Awake versus Asleep Deep Brain Stimulation Surgery: Technical Considerations and Critical Review of the Literature

Advancements in neuroimaging have led to a trend toward direct, image-based targeting under general anesthesia without the use of microelectrode recording (MER) or intraoperative test stimulation, also referred to as “asleep” deep brain stimulation (DBS) surgery. Asleep DBS, utilizing imaging in the form of intraoperative computed tomography (iCT) or magnetic resonance imaging (iMRI), has demonstrated reliable targeting accuracy of DBS leads implanted within the globus pallidus and subthalamic nucleus while also improving clinical outcomes in patients with Parkinson’s disease. In lieu, of randomized control trials, retrospective comparisons between asleep and awake DBS with MER have shown similar short-term efficacy with the potential for decreased complications in asleep cohorts. In lieu of long-term outcome data, awake DBS using MER must demonstrate more durable outcomes with fewer stimulation-induced side effects and lead revisions in order for its use to remain justifiable; although patient-specific factors may also be used to guide the decision regarding which technique may be most appropriate and tolerable to the patient.

Deep brain stimulation surgical techniques

Stereotactic techniques for placement of deep brain stimulation (DBS) electrodes have undergone continuous refinement since the introduction of human stereotaxis in the 1940s. Volumetric imaging techniques, including magnetic resonance imaging and computed tomography, have replaced ventriculography, and increasingly sophisticated computer systems now allow highly refined targeting of subcortical structures. This chapter reviews the underlying principles of stereotactic surgery, including imaging, targeting, and registration, and describes the surgical approach to DBS placement using both framed and frameless techniques.

Long-term survival with stereotactic radiotherapy for imaging-diagnosed pituitary tumors in dogs

Published studies on the use of stereotactic radiotherapy for dogs with pituitary tumors are limited. This retrospective observational study describes results of stereotactic radiotherapy for 45 dogs with imaging-diagnosed pituitary tumors. All dogs were treated at a single hospital during the period of December 2009-2015. The stereotactic radiotherapy was delivered in one 15 Gray (Gy) fraction or in three 8 Gy fractions. At the time of analysis, 41 dogs were deceased. Four were alive and censored from all survival analyses; one dog received 8 Gy every other day and was removed from protocol analyses. The median overall survival from first treatment was 311 days (95% confidence interval 226-410 days [range 1-2134 days]). Thirty-two dogs received 15 Gy (median overall survival 311 days; 95% confidence interval [range 221-427 days]), and 12 received 24 Gy on three consecutive days (median overall survival 245 days, 95% confidence interval [range 2-626 days]). Twenty-nine dogs had hyperadrenocorticism (median overall survival 245 days), while 16 had nonfunctional masses (median overall survival 626 days). Clinical improvement was reported in 37/45 cases. Presumptive signs of acute adverse effects within 4 months of stereotactic radiotherapy were noted in 10/45, and most had improvement spontaneously or with steroids. Late effects versus tumor progression were not discernable, but posttreatment blindness (2), hypernatremia (2), and progressive neurological signs (31) were reported. There was no statistical difference in median overall survival for different protocols. Patients with nonfunctional masses had longer median overall survival than those with hyperadrenocorticism (P = 0.0003). Survival outcomes with stereotactic radiotherapy were shorter than those previously reported with definitive radiation, especially for dogs with hyperadrenocorticism.

Robotic magnetic navigation for ablation of human arrhythmias

Radiofrequency treatment represents the first choice of treatment for arrhythmias, in particular complex arrhythmias and especially atrial fibrillation, due to the greater benefit/risk ratio compared to antiarrhythmic drugs. However, complex arrhythmias such as atrial fibrillation require long procedures with additional risks such as X-ray exposure or serious complications such as tamponade. Given this context, the treatment of arrhythmias using robotic magnetic navigation entails a technique well suited to complex arrhythmias on account of its efficacy, reliability, significant reduction in X-ray exposure for both patient and operator, as well as a very low risk of perforation. As ongoing developments will likely improve results and procedure times, this technology will become one of the most modern technologies for treating arrhythmias. Based on the literature, this review summarizes the advantages and limitations of robotic magnetic navigation for ablation of human arrhythmias.

The first formulation of image-based stereotactic principles: the forgotten work of Gaston Contremoulins

Although image-based human stereotaxis began with Spiegel and Wycis in 1947, the major principles of radiographic stereotaxis were formulated 50 years earlier by the French scientific photographer Gaston Contremoulins. In 1897, frustrated by the high morbidity of bullet extraction from the brain, the Parisian surgeon Charles Rémy asked Contremoulins to devise a method for bullet localization using the then new technology of x-rays. In doing so, Contremoulins conceived of many of the modern principles of stereotaxis, including the use of a reference frame, radiopaque fiducials for registration, images to locate the target in relation to the frame, phantom devices to locate the target in relation to the fiducial marks, and the use of an adjustable pointer to guide the surgical approach. Contremoulins' ideas did not emerge from science or medicine, but instead were inspired by his training in the fine arts. Had he been a physician instead of an artist, he might have never discovered his extraordinary methods. Contremoulins' "compass" and its variants enjoyed great success during World War I, but were abandoned by 1920 for simpler methods. Although Contremoulins was one of the most eminent radiographers in France, he was not a physician, and his personality was uncompromising. By 1940, both he and his methods were forgotten. It was not until 1988 that he was rediscovered by Moreau while reviewing the history of French radiology, and chronicled by Mornet in his extensive biography. The authors examine Contremoulins' stereotactic methods in historical context, describe the details of his devices, relate his discoveries to his training in the fine arts, and discuss how his prescient formulation of stereotaxis was forgotten for more than half a century.

MRI Atlas of the Human Deep Brain

Mastering detailed anatomy of the human deep brain in clinical neurosciences is challenging. Although numerous pioneering works have gathered a large dataset of structural and topographic information, it is still difficult to transfer this knowledge into practice, even with advanced magnetic resonance imaging techniques. Thus, classical histological atlases continue to be used to identify structures for stereotactic targeting in functional neurosurgery. Physicians mainly use these atlases as a template co-registered with the patient's brain. However, it is possible to directly identify stereotactic targets on MRI scans, enabling personalized targeting. In order to help clinicians directly identify deep brain structures relevant to present and future medical applications, we built a volumetric MRI atlas of the deep brain (MDBA) on a large scale (infra millimetric). Twelve hypothalamic, 39 subthalamic, 36 telencephalic, and 32 thalamic structures were identified, contoured, and labeled. Nineteen coronal, 18 axial, and 15 sagittal MRI plates were created. Although primarily designed for direct labeling, the anatomic space was also subdivided in twelfths of AC-PC distance, leading to proportional scaling in the coronal, axial, and sagittal planes. This extensive work is now available to clinicians and neuroscientists, offering another representation of the human deep brain ([https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/] [hal-02116633]). The atlas may also be used by computer scientists who are interested in deciphering the topography of this complex region.

Magnetic navigation facilitates percutaneous coronary intervention for complex lesions

BACKGROUND

We sought to determine the utility of a magnetic navigation system (MNS) in treating a variety of coronary artery lesions including those that could not be revascularized with standard percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). MNS may add value in the treatment of tortuous arteries and bifurcation lesions; however its widespread adoption has lagged because of cost and a lack of clear advantage over conventional PCI. We performed a retrospective analysis to determine whether MNS improved procedural success for highly complex lesions.

METHODS AND RESULTS

One hundred and forty-eight patients underwent treatment with MNS at Mayo Clinic, Rochester. Clinical data, angiographic and procedural characteristics, lesion crossing success and outcomes were reviewed. Overall 133 patients underwent successful revascularization with 87% (143) of 164 lesions crossed using MNS alone. Another six lesions required a combination of MNS and conventional devices resulting in overall success of 91% (149/164). Eighteen complex lesions had previously failed PCI and 12 (67%) were successfully treated with MNS. Success after failed PCI was higher (88%) when a frequent user operated MNS, but occasional users also noted incremental success (30%). Twenty-five chronic total occlusions were included amongst these 164 lesions, with observed antegrade MNS lesion crossing rates of 78% for regular and 14% for occasional users.

CONCLUSIONS

MNS is a useful adjunct to performance of PCI. This specialized technology has a clear learning curve and can facilitate treatment of highly complex lesions.

A Brief History of Stereotactic Atlases: Their Evolution and Importance in Stereotactic Neurosurgery

Following the recent acquisition of unprecedented anatomical details through state-of-the-art neuroimaging, stereotactic procedures such as microelectrode recording (MER) or deep brain stimulation (DBS) can now rely on direct and accurately individualized topographic targeting. Nevertheless, both modern brain atlases derived from appropriate histological techniques involving post-mortem studies of human brain tissue and the methods based on neuroimaging and functional information represent a valuable tool to avoid targeting errors due to imaging artifacts or insufficient anatomical details. Hence, they have thus far been considered a reference guide for functional neurosurgical procedures by neuroscientists and neurosurgeons. In fact, brain atlases, ranging from the ones based on histology and histochemistry to the probabilistic ones grounded on data derived from large clinical databases, are the result of a long and inspiring journey made possible thanks to genial intuitions of great minds in the field of neurosurgery and to the technical advancement of neuroimaging and computational science. The aim of this text is to review the principal characteristics highlighting the milestones of their evolution.

Ablative Limbic System Surgery: Review and Future Directions

The limbic system is a network of interconnected brain regions regulating emotion, memory, and behavior. Pathology of the limbic system can manifest as psychiatric disease, including obsessive-compulsive disorder and major depressive disorder. For patients with these disorders who have not responded to standard pharmacological and cognitive behavioral therapy, ablative surgery is a neurosurgical treatment option. The major ablative limbic system procedures currently used are anterior capsulotomy, dorsal anterior cingulotomy, subcaudate tractotomy, and limbic leucotomy. In this review, we include a brief history of ablative limbic system surgery leading up to its current form. Mechanistic justification for these procedures is considered in a discussion of the pathophysiology of psychiatric disease. We then discuss therapeutic efficacy as demonstrated by recent trials. Finally, we consider future directions, including the search for predictors of treatment response, the development of more precise targeting methods, and the use of advances in neuroimaging to track treatment response.

Stereotaxic cutting of post-mortem human brains for neuroanatomical studies

Stereotaxis is widely used in clinical neurosurgery, neuroradiosurgery, and neuroimaging. Yet, maps of brain structures obtained from post-mortem human brains are not usually presented in known stereotaxic coordinates. Post-mortem brain data given in stereotaxic coordinates would facilitate comparisons with in vivo human neuroimages and would also facilitate intra and inter-experiment comparisons. In this article, we present a crafted instrument for stereotaxic cutting of post-mortem human brain hemispheres. The instrument consists of a transparent methacrylate plate facing a mirror, four legs, and lateral regularly spaced columns permitting the insertion of large knives in-between the columns. This instrument can be built in any laboratory to obtain human brain slabs in the stereotaxic space of Talairach and Tournoux. We explain in detail the procedure for stereotaxic cutting of human brain hemispheres in the coronal plane, as well as the basis for calculating stereotaxic coordinates of histological sections obtained following the stereotaxic cutting protocol.

Stereotactic Photodynamic Therapy of Recurrent Malignant Gliomas

The aim of the study is to assess the effectiveness and safety of stereotactic photodynamic therapy (sPDT) with 5-aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA) in patients with recurrent malignant supratentorial gliomas in functionally relevant brain areas.

Materials and Methods

In a retrospective single-center study the results of sPDT with 5-ALA in 10 patients (6 of 10 were male), aged 30 to 62 years (median: 51.5 years; 95% CI: 38-59 years) with recurrent malignant brain gliomas after standard therapy who underwent surgery during the period of 2020-2023 were analyzed. sPDT was conducted during 15 min using 5-ALA at a dosage of 20 mg/kg, a diode laser with a wavelength of 635 nm and power of 1 W, and the LFT-02-BIOSPEC unit (BIOSPEC, Russia). Three patients got repeated sPDT after 3, 7, and 15 months due to a relapse. The number of target points and the optimal position for intervention paths were determined according to the data of preoperative stereotactic MRI of the brain with contrast intensification using the CRW Precision stereotactic navigation system (Integra, USA) and intraoperative registration of the area with the highest intensity of protoporphyrin IX fluorescence along the path (according to fluorescence biospectroscopy).

Results

Glioblastoma (grade IV, WHO) was diagnosed in 7 patients, anaplastic astrocytoma (grade III, WHO) - in 3 persons. Genetic studies were performed for 9 patients, 7 of them had tumors without the IDH1 gene mutation. None of the patients had a combined 1p/19q deletion. The median volume of the contrast-enhancing part of the recurrent tumor was 7.95 cm3 (95% CI: 3.3-13.6 cm3). The median time to relapse after sPDT in patients with anaplastic astrocytomas and glioblastomas was 14.5 and 6.5 months, respectively. The median survival time after sPDT in patients with glioblastomas was 15.8 months (95% CI: 0.5-20.1 months), and in patients with anaplastic astrocytomas - 46.3 months (95%, CI not specified). In the early postoperative period, two patients had motor aphasia and hemiparesis, which further regressed.

Conclusion

The results of a small group of patients allow to consider sPDT with 5-ALA as a promising technique to treat patients with recurrent high-grade gliomas in functionally relevant brain areas and require further prospective assessment.

Salvage stereotactic reirradiation for intraprostatic cancer recurrence: A large retrospective study

INTRODUCTION

Prostate cancer is the most common cancer in men. Thirty to forty-seven percent of patients treated with exclusive radiotherapy for prostate cancer will experience intraprostate recurrence. The use of radiotherapy in stereotactic conditions allows millimetric accuracy in irradiation to the target zone that minimizes the dose to organs at risk. In this study, we evaluated the clinical outcome of prostatic reirradiation with stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) in patients with intraprostatic recurrence initially treated by radiotherapy.

METHOD

This single-center retrospective study included 41 patients diagnosed with exclusive local recurrence of prostate cancer after radiotherapy and treatedby stereotactic Cyberknife irradiation. The objective of this study was to assess the efficacy and the safety of stereotactic reirradiation for patients with intraprostatic recurrence initially treated with radiotherapy.

RESULTS

Median follow-up was 35 months. The 2-year biochemical relapse-free survival was 72.89%, the 2-year local recurrence free survival was 93.59%, the 2-year local regional recurrence-free survival was 85.24%, and the 2-year metastasis-free survival was to 91.49%. The analysis of toxicities showed a good tolerance of stereotactic irradiation. Urinary and gastro-intestinal adverse events was mostly of grades 1-2 (CTCAEv4). Grade 3 toxicity occurred in one to two patients.

CONCLUSION

Stereotactic reirradiation appears effective and well-tolerated for local recurrence of prostate cancer and might allow to delay the introduction of hormonal therapy and its side effects.

Stereotaxic-assisted gene therapy in Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases: therapeutic potentials and clinical frontiers

INTRODUCTION

Alzheimer's disease (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD) are neurodegenerative disorders causing cognitive deficits and motor difficulties in the elderly. Conventional treatments are mainly symptomatic with little ability to halt disease progression. Gene therapies to correct or silence genetic mutations predisposing to AD or PD are currently being developed in preclinical studies and clinical trials, relying mostly on systemic delivery, which reduces their effectiveness. Imaging-guided stereotaxic procedures are used to locally deliver therapeutic cargos to well-defined brain sites, hence raising the question whether stereotaxic-assisted gene therapy has therapeutic potentials.

AREAS COVERED

The authors summarize the studies that investigated the use of gene therapy in PD and AD in animal and clinical studies over the past five years, with a special emphasis on the combinatorial potential with stereotaxic delivery. The advantages, limitations and futuristic challenges of this technique are discussed.

EXPERT OPINION

Robotic stereotaxis combined with intraoperative imaging has revolutionized brain surgeries. While gene therapies are bringing huge innovations to the medical field and new hope to AD and PD patients and medical professionals, the efficient and targeted delivery of such therapies is a bottleneck. We propose that careful application of stereotaxic delivery of gene therapies can improve PD and AD management. [Figure: see text].

Guiding histological assessment of uterine lesions using 3D in vitro ultrasonography and stereotaxis

OBJECTIVE

To compare ultrasonographic features of uterine lesions with the findings at macroscopy and microscopy.

METHODS

Case series of ten consecutive women undergoing a hysterectomy for uterine pathology. A preoperative transvaginal ultrasound examination was performed. After hysterectomy, the uterus was re-evaluated by 3D in vitro ultrasonography and in vitro gel instillation sonography (iGIS). The lesion of interest was pinpointed by inserting an intramuscular injection needle using a free-hand 2D-ultrasound guided technique to focus the macroscopic and the microscopic examination by the pathologist.

RESULTS

Adenomyosis, benign fibroids and infiltrating endometrial cancer were diagnosed in six, five and one patient, respectively. We found that iGIS improved image quality of in vitro ultrasound. There was a good correlation between the reported ultrasound features and the final histological diagnosis. Some lesions had been misinterpreted during preoperative ultrasonography or at macroscopical examination: e.g. dense myometrial vessels reported as small myometrial cysts at grey scale ultrasound examination; absence of macroscopical lesions in a case of diffuse adenomyosis.

CONCLUSIONS

In vitro 3D ultrasonography and iGIS allow for accurate mapping of uterine lesions so that ultrasound features can be matched with final histology. Our series demonstrates some pitfalls in the interpretation of sonographic and macroscopic features of uterine lesions. Stereotaxis of focal uterine lesions could focus histological assessment and reduces examination time for the pathologist.

Development of a murine laser interstitial thermotherapy system

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to develop a murine system for the delivery of laser interstitial thermotherapy (LITT) with probe-based thermometry as a model for human glioblastoma treatment to investigate thermal diffusion in heterogeneous brain tissue.

METHODS

First, the tissue heating properties were characterized using a diode-pumped solid-state near-infrared laser in a homogeneous tissue model. The laser was adapted for use with a repurposed stereotactic surgery frame utilizing a micro laser probe and Hamilton syringe. The authors designed and manufactured a stereotactic frame attachment to work as a temperature probe stabilizer. Application of this novel design was used as a precise method for real-time thermometry at known distances from the thermal ablative center mass during murine LITT studies.

RESULTS

Temperature measurements were achieved during LITT that verified the direct thermometry capability of the system without the need for MR-based thermal monitoring. Application of multiple stereotactic design iterations led to an accurately reproducible surgical laser ablation procedure. Histological staining confirmed precise thermal ablation and controllable lesion size based on time and temperature control. Treatment of a syngeneic intracranial glioma model highly resistant to conventional therapy resulted in a modest survival benefit.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors have successfully developed a murine model system of LITT with direct in situ thermometry for investigation into the effects of thermal ablation and combinatorial treatments in murine brain tumor models.

Intraoperative Stereotactic Arteriography in Complex Cervical Spine Surgery

Intra-operative navigation has revolutionized spinal instrumentation. The O-arm (a mobile X-ray system; Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN) is uniquely capable of enabling visualization of the spine in axial planes. The application of this technology is wide yet underutilized in terms of its capacity to image spinal vascular anatomy. We completed a retrospective chart review of the following case studies. A 24-year-old neurologically intact female presented with a Jefferson fracture without vertebral artery dissection after a motor vehicle accident. After the failure of conservative management due to pseudoarthrosis, the patient opted for fusion. Prior to the procedure, bilateral 5 French femoral sheaths were placed. After exposure, intraarterial (IA) contrast was injected prior to the O-arm spin to visualize both vertebral arteries, which were stretched and adjacent to a mobile boney segment. In the second case, a 71-year-old male presented with right shoulder pain and a flaccid left deltoid secondary to a large enhancing epidural lesion spanning C4-C7. Further work-up confirmed a diagnosis of metastatic intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma. Prior to resection with cervical spinal stabilization, a right radial artery 4 French Glidesheath was placed. Prior to the O-arm spin, the right vertebral artery was selected, and intravenous contrast was injected to permit visualization of the vertebral artery, which was encased within the tumor and at significant risk for iatrogenic injury. Both patients tolerated the endovascular and spinal procedures well without vertebral artery injury. This is the first series to report the effective use of the O-arm for improved visualization of vascular anatomy during surgery for cervical spinal trauma and oncology.