Does resident involvement in tonsillectomy affect outcomes?

OBJECTIVE

Tonsillectomy is essentially a solo surgery with a well-described complication profile. It may serve as a good benchmark to evaluate the resident-as-surgeon. This study examined complications such as post-tonsillectomy bleeding in children undergoing tonsillectomy by attending surgeons (AS) or pediatric otolaryngologist-supervised residents.

METHODS

Charts were reviewed of all children aged 12 and under who had tonsillectomy +/- adenoidectomy at a children's hospital between Jan 2019 and Dec 2020. Patient age, gender, BMI, indication for surgery, surgical technique, presence of a resident surgeon, primary bleeding, secondary bleeding, treatment of bleeding, other Emergency Room (ER) visits, and clinic phone calls were recorded. Binary logistic regression was performed.

RESULTS

2051 total children (1092 (53.2 %) males and 956 (46.6 %) females) with a mean age of 6.1 years (95 % CI 6.0-6.2) were included. 1910 (93.0 %) underwent surgery for tonsillar obstruction. 1557 (75.9 %) underwent monopolar cautery tonsillectomy. 661 (32.2 %) had a resident surgeon. 274 (13.4 %) had a related ER visit within 15 days. 18 (0.9 %) had a primary bleed and 155 (7.6 %) had a secondary bleed. Binary logistic regression showed that significant predictors of postoperative ER visits were patient age (OR = 1.101, 95 % CI = 1.050-1.154, p < .001) and resident involvement (OR = 0.585, 95 % CI = 0.429-,797, p < .001). Only age was associated with overall postoperative bleeding incidence (OR = 1.131, 95 % CI = 1.068-1.197, p < .001), as well as secondary bleeding (OR = 1.128, 95 % CI = 1.063-1.197, p < .001). There were no significant predictors of primary bleeding.

CONCLUSION

Resident involvement in pediatric tonsillectomy is associated with decreased postoperative ER utilization and does not appear to increase common postoperative complications including bleeding and dehydration.

Behind the pattern: General surgery residsent autonomy in robotic surgery

Objective

Robotic surgery is increasingly utilized and common in general surgery training programs. This study sought to better understand the factors that influence resident operative autonomy in robotic surgery. We hypothesized that resident seniority, surgeon work experience, surgeon robotic-assisted surgery (RAS) case volume, and procedure type influence general surgery residents' opportunities for autonomy in RAS as measured by percentage of resident individual console time (ICT).

Methods

General surgery resident ICT data for robotic cholecystectomy (RC), inguinal hernia (RIH), and ventral hernia (RVH) operations performed on the dual-console Da Vinci surgical robotic system between July 2019 and June 2021 were extracted. Cases with postgraduate year (PGY) 2-5 residents participating as a console surgeon were included. A sequential explanatory mixed-methods approach was undertaken to explore the ICT results and we conducted secondary qualitative interviews with surgeons. Descriptive statistics and thematic analysis were applied.

Results

Resident ICT data from 420 robotic cases (IH 200, RC 121, and VH 99) performed by 20 junior residents (PGY2-3), 18 senior residents (PGY4-5), and 9 attending surgeons were extracted. The average ICT per case was 26.8 % for junior residents and 42.4 % for senior residents. Compared to early-career surgeons, surgeons with over 10 years' work experience gave less ICT to junior (18.2 % vs. 32.0 %) and senior residents (33.9 % vs. 56.6 %) respectively. Surgeons' RAS case volume had no correlation with resident ICT (r = 0.003, p = 0.0003). On average, residents had the most ICT in RC (45.8 %), followed by RIH (36.7 %) and RVH (28.6 %). Interviews with surgeons revealed two potential reasons for these resident ICT patterns: 1) Surgeon assessment of resident training year/experience influenced decisions to grant ICT; 2) Surgeons' perceived operative time pressure inversely affected resident ICT.

Conclusions

This study suggests resident ICT/autonomy in RC, RIH, and RVH are influenced by resident seniority level, surgeon work experience, and procedure type, but not related to surgeon RAS case volume. Design and implementation of an effective robotic training program must consider the external pressures at conflict with increased resident operative autonomy and seek to mitigate them.

Unlocking Peer Review: Elevating Scholarly Writing and Research Competence in Urology Residency

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

It is incumbent upon training programs to set the foundation for evidence-based practices and to create opportunities for trainees to develop into academic leaders. As dedicated resident research time and funding have declined in recent years, residency programs and the field at large will need to create new ways to incorporate scholarly activity into residency curricula.

RECENT FINDINGS

Literature across specialties demonstrates barriers to resident involvement including lack of time, cost, and absent scholarly mentorship. Peer review stands as a ready-made solution that can be formalized into a collaborative relationship with journals. A formal relationship between professional societies, academic journals, and residencies can facilitate the use of peer review as a teaching tool for residency programs.

Case study and pilot results: Stepwise approach to teach a resident tube shunt surgery

Purpose

To illustrate the utility of a previously published stepwise rubric for evaluating a resident's progress learning aqueous tube shunt surgery.

Method

Using a stepwise rubric, a single PGY3 ophthalmology resident and attending glaucoma surgeon evaluated the resident's performance after each aqueous tube shunt surgery. The rubric subdivides the surgery into 12 consecutive steps and scores the resident's proficiency in each step with either a 0 (observation), 2 (novice), 3 (beginner), 4 (advanced beginner), or 5 (competent).

Results

The resident's cumulative score increased significantly throughout the 17 surgeries performed, with the resident's self-evaluated score and attending's score increasing from 12 to 27 and 14 to 27 from the first to last surgery, respectively. Scores were consistent between the resident and attending; for any given surgery, the resident's own score never deviated from the attending's score by more than 1 point. The resident completed at least 50% of the steps in 11 of the 17 cases. While some surgical steps were mastered earlier on ("tube tying" and "suture implantation"), other steps were more challenging to master ("tunnel in sclera and enter the AC" and "close conjunctiva", as demonstrated by fewer overall attempts or never attaining a score of '5' despite multiple attempts.

Conclusions and Importance

This study demonstrates the utility of the stepwise rubric in tracking resident surgical scores chronologically via self and attending assessment. The ability to compare their own scores to that of an attending allows the resident to learn how to effectively evaluate their own performance. Most importantly, statistics obtained for each step provides the resident with personalized and real-time feedback for learning specific surgical steps. In conclusion, the stepwise rubric is a useful add-on to a resident's aqueous tube shunt surgery education.

Radiation Oncology Resident Education: Is Change Needed?

Leading successful change efforts first requires assessment of the "before change" environment and culture. At our institution, the radiation oncology (RO) residents follow a longitudinal didactic learning program consisting of weekly 1-h lectures, case conferences, and journal clubs. The resident didactic education series format has not changed since its inception over 10 years ago. We evaluated the perceptions of current residents and faculty about the effectiveness of the curriculum in its present form. Two parallel surveys were designed, one each for residents and attendings, to assess current attitudes regarding the effectiveness and need for change in the RO residency curriculum, specifically the traditional didactic lectures, the journal club sessions, and the case conferences. We also investigated perceived levels of engagement among residents and faculty, whether self-assessments would be useful to increase material retention, and how often the content of didactic lectures is updated. Surveys were distributed individually to each resident (N = 10) and attending (N = 24) either in-person or via Zoom. Following completion of the survey, respondents were informally interviewed about their perspectives on the curriculum's strengths and weaknesses. Compared to 46% of attendings, 80% of RO residents believed that the curriculum should be changed. Twenty percent of residents felt that the traditional didactic lectures were effective in preparing them to manage patients in the clinic, compared to 74% of attendings. Similarly, 10% of residents felt that the journal club sessions were effective vs. 42% of attendings. Finally, 40% of residents felt that the case conferences were effective vs. 67% of attendings. Overall, most respondents (56%) favored change in the curriculum. Our results suggest that the perceptions of the residents did not align with those of the attending physicians with respect to the effectiveness of the curriculum and the need for change. The discrepancies between resident and faculty views highlight the importance of a dedicated change management effort to mitigate this gap. Based on this project, we plan to propose recommended changes in structure to the residency program directors. Main changes would be to increase the interactive nature of the course material, incorporate more ways to increase faculty engagement, and consider self-assessment questions to promote retention. Once we get approval from the residency program leadership, we will follow Kotter's "Eight steps to transforming your organization" to ensure the highest potential for faculty to accept the expectations of a new curriculum.

Residents underestimate their robotic performance: evaluating resident robotic console participation time

Lack of formal national robotic curriculum results in a void of knowledge regarding appropriate progression of autonomy in robotic general surgery training. One midwestern academic surgical training program has demonstrated that residents expect to independently operate more on the robotic console than they perceive themselves to do. As such, our study sought to evaluate expectations of residents and faculty regarding resident participation versus actual console participation time (CPT) at a community general surgery training program. We surveyed residents and faculty in two phases. Initially, participants were asked to reflect on their perceptions and expectations from the previous six months. The second phase included surveys (collected over six months) after individual cases with subjective estimation of participation versus CPT calculated by the Intuitive Surgical, Inc. MyIntuitive application. Using Mann-Whitney U-Test, we compared resident perceptions of CPT to actual CPT by case complexity and post-graduate year (PGY). Faculty (n = 7) estimated they allowed residents to complete a median of 26-50% of simple and 0-25% of complex cases in the six months prior to the study. They expected senior residents (PGY-4 and PGY-5) to complete more: 51-75% of simple and 26-50% of complex cases. Residents (n = 13), PGY-2-PGY-5, estimated they completed less than faculty perceived (0-25% of simple and 0-25% of complex cases). Sixty-six post-case (after partial colectomy, abdominoperoneal resection, low anterior resection, cholecystectomy, inguinal/ventral hernia repair, and others) surveys were completed. Residents estimated after any case that they had completed 26-50% of the case. However, once examining their MyIntuitive report, they actually completed 51-75% of the case (median). Residents, especially PGY-4 and 5, completed a higher percentage than estimated of robotic cases. Our study confirms that residents can and should complete more of (and increasingly complex) robotic cases throughout training, like the transition of autonomy in open and laparoscopic surgery.

Current status of robotic training during the urology residency: results from a national survey in Spain

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES

The increasing number of robotic urological procedures observed in recent years highlights the need to expand training opportunities in robotic surgery. Our objective is to investigate the state of robotic training during urology residency in Spain in order to identify significant deficiencies.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A 20-item online survey was conducted among urology residents in Spain who were registered in the database of the Residents and Young Urologists Group of the Spanish Association of Urology. The survey assessed subjective opinions, institutional aspects, training resources, and experience regarding robotic surgery. A total of 455 email invitations were sent throughout the year 2021. Descriptive analysis of the responses was performed.

RESULTS

The participation rate reached 30%, with a total of 135 residents. 52% of respondents lacked access to a robotic system in their institution, of which only 48% could compensate for this deficiency through external rotations. Among those with access to a robotic system, 25% and 23% reported having access to theoretical and practical training, respectively. The existence of a formal training program was low (13%). 85% of the respondents considered robotic surgery training in Spain to be deficient.

CONCLUSIONS

Training for Spanish residents in robotic urological surgery is perceived as inadequate, emphasizing the crucial need for improvement in training programs in this field.

Implementation of training level-specific self-study guides for diagnostic radiology residents

INTRODUCTION

Currently, there is no universally accepted diagnostic radiology curriculum for self-studying, so diagnostic radiology residents often have a challenging time knowing where to begin their independent studying away from work. In an effort to meet the needs of today's residents, we attempted to provide structured, comprehensive self-studying suggestions in a digestible and personalized format.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Each radiology division attempted to create an optimal learning resource form for the residents to use for self-studying while on each rotation. Each self-study guide included hyperlinks to easily accessible online resources.

RESULTS

Training level-specific week-by-week recommendations were provided based on the expected types of cases a resident would typically encounter during that timeframe. All of the neuroradiology rotation forms and several of the other subspecialty forms were originally made available to the residents and faculty electronically on July 1, 2022. The forms are now distributed to newly rotating residents on a monthly basis.

DISCUSSION

There is a fine balance between providing residents with comprehensive review material and promoting realistic expectations. In addition, educators must keep in mind financial limitations of their residents and institutions. Learning resources must be affordable to be accessible to all residents. As radiology and technology continuously advance, there will undoubtedly be more and more excellent resources for trainees to learn from. To optimize self-studying, retention of information, and wellness, it is imperative to provide our residents with a structured, personalized, manageable curriculum including easily accessible high-yield resources.

Impact of a coaching program on resident perceptions of communication confidence and feedback quality

BACKGROUND

While communication is an essential skill for providing effective medical care, it is infrequently taught or directly assessed, limiting targeted feedback and behavior change. We sought to evaluate the impact of a multi-departmental longitudinal residency communication coaching program. We hypothesized that program implementation would result in improved confidence in residents' communication skills and higher-quality faculty feedback.

METHODS

The program was implemented over a 3-year period (2019-2022) for surgery and neurology residents at a single institution. Trained faculty coaches met with assigned residents for coaching sessions. Each session included an observed clinical encounter, self-reflection, feedback, and goal setting. Eligible residents completed baseline and follow-up surveys regarding their perceptions of feedback and communication. Quantitative responses were analyzed using paired t-tests; qualitative responses were analyzed using content analysis.

RESULTS

The baseline and follow-up survey response rates were 90.0% (126/140) and 50.5% (46/91), respectively. In a paired analysis of 40 respondents, residents reported greater confidence in their ability to communicate with patients (inpatient: 3.7 vs. 4.3, p < 0.001; outpatient: 3.5 vs. 4.2, p < 0.001), self-reflect (3.3 vs. 4.3, p < 0.001), and set goals (3.6 vs. 4.3, p < 0.001), as measured on a 5-point scale. Residents also reported greater usefulness of faculty feedback (3.3 vs. 4.2, p = 0.001). The content analysis revealed helpful elements of the program, challenges, and opportunities for improvement. Receiving mentorship, among others, was indicated as a core program strength, whereas solving session coordination and scheduling issues, as well as lowering the coach-resident ratio, were suggested as some of the improvement areas.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest that direct observation of communication in clinical encounters by trained faculty coaches can facilitate long-term trainee growth across multiple core competencies. Future studies should evaluate the impact on patient outcomes and workplace-based assessments.

The performance of ChatGPT on orthopaedic in-service training exams: A comparative study of the GPT-3.5 turbo and GPT-4 models in orthopaedic education

Introduction

The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) such as Generative Pretrained Transformers (GPTs), has revolutionized numerous fields. The purpose of this study is to investigate the application of LLMs within the realm of orthopaedic in training examinations.

Methods

Questions from the 2020-2022 Orthopaedic In-Service Training Exams (OITEs) were given to OpenAI's GPT-3.5 Turbo and GPT-4 LLMs, using a zero-shot inference approach. Each model was given a multiple-choice question, without prior exposure to similar queries, and their generated responses were compared to the correct answer within each OITE. The models were evaluated on overall accuracy, performance on questions with and without media, and performance on first- and higher-order questions.

Results

The GPT-4 model outperformed the GPT-3.5 Turbo model across all years and question categories (2022: 67.63% vs. 50.24%; 2021: 58.69% vs. 47.42%; 2020: 59.53% vs. 46.51%). Both models showcased better performance with questions devoid of associated media, with GPT-4 attaining accuracies of 68.80%, 65.14%, and 68.22% for 2022, 2021, and 2020, respectively. GPT-4 outscored GPT-3.5 Turbo on first-order questions across all years (2022: 63.83% vs. 38.30%; 2021: 57.45% vs. 50.00%; 2020: 65.74% vs. 53.70%). GPT-4 also outscored GPT-3.5 Turbo on higher-order questions across all years (2022: 68.75% vs. 53.75%; 2021: 59.66% vs. 45.38%; 2020: 53.27% vs. 39.25%).

Discussion

GPT-4 showed improved performance compared to GPT-3.5 Turbo in all tested categories. The results reflect the potential and limitations of AI in orthopaedics. GPT-4's performance is comparable to a second-to-third-year resident and GPT-3.5 Turbo's performance is comparable to a first-year resident, suggesting the application of current LLMs can neither pass the OITE nor substitute orthopaedic training. This study sets a precedent for future endeavors integrating GPT models into orthopaedic education and underlines the necessity for specialized training of these models for specific medical domains.

Anatomic Review in 3D Augmented Reality Alters Craniotomy Planning Among Residents

OBJECTIVE

Objectively examine the effect of 3D-Augmented Reality anatomic review on craniotomy planning among neurosurgical residents as it pertains to craniotomy size, skull positioning, and knowledge of significant anatomic relationships.

METHODS

Postgraduate year 1-7 neurosurgery residents were instructed to review standard 2D radiographs, pin a skull, and tailor a craniotomy for 6 different lesions and case vignettes. Participants then reviewed the lesion in a 3D-augmented reality (AR) environment, followed by repeating the craniotomy station for a variety of lesion types and locations (superficial, subcortical, deep, skull base). Quiz with case-specific anatomic and surgical questions followed by an exit survey for qualitative impressions.

RESULTS

Eleven of thirteen eligible residents participated. Skull position significantly changed in 5 out of 6 cases after 3D-AR view (P < 0.05, 20° angular adjustment). No significant change in incision length or craniotomy size. Subgroup analysis of junior versus senior residents revealed that craniotomy size was significantly altered in 2 out of 6 cases. Qualitative testimonials (Likert scale 5 = strongly agree) reported a change in craniotomy approach after 3D-review (3.5), improved appreciation of anatomy (4.2), increased confidence in surgical approach (4.33 junior residents, 3.5 senior residents), smaller incision (3.5 junior residents, 1.75 senior residents), better appreciation of white matter tracts (4.6).

CONCLUSIONS

The augmented reality platform offers a medium to examine surgical planning skills. Residents uniformly appreciated 3D-AR as a valuable tool for improving appreciation of critical anatomic structures and their relationship to lesional pathology. 3D-AR review significantly altered skull positioning for various lesions and craniotomy approaches, particularly among junior residents.

A "just in time" educational intervention for opioid overprescribing in dialysis access surgery

BACKGROUND

Despite widespread efforts to combat the opioid epidemic, an ongoing contributor to opioid misuse remains post-operative opioid overprescribing by residents. The goal of this study was to evaluate the impact of a low-cost, reproducible "just in time" intervention on opioid prescribing in dialysis access operations.

METHODS

Standardized opioid prescribing guidelines were emailed to residents on the vascular service on the first day of the rotation. Opioid prescriptions were reviewed for four years before and one year after this intervention. Wilcoxon rank-sum test and tests of proportions were used to compare groups.

RESULTS

Overall, 299 patients underwent dialysis access procedures. There was a decrease in patients discharged with opioids following the intervention from 58% to 36% (p ​= ​0.003). For patients prescribed opioids, the median quantity decreased from 90 to 45 oral morphine equivalents (p ​= ​0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

This low-cost and timely learning intervention may be a useful adjunct to reduce post-operative opioid prescriptions.

Transgender and non-binary patient simulations can foster cultural sensitivity and knowledge among internal medicine residents: a pilot study

Transgender and nonbinary patients face unique healthcare challenges, such as harassment, discrimination, and/or prejudice, at higher rates than their cisgender counterparts. These experiences, or even the fear of these experiences, may push patients to delay or forego medical treatment, thus compounding any existing conditions. Such extraneous issues can be combatted through cultural sensitivity. The authors designed blended education consisting of an online module followed by a live simulation to educate and promote sensitivity. Internal medicine (IM) residents (n = 94) completed the module, which introduced them to transgender community terminology and medical disparities, and ways to incorporate affirming behaviors into their practice. Afterward, they engaged in a simulation with true transgender-simulated patients (SPs) - either trans-masculine, trans-feminine, or non-binary. Residents were expected to conduct a patient interview mirroring an intake appointment. Residents then engaged in a debriefing session with the lead investigator and the SP to reflect on the experience, receive feedback and constructive criticism, and ask questions. After the education, the residents' knowledge significantly increased, t(66) = 3.69, p ≤ 0.00, d = 0.45, and their attitude toward members of the transgender community also increased significantly, t(62) = 7.57, p ≤ 0.00, d = 0.95. Furthermore, nearly all residents (99%) reported the training allowed them to practice relevant skills and was a worthy investment of their time. Nearly half (45%) of the residents who listed changes they will make to their practice pledged to ask patients for their preferred name and pronouns. Most comments were positive (75%), praising the education's effectiveness, expressing gratitude, and reporting increased confidence. Results provided evidence that the education was effective in increasing IM residents' knowledge and attitudes. Further research is needed to investigate the longitudinal effects of this education and to extend the education to a broader audience. The investigators plan to adapt and expand the research to other specialties such as gynecology and emergency medicine.

Correlation between research productivity during and after orthopaedic surgery training

Background

Research experience is mandatory for all Orthopaedic Surgery residency programs. Although the allocation of required protected time and resources varies from program to program, the underlying importance of research remains consistent with mutual benefit to both residents and the program and faculty. Authorship and publications have become the standard metric used to evaluate academic success. This study aimed to determine if there is a correlation between the research productivity of Orthopaedic Surgery trainees and their subsequent research productivity as attending Orthopaedic Surgeons.

Methods

Using the University of Mississippi Orthopaedic Residency Program Research Productivity Rank List, 30 different Orthopaedic Surgery Residency Programs were analyzed for the names of every graduating surgeon in their 2013 class. PubMed Central was used to screen all 156 physicians and collect all publications produced by them between 2008 and August 2022. Results were separated into two categories: Publications during training and Publications post-training.

Results

As defined above, 156 Surgeons were analyzed for publications during training and post-training. The mean number of publications was 7.02 ± 17.819 post-training vs. 2.47 ± 4.313 during training, P < 0.001. The range of publication post-training was 0-124 vs. 0-30 during training. Pearson correlation between the two groups resulted in a value of 0.654, P < 0.001.

Conclusion

Higher research productivity while training correlates to higher productivity post-training, but overall Orthopaedic surgeons produce more research after training than during. With the growing importance of research, more mentorship, time, and resources must be dedicated to research to instill and foster greater participation while in training.

Virtual Reality-Enabled Resident Education of Lateral-Access Spine Surgery

OBJECTIVE

Lateral-access spine surgery has many benefits, but adoption has been limited by a steep learning curve. Virtual reality (VR) is gaining popularity and lends itself as a useful tool in enhancing neurosurgical resident education. We thus sought to assess whether VR-based simulation could enhance the training of neurosurgery residents in lateral spine surgery.

METHODS

Neurosurgery residents completed a VR-based lateral spine module on lateral patient positioning and performing lateral lumbar interbody fusion using the PrecisionOS VR system on the Meta Quest 2 headset. Simulation occurred 1×/week every other week for a total of 3 simulations over 6 weeks. Pre- and postintervention surveys as well as intrasimulation performance metrics were assessed over time.

RESULTS

The majority of resident participants showed improvement in performance scores, including an automated PrecisionOS precision score, number of radiographs used within the simulation, and time to completion. All participants showed improvement in comfort with anatomic landmarks for lateral access surgery, confidence performing lateral surgery without direct supervision, and assessing fluoroscopy in spine surgery for hardware placement and image interpretation. Participant perception on the utility of VR as an educational tool also improved.

CONCLUSIONS

VR-based simulation enhanced neurosurgical residents' ability to understand lateral access surgery. Immersive surgical simulation resulted in improved resident confidence with surgical technique and workflow, perceived improvement in anatomical knowledge, and simulation performance scores. Trainee perceptions on virtual simulation and training as a curriculum supplement also improved following completion of VR training.

Assessing the debt and current state of financial literacy in a cohort of diagnostic & interventional radiology residents

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study is to assess diagnostic and interventional radiology resident physicians' knowledge of core facets of financial literacy: loans, real estate, investments and retirement, and insurance, with the goal of determining the need for formal financial literacy education within radiology residency programs.

METHODS

From May 2021 to March 2022, surveys were sent to 196 diagnostic and 90 interventional radiology residency programs. Residents were asked 10 knowledge multiple choice questions to assess areas of financial literacy. Custom R programming was used to evaluate responses.

RESULTS

A total of 149 diagnostic radiology residents and 49 interventional radiology residents responded to portions of the survey, for a total of 198 respondents. Of the cohort with demographic data collected, 84 out of 141 residents (60 %) had over $100,000 of debt following medical school graduation, with 115 out of 146 DR residents (79 %) and 41 out of 47 (87 %) IR residents reporting no coursework in finance.

CONCLUSIONS

Many radiology resident physicians have a significant debt burden, no official financial education, and clear knowledge gaps in areas of financial literacy. A structured financial education curriculum could better prepare residents for the financial realities of post-residency life.

Resident Education Curriculum in Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology: The Short Curriculum 4.0

Exposure to pediatric and adolescent gynecology (PAG) varies across residency programs in obstetrics and gynecology, family medicine, and pediatrics, as well as both adolescent medicine and PAG fellowship programs. Nevertheless, these programs are responsible for training residents and fellows and providing opportunities to fulfill PAG learning objectives. To that end, the North American Society for Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology has taken a leadership role in PAG trainee education by creating and maintaining this Short Curriculum. The curriculum outlines specific learning objectives central to PAG education and lists high-yield, concise resources for learners. This updated curriculum replaces the previous 2021 publication with a new focus toward accessible online content and updated resources.

Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology WebEd: A Brief Report of an Underutilized Online Learning Module

Pediatric and adolescent gynecology (PAG) is a unique subspecialty for which accessible educational resources and clinical exposure have historically been limited; surveys show that trainees in both obstetrics and gynecology and pediatrics agree. In 2014, the North American Society for Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology (NASPAG) introduced PAG WebEd, an original and interactive online case-based curriculum designed to bridge this learning gap. As of 2023, there are 35 published PAG WebEd clinical cases with key learning points that present, test, and discuss a variety of current PAG topics. The NASPAG Resident Education Committee (REC) compiled and reviewed administrative data from the module platform to investigate trainee utilization and performance. The activity data and assessment scores for 161 registered users are included and reported in this article. This brief report highlights that a relatively small number of medical trainees use PAG WebEd and aims to raise awareness of this resource through publication. There is potential for many more users to benefit from this resource; its efficacy as an examination and clinical practice tool could also be measured. The NASPAG REC hopes to ultimately show, with increased utilization, that PAG WebEd deserves to be a key piece of PAG-focused medical education. For PAG WebEd information and faculty registration, as well as a link that allows faculty to submit new learners, please visit https://www.naspag.org/pagwebed-information.

Filling a gap in OBGYN education: a pilot lecture series on perinatal mental health

Perinatal mood and anxiety disorders (PMADs) are one of the most common complications in the peripartum period. The Council for Resident Education in Obstetrics and Gynecology (CREOG) includes diagnosis and management of PMADs as educational objectives, but no formal curriculum for trainees exists. Consequently, providers often struggle to identify and treat these disorders. We aimed to assess the effects of a pilot lecture series on obstetrics and gynecology (OBGYN) residents' knowledge and comfort in the diagnosis and management of PMADs. As part of an educational cross-sectional study, a Qualtrics survey was distributed to OBGYN residents at a single center in New York City. Residents were exposed to a 10-h virtual lecture series on perinatal mental health, and a follow-up survey was distributed. Initially, few residents were familiar with screening tools (45%), and few felt comfortable providing resources (5-45%), diagnosing (0-55%), and managing (0-30%) patients with the PMADs presented. After the pilot, improvement was seen in residents' familiarity with screening tools (86%), and their comfort in providing resources (11-67%) and diagnosing (11-78%) PMADs. However, comfort in management did not improve (0-22%). The majority of trainees (75%) found the virtual setting appropriate. There is a deficit in OBGYN residents' knowledge and comfort regarding diagnosis and discussion of PMADs that can be improved with a focused lecture series, though a greater emphasis on treatment is needed. The majority of OBGYN learners found the virtual setting conducive to learning this material. Their preferences should guide the development of a formal, national curriculum.

Clinical application of a three-dimensional-printed model in the treatment of intracranial and extracranial communicating tumors: a pilot study

BACKGROUND

Surgical management for intracranial and extracranial communicating tumors is difficult due to the complex anatomical structures. Therefore, assisting methods are urgently needed. Accordingly, this study aimed to investigate the utility of a three-dimensional (3D)-printed model in the treatment of intracranial and extracranial communicating tumors as well as its applicability in surgical planning and resident education.

METHODS

Individualized 3D-printed models were created for eight patients with intracranial and extracranial communicating tumors. Based on these 3D-printed models, a comprehensive surgical plan was made for each patient, after which the patients underwent surgery. The clinicopathological data of patients were collected and retrospectively analyzed to determine surgical outcomes. To examine the educational capability of the 3D-printed models, specialists and resident doctors were invited to review three of these cases and then rate the clinical utility of the models using a questionnaire.

RESULTS

The 3D-printed models accurately replicated anatomical structures, including the tumor, surrounding structures, and the skull. Based on these models, customized surgical approaches, including the orbitozygomatic approach and transcervical approach, were designed for the patients. Although parameters such as operation time and blood loss varied among the patients, satisfactory surgical outcomes were achieved, with only one patient developing a postoperative complication. Regarding the educational applicability of the 3D-printed model, the mean agreement for all eight questionnaire items was above six (seven being complete agreement). Moreover, no significant difference was noted in the agreement scores between specialists and residents.

CONCLUSION

The results revealed that 3D-printed models have good structural accuracy and are potentially beneficial in developing surgical approaches and educating residents. Further research is needed to test the true applicability of these models in the treatment of intracranial and extracranial communicating tumors.

Deformity, etiology, solution, sequence (DESS): Facial analysis in rhinoplasty

PURPOSE

Rhinoplasty is amongst the most challenging surgeries to perfect and can take decades. This process begins during residency; however, residents often have limited exposure to rhinoplasty during their training and lack a standardized method for systematically analyzing and formulating a surgical plan. The DESS (Deformity, Etiology, Solution, Sequence) is a novel educational format for residents that serves to increase their pre-operative comfort with the surgical evaluation and intraoperative planning for a rhinoplasty.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A qualitative study performed at a tertiary academic institution with an otolaryngology residency program evaluating three consecutive residency classes comprised of four residents per class. A 9-item questionnaire was distributed to measure change in resident comfort after utilizing the DESS during their facial plastics rotation. Questionnaire responses highlighted resident comfort with facial nasal analysis, identifying deformities, suggesting surgical maneuvers, and synthesizing a comprehensive surgical plan.

RESULTS

Ten of the twelve residents surveyed responded. Of those that responded, comfort in facial nasal analysis, identification of common nasal deformities, surgical planning, and development of an overall surgical plan were significantly improved after completion of the facial plastic rotation. These residents largely attributed their success to the systematic educational format, with an average score of 4.8/5.0 (SD 0.42).

CONCLUSION

While rhinoplasty is a challenging artform to master, systematic approaches to analysis and operative planning are vital for teaching and guiding residents. Through this novel methodology, residents display significant improvement in their comfort with facial nasal analysis and overall surgical preparation.

Virtual Interviews During COVID-19 Changed Neurosurgery Match-for Better or Worse

OBJECTIVE

The COVID-19 pandemic forced neurosurgery residency application processes to adopt a virtual interview model. This study analyzes the trends in program and applicant residency match behavior due to virtual interviews.

METHODS

National Resident Matching Program data from Main Residency Match, National Resident Matching Program Director and Applicant Survey, Electronic Residency Application Service, and Charting Outcomes in the Match were collected for neurosurgery residents for all available years, providing information on neurosurgery residency application, interview, and match outcomes. Studied years were dichotomized to account for virtual versus in-person interviews and analyzed for differences.

RESULTS

Although the average number of applications received during in-person versus virtual years was not statistically different, 245 versus 290 (P = 0.115), programs interviewed more applicants when interviews were virtual, 37.2 versus 46, (P = 0.008). Similarly, matched U.S. senior applicants did not submit a statistically higher number of applications in person versus virtual, 54 versus 77 (P = 0.055), but they did attend more interviews virtually, 20.5 versus 16.6 (P = 0.013), and ranked more programs, 20 versus 16.2 (P = 0.002). Although White applicants did not have a statistically significant difference in number of applications submitted (55 vs. 68, P = 0.129), Black applicants submitted more applications during virtual match compared with in-person match (52 vs. 74, P = 0.012). The number of applicants that programs needed to rank to fill each position was not statistically different when comparing in-person versus virtually conducted interviews, 4.6 versus 5.4 (P = 0.070).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite no change in the overall number of applications submitted per applicant, Black applicants submitted more applications virtually, suggesting potential benefits of virtual format for Black applicants. Interview format was strongly correlated to the use of perceived fitness by applicants in rank decision making. Virtual interviews provide major financial advantages to candidates and could help improve Black representation in neurosurgery. However, they impose limitations on ability access fitness.

Applying GPT-4 to the Plastic Surgery Inservice Training Examination

BACKGROUND

The recent introduction of Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT)-4 has demonstrated the potential to be a superior version of ChatGPT-3.5. According to many, GPT-4 is seen as a more reliable and creative version of GPT-3.5.

OBJECTIVE

In conjugation with our prior manuscript, we wanted to determine if GPT-4 could be exploited as an instrument for plastic surgery graduate medical education by evaluating its performance on the Plastic Surgery Inservice Training Examination (PSITE).

METHODS

Sample assessment questions from the 2022 PSITE were obtained from the American Council of Academic Plastic Surgeons website and manually inputted into GPT-4. Responses by GPT-4 were qualified using the properties of natural coherence. Incorrect answers were stratified into the consequent categories: informational, logical, or explicit fallacy.

RESULTS

From a total of 242 questions, GPT-4 provided correct answers for 187, resulting in a 77.3% accuracy rate. Logical reasoning was utilized in 95.0% of questions, internal information in 98.3%, and external information in 97.5%. Upon separating the questions based on incorrect and correct responses, a statistically significant difference was identified in GPT-4's application of logical reasoning.

CONCLUSION

GPT-4 has shown to be more accurate and reliable for plastic surgery resident education when compared to GPT-3.5. Users should look to utilize the tool to enhance their educational curriculum. Those who adopt the use of such models may be better equipped to deliver high-quality care to their patients.

Orthopaedic surgery residents report little subjective or objective familiarity with healthcare costs

PURPOSE

Residents have limited education regarding the cost of orthopaedic interventions. Orthopaedic residents' knowledge was surveyed in three scenarios involving an intertrochanteric femur fracture: 1) uncomplicated course with 2-day hospital stay; 2) complicated course necessitating ICU admission; and 3) readmission for pulmonary embolism management.

METHODS

From 2018 to 2020, 69 orthopaedic surgery residents were surveyed. Respondents estimated hospital charges and collections; professional charges and collections; implant cost; and level of knowledge depending on the scenario.

RESULTS

Most residents (83.6%) reported feeling "not knowledgeable". Respondents reporting "somewhat knowledgeable" did not perform better than those who reported "not knowledgeable". In the uncomplicated scenario, residents underestimated hospital charges and collections (p < 0.01; p = 0.87), and overestimated hospital charges and collections and professional collections (all p < 0.01) with an average percent error of 57.2%. Most residents (88.4%) were aware the sliding hip screw construct costs less than a cephalomedullary nail. In the complex scenario, while residents underestimated the hospital charges (p < 0.01), the estimated collections were closer to the actual figure (p = 0.16). In the third scenario, residents overestimated the charges and collections (p = 0.04; p = 0.04).

CONCLUSIONS

Orthopaedic surgery residents receive little education regarding healthcare economics and feel unknowledgeable therefore a role for formal economic education during orthopaedic residency may exist.