Water quality in a shallow eutrophic lake is unaffected by extensive thinning of planktivorous and benthivorous fish species

Ambitious to fulfill the European Water Framework Directive obligations, the European governments support projects to rehabilitate lakes with poor water quality. However, most lake restorations having relied on biomanipulation by fish thinning have failed to improve or even maintain water quality. Previous attempts removed all target fish species simultaneously, thus making it impossible to assess the specific impact of each feeding group on water chemistry. Lake Bromme was selected for extensive, time-selective fish biomanipulation to improve water clarity and promote submerged macrophytes and piscivorous fish stocks over a three-year monitoring period. Thinning of adult benthivorous bream (Abramis brama) and tench (Tinca tinca) was conducted throughout year one while thinning in years two and three targeted planktivorous roach (Rutilus rutilus), juvenile bream, and small perch (Perca fluviatilis). Yearly fish surveys assessed changes in fish population structure and biomass. Water quality parameters were monitored continually, and the cover of submerged macrophytes was surveyed annually via sonar. We found no improvement in water clarity or reductions of nutrients, organic particles, chlorophyll concentrations, or watercolor, despite a 6-fold thinning of total estimated fish biomass, from 112 to 19 kg ha-1. Over the period, the macrophyte cover increased from 0.8 to 13.5 %, but no recruitment of large piscivorous fish (perch and pike (Esox lucius) > 10 cm) was detected. We found higher correlations of particle concentration and water clarity to water temperature than to wind speed, which indicates sediment particle resuspension by the remaining fish community (mostly carp Cyprinus carpio) that forage on benthos in shallow lakes. Further system-ecological research in Lake Bromme should evaluate whether thinning the stock of carp and increasing plant cover may improve water quality and test which optical properties sustain high water turbidity and prevent shallow, eutrophic lakes like Lake Bromme from responding to intense fish thinning.

Assessing the suitability of lakes and reservoirs for recreation using Landsat 8

Water clarity has long been used as a visual indicator of the condition of water quality. The clarity of waters is generally valued for esthetic and recreational purposes. Water clarity is often assessed using a Secchi disk attached to a measured line and lowered to a depth where it can be no longer seen. We have applied an approach which uses atmospherically corrected Landsat 8 data to estimate the water clarity in freshwater bodies by using the quasi-analytical algorithm (QAA) and Contrast Theory to predict Secchi depths for more than 270 lakes and reservoirs across the continental US. We found that incorporating Landsat 8 spectral data into methodologies created to retrieve the inherent optical properties (IOP) of coastal waters was effective at predicting in situ measures of the clarity of inland water bodies. The predicted Secchi depths were used to evaluate the recreational suitability for swimming and recreation using an assessment framework developed from public perception of water clarity. Results showed approximately 54% of the water bodies in our dataset were classified as "marginally suitable to suitable" with approximately 31% classed as "eminently suitable" and approximately 15% classed as "totally unsuitable-unsuitable". The implications are that satellites engineered for terrestrial applications can be successfully used with traditional ocean color algorithms and methods to measure the water quality of freshwater environments. Furthermore, operational land-based satellite sensors have the temporal repeat cycles, spectral resolution, wavebands, and signal-to-noise ratios to be repurposed to monitor water quality for public use and trophic status of complex inland waters.

A remotely controlled automated field measurement system for light extinction in coastal waters

The Secchi disk depth (SD) is an important parameter in aquatic ecosystem monitoring. As algal growth depends on solar irradiation, the SD - a measure of light extinction - gives an indirect indication of the chlorophyll concentration. However, most SD measurements are manually based and too sparse to resolve water quality variations during algal blooms. A remotely controlled automatic system for field measurement of light extinction has been developed and installed in three marine fish culture zones in Hong Kong. The visual images of the disk at different prescribed depths and the surrounding water are taken. Based on the contrast theory and image analysis, the recorded light intensity distributions can be analyzed to give the SD and the light extinction coefficient. The method has been extensively verified by field data over a wide range of water quality and hydro-meteorological conditions. The proposed system enables high frequency SD measurements on demand for environmental management and emergency response.

The Use of Green Laser in LiDAR Bathymetry: State of the Art and Recent Advancements

Bathymetric LiDAR technology is a technology used for simultaneous data acquisition regarding the morphology of the bottom of water reservoirs and the surrounding coastal zone, realized from the air, e.g., by plane or drone. Contrary to the air topographic LiDAR, which uses an infrared wavelength of 1064 nm, bathymetric LiDAR systems additionally use a green wavelength of 532 nm. The green laser can penetrate the water, which makes it possible to measure the depth of shallow water reservoirs, rivers, and coastal sea waters within three Secchi depths. This article presents the theoretical basis for the construction of a green laser. Against the background of other methods of measuring the bottom of water reservoirs, the technology using waves from the visible light range is presented in detail in the assessment of the bottom morphology of shallow water reservoirs. The possibilities of using green laser in lidar bathymetry implemented in particular in non-navigable regions are shown. The results of the researchers' work on river processes (erosion, sedimentation), design of stream restoration, determination of morphometric parameters of the riverbed, as well as assessment of the topography of the marine coastal bottom zones are summarized. The development direction of lidar bathymetry is discussed.

Inferring causal impacts of extreme water-level drawdowns on lake water clarity using long-term monitoring data

Although long-term ecosystem monitoring provides essential knowledge for practicing ecosystem management, analyses of the causal effects of ecological impacts from large-scale observational data are still in an early stage of development. We used causal impact analysis (CIA)-a synthetic control method that enables estimation of causal impacts from unrepeated, long-term observational data-to evaluate the causal impacts of extreme water-level drawdowns during summer on subsequent water quality. We used more than 100 years of transparency and water level monitoring data from Lake Biwa, Japan. The results of the CIA showed that the most extreme drawdown in recorded history, which occurred in 1994, had a significant positive effect on transparency (a maximum increase of 1.75 m on average over the following year) in the north basin of the lake. The extreme drawdown in 1939 was also shown to be a trigger for an increase in transparency in the north basin, whereas that in 1984 had no significant effects on transparency. In the south basin, contrary to the pattern in the north basin, the extreme drawdown had a significant negative effect on transparency shortly after the extreme drawdown. These different impacts of the extreme drawdowns were considered to be affected by the timing and magnitude of the extreme drawdowns and the depths of the basins. Our approach of inferring the causal impacts of past events on ecosystems will be helpful in implementing water-level management for ecosystem management and improving water quality in lakes.

Assessing the current water clarity status of ~100,000 lakes across southern Canada: A remote sensing approach

Canada has more lakes than any other country, making comprehensive monitoring a huge challenge. As more and more satellite data become readily available, and as faster data processing systems make massive satellite data operations possible, new opportunities exist to use remote sensing to develop comprehensive assessments of water quality at very large spatial scales. In this study, we use a published empirical algorithm to estimate Secchi depth from Landsat 8 reflectance data in order to estimate water clarity in lakes across southern Canada. Combined with ancillary information on lake morphological, hydrological, and watershed geological and landuse characteristics, we were able to assess broad spatial patterns in water clarity for the first time. Ecological zones, underlying geological substrate, and lake depth had particularly strong influences on clarity across the whole country. Lakes in western mountain ecozones had significantly clearer waters than those in the prairies and plains, while lakes in sedimentary rock formations tended to have lower clarity than lakes in intrusive rock. Deep lakes were significantly clearer than shallow lakes over most of the country. Water clarity was also significantly influenced by human impact (urbanization, agriculture, and industry) in the watershed, with most lakes in high impact areas having low clarity or very low clarity. Finally, we used in situ measured data to help interpret the underlying optical water column constituents influencing clarity across Canada, and found that chlorophyll-a, total suspended solids, and color dissolved organic matter all had strong but varying underlying effects on water clarity across different ecozones. This research provides an important step towards further research on the relationship between water column optical properties and the health and vulnerability status of lakes across the country.

Effects of reduced shoreline erosion on Chesapeake Bay water clarity

Shoreline erosion supplies sediments to estuaries and coastal waters, influencing water clarity and primary production. Globally, shoreline erosion sediment inputs are changing with anthropogenic alteration of coastlines in populated regions. Chesapeake Bay, a prime example of such a system where shoreline erosion accounts for a large proportion of sediments entering the estuary, serves here as a case study for investigating the effects of changing sediment inputs on water clarity. Long-term increases in shoreline armoring have contributed to decreased erosional sediment inputs to the estuary, changing the composition of suspended particles in surface waters. This study examined the impact of shoreline erosion on water clarity using a coupled hydrodynamic-biogeochemical model. Experiments were conducted to simulate realistic shoreline conditions representative of the early 2000s, increased shoreline erosion, and highly armored shorelines. Together, reduced shoreline erosion and the corresponding reduced rates of resuspension result in decreased concentrations of inorganic particles, improving water clarity particularly in the lower Bay and in dry years where and when riverine sediment influence is low. This clarity improvement relaxed light limitation, which increased organic matter production. Differences between the two extreme experiments revealed that in the mid-estuary in February to April, surface inorganic suspended sediment concentrations decreased 3-7 mg L^-1, while organic suspended solids increased 1-3 mg L^-1. The resulting increase in the organic-to-inorganic ratio often had opposite effects on clarity according to different metrics, improving clarity in mid-Bay central channel waters in terms of light attenuation depth, but simultaneously degrading clarity in terms of Secchi depth because the resulting increase in organic suspended solids decreased the water's transparency. This incongruous water clarity effect, the spatial extent of which is defined here as an Organic Fog Zone, was present in February to April in all years studied, but occurred farther south in wet years.

The status of brown macroalgae Fucus spp. and its relation to environmental variation in the Finnish marine area, northern Baltic Sea

A large-scale loss of the habitat-forming macroalgae Fucus vesiculosus was reported around the Baltic Sea in the 1980's, but only relatively local studies have reported its current status. We studied recent comprehensive mapping data in the Finnish marine area and compared reported Fucus occurrences in relation to its potential, to find out its current status on a larger scale. We also investigated the effects of water quality on Fucus occurrence and its depth penetration. Our results show that the status of Fucus is better in the Gulf of Bothnia than in the Gulf of Finland, both in terms of its occurrence rate and its depth distribution. Despite high potential in the outer Archipelago Sea, the status of Fucus is poor. The Fucus occurrence patterns are mainly related to salinity, exposure and Secchi depth, all positively affecting the Fucus occurrence rate and/or the lower limit of the Fucus zone.

A synoptic assessment of water quality in two Great Lakes connecting channels

We conducted a probabilistic water quality assessment of two Great Lakes connecting channels, the St. Marys River, and the Lake Huron-Lake Erie Corridor (HEC) in 2014-2015. We compared the condition of the channels to each other and to the up- and down-river Great Lakes with data from an assessment of the Great Lakes nearshore conducted in 2015. We assessed the condition of each channel as good, fair, or poor by applying the most protective water quality thresholds for the down-channel lake. Condition in the St. Marys River rated mostly fair for total phosphorus (TP) and mostly good for chlorophyll a, and area-weighted mean concentrations were intermediate to nearshore Lake Superior and Lake Huron. A large proportion of the area of the St. Marys River was in poor condition for water clarity based on Secchi depth; while nearshore Lakes Superior and Huron were mostly in good condition for water clarity. Area-weighted mean concentrations of TP and chlorophyll a in the HEC were more like nearshore Lake Huron than Lake Erie. For those indicators, most of the area of the HEC was rated good. The HEC appears more degraded when Lake Huron thresholds are applied rather than Lake Erie thresholds. Appropriate thresholds for the connecting channels should align with assessment objectives and be at least as protective as thresholds for the down-channel lake. Future iterations of this assessment will allow evaluation of water quality trends in the connecting channels.

Color, chlorophyll a, and suspended solids effects on Secchi depth in lakes: implications for trophic state assessment

Secchi depth (SD), a primary metric to assess trophic state, is controlled in many lakes by algal densities, measured as chlorophyll-a (chl-a) concentration. Two other optically related water quality variables also directly affect SD: non-algal suspended solids (SS_NA ) and colored dissolved organic matter (CDOM, expressed as the absorption coefficient at 440 nm, a₄₄₀ ). Using a database of ~1,460 samples from ~625 inland lake basins in Minnesota and two other Upper Midwest states, Wisconsin and Michigan, we analyzed relationships among these variables, with special focus on CDOM levels that influence SD values and the Minnesota SD standards used to assess eutrophication impairment of lakes. Log-transformed chl-a, total suspended solids (TSS), and SD were strongly correlated with each other; log(a₄₄₀ ) had major effects on log(SD) but was only weakly correlated with log(chl-a) and log(TSS). Multiple regression models for log(SD) and 1/SD based on the three driving variables (chl-a, SS_NA , and CDOM) explained ~80% of the variance in SD in the whole data set, but substantial differences in the form of the best-fit relationships were found between major ecoregions. High chl-a concentrations (> 50 μg/L) and TSS (> 20 mg/L) rarely occurred in lakes with high CDOM (a₄₄₀  > ~4 m^-1 ), and all lakes with a₄₄₀  > 8 m^-1 had SD ≤ 2.0 m despite low chl-a values (<10 μg/L) in most lakes. Further statistical analyses revealed that CDOM has significant effects on SD at a₄₄₀ values > ~ 4 m^-1 . Thus, SD is not an accurate trophic state metric in moderately to highly colored lakes, and Minnesota's 2-m SD criterion should not be the sole metric to assess eutrophication impairment in warm/cool-water lakes of the Northern Lakes and Forest ecoregion. More generally, trophic state assessments using SD in regions with large landscape sources of CDOM need to account for effects of CDOM on SD.

Geographic patterns of the climate sensitivity of lakes

Climate change is a well-recognized threat to lake ecosystems and, although there likely exists geographic variation in the sensitivity of lakes to climate, broad-scale, long-term studies are needed to understand this variation. Further, the potential mediating role of local to regional ecological context on these responses is not well documented. In this study, we examined relationships between climate and water clarity in 365 lakes from 1981 to 2010 in two distinct regions in the northeastern and midwestern United States. We asked (1) How do climate-water-clarity relationships vary across watersheds and between two geographic regions? and (2) Do certain characteristics make some lakes more climate sensitive than others? We found strong differences in climate-water-clarity relationships both within and across the two regions. For example, in the northeastern region, water clarity was often negatively correlated with summer precipitation (median correlation = -0.32, n = 160 lakes), but was not correlated with summer average maximum temperature (median correlation = 0.09, n = 205 lakes). In the midwestern region, water clarity was not related to summer precipitation (median correlation = -0.04), but was often negatively correlated with summer average maximum temperature (median correlation = -0.18). There were few strong relationships between local and sub-regional ecological context and a lake's sensitivity to climate. For example, ecological context variables explained just 16-18% of variation in summer precipitation sensitivity, which was most related to total phosphorus, chlorophyll a, lake depth, and hydrology in both regions. Sensitivity to summer maximum temperature was even less predictable in both regions, with 4% or less of variation explained using all ecological context variables. Overall, we identified differences in the climate sensitivity of lakes across regions and found that local and sub-regional ecological context weakly influences the sensitivity of lakes to climate. Our findings suggest that local to regional drivers may combine to influence the sensitivity of lake ecosystems to climate change, and that sensitivities among lakes are highly variable within and across regions. This variability suggests that lakes are sensitive to different aspects of climate change (temperature vs. precipitation) and that responses of lakes to climate are heterogeneous and complex.

Water clarity measures as indicators of recreational benefits provided by U.S. lakes: Swimming and aesthetics

Lakes provide recreational benefits related to water quality. Using data from the 2007 and 2012 United States National Lake Assessments (N=2067 lake visits), we developed indicators for three benefits: swimming, general recreational value, and aesthetic appeal. For two combined ecoregions ("Mountains" and "Plains") we related objective measures of water clarity, including Secchi depth, turbidity, and water-column chlorophyll-a concentration to subjective visual assessments of recreational benefit quality. There were significant associations between water clarity measures and visual assessments from which we derived water-clarity based thresholds between benefit quality classes (exceptional, high, low, marginal) for each benefit type. More variation in Secchi depth and turbidity was explained by benefit quality than was variation in chlorophyll-a. Threshold values were different between combined ecoregions. Compared to lakes in the Mountains ecoregion, recreational users of Plains lakes have lower expectations for water clarity. Thresholds were generally in accord with water clarity thresholds and guidance derived from published regional studies. Including indicators of the quality of benefits humans receive from lakes in assessments of lake conditions can increase public participation in decision-making and reveal changes in benefit quality over time.

Using generalized additive models to investigate factors influencing cyanobacterial abundance through phycocyanin fluorescence in East Lake, China

East Lake is a shallow lake (in Wuhan, China) where cyanobacteria blooms occurred frequently from 1970 to 1985. During the study period, all Carlson trophic state index values were > 50, indicating that East Lake is in a eutrophic state. In this study, phycocyanin concentrations were measured through phycocyanin fluorometry for rapid assessment of cyanobacterial abundance. The smoothing splines of the optimal generalized additive model (GAM) indicated that Secchi depth (SD), total phosphorus (TP) and dissolved oxygen (DO) concentrations, electrical conductivity (EC), chemical oxygen demand (COD), and ratios of total nitrogen (TN) to TP (TN:TP) were the main environmental factors in a moderate nonlinear relationship with cyanobacterial phycocyanin concentrations in East Lake. The shape of the GAM smoother can be used to quantify the relationship between a response variable and an explanatory variable in the scatterplot. Phycocyanin concentrations were sharply and negatively related to both SD and EC when the SD was 20-80 cm and EC was > 270 mg/L. Phycocyanin concentrations increased with concentrations of TP, DO, and COD. Phycocyanin concentrations increased sharply with TP concentrations when TP concentrations were > 0.10 mg/L and approached to a constant when DO concentrations were > 8.20 mg/L. Approximately, 85% of the phycocyanin concentrations were negatively correlated with TN:TP of < 26. In summary, organic compounds and TP were inferred to the key factors limiting the potential growth of cyanobacteria in East Lake. These change points/thresholds of smoothing splines of aforementioned variables may serve as a framework for managing the cyanobacterial growth.

Trophic state assessment of Bhindawas Lake, Haryana, India

Trophic state allows for identification of problems and pressures that an ecosystem faces as well as demarcation of remedial measures. This study focuses on spatial and temporal variations in the trophic state and detection of possible causes of its divergence in Bhindawas Lake, India. The trophic state of the lake undulated between eutrophic and hyper-eutrophic state throughout the study period. Higher phosphorus concentration within the lake ecosystem is the dominant causal factor for its eutrophic state. The influence of other water quality parameters has also been analyzed using Spearman's coefficient of correlation. Deviations between trophic state index (TSI)-chlorophyll-a (Chl-a), TSI-total phosphorus (TP), and TSI-Secchi depth (SD) pointed out that the lake is principally phosphorus limited, and its trophic status is influenced by non-algal turbidity to a large extent. Spatial analysis of trophic levels in geographic information system (GIS) helped in identification of pollution sources and chemical attributes affecting the trophic state of the lake. This study provides a rationale for further investigation of nutrient and sediment loading into the lake system and development of sustainable management and conservation strategy identifying suitable measures ascertaining the ecosystem integrity.

An optical method to assess water clarity in coastal waters

Accurate estimation of water clarity in coastal regions is highly desired by various activities such as search and recovery operations, dredging and water quality monitoring. This study intends to develop a practical method for estimating water clarity based on a larger in situ dataset, which includes Secchi depth (Z sd ), turbidity, chlorophyll and optical properties from several field campaigns in turbid coastal waters. The Secchi depth parameter is found to closely vary with the concentration of suspended sediments, vertical diffuse attenuation coefficient K d (m(-1)) and beam attenuation coefficient c (m(-1)). The optical relationships obtained for the selected wavelengths (i.e. 520, 530 and 540 nm) exhibit an inverse relationship between Secchi depth and the length attenuation coefficient (1/(c + K d )). The variation in Secchi depth is expressed in terms of undetermined coupling coefficient which is composed of light penetration factor (expressed by z(1%)K d (λ)) and a correction factor (ξ) (essentially governed by turbidity of the water column). This method of estimating water clarity was validated using independent in situ data from turbid coastal waters, and its results were compared with those obtained from the existing methods. The statistical analysis of the measured and the estimated Z sd showed that the present method yields lower error when compared to the existing methods. The spatial structures of the measured and predicted Z sd are also highly consistent with in situ data, which indicates the potential of the present method for estimating the water clarity in turbid coastal and associated lagoon waters.