Pupil diameter for confirmation of brain death in adult organ donors in Japan

Aim

The criteria for brain death in Japan include a bilateral pupil diameter of ≥4 mm. We evaluated the appropriateness of a 4-mm pupil diameter in adult brain-dead donors in Japan.

Methods

We retrospectively reviewed the records of 148 consecutive adult brain-dead donors with an average age of 46 years. All records were anonymously registered to the Japanese Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (the Japanese Ministry of Health and Welfare before 2001) from the various designated emergency institutes that performed organ donation under brain death from 1999 to 2012 in Japan.

Results

All donors had a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 3, absence of all seven brain stem reflexes, an isoelectric electroencephalogram for >30 min, and apnea as tested by the standard method. All of these examinations were repeated approximately 6 h later for confirmation. The pupil diameter (average ± standard deviation) was 6.1 ± 1.1 mm at the first assessment and 6.4 ± 1.1 mm approximately 6 h later. The 95% probability distribution as calculated by statistical analysis was 3.93-8.30 mm in the left eye and 3.88-8.28 mm in the right eye in the first assessment, and 4.25-8.58 mm in the left eye and 4.32-8.43 mm in the right eye approximately 6 h later.

Conclusion

Despite the various original causes of brain death, we conclude that a pupil diameter of ≥4 mm is a reasonable criterion for brain death in adults.

Halal stunning and slaughter: Criteria for the assessment of dead animals

The debate surrounding the acceptability of stunning for Halal slaughter is one that is likely to linger. Compared to a couple of decades or so ago, one may argue that pre-slaughter stunning is becoming a popular practice during Halal slaughter due to the increasing number of Muslim-majority countries who continue to issue religious rulings (Fatwa) to approve the practice. Concerns have often, however been raised about the likelihood of some animals dying as a result of stunning and whether there are mechanisms in place to identify and remove dead animals stunned with irreversible techniques before their necks are cut. This paper reviews literature about what makes meat Halal, considers the arguments put forward by proponents and opponents of pre-slaughter stunning for Halal production and examines the criteria used by Halal Certification Bodies to identify and reject animals that may die as a result of irreversible stunning and considers the specific risks of waterbath stunning (for poultry) from a Halal viewpoint.

Opinions on the Legitimacy of Brain Death Among Sunni and Shi'a Scholars

The concept of brain death poses a great challenge to clinicians who may be required to bridge the interface of culture, religion, law, and medicine. This review discusses and applies Islamic jurisprudence to the question of whether brain death is accepted as true death under Islamic law. Among the five sources of Islamic law, the Qur'an and Sunnah do not directly address brain death. Scholarly consensus (Ijmā') does not exist, and Qiya does not apply. When applying Ijtihad, the identified collection of non-binding fatwā offer conflicting results. Debate continues as to the validity of brain-death criteria within Islamic circles.

Intracranial pressure and cerebral perfusion pressure in patients developing brain death

PURPOSE

We investigated whether a critical rise of intracranial pressure (ICP) leading to a loss of cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP) could serve as a surrogate marker of brain death (BD).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed ICP and CPP of patients in whom BD was diagnosed (n = 32, 16-79 years). Intracranial pressure and CPP were recorded using parenchymal (n = 27) and ventricular probes (n = 5). Data were analyzed from admission until BD was diagnosed.

RESULTS

Intracranial pressure was severely elevated (mean ± SD, 95.5 ± 9.8 mm Hg) in all patients when BD was diagnosed. In 28 patients, CPP was negative at the time of diagnosis (-8.2 ± 6.5 mm Hg). In 4 patients (12.5%), CPP was reduced but not negative. In these patients, minimal CPP was 4 to 18 mm Hg. In 1 patient, loss of CPP occurred 4 hours before apnea completed the BD syndrome.

CONCLUSIONS

Brain death was universally preceded by a severe reduction of CPP, supporting loss of cerebral perfusion as a critical step in BD development. Our data show that a negative CPP is neither sufficient nor a prerequisite to diagnose BD. In BD cases with positive CPP, we speculate that arterial blood pressure dropped below a critical closing pressure, thereby causing cessation of cerebral blood flow.

The Case for Reasonable Accommodation of Conscientious Objections to Declarations of Brain Death

Since its inception in 1968, the concept of whole-brain death has been contentious, and four decades on, controversy concerning the validity and coherence of whole-brain death continues unabated. Although whole-brain death is legally recognized and medically entrenched in the United States and elsewhere, there is reasonable disagreement among physicians, philosophers, and the public concerning whether brain death is really equivalent to death as it has been traditionally understood. A handful of states have acknowledged this plurality of viewpoints and enacted "conscience clauses" that require "reasonable accommodation" of religious and moral objections to the determination of death by neurological criteria. This paper argues for the universal adoption of "reasonable accommodation" policies using the New Jersey statute as a model, in light of both the ongoing controversy and the recent case of Jahi McMath, a child whose family raised religious objections to a declaration of brain death. Public policies that accommodate reasonable, divergent viewpoints concerning death provide a practical and compassionate way to resolve those conflicts that are the most urgent, painful, and difficult to reconcile.

Of wholes and parts: A Thomistic refutation of "Brain Death"

I propose a refutation of the two major arguments that support the concept of "brain death" as an ontological equivalent to death of the human organism. I begin with a critique of the notion that a body part, such as the brain, could act as "integrator" of a whole body. I then proceed with a rebuttal of the argument that destruction of a body part essential for rational operations-such as the brain-necessarily entails that the remaining whole is indisposed to accrue a rational soul. Next, I point to the equivocal use of the terms "alive" or "living" as being at the root of conceptual errors about brain death. I appeal to the Thomistic definition of life and to the hylomorphic concept of "virtual presence" to clarify this confusion. Finally, I show how the Thomistic definition of life supports the traditional criterion for the determination of death. Lay summary: By the mid-1960s, medical technology became available that could keep "alive" the bodies of patients who had sustained complete and irreversible brain injury. The concept of "brain death" emerged to describe such states. Physicians, philosophers, and ethicists then proposed that the state of brain death is equivalent to the state of death traditionally identified by the absence of spontaneous pulse and respiration. This article challenges the major philosophical arguments that have been advanced to draw this equivalence.

A Thomistic defense of whole-brain death

Michel Accad critiques the currently accepted whole-brain criterion for determining the death of a human being from a Thomistic metaphysical perspective and, in so doing, raises objections to a particular argument defending the whole-brain criterion by Patrick Lee and Germain Grisez. In this paper, I will respond to Accad's critique of the whole-brain criterion and defend its continued validity as a criterion for determining when a human being's death has occurred in accord with Thomistic metaphysical principles. I will, however, join Accad in criticizing Lee and Grisez's proposed defense of the whole-brain criterion as potentially leading to erroneous conclusions regarding the determination of human death. Lay summary: Catholic physicians and bioethicists currently debate the legally accepted clinical standard for determining when a human being has died-known as the "wholebrain criterion"-which has also been morally affirmed by the Magisterium. This paper responds to physician Michel Accad's critique of the whole-brain criterion based upon St. Thomas Aquinas's metaphysical account of human nature as a union of a rational soul and a material body. I defend the whole-brain criterion from the same Thomistic philosophical perspective, while agreeing with Accad's objection to an alternative Thomistic defense of whole-brain death by philosophers Patrick Lee and Germain Grisez.

Impact of time interval between donor brain death and cold preservation on long-term outcome in lung transplantation

OBJECTIVES

Brain death (BD) is associated with various systemic responses and a cascade of inflammatory reactions. It is still unknown how the time interval from BD to cold preservation (CP) affects outcome after lung transplantation (LTx). This report investigates the impact of the time interval from BD to CP on long-term outcome in LTx.

METHODS

We reviewed 250 consecutive recipients who underwent LTx at our institution between January 2000 and December 2011. In Group I (n = 212), the time interval from BD to CP was <24 h, and in Group II (n = 38) >24 h. Cox proportional hazard regression analysis was performed to determine the risk factors affecting survival.

RESULTS

The median time from BD to CP was 18.6 h (range 9-65). The rate of postoperative complications was comparable (P = 0.8). The 30-day mortality rate was 7.5% in Group I and 0% in Group II. The 5-year survival rate was better in Group II [70% (95% CI: 48.5-83.8%)] than in Group I [66% (95% CI: 58.3-72.5%)] without statistical significance (P = 0.3). Intraoperative extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) use was identified as a significant risk factor for survival [HR = 1.7, (95% CI: 1.1-2.6), P = 0.01].

CONCLUSION

In our cohort, the time interval from BD to CP had no impact on long-term outcome after LTx.

[Ancillary procedures in the diagnostics of brain death. Utilization, results and consequences in northeastern Germany]

BACKGROUND

According to the German Medical Council guidelines, the proof of irreversible brain death can be carried out using clinical investigations alone or can necessitate the use of ancillary tests (ATs), depending on the patient age and type of brain injury.

METHODS

Retrospective evaluation of the diagnostics of irreversible brain death, which were carried out using ATs according to the third edition of the guidelines between January 2001 and December 2010 in Berlin, Brandenburg and Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania and were registered at the German National Foundation for Organ Transplantation.

RESULTS

In 1401 patients (aged 0-94 years) a total of 1636 ATs were carried out. The most frequently used additional procedure for the first AT was an electroencephalogram (EEG) in 71.7 %. Confirmatory results regarding irreversibility were reported for 93.6 % of the initial ATs. Negative results of ATs were less common with primary supratentorial brain lesions (2.9 %) compared to infratentorial lesions (13.7 %), secondary hypoxic brain damage (8.1 %) and children younger than 2 years old (18.5 %). Regardless of the AT results, a return of clinical brain function was never documented. The timing, type and repetition of ATs were variable. In most cases the diagnostic process was clearly accelerated by the use of ATs but was significantly delayed in 10.1 % compared to a purely clinical proof of irreversible brain death.

CONCLUSION

ATs by themselves do not provide evidence of the cessation of all brain functions. Instead, they are used to prove the irreversibility of the clinically defined syndrome. For patients over 2 years old and in the absence of primary brainstem lesions, clinical re-assessment and ATs are considered to be equally accurate in demonstrating irreversibility. A standardization of diagnostic procedures between hospitals would be desirable.

Massive cerebral fat embolism leading to brain death: A rare presentation

Fat embolism syndrome (FES) typically consists of a triad of neurological, pulmonary, and cutaneous symptoms. There exist few case reports of FES involving central nervous system (CNS) only without pulmonary involvement. In most of such cases, CNS involvement is partial, and patients recover fully neurologically within days. We report a rare and unusual case of massive cerebral fat embolism that led to brain death in trauma patient.

Role of Transcranial Doppler Sonography in Diagnosis of Brain Death: A Single Center Study

BACKGROUND

Diagnosis of brain death relies on clinical and electroencephalographic (EEG) criteria. Waiting for 24 hours is mandatory to make definitive diagnosis of the condition in the Iranian protocol. Although it has been previously shown that oscillatory or spiked systolic or reversed diastolic flow patterns in transcranial Doppler sonography (TCD) are associated with faster brain death confirmation, it has not yet been approved in our protocol. Thus, the aim of this study was to assess the applicability of this method to our organ donation system.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study was performed in Masih Daneshvari Organ Procurement Unit from July to December 2009. TCD from the middle cerebral and basilar arteries was attempted in 35 patients who fulfilled the clinical and EEG criteria for brain death. Extensive skull defects and hypotension (blood pressure < 80 mmHg) were the exclusion criteria. Examinations were made for about 30 minutes via temporal and occipital windows as soon as possible after diagnosis of brain death.

RESULTS

The mean age of cases was 31.9±14.78 years and 18 (51.4%) were males. The most prevalent cause of brain death was trauma (in 19 or 54.2% of cases). We were unable to detect any intracranial artery in 2 (5.7%) cases. There were no false negative or false positive results in the remaining ones. Detected ultrasonic patterns of cerebral vascular flow were systolic spike and oscillating signal in 29 (87.9%) and 4 (12.1%) donors, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Our study showed that TCD results in brain dead cases were concordant with clinical and EEG criteria. Therefore, TCD, as a confirmatory test, can be applied for rapid diagnosis of brain death.

Spinal-generated movement disorders: a clinical review

Spinal-generated movement disorders (SGMDs) include spinal segmental myoclonus, propriospinal myoclonus, orthostatic tremor, secondary paroxysmal dyskinesias, stiff person syndrome and its variants, movements in brain death, and painful legs-moving toes syndrome. In this paper, we review the relevant anatomy and physiology of SGMDs, characterize and demonstrate their clinical features, and present a practical approach to the diagnosis and management of these unusual disorders.

Novel 24-h ovine model of brain death to study the profile of the endothelin axis during cardiopulmonary injury

BACKGROUND

Upregulation of the endothelin axis has been observed in pulmonary tissue after brain death, contributing to primary graft dysfunction and ischaemia reperfusion injury. The current study aimed to develop a novel, 24-h, clinically relevant, ovine model of brain death to investigate the profile of the endothelin axis during brain death-associated cardiopulmonary injury. We hypothesised that brain death in sheep would also result in demonstrable injury to other transplantable organs.

METHODS

Twelve merino cross ewes were randomised into two groups. Following induction of general anaesthesia and placement of invasive monitoring, brain death was induced in six animals by inflation of an extradural catheter. All animals were supported in an intensive care unit environment for 24 h. Animal management reflected current human donor management, including administration of vasopressors, inotropes and hormone resuscitation therapy. Activation of the endothelin axis and transplantable organ injury were assessed using ELISA, immunohistochemistry and standard biochemical markers.

RESULTS

All animals were successfully supported for 24 h. ELISA suggested early endothelin-1 and big endothelin-1 release, peaking 1 and 6 h after BD, respectively, but there was no difference at 24 h. Immunohistochemistry confirmed the presence of the endothelin axis in pulmonary tissue. Brain dead animals demonstrated tachycardia and hypertension, followed by haemodynamic collapse, typified by a reduction in systemic vascular resistance to 46 ± 1 % of baseline. Mean pulmonary artery pressure rose to 186 ± 20 % of baseline at induction and remained elevated throughout the protocol, reaching 25 ± 2.2 mmHg at 24 h. Right ventricular stroke work increased 25.9 % above baseline by 24 h. Systemic markers of cardiac and hepatocellular injury were significantly elevated, with no evidence of renal dysfunction.

CONCLUSIONS

This novel, clinically relevant, ovine model of brain death demonstrated that increased pulmonary artery pressures are observed after brain death. This may contribute to right ventricular dysfunction and pulmonary injury. The development of this model will allow for further investigation of therapeutic strategies to minimise the deleterious effects of brain death on potentially transplantable organs.

Revisiting the Persisting Tension Between Expert and Lay Views About Brain Death and Death Determination: A Proposal Inspired by Pragmatism

Brain death or determination of death based on the neurological criterion has been an enduring source of controversy in academic and clinical circles. The controversy chiefly concerns how death is defined, and it also bears on the justification of the proposed criteria for death determination and their interpretation. Part of the controversy on brain death and death determination stems from disputed crucial medical facts, but in this paper I formulate another hypothesis about the nature of ongoing controversies. At stake is a misunderstood relationship between, on the one hand, the nature of our lay (or our "manifest image") views about death and, on the other hand, the nature of scientific insights (and related conceptual refinements) into death and its determination (the "scientific image"). The misunderstanding of this relationship has partly anchored the controversy and continues to fuel it. Based on a perspective inspired by pragmatism, which stresses the positive contribution of science to ethical and policy debates but also challenges different forms of scientism in science and philosophy found in foundationalist interpretations, I scrutinize three different stances regarding the relationship between lay and scientific perspectives about the definition of death: (1) foundational lay views, (2) foundational expert views, and (3) co-evolving views. I argue that only the latter is sustainable given recent challenges to foundationalist interpretations.

Brain death determination: the imperative for policy and legal initiatives in Sub-Saharan Africa

The concept of brain death (BD), defined as irreversible loss of function of the brain including the brainstem, is accepted in the medical literature and in legislative policy worldwide. However, in most of Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) there are no legal guidelines regarding BD. Hypothetical scenarios based on our collective experience are presented which underscore the consequences of the absence of BD policies in resource-limited countries (RLCs). Barriers to the development of BD laws exist in an RLC such as Kenya. Cultural, ethnic, and religious diversity creates a complex perspective about death challenging the development of uniform guidelines for BD. The history of the medical legal process in the USA provides a potential way forward. Uniform guidelines for legislation at the state level included special consideration for ethnic or religious preferences in specific states. In SSA, medical and social consensus on the definition of BD is a prerequisite for the development BD legislation. Legislative policy will (1) limit prolonged and futile interventions; (2) mitigate the suffering of families; (3) standardise clinical practice; and (4) facilitate better allocation of scarce critical care resources in RLCs. There is a clear-cut need for these policies, and previous successful policies can serve to guide these efforts.

Descriptive analysis of neurological in-hospital consultations in a tertiary hospital

INTRODUCTION

In-hospital consultations (IHC) are essential in clinical practice in tertiary hospitals. The aim of this study is to analyse the impact of neurological IHCs.

PATIENTS AND METHOD

One-year retrospective descriptive study of neurological IHCs conducted from May 2013 to April 2014 at our tertiary hospital.

RESULTS

A total of 472 patients were included (mean age, 62.1 years; male patients, 56.8%) and 24.4% had previously been evaluated by a neurologist. Patients were hospitalised a median of 18 days and 19.7% had been referred by another hospital. The departments requesting the most in-hospital consultations were intensive care (20.1%), internal medicine (14.4%), and cardiology (9.1%). Reasons for requesting an IHC were stroke (26.9%), epilepsy (20.6%), and confusional states (7.6%). An on-call neurologist evaluated 41.9% of the patients. The purpose of the IHC was to provide a diagnosis in 56.3% and treatment in 28.2% of the cases; 69.5% of the patients required additional tests. Treatment was adjusted in 18.9% of patients and additional drugs were administered to 27.3%. While 62.1% of cases required no additional IHCs, 11% required further assessment, and 4.9% were transferred to the neurology department. Of the patient total, 16.9% died during hospitalisation (in 37.5%, the purpose of the consultation was to certify brain death); 45.6% were referred to the neurology department at discharge and 6.1% visited the emergency department due to neurological impairment within 6 months of discharge.

CONCLUSIONS

IHCs facilitate diagnosis and management of patients with neurological diseases, which may help reduce the number of visits to the emergency department. On-call neurologists are essential in tertiary hospitals, and they are frequently asked to diagnose brain death.

Role of computed tomography angiography and perfusion tomography in diagnosing brain death: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Several complications make the diagnosis of brain death (BD) medically challenging and a complimentary method is needed for confirmation. In this context, computed tomography angiography (CTA) and computed tomography perfusion (CTP) could represent valuable alternatives; however, the reliability of CTA and CTP for confirming brain circulatory arrest remains unclear.

METHODS

A systematic review was performed to identify relevant studies regarding the use of CTA and CTP as ancillary tests for BD confirmation.

RESULTS

Three hundred twenty-two patients were eligible for the meta-analysis, which exhibited 87.5% sensitivity. CTA image evaluation protocol exhibited variations between medical institutions regarding which intracranial vessels should be considered to determine positive or negative test results.

CONCLUSIONS

For patients who were previously diagnosed with BD according to clinical criteria, CTA demonstrated high sensitivity to provide radiologic confirmation. The current evidence that supports the use of CTA in BD diagnosis is comparable to other methods applied worldwide.

Exendin-4 protects rat islets against loss of viability and function induced by brain death

Islet quality loss after isolation from brain-dead donors still hinders the implementation of human islet transplantation for treatment of type 1 diabetes. In this scenario, systemic inflammation elicited by donor brain death (BD) is among the main factors influencing islet viability and functional impairment. Exendin-4 is largely recognized to promote anti-inflammatory and cytoprotective effects on β-cells. Therefore, we hypothesized that administration of exendin-4 to brain-dead donors might improve islet survival and insulin secretory capabilities. Here, using a rat model of BD, we demonstrate that exendin-4 administration to the brain-dead donors increases both islet viability and glucose-stimulated insulin secretion. In this model, exendin-4 treatment produced a significant decrease in interleukin-1β expression in the pancreas. Furthermore, exendin-4 treatment increased the expression of superoxide dismutase-2 and prevented BD-induced elevation in uncoupling protein-2 expression. Such observations were accompanied by a reduction in gene expression of two genes often associated with endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress response in freshly isolated islets from treated animals, C/EBP homologous protein and immunoglobulin heavy-chain binding protein. As ER stress response has been shown to be triggered by and to participate in cytokine-induced β-cell death, we suggest that exendin-4 might exert its beneficial effects through alleviation of pancreatic inflammation and oxidative stress, which in turn could prevent islet ER stress and β-cell death. Our findings might unveil a novel strategy to preserve islet quality from brain-dead donors. After testing in the human pancreatic islet transplantation setting, this approach might sum to the ongoing effort to achieve consistent and successful single-donor islet transplantation.

Simulation-based training for determination of brain death by pediatric healthcare providers

Background

Low competency for determination of brain death (BD) and unfamiliarity with Japanese BD (JBD) criteria among pediatricians were highlighted in previous nationwide studies. Because the JBD criteria were amended in 2010 to allow organ donation from pediatric brain-dead donors, we created a 2-day training course to assess knowledge and improve skill in the determination and diagnosis of pediatric BD.

Methods

The course consisted of two modules: a multistation round session and a group discussion session, and was bookended by a before and after 20-question test. In the multistation round session, participants rotated between stations staffed by expert faculty members. For hands-on skill development, we used the Sim Junior 3G™ simulation mannequin (Laerdal Medical, Wappingers Falls, NY, USA) for structured simulations. In the group discussion session, we implemented simulation-based role playing to practice decision making in prepared scenarios of complicated clinical situations. We investigated the participants’ impressions of the course by self-scoring and questionnaires.

Results

Of 147 pediatric healthcare providers from multiple specialties who participated in this course, 145 completed the entire process. The course was evaluated in three aspects with self-scoring and questionnaires: (1) value (4.58 ± 0.64; range 1–5); (2) time schedule (2.40 ± 0.61; range 1–3); and (3) difficulty (2.89 ± 0.43; range 1–5). Finally, participants scored the entire course program (9.64 ± 1.69; range 1–11). Various positive feedbacks were obtained from a total of 93 participants. Post-test scores (83.6 %) were significantly higher than pre-test scores (62.9 %).

Conclusion

This simulation-based course represents an effective method to train pediatric healthcare providers in determining BD in Japan and may improve baseline knowledge of BD among participants.

Moral Evaluations of Organ Transplantation Influence Judgments of Death and Causation

Two experiments investigated whether moral evaluations of organ transplantation influence judgments of death and causation. Participants’ beliefs about whether an unconscious organ donor was dead and whether organ removal caused death in a hypothetical vignette varied depending on the moral valence of the vignette. Those who were randomly assigned to the good condition (vs. bad) were more likely to believe that the donor was dead prior to organ removal and that organ removal did not cause death. Furthermore, attitudes toward euthanasia and organ donation independently predicted judgments of death and causation, regardless of experimental condition. The results are discussed in light of the framework of motivated reasoning, in which motivation influences the selection of cognitive processes and representations applied to a given domain, as well as Knobe’s person-as-moralist model, in which many basic concepts are appropriately imbued with moral features. On either explanatory framework, these data cast doubt on the psychological legitimacy of the mainstream justification for vital organ procurement from heart-beating donors, which holds that neurological criteria for death are scientifically justified, independently of concerns about organ transplantation. These data suggest that, rather than concluding that organ removal is permissible because the donor is dead, people may believe that the donor is dead because they believe organ removal to be permissible.

[Early human transplants: 60th anniversary of the first successful kidney transplants]

First kidney transplant attempts begin with the 20th century: improving vascular sutures, understanding the phenomena of rejection or tolerance, then progress in HLA groups enable early success in the second half of the century. Definition of brain death, use of corticosteroids, radiotherapy and prime immunosuppressors promote the development of transplants. Discover of cyclosporine in the 1980s, and legislative developments augur a new era. Many advances are arising: use of stem cells from the donor, enhancement of Maastricht 3 donor or living donation. Finally organ transplantation remains an immense human adventure, but also scientific and ethic.

Renaissance of criticism on the concept of brain death--the role of legal medicine in the context of the interdisciplinary discussion

BACKGROUND

In the practice of legal medicine in Germany, the assessment of brain death is of minor importance and attracts little attention. However, since several years, international criticism on the concept of brain death has culminated. By reviewing literature and the results of a questionnaire distributed among the participants of the 93rd Annual Congress of the Germany Society of Legal Medicine, the state of knowledge and the current views on brain death were evaluated.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Literature search of recent publications regarding brain death was performed (PubMed database, references of legal medicine, Report of the President's Council on Bioethics, USA 2008). A questionnaire was developed and distributed among the participants of the Congress.

RESULTS

The assumption that individual and brain death are synonymous is criticized. Internationally, there are trends to harmonize the very different clinical criteria to assess brain death. The diagnostic advantage of novel techniques such as CT angiography is controversially discussed. It becomes apparent that procedures which record the blood flow and perfusion of the brain will be applied more in the future. Regrettably, these developments are not described in the literature of legal medicine. Moreover, among German forensic scientists, different views concerning brain death exist. The majority favors its equivalent treatment with individual death. The thanatological background can be improved concerning certain aspects of brain death as well as its legal implications.

CONCLUSION

Teaching and research in legal medicine should include the subject brain death. Expertise in forensic science may contribute to the interdisciplinary discussion on brain death. The transfer of actual knowledge, also on disputed ethical aspects of thanatology, to physicians of all disciplines is of great importance.

Effect of sufentanil preconditioning on liver apoptosis induced by brain death in rats

AIM: To investigate the effect of sufentanil against liver apoptosis induced by brain death in rats.

METHODS: Eighteen SD rats were randomly divided into three groups: a sham operation group, a brain death group and a sufentanil group. Activation of cytochrome c (Cyt-c) and Caspase3 was examined by the immunohistochemical staining (IHC) and Western blot. Apoptosis was assessed by terminal deoxynucleotide transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end nick-end labeling assay (TUNEL). Brain death was induced by gradually increasing intracranial pressure (ICP). Sufentanil (10 μg/kg) was injected 1 h before induction of brain death.

RESULTS: Liver tissue samples harvested after brain death showed increased activation of Cyt-c and Caspase3 (P < 0.05). Consistent with this, TUNEL analysis confirmed apoptosis in the liver following brain death. Sufentanil significantly decreases levels of Cyt-c and Caspase3 compared to the brain death group (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION: Sufentanil preconditioning has a protective effect in reducing liver apoptosis induced by brain death in rats.

Brain death and management of a potential organ donor in the intensive care unit

The concept of brain death developed with the advent of mechanical ventilation, and guidelines for determining brain death have been refined over time. Organ donation after brain death is a common source of transplant organs in Western countries. Early identification and notification of organ procurement organizations are essential. Management of potential organ donors must take into consideration specific pathophysiologic changes for medical optimization. Future aims in intensive and neurocritical care medicine must include reducing practice variability in the operational guidelines for brain death determination, as well as improving communication with families about the process of determining brain death.