Ground-based research with heavy ions for space radiation protection

Human exposure to ionizing radiation is one of the acknowledged potential showstoppers for long duration manned interplanetary missions. Human exploratory missions cannot be safely performed without a substantial reduction of the uncertainties associated with different space radiation health risks, and the development of effective countermeasures. Most of our knowledge of the biological effects of heavy charged particles comes from accelerator-based experiments. During the 35th COSPAR meeting, recent ground-based experiments with high-energy iron ions were discussed, and these results are briefly summarised in this paper. High quality accelerator-based research with heavy ions will continue to be the main source of knowledge of space radiation health effects and will lead to reductions of the uncertainties in predictions of human health risks. Efforts in materials science, nutrition and pharmaceutical sciences and their rigorous evaluation with biological model systems in ground-based accelerator experiments will lead to the development of safe and effective countermeasures to permit human exploration of the Solar System.

DNA DSB induced by iron ions in human fibroblasts: LET dependence and shielding efficiency

This paper reports on DNA DSB induction in human fibroblasts by iron ions of different energies, namely 5, 1 GeV/u, 414 and 115 MeV/u, in absence or presence of different shields (PMMA, Al and Pb). Measure of DNA DSB was performed by calibrated Pulsed Field Gel Electrophoresis using the fragment counting method. The RBE-LET relationships for unshielded and shielded beams were obtained both in terms of dose average LET and of track average LET. Weak dependence on these parameters was observed for DSB induction. The shielding efficiency, evaluated by the ratio between the cross sections for unshielded and shielded beams, depends not only on the shield type and thickness, but also on the beam energy. Protection is only observed at high iron ions energy, especially at 5 GeV/u, where PMMA shield gives higher protection compared to Al or Pb shields of the same thickness expressed in g/cm2.

Comparison of genotoxic damage in monolayer cell cultures and three-dimensional tissue-like cell assemblies

Assessing the biological risks associated with exposure to the high-energy charged particles encountered in space is essential for the success of long-term space exploration. Although prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell models developed in our laboratory and others have advanced our understanding of many aspects of genotoxicity, in vitro models are needed to assess the risk to humans from space radiation insults. Such models must be representative of the cellular interactions present in tissues and capable of quantifying genotoxic damage. Toward this overall goal, the objectives of this study were to examine the effect of the localized microenvironment of cells, cultured as either 2-dimensional (2D) monolayers or 3-dimensional (3D) aggregates, on the rate and type of genotoxic damage resulting from exposure to Fe-charged particles, a significant portion of space radiation. We used rodent transgenic cell lines containing 50-70 copies of a LacI transgene to provide the enhanced sensitivity required to quantify mutational frequency and type in the 1100-bp LacI target as well as assessment of DNA damage to the entire 45-kbp construct. Cultured cells were exposed to high energy Fe charged particles at Brookhaven National Laboratory's Alternating Gradient Synchrotron facility for a total dose ranging from 0.1 to 2 Gy and allowed to recover for 0-7 days, after which mutational type and frequency were evaluated. The mutational frequency was found to be higher in 3D samples than in 2D samples at all radiation doses. Mutational frequency also was higher at 7 days after irradiation than immediately after exposure. DNA sequencing of the mutant targets revealed that deletional mutations contributed an increasingly high percentage (up to 27%) of all mutations in cells as the dose was increased from 0.5 to 2 Gy. Several mutants also showed large and complex deletions in multiple locations within the LacI target. However, no differences in mutational type were found between the 2D and the 3D samples. These 3D tissue-like model systems can reduce the uncertainty involved in extrapolating risk between in vitro cellular and in vivo models.

High LET-induced H2AX phosphorylation around the Bragg curve

We investigated the spatial distribution of the induction of the phosphorylated form of the histone protein H2AX (gamma-H2AX), known to be activated by DSBs. Following irradiation of human fibroblast cells with 600 MeV/nucleon silicon and 600 MeV/nucleon iron ions we observed the formation of gamma-H2AX aggregates in the shape of streaks stretching over several micrometers in an x/y plane. Polyethylene shielding was used to achieve a Bragg curve distribution with beam geometry parallel to the monolayer of cells. We present data that highlights the formation of immunofluorescent gamma-H2AX tracks showing the ion trajectories across the Bragg peak of irradiated human fibroblast cells. Qualitative analyses of these distributions indicated potentially increased clustering of DNA damage before the Bragg peak, enhanced gamma-H2AX distribution at the peak, and provided visual evidence of high-linear energy transfer particle traversal of cells beyond the Bragg peak in agreement with one-dimensional transport approximations. Spatial assessment of gamma-H2AX fluorescence may provide direct insights into DNA damage across the Bragg curve for high charge and energy ions including the biological consequences of shielding and possible contributors to bystander effects.

Towards a heavy-ion transport capability in the MARS15 code

In order to meet the challenges of new accelerator and space projects and further improve modelling of radiation effects in microscopic objects, heavy-ion interaction and transport physics have been recently incorporated into the MARS15 Monte Carlo code. A brief description of new modules is given in comparison with experimental data.

Fragmentation of 1 GeV/nucleon iron ions in thick targets relevant for space exploration

We have measured charged nuclear fragments produced by 1 GeV/nucleon 56Fe ions interacting with aluminium, polyethylene and lead. These materials are relevant for assessment of radiation risk for manned space flight. The data will be presented in a form suitable for comparison with models of nuclear fragmentation and transport, including linear energy transfer (LET) spectrum, fluence for iron and fragments, event-tack- and event-dose-averaged LET, total dose and iron contribution to dose.

Fragmentation studies of relativistic iron ions using plastic nuclear track detectors

We measured fluence and fragmentation of high-energy (1 or 5 A GeV) 56Fe ions accelerated at the Alternating Gradient Synchrotron or at the NASA Space Radiation Laboratory (Brookhaven National Laboratory, NY, USA) using solid-state CR-39 nuclear track detectors. Different targets (polyethylene, PMMA, C, Al, Pb) were used to produce a large spectrum of charged fragments. CR-39 plastics were exposed both in front and behind the shielding block (thickness ranging from 5 to 30 g/cm2) at a normal incidence and low fluence. The radiation dose deposited by surviving Fe ions and charged fragments was measured behind the shield using an ionization chamber. The distribution of the measured track size was exploited to distinguish the primary 56Fe ions tracks from the lighter fragments. Measurements of projectile's fluence in front of the shield were used to determine the dose per incident particle behind the block. Simultaneous measurements of primary 56Fe ion tracks in front and behind the shield were used to evaluate the fraction of surviving iron projectiles and the total charge-changing fragmentation cross-section. These physical measurements will be used to characterize the beam used in parallel biological experiments.

Analysis of secondary electron emission spectra of equal-LET protons and alpha particles for purposes of radiation quality and spaceflight hazard assessment

Amongst the great variety of heavy particles present in the galactic and solar cosmic ray spectra, hydrogen and helium nuclei are significantly more abundant than all other heavier ions and, as such, represent a major radiation hazard to humans in space. Experimental data have suggested that differences in relative biological effectiveness (RBE) exist between the two species at the same value of linear energy transfer (LET). This has consequences for heavily ionising radiation protection procedures, which currently still assume a simple dependence of radiation quality on LET. By analysing the secondary electron (delta-ray) emission spectra of protons and alpha particles, in terms of the spatial characteristics of energy deposition in cellular targets and the likelihood of complex lesion formation, a numerical quantity representing biological effectiveness is generated. When expressed relative to a reference radiation, this quantity is found to differ for protons and a particles of the same LET, demonstrating not only the ion-specific nature of RBE but also the inadequacy of specifying radiation quality as a function of LET only. Such a method for numerically assessing radiation quality may have implications for procedures for heavy ion protection in space at low doses and for understanding the initial mechanisms of radiation action.

Comparison doses of secondary neutron with the heavy ions in a 75-Mev/n heavy ion beam

The angular distributions for neutrons of energy >6 MeV that are induced by 75 MeV/n 12C6+ and 16O8+ ions were measured with the activation method of Al threshold detectors at the radiobiological terminal of HIRFL. The data were obtained by a high-purity Ge(HpGe) detector. The results show that the neutron angular distributions produced by heavy ion beams are strongly peaked in the forward direction and decreased exponentially with angles in experimental area. The experimental conditions for these measurements were similar to those for biological experiments, so the results should be representative of neutrons produced by heavy ions during the biological experiments and tumour therapy. Comparing with the neutron doses produced by the heavy ion beam, the heavy ion dose is the main factor in biological effects and tumour therapy response, so the contribution of neutron dose can be neglected.

Mice heterozygous for the ATM gene are more sensitive to both X-ray and heavy ion exposure than are wildtypes

Previous studies have shown that the eyes of ATM heterozygous mice exposed to low-LET radiation (X-rays) are significantly more susceptible to the development of cataracts than are those of wildtype mice. The findings, as well as others, run counter to the assumption underpinning current radiation safety guidelines, that individuals are all equally sensitive to the biological effects of radiation. A question, highly relevant to human space activities is whether or not, in similar fashion there may exist a genetic predisposition to high-LET radiation damage. Mice haplodeficient for the ATM gene and wildtypes were exposed to 325 mGy of 1 GeV/amu 56Fe ions at the AGS facility of Brookhaven National Laboratory. The fluence was equivalent to 1 ion per lens epithelial cell nuclear area. Controls consisted of irradiated wildtype as well as unirradiated wildtype and heterozygous mice. Prevalence analyses for stage 0.5-3.0 cataracts indicated that not only cataract onset but also progression were accelerated in the mice haplo-deficient for the ATM gene. The data show that heterozygosity for the ATM gene predisposes the eye to the cataractogenic influence of heavy ions and suggest that ATM heterozygotes in the human population may also be radiosensitive. This may have to be considered in the selection of individuals who will be exposed to both HZE particles and low-LET radiation as they may be predisposed to increased late normal tissue damage.

Chromosome aberration yields and apoptosis in human lymphocytes irradiated with Fe-ions of differing LET

In the present paper the relationship between cell cycle delays induced by Fe-ions of differing LET and the aberration yield observable in human lymphocytes at mitosis was examined. Cells of the same donor were irradiated with 990 MeV/n Fe-ions (LET=155 keV/micrometers), 200 MeV/n Fe-ions (LET=440 keV/micrometers) and X-rays and aberrations were measured in first cycle mitoses harvested at different times after 48-84 h in culture and in prematurely condensed G2-cells (PCCs) collected at 48 h using calyculin A. Analysis of the time-course of chromosomal damage in first cycle metaphases revealed that the aberration frequency was similar after X-ray irradiation, but increased two and seven fold after exposure to 990 and 200 MeV/n Fe-ions, respectively. Consequently, RBEs derived from late sampling times were significantly higher than those obtained at early times. The PCC-data suggest that the delayed entry of heavily damaged cells into mitosis results especially from a prolonged arrest in G2. Preliminary data obtained for 4.1 MeV/n Cr-ions (LET=3160 keV/micrometers) revealed, that these delays are even more pronounced for low energy Fe-like particles. Additionally, for the different radiation qualities, BrdU-labeling indices and apoptotic indices were determined at several time-points. Only the exposure to low energy Fe-like particles affected the entry of lymphocytes into S-phase and generated a significant apoptotic response indicating that under this particular exposure condition a large proportion of heavily damaged cells is rapidly eliminated from the cell population. The significance of this observation for the estimation of the health risk associated with space radiation remains to be elucidated.

Benchmarking of MCNPX with the experimental measurements of high-energy helium ions in HIMAC facility

The main aim of this study is the qualfication of MCNPX code by using the experimental information obtained at HIMAC facility on the bombardment of different materials with He ions accelerated to 100 and 180 MeV/nucleon. The flux of secondary neutrons at different angles relative to ion direction is calculated and compared with published experimental data. Main findings are the reasonable modelling of the high-energy part of the secondary neutrons at forward angles and the code fail for the low-energy part.

Magnetic field tracking with MCNP5

With the introduction of continuous-energy heavy charged particle transport in MCNP5, the need for tracking charged particles in a magnetic field becomes increasingly important. Two methods for including magnetic field effects on charged particles are included in the proton transport version of the code. The first technique utilises transfer maps produced by the beam dynamics simulation and analysis code COSY INFINITY. This method is fast and accurate; however, its use is limited to void cells only and to ensembles of particles with a fairly small energy spread. The second technique, particle ray tracing, is based on an algorithm adopted from the MARS transport code. This method can be applied to both void and material cells and is valid over a very large range of particle energies. Results from tracking particles in a quadrupole 'identity lens' using the two techniques are compared.

Comparison between calculation and measured data on secondary neutron energy spectra by heavy ion reactions from different thick targets

Measured neutron energy fluences from high-energy heavy ion reactions through targets several centimeters to several hundred centimeters thick were compared with calculations made using the recently developed general-purpose particle and heavy ion transport code system (PHITS). It was confirmed that the PHITS represented neutron production by heavy ion reactions and neutron transport in thick shielding with good overall accuracy.

Monte Carlo simulations for the shielding of the future high-intensity accelerator facility FAIR at GSI

The Gesellschaft für Schwerionenforschung (GSI) is planning a significant expansion of its accelerator facilities. Compared to the present GSI facility, a factor of 100 in primary beam intensities and up to a factor of 10,000 in secondary radioactive beam intensities are key technical goals of the proposal. The second branch of the so-called Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research (FAIR) is the production of antiprotons and their storage in rings and traps. The facility will provide beam energies a factor of approximately 15 higher than presently available at the GSI for all ions, from protons to uranium. The shielding design of the synchrotron SIS 100/300 is shown exemplarily by using Monte Carlo calculations with the FLUKA code. The experimental area serving the investigation of compressed baryonic matter is analysed in the same way. In addition, a dose comparison is made for an experimental area operated with medium energy heavy-ion beams. Here, Monte Carlo calculations are performed by using either heavy-ion primary particles or proton beams with intensities scaled by the mass number of the corresponding heavy-ion beam.

Direct visualisation of heavy ion induced DNA fragmentation using Atomic Force Microscopy

Atomic Force Microscopy of phiX174 plasmids irradiated in vitro was used to visualise the DNA fragmentation induced by heavy ions and to compare it to the fragmentation pattern obtained after X-irradiation. Fragment distributions induced by low ion fuences were found to be much more shifted towards small fragment sizes than the distributions obtained after corresponding doses of X-rays. The average fragment length was found to be significantly smaller than the full plasmid length even for single ion traversals.

On the uncertainty in activity measurements for samples containing “hot particles”

The uncertainty in activity measurements for samples containing hot particles is considered under three assumptions: (1) all activity in the samples is due to hot particles; (2) hot particle dimensions are log-normally distributed with the logarithm of the median radius m and the standard deviation of the logarithm of the particle radius s; and (3) the number of particles in the sample is a random quantity. It is shown that the measurement uncertainty grows when both s and m increase. Also, that for s < 0.25-0.3 the primary source of uncertainty is the randomness of the number of particles in the sample, and, if s exceeds 0.3, the "log-normality" effect becomes more dominant. The values of the variance/uncertainty estimated by the measurement of replicate aliquots from a single sample can be used for the estimation of the m and s relationship and boundary values of these parameters.

Chromosome fragmentation after irradiation with C ions

The premature chromosome condensation (PCC) technique has been used to compare chromatin breakage and repair in non-cycling CHO-K1 cells following high LET (C ions) and low LET (X-rays) irradiation. For both radiation qualities the average initial number of excess PCC fragments increases linearly with dose. However, the frequency of chromatin breaks follows the pattern of energy deposition and at higher LET values reveals clustering due to the large number of ionizing events being concentrated in a small volume of the cell nucleus. In consequence, the distribution of PCC chromosomes plus excess fragments among cells has followed Poisson statistics after X-ray irradiation while the overdispersion of the frequencies has been observed after C-irradiation indicating that a single particle traversal through a cell nucleus can produce multiple chromatin lesions.

Microbeams of heavy charged particles

We have established a single cell irradiation system, which allows selected cells to be individually hit with defined number of heavy charged particles, using a collimated heavy-ion microbeam apparatus at JAERI-Takasaki. This system has been developed to study radiobiological processes in hit cells and bystander cells exposed to low dose and low dose-rate high-LET radiations, in ways that cannot be achieved using conventional broad-field exposures. Individual cultured cells grown in special dishes were irradiated in the atmosphere with a single or defined numbers of 18.3 MeV/amu 12C, 13.0 MeV/amu 20Ne, and 11.5 MeV/amu 40Ar ions. Targeting and irradiation of the cells were performed automatically at the on-line microscope of the microbeam apparatus according to the positional data of the target cells obtained at the off-line microscope before irradiation. The actual number of particle tracks that pass through cell nuclei was detected with prompt etching of the bottom of the cell dish made of ion track detector TNF-1 (modified CR-39), with alkaline-ethanol solution at 37 degrees C for 15-30 minutes. Using this system, separately inoculated Chinese hamster ovary cells, confluent normal human fibroblasts, and single plant cells (tobacco protoplasts) have been irradiated. These are the first studies in which single-ion direct hit effect and the bystander effect have been investigated using a high-LET heavy particle microbeam.

Focused ion beam for microscopy and in situ sample preparation: application on a crustacean digestive system

We prove that the focused ion beam (FIB) machine can be used as a microscope and as an in situ cutting device for tissue and cells. For the first time we obtain high-resolution ion images, complemented by electron imaging of different animal tissues both from uncoated and coated samples. In our study, we select the digestive system of Porcellio scaber (isopoda, crustacea) as a test system for FIB microscopy and in situ sample preparation. After the milling operation, some of the ultrastructural elements of hepatopancreatic cells can clearly be recognized. Also, FIB operation reveals significant differences in structural integrity between the apical and basal parts of hepatopancreatic cells, which have not been observed before by classical microscopy techniques. FIB microscopy and in situ sample preparation have advantages over classical microscopy techniques because of: 1. in situ site-specific 2-D sectioning and imaging of subsurface microstructures; 2. no need to embed the sample prior to sectioning; and 3. a wide range of magnifications while imaging the same sample.

System of cell irradiation with a defined number of heavy ions (III)

A single cell irradiation system has been developed at JAERI-Takasaki to study radiobiological processes in single-ion-hit mammalian cells and bystander cells, in ways that cannot be achieved using conventional broad field exposures. Individual mammalian cultured cells are irradiated in the atmosphere on the cell dish, the bottom of which is made of ion-track-detector CR-39, with a single or defined numbers of 13.0 MeV/amu 20Ne and 11.5 MeV/amu 40Ar ions. Targeting and irradiation of the cells are performed automatically at the on-line microscope of the microbeam apparatus according to the positional data of the target cells obtained at the off-line microscope before irradiation. Using this system, Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cells were irradiated with counted number of 20Ne and 40Ar ions. Thereafter, the growth of the cells was observed individually and repeatedly during post-irradiation incubation. The cells hit by a single 40Ar ion on their nucleus showed strong growth inhibition. Meanwhile, the cells in the irradiated dish but not hit by the ion (bystander cells) showed limited cell growth. This might be a bystander effect caused by heavy ion hit cell co-existing in the same dish.

Space Radiation Transport Properties of Polyethylene-Based Composites

Composite materials that can serve as both effective shielding materials against cosmic-ray and energetic solar particles in deep space, as well as structural materials for habitat and spacecraft, remain a critical and mission enabling component in mission planning and exploration. Polyethylene is known to have excellent shielding properties due to its low density, coupled with high hydrogen content. Polyethylene-fiber reinforced composites promise to combine this shielding effectiveness with the required mechanical properties of structural materials. Samples of polyethylene-fiber reinforced epoxy matrix composite 1-5 cm thick were prepared at the NASA Marshall Space Flight Center and tested against a 500 MeV/nucleon Fe beam at the HIMAC facility of NIRS in Chiba, Japan. This paper presents measured and calculated results for the radiation transport properties of these samples.

Detection of adaptive response at chromosome level

We have just started the basic study to detect the genetic alterations at chromosome level as a result of radioadaptive response. The assay system is based upon the analysis of loss of heterozygosity (LOH) induced in human lymphoblastoid cell TK6, which were pre-irradiated with low-doses of ionizing radiation (IR) before the challenging irradiation. In our previous study, this analysis was shown to be very sensitive to IR because the radiation-specific hemizygous LOHs (interstitial deletions) were observed after 10 cGy of IR (X-rays or accelerated carbon-ion beam). Here, we would like to introduce our plan how to detect the changes in such radiation-specific LOH patterns by the pre-irradiation of TK6. If we succeed the detection, the radioadaptation assay system can be used for elucidating the biological effects of low-doses of space ionizing radiation. In addition, we are also considering the modification of assay system by introducing the site-specific chromosome breakage (DNA double-strand break) instead of challenging IR. Furthermore, the preliminary results of the experiments using frozen TK6 cells for the preparation of ISS experiments.

Formation and stability of complex organic compounds in space environments

Complex organic compounds have been found in extraterrestrial bodies such as meteorites and comets. We confirmed the formation of complex organic compounds that contained amino acid precursors from a mixture of carbon monoxide (or methanol), ammonia and water by radiation or UV. Molecular weights of the complex organics were several thousands. Stability of the complex precursors was studied. When free amino acids were irradiated with gamma rays or synchrotron radiation, they easily decomposed. The complex precursors were, however, much more stable than free amino acid against irradiation. We propose to examine the formation and alteration of amino acid precursors in space by using exposed facility of ISS.