Myringoplasty: does the size of the perforation matter?

Does the size of a tympanic membrane defect influence the success rate in myringoplasty? Many studies which have suggested that size does not affect results have included only small numbers of patients. After a power analysis to identify the size of groups needed to detect a clinically significant difference between the success rate of small and large perforations, a retrospective study was carried out to answer the question. A retrospective study of 423 myringoplasty-only operations showed that size does influence success; the success rate for small perforations was 74.1% compared with 56.0% for large perforations (P = 0.0003). Size also influences the change in four-frequency air conduction thresholds (small perforations +7.2 dB, large perforations +10.2 dB; t = 2.08, P = 0.039) in successful myringoplasties, a positive value indicating an improvement in hearing. This change is unlikely to be clinically significant. Patients should be made aware of these facts when informed consent is being obtained.

Myringoplasty in children: anatomical and functional results

To assess the results of myringoplasty in children and determine the factors influencing post-operative results a retrospective study of the anatomical and functional results of 41 myringoplasties in children was performed, considering only the cases of uncomplicated perforation that did not require ossiculoplasty or mastoidectomy. The overall success rate was 80.5 per cent after a mean follow-up of 39 months. The mean post-operative air conduction threshold significantly improved in the successful cases with a mean audiological improvement of 11 dB (p<0.05). No post-operative sensorineural hearing loss was observed. There was a significant statistical association between the presence of a dry ear at the time of surgery and good surgical results (p<0.01). Surgical outcome was not affected by the patient's age, the site and size of the perforation, previous adenoidectomy, surgical technique (overlay vs underlay), or the status of the contralateral ear. Our findings suggest that myringoplasty is a valid procedure in the paediatric population that gives good anatomical and functional results. The status of the middle ear (i.e. the presence of a dry ear), significantly improves surgical outcome; and so careful inflammatory changes in the middle-ear mucosa should be evaluated and medical treatment considered before surgery.

Repair of the tympanic membrane with urinary bladder matrix

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

To test urinary bladder matrix (UBM) as a potential treatment for tympanic membrane (TM) healing and regeneration.

STUDY DESIGN

This prospective pilot study was designed to provide both qualitative and semiquantitative assessment of temporal and spatial healing events in the chinchilla model of chronic TM perforations with and without UBM patching.

METHODS

Bilateral myringotomies were performed and repeated as necessary to create subtotal perforations over an 8-week period. Myringoplasty was then performed, with left TMs serving as controls and right TMs receiving UBM patches. TMs were excised at 4 weeks, 8 weeks, and 12 weeks. Fixed tissue samples were characterized for gross morphology, then processed for microscopic evaluation.

RESULTS

Chronic perforations were maintained with one or more repeated myringotomies. Although both control and patched TMs were thicker than native tissue, patched TMs were transparent and uniform in thickness without any inclusions. UBM patches were readily degraded and replaced by newly deposited and organized host tissue that recapitulated the native TM layers.

CONCLUSIONS

UBM scaffolds were an effective biological scaffold for TM closure and tissue remodeling, leading to thicker than normal anatomy but otherwise normal morphology. Future studies are required to determine functional and temporal outcomes as well as alternative patch orientations. The results show particular promise as a superior alternative means of reconstructing not only chronic TM perforations but also dimeric TMs associated with retraction pockets and atelectasis. Laryngoscope, 2009.

Myringoplasty

There is marked diversity in the reported success rates for achieving an intact tympanic membrane following myringoplasty. Controversy exists about the factors thought to influence surgical outcome. Both of these facts have important implications for obtaining informed consent prior to surgery. This study reviews the factors thought to determine the likelihood of achieving complete closure of the tympanic membrane following surgical closure.

Tissue-Engineered Calcium Alginate Patches in the Repair of Chronic Chinchilla Tympanic Membrane Perforations

OBJECTIVE

Chronic tympanic membrane perforations are a common problem in the United States. A high number of these cases results from placement of pressure equalization tubes. These perforations may initially be treated with paper patch techniques and although safe and well tolerated, the procedure demonstrates poor efficacy. The ideal treatment for small perforations should be rapid, minimally invasive, and efficacious. Calcium alginate-based tissue engineered tympanic membrane patches represent an attractive option, but in vivo data are required.

METHODS

A controlled prospective study of tympanic membrane perforation repair using a well-known chinchilla model of chronic tympanic membrane perforation was performed. Calcium alginate-based tympanic membrane patches were created using computer-aided design techniques. A previously described chinchilla model of chronic tympanic membrane perforations was used to create stable perforations ranging from 2 to 5 mm. Ears with chronic perforations were divided into three groups: control (no patch), paper patch, and calcium alginate plugs. At 10 weeks postimplantation, all animals were killed and inspected both grossly and histologically for healing.

RESULTS

In the chinchilla model, the alginate grafts demonstrated significantly improved healing rates over both the untreated control group (spontaneous repair) and the paper patch group; nine of 13 healed in the alginate group versus two of nine healed in the paper patch group (P < .05) versus one of 11 healed in the control group (P < .05).

CONCLUSION

Calcium alginate tympanic membrane perforation patches offer a significant advantage in the repair of chronic perforations over traditional techniques in the chinchilla perforation model and may offer attractive opportunities in the clinical setting.

Bacterial cellulose nanofibrillar patch as a wound healing platform of tympanic membrane perforation

Bacterial cellulose (BC)-based biomaterials on medical device platforms have gained significant interest for tissue-engineered scaffolds or engraftment materials in regenerative medicine. In particular, BC has an ultrafine and highly pure nanofibril network structure and can be used as an efficient wound-healing platform since cell migration into a wound site is strongly meditated by the structural properties of the extracellular matrix. Here, the fabrication of a nanofibrillar patch by using BC and its application as a new wound-healing platform for traumatic tympanic membrane (TM) perforation is reported. TM perforation is a very common clinical problem worldwide and presents as conductive hearing loss and chronic perforations. The BC nanofibrillar patch can be synthesized from Gluconacetobacter xylinus; it is found that the patch contained a network of nanofibrils and is transparent. The thickness of the BC nanofibrillar patch is found to be approximately 10.33 ± 0.58 μm, and the tensile strength and Young's modulus of the BC nanofibrillar patch are 11.85 ± 2.43 and 11.90 ± 0.48 MPa, respectively, satisfying the requirements of an ideal wound-healing platform for TM regeneration. In vitro studies involving TM cells show that TM cell proliferation and migration are stimulated under the guidance of the BC nanofibrillar patch. In vivo animal studies demonstrate that the BC nanofibrillar patch promotes the rate of TM healing as well as aids in the recovery of TM function. These data demonstrate that the BC nanofibrillar patch is a useful wound-healing platform for TM perforation.

Spontaneous healing of various tympanic membrane perforations in the rat

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the spontaneous healing process of various types of perforation and the location of the epithelial generation center in the tympanic membrane of rats.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Various types of perforation were made in the ears of 50 rats and the healing process was observed using light and electron microscopy.

RESULTS

Epithelia hyperplasia could not be seen at the edge of the perforations, but occurred in the annulus and handle of malleus regions during the early stage of healing. There was no correlation between the healing time and the size of the perforations. When one ear was perforated, no changes were observed in the intact ear on the other side. The epithelium did not migrate into the tympanic cavity in the posterior marginal perforations. All the perforations healed, although the manubria of the malleus were damaged.

CONCLUSIONS

The perforations healed by means of epithelial migration. The epithelial generation center was located near the annulus and the handle of the malleus, and therefore protection of these two regions is very important in middle ear surgery.

Topical ascorbic acid reduces myringosclerosis in perforated tympanic membranes. A study in the rat

Myringosclerosis, a common finding after myringotomy, has been recently associated with an increased production of oxygen free radicals. Ascorbic acid's proposed actions include collagen synthesis, antioxidation, and free radical scavenging. The effects of topical ascorbic acid on healing tympanic membranes were studied. Particular attention was given to detecting the presence of myringosclerosis. Twelve Sprague-Dawley rats were bilaterally myringotomized. Their ears were randomized into group A, which received topical ascorbic acid in Gelfoam, group B, which received topical saline solution in Gelfoam, and group C, which received no treatment. The tympanic membranes were harvested on day 13, after routine otomicroscopy. Under light microscopy, the connective tissue layer of the untouched side of the pars tensa was distinctly thicker in group A than in group B or group C. At this level, the extent of sclerotic lesions was significantly less in the ascorbic acid-treated group. It is inferred that topical ascorbic acid reduces the occurrence of myringosclerosis following tympanic membrane perforations in the rat.

The inhibitory effect of topical N-acetylcysteine application on myringosclerosis in perforated rat tympanic membrane

OBJECTIVE

Myringosclerosis often occurs in patients in whom ventilation tube insertion and tympanoplasty procedures are performed. Recent studies have revealed a relationship between the development of myringosclerosis and oxygen-derived free radicals, and some investigations have demonstrated that free radical scavengers prevent the development of myringosclerosis. N-acetylcysteine is a well-known anti-oxidant and anti-inflammatory agent. In this study, we aimed to investigate the preventive effect of N-acetylcysteine on myringosclerosis in myringotomized rat tympanic membranes.

METHODS

Twenty Sprague-Dawley rats were bilaterally myringotomized and divided into four groups. Group 1 received no treatment, group 2 was treated with topical saline solution in Spongostan, group 3 received topical 0.6 mg N-acetylcysteine in Spongostan and group 4 received 1.2 mg N-acetylcysteine in Spongostan daily for 12 days. Tympanic membranes were examined by otomicroscopy on day 12. Then, the membranes were harvested and evaluated histologically by light microscopy.

RESULTS

The tympanic membranes of groups 1 and 2 (saline and non-treated) showed extensive occurrence of myringosclerosis, whereas groups 3 and 4 (treated with N-acetylcysteine) showed lesser occurrence of myringosclerosis in otomicroscopic evaluation (P<0.01). Under light microscopic examination, lamina propria of pars tensa was found thicker in groups 3 and 4 when compared with groups 1 and 2. There was no significant difference between groups 3 and 4 (P: 0.30).

CONCLUSIONS

Topically applied N-acetylcysteine was found to be effective in the prevention of sclerotic lesions in myringotomized rat tympanic membranes.

An observational study of the management of traumatic tympanic membrane perforations

Controversies of how best to treat fresh tympanic membrane perforations have always existed. While some otolaryngologists prefer the paper patch method, others prefer modified myringoplasty. A prospective study is needed to investigate the most effective and least expensive management of this common ear trauma. This study examined prospectively, in three sections, a group of patients with a cellophane patch (n = 6), another group with a gentamicin ointment seal (n = 15) and a control group (n = 9) with a gentamicin plug placed at the distal end of the external auditory cavity. Successful healing of the traumatic tympanic membrane perforations was achieved in 50 per cent of the cellophane seal group, 86.7 per cent of the gentamicin ointment seal group and 77.8 per cent of the control group. This study shows that the management of a fresh tympanic membrane perforation should be limited to cleaning the traumatized ear and preventing infection.

Repair of Tympanic Membrane Perforations with Customized Bioprinted Ear Grafts Using Chinchilla Models

The goal of this work is to develop an innovative method that combines bioprinting and endoscopic imaging to repair tympanic membrane perforations (TMPs). TMPs are a serious health issue because they can lead to both conductive hearing loss and repeated otitis media. TMPs occur in 3-5% of cases after ear tube placement, as well as in cases of acute otitis media (the second most common infection in pediatrics), chronic otitis media with or without cholesteatoma, or as a result of barotrauma to the ear. About 55,000 tympanoplasties, the surgery performed to reconstruct TMPs, are performed every year, and the commonly used cartilage grafting technique has a success rate between 43% and 100%. This wide variability in successful tympanoplasty indicates that the current approach relies heavily on the skill of the surgeon to carve the shield graft into the shape of the TMP, which can be extremely difficult because of the perforation's irregular shape. To this end, we hypothesized that patient specific acellular grafts can be bioprinted to repair TMPs. In vitro data demonstrated that our approach resulted in excellent wound healing responses (e.g., cell invasion and proliferations) using our bioprinted gelatin methacrylate constructs. Based on these results, we then bioprinted customized acellular grafts to treat TMP based on endoscopic imaging of the perforation and demonstrated improved TMP healing in a chinchilla study. These ear graft techniques could transform clinical practice by eliminating the need for hand-carved grafts. To our knowledge, this is the first proof of concept of using bioprinting and endoscopic imaging to fabricate customized grafts to treat tissue perforations. This technology could be transferred to other medical pathologies and be used to rapidly scan internal organs such as intestines for microperforations, brain covering (Dura mater) for determination of sites of potential cerebrospinal fluid leaks, and vascular systems to determine arterial wall damage before aneurysm rupture in strokes.

Tympanoscope-assisted myringoplasty

Thirty ears of 29 patients with different sized perforation of the tympanic membrane were operated on with the aid of rigid otoendoscopes. The technique has a significant novel feature: endoscopy of the tympanic cavity through a perforation with small tympanoscopes 1.7 mm in diameter with a 0%. The postoperative air-bone gap was less than 10 dB in 90% of the ears. It was concluded that tympanoscope-assisted myringoplasty is a reliable and simple procedure with the benefit of minimal trauma in healthy tissue and that it is a feasible approach for day-case surgery with an ordinary success rate of tympanic membrane closure and hearing results.

Natural course of tympanic membrane pathology related to otitis media and ventilation tubes between ages 8 and 18 years

OBJECTIVE

To present the course of tympanic membrane pathology in childhood and young adulthood after otitis media (OM) in early life.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective follow-up study.

SETTING

Community study of a birth cohort.

PATIENTS

Three hundred fifty-eight subjects with a positive and negative history of OM (OM+ or OM-) or ventilation tube insertion (VT+ or VT-) derived from a birth cohort that had been followed-up from preschool to adult age.

METHODS

Standardized otomicroscopic examination performed at ages 8 and 18 years.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Tympanic membrane abnormalities (i.e., tympanosclerosis, atrophy, atelectasis and retraction pockets of the pars tensa, and retraction of the pars flaccida).

RESULTS

At the age of 8 years, tympanic membrane pathology was highly prevalent in the both OM+ subcohorts (OM+VT+, 92% and OM+VT-, 46%), whereas in the OM- ears (11%), tympanic membrane abnormalities were rare. In the subsequent 10-year period, many tympanic membrane abnormalities disappeared spontaneously, although the prevalence of tympanosclerosis remained substantial in the OM+VT+ cohort.

CONCLUSION

The natural course of most tympanic membrane pathology associated with OM in early life is favorable over time, suggesting an intrinsic repair capacity of the tympanic membrane. Tympanosclerosis, the most prevalent sequelae of OM and treatment with VT, however, shows little tendency of resolution.

Effectiveness of MeroGel hyaluronic acid on tympanic membrane perforations

CONCLUSIONS

Our results support the proposition that hyaluronic acid (HA) provides a moist wound-healing environment to aid in the healing process of tympanic membrane perforation. A single MeroGel administration can be effective as well as daily topical HA application in the treatment of tympanic membrane perforations. A single application of esterified HA may be more suitable for patients and also for otolaryngologists.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the effectiveness of a single MeroGel application on traumatic tympanic membrane perforations in rats.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The posterior quadrant of the tympanic membranes in both ears of 24 male pathogen-free Sprague-Dawley rats was perforated with a 20-gauge needle. Subjects were divided into two groups: MeroGel and daily topical HA-treated groups. All subjects were sacrificed and histopathological examinations of the tympanic bullas were carried out.

RESULTS

Perforations of controls, and MeroGel- and daily HA-treated groups closed in 17/24 (70.8%), 11/12 (91.7%), and 12/12 (100%) ears, respectively. There was a significant difference between control and MeroGel-treated groups, and also between control and daily topical HA-treated groups for the presence of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), fibroblast growth factor (FGF), lymphocytes and collagen fibrils (p<0.05), whereas there was no significant difference between MeroGel- and daily topical HA-treated groups (p>0.05).

Tympanic membrane perforation repair using AlloDerm

BACKGROUND

Some patients lack quality autologous tissue for tympanic membrane (TM) grafting. AlloDerm (LifeCell Corp, The Woodlands, TX) is a preserved allograft that has been effective in nonotologic applications.

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this study was to investigate AlloDerm in the repair of chronic TM perforations.

METHODS

Ten adult chinchillas underwent a controlled, 2-stage procedure for creation and repair of bilateral TM perforations. Myringoplasties were performed. The control side (left) was repaired with autologous fascia; AlloDerm was used in all right ears. Grafts were assessed at 3 to 8 weeks.

RESULTS

Complete TM perforation closure was noted in 9 of 10 (90%) control ears and 8 of 10 (80%) AlloDerm-treated ears. Fascia and AlloDerm integrated consistently with host tissues. No variables demonstrated statistical significance.

CONCLUSIONS

AlloDerm appeared to be an ideal substitute for grafting of the TM. It was equally effective as fascia. Clinical trials in human beings appear warranted. Potential health care savings are discussed.

Histology of the perforated tympanic membrane and its muco-epithelial junction

A histological study was performed on total human tympanic membranes with a central perforation. The specimens originated from 30 consecutive and unselected operations in which a total myringectomy was performed prior to reconstruction by means of a tympanic allograft. Beside excessive thickening of the tympanic membrane in 73%, all membranes showed other histological abnormalities: inflammation (97%), excessive fibrosis (97%), tympanosclerosis (80%), hyperkeratosis (83%), rete riges (43%) and epithelial inclusions (6%). Histological localisation of the muco-epithelial junction showed a medial position in 30%, with extensive middle ear invasion by squamous epithelium in 7%. The surgeon performing myringoplasty should keep these findings in mind and he should closely examine the medial side of the perforated tympanic membrane in order to remove any ingrowing epithelium that otherwise would be trapped.

The effect of tympanic membrane perforation size on umbo velocity in the rat

The tympanic membrane (TM) in adult rats was surgically exposed and laser interferometry was used to measure TM velocity at the umbo for frequencies between 1.0 and 40.0 kHz. Velocity measures were obtained for five conditions: TM intact, and four progressively larger holes cut into the posterior region of the membrane. Photomicrographs of each condition were used to calculate the percentage of pars tensa lost to the perforation. The relation between TM velocity and stimulus sound pressure level (SPL) was also examined for each of the conditions. The results revealed a systematic loss in low-frequency velocity as perforation size increased. These observations were consistent with clinical reports of low-frequency hearing loss in the perforated human TM. The rat appears to be a successful model for studying this form of conductive pathology.

Middle ear pathology can affect the ear-canal sound pressure generated by audiologic earphones

OBJECTIVE

To determine how the ear-canal sound pressures generated by earphones differ between normal and pathologic middle ears.

DESIGN

Measurements of ear-canal sound pressures generated by the Etymtic Research ER-3A insert earphone in normal ears (N = 12) were compared with the pressures generated in abnormal ears with mastoidectomy bowls (N = 15), tympanostomy tubes (N = 5), and tympanic-membrane perforations (N = 5). Similar measurements were made with the Telephonics TDH-49 supra-aural earphone in normal ears (N = 10) and abnormal ears with mastoidectomy bowls (N = 10), tympanostomy tubes (N = 4), and tympanic-membrane perforations (N = 5).

RESULTS

With the insert earphone, the sound pressures generated in the mastoid-bowl ears were all smaller than the pressures generated in normal ears; from 250 to 1000 Hz the difference in pressure level was nearly frequency independent and ranged from -3 to -15 dB; from 1000 to 4000 Hz the reduction in level increased with frequency and ranged from -5 dB to -35 dB. In the ears with tympanostomy tubes and perforations the sound pressures were always smaller than in normal ears at frequencies below 1000 Hz; the largest differences occurred below 500 Hz and ranged from -5 to -25 dB. With the supra-aural earphone, the sound pressures in ears with the three pathologic conditions were more variable than those with the insert earphone. Generally, sound pressures in the ears with mastoid bowls were lower than those in normal ears for frequencies below about 500 Hz; above about 500 Hz the pressures showed sharp minima and maxima that were not seen in the normal ears. The ears with tympanostomy tubes and tympanic-membrane perforations also showed reduced ear-canal pressures at the lower frequencies, but at higher frequencies these ear-canal pressures were generally similar to the pressures measured in the normal ears.

CONCLUSIONS

When the middle ear is not normal, ear-canal sound pressures can differ by up to 35 dB from the normal-ear value. Because the pressure level generally is decreased in the pathologic conditions that were studied, the measured hearing loss would exaggerate substantially the actual loss in ear sensitivity. The variations depend on the earphone, the middle ear pathology, and frequency. Uncontrolled variations in ear-canal pressure, whether caused by a poor earphone-to-ear connection or by abnormal middle ear impedance, could be corrected with audiometers that measure sound pressures during hearing tests.

Healing time, long-term result and effects of stem cell treatment in acute tympanic membrane perforation

OBJECTIVE

The incidence of otitis media in children between the age of 2 and 6 years is well documented. Repeated attacks may cause acute and chronic perforations. The surgical treatment for repairing chronic perforation is quite uncomfortable for the patients of this age group because of the invasiveness of this treatment. The aim of this study was to determine the long-term influence of embryonic stem cells on acute perforations and the effect of gelatin as a vehicle for applied stem cells. The possibility of teratogenic effects of the stem cells was also observed.

METHODS

Bilateral laser myringotomy was performed in 17 adult Sprague-Dawley rats, divided into two groups. Gelatin, a substance suitable as vehicle for bioactive material was used bilaterally around the perforation in group A, to serve as a scaffold for repairing tissue. The stem cells were used in the right tympanic membrane perforation leaving the left tympanic membrane as a control. The animals in group B received the same treatment except for the use of gelatin and in addition received an immuno-suppressive agent. After half a year of observation the mechanical stiffness of the tympanic membrane was measured by moiré interferometry for group B and the morphological study was performed by light microscopy for both groups A and B and electron microscopy for group A.

RESULTS

Stem cell treated ears did not show any enhanced healing of the perforation although a marked thickening of the lamina propria was observed compared with control group. After half a year the strength and the stiffness of the tympanic membrane was almost the same for both treated and untreated ears. No evidence of teratoma was found after half a year.

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that the stem cells stimulate the proliferation of connective tissue and fibers in the lamina propria, possibly mediated by secreted substances, although the stiffness properties do not seem to be altered. The use of gelatin does not seem to enhance the healing process of the tympanic membrane perforation.

Acoustic mechanisms that determine the ear-canal sound pressures generated by earphones

In clinical measurements of hearing sensitivity, a given earphone is assumed to produce essentially the same sound-pressure level in all ears. However, recent measurements [Voss et al., Ear and Hearing (in press)] show that with some middle-ear pathologies, ear-canal sound pressures can deviate by as much as 35 dB from the normal-ear value; the deviations depend on the earphone, the middle-ear pathology, and frequency. These pressure variations cause errors in the results of hearing tests. Models developed here identify acoustic mechanisms that cause pressure variations in certain pathological conditions. The models combine measurement-based Thévenin equivalents for insert and supra-aural earphones with lumped-element models for both the normal ear and ears with pathologies that alter the ear's impedance (mastoid bowl, tympanostomy tube, tympanic-membrane perforation, and a "high-impedance" ear). Comparison of the earphones' Thévenin impedances to the ear's input impedance with these middle-ear conditions shows that neither class of earphone acts as an ideal pressure source; with some middle-ear pathologies, the ear's input impedance deviates substantially from normal and thereby causes abnormal ear-canal pressure levels. In general, for the three conditions that make the ear's impedance magnitude lower than normal, the model predicts a reduced ear-canal pressure (as much as 35 dB), with a greater pressure reduction with an insert earphone than with a supra-aural earphone. In contrast, the model predicts that ear-canal pressure levels increase only a few dB when the ear has an increased impedance magnitude; the compliance of the air-space between the tympanic membrane and the earphone determines an upper limit on the effect of the middle-ear's impedance increase. Acoustic leaks at the earphone-to-ear connection can also cause uncontrolled pressure variations during hearing tests. From measurements at the supra-aural earphone-to-ear connection, we conclude that it is unusual for the connection between the earphone cushion and the pinna to seal effectively for frequencies below 250 Hz. The models developed here explain the measured pressure variations with several pathologic ears. Understanding these mechanisms should inform the design of more accurate audiometric systems which might include a microphone that monitors the ear-canal pressure and corrects deviations from normal.

Day-case myringoplasty: five years’ experience

A retrospective study of patients who underwent myringoplasty as a day-case procedure in two freestanding day-surgery units during a five-year period was carried out.

Their case notes were identified and details including age, site and size of perforation, grade of surgeon, surgical approach, graft material, post-operative dressings, overnight stay, complications, and outcome were noted and analysed.

The total number of patients including both children and adults who had myringoplasty as a day case was 144. Of these, 125 patients with 143 procedures were included in this study. Their ages ranged from four to 74 years (mean = 31 years). The perforation size was small in 40 cases, medium in 61 cases, and large/subtotal in 42 cases. The overnight stay rate was 2.7 per cent and this was for immediate post-operative problems such as nausea and bleeding from the wound. The readmission rate for post-operative complications was 2.1 per cent. The follow-up ranged from six months to five years (mean = 19 months). The success rate was 83.3 per cent and thresholds on pure tone audiometry improved in 69.2 per cent of cases. The age of the patient, grade of the surgeon, and graft material did not influence the surgical outcome. There was no case of dead ear as a result of surgery.

Myringoplasty can be safely performed in both adults and children as a day-case procedure with low overnight stay and readmission rates. Success rates are comparable to when the procedure is performed on an in-patient basis.

Structural characterization of persistent tympanic membrane perforations in man

In the present structural study the authors investigated the border of permanent tympanic membrane (TM) perforations in patients selected for myringoplasty. Furthermore, a panel of monoclonal antibody markers that recognize different epitopes within glycosaminoglycans as well as antibodies to epidermal growth factor and fibronectin were applied to the sections. In half of the specimens the epithelial junction ended at the inside of the perforation border, whereas in the other half it was located at the perforation border itself. In the junctional area the keratinocytes were covered by a thick keratin layer which protruded as a spur centripetally in order to bridge the perforation. Epidermal cells formed papillae and contained remnants of keratinocyte nuclei that showed similarities to those of the skin in inflammatory conditions. The connective tissue layer was fibrous and showed areas containing sclerotic plaques. The inner epithelium of the TM had abundant ciliae, thus supporting the concept that cells of the mucosal lining of the TM are able to differentiate in inflammatory conditions into ciliated cells and secretory cells. The immunoreactivity of hyaluronan and other glycosaminoglycans, the immunoreactivity of epidermal growth factor, and immunoreactivity of fibronectin, all of which are known to occur in healing wounds, were only scantily demonstrated; this could be one reason for the arrested healing and a reason why the natural drive to complete a mature closure is abandoned.

Embryonic stem cells enhance the healing of tympanic membrane perforations

OBJECTIVE

Tympanic membrane perforations may cause hearing impairment and otorhea. It is a common indication for ear surgery. The aim of the study was to test whether stem cells may enhance the healing of fresh tympanic membrane perforations.

METHODS

In a first assay, the status of the tympanic membrane at 5 days after myringotomy was tested in five Mongolian gerbils that were treated on one side with embryonic stem cells and on the other side with control substance. In a second assay, nine gerbils were treated in the same way, except that fluorescent-labeled embryonic stem cells were used. The integration of the stem cells into the surface layer of the healing tympanic membrane was assessed with fluorescence microscopy, as well as the differentiation of these cells.

RESULTS

In the first assay, all perforations in the treated ears were closed, whereas only two of the untreated ears were closed. The strength of the healed perforation was greater in the stem cell treated tympanic membranes (mean rupture pressure 120 daPa in three treated ears compared to 60 daPa in the one control ear). Two stem cell-treated tympanic membranes remained intact throughout the whole sequence of pressures, whereas only one control tympanic membrane remained intact. In three tympanic membranes in the second assay, a group of fluorescence-doped cells was detected in the region of the perforation.

CONCLUSION

These findings indicate that stem cells enhance the healing of tympanic membrane perforations, possibly by differentiation and integration into the tympanic membrane tissue.

Outcome of children with edge-everted traumatic tympanic membrane perforations following spontaneous healing versus fibroblast growth factor-containing gelfoam patching with or without edge repair

OBJECTIVES

To retrospectively analyze the outcome of children with edge-everted tympanic membrane (TM) perforations following spontaneous healing and fibroblast growth factor-containing gelfoam patching with or without repair of the edge flaps.

METHODS

Medical records of children with TM perforations who underwent spontaneous healing (n = 69) or received fibroblast growth factor (FGF)-containing gelfoam patching treatment (n = 67) were retrieved from the Records Department of the Wenzhou Medical College-Affiliated Yiwu Hospital in China. The demographic data and outcome measures were analyzed and compared between these two groups of patients.

RESULTS

Patching with FGF-containing gelfoams significantly improved the healing rate (P < 0.01) and the average perforation closure time (P<0.01), as compared with spontaneous healing. Repair of the perforation edge flaps did not significantly affect the outcome of gelfoam patching (P>0.05), despite a slightly reduced healing rate (96.4% versus 100%) and a slightly shorter closure time (10.2 ± 2.6 d versus 10.9 ± 3.3 d) observed as compared with no edge repair. The everted perforation edge flaps formed scabs during the process of spontaneous healing whereas they underwent retraction and eventually dissolved during the process of gelfoam patching-facilitated healing.

CONCLUSIONS

As compared with spontaneous healing, FGF-containing gelfoam patching had an improved outcome in children with edge-everted traumatic eardrum perforation. Repair of everted edge flaps did not affect the healing outcome. Our results suggest that growth factor-containing gelfoam patching without eardrum flap repair would offer a feasible option to manage traumatic tympanic membrane perforations in children.