Thymic activity in late-stage HIV-1 infected individuals receiving highly active antiretroviral therapy: potential effect of steroid therapy

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to monitor the effect of steroid therapy on the thymic output and function of late-stage HIV-1-infected patients undergoing highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART).

DESIGN

The indirect measurement of T cells that have recently emigrated from the thymus as a means of quantifying thymic output, and therefore thymic function, was achieved through use of the polymerase chain reaction-based signal joint T cell receptor rearrangement excision circles (sjTREC) assay. Proliferative capacity and interleukin (IL)-2 and IL-4 production by T cells after antigenic, mitogenic and IL-2 stimulation were also analysed.

METHOD

Measurements were made of sjTREC levels in peripheral blood mononuclear cell DNA samples from five HIV-1 infected patients (one on steroid therapy prior to and at the time of sample extraction) receiving HAART. IL-2 and IL-4 production and proliferative capacity were also measured in three patients, including the patient receiving steroids.

RESULT

The sjTREC assay gave an extremely weak result for the patient on steroids but, under the same assay conditions, provided clear, positive readings for the four patients not on steroids. Comparison of the patients' cytokine profiles revealed that IL-2 production was generally low or absent in all three patients tested but that IL-4 production was significantly higher in the patient given steroids. Functional potential as revealed by proliferation assays showed very low or absent cellular proliferation.

CONCLUSION

The thymic contribution to the restoration of T lymphocyte numbers, particularly during the treatment of HIV-1 infection, may become compromised if thymic inhibitory factors such as steroids are used. Furthermore, the use of steroids may also favour the development of a T helper 2 response, which could prove particularly undesirable during HIV-1 infection.

Immune responses and reconstitution in HIV-1 infected individuals: impact of anti-retroviral therapy, cytokines and therapeutic vaccination

Most patients with chronic HIV-1 infection lack functional CD4(+) and CD8(+) HIV-1-specific T cells with proliferative and cytolytic capacity, respectively. This is despite being able to produce intracellular cytokines in response to viral antigens. Protease inhibitor (PI)-based highly active anti-retroviral therapy (HAART) is unable to completely eradicate virus and fails to enable total restoration of immunity including induction of anti-HIV-1 responses. We have taken novel approaches towards the treatment of chronic HIV-1 disease with the aim of instigating long-term non-progressor status and depletion of virus reservoirs. HIV-1-specific CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell responses were measured following the administration of cytokines, during therapeutic vaccination, and following treatment interruption (TI) or drug therapy change. Administration of cytokines, with or without therapeutic vaccination, in HAART treated patients, improved both CD4(+) and CD8(+) HIV-1-specific T cell responses even in late-stage disease. Virus-specific T cell responses were also seen during TI or when transient viraemia was apparent, and following therapy change from a PI- to a non-nucleoside-based HAART regimen. Reconstitution of HIV-1-specific immune responses was found to be transient and reversal to the previous anergic state was rapid. Viral reservoirs in the latently infected resting CD4(+) T cells, on follicular dendritic cells of germinal centers or even in infected thymic epithelium may be involved in clonal suppression and anergy. These may present major obstacles to the maintenance of HIV-1-specific responses and the eventual eradication of HIV-1.

Candidate vaccines for immunotherapy in HIV

In this short article we review the immunopathology of HIV infection and delineate the kinds of immune responses seen in acute infection and in long-term nonprogression that are understood to be necessary if the host is to maintain long-term control of the virus. In this context we discuss the potential promise of therapeutic vaccination in HIV infection.

A point mutation in CD45 may be associated with an increased risk of HIV-1 infection

The CD45 antigen is essential for normal antigen receptor-mediated signalling in lymphocytes, and different patterns of splicing of CD45 are associated with distinct functions in lymphocytes. Here we show that abnormal CD45 splicing caused by a C77G transversion in exon A of the gene encoding CD45 (PTPRC) is associated with increased susceptibility to HIV-1 infection.

Development of immunotherapeutic strategies for HIV-1

In the majority of untreated patients, HIV-1 infection presents as a progressive disease of the immune system. Recent studies indicate that immune responses can be induced in HIV-1 infected individuals, leading to some immune control of virus replication. Such immune responses are also observed in small numbers of untreated HIV-1 infected long-term non-progressor (LTNP) patients, as well as in other viral infections (including those with human herpes viruses). Emerging novel technologies, animal studies and detailed immunological studies have proven invaluable in defining the immune responses that are associated with a favourable clinical outcome. Central effector and regulatory cells are HIV-1-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTL) and CD4+ helper T-lymphocytes respectively. Fully functional antigen-presenting cells (APC) are also essential in all stages of HIV-1 infection and possibly some (but not all) antibody responses contribute to beneficial immunity. The availability of combination anti-retroviral drug therapy, which successfully controls viraemia, has enabled a beneficial outcome in many HIV-1 infected individuals. Since no chronically HIV-1 infected patient has been shown to eradicate virus, novel approaches utilising therapeutic immunisation and various cytokines to manipulate immune responses and to induce and steer immunity towards a desired phenotype are required. There is a clear rationale for immunotherapeutic intervention in chronic progressive HIV-1 infection, which forms the foundation for novel approaches aimed at inducing and maintaining immune control. Here we review the immunopathogenesis of HIV-1 infection and discuss the promises of therapeutic immunisation and immunotherapy in general and their potential in the treatment of chronic HIV-1 disease.

Both age and gender affect thymic output: more recent thymic migrants in females than males as they age

The thymus undergoes age-associated involution, with studies showing thymic size decreasing from birth at a rate of approximately 3% per year until middle age, and at a rate of 1% per year thereafter. The aim of this study was to determine the effect of thymic atrophy on T-lymphocyte production by the thymus, and to clarify the ongoing uncertainty regarding gender differences in thymic function. We quantified recent thymic emigrants (RTEs) in blood through the measurement of signal joint T-cell receptor rearrangement excision circles (sjTRECs), and showed that the decline in the number of RTEs in the blood with increasing age is gender-linked. Peripheral blood from females contained significantly higher levels of sjTRECs per CD3+ T cell than blood from males (P = 0.002), despite there being no significant gender difference in the absolute number of CD3+ T cells in the populations analysed (P > 0.10). Our findings suggest better thymic function in females compared with males, providing females with a higher number of recent thymic emigrants for longer periods of life. Such a finding provides a plausible explanation for the immunological gender differences observed in previous studies and possibly, for the general longer life expectancy in females compared with males.

Detection and quantification of HIV-1 specific CD4 helper and CD8 cytotoxic cells: their role in HIV-1-infected individuals and vaccine recipients

There is a strong link between virus specific CD8 T-cell function and the efficiency of regulatory CD4 helper T cells. Controlling viraemia in HIV-1-infected individuals requires the maintenance of strong CD4 and CD8 T-cell responses. These responses should be elicited by prophylactic vaccination and by postexposure immunotherapy. This review will examine the methods that are available for the detection and quantification of HIV-1 specific CD4 and CD8 T-cell responses. We will also discuss the methods that should be used to identify these responses in HIV-1-infected individuals, seropositive recipients of immunotherapy and seronegative vaccinees. Finally, we will give examples of how responses observed in vitro relate to those known to occur in vivo.

The exon A (C77G) mutation is a common cause of abnormal CD45 splicing in humans

The leukocyte common (CD45) Ag is essential for normal T lymphocyte function and alternative splicing at the N terminus of the gene is associated with changes in T cell maturation and differentiation. Recently, a statistically significant association was reported in a large series of human thymus samples between phenotypically abnormal CD45 splicing and the presence of the CC chemokine receptor 5 deletion 32 (CCR5del32) allele, which confers resistance to HIV infection in homozygotes. We show here that abnormal splicing in these thymus samples is associated with the presence of the only established cause of CD45 abnormal splicing, a C77G transversion in exon A. In addition we have examined 227 DNA samples from peripheral blood of healthy donors and find no association between the exon A (C77G) and CCR5del32 mutations. Among 135 PBMC samples, tested by flow cytometric analysis, all those exhibiting abnormal splicing of CD45 also showed the exon A C77G transversion. We conclude that the exon A (C77G) mutation is a common cause of abnormal CD45 splicing and that further disease association studies of this mutation are warranted.

Loss of CD4+ T cell proliferative ability but not loss of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 specificity equates with progression to disease

In this study, we compared human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1-specific proliferative responses with HIV-1-induced intracellular cytokine production in a cohort of clinically nonprogressing patients and individuals with progressive HIV-1 infection. We found strong HIV-1-specific proliferative responses in the clinical nonprogressor cohort that correlated with significant numbers of circulating HIV-1-specific CD4(+) T cells. In contrast, HIV-1-specific proliferative responses were absent in most individuals with progressive HIV-1 infection, even though interferon-gamma-producing HIV-1-specific CD4(+) T cells were detectable by flow cytometry. The implication of these data is that the important dysfunction seen in most HIV-positive patients from very early in disease may be an inability of HIV-1-specific CD4(+) memory T cells to proliferate in response to HIV antigens rather than an absolute loss of circulating virus-specific CD4(+) T cells.

Vaccines for the control of HIV/AIDS

This review discusses the feasibility of an HIV vaccine and describes the history, efficacy and potential to succeed of old and new vaccine concepts.

Assessment of type 1 and type 2 cytokines in HIV type 1-infected individuals: impact of highly active antiretroviral therapy

Although the effect of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) on HIV-1 replication has been established, the mechanisms involved in restoration of immune responses and reconstitution remain unknown. This study provides evidence of changes in expression of type 1 and type 2 cytokine-specific mRNA occurring during HIV-1 infection, before and after initiation of HAART. Unstimulated PBMCs from nine HIV-1-infected individuals obtained at different time intervals before and after the initiation of HAART were assessed for specific IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-4, and IL-10 mRNA expression, using RT-PCR. Correlation with CD4+ T cell counts and viral load was also carried out. Before initiation of HAART, in all patients, little expression of specific IFN-gamma and IL-2 (type 1 cytokine) mRNA was noted. In contrast, expression of specific IL-4 and/or IL-10 (type 2) mRNA was readily detectable in the majority of patients. After initiation of HAART there was a continuous increase in IFN-gamma and IL-2 mRNA expression, although the latter occurred in lower amounts. This paralleled a dramatic reduction in viral load and increase in CD4+ T cell counts. Type 2 cytokine-specific mRNA expression fell to undetectable levels and in some cases reappeared later in the course of HAART. Predominant expression of type 2 cytokine mRNA, before initiation of HAART, concurs with previous findings of a dominant antiproliferative, type 2 cytokine profile during HIV-1 infection. Reversion of the cytokine profile, after HAART, to a strong type 1 profile suggests that in addition to suppressing virus replication directly the immune system may be given a chance to recover.

Induction of HIV-1-specific T cell responses by administration of cytokines in late-stage patients receiving highly active anti-retroviral therapy

Highly active anti-retroviral therapy (HAART) is associated with reduction in the morbidity and mortality of patients with advanced HIV-1 disease. The ability of such treatment to improve immune responses against HIV-1 and opportunistic pathogens is variable and limited. Addition of cytokine immunotherapy to this treatment may improve immune responses. IL-2 with or without granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) was administered to HIV-1+ individuals receiving HAART with undetectable viral loads, and CD4 counts < 100 cells/microl. In one patient presenting with Mycobacterium avium complex (MAC) infection, we evaluated the effect of cytokine immunotherapy on lymphocyte phenotype; plasma viral load; proliferative responses to mitogens, recall and HIV-1 antigens; cytokine production and message in response to non-specific and specific stimuli; and natural killer (NK) cell activity. Proliferation assays were performed in two similar patients. Before cytokine immunotherapy the predominant CD8+ population was mainly CD28-. No proliferation or IL-2 production was seen in response to mitogens, recall or HIV-1 antigens; and no HIV-1 peptide-specific interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma)-secreting cells were present. Low levels of IL-4 were detected in response to antigens to which patients had been exposed, associated with up-regulated expression of costimulatory molecules influenced by IL-4. Following IL-2 administration, loss of IL-4 was associated with increased NK cell activity and HIV-1 peptide-specific and non-specific IFN-gamma-producing cells. Proliferative responses associated with IL-2 production and responsiveness were only seen after subsequent concomitant administration of GM-CSF with IL-2. These changes mirrored clinical improvement. An imbalance of lymphocyte subsets may account for immune unresponsiveness when receiving HAART. Restoration of responses following immunotherapy suggests a shift towards a lymphocyte profile with anti-pathogen activity.

Therapeutic vaccines in HIV.1 infection

In this review we address questions which must be considered if better attempts are to be made to treat all persons presently infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). There are thirty million people in the world presently living with HIV, only 10% of whom are likely to be able to access currently available drug therapy. Even when available, such therapy causes considerable inconvenience and undesirable clinical side effects, and fails to eradicate virus from a small reservoir of latently infected cells. Thus, we must ask what forms of alternative therapy might be used. One strategy that may be considered is to reduce virus levels as low as possible using highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART), followed by modulation of host immunity with immunotherapy in order to effect an appropriate and efficient response mimicking that found in long-term asymptomatic patients, with the aim of indefinitely maintaining the asymptomatic period following discontinuation of chemotherapy, or even of eradicating the virus from the latent reservoirs. In 1987, long before the advent of highly active antiretroviral therapy, J. Salk proposed the use of a 'suitable potent non-infectious (HIV) immunogen' to delay or prevent the development of AIDS in infected individuals (1). The objective of administering such an agent was to 'enhance and prolong the presence of (immunologically) protective factors'. The stated aim at that time was 'to destroy virus and viral antigen producing cells by the induction of the immune system's cytotoxic mechanisms known to rid the host of virus and virus producing cells'. Twelve years later, and after a quarter of a century living with HIV, and with the advent of HAART, is it time to use our knowledge of the host's own immune system to fight this seemingly intractable invader?

Lack of T cell proliferation without induction of nonresponsiveness after antigen presentation by endothelial cells

BACKGROUND

After priming or reactivation in lymph nodes, T cells recirculate to sites of inflammation, and enter tissues by migrating across activated endothelium. Given that activated endothelial and tissue parenchymal cells express both class I and class II MHC molecules, it is probable that transmigrating T cells encounter cognate antigen on endothelial cells, and on tissue parenchymal cells once they have entered the tissue.

METHODS

In this study the consequences of antigen presentation by endothelial and epithelial cells to human CD4+ T cell clones were analyzed and compared by a two-step culture system.

RESULTS

T cell clones that required B7-mediated costimulation to be activated were found not to be able to proliferate to antigen presented by either endothelial or epithelial cells, unless trans-costimulation was provided by the addition of B7-transfected cells in the cultures. Furthermore, antigen presentation by epithelial cells induced nonresponsiveness in the T cell clones. In contrast, after cognate recognition on endothelial cells, the ability of the T cell clones to proliferate to a subsequent rechallenge with antigen presented on a specialized APC was unaffected.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that endothelial cells have unique properties as antigen-presenting cells, in that they do not influence the subsequent reactivity of cognate T cells.

The gp200-MR6 molecule which is functionally associated with the IL-4 receptor modulates B cell phenotype and is a novel member of the human macrophage mannose receptor family

The human gp200-MR6 molecule has previously been shown to have either an antagonistic or agonistic effect on IL-4 function, demonstrated by inhibition of IL-4-induced proliferation of T cells or mimicking of IL-4-induced maturation of epithelium, respectively. We now show that gp200-MR6 ligation can also mimic IL-4 and have an anti-proliferative pro-maturational influence within the immune system, causing up-regulation of co-stimulatory molecules on B lymphocytes. Biochemical analysis and cDNA cloning reveal that gp200-MR6 belongs to the human macrophage mannose receptor family of multidomain molecules. It comprises 1722 amino acids in toto (mature protein, 1695 amino acids; signal sequence, 27 amino acids) organized into 12 external domains (an N-terminal cysteine-rich domain, a fibronectin type II domain and 10 C-type carbohydrate recognition domains), a transmembrane region and a small cytoplasmic C terminus (31 amino acids) containing a single tyrosine residue (Y1679), but no obvious kinase domain. Strong amino acid sequence identity (77%) suggests that gp200-MR6 is the human homologue of the murine DEC-205, indicating that this molecule has much wider functional activity than its classical endocytic role. We also show that the gp200-MR6 molecule is closely associated with tyrosine kinase activity; the link between gp200-MR6 and the IL-4 receptor may therefore be via intracellular signaling pathways, with multifunctionality residing in its extracellular multidomain structure.

The gp200-MR6 molecule which is functionally associated with the IL-4 receptor modulates B cell phenotype and is a novel member of the human macrophage mannose receptor family

The human gp200-MR6 molecule has previously been shown to have either an antagonistic or agonistic effect on IL-4 function, demonstrated by inhibition of IL-4-induced proliferation of T cells or mimicking of IL-4-induced maturation of epithelium, respectively. We now show that gp200-MR6 ligation can also mimic IL-4 and have an anti-proliferative pro-maturational influence within the immune system, causing up-regulation of co-stimulatory molecules on B lymphocytes. Biochemical analysis and cDNA cloning reveal that gp200-MR6 belongs to the human macrophage mannose receptor family of multidomain molecules. It comprises 1722 amino acids in toto (mature protein, 1695 amino acids; signal sequence, 27 amino acids) organized into 12 external domains (an N-terminal cysteine-rich domain, a fibronectin type II domain and 10 C-type carbohydrate recognition domains), a transmembrane region and a small cytoplasmic C terminus (31 amino acids) containing a single tyrosine residue (Y1679), but no obvious kinase domain. Strong amino acid sequence identity (77%) suggests that gp200-MR6 is the human homologue of the murine DEC-205, indicating that this molecule has much wider functional activity than its classical endocytic role. We also show that the gp200-MR6 molecule is closely associated with tyrosine kinase activity; the link between gp200-MR6 and the IL-4 receptor may therefore be via intracellular signaling pathways, with multifunctionality residing in its extracellular multidomain structure.

Association between interleukin-4-producing T lymphocyte frequencies and reduced risk of graft-versus-host disease

BACKGROUND

We have previously developed and used limiting dilution analysis to measure frequencies of alloreactive cytotoxic T cell precursors (CTLp) and interleukin (IL)-2-producing T helper cells (IL-2/HTLp) to assess the risk of graft-versus-host disease in bone marrow transplantation (BMT). However, no test has been available to measure precursor frequencies of the important IL-4-secreting subset.

METHODS

We have now established a limiting dilution analysis to measure the frequency of IL-4-producing T helper cells (IL-4/HTLp) using the IL-4-responsive indicator cell line CT.h4S and have applied this assay to measure alloreactive IL-4/HTLp frequencies in BMT donor-recipient pairs. These frequencies were then analyzed in the context of clinical data to assess the relationship between the number of donor anti-recipient IL-4-secreting T cells and disease outcome.

RESULTS

Frequencies of IL-4/HTLp have been studied in HLA-identical siblings, HLA-"matched" unrelated, and HLA-mismatched combinations and found to range from approximately 1/500,000 in HLA-identical sibling pairs to -1/2,000 in HLA-DR-mismatched pairs. These frequencies were independent of those for IL-2/HTLp and showed a negative correlation with those for CTLp. Clinical follow-up of 30 patients showed that high IL-4/HTLp frequencies are associated with a reduced risk of severe graft-versus-host disease. High IL-4/HTLp frequencies may also indicate an increased risk of leukemia relapse.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggest that measurement of IL-4/HTLp frequencies provides information distinct from that obtained with CTLp and IL-2/HTLp. This new assay provides a valuable additional method for optimizing donor selection in unrelated BMT.

Laser energy reaching the posterior pole during transscleral cyclophotocoagulation

OBJECTIVE

To measure scattered laser energy reaching the posterior pole during transscleral cyclophotocoagulation.

METHODS

Transscleral cyclophotocoagulation was performed on 4 cadaver eyes with Nd:YAG noncontact, Nd:YAG contact, and diode contact lasers. Energy was measured with a photodiode through a 7-mm trephined hole in the posterior pole. Average percentage power, average power, and average energy transmission were calculated. American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) guidelines were used to calculate allowable energy exposures for each laser.

RESULTS

All 3 lasers transmitted 3% to 5% of the power to the posterior pole. The average energy transmission was 240 to 260 mJ for all lasers. The contact lasers had an average power transmission of 120 mW. The noncontact Nd:YAG laser, with shorter pulse duration, had an average power transmission of 13,000 mW, significantly greater than that of the other lasers. The ACGIH guidelines for allowable energy exposures were 93 mJ for the noncontact Nd:YAG laser, 1300 mJ for the contact Nd:YAG laser, and 440 mJ for the contact diode laser.

CONCLUSIONS

Three percent to 5% of laser power delivered during cyclophotocoagulation reaches the posterior pole. Exposure energies may approach or exceed ACGIH guidelines. The clinical significance of these findings remains to be shown.