Abstract
OBJECTIVE
To determine whether out-of-hospital administration of hypertonic fluids would improve survival after severe injury with hemorrhagic shock.
BACKGROUND
Hypertonic fluids have potential benefit in the resuscitation of severely injured patients because of rapid restoration of tissue perfusion, with a smaller volume, and modulation of the inflammatory response, to reduce subsequent organ injury.
METHODS
Multicenter, randomized, blinded clinical trial, May 2006 to August 2008, 114 emergency medical services agencies in North America within the Resuscitation Outcomes Consortium.
INCLUSION CRITERIA
injured patients, age ≥ 15 years with hypovolemic shock (systolic blood pressure ≤ 70 mm Hg or systolic blood pressure 71-90 mm Hg with heart rate ≥ 108 beats per minute). Initial resuscitation fluid, 250 mL of either 7.5% saline per 6% dextran 70 (hypertonic saline/dextran, HSD), 7.5% saline (hypertonic saline, HS), or 0.9% saline (normal saline, NS) administered by out-of-hospital providers. Primary outcome was 28-day survival. On the recommendation of the data and safety monitoring board, the study was stopped early (23% of proposed sample size) for futility and potential safety concern.
RESULTS
: A total of 853 treated patients were enrolled, among whom 62% were with blunt trauma, 38% with penetrating. There was no difference in 28-day survival-HSD: 74.5% (0.1; 95% confidence interval [CI], -7.5 to 7.8); HS: 73.0% (-1.4; 95% CI, -8.7-6.0); and NS: 74.4%, P = 0.91. There was a higher mortality for the postrandomization subgroup of patients who did not receive blood transfusions in the first 24 hours, who received hypertonic fluids compared to NS [28-day mortality-HSD: 10% (5.2; 95% CI, 0.4-10.1); HS: 12.2% (7.4; 95% CI, 2.5-12.2); and NS: 4.8%, P < 0.01].
CONCLUSION
Among injured patients with hypovolemic shock, initial resuscitation fluid treatment with either HS or HSD compared with NS, did not result in superior 28-day survival. However, interpretation of these findings is limited by the early stopping of the trial.
CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION
Clinical Trials.gov, NCT00316017.
Collapse
Collaborators
Richard L George, Henry E Wang, Shannon W Stephens, Joe E Acker, Michael L Minor, Paul A MacLennan, Sandra Caldwell, Katherine R Lai, Ahamed H Idris, Fernando Benitez, Raymond Fowler, Dorothy Lemecha, Joseph Minei, Paul Pepe, Michael Ramsay, Robert Simonson, Jane Wigginton, Rajesh Gandhi, John Smithson, John Griswell, Dixie Climer, Melinda Moffat, Kate Newman, Pamela Owens, Andrea Bennett, Richard Black, Debra Cason, Billy Craft, Lucy Detamble, Ryan Dykes, Tony Harvey, Suzanne Hewitt, Marshal Isaacs, Joe Kay, Tami Kayea, Richard LaChance, Thomas Lehman, Paul Mayer, Jeffrey Metzger, Danny Miller, Kenneth Navarro, Steven Parker, Karen Pickard, Warren Porter, T J Starling, Tommy Tine, Chris Vinson, Kyle Roach, David Abebefe, Steven Arze, Sean Black, Matthew Bush, Michael Forman, Jeffery Goodloe, Ralph Kelly, Gregory Lachar, Alicia Mangram, Marc Morales, Edward Thornton, Robert Wiebe, Paula Novonty, Linda Haynes, Richard Kerber, Steve Hata, Dianne Atkins, Catherine Rost, Alexander Drum, Timothy Fabian, Martin Croce, Ben Zarzaur, Louis Magnott, Thomas Schroeppel, George Maish, Tiffany Bee, Suzanne Wilson, Stephanie Panzer-Baggett, Lynda Waddle-Smith, Tom P Aufderheide, Ronald G Pirrallo, Karen J Brasel, Andrea L Winthrop, John P Klein, Joseph Brandt, Walter Bialkowski, Jennifer Noldin, David J Kitscha, Barbara J Burja, Heather Bertelson, Chris von Briesen, Christopher W Sparks, Pamela Walsh, John Chianelli, Rosemarie Forster, Michael Milbrath, Lauryl Pukansky, Kenneth Sternig, Eugene Chin, Nancy Frieberg, Kim Krueger, Del Szewczuga, Thomas Duerr, Rebecca Funk, Gail Jacobsen, Janis Spitzer, Richard Demien, James Martins, John Cohn, Russell R Spahn, Mike Jankowski, Timothy James, William E Wentlandt, David Berousek, Brian M Satula, Jay B Behling, Dean K Redman, Steven Hook, Andrew Neargarder, Jim Singer, Thomas Reminga, Dennis Shepherd, Peter Holzhauer, Jonathan Rubin, Craig Skold, Orlando Alvarez, Heidi Harkins, Edward Barthell, William Haselow, Albert Yee, John Whitcomb, Eduardo E Castro, Steven Motarjeme, Paul Coogan, Keith Rader, Jeff Glaspy, Gary Gerschke, Howie Croft, Mike Brin, Cory Wilson, Anne Johnson, William Kumprey, David B Hoyt, John Shaver, Frank Nastanski, Bernardine Donato, Sam Stratton, Ken Miller, Ruth Grubb, John Herrera, Larry Grihalva, Cristobal Barrios, Michael Lekawa, Marianne Cinat, Darren Malinoski, Matthew Dolich, Humberto Sauri, Ian Stiell, Jim Christenson, Martin Osmond, Morad Hameed, David Evans, Randi van Heest, Christian Vaillancourt, Patrick Lefaivre, Marc-Andre Da Ponti, Jane Banek, Irene Watpool, Tracy McArdle, Julia Foxall, Mary-Jo Lewis, Barb Boychuk, Sarah Pennington, Jonathan Dreyer, Douglas Munkley, Justin Maloney, Paul Colella, Andrew Affleck, David Waldbillig, Paul Bradford, Andrew Reid, Kenneth Boyle, Lorraine Luinstra-Toohey, John Trickett, Nicole Sykes, Elaine Graham, Kieran Ballah, Cathy Hedges, Dug Andrusiek, Dan Bishop, Ron Straight, Brian Twaites, Stuart Donn, Clifton Callaway, Samuel Tisherman, Jon Rittenberger, Joseph Condle, Mitch Kampmeyer, Timothy Markham, Maureen Morgan, Paul Sabol, Gina Sicchitano, Scott Sherry, Anthony Shrader, Greg Stull, Manuel Torres, William Groft, Robert McCaughan, Rodney Rohrer, John Cole, David Fuchs, Francis Guyette, William Jenkins, Ronald Roth, Heather Walker, Alain Corcos, Ankur Doshi, Adrian Ong, Andrew Peitzman, Terri Schmidt, Jerris R Hedges, Martin A Schreiber, Craig D Newgard, Mohamud R Daya, Robert A Lowe, Denise E Griffiths, Dana M Zive, Aaron W Monnig, Abdolaziz Yekrang, John Brett, Jonathan Jui, Ritu Sahni, Craig R Warden, Skip Freedman, Marc D Muhr, John A Stouffer, Kyle Gorman, Pontine Rosteck, Cyndi Newton, Tina Beeler, Ken Horn, Karl Koenig, Jan Lee, Roxy Barnes, Heather Tucker, Brad Allen, T J Bishop, Mike Hollingsworth, Eric Schult, Scott Sullivan, Rick Williams, Steve Dehart, Mark Stevens, Rob Hawks, Adam Glaser, Rod Rowan, Jonathan Chin, Steve Dargan, Gert Zoutendijk, Chris Koppenhafer, Corie Depuy, Jim Anderson, Ameen I Ramzy, K Dean Gubler, Lynn K Wittwer, Riyad Karmy-Jones, Greg Hoskins, Samantha Underwood, Denise Haun-Taylor, Elizabeth Bryant, Joanne Miller, Brooke Barone, Kristine Patterson, Daniel Davis, Raul Coimbra, Gary Vilke, James Dunford, Donna Kelly Aker, Lana McCallum-Brown, Bruce Haynes, Brad Schwartz, Michael Sise, Frank Kennedy, Fred Simon, Gail Tominaga, John Steele, Peter J Kudenchuk, Eileen Bulger, Michael Copass, Mickey S Eisenberg, Tom D Rea, Pat Klotz, Jonathan Larsen, Mike Helbock, Arthur Slutsky, Laurie J Morrison, Paul Dorian, Alan Craig, Andrew Baker, James Hutchison, Ori Rotstein, P Richard Verbeek, Russell MacDonald, Sandra Black, Sandro Rizoli, Sheldon Cheskes, Steven Brooks, Cathy Zhan, Merita Simitciu, Morgan Slater, Precilla D'Souza, Suzanne Chung, Tyrone Perreira, Bruce Cameron, David Austin, Grant Burse, Jamie Frank, Jennifer Shield, John Locke, Kyle Grant, Michelle Welsford, Philip Moran, Rob Burgess, Roy Suthons, Russell MacDonald, Steve Darling, Steve Dewar, Steve Tyukodi, Tim Dodd, Verena Jones, Andrew Arcand, Chris O'Connor, Eric Letovsky, Hy Dwosh, Julie Spence, Karen Choong, Niv Sne, Steven Segal, Boris Bojilov, Caitlin Wenkstern, Jennifer Watson, Leslie Cicero, Marlene Santos, Rose Geiteiro, Rosemarie Farrell, Sherry Rodgerson, Yangmei Li, Myron Weisfeldt, David B Hoyt, John B Holcomb, George Sopko, Debra Egan, David Lathrop, Alice Mascette, Patrice Desvigne Nickens, Colin Wu, Phyllis Mitchell, Tracey Hoke, Gerald van Belle, Scott Emerson, Graham Nichol, Susanne May, Eileen Bulger, Judy Powell, Berit Bardarson, Amy Gest, Andrea Cook, Eric Meier, Luis Crouch, Sean Devlin, Danielle Schroeder, Colleen Sitlani, Kent Koprowicz, Siobhan Everson-Stewart, Liz Thomas, Erin Gabriel, Ken Wu, Rob Schmicker, Robert B Ledingham, Richard Moore, Ben Bergsten-Buret, Chi Shen, Winnie Kirdpoo, Jackie Berhorst, Anna Leonen, Yang Wang, Al Hallstrom,
Collapse