Clinical outcomes of hemispherectomy for epilepsy in childhood and adolescence

Hemispherectomy has been performed in the treatment of epilepsy in association with hemiplegia for over 50 years. However, the optimal timing of surgery with respect to age at presentation and the influence of underlying pathology on outcome is only slowly emerging. This study reports on the clinical course and outcomes of 33 children who underwent hemispherectomy at Great Ormond Street Hospital, London, between 1991 and 1997. Age at surgery was 0.33-17 years (median 4.25) with 1-8 years follow-up (median 3.4). The underlying pathology was developmental in 16 (10 hemimegalencephaly, two polymicrogyria, two focal cortical dysplasia, one diffuse cortical dysplasia and one microdysgenesis), acquired in 11 (six middle cerebral artery infarct, three post encephalitis/trauma, and one each of hemiconvulsion-hemiplegia epilepsy and perinatal ischaemic insult) and progressive in six children (four Rasmussen encephalitis, two Sturge-Weber syndrome). At follow-up, 52% were seizure free, 9% experienced rare seizures, 30% showed >75% reduction in seizures and 9% showed <75% seizure reduction or no improvement. Seizure freedom was highest in those with acquired pathology (82%), followed by those with progressive pathology (50%) and those with developmental pathology (31%). However, seizure freedom, rare seizures or >75% reduction in seizures occurred in 100% of those with progressive pathology, 91% of those with acquired and 88% of those with developmental pathology, indicating a worthwhile seizure outcome in all groups. Hemiplegia remained unchanged following surgery in 22 out of 33 children, improved in five and was worse in six. No significant cognitive deterioration or loss of language occurred, and four children showed significant cognitive improvement. Behavioural improvement was reported in 92% of those who had behaviour problems pre-operatively.

Hemispherectomy for intractable unihemispheric epilepsy Etiology vs outcome

BACKGROUND

Surgical removal of one hemisphere has been performed for several decades to treat intractable unihemispheric epilepsy. A prior case series focused on the outcomes after 58 surgeries at Johns Hopkins Hospital in 1997. This series, and an additional 53 cases, were reviewed to bring the outcomes up to date.

METHODS

Charts of the 111 patients undergoing hemidecortications at the Pediatric Epilepsy Center from 1975 to 2001 were reviewed and families were contacted. Three children died in the immediate perioperative period and three were lost to follow-up immediately after surgery. Follow-up ranged from 3 months to 22 years.

RESULTS

Two children died several years later due to intractable seizures. Overall, 65% are seizure-free, 21% have occasional, non-handicapping seizures, and 14% have troublesome seizures. Eighty percent are on one anticonvulsant or none and 89% are able to walk without assistance. Etiology strongly predicted seizure outcome. Patients with migrational disorders are less likely to be seizure-free than all other etiologies (predominantly Rasmussen and congenital vascular injuries) combined (51% vs 71%, p = 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Hemidecortication continues to be a beneficial procedure in reducing seizure frequency in cases of unilateral cortical epilepsy. Fewer children with migrational disorders are seizure-free.

The Cognitive Outcome of Hemispherectomy in 71 Children

PURPOSE

Long-term neuropsychological outcome was studied in 71 patients who underwent hemispherectomy for severe and intractable seizures at The Johns Hopkins Hospital between 1968 and 1997 and who agreed to participate. Seizures were due to cortical dysplasias (n = 27), Rasmussen syndrome (n = 37), or vascular malformations or strokes (n = 7). Both presurgical and follow-up results are available and reported for 53 patients.

METHODS

Patients and caretakers were interviewed, and patients were administered standard measures of intelligence, receptive and expressive language, visual-motor skills, adaptive/developmental functioning, and behavior.

RESULTS

Mean age at surgery was 7.2 years. At follow-up, on average 5.4 years after surgery, 65% are seizure free, 49% are medication free, and, of those responding, none rated quality of life as worse than before surgery. Mean IQ was in the 70s for Rasmussen and vascular patients and in the 30s for cortical dysplasia patients. Language and visual-motor skills were consistent with IQ. For Rasmussen patients only, language was significantly more impaired for left than for right hemispherectomy, both before surgery and at follow-up. Adaptive skills were mildly impaired, with greatest impairment in the physical domain. Cognitive measures typically changed little between surgery and follow-up, with IQ change <15 points for 34 of 53 patients; of the remainder, 11 declined and eight improved. Behavior was free of major problems, but social interactions and activities were limited.

CONCLUSIONS

The most significant predictor of cognitive skills at follow-up was etiology, with dysplasia patients scoring lowest in intelligence and language but not in visual-motor skills. Regardless of etiology, most patients showed only moderate change in cognitive performance at follow-up.

Unconscious vision: new insights into the neuronal correlate of blindsight using diffusion tractography

The existence of several types of unconscious vision, or 'blindsight', has convincingly been demonstrated in numerous studies, and their neuronal correlates have been hypothesized according to the nature of the residual vision observed. We used diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) tractography to demonstrate an association between the presence of 'Type I'- blindsight or 'attention blindsight' and reconstructed superior colliculi (SC) fibre tracts in hemispherectomized subjects, in support of the hypothesis that this subcortical structure plays a pivotal role in this type of blindsight. Before the DTI study, 'Type I' blindsight was identified in two of four hemispherectomized subjects by using a spatial summation effect paradigm, an indirect behavioural method, in which subjects were unaware of a stimulus presented in their blind visual field and were required to respond to an identical stimulus presented simultaneously in their intact field. SC tracts were then reconstructed in six control subjects, the two hemispherectomized subjects with blindsight and the two hemispherectomized subjects without blindsight. Whereas control subjects demonstrated mainly ipsilateral connections to visual association areas, parietal cortex, prefrontal areas and to an area close to the frontal eye fields, hemispherectomized subjects with blindsight showed ipsi- and contralateral connections from the SC to visual association areas, primary visual areas, parietal areas, prefrontal areas and to the posterior part of the internal capsule. In contrast, no projections from the SC on the hemispherectomized side were observed in hemispherectomized subjects without blindsight, in support of a key role of this structure in 'Type-I' or 'attention blindsight'.

Experience with immunomodulatory treatments in Rasmussen's encephalitis

The authors investigated immunomodulatory treatments in 15 patients with Rasmussen encephalitis (RE) (14 with childhood and one with adolescent onset RE). Positive time-limited responses were obtained in 11 patients using variable combinations of corticosteroids, apheresis, and high-dose IV immunoglobulins. Although surgical exclusion of the affected hemisphere is the only treatment that halts disease progression, immunomodulation can be considered when early surgery is not feasible, in late-onset patients with slower disease progression, and in the few cases of bilateral disease.

Contralateral hemimicrencephaly and clinical-pathological correlations in children with hemimegalencephaly

In paediatric epilepsy surgery patients with hemimegalencephaly (HME; n = 23), this study compared clinical, neuroimaging and pathologic features to discern potential mechanisms for suboptimal post-hemispherectomy developmental outcomes and structural pathogenesis. MRI measured affected and non-affected cerebral hemisphere volumes for HME and non-HME cases, including monozygotic twins where one sibling had HME. Staining against neuronal nuclei (NeuN) determined grey and white matter cell densities and sizes in HME and autopsy cases, including the non-affected side of a HME surgical/autopsy case. By MRI, the affected hemisphere was larger and the non-affected side smaller in HME compared with non-HME children. The affected HME side showed enlarged abnormal deep grey and white matter structures and/or T2-weighted hypointensity in the subcortical white matter in 75% of cases, suggestive of excessive pre-natal neurogenesis and heterotopias. Histopathological examination of the affected HME side revealed immature-appearing neurons in 70%, polymicrogyria (PMG) in 61% and balloon cells in 45% of cases. Compared with autopsy cases, in HME children NeuN cell densities on the affected side were increased in the molecular layer and upper cortex (+244 to +18%), decreased in lower cortical layers (-35%) and increased in the white matter (+139 to +149%). Deep grey matter MRI abnormalities and/or T2-weighted white matter hypointensity correlated with the presence of immature-appearing neurons and PMG on histopathology, decreased NeuN cell densities in lower cortical layers and a positive history of infantile spasms. Post-surgery seizure control was associated with decreased NeuN densities in the molecular layer. In young children with HME and epilepsy, these findings indicate that there are bilateral cerebral hemispheric abnormalities and contralateral hemimicrencephaly is a likely explanation for poorer post-surgery seizure control and cognitive outcomes. In addition, our findings support the hypothesis that HME pathogenesis probably involves somatic mutations that affect each developing cerebral hemisphere differently with more neurons than expected on the HME side.

Current management and surgical outcomes of medically intractable epilepsy

Epilepsy is one of the most common neurologic disorders in the world. While anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs) are the mainstay of treatment in most cases, as many as one-third of patients will have a refractory form of disease indicating the need for a neurosurgical evaluation. Ever since the first half of the twentieth century, surgery has been a major treatment option for epilepsy, but the last 10-15 years in particular has seen several major advances. As shown in relatively recent studies, resection is more effective for medically intractable epilepsy (MIE) than AED treatment alone, which is why most clinicians now endorse a neurosurgical consultation after approximately two failed regimens of AEDs, ultimately leading to decreased healthcare costs and increased quality of life. Temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) is the most common form of MIE and comprises about 80% of epilepsy surgeries with the majority of patients gaining complete seizure-freedom. As the number of procedures and different approaches continues to grow, temporal lobectomy remains consistently focused on resection of mesial structures such as the amygdala, hippocampus, and parahippocampal gyrus while preserving as much of the neocortex as possible resulting in optimum seizure control with minimal neurological deficits. MIE originating outside the temporal lobe is also effectively treated with resection. Though not as successful as TLE surgery because of their frequent proximity to eloquent brain structures and more diffuse pathology, epileptogenic foci located extratemporally also benefit from resection. Favorable seizure outcome in each of these procedures has heavily relied on pre-operative imaging, especially since the massive surge in MRI technology just over 20 years ago. However, in the absence of visible lesions on MRI, recent improvements in secondary imaging modalities such as fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission computed tomography (FDG-PET) and single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) have lead to progressively better long-term seizure outcomes by increasing the neurosurgeon's visualization of supposed non-lesional foci. Additionally, being historically viewed as a drastic surgical intervention for MIE, hemispherectomy has been extensively used quite successfully for diffuse epilepsies often found in pediatric patients. Although total anatomic hemispherectomy is not utilized as commonly today, it has given rise to current disconnective techniques such as hemispherotomy. Therefore, severe forms of hemispheric developmental epilepsy can now be surgically treated while substantially decreasing the amount of potential long-term complications resulting from cavitation of the brain following anatomical hemispherectomy. Despite the rapid pace at which we are gaining further knowledge about epilepsy and its surgical treatment, there remains a sizeable underutilization of such procedures. By reviewing the recent literature on resective treatment of MIE, we provide a recent up-date on epilepsy surgery while focusing on historical perspectives, techniques, prognostic indicators, outcomes, and complications associated with several different types of procedures.

Resective surgery to treat refractory status epilepticus in children with focal epileptogenesis

Prolonged high-dose suppressive therapy (HDST) is a mainstay in the management of refractory status epilepticus (RSE), albeit with high morbidity and mortality. The authors studied 10 patients who were carefully selected for epilepsy surgery after failing prolonged (>2 weeks) HDST. Status epilepticus was stopped acutely in all of them with no mortality and no substantial morbidity. At follow-up (median 7 months), 7 (70%) of 10 patients were seizure free, and 3 (30%) of 10 had significant improvement in their epilepsy.

Posterior quadrantic dysplasia or hemi-hemimegalencephaly: A characteristic brain malformation

INTRODUCTION

Posterior quadrantic dysplasia (PQD), a developmental malformation involving the temporal, parietal, and occipital lobes of one cerebral hemisphere, leads to intractable epilepsy.

OBJECTIVE

To characterize the clinical features of 19 patients with PQD and analyze the postsurgical outcome of those who underwent resection of dysplastic tissue.

METHODS

The extent and nature of the malformation were primarily assessed with high-resolution brain imaging. Fourteen patients underwent complete or partial temporoparieto-occipital resection or temporal resection associated with parieto-occipital disconnection. Postoperative follow-up period ranged from 8 months to 7 years. The authors used the Engel classification for postoperative outcome.

RESULTS

All patients were sporadic. Clinical features included infantile spasms, partial seizures, mental retardation, mild hemiparesis, and visual field defects. Neuroimaging localized the malformation within the posterior cerebral quadrant contralateral to the neurologic deficit and demonstrated hemi-hemimegalencephaly in 14 of 19 patients and multilobar cortical dysplasia in 5 of 19 patients. The authors observed class I outcome in six patients. Two patients had class II and four patients had class III outcome. Class IV outcome was seen in two patients. After surgery, two patients developed mild hemiparesis, and two developed a visual field defect.

CONCLUSIONS

Widespread cortical dysplasia is more frequent in the posterior quadrant. In our series, posterior quadrantic dysplasia represents either hemi-hemimegalencephaly or multilobar cortical dysplasia. Individuals with posterior quadrantic dysplasia share a spectrum of clinical features. The intractable epilepsy in these patients may be alleviated by a large quadrantic temporoparieto-occipital resection.

Treatment of encephalotrigeminal angiomatosis (Sturge-Weber disease) by hemispherectomy

Images

Visual functions without the occipital lobe or after cerebral hemispherectomy in infancy

This paper investigates whether and to what extent vision with awareness is still possible in the whole visual field after loss of the occipital lobe of one or both cerebral hemispheres or after hemispherectomy in childhood. The visual functions of four children who suffered from unilateral or bilateral loss of the occipital lobe or who had been hemispherectomized were examined. The results show that even after unilateral loss of the striate and prestriate cortex the extent of the visual field may still be in the normal range. The residual visual functions may be mediated by intact extrastriate areas such as V5 and LO of the damaged cerebral hemisphere. It is also shown that even after complete hemispherectomy in early life the visual field may have a normal extent and that conscious visual perception in the whole visual field may be preserved. In hemispherectomized children, the remaining cerebral hemisphere or neural structures in the midbrain, including the superior colliculi and the praetectum, may be able to mediate these visual functions.

Neural Substrates of Blindsight After Hemispherectomy

Blindsight is a visual phenomenon whereby hemianopic patients are able to process visual information in their blind visual field without awareness. Previous research demonstrating the existence of blindsight in hemianopic patients has been criticized for the nature of the paradigms used, for the presence of methodological artifacts, and for the possibility that spared islands of visual cortex may have sustained the phenomenon because the patients generally had small circumscribed lesions. To respond to these criticisms, the authors have been investigating for several years now residual visual abilities in the blind field of hemispherectomized patients in whom a whole cerebral hemisphere has been removed or disconnected from the rest of the brain. These patients have offered a unique opportunity to establish the existence of blindsight and to investigate its underlying neuronal mechanisms because in these cases, spared islands of visual cortex cannot be evoked to explain the presence of visual abilities in the blind field. In addition, the authors have been using precise behavioral paradigms, strict control for potential methodological artifacts such as light scatter, fixation, criterion effects, and macular sparing, and they have utilized new neuroimaging techniques such as diffusion tensor imaging tractography to enhance their understanding of the phenomenon. The following article is a review of their research on the involvement of the superior colliculi in blindsight in hemispherectomized patients. NEUROSCIENTIST 13(5):506—518, 2007.

Extratemporal resection for childhood epilepsy

There have been relatively few studies reporting the safety, efficacy, and outcome in children undergoing extratemporal resection for epilepsy. We reviewed the pediatric cases of extratemporal resection for intractable epilepsy performed by the Comprehensive Epilepsy Program at the University of Alberta Hospitals between 1988-1998. Thirty-five patients were studied, 14 male and 21 female. The age at operation ranged from 6 months to 16 years. The operations included frontal excisions (12), parietal (8), occipital (4), hemispherectomies or multilobar resections (10), and one removal of a hypothalamic hamartoma. The pathology at surgery included patients with focal cortical dysplasia (8), brain tumors (6), neurocutaneous syndrome (7), Rasmussen's encephalitis (2), porencephalic cysts (4), hypothalamic hamartoma (1), and nonspecific gliosis (6). Twenty-four of 35 patients (68.5%) had an Engel Class I outcome after surgery and an additional six patients (11%) had a significant decrease in seizure frequency (Engel Class III). Complications were observed in two patients (5%) and there were no deaths. Extratemporal resection is a safe and effective treatment for children with intractable epilepsy. Overall, 68% of patients were seizure-free after surgery, although outcome may be dependent on site and pathology. A wide range of developmental pathology was observed including focal cortical dysplasia, brain tumors, and lesions with neurocutaneous syndromes. Many families reported improvement in behavior and psychosocial function after surgery.

Hemispheric surgery for refractory epilepsy: a systematic review and meta-analysis with emphasis on seizure predictors and outcomes

OBJECTIVE

Conflicting conclusions have been reported regarding several factors that may predict seizure outcomes after hemispheric surgery for refractory epilepsy. The goal of this study was to identify the possible predictors of seizure outcome by pooling the rates of postoperative seizure freedom found in the published literature.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search of PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Library identified English-language articles published since 1970 that describe seizure outcomes in patients who underwent hemispheric surgery for refractory epilepsy. Two reviewers independently assessed article eligibility and extracted the data. The authors pooled rates of seizure freedom from papers included in the study. Eight potential prognostic variables were identified and dichotomized for analyses. The authors also compared continuous variables within seizure-free and seizure-recurrent groups. Random- or fixed-effects models were used in the analyses depending on the presence or absence of heterogeneity.

RESULTS

The pooled seizure-free rate among the 1528 patients (from 56 studies) who underwent hemispheric surgery was 73%. Patients with an epilepsy etiology of developmental disorders, generalized seizures, nonlateralization on electroencephalography, and contralateral MRI abnormalities had reduced odds of being seizure-free after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemispheric surgery is an effective therapeutic modality for medically intractable epilepsy. This meta-analysis provides useful evidence-based information for the selection of candidates for hemispheric surgery, presurgical counseling, and explanation of seizure outcomes.

Language after hemispherectomy in childhood: contributions from memory and intelligence

After hemispherectomy (removal or disconnection of an entire cerebral hemisphere) in childhood for treatment of intractable epilepsy, gross speech and language functions are often rescued. Whether more complex functions, such as syntactic processing, are selectively impaired, remains controversial. Here we present a cross-sectional study of expressive and receptive language functions in 30 patients who have undergone hemispherectomy (17 left, 13 right). The patients had developed epilepsy-induced pathology either during the pre/perinatal period (19 cases), or after a period of normal development (11 cases; onset range=20 months to 10 years). The patients were assessed at least 1 year post surgery on tests of receptive vocabulary, expressive and receptive grammar, instruction comprehension, and semantic association. Measures of verbal and nonverbal intelligence, short-term verbal memory, and working memory were also obtained. Principal component analysis revealed that two core components could be extracted from the five language measures, one reflecting receptive vocabulary abilities, and the other a composite of the other four measures. Regression analyses revealed that the best predictor of the composite language score was the short-term verbal memory score with some contribution from verbal intelligence, while the only predictor of receptive vocabulary was verbal intelligence. The results suggest that during childhood the lone left and right hemispheres have a similar potential for developing an adequate level of receptive vocabulary. However, congenital pathology affecting either hemisphere, and postnatal damage to the left hemisphere result in substantial language deficits that are reflected also in limitations in short-term verbal memory, and, to a lesser extent, in verbal intelligence.

Seizure outcome, functional outcome, and quality of life after hemispherectomy in adults

BACKGROUND

Functional hemispherectomy is a well-established method in childhood epilepsy surgery with only a few reports on its application in adults.

METHODS

We report on 27 patients (median age 30 years, range 19-55) with a follow-up of more than 1 year (median 124 months, range 13-234). Etiology was developmental in two (one schizencephaly, one hemimegalencephaly), acquired in 21 (two hemiatrophy, 17 porencephaly, two postencephalitic), and progressive in four (Rasmussen's encephalitis).

RESULTS

At last available follow-up, 22 patients were seizure free (81 % ILAE class 1), one had auras (4 % ILAE class 2), one had no more than three seizures per year (4 % ILAE class 3). Thirty-seven percent were without antiepileptic drugs. Seventeen patients of 20 responding patients stated improved quality of life after surgery, one patient reported deterioration, and two patients reported no difference. Additionally, a self-rated postoperative functional status and changes compared to the pre-operative status was assessed. Six patients improved in gait, ten remained unchanged, and four deteriorated. Three patients improved in speech, none deteriorated. Hand function got worse five times, and in 15 cases remained unchanged. There was no mortality, one bone flap infection, and one subdural hematoma. Hydrocephalus was seen in three cases (12 %).

CONCLUSIONS

It is possible to achieve good seizure outcome results despite long-standing epilepsy across a variety of etiologies, comparable to epilepsy surgery in pediatric patients. Adult patients do not have to expect more problems with new deficits, appear to cope quite well, and mostly profit from surgery in several quality of life domains.

Two-year follow-up of intelligence after pediatric epilepsy surgery

Research findings concerning cognitive effects of pediatric epilepsy surgery form an important basis for decisions about surgery. However, most follow-up studies have been of limited duration. In this study, a 2-year follow-up of intelligence was undertaken. Risk factors were analyzed. Included were 38 patients aged 3 to 17 years. Surgery was left in 19 patients and right in 19 patients. Types of surgery included temporal lobe resection (n = 23), extratemporal or multilobar resection (n = 8), and hemispherectomy (n = 7). The Wechsler Scales of Intelligence were administered presurgically, 6 months postsurgically, and 2 years postsurgically. No significant change in verbal or performance intelligence quotient (IQ) was demonstrated on a group level. Lateralization, type of surgery, age at surgery, sex, and presurgical IQ did not affect outcome. Across assessments, IQ scores of left-hemisphere patients were lower than those of right-hemisphere patients. Scores of patients in the hemispherectomy group were lower than those of the extratemporal or multilobar resection group, which were lower than the temporal lobe resection group. Scores improved significantly in six patients and deteriorated in seven. In conclusion, epilepsy surgery in children and adolescents does not, in general, have a significant impact on cognitive development in a 2-year perspective. In individual patients, poor seizure control and extensive surgery for Rasmussen's encephalitis were related to a deterioration of IQ.

Corpus callosotomy via laser interstitial thermal therapy: a case series

Corpus callosotomy has been used as a form of surgical palliation for patients suffering from medically refractory generalized seizures, including drop attacks. Callosotomy has traditionally been described as involving a craniotomy with microdissection. MR-guided laser interstitial thermal therapy (MRg-LITT) has recently been used as a minimally invasive method for performing surgical ablation of epileptogenic foci and corpus callosotomy. The authors present 3 cases in which MRg-LITT was used to perform a corpus callosotomy as part of a staged surgical procedure for a patient with multiple seizure types and in instances when further ablation of residual corpus callosum is necessary after a prior open surgical procedure. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first case series of corpus callosotomy performed using the MRg-LITT system with a 3.3-year average follow-up. Although MRg-LITT is not expected to replace the traditional corpus callosotomy in all cases, it is a safe, effective, and durable alternative to the traditional open corpus callosotomy, particularly in the setting of a prior craniotomy.