies, protocol or cause, indicated, remain a golden diagnostic tool for clinical follow up of kidney transplant recipients (KTR).

AIM

The study aimed to analyse the histopathological changes in renal grafts 12 months after the surgery in KTR with satisfactory kidney function.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A 12-month protocol biopsy study was performed in a cohort of 50 Kidney transplant recipients (42 from living and 8 from deceased donors). Usual work-up for suitable donors and recipients, standard surgical procedure, basic principles of peri and postoperative care and follow up were done in all KTR. Sequential quadruple immunosuppression including induction with Anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG) or Interleukin-2R antagonist (IL-2R), and triple drug maintenance therapy with Calcineurin Inhibitors (CNI), Mycophenolate Mofetil (MMF) and Steroids were prescribed to all pts. Different forms of Glomerulonephritis (16), Hypertension (10), End Stage Renal Disease (13), Hereditary Nephropathies (6), Diabetes (3) and Vesicoureteral Reflux (2) were the underlying diseases. All biopsies were performed under ultrasound guidance. The 16 gauge needles with automated "gun" were used to take 2 cores of tissue. The samples were stained with HE, PAS, Trichrome Masson and Silver and reviewed by the same pathologist. A revised and uploaded BANFF 2013 classification in 6 categories (Cat) was used.

RESULTS

Out of 48 biopsies, 15 (31%) were considered as normal, 4 (8%), Borderline (BL-Cat 3), 5 (10%) as Interstitial Fibrosis/Tubular Atrophy (IF/TA-Cat 5), 5 (10%) were classified as non-immunological (Cat 6), 2 as a pure antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR-Cat 2) and T-cell Mediated Rejection (TCMR-Cat 4). The remaining 17 samples were classified as a "mixed" rejection: 7 (41%) ABMR + IF/TA, 5 (29%) ABMR + BL + IF/TA, 2 (11%) BL + IF/TA, 1 (5%) ABMR + BL, 1 (5%) ABMR + TCMR and 1 (5%) TCMR + IF/TA. The mean serum creatinine at the time of the biopsy was 126.7 ± 23.4 µmol/L, while GFR-MDRD 63.4 ± 20.7 ml/min, which means that the majority of the findings were subclinical. Among the non-immunological histological findings (Cat 6), 3 cases belonged to CNI toxicity, 1 to BK nephropathy and 1 to recurrence of the primary disease.

CONCLUSION

Our 12-month protocol biopsy study revealed the presence of different forms of mixed subclinical rejection. Use of recent BANFF classification and scoring system enables more precise diagnosis and subsequently different approach to the further treatment of the KTR. More correlative long-term studies including Anti HLA antibodies and Endothelial Cell Activation- Associated Transcripts (ENDAT) are needed.

The role of hyperleptinaemia and low values of interleukin 10 in de novo DSA production after kidney transplantation

BACKGROUND

White adipose tissue secretes a number of peptide hormones. The aim of this paper was to determine the role of leptin, adiponectin and interleukin-10 and interleukin-6 on the development of graft rejection in protocol biopsy after kidney transplantation.

METHODS

In a prospective analysis (n = 104), we monitored the values of leptin, adiponectin, IL-6, and IL-10 prior to the transplantation and in the 3rd month after the transplantation. The protocol biopsy of the graft was performed in the 3rd month after the transplantation. The group was divided into the following according to the biopsy result: negative result, IFTA 1, borderline, and DSA positive.

RESULTS

After adjusting for the differences in the baseline recipient and donor characteristics, we identified the hyperleptinaemia baseline (HR = 2.0444, P = 0.0341) and month 3 (HR = 49.8043, P < 0.0001) as independent risk factors for borderline changes in the protocol biopsy. The hyperleptinaemia baseline (HR = 7.4979, P = 0.0071) and month 3 (HR = 9.7432, P = 0.0057) are independent risk factors for de novo DSA positivity. A low value of IL-10 month 3 is a risk factor for de novo DSA positivity (HR = 3.0746, P = 0.0388).

CONCLUSIONS

Higher leptin levels and low values of IL-10 might play a role in rejection and de novo DSA production.

Vesicoureteral Reflux Causes Interstitial Inflammation in Pediatric Kidney Allograft: A Clinicopathological Analysis of 1-Year Protocol Biopsies

INTRODUCTION

At present, there is limited evidence of the histological impact of vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) on pediatric kidney allografts. In this study, we aimed to investigate the relationship between VUR diagnosed by voiding cystourethrography (VCUG) and 1-year protocol biopsy results.

METHODS

One hundred thirty-eight pediatric kidney transplantations were performed in Toho University Omori Medical Center between 2009 and 2019. We included 87 pediatric transplant recipients who were evaluated for VUR by VCUG prior to or at the time of the 1-year protocol biopsy and underwent a 1-year protocol biopsy after transplantation. We evaluated the clinicopathological findings of the VUR and non-VUR groups, and histological scores were evaluated using the Banff score. Tamm-Horsfall protein (THP) within the interstitium was identified by light microscopy.

RESULTS

Of the 87 transplant recipients, 18 cases (20.7%) were diagnosed with VUR by VCUG. The clinical background and findings were not significantly different between the VUR and non-VUR groups. The pathological findings revealed a significantly higher Banff total interstitial inflammation (ti) score in the VUR group than in the non-VUR group. Multivariate analysis indicated a significant relationship between the Banff ti score and THP within the interstitium, and VUR. The 3-year protocol biopsy results (n = 68) revealed a significantly higher Banff interstitial fibrosis (ci) score in the VUR group than in the non-VUR group.

CONCLUSION

VUR caused interstitial fibrosis in the 1-year pediatric protocol biopsies, and interstitial inflammation at the 1-year protocol biopsy may affect interstitial fibrosis at the 3-year protocol biopsy.

Follow-up biopsies with microvascular inflammation and persistent donor specific antibodies identify ongoing rejection in pediatric kidney transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Inadequate treatment of acute rejection (AR) in pediatric kidney transplant recipients (KTR) can contribute to early allograft failure. Serum creatinine is an insensitive marker of allograft function, especially in the pediatric population, and may not detect ongoing rejection after treatment. We evaluated the utility of follow-up biopsies to detect persistent inflammation and future episodes of rejection.

METHODS

We performed a single-center retrospective review to identify pediatric KTR with biopsy-proven rejection and a subsequent follow-up biopsy, noting type of AR, Banff scores, serum creatinine, and presence of donor specific antibodies (DSA). Outcomes included resolution of AR, change in eGFR, DSA, persistent microvascular inflammation (MVI) and future episodes of AR.

RESULTS

Twelve cases of cellular (TCMR), 9 antibody-mediated (AMR), and 8 mixed cases of AR were identified among 23 KTR. Resolution was noted in 75% with TCMR, significantly higher than AMR (22%) or mixed rejection (13%), p < 0.01. Those without resolution of AR on follow-up biopsy were more likely to have ongoing episodes of AR or graft loss (p = 0.02). Persistence of DSA and MVI was associated with lack of AR resolution (p = 0.01 and p = 0.001, respectively). Those with persistent MVI on follow-up biopsy had higher probability of future AR events or graft loss, p = 0.003.

CONCLUSION

Follow-up biopsies to assess response to AR treatment revealed that most cases of TCMR were successfully treated but that AMR and mixed rejection portend a component of chronicity and more complicated course. Identification of persistent subclinical inflammation predicts future rejection episodes, has adverse effects on graft longevity, and can inform the need for additional treatment. We advocate for implementation of a follow-up biopsy protocol and future study of non-invasive biomarkers paired with protocol biopsies.