Activation patterns of the dorsal medial prefrontal cortex and frontal pole predict individual differences in decision impulsivity

Intertemporal choice refers to decisions that need to weigh different rewards at different time points in the future. Decision impulsivity manifests in the tendency of choosing smaller immediate options rather than larger later ones. Previous studies have suggested that decision impulsivity in intertemporal decision-making shares similar cognitive and neural mechanisms with risky decision-making. The present study theorizes on and examines whether the activation patterns of the dorsal medial prefrontal cortex (DMPFC) and the frontal pole (FP) during the risk-taking "cups task", as captured in the scanner, can predict the delay discounting rate (k) based on an intertemporal decision task performed outside the scanner. To this end, we scanned with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) techniques a sample of 257 college students (N = 257) while performing the cups task. Univariate analyses showed that activation levels of the DMPFC and the FP were inversely correlated with risk preference, but not with the delay discounting rate k. Multivariate pattern analysis, which can overcome key limitations of the univariate analyses, showed that activation patterns of these two regions predict the delay discounting rate k. These results confirmed the important roles of DMPFC and FP in decision impulsivity and the utility of using multivariate pattern analysis with fMRI data involving decision making tasks.

Variable delay-to-signal: a fast paradigm for assessment of aspects of impulsivity in rats

Testing impulsive behavior in rodents is challenging and labor-intensive. We developed a new behavioral paradigm—the Variable Delay-to-Signal (VDS) test—that provides rapid and simultaneous assessment of response and decision impulsivity in rodents. Presentation of a light at variable delays signals the permission for action (nose poke) contingent with a reward. 2 blocks of 25 trials at 3 s delay flank a block of 70 trials in which light is presented with randomly selected 6 or 12 s delays. Exposure to such large delays boosts the rate of premature responses when the delay drops to 3 s in the final block, an effect that is blunted by an acute methamphetamine challenge and that correlates with the delay-discounting (DD) paradigm (choice impulsivity). Finally, as expected, treatment with the NMDA antagonist MK-801 caused a generalized response increase in all VDS blocks. The pharmacological validation, particularly with methamphetamine which has a well established dual effect on response and decision impulsivity, and the correlations between the impulsive behavior in the DD and VDS paradigms, suggests that the later is able to provide, in a single session, a multi-dimensional assessment of impulsive behavior.