Issues in implementing prenatal screening for cystic fibrosis: results of a working conference

PURPOSE

To summarize a conference convened to examine how cystic fibrosis screening might appropriately be introduced into routine prenatal practice.

METHODS

Participants included experts from various relevant disciplines. Systematic reviews and data from individual trials were presented; issues were identified and discussed.

RESULTS

Judged by published criteria, prenatal cystic fibrosis screening is suitable for introduction. Screening can be performed cost-effectively by identifying racial/ethnic groups at sufficient risk and then using either of two models for delivering laboratory services. Validated educational materials exist. Ethical issues are not unique.

CONCLUSIONS

Once adequate facilities for patient and provider education, testing, counseling, quality control, and monitoring are in place, individual programs can begin prenatal screening for cystic fibrosis.

A 2.5 kb polypyrimidine tract in the PKD1 gene contains at least 23 H-DNA-forming sequences

A pyrimidine-rich element (PyRE), present in the 21st intron of the PKD1 gene, posed a significant obstacle in determining the primary structure of the gene. Only cycle sequencing of nested, single-stranded phage templates of the CT-rich strand enabled complete and accurate sequence data. Similar attempts on the GA-rich strand were unsuccessful. The resulting primary structure showed the 3 kb 21st intron to contain a 2.5 kb PyRE, whose sense-strand is 97% C + T. The PKD1 PyRE does not appear to be polymorphic based on RFLP analysis of DNA from 6 unrelated individuals digested with 9 different restriction enzymes. This is the largest pyrimidine tract sequenced to date, being over twice as large as those previously identified and shows little homology to other polypyrimidine tracts. Additional analysis of this PyRE revealed the presence of 23 mirror repeats with stem lengths of at least 10 nucleotides. The 23 H-DNA-forming sequences in the PKD1 PyRE exceed the cumulative total of 22 found in 157 human genes that have been completely sequenced. The mirror repeats confer this region of the PKD1 gene with a strong probability of forming H-DNA or triplex structures under appropriate conditions. Based on studies with PyRE found in other eukaryotic genes, the PKD1 PyRE may play a role in regulating PKD1 expression, and its potential for forming an extended triplex structure may explain some of the observed instability in the PKD1 locus.

Somatic mutation in individual liver cysts supports a two-hit model of cystogenesis in autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease

Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD), Type I is a common genetic disorder and an important cause of renal failure. The disease is characterized by progressive cyst formation in a variety of organs including the kidney, liver and pancreas. We have previously shown that in the case of PKD1, renal cyst development is likely to require somatic inactivation of the normal allele coupled to a germline PKD1 mutation. In this report, we have used unique reagents to show that intragenic, somatic mutations are common in hepatic cysts. All pathogenic mutations were shown to have altered the previously normal copy of the gene. These data extend the "two-hit" model of cystogenesis to include a second focal manifestation of the disease.

PCR quantitation of fetal cells in maternal blood in normal and aneuploid pregnancies

Fetal cells in maternal blood are a noninvasive source of fetal genetic material for prenatal diagnosis. We determined the number of fetal-cell DNA equivalents present in maternal whole-blood samples to deduce whether this number is affected by fetal karyotype. Peripheral blood samples were obtained from 199 women carrying chromosomally normal fetuses and from 31 women with male aneuploid fetuses. Male fetal-cell DNA-equivalent quantitation was determined by PCR amplification of a Y chromosome-specific sequence and was compared with PCR product amplified from known concentrations of male DNA run simultaneously. The mean number of male fetal-cell DNA equivalents detected in 16-ml blood samples from 90 women bearing a 46,XY fetus was 19 (range 0-91). The mean number of male fetal-cell DNA equivalents detected in 109 women bearing a 46,XX fetus was 2 (range 0-24). The mean number of male fetal-cell DNA equivalents detected when the fetus was male compared with when the fetus was female was highly significant (P = .0001). More fetal cells were detected in maternal blood when the fetus was aneuploid. The mean number of male fetal-cell DNA equivalents detected when the fetal karyotype was 47,XY,+21 was 110 (range 0.1-650), which was significantly higher than the number of male fetal-cell DNA equivalents detected in 46,XY fetuses (P = .0001). Feto-maternal transfusion of nucleated cells appears to be influenced by fetal karyotype. The sixfold elevation of fetal cells observed in maternal blood when the fetus had trisomy 21 indicates that noninvasive cytogenetic diagnosis of trisomy 21 should be feasible.

Polycystin: in vitro synthesis, in vivo tissue expression, and subcellular localization identifies a large membrane-associated protein

The primary structure of polycystin predicts a large integral membrane protein with multiple cell recognition motifs, but its function remains unknown. Insight into polycystin's normal function and its role in the development of autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (PKD1) requires the assembly of an extensive collection of molecular reagents to examine its expression and create model systems for functional studies. Development of these crucial reagents has been complicated due to the presence of transcriptionally active homologous loci. We have assembled the authentic full-length PKD1 cDNA and demonstrated expression of polycystin in vitro. Polyclonal antibodies directed against distinct extra- and intracellular domains specifically immunoprecipitated in vitro translated polycystin. The panel of antibodies was used to determine localization of polycystin in renal epithelial and endothelial cell lines and tissues of fetal, adult, and cystic origins. In normal adult kidney and maturing fetal nephrons, polycystin expression was confined to epithelial cells of the distal nephron and vascular endothelial cells. Expression in the proximal nephron was only observed after injury-induced cell proliferation. Polycystin expression was confined to ductal epithelium in liver, pancreas, and breast, and restricted to astrocytes in normal brain. We report clear evidence for the membrane localization of polycystin by both tissue sections and by confocal microscopy in cultured renal and endothelial cells. Interestingly, when cultured cells made cell-cell contact, polycystin was localized to the lateral membranes of cells in contact. These data suggest that polycystin is likely to have a widespread role in epithelial cell differentiation and maturation and in cell-cell interactions.

The NTN2L gene encoding a novel human netrin maps to the autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease region on chromosome 16p13.3

The netrins define a family of chemotropic factors that have been shown to play a central role in axon guidance. We identified two exon traps encoding netrin-like sequences during the assembly of a transcriptional map for the genomic interval surrounding the polycystic kidney disease type 1 and tuberous sclerosis type 2 genes. We describe the characterization of a novel human netrin-2-like gene, designated NTN2L, and its transcript. The genomic interval containing the NTN2L gene was sequenced, and the coding region was predicted based on computer analysis. The structure of the NTN2L gene has been confirmed utilizing nested RT-PCR. The NTN2L gene is predicted to encode a 580-amino-acid protein having homology to the chicken and Drosophila netrins and to Caenorhabditis elegans UNC-6. The NTN2L gene has a restricted pattern of expression; its transcript is undetectable by Northern analysis in all tissues examined, but can be recovered from spinal cord RNA by RT-PCR. This report represents the first description and characterization of a human netrin.

High throughput parallel analysis of hundreds of patient samples for more than 100 mutations in multiple disease genes

As more mutations are identified in genes of known sequence, there is a crucial need in the areas of medical genetics and genome analysis for rapid, accurate and cost-effective methods of mutation detection. We have developed a multiplex allele-specific diagnostic assay (MASDA) for analysis of large numbers of samples (> 500) simultaneously for a large number of known mutations (> 100) in a single assay. MASDA utilizes oligonucleotide hybridization to interrogate DNA sequences. Multiplex DNA samples are immobilized on a solid support and a single hybridization is performed with a pool of allele-specific oligonucleotide (ASO) probes. Any probes complementary to specific mutations present in a given sample are in effect affinity purified from the pool by the target DNA. Sequence-specific band patterns (fingerprints), generated by chemical or enzymatic sequencing of the bound ASO(s), easily identify the specific mutation(s). Using this design, in a single diagnostic assay, we tested samples for 66 cystic fibrosis (CF) mutations, 14 beta-thalassemia mutations, two sickle cell anemia (SCA) mutations, three Tay-Sachs mutations, eight Gaucher mutations, four mutations in Canavan disease, four mutations in Fanconi anemia, and five mutations in BRCA1. Each mutation was correctly identified. Finally, in a blinded study of 106 of these mutations in > 500 patients, all mutations were properly identified. There were no false positives or false negatives. The MASDA assay is capable of detecting point mutations as well as small insertion or deletion mutations. This technology is amenable to automation and is suitable for immediate utilization for high-throughput genetic diagnostics in clinical and research laboratories.

The cloning of a human ABC gene (ABC3) mapping to chromosome 16p13.3

The ATP binding cassette (ABC) transporters, or traffic ATPases, constitute a large family of proteins responsible for the transport of a wide variety of substrates across cell membranes in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. We describe a human ABC protein with regions of strong homology to the recently described murine ABC1 and ABC2 transporters. The gene for this novel protein, human ABC3, maps near the polycystic kidney disease type 1 (PKD1) gene on chromosome 16p13.3. The ABC3 gene is expressed at highest levels in lung compared to other tissues.

Alternative splicing of exon 3 of the human growth hormone receptor is the result of an unusual genetic polymorphism

Two isoforms of the human growth hormone receptor (hGHR), which differ in the presence (hGHRwt) or absence (hGHRd3) of exon 3, are expressed in the placenta. Specifically, three expression patterns are observed: only hGHRwt, only hGHRd3, or an approximately 1:1 combination of both isoforms. We investigated several potential regulatory mechanisms which might account for the expression of the hGHR isoforms. The frequency of hGHRd3 expression did not change when placentas from differing stages of gestation were examined, suggesting splicing was not developmentally regulated. However, when hGHR isoform expression patterns were examined in each component of a given placenta, it was evident that alternative splicing of exon 3 is individual-specific. Surprisingly, the individual-specific regulation of hGHR isoforms appears to be the result of a polymorphism in the hGHR gene. We analyzed hGHRwt and hGHRd3 expression in Hutterite pedigrees, and our results are consistent with a simple Mendelian inheritance of two differing alleles in which exon 3 is spliced in an "all-or-none" fashion. We conclude the alternative splicing of exon 3 in hGHR transcripts is the result of an unusual polymorphism which significantly alters splicing of the hGHR transcript and that the relatively high frequency (approximately 10%) of homozygous hGHRd3 expression suggests the possibility it may play a role in polygenic determined events.

A novel ribosomal protein L3-like gene (RPL3L) maps to the autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease gene region

A full-length cDNA encoding a novel ribosomal protein L3 gene was isolated and sequenced. The deduced protein sequence is 407 amino acids long and shows 77% identity to other known mammalian ribosomal protein L3 genes, which are themselves highly conserved. Southern blot analysis of human genomic DNA suggests that this novel gene is single copy. While the previously identified human ribosomal protein L3 gene has ubiquitous expression in all tissues surveyed, the novel gene described herein is strongly expressed in skeletal muscle and heart tissue, with low levels of expression in the pancreas. This novel gene, RPL3L, is located in a gene-rich region near the PKD1 and TSC2 genes on chromosome 16p13.3.

Prenatal detection of chromosome aneuploidies in uncultured chorionic villus samples by FISH

We developed a 1-d FISH assay for detection of numerical chromosome abnormalities in uncultured chorionic villus samples (CVS). Probes specific for chromosomes 13, 18, 21, X, and Y were used to determine ploidy by analysis of signal number in hybridized nuclei. Aneuploidy detection using this assay was directly compared with the results obtained by conventional cytogenetic analysis in a consecutive, clinical study of 2,709 CVS and placental samples. The FISH assay yielded discrete differences in the signal profiles between cytogenetically normal and abnormal samples. On the basis of these results, we generated FISH-assay cutoff values that discriminated between karyotypically normal and aneuploid samples. Samples with mosaicism and a single sample with possible heritable small chromosome X probe target were exceptions and showed poor agreement between FISH results and conventional cytogenetics. We conclude that the FISH assay may act as a more accurate and less labor-demanding alternative to "direct" CVS analysis.

The region surrounding the PKD1 gene: a 700-kb P1 contig from a YAC-deficient interval

As part of an effort to identify the gene responsible for the predominant form of polycystic kidney disease (PKD1), we used a gridded human P1 library for contig assembly. The interval of interest, a 700-kb segment on chromosome 16p13.3, can be physically delineated by the genetic markers D16S125 and D16S84 and chromosomally characterized as a GC-rich isochore enriched for CpG islands, genes, and Alu-like repeats. Our attempts to recover CEPH YACs that encode this region of chromosome 16 were unsuccessful. However, we screened an arrayed P1 library using 15 distinct probes from the D16S125-D16S84 interval and identified 56 independent P1 clones. Only one probe from the interval was unsuccessful in identifying a P1 clone. Forty-four P1 clones were determined to be unique based on restriction enzyme analysis, and 42 of these were found to originate from chromosome 16p13.3, based on FISH to metaphase chromosomes. The 700-kb interval could be defined by a single sequence-ready contig comprised of 12 P1 clones and 1 cosmid clone. Our studies support the use of multiple libraries to generate the requisite physical reagents for positional cloning and encourage the use of Escherichia coli-based large-insert cloning systems to recover clones from YAC-deficient chromosomal intervals.

Generation of a transcriptional map for a 700-kb region surrounding the polycystic kidney disease type 1 (PKD1) and tuberous sclerosis type 2 (TSC2) disease genes on human chromosome 16p3.3

A 700-kb region of DNA in human chromosome 16p13.3 has been shown to contain the polycystic kidney disease 1 (PKD1) and the tuberous sclerosis type 2 (TSC2) disease genes. An estimated 20 genes are present in this region of chromosome 16. We have initiated studies to identify transcribed sequences in this region using a bacteriophage P1 contig containing 700 kb of DNA surrounding the PKD1 and TSC2 genes. We have isolated 96 unique exon traps from this interval, with 23 of the trapped exons containing sequences from five genes known to be in the region. Thirty exon traps have been mapped to additional transcription units based on data base homologies, Northern analysis, or their presence in cDNA or reverse transcriptase (RT)-PCR products. We have mapped the human RNPS gene to the cloned interval. We have obtained cDNAs or RT-PCR products from eight novel genes, with sequences from seven of these genes having homology to sequences in the data bases. Two of the newly identified genes represent human homologs for rat and murine genes identified previously. We have isolated three exon traps with homology to sequences in the data bases but have been unable to confirm the presence of these exon traps in expressed sequences. In addition, we have isolated 43 exon traps that do not map to our existing cDNAs or PCR products and have no homology to sequences in the data bases. In this report we present a transcriptional map for the 700 kb of DNA surrounding the PKD1 and TSC2 genes.

Development of a model system to compare cell separation methods for the isolation of fetal cells from maternal blood

Three major methods have been described for the isolation of fetal cells from maternal blood: fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS), immunomagnetic beads, and magnetic-activated cell sorting (MACS). To date, no study has directly compared fetal cell recovery using each of these methods. Here we describe our system using a "model' male fetal cell mixed into female peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Fetal cell yields and purities were assayed by a quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) using chromosomes Y- and 7-specific sequences. Fetal cell recovery was investigated by selection of CD71+ cells or depletion of CD45+ cells. Our data demonstrated variation in fetal cell recovery for all methods tested, although CD71+ selection by FACS gave the best and most consistent results.

A simplified procedure for developing multiplex PCRs

We have developed a simplified method for multiplex PCR based on the use of chimeric primers. Each primer contains a 3' region complementary to sequence-specific recognition sites and a 5' region made up of an unrelated 20-nucleotide sequence. Identical reaction conditions, cycling times, and annealing temperatures have been established for any PCR primer pair comprising the chimeric motif. Under these conditions, efficient multiplex amplification is achieved easily and reproducibly by simple adjustment of the individual primer concentrations. No additional modification of either the reaction components or annealing temperatures is required. The use of tagged primers provides a method for primer design that eliminates the multiple optimization steps involved in developing multiplex PCR.

Increased exon-trapping efficiency through modifications to the pSPL3 splicing vector

Exon trapping allows for the rapid identification and cloning of coding regions from cloned eukaryotic DNA. In preliminary experiments, we observed two phenomena which limited the exon-trapping efficiency of pSPL3-based systems. The first factor that affected performance was revealed when we found that up to 50% of the putative trapped exons contained sequences derived from the intron of the pSPL3 trapping vector. Removal of the DNA sequences responsible for the cryptic splice event from the original splicing vector resulted in a new vector, pSPL3B. We demonstrate that pSPL3B virtually eliminates pSPL3-only spliced products while maximizing the proportion of exon traps containing genomic DNA (> 98%). The other step which impacted performance was our observation that a majority of the ampicillin-resistant (APR) clones produced after shotgun subcloning from ApR cosmids into pSPL3 were untrappable, pSPL3-deficient, recircularized cosmid vector fragments. Replacement of the pSPL3 ApR gene with the CmR cassette encoding chloramphenicol (Cm) acetyltransferase enabled selection for only pSPL3-containing CmR clones. We show a 30-40-fold increase in the initial subcloning efficiency of cosmid-derived fragments with pSPL3-CAM, when compared to pSPL3. The collective vector alterations described improve the overall exon-trapping efficiency of the pSPL3-based trapping system.

Rapid prenatal diagnosis of 14 cases of triploidy using fish with multiple probes

Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) of chromosome-specific probes to interphase nuclei can rapidly identify aneuploidies in uncultured amniotic fluid cells. Using DNA probe sets specific for chromosomes 13, 18, 21, X, and Y, we have identified 14 fetuses where the hybridization pattern was consistent with a triploid chromosome constitution. In each case, the identification of fetal abnormalities by ultrasound examination initiated a request for rapid determination of ploidy status via prenatal FISH analysis of uncultured amniocytes. FISH produced a three-signal pattern for the three autosomes in combination with signals indicating an XXX or XXY sex chromosome complement. This hybridization pattern was interpreted to be consistent with triploidy. Results were reported to the physician within 2 days of amniocentesis and subsequently confirmed by cytogenetics. These cases demonstrate the utility of FISH for rapid prenatal identification of triploidy, particularly when fetal abnormalities are seen with ultrasonographic examination.

Fluorescent in situ hybridization and second-trimester sonographic anomalies: uses and limitations

The critical need for rapid and reliable karyotype analysis can be no greater than in the setting of sonographic fetal anomalies. Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) directly applied to interphase chromosomes can decrease the time required to identify the common aneuploidies. Our retrospective study reviewed 50 consecutive patients with sonographic fetal anomalies who underwent FISH. Within this high risk group, nonmosaic chromosomal aneuploidies were present in 16% of the fetuses (8 of 50), and 2 additional fetuses had cytogenetic abnormalities: 1 case, 46,XY,-12,+der(12)t(12;13)(p13; q14.1), and 1 case a 10% mosaic for trisomy 21. Of the 10 cytogenetically abnormal fetuses, FISH was able to identify correctly all 8 of the nonmosaic aneuploidies within 2 days of receipt of the specimen in the laboratory. Clinical decisions can be made on the basis of concordant FISH and ultrasound abnormalities, shortening the decision-making process for most of the aneuploid cases. However, our experience demonstrates some of the limitations of current FISH protocols and the continued necessity for formal karyotype analysis.

Fetal cells in maternal blood: determination of purity and yield by quantitative polymerase chain reaction

OBJECTIVE

The detection of fetal aneuploidy and gene mutations by analysis of fetal cells in maternal blood has demonstrated the feasibility of noninvasive prenatal diagnosis. Fetal cells are rare in the maternal circulation; all current methods used for their isolation also yield maternal cells. We developed a method that permits a quantitative assessment of the relative numbers of fetal and maternal cells.

STUDY DESIGN

Samples from 40 pregnant women were flow sorted with different monoclonal antibodies. Deoxyribonucleic acid was subsequently purified from candidate fetal cells; polymerase chain reaction was performed with synthetic primers specific for sequences on chromosomes Y and 7.

RESULTS

The maximum number of fetal cells detected was 52 in 1080 maternal cells. Fetal cell purity ranged from 0.001% to 4.8%. Fetal cells were detected with antibodies to CD71, CD36, and glycophorin A.

CONCLUSION

Quantitative polymerase chain reaction enables the determination of the purity and yield of fetal cells remaining after isolation from maternal blood, facilitating rapid comparisons between different cell separation techniques.

FISH: sensitivity and specificity on sorted and unsorted cells

The results of our FISH studies of maternal samples and model systems are very encouraging. Aneuploidies have been detected prospectively, and the model experiments show that the FISH technique is both sensitive and specific. We have previously shown that the probe sets used in this study can be combined for simultaneous multicolor analysis. Given sufficient enrichment of the fetal cells, FISH analysis should prove applicable to this diagnostic challenge.

High resolution mapping of overlapping cosmids by fluorescence in situ hybridization

The constituents of two cosmid contigs were analyzed by high resolution mapping using two-color fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) to extended DNA molecules. Samples were prepared by lysing the nuclei in situ followed by histone depletion. This treatment results in elongate DNA filaments appropriate for high resolution mapping. The hybridization signals appeared as a strong of fluorescent spots separated by non-fluorescing gaps. Probe-specific features of the hybridization patterns were detected and some of the non-fluorescing gaps were found to represent regions of repetitive DNA suppressed during hybridization.

Rapid prenatal diagnosis of chromosomal aneuploidies by fluorescence in situ hybridization: clinical experience with 4,500 specimens

Detection of chromosome aneuploidies in uncultured amniocytes is possible using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). We herein describe the results of the first clinical program which utilized FISH for the rapid detection of chromosome aneuploidies in uncultured amniocytes. FISH was performed on physician request, as an adjunct to cytogenetics in 4,500 patients. Region-specific DNA probes to chromosomes 13, 18, 21, X, and Y were used to determine ploidy by analysis of signal number in hybridized nuclei. A sample was considered to be euploid when all autosomal probes generated two hybridization signals and when a normal sex chromosome pattern was observed in greater than or equal to 80% of hybridized nuclei. A sample was considered to be aneuploid when greater than or equal to 70% of hybridized nuclei displayed the same abnormal hybridization pattern for a specific probe. Of the attempted analyses, 90.2% met these criteria and were reported as informative to referring physicians within 2 d of receipt. Based on these reporting parameters, the overall detection rate for aneuploidies was 73.3% (107/146), with an accuracy of informative results for aneuploidies of 93.9% (107/114). Compared to cytogenetics, the accuracy of all informative FISH results, euploid and aneuploid, was 99.8%, and the specificity was 99.9%. In those pregnancies where fetal abnormalities had been observed by ultrasound, referring physicians requested FISH plus cytogenetics at a significantly higher rate than they requested cytogenetics alone. The current prenatal FISH protocol is not designed to detect all chromosome abnormalities and should only be utilized as an adjunctive test to cytogenetics. This experience demonstrates that FISH can provide a rapid and accurate clinical method for prenatal identification of chromosome aneuploidies.

Identification of the M1101K mutation in the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene and complete detection of cystic fibrosis mutations in the Hutterite population

The Hutterite population is a genetic isolate with an increased incidence of cystic fibrosis (CF). Previously we identified three CF haplotypes defined by polymorphisms flanking the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene. delta F508 was present on one of the haplotypes in only 35% of CF chromosomes. We hypothesized that the other two CF haplotypes, one of which was the most common and the other of which is rare, each harbored different non-delta F508 mutations. Single-strand conformation polymorphism analysis detected a missense mutation, M1101K, in both chromosomes of a Hutterite patient carrying the two non-delta F508 haplotypes. M1101K appears to have originated on an uncommon CFTR allele and to be infrequent outside the Hutterite population. The presence of M1101K on two haplotypes is likely the result of a CFTR intragenic recombination which occurred since the founding, 10-12 generations ago, of the Hutterite population. The crossover was located between exons 14a and 17b, an interval of approximately 15 kbp. delta F508 and M1101K accounted for all of the CF mutations in patients from 16 CF families representing the three subdivisions of the Hutterite population.