Interspecific Competition Study Between Pseudochattonella farcimen and P. verruculosa (Dictyochophyceae)-Two Ichthyotoxic Species that Co-occur in Scandinavian Waters

The genus Pseudochattonella has become a frequent component of late winter-early spring phytoplankton community in Scandinavian waters, causing extensive fish kills and substantial economic losses. One of currently two recognised species, P. farcimen, is often abundant prior to the diatom spring bloom. Recent field studies have revealed that P. farcimen and P. verruculosa have a period of overlap in their temperature ranges and thus their seasonal occurrences. Using laboratory cultures, we investigated the seasonal succession and growth of P. farcimen and P. verruculosa in both mono- and mixed-culture using the recently developed Pseudochattonella 'qPCR subtraction method', which for the first time allowed the simultaneous enumeration of these morphologically indistinguishable species in mixed assemblages. We examined how these species interacted over four different temperatures (5, 8, 11 and 15 °C). The observed growth rates and cell yields varied with temperature revealing their preferred temperature optima. P. farcimen was able to achieve positive net growth over all temperatures, while P. verruculosa failed to grow below 11 °C. Growth responses were statistically different between mono- and mixed-cultures with the outcome of these interactions being temperature-dependent. Nutrients (nitrate and phosphate) and pH levels were also measured throughout the growth experiments to better understand how these factors influenced growth of both species. P. verruculosa was shown to be less sensitive to high pH as growth ceased at pH 9.1, whereas P. farcimen stopped growing at pH 8.4. Understanding the influence of abiotic factors (e.g. temperature, pH and competition) on growth rates allows for a better understanding and prediction of phytoplankton community dynamics.

The ichthyotoxic genus Pseudochattonella (Dictyochophyceae): Distribution, toxicity, enumeration, ecological impact, succession and life history - A review

The marine genus Pseudochattonella is a recent addition to the list of fish killing microalgae. Currently two species are recognised (viz. P. verruculosa and P. farcimen) which both form recurrent coastal blooms sometimes overlapping in space and time. These events and their ecological and economic consequences have resulted in great interest and concern from marine biologists and the aquaculture industry. Since the first recorded blooms in Japanese (late 1980s), Scandinavian (1993) and Chilean (2004) waters numerous studies have focused on understanding the causative means of the fish killing. Mortality is probably due to Pseudochattonella discharging mucocysts that cause gill irritation and damage to the fish fills. Here, a review is provided of the literature on Pseudochattonella that covers the last ca. 25 years and focus on a number of topics relevant to understanding the general biology of the genus including ways to distinguish the two species. The literature addressing biogeography and known harmful events is evaluated and based on these findings an updated distribution map is proposed. P. farcimen is presently restricted to North European waters. Despite being very difficult to delineate based on morphology alone the two Pseudochattonella species seem to have separate growth optima. In laboratory experiments P. verruculosa consistently has higher temperature growth optima compared to P. farcimen though periods of overlap have been noted in the field. The review ends by proposing five areas with knowledge gaps and each of these could form the basis of future studies.

A quantitative real-time PCR assay for identification and enumeration of the occasionally co-occurring ichthyotoxic Pseudochattonella farcimen and P. verruculosa (Dictyochophyceae) and analysis of variation in gene copy numbers during the growth phase of single and mixed cultures

The ichthyotoxic genus Pseudochattonella forms recurrent extensive blooms in coastal waters in Japan, New Zealand and Northern Europe. It comprises of two morphologically similar species, P. verruculosa and P. farcimen, which complicates visual species identification and enumeration of live and fixed material. Primers designed previously could not quantitatively distinguish species in mixed assemblages. To address this issue we developed two primer sets: one revealed itself to be genus specific for Pseudochattonella and the other species-specific for P. verruculosa. By subtracting cell estimates for P. verruculosa from combined results we could calculate cell numbers for P. farcimen. This approach has overcome the challenges posed by the very limited sequence availability and low gene variability between the two species. The qPCR assay was extensively tested for specificity, efficiency and sensitivity over an entire growth cycle in both single and mixed assemblages. Comparison of cell abundance estimates obtained by qPCR assay and microscopy showed no statistically significant difference until stationary and death phases. The assay was also tested on environmental samples collected during a small Pseudochattonella bloom in Denmark in March-April 2015. It was impossible to distinguish P. farcimen and P. verruculosa by light microscopy but qPCR showed both species were present. The two methods provided nearly identical cell numbers but the assay provided discrimination and enumeration of both species.