Ploidy Testing of Blastocoel Fluid for Screening May Be Technically Challenging and More Invasive Than That of Spent Cell Culture Media

Background

Recent studies have demonstrated that both blastocoel fluid (BF) and spent cell culture media (SCM) have potential as materials for non-invasive or less-invasive pre-implantation genetic analysis. BF may allow more opportunity to obtain cell-free DNA from the inner cell mass (ICM), and it has a lower risk of containing contaminant DNA from cumulus cells, sperm and culture media. There are no data regarding the ICM as a gold standard to evaluate the chromosome constitution of BF or SCM for embryo liquid biopsy.

Methods

Two hundred eighteen donated human blastocysts were warmed and cultured in blastocyst culture media for 18–24 h. The corresponding SCM was collected, and only clear ICM was biopsied in blastocysts; otherwise, the whole blastocyst (WB) was biopsied. Quantitative PCR was performed to determine the DNA levels in the SCM and BF before and after amplification. ChromInst was used to amplify BF/SCM and blastocyst DNA before sequencing. Chromosomal copy number variation (CNV) was investigated to evaluate the chromosome constitution.

Results

In total, 212 blastocysts were available for SCM and BF collection. The technical success rates (next-generation sequencing data) were 100 and 69.8% (148/212) for SCM and BF, respectively. Among the 148 blastocysts with both SCM and BF data, 101 were euploid and 47 were aneuploid based on ICM (n = 89) or WB (n = 59) analysis as the gold standard. Among all blastocysts, SCM was comparable to BF [specificity: 80.2 versus 61.4% (P = 0.005, χ² test); sensitivity: 91.5 versus 87.2% (P = 0.738, χ² test); negative predictive value (NPV): 95.3 versus 91.2% (P = 0.487, χ² test); positive predictive value (PPV): 68.3% versus 51.3% (P = 0.042, χ² test)]. The SCM and BF samples were 83.8% (124/148) and 69.6% (103/148) concordant with the corresponding ICM/WB samples when only two categories, euploid or aneuploid/mosaic, were grouped to calculate the concordance.

Conclusions

Compared with BF, SCM has superior diagnostic performance, and it is non-invasive for embryos.

Clinical Trial Registration

[http://www.chictr.org.cn], identifier [ChiCTR-BPD-17014087].

A Non-invasive Chromosome Screening Strategy for Prioritizing in vitro Fertilization Embryos for Implantation

Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) is widely used to select embryos having normal ploidy for transfer, but they require an invasive embryo biopsy procedure that may cause harm to the embryos and offspring. Therefore, a non-invasive approach to select embryos with normal ploidy for implantation is highly demanded. Non-invasive chromosome screening (NICS) methods have been proposed and applied in clinical practices, but a large-scale validation versus invasive preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) and the whole embryo ploidy has not yet been reported. In this study, by using the whole embryo as a gold standard, we validated NICS assay in a total of 265 donated human embryos and compared its performance with conventional trophectoderm (TE) biopsy PGT. The NICS assay showed promising performance, which is comparable to PGT-TE [sensitivity: 87.36 versus 89.66%; specificity: 80.28 versus 82.39%; negative predictive value (NPV): 91.2 versus 92.86%; positive predictive value (PPV): 73.08 versus 75.73%]. Additionally, NICS provides a scoring system for prioritizing embryo: embryos can be categorized into three groups with euploid prediction probabilities of 90.0, 27.8, and 72.2% for group euploid (A), aneuploid (B), and multiple abnormal chromosomes (MAC) (C), respectively. When an addition of TE assay is provided as a secondary validation, the accuracy significantly increases from 72.2 to 84.3% for group B and from 27.8 to 83.3% for group C. Our results suggest that NICS is a good rule in assay for identifying chromosomal normal embryos for transfer and might serve as a non-invasive approach for prioritizing embryos instead of preventing transfer of aneuploid and MAC embryos. It will help to ensure the safety of offspring and efficient utilization of embryos.

NGS-Based Application for Routine Non-Invasive Pre-Implantation Genetic Assessment in IVF

Although non-invasive pre-implantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (NIPGT-A) is potentially appropriate to assess chromosomal ploidy of the embryo, practical application of it in a routine IVF centre have not been started in the absence of a recommendation. Our objective in this study was to provide a comprehensive workflow for a clinically applicable strategy for NIPGT-A based on next-generation sequencing (NGS) technology with the corresponding bioinformatic pipeline. In a retrospective study, we performed NGS on spent blastocyst culture media of Day 3 embryos fertilised with intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) with quality score on morphology assessment using the blank culture media as background control. Chromosomal abnormalities were identified by an optimised bioinformatics pipeline applying copy number variation (CNV) detecting algorithm. In this study, we demonstrate a comprehensive workflow covering both wet- and dry-lab procedures supporting a clinically applicable strategy for NIPGT-A that can be carried out within 48 h, which is critical for the same-cycle blastocyst transfer. The described integrated approach of non-invasive evaluation of embryonic DNA content of the culture media can potentially supplement existing pre-implantation genetic screening methods.

Improved Non-Invasive Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Beta-Thalassemia Using Spent Embryo Culture Medium Containing Blastocoelic Fluid

OBJECTIVES

To compare successful beta-thalassemia (β-thalassemia) detection rates obtained using spent culture medium and spent culture medium containing blastocoelic fluid (BF).

METHOD

This study involved data from 10 couples who underwent preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) for β-thalassemia. A total of 26 samples of spent culture medium containing BF (group A) and 33 samples without BF (group B) were collected and analyzed. The DNA concentration and β-thalassemia detection rates were evaluated.

RESULTS

The HBB mutation analysis results of 34 samples were concordant with the biopsy results (34/59, 57.6%). In group A, the HBB mutation analysis results of 19 of 26 samples (73.1%) were concordant with the biopsy results. The concordance rate in group A was higher than that in group B (15/33, 45.5%; P < 0.05). The haplotyping results of 38 samples were concordant with the biopsy results (38/59, 64.4%). The concordance rate in group B was 17/33 (51.5%), which was significantly lower than that in group A (21/26, 80.8%) (P < 0.05). In group A, the mean DNA concentration of samples with <10% fragmentation was 107.3 ± 70.1 ng/μL, which was lower than that of samples with ≥10% fragmentation (194.6 ± 28.0 ng/μL) (P < 0.05). However, the detection rates of <10% and ≥10% fragmentation were not significantly different (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The β-thalassemia detection rate with non-invasive PGT using the spent culture medium containing BF was higher than that using the spent culture medium alone. Fragmentation is associated with DNA concentration in the spent culture medium containing BF.

Small Noncoding RNA Signatures for Determining the Developmental Potential of an Embryo at the Morula Stage

As part of the optimization of assisted reproductive technology programs, the aim of the study was to identify key small noncoding RNA (sncRNA) molecules that participate in maternal-to-zygotic transition and determine development potential and competence to form a healthy fetus. Small RNA deep sequencing followed by quantitative real-time RT-PCR was used to profile sncRNAs in 50 samples of spent culture medium from morula with different development potentials (no potential (degradation/developmental arrest), low potential (poor-quality blastocyst), and high potential (good/excellent quality blastocyst capable of implanting and leading to live birth)) obtained from 27 subfertile couples who underwent in vitro fertilization. We have shown that the quality of embryos at the morula stage is determined by secretion/uptake rates of certain sets of piRNAs and miRNAs, namely hsa_piR_011291, hsa_piR_019122, hsa_piR_001311, hsa_piR_015026, hsa_piR_015462, hsa_piR_016735, hsa_piR_019675, hsa_piR_020381, hsa_piR_020485, hsa_piR_004880, hsa_piR_000807, hsa-let-7b-5p, and hsa-let-7i-5p. Predicted gene targets of these sncRNAs included those globally decreased at the 8-cell–morula–blastocyst stage and critical to early embryo development. We show new original data on sncRNA profiling in spent culture medium from morula with different development potential. Our findings provide a view of a more complex network that controls human embryogenesis at the pre-implantation stage. Further research is required using reporter analysis to experimentally confirm interactions between identified sncRNA/gene target pairs.

Non-invasive pre-implantation aneuploidy screening and diagnosis of beta thalassemia IVSII654 mutation using spent embryo culture medium

BACKGROUND

Cell-free nuclear DNA has been isolated from spent embryo culture medium. Whether this small amount of DNA can be amplified at the whole genome level and the concordance rate of karyotypes and specific alleles between biopsied cells and media has not been evaluated.

METHODS

Seven couples were recruited, 88 donated embryos and their corresponding media were collected for whole genome amplification (WGA). The efficiency of WGA, the concordance of chromosome status, and the HBB gene IVSII654 allele between biopsied cells and media were investigated.

RESULTS

After WGA, the DNA detection rate was 90.90% with a mean concentration of 26.15 ng/μl. The full chromosome concordance rate between biopsied cells and medium was 64.52%, and it increased to 90.00% for diploid blastocyst samples. Analysis of the mutated IVSII654 locus and SNP linkage verified that the DNA present in the medium originated from embryonic cells.

CONCLUSION

We confirmed that nuclear DNA is present in spent culture medium and that the majority of this DNA can be amplified for subsequent analysis. Our results showed that non-invasive embryo genetic testing at the chromosomal-level using medium can concordant to the biopsied cells, but it needs further optimized before use in clinical applications. KEY MESSAGES The aggressive biopsy step during PGD/PGS procedure would have a negative effect on the future development of the embryo. Cell-free nuclear DNA has been observed in spent embryo culture medium, which holds promise for the development of non-invasive PGD/PGS approaches. The presence of DNA in medium, its efficiency for WGA, and the concordance between chromosome status and the HBB gene IVSII654 allele as diagnosed from biopsied cells or medium were investigated. Non-invasive embryo genetic testing at the chromosomal-level and allele site using medium can concordant to the biopsied cells, but it needs further optimized before use in clinical applications.