Thoracic radiotherapy does not prolong survival in patients with locally advanced, unresectable non-small cell lung cancer

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To compare the survival of patients with locally advanced non-small cell lung cancer treated with single-agent vindesine, thoracic radiotherapy, or both treatment modalities.

DESIGN

Randomized, prospective, phase III trial.

SETTING

Multi-institutional, university-based national cooperative oncology group.

PATIENTS

The study included 319 patients with locally advanced, unresectable non-small cell lung cancer who had no evidence of extrathoracic metastases. All patients were ambulatory and had measurable disease. Some patients could not have surgery because of coexisting medical conditions.

INTERVENTION

Patients were randomly assigned to receive vindesine, 3 mg/m2 body surface area weekly; standard thoracic radiotherapy, 60 Gy over 6 weeks; or both vindesine and thoracic radiotherapy. Vindesine was administered for 6 weeks and then every other week to patients who had no disease progression. Patients who developed progressive disease while receiving vindesine or radiotherapy alone were crossed over to radiotherapy or vindesine, respectively. Response assessment took place at week 6.

RESULTS

The overall response rate was superior in the radiotherapy arms (radiotherapy alone, 30%; radiotherapy plus vindesine, 34%; vindesine alone, 10%; P = 0.001). However, with a minimum follow-up of 42 months, no improvement in survival has been seen with radiotherapy. The median survival was 8.6 months for patients receiving radiotherapy alone, 9.4 months for those receiving radiotherapy plus vindesine, and 10.1 months for those receiving vindesine (P = 0.58). Radiotherapy also failed to improve long-term survival. The 5-year survivals were 3%, 3%, and 1%, respectively (P = 0.56).

CONCLUSION

Patients with non-small cell lung cancer who have inoperable, nonmetastatic disease gain no clinically meaningful survival advantage with immediate thoracic irradiation, even when modern megavoltage radiation therapy techniques and equipment are used.

Therapy of acute myelogenous leukemia in patients over the age of 50: a randomized Southeastern Cancer Study Group trial

In a randomized trial, 299 evaluable patients with acute myelogenous leukemia, age greater than or equal to 51, were initially randomized to cytosine arabinoside, 100 mg/m2/day, by continuous intravenous infusion for seven days, plus either daunorubicin 45 mg/m2/day x 3 (DA), or m-AMSA 200 mg/m2/day x 3 days (MA). Complete remission (CR) rates were not significantly different, 47% for DA and 42% for MA. Toxicities were similar except that severe hepatic toxicity, serum bilirubin greater than or equal to 7 mg/dl, was more frequent in patients receiving MA (10%) than in patients receiving DA (4%), p less than 0.05. Deaths during induction were significantly more frequent in patients receiving MA (38%) than in patients receiving DA (25%), p = 0.018. Patients achieving a CR received thioguanine, cytosine arabinoside, and daunorubicin (TAD) for three cycles as consolidation. Among evaluable patients, 82/102 (80%) stayed in CR during these three cycles. Patients were then randomized to either no maintenance or to DA every 13 weeks x 4 cycles, at a dose slightly lower than used for induction. Remission duration was similar for the two maintenance programs, 10.7 months for no maintenance and 8.5 months for DA. The percentage of patients evaluable for maintenance achieving three year relapse-free survival was similar for the two maintenance programs, 28% for no maintenance and 21% for DA. However, overall survival was significantly greater (40 vs 12 months, p = 0.007) for patients receiving no maintenance therapy, due to greater survival after recurrence in these patients. At each phase of the study there were substantial numbers of non-evaluable cases, often due to incomplete evaluation of remission status. Of the 379 patients initially entered into the trial, 35% obtained a complete remission. Of all the patients who achieved a complete remission, 61% were both evaluable and in remission upon completion of the maintenance phase. Of these patients who completed the maintenance phase in remission, 15% were relapse free survivors three years following initiation of maintenance therapy. Overall, only 3.2% of patients who entered the trial (35% x 61% x 15%) were continuous relapse-free survivors three years into the maintenance phase.

Prognosis in systemic lupus erythematosus. Negative impact of increasing age at onset, black race, and thrombocytopenia, as well as causes of death

To assess the impact of demographic and clinical factors on prognosis in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), we examined survivorship by life-table analysis in 389 patients. There were approximately equal numbers of Caucasian patients and American black patients in this study group. On both univariate and multivariate analyses, we found that both American black race and increasing age at SLE onset independently worsened the probability of survival. Of all the clinical factors we analyzed, thrombocytopenia emerged as the only independent risk factor for a worse prognosis in SLE. In all clinical and demographic groups considered, the leading cause of death was infection.

Prognosis in stage D-1 prostate cancer relative to anatomic sites of nodal metastases. National Prostatic Cancer Treatment Group

The investigators of the National Prostatic Cancer Treatment Group (NPCTG) have entered 212 patients with surgically confirmed stage D-1 prostate cancer in studies to determine the efficacy of adjuvant therapy after either definitive surgery (Protocol 900) or definitive radiotherapy (Protocol 1000). Follow-up indicates that this group represents 70% of all patients with recurrent disease. Because patients with less than 20% nodal involvement were found to have a statistically significant better progression-free-survival (PFS) than those with greater than 20% nodal involvement, we examined the exact anatomic sites of nodal metastases. The status of obturator, external iliac, internal iliac, and common iliac nodes was compared to PFS and overall survival in 198 patients with D-1 disease in both protocols. Results demonstrate no significant difference in either PFS or overall survival relative to anatomic sites of positive nodes. These data suggest that although minimal pelvic nodal metastasis is consistent with improved PFS, there is no predictable anatomic distribution of disease consonant with that better prognosis.

Seizures after primary intracerebral hemorrhage

We followed 123 patients with primary intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH), defined as bleeding without known precipitating cause except hypertension, for an average of 4.6 years or until death in order to determine the incidence, prevalence, and type of epileptic seizures. Twenty-five percent had seizures. In one-half of these, the seizures began within 24 hours of the hemorrhage. Survival table analysis predicted a potential cumulative seizure incidence of 50%, had all patients survived 5 years. Seizure incidence was high with bleeding into lobar cortical structures (54%), low with basal ganglionic hemorrhages (19%), and zero with thalamic hemorrhages. Within the basal ganglia, caudate involvement predicted seizures; within the cortex, temporal or parietal involvement predicted seizures. Although seizure incidence was high, prevalence of chronic epilepsy was much lower: 13% in 30-day to 2-year survivors and 6.5% in 2- to 5-year survivors. Seizure incidence is higher than previously reported after ICH because small lobar hemorrhages are the most epileptogenic and are now easily recognized with computed tomography.

Improvement in disease-free survival of melanoma patients in conjunction with serologic response in a phase Ia/Ib Southeastern Cancer Study Group trial of vaccinia melanoma oncolysate

Thirty-nine patients with malignant melanoma who were disease-free after surgery but at high risk for recurrence were treated with vaccinia melanoma oncolysate (VMO) for 12 months. Clinical results, after a mean follow-up of 17 months showed that 25 of 39 patients had no evidence of disease. Comparison of disease-free survival of patients in this study with that of 39 matched controls from other adjuvant trials shows statistically significant advantage of VMO therapy. Evaluation of serological responses of patients undergoing VMO treatment by an enzyme-linked immunosorbant assay (ELISA) showed a positive correlation between IgG antibody binding to cultured melanoma cells and disease-free survival.

Phase II evaluation of bolus gallium nitrate in lymphoproliferative disorders: a Southeastern Cancer Study Group trial

Gallium nitrate was administered as a 700-mg/m2 iv bolus infusion over 15-30 minutes every 2 weeks to 138 patients with malignant lymphoproliferative diseases. Responses occurred in patients with well-differentiated lymphomas (five responses among eight patients), but the drug produced few responses in any other group of patients. Toxic effects were primarily gastrointestinal and reversible renal abnormalities and anemia. As a single agent, bolus gallium nitrate has little activity in lymphoproliferative diseases.

Phase II evaluation of anguidine (NSC 141537) in 5-day courses in colorectal adenocarcinoma. A Southeastern Cancer Study Group Trial

Thirty-three patients with advanced colorectal adenocarcinoma were treated with daily Anguidine i.v. 5 mg/m2 X 5 for 3 weeks. The patients were stratified into two groups: prior chemotherapy and no prior chemotherapy. No responses were noted. Major toxicities were hypotension and fever.

Phase I-II evaluation of razoxane (ICRF-159) and doxorubicin in gastrointestinal cancer. A Southeastern Cancer Study Group Trial

A Phase I-II study of razoxane (ICRF-159) and doxorubicin was undertaken in 34 adults with advanced gastrointestinal carcinoma. Three dose schedules were studied; weekly razoxane at 600 mg/m2 orally plus doxorubicin 60 mg/m2 every 3 weeks, razoxane at 300 mg/m2 plus doxorubicin 60 mg/m2, and weekly razoxane 300 mg/m2 plus doxorubicin 35 mg/m2 every 3 weeks. This combination produced moderate to severe granulocytopenia in 24 patients including granulocytopenia less than or equal to 500/mm3 in 15. The granulocytopenia occurred regardless of prior chemotherapy and regardless of dose schedule employed. Two septic deaths were recorded but no responses. Further evaluation of this combination is not recommended.

A phase I/II SECSG (Southeastern Cancer Study Group) pilot study of surgical adjuvant immunotherapy with vaccinia melanoma oncolysates (VMO)

Forty-eight patients with nonrecurrent high risk Stage I and II malignant melanoma were treated with Vaccinia Melanoma Oncolysates (VMO). Six different dose levels and two different treatment regimens were tested. Thirty-two out of 48 patients completed the 12 months of therapy. Side effects were mild to moderate. Twenty-eight out of 48 patients remain free from disease with a mean survival of 19 months, while 20/48 patients have recurred with a mean time to recurrence of 6 months.

Age and the treatment of multiple myeloma. Southeastern Cancer Study Group experience

To determine the impact of age upon the response to treatment, survival, and toxicity of chemotherapy for multiple myeloma, the results of a large cooperative group trial were examined. Patients were randomly assigned to induction therapy with either carmustine, cyclophosphamide, and prednisone or melphalan and prednisone; patients with response received two years of treatment. The age distribution of patients in this trial compared with the incidence figures from the Surveillance Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) study shows a degree of under-representation of the oldest patient groups. Prognostic factors were evenly distributed over the age range and treatment groups. Older patients had responses and survival rates equivalent to younger patients and with both treatment regimens regardless of prognostic factor characteristics. Hematologic toxicity was no greater for the older group in either regimen despite the presence of a nitrosourea in one. Gastrointestinal toxicity was increased in the older patients who received the regimen of melphalan and prednisone. The study suggests that in myeloma and perhaps other such chemotherapy-responsive malignancies treated with moderately intense chemotherapy, without bone marrow ablation, elderly and younger patients have similar outcomes.

Free thyroid hormones in evaluating persistently elevated thyrotropin levels in children with congenital hypothyroidism on replacement therapy

Some children with congenital hypothyroidism receiving L-T4 therapy have elevated serum TSH levels despite having normal serum T4 concentrations, suggesting that they have a higher threshold for the feedback regulation of TSH release. To further study this possibility, we determined serum free T4 (FT4) and T3 (FT3) concentrations in two groups of L-T4-treated hypothyroid children. Group A consisted of 10 patients with high serum TSH levels; group B consisted of 10 patients with normal TSH levels. All patients were clinically euthyroid, and serum total T4 and T3 concentrations were similar in the two groups. A third (control) group (C) consisted of randomly selected normal children. The three groups were age matched. Serum FT3 and FT4 were significantly lower in group A compared to group B. Serum FT4 and T4 were higher and TSH was lower in group B compared to group C. The T4/T3 ratio wash higher in both groups of children with hypothyroidism than in group C. We conclude that in most patients a high serum TSH was due to inadequate L-T4 therapy, as shown by free hormone concentrations (low) but not by total hormone levels (normal). This suggests that L-T4 therapy should be monitored by measurement of TSH and free hormone concentrations. The latter also can be used to indicate moderate overdosage, not clinically detectable, as shown by the comparison between groups B and C. Measurement of serum total T4, as indicated by the lack of difference between groups A and B and also by T4/T3 ratio, cannot be considered a reliable index of therapeutic adequacy in such children.

Phase II studies of mitoxantrone (dihydroxyanthracenedione) in the treatment of advanced colorectal carcinoma

One hundred four patients with advanced colon carcinoma were treated with mitoxantrone 5 mg/m2 I.V. weekly. The patients were stratified into two groups: prior chemotherapy and no prior chemotherapy. Only one partial response was noted in the prior treatment category.

Mitoxantrone in malignant melanoma

Twenty-nine patients with metastatic malignant melanoma without prior chemotherapy and 36 patients refractory to prior chemotherapy received mitoxantrone (5 mg/m2/week). No patient achieved a partial response. The dose-limiting toxic effect was granulocytopenia. Mitoxantrone is ineffective in malignant melanoma.

Results of a uniform histopathologic review system of lymphoma cases. A ten-year study from the Southeastern Cancer Study Group

To determine the usefulness of a consulting panel for histopathologic review in lymphoma cases, a comparative study of the histopathologic diagnosis of the local pathologist was done and compared with the final diagnosis by an expert pathologist in 1088 cases of lymphoma studied by the Southeastern Cancer Study Group (SECSG) during the implementation of five protocols during the last ten years. The following conclusions were reached: (1) In 44 cases (4%), the material sent for review was judged inadequate to make a diagnosis; (2) In 82 cases (8%), the local pathologist's diagnosis was judged incorrect; (3) In Hodgkin's Disease (HD), the diagnosis was confirmed in 545 of 595 cases (92%). However, using the Lukes and Butler classification by subtype of HD, the expert pathologist judged only 289 of 595 cases as correct (49%). The least agreement was found in the lymphocytic predominance (LP) subtype, in which only six of 34 (18%) cases were correct. The best correlation was found in the nodular sclerosis (NS) type of HD where agreement occurred in 161 of 186 (87%) cases; and (4) In the non-Hodgkin's lymphomas (NHL) the diagnosis was confirmed in 428 of the 493 cases studied (87%). Subclassification using the Rappaport system revealed agreement in 274 of 493 (56%) cases. Subtypes associated with good prognosis were judged correct by the expert pathologist in 105 of 139 instances (76%). Likewise, agreement in subtypes of poor prognosis occurred in 254 of 351 cases (72%). These data again confirm the need for an uniform consulting panel system especially for cases involved in cooperative group trials. This has even become more important now with the increasing complexity of the different classifications currently in use.

A comparison of cyclophosphamide, adriamycin, and 5-fluorouracil (CAF) and cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, 5-fluorouracil, vincristine, and prednisone (CMFVP) in patients with advanced breast cancer

The Southeastern Cancer Study Group, in a prospectively randomized study involving patients with advanced breast cancer, has compared a low dose intermittently administered five-drug regimen including cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, 5-fluorouracil, vincristine, and prednisone (CMFVP) with an aggressively administered three-drug regimen including cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, and 5-fluorouracil (CAF). CAF induced more responses and more complete responses and a longer duration of disease control. However, only a marginal difference was demonstrated in overall survival between the two regimens (p = less than 0.10). Patients with a good risk pattern of metastases, i.e. those with nodular local chest wall recurrence, nodular pulmonary metastases, or bone-only metastases were more likely to achieve a response and survive longer than those with a poor risk pattern, i.e. lymphangitic pulmonary metastases, pleural effusion with chest wall ulceration, or widespread metastases, including hepatic. All of the differences between the two regimens were noted in the good risk pattern groups. CAF provided no additional benefit to patients presenting with poor risk patterns of metastases. Adriamycin-containing combinations may achieve a greater degree of tumor cell kill in certain subsets of patients with advanced breast cancer, but this provides only a marginal increase in survival.

Effects of age on responses to treatment and survival of patients with multiple myeloma

The elderly patient with malignancy is often considered a poor risk for treatment. To assess the effect of age on the treatment of one such disease, multiple myeloma (a disease with increased incidence in the elderly), a study was made of 280 patients treated with 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea (BCNU), cyclophosphamide and prednisone on a Southeastern Cancer Study Group protocol. Initial response rates after six months of treatment were equivalent for the older compared with the younger age groups, with a slightly longer remission duration for those over 70. Likewise, survival was equivalent for the older patients. This was not the result of selection of older patients with less advanced disease, since the proportion with both good and poor risk factors are not significantly different in the various age groups. Moreover, for patients with each of the prognostic factors, older patients responded at least as well as younger patients. There were no significant differences among the age groups in gastrointestinal, skin, hair, or hematologic toxicity, although there was a slightly higher incidence of mild granulocyte and platelet toxicity in patients over 60. These findings are in contrast to the widely held belief that older patients cannot tolerate chemotherapy. On the contrary, they suggest that the elderly patient with myeloma may be expected to respond and survive, without excessive toxicity, at least as well as a younger counterpart with similar prognostic factors.

Postmastectomy adjuvant chemotherapy with or without radiation therapy in women with operable breast cancer and positive axillary lymph nodes: the Southeastern Cancer Study Group experience

Between September 1976 and June 1982, 308 patients with operable breast cancer with 1-3 involved axillary nodes were stratified according to institution, type of mastectomy, and time from surgery to protocol entry, and then randomized to receive either six or 12 months of adjuvant chemotherapy with cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, and 5-fluorouracil (CMF). With a median time of follow-up of 33 months, relapse rates among 181 reviewed and evaluable patients are 20/85 (23.5%) for pre- and 23/96 (24%) for postmenopausal patients. Results for premenopausal women, while better than historical controls at a similar time interval, appear inferior to other published adjuvant studies (e.g., NSABP and Milan). Although total relapse rates were 23/100 (23%) for six months and 20/81 (25%) for 12 months of therapy, suggestive differences were encountered by menopausal status with early trends favoring 12 months of treatment for premenopausal patients and six months of treatment for postmenopausal patients. During this same period, 283 patients with four or more involved axillary nodes were randomized to 1-3 treatment arms: six months of CMF, six months of CMF preceded by local-regional x-ray therapy (XRT), or 12 months of CMF. The latter arm was closed in February 1980 while the two six-month chemotherapy arms remain open as of January 1983. Relapse rates for 174 reviewed and evaluable patients on the three arms include: 27/76 (36%) for six months CMF, 15/54 (28%) for XRT and CMF, and 24/44 (45%) for 12 months CMF. Local-regional relapse rates were 12/120 (10%) for the combined two non-XRT arms and 3/54 (6%) for the XRT treatment arm (p = 0.34). Thus, at this early stage of follow-up there are still no statistically significant differences between six or 12 months of adjuvant CMF therapy and neither definite beneficial nor detrimental effects of prechemotherapy adjuvant radiation therapy. Longer follow-up will be needed to provide definitive conclusions.

Adriamycin, BCNU, and cyclophosphamide in drug-resistant adenocarcinoma of the ovary

Because of an encouraging response rate in a pilot study of adriamycin, BCNU, and cyclophosphamide (ABC), the Southeastern Cancer Study Group conducted a phase II study of ABC in patients with melphalan-resistant ovarian carcinoma. Of 36 evaluable patients, there were only 4 partial responses to therapy, for a partial response rate of 11%. Durations of response were 4 to 50 + weeks, and the overall median survival was 29 weeks. No complete responses were seen. Dose-limiting toxicity was granulocytopenia. We conclude that ABC is generally ineffective in management of alkylator-resistant ovarian adenocarcinoma.

The superiority of combination chemotherapy over single agent chemotherapy in small cell lung carcinoma

From June 1974 to October 1976, 288 patients with small cell undifferentiated lung carcinoma were entered into a randomized, controlled study comparing the two noncycle-active induction regimens of cyclophosphamide vs. the combination of cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin and imidazole carboximide (DTIC). Patients were stratified by extent of disease, previous radiotherapy and performance status. Responding patients and those who did not progress were then randomized to receive their initial regimen alone, or their initial regimen with added cycle-active therapy (vincristine, hydroxyurea and methotrexate). While only 4/34 (12%) evaluable patients treated with cyclophosphamide achieved a response (greater than 50% regression), a final total of 119/217 (57%) evaluable patients on the three drugs have responded (p = 0.005). The survival curve for all the combination-treated patients was significantly better than for those treated with cyclophosphamide alone (p = 0.012). There was no demonstrable statistical superiority in length of remission or survival for patients on the combination who received in addition cycle-active consolidation therapy. In the combination chemotherapy group, survival duration was longer for patients with limited disease than extensive disease (p = 0.035). There was a strong correlation between quality of remission produced by the combination and survival.

A comparison of cyclophosphamide, adriamycin, 5-fluorouracil (CAF) and cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, 5-fluorouracil, vincristine, prednisone (CMFVP) in patients with metastatic breast cancer: a Southeastern Cancer Study Group project

In an ongoing prospective randomized study, 113 evaluable patients have received either a three-drug combination that included cyclophosphamide, Adriamycin and 5-fluorouracil (CAF) or a five-drug combination including cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, 5-fluorouracil, vincristine and prednisone (CMFVP) given intermittently 1 week out of 4. Responses (64%), median duration of response (32 weeks), and median duration of disease control (32 weeks) achieved with CAF were superior to those achieved with CMFVP (37%, 22 weeks, 17 weeks, respectively). Morbidity secondary to CAF was significant, with nausea and vomiting, malaise, total alopecia, and granulocytopenia being the main features.

Southeastern Cancer Study Group trials with nitrosoureas in Hodgkin's disease

A decade of studies with the nitrosoureas in the Southeastern Cancer Study Group has shown that they are active agents for the treatment of Hodgkin's disease and that they may be combined with other chemotherapeutic agents in regimens which have acceptable toxicity to produce excellent response rates. Further more, six monthly cycles of treatment with a combination of either BCNU, vinblastine, cyclophosphamide, procarbazine, and prednisone or mechlorethamine, vincristine, prednisone and procarbazine(MOPP), following the achievement of a clinical CR, produce significantly superior durations of remission and survival in previously untreated patients. Our studies with BCNU given orally have indicated that it is not a clinically useful drug. Finally, studies with methyl-CCNU given orally have indicated no particular place for this agent in the treatment od Hodgkin's disease when compared to CCNU and BCNU.