Barriers to smoking cessation initiatives for Medicaid clients in managed care

In this paper, key barriers to providing smoking cessation services for low income individuals are illustrated using epidemiologic data from a population which was enrolled in a Medicaid managed care plan in Kansas during 1998. The Plan served 623 pregnant women who could potentially benefit from assistance in avoiding tobacco exposure. The prevalence of smoking among adult clients was 44.8%. twice the national average. Only 52.3% of adult smokers were advised by a provider to quit in the previous year. Most individuals in the client population (81.7% of the 10,733 members) were children, suggesting the importance of targeting environmental tobacco smoke exposure in order to reduce morbidity from asthma. The adult household member who needed smoking cessation services, however, was unlikely to qualify for health care benefits through Medicaid. The median length of enrollment was only 1.9 months, providing very little client contact time for tobacco control initiatives. The literature suggests that some providers may lack skills in treating tobacco as an addiction. It would be a major task for the managed care organization to train the 2,000 physicians in 68 of the 105 counties of Kansas who cared for this population. Potential solutions include improving reimbursement for smoking prevention and treatment, and developing cheaper smoking cessation services which are effective and acceptable among low-income individuals. The managed care organization could provide patient education materials and staff training for physicians and other members of the office staff.

Medically recommended cessation of employment among pregnant women in Georgia

OBJECTIVE

To ascertain the proportion of employed pregnant women who receive medical advice to stop working during pregnancy and to describe their characteristics.

METHODS

Data were analyzed from the Georgia Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System, a surveillance system that surveys new mothers about pregnancy risk factors, health behaviors, and birth-related outcomes. Employment during pregnancy was defined as work for pay for 10 hours or more per week.

RESULTS

We studied 1635 women who were employed during pregnancy. A physician or nurse had advised 27.7% (95% CI 24.5%, 30.9%) of them to stop working during pregnancy. Independent predictors of receiving this advice were hospitalization (RR 2.3, 95% CI 1.7, 2.8) and history of previous preterm birth (RR 1.6, 95% CI 1.1, 2.2). Low birth weight (under 2500 g) occurred in 5.8% of women not advised to stop work, in 6.9% of women advised to stop work because of swelling, fatigue, stress, or another reason, and in 13.4% of women advised to stop work because of labor, high blood pressure, or vaginal bleeding (P <.001). Among women advised to stop working in the first through seventh months of pregnancy, 91.7% (95% CI 88.8, 94.5) delivered at 36 or more weeks' gestation.

CONCLUSION

Work cessation during pregnancy was commonly recommended in this population and was associated with clinical risk factors and adverse birth outcomes. For some women it resulted in a long period of work absence before delivery.

Health information in material safety data sheets for a chemical which causes asthma

OBJECTIVE

To assess the quality of health information on material safety data sheets (MSDS) for a workplace chemical that is well known to cause or exacerbate asthma (toluene diisocyanate, TDI).

DESIGN

We reviewed a random sample of 61 MSDSs for TDI products produced by 30 manufacturers.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Two physicians independently abstracted data from each MSDS onto a standardized audit form. One manufacturer provided no language about any respiratory effects of TDI exposure. Asthma was listed as a potential health effect by only 15 of the 30 manufacturers (50%). Listing asthma in the MSDS was associated with higher toluene diisocyanate concentrations in the product (P <.042). Allergic or sensitizing respiratory reactions were listed by 21 manufacturers (70%).

CONCLUSIONS

Many MSDSs for toluene diisocyanate do not communicate clearly that exposure can cause or exacerbate asthma. This suggests that physicians should not rely on the MSDS for information about health effects of this chemical.

Workplace reproductive problems

Occupational exposures can harm reproductive processes in men or women. Exposures may affect fertility, pregnancy outcomes or the child's health after delivery. The goal of patient management is to provide counseling at an appropriate level. Over-restricting the patient should be avoided while hazardous exposures should be identified and reduced. The occupational history can be used to estimate the magnitude of each exposure. If the exposure is a known reproductive hazard and the exposure level appears significant, there are several options for making the job safer. Modifications in work practices can be accomplished by advising the patient about changing work practices, writing formal work restrictions and talking with the employer. Temporary job transfers may be available. In some cases, a medical leave is needed. The primary care provider can play a key role in assisting patients to reduce reproductive risks.

Managing patients with concerns about workplace reproductive hazards

OBJECTIVES

To find out who uses an occupational reproductive consultation service, what proportion of patients have different types of workplace exposures, and what hypotheses can be generated about barriers to implementing medically necessary job modifications to promote reproductive health.

METHODS

A case series study was conducted by reviewing medical records at two occupational health clinics.

RESULTS

51 patients (1 man and 50 women) were seen, 10 of whom wished to discuss a future pregnancy and 41 of whom were pregnant. Pregnant women worked with a mean of 15.5 different chemicals, and patients were also concerned about ionizing radiation, biological hazards, electromagnetic fields, and ultraviolet light. Pregnant women made clinic visits at a mean gestational age of 10.9 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

Only one man used the service, suggesting a lack of knowledge about possible paternal contributions to adverse reproductive outcomes. Many pregnant women visited the clinic too late to prevent harm from exposure to some teratogens, so preconception counseling may be of benefit. Cases are presented that illustrate ways in which the primary care provider can assist the patient who may be exposed to reproductive hazards.

Developing occupational and environmental medicine curricula for primary care residents: project EPOCH-Envi. Educating Physicians in OCupational Health and the Environment

To help primary care residency programs develop or improve residency curricula in occupational and environmental medicine, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health launched a train-the-trainer initiative. This project was called EPOCH-Envi (Educating Physicians in OCcupational Health and the Environment). From 1990 to 1996, 46 2-day curriculum development workshops were held. These featured (1) guidelines on how to plan, implement, and evaluate a curriculum, (2) continuing education on occupational illnesses and injuries, (3) a worksite or environmental site visit, and (4) information resources. A total of 435 faculty from 305 residency programs participated, representing 42.5% of the family practice residencies and 24.9% of the internal medicine residencies in the United States. A survey conducted among attendees (60.4% response rate) 17 months after their workshop revealed that 65.6% of respondents had added lectures on occupational and environmental topics to the residency curriculum. Other curriculum improvements were also made. Primary care physicians manage most patients with occupational and environmental health problems or concerns. Providing technical assistance specifically designed to support occupational and environmental health education in primary care residencies can have a positive impact on curriculum content.

Effect of over-the-counter cimetidine on phenytoin concentrations in patients with seizures

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effects of the maximum recommended over-the-counter (OTC) cimetidine dosage on phenytoin concentrations in ambulatory seizure patients on long-term phenytoin therapy.

METHODS

Adults with seizure disorders requiring phenytoin therapy were recruited. Trough total phenytoin concentrations were measured initially and once weekly for six weeks. All assays were performed using Biotrack patient-side cartridges. After a two-week baseline period, patients took cimetidine 200 mg twice daily for two weeks. Toxicity was monitored via weekly neurologic examinations and midweek telephone surveys. Patients were asked to return to clinic weekly during a two-week cimetidine washout period.

RESULTS

Nine patients entered and completed the study. All but two patients took other anticonvulsants known to interact with phenytoin (carbamazepine, n = 5; phenobarbital, n = 2). No adverse effects or changes in seizure frequency were reported. Paired Student's t-tests revealed no significant difference between serum phenytoin concentrations before (12.3+/-3.2 mg/L [mean +/- SD]) and after (12.8+/-4.0 mg/L) two weeks on the OTC cimetidine regimen. No differences were noted in estimated pharmacokinetic parameters (maximum metabolic rate, Michaelis-Menten constant) for the same time periods (paired Student's t-test, p > 0.05). The Biotrack assay had an r2 = 0.7311 (p < 0.001, two-sided) when compared with TDx.

CONCLUSIONS

It is possible that the lack of change in phenytoin concentrations was a result of the low daily dosage of cimetidine used or other factors related to the "real world" setting of the study. However, the potential for a serious drug interaction occurring in patients taking long-term oral phenytoin and OTC cimetidine appears to be small.

The unit of analysis error in studies about physicians' patient care behavior

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the frequency with which patients are incorrectly used as the unit of analysis among statistical calculations in published studies of physicians' patient care behavior.

DESIGN

Retrospective review of studies published during 1980-1990. ARTICLES: 54 articles retrieved by a computerized search using medical subject headings for physicians and study characteristics. Article selection criteria included the requirement that the physician should have been the correct unit of analysis.

INTERVENTION

Presence of the error was determined by consensus using published criteria.

MAIN RESULTS

The error was present in 38 articles (70%). The number of study physicians was reported in 35 articles (65%). The error was found in 57% of articles that reported the number of study physicians and in 95% of those that did not. The error rate was not lower among articles published more recently nor among those published in journals with higher rates of article citations in the medical literature.

CONCLUSION

The unit of analysis error occurs frequently and can generate artificially low p values. Failure to report the number of study physicians can be a clue that this type of error has been made.

Can physician education lower the cost of prescription drugs? A prospective, controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether an educational program featuring a drug cost manual can assist physicians in reducing their patients' out-of-pocket prescription drug expenses.

DESIGN

Prospective controlled trial.

SETTING

A general internal medicine-teaching clinic in a university hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Fifty-one medical interns.

INTERVENTION

Thirty-one interns received a manual of comparative drug prices annotated with prescribing advice, two feedback reports, and weekly cost-oriented prescribing reminders. A control group concurrently participated in a manual-based educational program on cholesterol management.

MEASUREMENTS

Copies of 3012 prescriptions written over 8 months were analyzed.

MAIN RESULTS

Intervention group physicians prescribed less expensive drugs within classes of drugs. The change in drug price score per prescription was -0.15 (95% Cl, -0.27 to -0.04; P = 0.01). A score of 3 was assigned to the most expensive, 2 was assigned to intermediate-priced, and 1 was assigned to the least expensive drug or drugs in the class. An increase of 0.74 months' (Cl, 0.49 to 0.98; P less than 0.001) supply of medication was dispensed per prescription, reducing dispensing fees. The program was well accepted by the physicians.

CONCLUSION

This relatively simple educational intervention can help physicians to reduce their patients' drug expenses and may serve as a model for incorporating cost information into the routine practice of medicine.

Teaching occupational and environmental medicine in primary care residency training programs: experience using three approaches during 1984-1991

There is a critical shortage of physicians trained to recognize and treat occupational and environmental health problems. We implemented several required teaching programs for internal medicine and family medicine residents that focus on providing primary care for these problems. Clinical experiences were developed using the university and medical center as an example of a workplace with chemical and physical hazards. On-site experiences were also provided at local industries, but when resident stipend support for this aspect was discontinued, that part of the program was suspended. Didactic programs were associated with a statistically significant improvement in house staff knowledge scores. These occupational and environmental health issues can be introduced during residency, resulting in increased expertise in this discipline.

Lengthy bed rest prescribed for acute low back pain: experience at three general medicine walk-in clinics

Early gradual ambulation is currently recommended for patients with acute low back pain if results of neurologic examination are normal. Bed rest for up to 2 days is considered optimal. To assess management practices, we retrospectively reviewed the medical records of individuals with acute back pain treated at three independent general medicine walk-in clinics. Patients having an acute flare-up of chronic back pain were excluded. Bed rest was recommended at the initial visit for 171 patients who had normal findings on neurologic examination. The duration of recommended bed rest was recorded in 76 of these 171 patients' medical records (44%). The median duration of recommended bed rest was 5.5 days (range 1 to 14 days). Most patients (60/76 [79%]) were advised to rest in bed longer than 2 days. Even if all patients in whom duration of bed rest was not recorded had been told to rest in bed for 2 days or less, bed rest prescriptions would still have been too lengthy in 60 of these 171 patients (35%). This practice may prolong the recovery of patients with acute low back pain.

Effect of daily charge feedback on inpatient charges and physician knowledge and behavior

Concurrent charge feedback has gained widespread acceptance as a method of minimizing hospitals' losses under the Medicare prospective payment system despite the fact that its effect on patient outcomes, physician behavior, or charges has not been studied in depth. In a controlled trial on two medical wards in an academic medical center, the effect of daily charge feedback on charges was studied. Sixty-eight house staff and 16 teaching attending physicians participated during a 35-week period, taking care of 1057 eligible patients. No significant differences in charges were seen when all patients were included. Since 45% of patients had planned protocol admissions (diagnostic workups or protocol treatment) on which the house staff had little change to impact, a subgroup analysis was performed, excluding these patients. In the remaining patients, a highly significant reduction in mean total charges (17%), length of stay (18%), room charges (18%), and diagnostic testing (20%) was found. In-hospital mortality and preventable readmission within 30 days were similar on the two wards. It was concluded that charge feedback alone is effective in a teaching hospital for decreasing charges.

Selective criteria may increase lumbosacral spine roentgenogram use in acute low-back pain

Eleven clinical criteria have been proposed to limit use of lumbosacral spine roentgenograms in patients with acute low-back pain who are at risk for vertebral cancer, osteomyelitis, acute fracture, or herniated disk. We retrospectively applied the criteria to 471 patients with acute low-back pain in three teaching hospital walk-in clinics. Roentgenograms were obtained at the initial visit in 99 patients (21.1%); the number would have increased to 217 (46.1%) if the criteria had been used. The following four patient characteristics were associated with actual roentgenogram use: older age, longer duration of symptoms, reflex asymmetry, and point vertebral tenderness. Adoption of the 11 criteria studied herein may inadvertently increase roentgenogram use, thereby raising health care costs and exposing more patients to gonadal irradiation. The standard of practice in these three clinics seemed to entail use of less broad roentgenogram selection criteria. Other published guidelines for roentgenograms emphasize clinical follow-up, reserving further evaluation for patients who fail to improve after a trial of bed rest and analgesics.

Need for insulin therapy in type II diabetes mellitus. A randomized trial

To identify patients with type II diabetes mellitus for whom insulin therapy is most beneficial, we conducted a randomized controlled trial in the general medicine clinic of a university hospital. Asymptomatic, obese, insulin-treated patients were given diet and diabetes education and, in half of these patients, insulin therapy was withdrawn. Over six months, patients developing hyperglycemic symptoms or acetonemia were counted as study failures. Failure criteria developed in 13 of 25 insulin-withdrawal patients, at a median of four weeks after withdrawal, compared with two of 24 control subjects. Elevated stimulated glucose levels predicted the need for insulin therapy. Hyperglycemia worsened in insulin-withdrawal patients who did not meet study failure criteria, but it improved in control patients. Study patients were insulin deficient as shown by low baseline C peptide values (0.43 +/- 0.05 nmol/L). The prompt metabolic decompensation precipitated by insulin withdrawal suggests that insulin-deficient patients may benefit from insulin therapy and may need it to prevent symptomatic hyperglycemia.

Characterization of aquatic bacteria and cloning of genes specifying partial degradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid

Water samples from rivers, streams, ponds, and activated sewage were tested for the presence of bacteria which utilize 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) as a sole source of carbon. Seventy percent of the attempted enrichments yielded pure cultures of 2,4-D-metabolizing bacteria. All but 1 of the 30 isolates were gram-negative rods, all but 2 were motile, and all were nonfermentative and oxidase and catalase positive. Nine isolates had DNA guanine-plus-cytosine values of 61.1 to 65 mol%. One isolate had a 67 mol% guanine-plus-cytosine value. The results suggest that these 2,4-D-metabolizing bacteria belong to the genus Alcaligenes. Fourteen of 23 isolates contained one or more detectable plasmids of about 20, 60, or 100 megadaltons. HindIII restriction fragment patterns showed these plasmids to be different from each other with one exception. Very similar restriction fragment patterns were revealed with a plasmid isolated from an Alcaligenes eutrophus strain obtained from Australia (pJMP397) and in an Alcaligenes sp. isolated in Oregon (pEML159). These two plasmids were about 56 megadaltons, had the same guanine-plus-cytosine value, were transmissable, and coded for 2,4-D metabolism and resistance to HgCl2. Hybridization of these two plasmids was demonstrated by using nick-translated 32P-labeled pJMP397. The vector pBR325 was used to clone HindIII fragments from pEML159. One cloned fragment of 14.8 megaldaltons expressed in Escherichia coli the ability to release 14CO2 from 2,4-D labeled in the acetate portion.