A directional preference approach for chronic pelvic pain, bladder dysfunction and concurrent musculoskeletal symptoms: a case series

BACKGROUND

Chronic pelvic pain (CPP) with concurrent musculoskeletal and bladder symptoms is a complex and challenging problem. However, clinically the co-existence of these symptoms is not routinely questioned, and their musculoskeletal source is not investigated thoroughly. The purpose of this case series is to present the use of Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT) principles in seven patients with concurrent chronic pelvic pain, bladder dysfunction and musculoskeletal symptoms.

CASE DESCRIPTIONS

Seven patients with coexisting pelvic health and musculoskeletal signs and symptoms were retrospectively reviewed. Most common symptoms were urinary frequency, incontinence, pelvic pain, nocturia, dyspareunia, bladder dyssynergia, and lumbar, pelvic or hip pain. All patients failed to recognize the possible interconnectedness of the two sets of symptoms. Each exhibited a directional preference (DP) and subsequent MDT provisional classification of derangement was established; the use of DP forces abolished or dramatically improved both symptoms and mobility impairments. In all cases DP was for sustained sagittal forces initially, but ultimately lateral forces and mobilization were indicated.

OUTCOMES

Changes in Pelvic Floor Impact Questionnaire, Care Connections Pelvic Floor and Lumbar spine were all clinically significant and exceeded minimally Clinical Important Differences several times. Average of 5.8 sessions per patient was noted. Follow-up at an average of 3.3 years revealed ongoing satisfaction and confidence in independent self-management.

DISCUSSION

These case studies highlight the importance of ensuring expansion of intake questions for possible co-existence of symptoms in both pelvic and musculoskeletal patients, possibly suggesting a mechanical intervention is indicated. Provisional subclassification into 'Mechanical Pelvic Syndrome' is proposed. Level of Evidence: 4.

The use of Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT) in patients with lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS): case series

Lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) are highly prevalent among men over the age of 40. Even though associations between lumbar spine conditions and LUTS have been documented in the literature, no studies have detailed a specific lumbar assessment and classification process, and the related treatment effects in patients with LUTS. In this case series, we present three male patients with LUTS as primary complaints, who were evaluated and treated with Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT) for the lumbar spine. The duration of their symptoms was between 4 months and 7 years. Urogenital pathologies were ruled out for all patients. The Chronic Prostatitis Symptom Index was used as a functional outcome measure. All patients were classified as having lumbar derangements. Treatment of derangements with directional preference exercises resulted in the improvement of their LUTS, with clinically significant improvements (56.0%-77.4%) in functional outcome measures over an average of six sessions. Preliminary indications suggest that these LUTS cases may possibly have had a lumbar spine origin and "mechanical" nature. Therefore, they may be within the scope of MDT assessments and interventions. With careful monitoring of symptoms, MDT may serve as a screening tool and conservative treatment option.

Initial pain and disability characteristics can assist the prediction of the centralization phenomenon on initial assessment of patients with low back pain

OBJECTIVES

Determine whether the achievement of the centralization phenomenon on initial assessment of patients with low back pain (LBP) can be predicted by history and physical examination variables.

METHODS

Ninety patients referred to physical therapy due to LBP completed pain, disability, and fear-avoidance questionnaires, followed by a complete history and a physical examination based on mechanical diagnosis and therapy principles. Patients were subsequently classified as centralizers or noncentralizers. Univariate, followed by multivariate analysis was performed to identify history and physical examination variables that predicted the occurrence of the CP. Factors retained in the multivariate analysis were used to develop a clinical prediction rule (CPR).

RESULTS

Twenty-eight patients (31%) were classified as centralizers immediately following assessment. Three predictors were retained in the multivariate analysis: (1) modified Oswestry Disability Index score lower than 33%; (2) intensity of the most distal symptom lower than 6/10; and (3) back pain equal to or greater than leg pain. The resultant CPR indicated the presence of all three variables increased the post-test likelihood of the CP to 57%.

DISCUSSION

The findings of this study suggest the CP may be considerably more likely in less severe cases of LBP characterized by lower disability, lower intensity of distal symptoms, and a greater back-versus-leg pain intensity. Pending future validation, the CPR developed in this study may aide decision making regarding the initial management strategy of patients with LBP.

Mechanical diagnosis and therapy and Morton's neuroma: a case-series

Objectives: Morton's neuroma (MN) is a neuralgia involving the common plantar digital nerves of the metatarsal region. Evidence-based treatment options for MN are sparse, and utility of physical therapy (PT) is unknown. Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT) is a classification system utilizing direction-specific treatment for orthopedic conditions based on mechanical and symptomatic response to repeated end range movements. The purpose of this case series is to describe the management of three patients with a medical diagnosis of MN using the MDT classification system.Methods: Three female patients aged 54-75 years with unilateral plantar forefoot pain for 6 weeks to 8 years were referred by a podiatrist following positive clinically accepted diagnostic criteria for MN including radiological imaging and provocation testing. Patients were evaluated and treated utilizing MDT assessment and treatment principles. The intervention consisted of repeated movements matched to the patient's directional preference at either the lumbar spine (1 patient) or distal extremity (2 patients).Results: Immediate and one-year outcomes were excellent, demonstrating rapid and lasting improvement. Following discharge, the patients have been asymptomatic or able to self-manage without seeking additional medical intervention for this condition. Total visit frequency per patient averaged 2-3 visits total across 8-16 days.Discussion: Responses to repeated end range movements testing allowed for classification and prescription of exercise to rapidly improve symptoms and function in three patients referred to PT services with medically diagnosed MN. This series provides preliminary evidence that MDT may be effective in classifying and treating patients with MN.

Does the Keele STarT Back Screening Tool Contribute to Effectiveness in Treatment and Cost and Loss of Follow-Up of the Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy for Patients with Low Back Pain?

Background: Mechanical diagnosis and therapy (MDT) and the stratified approach using the Keele STarT Back Screening Tool (SBST) are examples of stratified low back pain (LBP) management. We investigated whether the medium–high risk in SBST can contribute to the time and sessions until discharge from MDT (Question 1) and to the loss of follow-up before identifying a promising management strategy (Question 2). Methods: A retrospective chart study was conducted. Multiple regression modeling was constructed using 10 independent variables, including whether the SBST was medium–high risk or not for Question 1, and the 9/10 independent variables for Question 2. Results: The data of 89 participants for Question 1 and 166 participants for Question 2 were analyzed. SBST was not a primary contributing factor for Question 1 (R² = 0.17–0.19). The model for Question 2 included SBST as a primary contributing factor and the shortest distance from the patient address to the hospital as a secondary contributing factor (93.4% correct classification). Conclusion: SBST status was not a primary contributing factor for time and sessions until discharge from MDT, but was a critical factor for the loss of MDT follow-up before identifying a promising management strategy.

Rehabilitation and return to sport of a high-level track & field athlete with low back pain - a case report

INTRODUCTION: Low back pain is prevalent among elite athletes with initial high levels of physical activity. Currently, there is a lack of evidence describing the optimal management strategy of high-level track and field athletes presenting with low back pain. CASE DESCRIPTION: This case report describes the clinical management and return-to-sport strategies of a male high-level track and field athlete presenting with low back pain in an outpatient physiotherapy clinic. Mechanical diagnosis and therapy (MDT) served as an important tool in the clinical management of the athlete. Patient-Specific Function Scale (PSFS), an 11-point scale (0 = unable to perform activity to 10 = able to perform activity at preinjury level), was used during three activities: hammer throw, squats and getting socks and shoes on.OUTCOMES: Eight weeks after initial consultation (15 weeks after the index injury), the athlete returned to sport and competition at national championship-level. PFPS scores at final consultation: hammer throw - 10/10; squats - 10/10 and getting socks and shoes on - 10/10. CONCLUSION: In combination with modern rehabilitation strategies, MDT provided the opportunity to engage the athlete as an active collaborator, which is in accordance with current clinical guidelines and best practice.

Physiotherapy assessment and treatment of chronic subjective tinnitus using mechanical diagnosis and therapy: a case report

Objectives: Tinnitus is the perception of sound without any external auditory stimulus. Cervicogenic somatic tinnitus (CST) is a subset in which symptoms are modulated by maneuvers of the neck. The evidence for effective diagnosis and treatment of CST is limited. Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT) is a biopsychosocial assessment and management system that uses the response to mechanical forces to classify clinical presentations accurately. The purpose of this case report is to describe the MDT assessment and management of a patient with chronic subjective tinnitus.Methods: A 67-year-old female with a 5-year history of left-sided subjective tinnitus, neck pain, and headache was referred for physiotherapy. Outcome measures included the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), Tinnitus Handicap Inventory (THI), and Neck Disability Index (NDI). She was evaluated and treated according to MDT principles with management consisting of individualized directional preference exercises and postural correction.Results: Significant improvements in symptoms, cervical range of motion, function, and psychosocial status were observed over the long-term. At 6 months, THI scores dropped from 62/100 to 18/100 and NDI scores dropped from 18/50 to 3/50.Discussion: A comprehensive MDT assessment led to a classification of Derangement, with treatment focusing on tailored self-management. Contrary to other interventions described for CST, the patient was able to make significant and lasting changes to her symptoms without the need for any externally applied interventions. The emphasis on self-management dovetails well with the biopsychosocial model of care. This case provides preliminary evidence for the utility of screening for Derangement in conservative tinnitus assessments.Level of Evidence: 4.

A prospective study of patients with knee pain and mechanical diagnosis and therapy (MDT) classification

OBJECTIVES

A prospective observational cohort study was conducted to 1) determine the prevalence of Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT) syndromes for patients with knee impairments, and 2) report the interaction between MDT classification and clinical outcomes, including pain intensity and disability, at discharge.

METHODS

Clinical outcome measures were completed at intake and discharge on 186 patients. A two-way mixed model analysis of variance with subsequent pairwise comparisons was done to examine differences between the following MDT classifications: Knee Derangement, Knee Dysfunction, and Other.

RESULTS

The primary findings were that: 1) 61.3% (54.3, 68.3), 9.7% (5.4, 13.9), and 29.0% (22.5, 35.5) of patients' conditions were classified as Knee Derangement, Knee Dysfunction, and Other, respectively; 2) all groups managed via MDT methods made clinically significant improvements in disability and pain intensity at discharge with the exception of the Other classification for pain intensity (NPRS difference score = 1.8); 3) a clinically significant difference was observed between the Knee Derangement and Other for pain and between the Knee Derangement and Other and the Knee Dysfunction and Other classifications for disability; and 4) the Knee Derangement classification was discharged, on average, 15.8 days earlier than the Knee Dysfunction classification.

DISCUSSION

This was the first prospective study of the application of MDT in patients with knee impairments. Results should be interpreted with caution as follow-up data were only completed on 58% of patients that started data collection. Assuming that none of the dropouts were Derangement, the overall prevalence of Derangement would be 32.2% and 79.7% if all dropouts were classified as Derangement. This study adds insight into understanding the unique clinical trajectories of these MDT classifications for the knee and offers recommendations for future work in this growing field of research.

Utilization of the Cervical Flexion Rotation Test to Confirm Rotation Directional Preference in People With Neck Pain: A Case Series

Despite the prevalence of neck pain, evidence is lacking regarding the relationship of pathophysiology to function in people with neck conditions. Although movement-based diagnoses based on directional preference (DP) are described for lumbar spinal conditions, how these diagnoses guide interventions is not supported in the Cervical Spine Clinical Practice Guidelines. To date, there are no case studies in the literature that demonstrate the efficacy of cervical spine management based on a rotation DP. This case series highlights patient response to repeated end-range neck movements to inform DP and how the cervical flexion rotation test (CFRT) was used as a clinical baseline to assess mechanical and symptomatic changes. Three consecutive patients were evaluated by a physical therapist fellow trained in orthopedic manual physical therapy and diplomaed in mechanical diagnosis and therapy. The patients' baseline pain ranged from 3 to 7/10 on the Numerical Pain Rating Scale (NPRS), and disability scores ranged from 20% to 52.6% on patient-reported outcome (PRO) measures. All three cases demonstrated a limited and painful CFRT. Examination procedures included repeated end-range movement testing in the sagittal and frontal and transverse planes. Across five to six visits in five to eight weeks, a decrease in the primary outcome measures from baseline to discharge were observed: NPRS, 50-85%; PRO, 60-82%. The CFRT may be a key baseline when screening patients with neck pain for DP. Following repeated end-range sagittal and frontal plane movements, the rapid change in the CFRT following targeted upper cervical rotation techniques confirmed a rotation DP.

The influence of directional preference on lateral patellar dislocation: a case report

BACKGROUND

There is little consensus on the conservative management of lateral patellar dislocations (LPD). Mechanical diagnosis and therapy (MDT) is an established classification system in the spinal and extremity population. This case report describes the use of MDT in the management and classification of a patient with LPD.

CASE DESCRIPTION

The patient was a 20-year-old female with a 3-month history of left knee pain precipitated by a lateral patellar dislocation. The patient described pain and a feeling of instability with standing and walking and limitations in work and recreational activities which involve lifting, squatting, and running. Based on the patient's response to repeated end range knee movements, the patient was found to have a directional preference (DP) for knee extension and instruction in performance of knee extension DP exercises was provided.

OUTCOMES

The patient's knee examination and subsequent intervention included her responses to repeated end range knee movements. Her knee pain was abolished, and strength, function, and motion were fully restored in five visits. A minimal clinically important difference (MCID) was achieved on the Lower Extremity Functional Scale (LEFS). At discharge, the patient was able to independently manage symptoms and perform all work and recreational activities at a pre-injury level and these improvements were maintained at a 9-month follow-up.

DISCUSSION

There are various management strategies for lateral patellar dislocation. This case demonstrated the use of classifying, subgrouping, and treating a patient with lateral patellar dislocation using the principle of DP.

CONCLUSION

The patient's outcomes suggest that MDT may be used in the nonoperative management of people with LPD who present with a DP.

Quantitative MRI to Characterize the Nucleus Pulposus Morphological and Biomechanical Variation According to Sagittal Bending Load and Radial Fissure, an ex vivo Ovine Specimen Proof-of-Concept Study

Background and context: Low back pain is a dramatic burden worldwide. Discography studies have shown that 39% of chronic low back pain patients suffer from discogenic pain due to a radial fissure of intervertebral disc. This can have major implications in clinical therapeutic choices. The use of discography is restricted because of its invasiveness and interest in it remains low as it represents a static condition of the disc morphology. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) appears to be less invasive but does not describe the biomechanical dynamic behavior of the fissure. Purpose: We aimed to seek a quantitative MRI protocol combined with ex vivo sagittal loading to analyze the morphological and biomechanical changes of the intervertebral disc structure and stress distribution. Study design: Proof of concept. Methods: We designed a proof-of-concept ovine study including 3 different 3.0 T-MRI sequences (T₂-weighted, T₁ and T₂ mapping). We analyzed 3 different mechanical states (neutral, flexion and extension) on a fresh ovine spine specimen to characterize an intervertebral disc before and after puncturing the anterior part of the annulus fibrosus. We used a mark tracking method to calculate the bending angles and the axial displacements of the discal structures. In parallel, we created a finite element model to calculate the variation of the axial stress and the maximal intensity shear stress, extrapolated from our experimental boundary conditions. Results: Thanks to an original combination of specific nuclear relaxation time quantifications (T₁, T₂) of the discal tissue, we characterized the nucleus movement/deformation into the fissure according to the synchronous mechanical load. This revealed a link between disc abnormality and spine segment range of motion capability. Our finite element model highlighted significant variations within the stress distribution between intact and damaged disc. Conclusion: Quantitative MRI appears to provide a new opportunity to characterize intra-discal structural morphology, lesions and stress changes under the influence of mechanical load. This preliminary work could have substantial implications for non-invasive disc exploration and could help to validate novel therapies for disc treatment.

Evaluation of the Structural and Construct Validity of the Credibility and Expectancy Scale for Patients With Musculoskeletal Disorders

Background The Credibility Expectancy Questionnaire (CEQ) includes three items each on the credibility and expectancy subscales. Credibility indicates to what extent the treatment is reasonable, and expectancy indicates to what extent the treatment is expected to be effective. The CEQ has been assumed to have a two-factor structure: credibility and expectancy, among patients receiving psychotherapy. However, its internal structure has been unknown to patients receiving physical therapy for musculoskeletal disorders. This study aimed to explore the internal structure of the CEQ and preliminary investigate the construct validity of the CEQ among patients receiving physical therapy for musculoskeletal disorders. Methodology A multi-center prospective cohort study was conducted. Data from 100 patients receiving outpatient physical therapy for musculoskeletal disorders was collected using an anonymous paper-based survey. The initial survey was conducted immediately before the initial physical therapy session, and the second survey was conducted after the third to seventh physical therapy sessions. The Patient Specific Functional Scale 2.0 (PSFS 2.0) was collected in both surveys, and the CEQ and an 11-point global rating of change scale (GRCS) were collected in the second survey. Exploratory factor analysis was conducted for the CEQ, and internal consistency was assessed for each subscale and an identified factor structure. Convergent validity in construct validity was also assessed with the hypothesis that Pearson's r values of each CEQ factor score to the PSFS 2.0 change scores and GRCS would range from 0.4 to 0.6. Results An exploratory factor analysis revealed a one-factor structure, where the percentage of the variance for the extraction sums of squared loadings was 62.8%. Cronbach's alpha was 0.89 for all items, 0.91 for the credibility subscale, and 0.75 for the expectancy subscale. Hypothesized correlations to the PSFS 2.0 change score and GRCS were detected with the CEQ total score (r = 0.48 for the PSFS 2.0 change score and r = 0.59 for the GRCS) and each subscale score (credibility subscale, r = 0.48 for the PSFS 2.0 change score and r = 0.49 for the GRCS; and expectancy subscale, r = 0.43 for the PSFS 2.0 change score and r = 0.62 for the GRCS). Conclusion A single-factor internal structure of the CEQ was detected among patients receiving physical therapy for musculoskeletal disorders. Additionally, preliminary evidence of construct validity was detected with convergent validity between the CEQ and functional and perceived improvement.