A novel reconstructive technique after endoscopic expanded endonasal approaches: vascular pedicle nasoseptal flap

BACKGROUND

In patients with large dural defects of the anterior and ventral skull base after endonasal skull base surgery, there is a significant risk of a postoperative cerebrospinal fluid leak after reconstruction. Reconstruction with vascularized tissue is desirable to facilitate rapid healing, especially in irradiated patients.

METHODS

We developed a neurovascular pedicled flap of the nasal septum mucoperiosteum and mucoperichondrium based on the nasoseptal artery, a branch of the posterior septal artery (Hadad-Bassagasteguy flap [HBF]). A retrospective review of patients undergoing endonasal skull base surgery at the University of Rosario, Argentina, and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center was performed to identify patients who were reconstructed with a vascularized septal mucosal flap.

RESULTS

Forty-three patients undergoing endonasal cranial base surgery were repaired with the septal mucosal flap. Two patients with postoperative cerebrospinal fluid leaks (5%) were successfully treated with focal fat grafts. We encountered no infectious or wound complications in this series of patients. One patient experienced a posterior nose bleed from the posterior nasal artery. This was controlled with electrocautery and the flap blood supply was preserved.

CONCLUSION

The HBF is a versatile and reliable reconstructive technique for defects of the anterior, middle, clival, and parasellar skull base. Its use has resulted in a sharp decrease in the incidence of postoperative cerebrospinal fluid leaks after endonasal skull base surgery and is recommended for the reconstruction of large dural defects and when postoperative radiation therapy is anticipated.

Septal extension grafts: a method of controlling tip projection shape

Failure to control the projection, shape, and rotation of the nasal tip is a common occurrence among patients with weak lower lateral cartilages. These patients' noses are characterized by a weak midvault, a plunging tip with "Polly beak," and drawn-up alae. The purpose of our study was to identify methods for controlling the position and shape of the nasal tip in these high-risk patients. Twenty patients at risk of losing nasal tip projection were retrospectively identified, and measurements made from their preoperative and postoperative photographs were compared. Loss of tip projection occurred in all but one patient whose columella strut was fixed to the caudal septum. Prompted by these failures, we studied the relationship between the dorsum and tip in cadaveric specimens with and without a supratip break. From our observations, a structural extension of the septum-an anterior septal extension graft-was developed to predictably control this relationship. The clinical application of septal extension grafts in open rhinoplasty was subsequently evaluated in 20 patients who were deemed to be at risk of losing tip projection. Postoperative photographic analysis showed nasal tip projection to be maintained or increased in all but one patient with the use of septal extension grafts. A stable caudal septum is essential to the success of the technique.

Improving the design of the pedicled nasoseptal flap for skull base reconstruction: a radioanatomic study

BACKGROUND

Reconstruction of the skull base after an expanded endonasal approach (EEA) is critical to achieve a good outcome. A novel technique based on the use of a pedicled nasoseptal flap has proven to be a reliable and versatile reconstructive option for extensive defects of the skull base. Data regarding the potential dimensions of a nasoseptal flap are lacking in the literature. This pilot study was developed to help optimize the design of the nasoseptal flap and to ensure that when harvesting the flap, its width and length are adequate to reconstruct the defects that are created by various EEAs.

METHODS

We analyzed the computed tomographic (CT) scans of four patients who underwent EEAs for skull base lesions. Sagittal and coronal CT reconstructions were generated from axial images. The measurements were divided into skull base measurements, flap dimensions required to cover skull base defects resulting from various EEAs, and potential maximal dimensions of the nasoseptal flap. Measurements were studied for three different EEAs: sellar/transplanar, transclival, and transcribiform/anterior skull base. We measured the potential defects for each of these EEAs and the nasoseptal flap dimensions that would be required to reconstruct them. We estimated all dimensions based on the most extensive defect that could result with each EEA. We then compared these with various modifications of the nasoseptal flap.

RESULTS

Two male and two female patients were studied. Twenty-seven measurements were taken to compare the different skull base defects and nasoseptal flaps.

CONCLUSIONS

The length of the nasal septum comprises sufficient mucoperichondrium and mucoperiosteum to allow the harvesting of a nasoseptal flap that could cover any defect resulting from an anterior skull base, a transsellar/transplanar, or a transclival EEA. Similarly, the height of the nasal septum has the potential to yield a nasoseptal flap with a width that is adequate to cover the laterolateral aspect of any defect of the anterior skull base and clivus. Skull base defects resulting from combined EEAs, such as those that would create a defect that comprises the skull base from sella turcica to frontal sinus, are beyond the potential dimensions of a single nasoseptal flap. This and other defects resulting from a combination of EEAs require other strategies, such as the use of bilateral nasoseptal flaps, or the use of other reconstructive options.

The use of cartilage grafts in primary aesthetic rhinoplasty

Our experience with the use of cartilage grafts in 430 primary rhinoplasties is presented. We find grafts indicated when operating on small noses with thick skin to increase and define the dorsum, to add projection and angularity to the tip, to project the columella, and to correct the acute nasolabial angle. The procedure is technically simple and relatively free of complications. Long-term evaluations show no absorption of the grafts and preservation of the desired shape.

Correction of the pinched nasal tip with alar spreader grafts

A pinched nasal tip is caused by collapsed alar rims secondary to weak lateral crura. The resulting deformity can be corrected with alar spreader grafts--autogenous grafts of septal or auricular cartilage that are inserted between and deep to the remaining lateral crura to force them apart, propping up the caved-in segment. We describe the surgical technique, indications, and variations in design of alar spreader grafts and present representative results from our series of 38 patients.

A tissue-engineering model for the manufacture of auricular-shaped cartilage implants

The established surgical methods of external ear reconstruction using autogenous tissue represent the current state of the art. Because of the limited possibilities for shaping conventional harvested autogenous rib cartilage, the cosmetic results of auricular reconstruction are frequently unsatisfactory. Tissue engineering could represent an alternative technique for obtaining a precisely shaped cartilage implant that avoids donor site morbidity and unsatisfactory cosmetic results. In this study, the reliability and quality of a tissue-engineering model for the manufacture of auricular-shaped human cartilage implants was investigated, focusing on the feasibility of the manufacturing process and the in vivo and in vitro maturation of an extracellular cartilage-like matrix. Implants were molded within an auricular-shaped silicone cylinder, and human nasal septal chondrocytes crosslinked by human fibrin within bioresorbable PGLA-PLLA polymer scaffolds were used. After an in vitro incubation of up to 6 weeks, defined fragments of the prefabricated auricular-shaped construct were implanted subcutaneously on the backs of nude mice for at least 6 to 12 weeks ( n=7). Scaffolds without cell loading served as controls. Macroscopic and histochemical examination after 3 and 6 weeks in vitro showed a solid compound of homogenously distributed chondrocytes within the polymer scaffold, leading only to a limited pericellular matrix formation. Analysis after 6 and 12 weeks of in vivo maturation demonstrated a solid tissue compound and neocartilage formation with the presence of cartilage-specific matrix components. Implants obtained shape and size during the entire period of implantation. The model of cartilage implant manufacturing presented here meets all biocompatible requirements for in vitro prefabrication and in vivo maturation of autogenous, individually shaped cartilage transplants.

Alloplastic materials in rhinoplasty

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review examines implant materials currently used in rhinoplasty. In revision cases, the most desirable autogenous grafts from the septum are often unavailable in adequate quantities. The 'ideal' implant has strict requirements concerning biocompatibility, plasticity, stability of form, resistance to infection, and removability.

RECENT FINDINGS

Silicone implants continue to be used in spite of frequent reports of rejection. In spite of its described absorption, conserved cartilage can help in preserving profiles. Increasingly, good results are being reported with porous polyethylene, although Proplast is sometimes used in its place. Despite the fact that AlloDerm is partially absorbed, it can still be useful. GoreTex is effective for smaller defects. Mersilene mesh is not absorbed and retains its stability of shape. 'Turkish Delight' (diced cartilage with a wrapping) seems to be absorbed when the wrapping is made of Surgicel, but a wrapping of autogenous fascia provides lasting results.

SUMMARY

Several alloplastic materials do have a place in nasal surgery. Provided that the correct techniques are employed, side effects from their use are no greater than the complications resulting from the use of autogenous costal cartilage, with the intervention necessary for its harvesting.

Crushed cartilage grafts over alar dome reduction in open rhinoplasty

Primary and secondary nasal tip deformities can be repaired more easily with an open technique rather than with the traditional closed methods that have been used for the over-projecting tip. Division of the alar domes with a side-to-side repair followed by the onlay of a single crushed cartilage graft to prevent postoperative cartilaginous deformities has been shown to be a reliable maneuver in both primary and secondary rhinoplasties.

Laryngotracheal reconstruction with composite nasal septal cartilage grafts

The composite nasal septal graft has been used successfully by us to reconstruct patients with high tracheal and laryngotracheal stenosis. We have treated ten patients and have been able to decannulate seven of these patients. When these ten cases are added to the six original cases presented in an earlier report (1981), certain conclusions can be drawn. The success or failure of these procedures, which is judged by the ability to decannulate the patient, appears to be related to the extent of the initial injury. We discuss the indications for the composite nasal septal graft and the use of additional treatment, including stents, steroid injections, dilatations, and flaps. In conclusion, the addition of these ten cases to the original six cases of composite nasal septal grafts now provides the opportunity to review indications and contraindications for the use of this graft in the management of advanced laryngotracheal stenosis.

Use of vomer flap in palatoplasty: revisited

OBJECTIVE

To present a new comprehensive and simple classification of vomerine flaps for palatoplasty.

DESIGN

This classification has been developed on the basis of a literature search and our clinical experience. The vomerine flaps have been classified into three types, each with A and B subtypes.

PATIENTS, PARTICIPANTS

Vomerine tissue has been used in more than 1000 palatoplasties over the past 17 years. The analysis includes 678 cleft palate patients for whom detailed records were available. Type II-A vomerine flaps were used most commonly in unilateral cleft palate patients, whereas Type II-B1 flaps were used in bilateral cleft palate patients.

RESULTS

The overall fistula rate at the hard and soft palate junction was 2.95%. Although facial growth pattern was not recorded, obvious midface growth abnormalities were not observed in any of these patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Vomerine tissue is available in the vicinity of the palatal defect. Raising of the vomerine flap is simple and safe. If properly designed, it can be used judiciously for closure of the nasal and oral defects in the cleft palate. We have used these flaps only to augment the nasal mucosal defect. This comprehensive classification will be useful in understanding, designing, and implementing these small, but very important, flaps.

Use of cartilaginous autografts in nasal surgery: 8 years of experience

Although the cartilaginous autografts are one of the tissues more utilized in nasal surgery, a comparative study does not exist to determine which are better options and their precise indications. It is for this reason that a histopathologic analysis was carried out comparing the characteristics and properties of the four principal cartilages that are utilized in aesthetic functional surgery of the nose. Considering these particularities, the precise indications for the employment of the different cartilage as nasal autografts were determined. Of 1120 aesthetic functional rhinoplasties during a period of 8 years, 930 (83 percent) required cartilaginous autografts, 86 percent were primary, 11 percent were secondary, and 3 percent had two or more surgeries. Eighty-three percent of the grafts used were from nasal septum, 12 percent from the auricle, 3 percent from alar cartilages, and 2 percent from the rib. The anatomic sites in which they were employed consisted of the following: 64 percent between the medial crura, 28 percent as in Sheen's graft, 19 percent in the nasal dorsum, 8 percent as spreader grafts, 8 percent as in Peck's graft, and 3 percent in the rim to improve alar collapse. We followed at all times the previous indications for obtaining and placing the nasal autografts. Eighty-four percent of the patients were totally satisfied and only 8 percent required a second surgical procedure to achieve the results desired. Based on this study, it is recommended to utilize the cartilaginous autografts in nasal surgery considering three parameters: the physical and histologic characteristics of each cartilage, the anatomic site in which they are to be placed, and the effect desired with their application.

The potency of culture-expanded nasal septum chondrocytes for tissue engineering of cartilage

Tissue engineering techniques to create extra autologous cartilage for reconstructive surgery receive more and more scientific and industrial attention. The objective of this experimental study was to assess the use of in vitro multiplied chondrocytes of the nasal septum for generation of cartilage grafts using tissue engineering techniques. Cells isolated from a biopsy of septal cartilage of rabbits and humans were expanded in culture to get a sufficient number of cells to engineer a cartilage graft. The drawback of the expansion procedure is that the cells lose their cartilaginous phenotype (dedifferentiation). We studied a method to reverse the dedifferentiation of expanded cells to stimulate them to produce cartilage matrix of good quality. Rabbit chondrocytes showed reversion of dedifferentiation (redifferentiation) when fetal calf serum was replaced by the growth factors IGF1 and TGFbeta2. This was expressed by increased glycosaminoglycan synthesis and increased numbers of collagen type II-producing cells. The redifferentiation capacity of septal cartilage cells of young rabbits was higher than that of adult rabbits. In human chondrocytes from the nasal septum redifferentiation could also be induced by replacement of serum with IGF1 and TGFbeta2. This method, however, was less efficient than in rabbits. Chondrocytes of older patients (>40 years old) were no longer sensitive to the growth factor treatment. In conclusion, our study demonstrates a method to regain cartilage phenotype in multiplied cells of nasal septum cartilage needed for tissue engineering of new cartilage. These results are promising for this technique to generate cartilage grafts for facial plastic surgery of the nasal septum.

Repair of orbital blow-out fractures with nasoseptal cartilage

The goals of reconstruction in orbital blow-out fractures are to restore floor continuity, provide support of orbital contents, and prevent fibrosis of soft tissues. Although ease of use has popularized alloplasts, autogenous material provides greater biocompatibility and results in low rates of infection, extrusion, and migration. Nasoseptal cartilage is an easily accessible, abundant, autogenous source that provides support to the orbital floor and minimal donor site morbidity. Thirteen patients who presented with orbital blow-out fractures underwent reconstruction with nasoseptal cartilage. Follow-up at 3 months to 4 years shows one patient with persistent manifest enophthalmos requiring further augmentation. There were no recipient or donor site complications. Nasoseptal cartilage is an underutilized and superior material for reconstruction of orbital blow-out fractures.

Bone chips and diced cartilage: an anatomically adopted graft for the nasal dorsum

Since 1996, cranial bone chips or septal bone chips harvested during septal deviation surgery and small chips of ear or septal cartilage have been used in 67 patients for dorsal nasal augmentation or for smoothing dorsal nasal irregularities. In this study, 59 overresections of ostecartilaginous nose structures during previous aesthetic nose surgeries and 8 primary rhinoplasties occasioned the use of bone or cartilage grafts. For 57 patients both bone and ear cartilage grafts were used for the reconstruction. Bone grafts were used for seven cases and cartilage grafts for three cases. The results from 7 years, of experience with this method of nasal dorsum reconstruction were satisfactory and durable. The most important advantage of this method is that the bony side of the nose is reconstructed with bone and the cartilage side with cartilage. Another advantage is that the bone chips are incorporated with both nasal bones, building a strong dorsal nasal bony mono-black. This technique also is useful for augmenting mild saddle nose deformity and dorsal nasal projection deficiency on the bony part, cartilage part, or both parts.

The value of spreader grafts in rhinoplasty: a critical review

The value of spreader grafts in rhinoplasty cannot be underestimated. Various studies have demonstrated that they play a valuable role in the restoration of nasal dorsum aesthetics, provide support for the nasal valve and maintain the straightened position of the corrected deviated cartilaginous septal dorsum. However, there is still controversy on the extent of its value in nasal patency. This study reviews the literature and describes the values and limitations of spreader grafts in rhinoplasty and the alternatives to classic spreader grafts.

Repair of laryngeal stenosis with nasal septal grafts

Autogenous nasal septal grafts were utilized in 18 dogs. The availability, method of transfer, placement, take, stability and long-term survival of these grafts are presented. Transfer of septal cartilage or composite grafts of nasal mucosa and cartilage to surgically created defects of cricoid and thyroid cartilage was performed on eight animals. Ten animals had composite grafts three months after stenosing procedures. Results were excellent in all grafts to the cricoid and subglottic areas. Grafts to the thyroid and glottic regions were characterized by severe resorption of cartilage and fibrosis. Composite grafts to the glottic area were successful in improving the airway. Results are documented by microlaryngeal photographs and histologic sections. A literature review accompanies the presentation with emphasis on clinical utilization of composite nasal septal grafts. Twelve previously reported cases of repair by this method for laryngeal and upper tracheal stenosis are discussed. A patient with severe traumatic laryngeal stenosis successfully rehabilitated is added to this list and details the clinical value of these grafts.

Extracorporeal septoplasty combined with open rhinoplasty

Extracorporeal septoplasty is a radical solution for the severely deviated nose. The major problems associated with this procedure are fixation of the septal cartilage graft and dorsal irregularities. Extracorporeal septoplasty was performed in combination with open rhinoplasty in 17 patients with severe nasal deformities. In this technique septum was totally removed through the columellar incision of open rhinoplasty, corrected outside, and replaced as a free "L" shaped cartilage graft. The cartilage graft was fixated to the upper lateral cartilages to restore the natural relations of the anatomical structures. Additional rhinoplastic manipulations were also performed. The follow-up period was up to 18 months. The overall result was successful in all patients. Nasal deviation did not recur and secondary revisions were not needed for any patient during follow-up.

Mechanical properties of septal cartilage homografts

The compressive mechanical properties of untreated and chemically and physically treated nasal septum homografts were determined. Mechanical properties of control, saline-, thimerosal (Merthiolate)- and Alcide-treated specimens were similar. At high strains, the stiffness of treated cartilage ranged from 12.8 to 22.5 MPa and was unaffected by storage time. In comparison, irradiated and freeze-dried nasal septum exhibited stiffnesses of 35 and 37.5 MPa, respectively, after approximately 1 month of storage. These values of stiffness were significantly different from controls at a 0.95 confidence level. On the basis of these results, it was concluded that Alcide and Merthiolate treatment did not alter the compressive mechanical properties of cartilage and that a combination of these treatments may adequately sterilize and preserve nasal septum homografts.

Secondary rhinoplasty of the Asian nose: correction of the contracted nose

The contracted nose is a unique entity that follows primary rhinoplasty in the Asian patient. The proposed reasons for this complication are capsular contraction from a silicone nasal implant, pressure necrosis of the lower lateral cartilage resulting from the nasal implant, and infection after alloplastic implantation. The two principal anatomic constituents that must be addressed at the time of secondary rhinoplasty are the lower lateral cartilages and the skin envelope. The lower lateral cartilages should be derotated, projected, and transfixed with an extended spreader graft. Additional onlay grafting may be required to provide greater nasal tip derotation and projection. A transcolumellar incision situated at the columellar-labial angle permits undermining of the upper lip skin to release tension on the incision. If the nasal tip retraction is severe, then the skin envelope may be insufficient to provide coverage to the new cartilaginous framework. In this case, a paramedian forehead flap is recommended to provide adequate tissue coverage. Correction of alar-columellar disparity should be undertaken with composite grafting only after 6 months have transpired to gauge the ultimate relation between the alae and columella. Infection that arises after correction of the contracted nose can be devastating. It should be treated aggressively, but tailored to the severity of the infection. Wound tension along the columella may predispose to skin necrosis and consequent cartilage exposure, which should be managed in turn with prostaglandin emollients to accelerate wound healing and to prevent infection.

Reconstruction of the nasal cap with a thin septal graft

Following hump resection, dorsal irregularities are common. Patients with thin skin or those whose skin will become thin will develop the stigmata of rhinoplasty due to an open roof, irregular osseous cartilaginous junction, or twisted septum becoming visible. Although other techniques have been described to overcome this problem, they have significant drawbacks. We describe a technique for dorsal camouflage using a thin septal graft. The technique has the advantages of providing dependable camouflage with autogenous tissue without raising the dorsum and without the need for a separate donor site. It involves sanding a 35 x 7 mm shield-shaped dorsal graft to less than 3/4-mm thickness and placing this over the nasal dorsum to simulate the preoperative fused dorsal cap. We have performed this technique in 18 patients followed for 28 months. We utilize this graft in all patients with twisted noses and all thin-skinned individuals. It is not a technique of dorsal augmentation but rather of camouflage.

Macroencapsulation of human cartilage implants: pilot study with polyelectrolyte complex membrane encapsulation

Autogenous cartilage transplantation is a generally accepted method in reconstructive surgery. A promising alternative to this established method could be represented by in vitro engineering of cartilage tissue. In both methods of autogenous transplantation, host response induces reduction of transplant size and transplant instability to an unforeseeable extent. To investigate if polyelectrolyte complex (PEC) membranes were able to avoid host-induced effects on implanted tissues without neglecting the tissue metabolism, human septal cartilage was encapsulated with polyelectrolyte complex membranes and subcutaneously implanted on the back of nude mice. Septal cartilage implants, without encapsulation served as control group. Histochemical and electron microscopic investigations were performed 1, 4, 8 and 16 weeks after implantation. In the case of an intact PEC-membrane no interactions between the host and the implant could be observed. In some implants, the capsule was torn in several areas and signs of chronic inflammation with the cartilage having been affected mildly could be observed. Implanted cartilage protected with PEC-encapsulation showed no signs of degeneration and significantly lower level of after effects of chronic inflammation than implanted cartilage without PEC-encapsulation. Therefore, it could be expected, that PEC membrane encapsulation offers a novel approach to protect cartilage implants from host response after autogenous transplantation.