Childhood vaccination against varicella: persistence of antibody, duration of protection, and vaccine efficacy

OBJECTIVE

To document the duration of protection afforded by Oka/Merck varicella vaccine over a 7-year period.

STUDY DESIGN

The subjects were healthy children 1 to 12 years of age originally enrolled in clinical studies to evaluate the primary immune response to varicella vaccine 6 weeks after vaccination. Each was monitored for antibody persistence, breakthrough infection, and household exposure to varicella to produce estimates of vaccine efficacy.

RESULTS

The 6-year cumulative varicella antibody persistence rate was 99.5% (95% CI: 98.9%, 100.0%). The annual breakthrough rate through 7 years ranged from 0.2% to 2.3% per year; the estimated cumulative event rate was 6.5%. Comparison of the observed average annual breakthrough rate with the age-adjusted expected annual incidence rate of varicella in unvaccinated children corresponded to an estimated vaccine efficacy of 93.8% to 94.6%. Eighty vaccinated children were exposed to varicella in the household, resulting in 8 (10%) cases of infection. When compared with the historical attack rate of 86.8% in unvaccinated susceptible persons exposed to varicella in the household, this yields an estimated vaccine efficacy of 88.5% (95% CI: 80.9%, 96.1%). Varicella cases in vaccinated children generally were mild.

CONCLUSION

The live attenuated varicella vaccine is highly effective in inducing persistent immunity and long-term protection against breakthrough varicella infection.

Measuring injection-site pain associated with vaccine administration in adults: a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial

BACKGROUND

Pain at the injection site is one of the most commonly-reported local reactions associated with administration of a vaccine, but it has not been quantified by a validated instrument for pain measurement. We conducted a randomised, double-blind clinical trial to evaluate the measurement characteristics of two commonly-used pain questionnaires, the McGill Present Pain Intensity (PPI) and the Brief Pain Inventory (BPI) Current Pain Question, in the assessment of intramuscular injection-site pain associated with vaccine administration. The PPI measures pain on a scale of 0 (no pain) to 5 (excruciating pain) and the BPI measures pain on a scale of 0 (no pain) to 10 (pain as bad as you can imagine).

METHODS

Two hundred healthy adults were randomised to one of the five regimens: tetanus and diphtheria toxoids adsorbed (Td), aluminum hydroxide adjuvant (alum), physiological saline, or one of the two licensed hepatitis A vaccines, VAQTA, or HAVRIX. Pain assessment was made at eight time-points over a 2-day period after injection.

RESULTS

The differences in the time-averaged pain (+/- standard deviation) on the PPI were statistically significant between Td (0.58+/-0.59) and either saline (0.14+/-0.23) (p < 0.005) or alum (0.22+/-0.35) (p < 0.01). Reported time-averaged pain were significantly lower for VAQTA than HAVRIX (p = 0.028). Similar differences were observed for the BPI.

CONCLUSIONS

Both instruments have sufficient discriminative validity to distinguish between different levels of injection-site pain in adults.

Safety, tolerability and immunogenicity of concomitant injections in separate locations of M-M-R II, VARIVAX and TETRAMUNE in healthy children vs. concomitant injections of M-M-R II and TETRAMUNE followed six weeks later by VARIVAX

OBJECTIVES AND STUDY DESIGN

The primary objectives of this study were to compare immunologic responses, antibody persistence, safety and varicella breakthrough rates when VARIVAX (varicella vaccine) is given at the same time as M-M-R II (measles, mumps, rubella vaccine) and TETRAMUNE (conjugate Haemophilus influenzae type b, diphtheria, tetanus and whole cell pertussis vaccine) at separate injection sites (Group A) vs. VARIVAX given 6 weeks after M-M-R II and TETRAMUNE (Group B). Six hundred nine healthy children, 12 to 23 months of age, were randomized to one of two treatment (immunization) groups (Group A and Group B). Blood for antibody titers was drawn on the day of immunization, 6 weeks after each injection and 1 year later. Local and systemic adverse reactions were recorded. Exposure and cases of varicella were documented through a 1-year follow-up period.

RESULTS

Measles, mumps and rubella seroconversion rates and geometric mean titers (GMTs) were similar for both treatment groups. Varicella seroconversion rates were also similar between groups. However, varicella GMTs and percent with a varicella-protective level [> or =5.0 glycoprotein (gp) enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) units] did not meet the prespecified criteria for similarity were lower for Group A (GMT 10.5; 82.8% > or =5.0 gp ELISA units) than for Group B (GMT 14.5; 91.2% > or =5.0 gp ELISA units). The GMTs between groups for other antibodies were similar. At the 1-year follow-up antibody titers were comparable in both groups and breakthrough varicella cases appeared generally similar. There were fewer local adverse events (AEs) at the VARIVAX injection sites (9.8% and 2.9%, Group A and B, respectively) than at the TETRAMUNE sites (27.9% and 24.0%). Systemic AEs were not statistically different when M-M-R II was administered alone (8.6%) or concomitantly with VARIVAX (8.9%). When VARIVAX was given alone AEs were 1.8%. The rate of fever > or =102 degrees F after M-M-R II and TETRAMUNE administered together was 10.7% on Days 0 to 3 and 23.7% on Days 7 to 21. When VARIVAX was administered alone, the rate of fever was 5.4% on Days 0 to 3 (P = 0.018) and 10.8% on Days 7 to 21 (P<0.001).

CONCLUSION

Because the varicella titers were comparable and varicella breakthrough rates generally similar at 1 year in both groups, we expect that the concomitant administration of VARIVAX with M-M-R II and TETRAMUNE has clinical effectiveness similar to that with VARIVAX 6 weeks after the administration of these other two vaccines. VARIVAX appears to be less reactogenic than M-M-R II and TETRAMUNE.

Safety and immunogenicity of concurrent administration of measles-mumps-rubella-varicella vaccine and PedvaxHIB vaccines in healthy children twelve to eighteen months old. The MMRV Study Group

OBJECTIVE

To determine the safety and immunogenicity of concurrent administration of measles-mumps-rubella-varicella vaccine (MMRV) and PedvaxHIB (Haemophilus influenzae type b conjugate vaccine) vs. M-M-R II and PedvaxHIB followed by an optional dose of VARIVAX 6 weeks later.

DESIGN

Healthy children, 12 to 18 months of age, were randomly assigned to two groups to receive (1) MMRV and PedvaxHIB given concurrently or (2) M-M-R II and PedvaxHIB followed by an optional dose of VARIVAX 6 weeks later.

SUBJECTS

The study group included 294 healthy children, ages 12 to 18 months, with a negative history of measles, mumps, rubella and varicella.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The seroconversion rate and magnitude of antibody responses when MMRV was given concurrently with PedvaxHIB compared with the antibody responses when VARIVAX was given 6 weeks after M-M-R II and PedvaxHIB.

RESULTS

Healthy children, 12 to 18 months of age, who received MMRV and PedvaxHIB concurrently showed immune responses similar to those in the control group who received M-M-RII vaccine with PedvaxHIB followed by VARIVAX 6 weeks later. Antibody titers for varicella were significantly lower when MMRV was administered than when varicella vaccine was given separately (0.712-fold difference, P = 0.028). No vaccine-related serious adverse reactions were reported, and no clinically significant differences were seen in the safety profiles of the two treatment groups.

CONCLUSIONS

There were no statistically significant differences in the seroconversion rates between the two treatment groups for any of the antigens tested at 6 weeks and 1 year. Significantly lower geometric mean titers for varicella were noted in the group who received MMRV compared to VARIVAX given alone. Six-week seroconversion rates, persistence of immune responses at 1 year and the frequency of local and systemic reactions were comparable when MMRV was administered with PedvaxHIB compared with M-M-R II and PedvaxHIB followed by VARIVAX 6 weeks later.

Duration of protection from clinical hepatitis A disease after vaccination with VAQTA

Recent papers examining the expected persistence of anti-hepatitis A virus antibody following vaccination with inactivated hepatitis A vaccine have estimated that geometric mean antibody levels will remain above cut-off levels for 10-30 years. However, the methodology used in these papers did not take into account any estimates of variability between subjects. In this paper data from the persistence of antibody after the administration of another vaccine, VAQTA (hepatitis A vaccine, inactivated; MSD), were used to develop further models of antibody decay. Using individual subject estimates instead of group means allowed the estimation of time to negativity for various percentiles of the population (including the median), and the construction of confidence intervals on estimates of time to negativity. Data from studies of subjects who seroreverted to negativity, and subsequently received a booster dose, were also considered to show that subjects who lose detectable antibody are likely to remain protected from hepatitis A disease by persistent immune memory and rapid anamnestic response soon after exposure to hepatitis A virus. The estimates of duration of protection suggest that VAQTA will provide protection for many years, first through presence of antibody and further through an anamnestic response based on persistent immune memory.

Safety and immunogenicity of a combined live attenuated measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella vaccine (MMR(II)V) in healthy children

An investigational tetravalent combined measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella vaccine and measles-mumps-rubella and varicella vaccines at separate injection sites given at the same visit were evaluated with respect to safety and cell-mediated and humoral immune responses at 6 weeks and 1 year after vaccination. Varicella seroconversion rates and lymphocyte proliferation responses were 100% for both vaccine groups at 6 weeks and 1 year. However, the antibody titer to varicella was lower in the combined vaccine group at 6 weeks, but there was no statistical difference in cell-mediated immune responses. One-year geometric mean titers were not statistically different. Seroconversion rates for measles, mumps, and rubella were 100% for both vaccine at 6 weeks and 1 year. Long-term follow-up of these immune responses is planned.

Safety and immunogenicity of one vs. two injections of Oka/Merck varicella vaccine in healthy children

OBJECTIVE

To compare the safety and immunogenicity of a one- vs. two-dose regimen of Oka/Merck varicella vaccine in approximately 2000 healthy children 12 months to 12 years of age.

METHODOLOGY

Subjects with a negative history of varicella were randomized to receive either one or two injections of the vaccine given 3 months apart and were followed for clinical reactions and serologic response (glycoprotein-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay).

RESULTS

Both one- and two-dose vaccine regimens were generally well-tolerated. The incidences of varicelliform rash and fever were less frequent after the second injection. However, a slight increase in the incidence of injection site reactions was noted after the second injection; these were generally mild. Seroconversion rates by glycoprotein-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay were 98.2% (1700 of 1731) after one injection and 99.9% (717 of 718) after two injections. A significant (P < 0.001) boost in geometric mean titers was observed in children who received a second injection of vaccine 3 months after the first injection. Of the children who seroconverted at 6 weeks postregimen (one or two doses as assigned), 99.8% (528 of 529) of the one-dose group and 99.8% (473 of 474) of the two-dose group maintained antibody to varicella at 1 year with geometric mean titers of 19.5 and 31.2, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Administration of a one- or two-dose regimen of the live Oka/Merck varicella vaccine (VARIVAX) is immunogenic and is generally well-tolerated in healthy children 1 to 12 years old. Antibody to varicella persists in > 99% of vaccinees 1 year after vaccination regardless of a one- or two-dose regimen. Long-term follow-up studies of this cohort of children may determine whether a two-dose regimen offers superior protection against chickenpox.

Safety, tolerability, and immunogenicity of two regimens of Oka/Merck varicella vaccine (Varivax) in healthy adolescents and adults. Oka/Merck Varicella Vaccine Study Group

A multicenter clinical trial was conducted among 757 healthy adolescents and adults, 13-54 years, to compare two regimens of Oka/Merck varicella vaccine with respect to safety, tolerability, and immunogenicity. Participants were randomized to receive two injections of vaccine either four or eight weeks apart and were followed for clinical reactions and serologic response. The two vaccine regimens were equally well tolerated. The seroconversion rates (gpELISA) four weeks after injection 1 and 2 were 72 and 99%, respectively, for those who received vaccine four weeks apart and 78 and 99%, respectively, for those who received vaccine eight weeks apart. The differences in seroconversion rates were not statistically significant. However, delaying the second dose to eight weeks resulted in a higher antibody titer one month after the second injection. Administration of a two-dose regimen of varicella vaccine to susceptible adolescents and adults is well tolerated and highly immunogenic.

Worldwide experience with the CR326F-derived inactivated hepatitis A virus vaccine in pediatric and adult populations: an overview

The worldwide experience to date with VAQTA, a highly purified formalin-inactivated hepatitis A vaccine containing alum-adjuvant, is reviewed. No serious adverse experience related to vaccination has been reported. The vaccine has proven highly immunogenic, with seroconversion detectable after a single dose in 90-99% of children 2-16 years old, and of adults under 77 kg (170 lb) body weight. There is a trend toward lower one-dose seroconversion rates with increasing age and with weight > 77 kg. Early seroconversion in the latter groups may require two 25-unit doses given 2, 4 or 8 weeks apart, or a higher priming dose. Seroconversion induced by this vaccine has been shown to signify protection from clinical hepatitis A disease. The few vaccines whose titers have waned to borderline levels responded anamnestically to a booster, suggesting that the vaccine induces an immune memory response and should provide long-term protection.

Modified cases of chickenpox after varicella vaccination: correlation of protection with antibody response

Four thousand forty-two healthy children and adolescents, ages 12 months to 17 years, were vaccinated with a single dose of live attenuated varicella vaccine (VARIVAX; Merck Sharp and Dohme Research Laboratories) containing approximately 1000 to 1625 plaque-forming units/dose during clinical trials conducted from 1987 to 1989. Clinical follow-up of vaccinees revealed that 2.1 and 2.4% of vaccinees developed modified cases of varicella in the first and second years, respectively, after vaccination. Most of those who developed varicella postvaccination had an attenuated illness, characterized by fewer lesions and a lower incidence of fever (greater than or equal to 100 degrees F, oral) than after natural infection. The likelihood of developing varicella postvaccination decreased (P less than 0.0001) as the 6-week postvaccination glycoprotein-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay titer increased. In addition the number of lesions in these cases tended to decrease (P = 0.07 for Year 1 and P = 0.02 for Year 2) as the 6-week glycoprotein-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay titer increased. Thus the 6-week postvaccination glycoprotein-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay titer can be used as a surrogate marker for protection from natural disease.

Oka/Merck varicella vaccine in healthy children: final report of a 2-year efficacy study and 7-year follow-up studies

A large double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial of live attenuated Oka/Merck varicella vaccine was conducted among healthy children, 1-14 years of age. During the first varicella season, the efficacy of the vaccine among susceptible children was 100%1. During the second varicella season, 22 children were diagnosed with varicella; 21 cases in placebo recipients and one in a vaccine recipient. The overall efficacy of the vaccine through two varicella seasons was 98%. After the code for the study was broken, the original group of vaccine recipients continued to be followed for development of varicella. The estimated proportion of vaccine recipients who remained varicella-free at the end of 7 years was 95%. The 23 cases of varicella that occurred in vaccine recipients over the 7-year period were considerably milder than natural varicella. The average number of lesions was 53, 50% of the children had non-vesicular rashes, and 14% of the children had a temperature greater than or equal to 38.9 degrees C (102 degrees F), oral. The persistence of antibody in a subset of vaccine recipients followed for 6 years was 100%.

Varicella vaccine (VARIVAX) in healthy children and adolescents: results from clinical trials, 1987 to 1989

A total of 3303 healthy children and adolescents, aged 12 months to 17 years, were vaccinated with one of five production lots of a live attenuated varicella vaccine (VARIVAX) containing 1000 to 1625 plaque-forming units per dose. The vaccine was generally well tolerated. Ninety-six percent (2381/2475) of vaccinees responded to vaccination by producing antibody as measured by a glycoprotein-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; 99% (569/576) of those tested maintained antibody at 1 year following vaccination. The incidence of varicella following household exposure in vaccinees was approximately 12%; household contact historically results in 87% infection. Nearly all of the vaccinees who had varicella after vaccination had a clinically modified disease.

Antibody assays suitable for assessing immune responses to live varicella vaccine

An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for antibodies to varicella-zoster virus (VZV), using purified viral glycoproteins as antigen (gpELISA), was compared with other assays for measuring vaccine-induced antibody responses. The gpELISA was more sensitive than conventional assays, proved highly specific for VZV and agreed well with an assay for neutralizing antibody activity. It was successfully applied to large-scale testing of live varicella vaccine in humans.

Association of steroid therapy with vaccine-associated rashes in children with acute lymphocytic leukaemia who received Oka/Merck varicella vaccine. NIAID Varicella Vaccine Collaborative Study Group

Oka strain varicella vaccine generally has been well tolerated by children with acute lymphocytic leukaemia (ALL) in remission and has induced protection against disease caused by wild-type varicella virus. At the end of 1985, four extensive vaccine-associated rashes were reported among children on maintenance chemotherapy. Steroid therapy in the week before vaccination or in the week following vaccination was significantly associated with rash in a retrospective analysis (odds ratio = 3.84, p = 0.0006). These findings were confirmed prospectively (OR = 2.38, p less than 0.05, one-sided) in a second smaller group of children with ALL on maintenance therapy who received varicella vaccination after the end of the data collection for the initial study but before the relationship between rash and steroids was discovered. As a result of these studies, investigators have been asked to withhold steroids for 1 week before vaccination and to delay resumption of steroid therapy for at least 2 weeks after vaccination. These results should serve as a caution that vaccination of these children should be undertaken only with full knowledge of their therapeutic regimen and a thorough clinical understanding of the competing risks of varicella, vaccination and modification of the child's chemotherapy.

Live Oka/Merck varicella vaccine in healthy children. Further clinical and laboratory assessment

A clinical trial among 137 healthy children, ages 1 to 12 years, was conducted with four different doses (4,350, 870, 435, and 43 plaque-forming units [pfu]) of live Oka/Merck varicella vaccine to evaluate clinical reactions and selected laboratory parameters and to determine the minimum effective dose and induction time of antibody. The vaccine was well tolerated with no significant difference in the rate of reported symptoms by dose. The frequency of varicellalike rash was 3% (4/137); all rashes were mild. Serum aminotransferase values were essentially unchanged after vaccination. Minor variations found in platelet counts after vaccination were not associated with any bleeding, bruising, or clotting. Among initially seronegative children who received doses of 435 pfu or greater, 94% assayed at two weeks and 100% assayed at four or six weeks seroconverted. The geometric mean titers were similar for all four doses at six weeks. IgG and IgA responses were demonstrated with no relation to the vaccine dose.

Isolated antibody to hepatitis B surface antigen and response to hepatitis B vaccination

To determine the need for immunization of health workers with antibody to hepatitis B surface antigen (anti-HBs) as their only serologic marker of previous hepatitis B exposure, we studied the level, persistence, and immunologic specificity of isolated anti-HBs in 46 persons identified during screening for hepatitis B vaccine. We rescreened these persons 1 year later, administered a single dose of hepatitis B vaccine, and determined the anti-HBs level at 1, 2, and 8 weeks after vaccination. Isolated anti-HBs levels were low and antibody did not persist; 22 subjects tested had lost detectable anti-HBs within 19 months even though immunologic specificity was shown in vitro in 34. Anamnestic responses suggesting previous exposure and immunity were seen in only 10 subjects; 5 of these subjects had moderate-level, persistent anti-HBs. Although some persons with naturally acquired, isolated anti-HBs may be protected from hepatitis B, the immunologic specificity and protective value of anti-HBs, especially when levels are low, remain questionable.

Live attenuated varicella virus vaccine. Efficacy trial in healthy children

We conducted a double-blind, placebo-controlled efficacy trial of the live attenuated Oka/Merck varicella vaccine among 956 children between the ages of 1 and 14 years, with a negative clinical history of varicella. Of the 914 children who were serologically confirmed to be susceptible to varicella, 468 received vaccine and 446 received placebo. The vaccine produced few clinical reactions and was well tolerated. There was no clinical evidence of viral spread from vaccinated children to sibling controls. Approximately eight weeks after vaccination, 94 per cent of the initially seronegative children who received vaccine had detectable antibody to varicella. During the nine-month surveillance period, 39 clinically diagnosed cases of varicella, 38 of which were confirmed by laboratory tests, occurred among study participants. All 39 cases occurred in placebo recipients; no child who received vaccine contracted varicella. The vaccine was 100 per cent efficacious in preventing varicella in this population of healthy children (P less than 10(-9).