Previously unidentified changes in renal cell carcinoma gene expression identified by parametric analysis of microarray data

Background

Renal cell carcinoma is a common malignancy that often presents as a metastatic-disease for which there are no effective treatments. To gain insights into the mechanism of renal cell carcinogenesis, a number of genome-wide expression profiling studies have been performed. Surprisingly, there is very poor agreement among these studies as to which genes are differentially regulated. To better understand this lack of agreement we profiled renal cell tumor gene expression using genome-wide microarrays (45,000 probe sets) and compare our analysis to previous microarray studies.

Methods

We hybridized total RNA isolated from renal cell tumors and adjacent normal tissue to Affymetrix U133A and U133B arrays. We removed samples with technical defects and removed probesets that failed to exhibit sequence-specific hybridization in any of the samples. We detected differential gene expression in the resulting dataset with parametric methods and identified keywords that are overrepresented in the differentially expressed genes with the Fisher-exact test.

Results

We identify 1,234 genes that are more than three-fold changed in renal tumors by t-test, 800 of which have not been previously reported to be altered in renal cell tumors. Of the only 37 genes that have been identified as being differentially expressed in three or more of five previous microarray studies of renal tumor gene expression, our analysis finds 33 of these genes (89%). A key to the sensitivity and power of our analysis is filtering out defective samples and genes that are not reliably detected.

Conclusions

The widespread use of sample-wise voting schemes for detecting differential expression that do not control for false positives likely account for the poor overlap among previous studies. Among the many genes we identified using parametric methods that were not previously reported as being differentially expressed in renal cell tumors are several oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes that likely play important roles in renal cell carcinogenesis. This highlights the need for rigorous statistical approaches in microarray studies.

Acetylation of histone H4 by Esa1 is required for DNA double-strand break repair

Although the acetylation of histones has a well-documented regulatory role in transcription, its role in other chromosomal functions remains largely unexplored. Here we show that distinct patterns of histone H4 acetylation are essential in two separate pathways of double-strand break repair. A budding yeast strain with mutations in wild-type H4 acetylation sites shows defects in nonhomologous end joining repair and in a newly described pathway of replication-coupled repair. Both pathways require the ESA1 histone acetyl transferase (HAT), which is responsible for acetylating all H4 tail lysines, including ectopic lysines that restore repair capacity to a mutant H4 tail. Arp4, a protein that binds histone H4 tails and is part of the Esa1-containing NuA4 HAT complex, is recruited specifically to DNA double-strand breaks that are generated in vivo. The purified Esa1-Arp4 HAT complex acetylates linear nucleosomal arrays with far greater efficiency than circular arrays in vitro, indicating that it preferentially acetylates nucleosomes near a break site. Together, our data show that histone tail acetylation is required directly for DNA repair and suggest that a related human HAT complex may function similarly.

Replication-related activities establish cohesion between sister chromatids

Replicated sister chromatids are held together from their synthesis in S phase to their separation in anaphase. The process of sister chromatid cohesion is essential for the proper segregation of chromosomes in eukaryotic cells. Recent studies in Saccharomyces cerevisiae have advanced our understanding of how sister chromatid cohesion is established, maintained, and dissolved during the cell cycle. Historical observations have suggested that establishment of cohesion is roughly coincident with replication fork passage. Emerging evidence now indicates that replication fork components, such as PCNA, a novel DNA polymerase, Trf4p/Pol sigma (formerly Trf4p/Pol kappa), and a modified clamp-loader complex, actively participate in the process of the cohesion establishment. Here, we review the molecular events in the chromosome cycle with respect to cohesion. Failure of sister chromatid cohesion results in the aneuploidy characteristic of many birth defects and tumors in humans.

Structure/function analysis of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Trf4/Pol sigma DNA polymerase

The Trf4p/Pol sigma DNA polymerase (formerly Trf4p/Pol kappa) couples DNA replication to the establishment of sister chromatid cohesion. The polymerase is encoded by two redundant homologs in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, TRF4 and TRF5, that together define a fourth essential nuclear DNA polymerase in yeast and probably in all eukaryotes. Here we present a thorough genetic analysis of the founding member of this novel family of DNA polymerases, TRF4. Analyses of mutants carrying 1 of 34 "surface-targeted" alanine scanning mutations in TRF4 have identified those regions required for Pol sigma's essential function, for its role in DNA double-strand break repair, and for its association with chromosomes. The data strongly support the importance of the regions of predicted structural similarity with the Pol beta superfamily as critical for Trf4p/Pol sigma's essential and repair functions. Surprisingly, five lethal mutations lie outside all polymerase homology in a C-terminal region. The protein possesses Mg2+-dependent 3' to 5' exonuclease activity. Cell cycle analysis reveals that Trf4p/Pol sigma associates with chromosomes in G1, S, and G2 phases, but that association is abolished coincident with dissolution of cohesion at the metaphase-to-anaphase transition.

Separase anxiety: dissolving the sister bond and more

Separase is a protease that cleaves the bonds between sister chromatids during cell division. Until now, separase was thought to be a somewhat repressed protease, cleaving only a few substrates in a very controlled fashion. New findings in this issue raise the possibility that separase has some of the atavistic impulses that characterize caspases, its more destructive relatives.

Evidence that replication fork components catalyze establishment of cohesion between sister chromatids

Accurate chromosome segregation requires that replicated sister chromatids are held together until anaphase, when their "cohesion" is dissolved, and they are pulled to opposite spindle poles by microtubules. Establishment of new cohesion between sister chromatids in the next cell cycle is coincident with replication fork passage. Emerging evidence suggests that this temporal coupling is not just a coincident timing of independent events, but rather that the establishment of cohesion is likely to involve the active participation of replication-related activities. These include PCNA, a processivity clamp for some DNA polymerases, Trf4/Pol final sigma (formerly Trf4/Pol kappa), a novel and essential DNA polymerase, and a modified Replication Factor C clamp--loader complex. Here we describe recent advances in how cohesion establishment is linked to replication, highlight important unanswered questions in this new field, and describe a "polymerase switch" model for how cohesion establishment is coupled to replication fork progression. Building the bridges between newly synthesized sister chromatids appears to be a fundamental but previously unrecognized function of the eukaryotic replication machinery.

Pol kappa: A DNA polymerase required for sister chromatid cohesion

Establishment of cohesion between sister chromatids is coupled to replication fork passage through an unknown mechanism. Here we report that TRF4, an evolutionarily conserved gene necessary for chromosome segregation, encodes a DNA polymerase with beta-polymerase-like properties. A double mutant in the redundant homologs, TRF4 and TRF5, is unable to complete S phase, whereas a trf4 single mutant completes a presumably defective S phase that results in a failure of cohesion between the replicated sister chromatids. This suggests that TRFs are a key link in the coordination between DNA replication and sister chromatid cohesion. Trf4 and Trf5 represent the fourth class of essential nuclear DNA polymerases (designated DNA polymerase kappa) in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and probably in all eukaryotes.

The topoisomerase-related function gene TRF4 affects cellular sensitivity to the antitumor agent camptothecin

Camptothecin is an antitumor agent that kills cells by converting DNA topoisomerase I into a DNA-damaging poison. Although camptothecin derivatives are now being used to treat tumors in a variety of clinical protocols, the cellular factors that influence sensitivity to the drug are only beginning to be understood. We report here that two genes required for sister chromatid cohesion, TRF4 and MCD1/SCC1, are also required to repair camptothecin-mediated damage to DNA. The hypersensitivity to camptothecin in the trf4 mutant does not result from elevated expression of DNA topoisomerase I. We show that Trf4 is a nuclear protein whose expression is cell cycle-regulated at a post-transcriptional level. Suppression of camptothecin hypersensitivity in the trf4 mutant by gene overexpression resulted in the isolation of three genes: another member of the TRF4 gene family, TRF5, and two genes that may influence higher order chromosome structure, ZDS1 and ZDS2. We have isolated and sequenced two human TRF4 family members, hTRF4-1 and hTRF4-2. The hTRF4-1 gene maps to chromosome 5p15, a region of frequent copy number alteration in several tumor types. The evolutionary conservation of TRF4 suggests that it may also influence mammalian cell sensitivity to camptothecin.

Mitotic chromosome condensation in the rDNA requires TRF4 and DNA topoisomerase I in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

DNA topoisomerase I (topo I) is known to participate in the process of DNA replication, but is not essential in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The TRF4 gene is also nonessential and was identified in a screen for mutations that are inviable in combination with a top1 null mutation. Here we report the surprising finding that a top1 trf4-ts double mutant is defective in the mitotic events of chromosome condensation, spindle elongation, and nuclear segregation, but not in DNA replication. Direct examination of rDNA-containing mitotic chromosomes demonstrates that a top1 trf4-ts mutant fails both to establish and to maintain chromosome condensation in the rDNA at mitosis. We show that the Trf4p associates physically with both Smclp and Smc2p, the S. cerevisiae homologs of Xenopus proteins that are required for mitotic chromosome condensation in vitro. The defect in the top1 trf4-ts mutant is sensed by the MAD1-dependent spindle assembly checkpoint but not by the RAD9-dependent DNA damage checkpoint, further supporting the notion that chromosome structure influences spindle assembly. These data indicate that TOP1 (encoding topo I) and TRF4 participate in overlapping or dependent steps in mitotic chromosome condensation and serve to define a previously unrecognized biological function of topo I.

Cloning, mapping, and in vivo localization of a human member of the PKCI-1 protein family (PRKCNH1)

We report here the complete cDNA sequence, genomic mapping, and immunolocalization of the first human member of the protein kinase C inhibitor (PKCI-1) gene family. The predicted human protein (hPKCI-1) is 96% identical to bovine and 53% identical to maize members, indicating the great evolutionary conservation of this protein family. The hPKCI-1 gene (HGMV-approved symbol PRKCNH1) maps to human chromosome 5q31.2 by fluorescence in situ hybridization. Indirect immunofluorescence shows that hPKCI-1 localizes to cytoskeletal structures in the cytoplasm of a human fibroblast cell line and is largely excluded from the nucleus. The cytoplasmic localization of hPKCI-1 is consistent with a postulated role in mediating a membrane-derived signal in response to ionizing radiation.

A novel family of TRF (DNA topoisomerase I-related function) genes required for proper nuclear segregation

We recently reported the identification of a gene, TRF4 (for DNA topoisomerase related function), in a screen for mutations that are synthetically lethal with mutations in DNA topoisomerase I (top1). Here we describe the isolation of a second member of the TRF4 gene family, TRF5. Overexpression of TRF5 complements the inviability of top1 trf4 double mutants. The predicted Trf5 protein is 55% identical and 72% similar to Trf4p. As with Trf4p, a region of Trf5p is homologous to the catalytically dispensable N-terminus of Top1p. The TRF4/5 function is essential as trf4 trf5 double mutants are inviable. A trf4 (ts) trf5 double mutant is hypersensitive to the anti-microtubule agent thiabendazole at a semi-permissive temperature, suggesting that TRF4/5 function is required at the time of mitosis. Examination of nuclear morphology in a trf4 (ts) trf5 mutant at a restrictive temperature reveals the presence of many cells undergoing aberrant nuclear division, as well as many anucleate cells, demonstrating that the TRF4/5 function is required for proper mitosis. Database searches reveal the existence of probable Schizosaccharomyces pombe and human homologs of Trf4p, indicating that TRF4 is the canonical member of a gene family that is highly conserved evolutionarily.

Isolation of mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae requiring DNA topoisomerase I

Despite evidence that DNA topoisomerase I is required to relieve torsional stress during DNA replication and transcription, yeast strains with a top1 null mutation are viable and display no gross defects in DNA or RNA synthesis, possibly because other proteins provide overlapping functions. We isolated mutants whose inviablility or growth defect is relieved when TOP1 is expressed [trf mutants (topoisomerase one-requiring function)]. The TRF genes define at least four complementation groups. TRF3 is allelic to TOP2. TRF1 is allelic to HPR1, previously shown to be homologous to TOP1 over two short regions. TRF4 encodes a novel 584-amino acid protein with homology to the N-terminus of Saccharomyces cerevisiae topo I. Like top1 mutants, trf4 mutants have elevated rDNA recombination and fail to shut off RNA polymerase II transcription in stationary phase. trf4 null mutants are cs for viability, display reduced expression of GAL1 and Cell Cycle Box UAS::LacZ fusions, and are inviable in combination with trfI null mutants, indicating that both proteins may share a common function with DNA topoisomerase I. The existence of multiple TRF complementation groups suggests that not all biological functions of topo I can be carried out by topo II.

The product of the ataxia-telangiectasia group D complementing gene, ATDC, interacts with a protein kinase C substrate and inhibitor

Ataxia-telangiectasia (AT) is an autosomal recessive human genetic disease characterized by immunological, neurological, and developmental defects and an increased risk of cancer. Cells from individuals with AT show sensitivity to ionizing radiation, elevated recombination, cell cycle abnormalities, and aberrant cytoskeletal organization. The molecular basis of the defect is unknown. A candidate AT gene (ATDC) was isolated on the basis of its ability to complement the ionizing radiation sensitivity of AT group D fibroblasts. Whether ATDC is mutated in any AT patients is not known. We have found that the ATDC protein physically interacts with the intermediate-filament protein vimentin, which is a protein kinase C substrate and colocalizing protein, and with an inhibitor of protein kinase C, hPKCI-1. Indirect immunofluorescence analysis of cultured cells transfected with a plasmid encoding an epitope-tagged ATDC protein localizes the protein to vimentin filaments. We suggest that the ATDC and hPKCI-1 proteins may be components of a signal transduction pathway that is induced by ionizing radiation and mediated by protein kinase C.

Frequent novel DNA copy number increase in squamous cell head and neck tumors

We have undertaken a study of DNA copy number changes in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas to identify novel DNA copy number changes and to determine the significance of previous findings of cytogenetic alterations in cultured cells. Comparative genomic hybridization was performed on genomic DNA extracted from ten tumors. A novel copy number gain on chromosome 3q26-27 and a loss of chromosome 3p were found at high frequency (> or = 50% of tumors). Many other novel chromosomal copy number changes were identified but occurred at a lower frequency. In addition, our data confirm that DNA copy number changes that frequently occur in cultured cells, such as loss of chromosome 3p, also occur in tumors. Frequently altered loci may encode oncogenes or tumor suppressor genes involved in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma tumorigenesis.

Identification of novel regions of altered DNA copy number in small cell lung tumors

Identification of the genetic alterations that occur in tumors is an important approach to understanding tumorigenesis. We have used comparative genomic hybridization (CGH), a novel molecular cytogenetic method, to identify the gross DNA copy number changes that commonly occur in small cell lung cancer (SCLC). We analyzed ten SCLC tumors (seven primary tumors and three metastases) from eight patients. We found frequent increases in DNA copy number on chromosome arms 5p, 8q, 3q, and Xq and frequent decreases in copy number on chromosome arms 3p, 17p, 5q, 8p, 13q, and 4p. The increase in copy number at 8q24 (MYC) and decreases at 17p13 (TP53), 13q14 (RB), and 3p have previously been identified in SCLC with other methods. Many of the other regions in which we detected common copy number changes have not been reported to be regions of common alteration in SCLC tumors. Comparison of copy number changes between a primary tumor and a metastasis from the same patient showed that they were more closely related to each other than to any of the other tumors. The results of direct CGH analysis of SCLC tumors reported here confirm the existence of copy number changes that we identified previously by using cell lines.

Neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2) gene is somatically mutated in mesothelioma but not in lung cancer

We have found 16 of 28 small cell lung cancers, 17 of 31 non-small cell lung cancers, 2 of 3 carcinoids, and 12 of 14 mesotheliomas that had chromosome 22 cytogenetic abnormalities. To determine whether the neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2) gene located on chromosome 22 participates in the oncogenesis of these malignancies, we studied DNAs from lung cancer cell lines and mesotheliomas using Southern blot analysis and the single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) technique for mutations covering 8 of the 16 known NF2 exons. We detected 7 mutations in 17 mesotheliomas (41%) within the coding region of NF2 but none in 75 lung cancer cell lines (38 small cell lung cancers, 34 non-small cell lung cancers, and 3 carcinoids). These mutations were found to be somatic when normal tissue was available for testing. Four mesothelioma cell lines had relatively large deletions (approximately 10-50 kilobases) in the NF2 gene detectable by Southern blot analysis. Two mesothelioma cell lines had nonsense mutations at codons 57 and 341, respectively. Another mesothelioma obtained as a specimen directly from a patient, had a 10-base pair microdeletion from nucleotide 1004 to nucleotide 1013 causing a frameshift mutation. These results suggest that the NF2 gene participates in the oncogenesis in a subset of mesotheliomas but not in lung cancers.

HPR1 encodes a global positive regulator of transcription in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The Hpr1 protein has an unknown function, although it contains a region of homology to DNA topoisomerase I. We have found that hpr1 null mutants are defective in the transcription of many physiologically unrelated genes, including GAL1, HO, ADH1, and SUC2, by using a combination of Northern (RNA) blot analysis, primer extension, and upstream activation sequence-lacZ fusions. Many of the genes positively regulated by HPR1 also require SWI1, SWI2-SNF2, SWI3, SNF5, and SNF6. The transcriptional defect at HO and the CCB::lacZ upstream activation sequence in hpr1 mutants is partially suppressed by a deletion of SIN1, which encodes an HMG1p-like protein. Elevated gene dosage of either histones H3 and H4 or H2A and H2B results in a severe growth defect in combination with an hpr1 null mutation. However, increased gene dosage of all four histones simultaneously restores near-normal growth in hpr1 mutants. Altered in vivo Dam methylase sensitivity is observed at two HPR1-dependent promoters (GAL1 and SUC2). Most of the Hpr1 protein present in the cell is in a large complex (10(6) Da) that is distinct from the SWI-SNF protein complex. We propose that HPR1 affects transcription and recombination by altering chromatin structure.

Expression of the candidate A-T gene ATDC is not detectable in a human cell line with a normal response to ionizing radiation

Nucleotide sequence analysis of a candidate gene for A-T group D (ATDC) demonstrated that it is related to a group of proteins that contain both zinc finger and leucine zipper motifs. The presence of a leucine zipper suggested that this protein might form homodimers, and this was confirmed by means of the two-hybrid system in yeast. The activity of some proteins that form homodimers can be effectively eliminated by overexpression of inactive forms of the protein that bind to the wild-type protein to create a dominant negative phenotype. An ATDC cDNA containing a 37 amino acid deletion in the zinc finger region (ATDC delta) was therefore transfected into colorectal carcinoma human tumour cells (RKO) to determine whether its expression would produce a response to radiation similar to that seen in A-T cells. RKO cells have been shown to have normal radiosensitivity and cell cycle regulation and, therefore, seemed ideal for this study. Despite the fact that the A-T gene has been found to be important in the radiation damage response, no ATDC mRNA transcripts were detectable in the RKO cell line. In addition, the RKO subclones expressing the ATDC delta mRNA showed no change in radiosensitivity or cell cycle regulation. These results do not support the conclusion that ATDC is an A-T gene, and suggest that the ATDC protein acts indirectly to suppress radiosensitivity in A-T cells.

Identification of frequent novel genetic alterations in small cell lung carcinoma

We have performed a comprehensive analysis of the DNA copy number changes that occur in 18 small cell lung carcinoma cell lines using comparative genomic hybridization (Kallioniemi et al., Science (Washington DC). 258: 818-821, 1992). DNA copy number abnormalities detected in this study include previously identified increases at 1p22-32 (L-myc), 2p24-25 (N-myc), and 8q24 (c-myc) and decreases at 17p13 (p53), 13q14 (RB), and 3p. In addition, novel DNA copy number increases were detected at 5p, 1q24, and Xq26, and novel decreases were found at 22q12.1-13.1, 10q26, and 16p11.2. Many of the most common DNA copy number changes revealed are at loci not previously recognized to be important in small cell lung cancer. In addition, a number of the DNA copy number changes, including increases at 1p22-32, 2p24-25, and 3q22-25 and a decrease on 18p, were found to occur preferentially in small cell lung carcinoma lines of the "variant" phenotype. This correlation suggests that genes may reside at these loci whose overexpression or inactivation contributes to the radiation resistance or aggressive growth phenotypes characteristic of this subtype of small cell lung carcinoma.

The rRNA-encoding DNA array has an altered structure in topoisomerase I mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

All the chromosomes from isogenic TOP1 and top1 strains have similar mobility on pulsed-field gels except for chromosome XII, which fails to migrate into the gels in top1 mutants. Chromosome XII contains the tandem repeats of rRNA-encoding DNA (rDNA). When a segment of chromosome XII containing only rDNA is transferred to chromosome III by a recombination event, chromosome III fails to enter a pulsed-field gel in extracts from top1 strains, indicating that the aberrant migration of chromosome XII in top1 mutants is caused by the presence of rDNA. Failure of chromosome XII to migrate into a pulsed-field gel occurs only in preparations from exponentially growing top1 cultures and not in preparations from stationary-phase top1 cultures. rDNA from a top1 strain does enter the gel if it is cut with an enzyme (Pst I) that cuts the tandem rDNA array into single 9-kb repeat units, indicating that more than a single repeat unit is required to maintain the aberrant structure.

OxyR, a positive regulator of hydrogen peroxide-inducible genes in Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium, is homologous to a family of bacterial regulatory proteins

The oxyR gene is required for the induction of a regulon of hydrogen peroxide-inducible genes in Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. The E. coli oxyR gene has been cloned and sequenced, revealing an open reading frame (305 amino acids) that encodes a 34.4-kDa protein, which is produced in maxicells carrying the oxyR clone. The OxyR protein shows homology to a family of positive regulatory proteins including LysR in E. coli and NodD in Rhizobium. Like them, oxyR appears to be negatively autoregulated: an oxyR::lacZ gene fusion produced 5-fold higher levels of beta-galactosidase activity in oxyR null mutants compared to oxyR+ controls, and extracts from an OxyR-overproducing strain were able to protect regions (-27 to +21) of the oxyR promoter from DNase I digestion. DNA sequence analysis of the oxyR2 mutation, which causes overexpression of oxyR-regulated proteins in the absence of oxidative stress, showed that the oxyR2 phenotype is due to a missense mutation (C.G to T.A transition) that changes alanine to valine at amino acid position 234 of OxyR.

An alkyl hydroperoxide reductase from Salmonella typhimurium involved in the defense of DNA against oxidative damage. Purification and properties

A peroxide reductase (peroxidase) which converts lipid hydroperoxides and other alkyl hydroperoxides to the corresponding alcohols, using either NADH or NADPH as the reducing agent, has been identified in both Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli. This enzyme is shown to play a role in protecting against alkyl hydroperoxide mutagenesis. To our knowledge this work represents the first description of an NAD(P)H peroxidase in enteric bacteria and the first reported bacterial peroxidase to exhibit high activity toward alkyl hydroperoxides. A high performance liquid chromatography-based assay for the alkyl hydroperoxide reductase has been developed by monitoring the reduction of cumene hydroperoxide, a model alkyl hydroperoxide. By using this assay, the enzyme has been purified from a S. typhimurium regulatory mutant, oxyR1, which overexpresses a number of proteins involved in defenses against oxidative damage, and which contains 20-fold more of the alkyl hydroperoxide reductase than the wild-type strain. The purified activity requires the presence of two separable components having subunit molecular weights of 22,000 and 57,000. The 57-kDa protein contains a bound FAD cofactor and can use either NADH or NADPH as an electron donor for the direct reduction of redox dyes, or of alkyl hydroperoxides when combined with the 22-kDa protein. This enzyme may thus serve as a prokaryotic equivalent to the glutathione reductase/glutathione peroxidase system in eukaryotes.

Mitotic recombination in the rDNA of S. cerevisiae is suppressed by the combined action of DNA topoisomerases I and II

We have found that mitotic recombination within the S. cerevisiae rDNA cluster (200 tandemly repeated 9.1 kb units) is strongly suppressed and that this suppression requires the combined action of DNA topoisomerases I and II. Strains with a null mutation in the TOP1 gene (encoding topoisomerase I) or a ts mutation in the TOP2 gene (encoding topoisomerase II) grown at a semipermissive temperature show 50- to 200-fold higher frequencies of mitotic recombination in rDNA relative to TOP+ controls. Suppression of recombination is specific to the rDNA because the recombination frequency at another tandem array, the CUP1 locus, at a simple HIS4 duplication, or among dispersed repeats (MAT and HML or HMR) is not elevated in top1 or top2 mutants. The high frequency of mitotic recombination within the rDNA cluster in topoisomerase mutants shows that both TOP1 and TOP2 are required for suppression of recombination in this region of the genome.